Effect of Polystyrene Microplastics of Different Sizes to Escherichia coli and Bacillus cereus

Microplastic interactions with co-existing pollutants in water environments: Synergistic or antagonistic roles on their removal through current remediation technologies

Composite water pollution, caused by microplastics (MPs) and co-occurring pollutants, is an emerging issue that induces synergistic toxicity. Multidimensional interactions occur between MPs and co-existing pollutants in a composite system, which alter the behavior of each component, resulting in unpredictable effects on the treatment processes. However, significant gaps exist in current review papers regarding MP‒pollutant interaction mechanisms and the corresponding synergistic or antagonistic effects on their removal processes. This review comprehensively describes the latest research in composite water pollution caused by MPs and various other pollutants with different compositions and states, systematically discusses their interaction mechanisms, and critically evaluates the impact of co-existing contaminants on the treatment performance of current remediation technologies. Based on current research progress and gaps, opportunities, challenges, and perspectives for future research directions are proposed. This review highlights state-of-the-art research related to composite water pollution caused by MPs and various pollutants, which is expected to inspire new strategies for the effective removal of multiple contaminants from the aquatic environment.

Dose-Dependent Responses of Escherichia coli and Acinetobacter sp. to Micron-Sized Polystyrene Microplastics

Microplastics are ubiquitous environmental contaminants that can cause significant ecological damage because of their resistance to biodegradation. We evaluated the toxic effects of 1,040 nm polystyrene (PS) microplastics in two representative bacteria, Escherichia coli and Acinetobacter sp. In particular, we examined the effects of these PS microplastics on bacterial growth and viability, parameters related to oxidative stress (reactive oxygen species [ROS], lactate dehydrogenase [LDH], and malondialdehyde [MDA]), membrane integrity, and biofilm formation. An increasing concentration of PS microplastics decreased cell growth and viability in both species. These PS microplastics also decreased cell membrane integrity and increased biofilm formation in both species. Although both species exhibited adverse overall effects from PS microplastics, they had significant differences in specific indicators of oxidative stress. Correlation analysis demonstrated different correlations among measured experimental parameters (cell viability, ROS, LDH, MDA, and biofilm formation) in these two species. These results suggest that 1,040 nm PS microplastics decreased cell growth and viability by different mechanisms in E. coli and Acinetobacter sp.

The effects of small plastic particles on antibiotic resistance gene transfer revealed by single cell and community level analysis

Small plastic particles with sizes comparable to bacterial cells, widely exist in environment. However, their effects on antibiotic resistance gene (ARG) dissemination remain unclear. Using polystyrene (PS) particles (0.2 µm, 2 µm, 5 µm, 10 µm, 15 µm, 20 µm) as models, conjugative transfer of ARGs between the donor E. coli and different recipients (E. coli or sludge bacterial community) was investigated. Compared to the pure strain, the sludge bacterial community exposed to PS particles showed higher transfer frequencies (1.67 to 14.31 times the blank control). The transfer frequencies first decreased and then increased with particle size, and plastics similar in size to bacteria (e.g., 2 µm) appear to be a transitional zone with minimal impact on ARG transmission. Furthermore, using microfluidics, in-situ observation at single cell level found that 2 µm plastics can act as barriers between donor and recipient bacteria inhibiting growth, but conjugation events mostly occurred around them. Conversely, nanoplastics (e.g., 0.2 µm) and larger microplastics (e.g., 20 µm) significantly promote conjugation, mainly due to increased reactive oxygen species production and cell membrane permeability, or facilitating bacterial adhesion and biofilm formation, respectively. This study aids in assessing environmental risks of small plastic particles on ARG dissemination.

