Experimental transplantation gliomas in the adult cat brain. 1. Experimental model and neuropathology

Do animal models of brain tumors replicate human peritumoral edema? a systematic literature search

INTRODUCTION

Brain tumors cause morbidity and mortality in part through peritumoral brain edema. The current main treatment for peritumoral brain edema are corticosteroids. Due to the increased recognition of their side-effect profile, there is growing interest in finding alternatives to steroids but there is little formal study of animal models of peritumoral brain edema. This study aims to summarize the available literature.

METHODS

A systematic search was undertaken of 5 literature databases (Medline, Embase, CINAHL, PubMed and the Cochrane Library). The generic strategy was to search for various terms associated with "brain tumors", "brain edema" and "animal models".

RESULTS

We identified 603 reports, of which 112 were identified as relevant for full text analysis that studied 114 peritumoral brain edema animal models. We found significant heterogeneity in the species and strain of tumor-bearing animals, tumor implantation method and edema assessment. Most models did not produce appreciable brain edema and did not test for observable manifestations thereof.

CONCLUSION

No animal model currently exists that enable the investigation of novel candidates for the treatment of peritumoral brain edema. With current interest in alternative treatments for peritumoral brain edema, there is an unmet need for clinically relevant animal models.

Animal models of tumour-associated epilepsy

Brain tumours cause a sizeable proportion of epilepsies in adulthood, and actually can be etiologically responsible also for childhood epilepsies. Conversely, seizures are often first clinical signs of a brain tumour. Nevertheless, several issues of brain-tumour associated seizures and epilepsies are far from understood, or clarified regarding clinical consensus. These include both the specific mechanisms of epileptogenesis related to different tumour types, the possible relationship between malignancy and seizure emergence, the interaction between tumour mass and surrounding neuronal networks, and - not least - the best treatment options depending on different tumour types. To investigate these issues, experimental models of tumour-induced epilepsies are necessary. This review concentrates on the description of currently used models, focusing on methodological aspects. It highlights advantages and shortcomings of these models, and identifies future experimental challenges.

Standardization and Detailed Characterization of the Syngeneic Fischer/F98 Glioma Model

Introduction:

Adequate animal glioma models are mandatory for the pursuit of preclinical research in neuro-oncology. Many implantation models have been described, but none perfectly emulate human malignant gliomas. This work reports our experience in standardizing, optimizing and characterizing the Fischer/F98 glioma model on the clinical, pathological, radiological and metabolic aspects.

Materials and methods:

F98 cells were implanted in 70 Fischer rats, varying the quantity of cells and volume of implantation solution, and using a micro-infusion pump to minimize implantation trauma, after adequate coordinates were established. Pathological analysis consisted in hematoxylin and eosin (H&E) staining and immunohistochemistry for GFAP, vimentin, albumin, TGF-b1, TGF-b2, CD3 and CD45. Twelve animals were used for MR imaging at 5, 10, 15 and 20 days. Corresponding MR images were compared with pathological slides. Two animals underwent 18F-FDG and 11C-acetate PET studies for metabolic characterization of the tumors.

Results:

Implantation with 1x104 cells produced a median survival of 26 days and a tumor take of 100%. Large infiltrative neoplasms with a necrotic core were seen on H&E. Numerous mitosis, peritumoral infiltrative behavior, and neovascular proliferation were also obvious. GFAP and vimentin staining was positive inside the tumor cells. Albumin staining was observed in the extracellular space around the tumors. CD3 staining was negligible. The MR images correlated the pathologic findings. 18F-FDG uptake was strong in the tumors.

Conclusion:

The standardized model described in this study behaves in a predictable and reproducible fashion, and could be considered for future pre-clinical studies. It adequately mimics the behavior of human malignant astrocytomas.

Experimental rodent models of brainstem tumors

Despite recent advances in surgical technology, resection is not an option for many brainstem tumors. Experimental models have played essential roles in examining new approaches to therapy. The objective of the present study was to generate models by determining coordinates for safe inoculation into the brainstem of mice and rats, and to establish whether the implantation of heterotopic cells would create reproducible survival curves. Morbidity and survival studies were used to map stereotactic coordinates allowing successful inoculation of tumor cells. Survival studies were used to investigate the time course of tumor growth. Tumor location was examined by light microscopy and magnetic resonance imaging. Mice survived injections of 2 microL of saline at interaural, lateral, and depth coordinates of -2.5, 1.0, and 3.5 mm and -1.5, 1.0, and 3.5 mm. Rats survived injections at interaural, lateral, and depth coordinates of -2.0, 2.0, and 7.0 mm and -3.0, 0, and 7.0 mm. Median survival of mice challenged with 5 x 10(5) EMT6 and 10(4) B16 tumor cells was 11 and 10 days, respectively. Median survival for rats challenged with 10(4) 9L and F98 cells was 14 and 13 days, respectively. The present study demonstrates a feasible approach to preparing models of brainstem tumors. Limitations of these models are discussed.