Heterogenous bioluminescence patterns, cell viability, and biofilm formation of Photobacterium leiognathi strains exposed to ground microplastics

Microplastics (MPs) have been detected in various aquatic environments and negatively affect organisms, including marine luminous bacteria. This study investigated the differences in bioluminescence patterns, cell viability, and biofilm formation of Photobacterium leiognathi strains (LB01 and LB09) when exposed to various concentrations of ground microplastics (GMPs; 0.25%, 0.50%, 1%, or 2% [w/v] per mL) at 22°C or 30°C for 3.1 days (75 h) and 7 days. The strains exhibited heterogenous responses, including variable bioluminescence patterns, cell viability, and biofilm formation, due to the GMPs having effects such as hormesis and bioluminescence quenching. Moreover, the bioluminescence and cell viability differed between the two strains, possibly involving distinct cellular mechanisms, suggesting that GMPs affect factors that influence quorum sensing. Furthermore, the biofilm formation of LB01 and LB09 was observed following exposure to GMPs. Both strains showed increased biofilm formation at higher GMP concentrations (1% and 2%) after 3.1 days at 30°C and 22°C. However, in the 7-day experiment, LB01 significantly (p < 0.05) increased biofilms at 22°C, while LB09 significantly (p < 0.05) produced biofilms at 30°C. These findings highlight the strain-specific responses of Phb. leiognathi to MP pollutants. Therefore, this study underscores the importance of evaluating MPs as environmental stressors on marine microorganisms and their role in the ecophysiological repercussions of plastic pollution in aquatic environments.

Microplastics and copper impacts on feeding, oxidative stress, antioxidant enzyme activity, and dimethylated sulfur compounds production in Manila clam Ruditapes philippinarum

Microplastics (MPs) are widespread ocean pollutants and many studies have explored their effects. However, research on MPs combined impact with copper (Cu) on dimethylated sulfur compound production is limited. Dimethyl sulfide (DMS) is an important biogenic sulfur compound related to global temperatures. This study examined the ecotoxicological effects of polyamide 6 MPs and Cu on dimethylsulfoniopropionate (DMSP), DMS, and dimethyl sulfoxide (DMSO) production in Manila clams (Ruditapes philippinarum). Our findings showed that MPs and Cu increased oxidative stress, indicated by higher superoxide anion radical production and malondialdehyde levels while decreasing glutathione contents and increasing superoxide dismutase activities. Additionally, MPs and Cu exposure reduced DMS and dissolved DMSO (DMSOd) concentrations due to decreased grazing. These results contribute to a better understanding of the ecotoxicological effects of MPs/Cu on bivalves and their roles in the organic sulfur cycle, suggesting a need for further research on long-term impacts on them.

Single exposure of food-derived polyethylene and polystyrene microplastics profoundly affects gut microbiome in an in vitro colon model

Microplastics (MPs) are widespread contaminants highly persistent in the environment and present in matrices to which humans are extensively exposed, including food and beverages. MP ingestion occurs in adults and children and is becoming an emerging public health issue. The gastrointestinal system is the most exposed to MP contamination, which can alter its physiology starting from changes in the microbiome. This study investigates by an omic approach the impact of a single intake of a mixture of polyethylene (PE) and polystyrene (PS) MPs on the ecology and metabolic activity of the colon microbiota of healthy volunteers, in an in vitro intestinal model. PE and PS MPs were pooled together in a homogeneous mix, digested with the INFOGEST system, and fermented with MICODE (multi-unit in vitro colon model) at loads that by literature correspond to the possible intake of food-derived MPs of a single meal. Results demonstrated that MPs induced an opportunistic bacteria overgrowth (Enterobacteriaceae, Desulfovibrio spp., Clostridium group I and Atopobium - Collinsella group) and a contextual reduction on abundances of all the beneficial taxa analyzed, with the sole exception of Lactobacillales. This microbiota shift was consistent with the changes recorded in the bacterial metabolic activity.

Polystyrene microplastics interaction and influence on the growth kinetics and metabolism of tilapia gut probiotic Bacillus tropicus ACS1

Gut probiotic bacteria play a significant role in the host health, immunity, and survival. In aquaculture, changes in the gut microbiome of fishes affect the overall productivity and product quality. In the scenario of growing plastic pollution and associated microplastic prevalence, the current study was designed to investigate the interactions and impact of prepared polystyrene microplastics (PS-MPs) of irregular surface morphology on a probiotic bacteria Bacillus tropicus ACS1, isolated from the gut of Oreochromis mossambicus (commonly called as Tilapia). The cell viability was significantly increased along with changes in bacterial growth kinetics upon exposure to varying concentrations of PS-MPs. The microplastic exposure also increased the production of exopolysaccharides (EPS) and induced slight changes in the IR spectra of the EPS. A peak representing a carbonyl linkage that could be attributed to the glycosidic linkages between sugars disappeared following exposure to higher concentrations of PS-MPs. The interaction between the bacteria and the microplastics was visualized using scanning electron microscopy (SEM) and the colonization of the bacteria with active biofilm formation was observed. The investigation of PS-MP induced oxidative stress in the bacteria revealed the generation of reactive oxygen species (ROS) and increase in anti-oxidant enzyme concentrations, superoxide dismutase (SOD), and catalase. The study provides new insights into the effect of microplastics on gut probiotics of an economically significant aquaculture species.

Vertical distribution and weathering characteristic of microplastics in soil profile of different land use types

After deposition on the topsoil, microplastics (MPs) may be vertically migrated to deeper soil layers over time or eventually enter the groundwater system, leading to more widespread environmental and ecological issues. However, the vertical distribution of MPs in natural soils are not yet fully understood. In this study, we collected soil profiles (0-100 cm) from four different land use types on the west bank of Taihu Lake in China to investigate the vertical distribution and weathering characteristics of MPs. The average abundance of soil MPs followed the pattern of paddy field (490 ± 82 items/kg) > dryland (356 ± 55 items/kg) > tea garden (306 ± 32 items/kg) > woodland (171 ± 27 items/kg) in the 0-10 cm layer, and the abundance of MPs decreased linearly with soil depth (r = -0.89, p < 0.01). Compared to tea garden and woodland, MPs in dryland and paddy field have migrated to deeper soil layers (80-100 cm). The carbonyl index of polyethylene and polypropylene MPs increased significantly with soil depth (r = 0.96, p < 0.01), with values of 0.58 ± 0.30 and 0.54 ± 0.33, respectively. The significant negative correlation between MPs size and carbonyl index confirmed that small-sized MPs in deeper soil layers originated from the weathering and fragmentation of MPs in topsoil. The results of structural equation model showed that roots and soil aggregates may act as filters during the vertical migration of MPs. These findings contribute to a better understanding of the environmental fate of MPs in soil and the assessment of associated ecological risks.

Microplastics released from disposable medical devices and their toxic responses in Caenorhabditis elegans

Owing to accelerated urbanization and industrialization, many plastic products have been manufactured and discharged into the environment, causing environmental and public health problems. Plastics in environmental media are further degraded by prolonged exposure to light, heat, mechanical friction, and other factors to form new pollutants called microplastics (MPs). Medical plastics have become a crucial source of plastics in environmental media. However, the release profiles of MPs from medical plastics and their potential ecological and health risks remain unclear. We used optical photothermal infrared spectroscopy to explore the release profiles of eight typical disposable medical devices under high-temperature steam disinfection (HSD). We also evaluated the toxicity of disposable medical devices-derived MPs in Caenorhabditis elegans (C. elegans). Our results showed that the changes in the surface morphology and modification of the disposable medical devices were mainly associated with the material. Polypropylene (PP) and polystyrene (PS) materials exhibited high aging phenomena (e.g., bumps, depressions, bulges and cracks), and HSD broke their oxygen-containing functional groups and carbon chains. By contrast, minor changes in the chemical and physical properties were observed in the polyvinyl chloride (PVC)-prepared disposable medical devices under the same conditions. Further physicochemical characterization indicated that the amount of MPs released from PP-prepared disposable medical devices (P4: 1.27 ± 0.34 × 106) was greater than that from PVC-prepared disposable medical devices (P7: 1.08 ± 0.14 × 105). The particle size of the released MPs was the opposite, PVC-prepared disposable medical devices (P7: 11.45 ± 1.79 μm) > PP-prepared disposable medical devices (P4: 7.18 ± 0.52 μm). Toxicity assessment revealed that disposable medical devices-released MPs significantly increased germ cell apoptosisin C. elegans. Moreover, MPs from PP-prepared disposable medical devices disrupted the intestinal barrier of worms, decreasing their lifespan. Our findings provided novel information regarding the profiles and mechanisms of MP release from disposable medical devices and revealed their potential risks to ecological environment.