Regional metabolism in experimental brain tumors in cats: relationship with acid/base, water, and electrolyte homeostasis

Experimental brain tumors were produced in cats by xenotransplantation of the rat glioma clone F98 into the white matter of the left hemisphere. One to 4 weeks after implantation, local adenosine triphosphate (ATP), glucose, lactate, and tissue pH were measured via imaging techniques in cryostat sections passing through the center of the tumor and correlated with changes in water and electrolyte content. The tumors exhibited a heterogeneous metabolic pattern, with a tendency for ATP to decrease and lactate to increase during tumor development. Tissue pH was above 7.5 in tumors with high ATP content but it sharply declined at low ATP levels. In peritumoral edema, ATP also decreased and lactate increased but, in contrast to tumor tissue, pH became more alkaline. Metabolic changes were associated with edema formation, as evidenced by the rise in water and sodium content. There was a distinct difference between tumor tissue and peritumoral edema: in tumor tissue, pH declined with increasing water content, whereas in peritumoral edema it increased. These observations are interpreted as follows: 1) in tumor tissue, "lactacidosis" and ATP depletion are attributed to disturbances in blood flow, resulting in metabolic failure and the intracellular "cytotoxic" accumulation of water; 2) in peritumoral edema, "lactalkalosis" is the result of an efflux of (alkaline) lactate salts from the tumor into the expanded extracellular compartment, and the decrease in ATP is the volumetric effect of extracellular "vasogenic" edema fluid and not the result of cellular energy failure. These findings are of importance for the interpretation of volume-selective magnetic resonance spectroscopy and may contribute to the establishment of spectroscopic criteria for the evaluation of therapeutical interventions.

In vivo NMR T2 relaxation of experimental brain tumors in the cat: a multiparameter tissue characterization

Experimental gliomas (F98) were inoculated in cat brain for the systematic study of their in vivo T2 relaxation time behavior. With a CPMG multi-echo imaging sequence, a train of 16 echoes was evaluated to obtain the transverse relaxation time and the magnetization M(0) at time t = 0. The magnetization decay curves were analyzed for biexponentiality. All tissues showed monoexponential T2, only that of the ventricular fluid and part of the vital tumor tissue were biexponential. Based on these NMR relaxation parameters the tissues were characterized, their correct assignment being assured by comparison with histological slices. T2 of normal grey and white matter was 74 +/- 6 and 72 +/- 6 msec, respectively. These two tissue types were distinguished through M(0) which for white matter was only 0.88 of the intensity of grey matter in full agreement with water content, determined from tissue specimens. At the time of maximal tumor growth and edema spread a tissue differentiation was possible in NMR relaxation parameter images. Separation of the three tissue groups of normal tissue, tumor and edema was based on T2 with T2(normal) < T2(tumor) < T2(edema). Using M(0) as a second parameter the differentiation was supported, in particular between white matter and tumor or edema. Animals were studied at 1-4 wk after tumor implantation to study tumor development. The magnetization M(0) of both tumor and peritumoral edema went through a maximum between the second and third week of tumor growth. T2 of edema was maximal at the same time with 133 +/- 4 msec, while the relaxation time of tumor continued to increase during the whole growth period, reaching values of 114 +/- 12 msec at the fourth week. Thus, a complete characterization of pathological tissues with NMR relaxometry must include a detailed study of the developmental changes of these tissues to assure correct experimental conditions for the goal of optimal contrast between normal and pathological regions in the NMR images.

Determination of endogenous serum proteins in normal and oedematous brain tissue of cat by rocket and crossed immunoelectrophoresis

A quantitative method for determination of endogenous serum proteins has been established and tested in an experimental model of peritumoural brain oedema in cats. Rocket and crossed immunoelectrophoresis were applied for determination of total serum proteins, albumin, IgG and haemoglobin in blood and brain homogenates. Modifications such as the use of non-ionic detergents and of antisera with different specificity were established for each antigen under investigation. The content of total serum proteins, albumin and IgG was substantially higher in tumour and peritumoural brain tissue than in the non-oedematous brain. The measurement of haemoglobin allowed the calculation of blood volume and, in consequence, the differentiation between intra- and extravascular serum proteins. The results are in line with earlier measurements obtained by different analytical methods and demonstrate that the present technique provides a reliable approach for the quantitative assessment of serum protein extravasation.