Do microbial decomposers find micro- and nanoplastics to be harmful stressors in the aquatic environment? A systematic review of in vitro toxicological research

Microbial decomposers (bacteria and fungi) are likely to interact with plastic particles introduced into natural systems, particularly micro- and nanoplastics (MNPs), exposing them to a variety of risks. In vitro testing has proven to be an accessible and viable method for gaining insights into how microbial decomposers behave individually and systemically toward MNPs. Recent advances have enhanced our understanding of MNP interactions with organisms, revealing the molecular foundations of adaptive responses as well as the biological impact and potential risks to MNPs. Despite widespread attention, this topic has not yet been reviewed. Here, we conducted a systematic review of the available research to critically assess and highlight the most recent advances in two major areas: (1) methods for in vitro evaluation of environmentally relevant microbial decomposers to MNPs; and (2) current understanding of the underlying toxicity mechanisms gained from in vitro assessments. We also addressed the key considerations throughout and proposed available opportunities in the field. Our analysis revealed that MNPs' toxicity has been studied in vitro either alone or in combination with other contaminants (e.g., antibiotics and metallic nanoparticles), with Escherichia coli and polystyrene particles receiving the most attention. Moreover, there were methodological differences in terms of MNP size, shape, polymer, surface characteristics, exposure period, and concentrations. A combination of methods, including growth-viability tests, biochemical assays, and omics profiling (metabolomics and transcriptomics), were employed to detect the effects of MNP exposure and explain its toxicity mechanism. The current literature suggests that the impacts of MNPs on microbial decomposers include alterations in the antioxidative system, gene expression levels and cell-membrane permeability and oxidative damage, all of which can be further influenced by MNPs interaction with other contaminants. This review will thus provide critical insights and up-to-date knowledge to assist novices and experts in promoting advancements and research.

Toxic effects of aging mask microplastics on E. coli and dynamic changes in extracellular polymeric matter

Contamination of disposable medical masks has become a growing problem globally in the wake of Covid-19 due to their widespread use and improper disposal. Three different mask layers, namely the outer layer, the meltblown (MB) filler layer and the inner layers release three different types of microplastics, whose physical and chemical properties change after prolonged environmental weathering. In this study, physical and chemical changes of mask microplastics before and after aging were characterized by different characterization techniques. The toxic effect and mechanism of aged mask microplastics on Escherichia coli (E. coli) were studied by measuring the growth inhibition of mask microplastics, the change in ATPase activity, the change in malondialdehyde content and reactive oxygen species production, and the release of the chemical composition of exopolymeric substances (EPS). The microplastics of the aged MB filter layer had the most significant inhibitory effect on E. coli growth, reaching 19.2 % after 36 h. Also, under the influence of mask microplastics, ATPase activity of E. coli was inhibited and a large amount of EPS was released. The chemical composition of EPS has also changed. This study proposed the possible toxicity mechanism of mask microplastics and the self-protection mechanism of E. coli, and provided a reference for future research on the toxic effects of mask microplastics on environmental organisms.

Role of extracellular polymeric substances in the aggregation and biological response of micro(nano)plastics with different functional groups and sizes

In this work, the effects of extracellular polymeric substances (EPS) on the aggregation and biological responses of different micro(nano)plastics (MNPs, <1000 µm) were investigated. EPS increased the colloidal stability of PS MPs in NaCl or CaCl₂. For the three PS NPs (PS-NH₂, PS-COOH, and PS-naked), EPS also enhanced their colloidal stabilities in the presence of NaCl. However, the effect of CaCl₂ on the colloidal stabilities of PS NPs in the presence of EPS depended on their surface functional groups. In CaCl₂, both Derjaguin-Landau-Verwey-Overbeek theory and molecular bridging explained the interaction between MNPs (both NPs and MPs) and EPS. Laser Direct Infrared and scanning electron microscope imaging showed that opalescent EPS corona formed on PS MPs via intermolecular-bridging by Ca²⁺, and the critical coagulation concentrations (70 mM in NaCl, 1.5 mM in CaCl₂) in EPS were much lower than that for PS NPs (1000 mM for NaCl; 65 mM for CaCl₂). PS-NH₂ NPs showed the highest increase in the growth of bacteria (Bacillus subtilis), followed by PS MPs and PS-naked NPs, while PS-COOH NPs had no significant effect. Biological response of PS NPs was unaffected by EPS, while EPS further enhanced the positive effects of PS MPs on bacterial growth.

Effects of microplastics on arsenic uptake and distribution in rice seedlings

The potential of microplastics (MPs) and nanoplastics (NPs) to act as a carrier for heavy metals derived from the environment is of rising concern to the health of global ecosystems. Here, we investigated the effects of particle size of polystyrene micro/nano plastics on the uptake, accumulation, and toxicity of As in rice seedlings in a hydroponic system. Significant differences in As uptake and accumulation in different plant tissue were observed between the plants co-exposed to 82 nm NPs + As and 200 nm MPs + As. The NPs + As co-exposure led to higher As accumulation in rice leaves (12.4-36.7 %), while larger sized MPs + As(V) treatment reduced As accumulation in rice leaves. Furthermore, the co-exposure of NPs/MPs + As mitigated the rice growth inhibition caused by As toxicity. These results will provide insight into elucidating the potentially effects of nano/microplastics on As uptake and accumulation in crop plants for assessing the hazards of micro-and nanoplastics as pollutants in the food chain and environment.

From marine to freshwater environment: A review of the ecotoxicological effects of microplastics

Microplastics (MPs) have been widely detected in the world's water, which may pose a significant threat to the ecosystem as a whole and have been a subject of much attention because their presence impacts seas, lakes, rivers, and even the Polar Regions. There have been numerous studies that report direct adverse effects on marine organisms, but only a few have explored their ecological effects on freshwater organisms. In this field, there is still a lack of a systematic overview of the toxic effects and mechanisms of MPs on aquatic organisms, as well as a consistent understanding of the potential ecological consequences. This review describes the fate and impact on marine and freshwater aquatic organisms. Further, we examine the toxicology of MPs in order to uncover the relationship between aquatic organism responses to MPs and ecological disorders. In addition, an overview of the factors that may affect the toxicity effects of MPs on aquatic organisms was presented along with a brief examination of their identification and characterization. MPs were discussed in terms of their physicochemical properties in relation to their toxicological concerns regarding their bioavailability and environmental impact. This paper focuses on the progress of the toxicological studies of MPs on aquatic organisms (bacteria, algae, Daphnia, and fish, etc.) of different trophic levels, and explores its toxic mechanism, such as behavioral alternations, metabolism disorders, immune response, and poses a threat to the composition and stability of the ecosystem. We also review the main factors affecting the toxicity of MPs to aquatic organisms, including direct factors (polymer types, sizes, shapes, surface chemistry, etc.) and indirect factors (persistent organic pollutants, heavy metal ions, additives, and monomer, etc.), and the future research trends of MPs ecotoxicology are also pointed out. The findings of this study will be helpful in guiding future marine and freshwater rubbish studies and management strategies.

Hazard of polystyrene micro-and nanospheres to selected aquatic and terrestrial organisms