Experimental transplantation gliomas in the adult cat brain. 2. Pathophysiology and magnetic resonance imaging

In adult cats experimental brain tumours were produced by stereotactical xenotransplantation of the rat glioma clone F 98 into the internal capsule of the left hemisphere. Two to four weeks after transplantation tumours and peritumoural oedema were investigated by magnetic resonance imaging (MRI), electrophysiological recording and analysis of tissue content of water, electrolytes and extravasated serum proteins. Spherical tumours with a diameter of about 10 mm developed at the injection site and were surrounded by massive white matter oedema. Water content in peritumoural white matter increased from 2.63 +/- 0.17 to 3.65 +/- 0.19 ml/g d.w. (means +/- SD), sodium from 187 +/- 11 to 351 +/- 55 mueq/g d.w. and calcium from 7.4 +/- 1.1 to 13.3 +/- 1.3 +/- 1.3 mueq/g d.w. Potassium and magnesium did not change. Oedema development was associated with the extravasation of 18.0 +/- 16.8 mg/g d.w. albumin and 15.8 +/- 12.2 mg/g d.w. immunoglobulin. The calculated electrolyte content of oedema fluid approximated that of plasma but the serum protein content was about 40% lower. The ratio of low (albumin) to high (immunoglobulin) molecular weight proteins was the same in blood and oedema fluid. It is, therefore, concluded that peritumoural oedema consist of two components, a whole plasma extravasate and a protein-free ultrafiltrate. Peritumoural oedema could be clearly detected by MRI but differentiation between tumour and oedema was only possible after contrast enhancement with gadolinium-DTPA. The ratios of the intensities of the MR signal correlated linearly with the water content within white matter. MRI, in consequence, allows quantification of oedema provided a reference area with normal water content is present.

Experimental transplantation gliomas in the adult cat brain. 3. Regional biochemistry

Experimental brain tumours were produced in adult cats by stereotactic xenotransplantation of the rat glioma clone F98. Regional ATP, glucose and lactate were measured after 2-4 weeks on coronal cryostat sections by substrate-induced bioluminescence, potassium content was imaged by the histochemical sodium cobaltinitrite method, and regional pH by incubating cryostat sections with the fluorescent pH-indicator umbelliferone. The regional biochemical alterations were correlated with magnetic resonance imaging and tissue water content. Biochemical changes were heterogeneous in tumours but exhibited a rather uniform pattern in peritumoural oedema. ATP was consistently reduced, glucose and lactate were increased and pH was more alkaline than in normal white matter. The decrease of ATP matched the increase of water, indicating that ATP decline represents fractional dilution in the oedematous tissue rather than break-down of energy metabolism. The increased lactate levels, therefore, may originate from the tumour and not from a metabolic disturbance in the peritumoural oedematous tissue. The implications of this interpretation for the pathogenesis of peritumoural oedema are discussed.

Experimental transplantation gliomas in the adult cat brain. 1. Experimental model and neuropathology

Tumours were produced in the adult cat brain by injection of the rapidly growing anaplastic rat glioma clone F98 in order to study their neuropathology, pathophysiology, regional biochemistry and magnetic reasonance imaging. We report here the neuropathological behaviour of cell suspensions in the basal ganglia and the left cerebral hemisphere one, two, three, four and six weeks after stereotactic implantation with respect to tumour growth, immunological tumour regression and alterations of the blood-brain barrier with associated vasogenic brain oedema. Injected cell suspensions produce consistently growing tumours during the first, second and third weeks. Tumour sizes varied according to the survival time and were only slightly dependent on the inoculated cell number, i.e., 3 and 6 x 10(6) tumour cells, respectively. Immunohistochemistry with respect to proteins of the cytoskeleton and other cell markers showed positive tumour cell immunoreactions for vimentin and S 100, but not for GFAP, Leu-7, Leu-M1 and MBP. While leucocyte infiltration is apparent after only one week, major tumour regression phenomena develop after three weeks in conjunction with severe lymphocytic reactions of the host, resulting in complete tumour rejection with scar gliosis after four and six weeks, respectively. This transplantation glioma model is accompanied by vasogenic brain oedema both within the tumour area and in the homolateral hemisphere. Immunohistochemistry of serum proteins, i.e. total serum protein, albumin and IgG reveals impairment of the blood-brain barrier after one week, reaching its maximum after two and three weeks. The oedematous changes decrease dramatically after four and six weeks, when most of the serum proteins are reabsorbed by cellular activities in the tumour scar. The vasogenic brain oedema in this xenogeneic glioma transplantation model may be enhanced by the immunological reactions in the brain.