Plastics contamination in the environment is a major concern. Risk assessment of micro- and nanoplastics (MPL and NPL) poses significant challenges due to MPL and NPL heterogeneity regarding compositional polymers, particle sizes and morphologies in the environment. Yet, there exists considerable toxicological literature on commercial polystyrene (PS) micro- and nanospheres. Although such particles do not directly represent the environmental MPL and NPL, their toxicity data should be used to advance the hazard assessment of plastics. Here, toxicity data of PS micro- and nanospheres for microorganisms, aquatic and terrestrial invertebrates, fish, and higher plants was collected and analyzed. The evaluation of 294 papers revealed that aquatic invertebrates were the most studied organisms, nanosized PS was studied more often than microsized PS, acute exposures prevailed over chronic exposures, the toxicity of PS suspension additives was rarely addressed, and ∼40 % of data indicated no organismal effects of PS. Toxicity mechanisms were mainly studied in fish and nematode Caenorhabditis elegans, providing guidance for relevant studies in higher organisms. Future studies should focus on environmentally relevant plastics concentrations, wide range of organisms, co-exposures with other pollutants, and method development for plastics identification and quantification to fill the gap of bioaccumulation assessment of plastics.

Plastisphere showing unique microbiome and resistome different from activated sludge

Plastisphere (the biofilm on microplastics) in wastewater treatment plants (WWTPs) may enrich pathogens and antibiotic resistance genes (ARGs) which can cause risks to the ecological environment by discharging into receiving waters. However, the microbiome and resistome of plastisphere in activated sludge (AS) systems remain inconclusive. Here, metagenome was applied to investigate the microbial composition, functions and ARGs of the Polyvinyl chloride (PVC) plastisphere in lab-scale reactors, and revealed the effects of tetracycline (TC) and/or Cu(II) pressures on them. The results indicated that the plastisphere provided a new niche for microbiota showing unique functions distinct from the AS. Particularly, various potentially pathogenic bacteria tended to enrich in PVC plastisphere. Moreover, various ARGs were detected in plastisphere and AS, but the plastisphere had more potential ARGs hosts and a stronger correlation with ARGs. The ARGs abundances increased after exposure to TC and/or Cu(II) pressures, especially tetracycline resistance genes (TRGs), and the results further showed that TRGs with different resistance mechanisms were separately enriched in plastisphere and AS. Furthermore, the exogenous pressures from Cu(II) or/and TC also enhanced the association of potential pathogens with TRGs in PVC plastisphere. The findings contribute to assessing the potential risks of spreading pathogens and ARGs through microplastics in WWTPs.

Interactions between bacteria and nano (micro)-sized polystyrene particles by bacterial responses and microscopy

Microorganisms play an important role in biogeochemical cycles, and are inevitably found associated with plastic debris. The interplay between microbes and plastics may change the characteristics of certain plastics over time and drive the environmental fate of plastics. In this study, we evaluated interactions of bacteria with nano- and microplastics. Here, polystyrene (PS) polymer particles of various diameters, specifically 60, 220, 430, 700, 1040, 1700, and 2260 nm, were used as the plastics. Escherichia coli (E. coli, gram-negative) and Bacillus sp. (gram-positive) were chosen as model bacteria. The effects of nano- and microPS particles on E. coli and Bacillus sp. cells were investigated by measuring the growth and viability of the cells in laboratory-scale flasks and their generation of reactive oxygen species (ROS) upon their exposure to these particles of 100 mg/L. The particles inhibited the growth and viability of both types of bacterial cells, but their inhibitory effects varied depending on the diameter of PS particle. The 60-nm-diameter PS particles were visually observed to enter the cells as well as accumulate on their surfaces and enhanced ROS generation of the cells. Unexpectedly, the 1040-nm-diameter PS particles, similar in size to the bacterial cells, inhibited the growth of both E. coli and Bacillus sp. cells the most. The E. coli and Bacillus sp. cells formed microPS-biofilm complex by secreting an extracellular polymeric substance (EPS) in response to their exposure to the ∼ 1-μm-diameter PS particles. A positive correlation between relative ROS levels and specific growth rates of the E. coli cells were observed with a Pearson correlation coefficient r value of 0.676 (p < 0.05).

Toxicity of tire wear particles and the leachates to microorganisms in marine sediments

Tire wear particles (TWPs), which are among the microplastic pollutants in the environment, can inevitably accumulate in coastal sediments. The present study comprehensively investigated the effect of pristine TWPs on bacterial community structure in coastal sediments and compared the effect of pristine TWPs and aged TWPs on nine strains of bacteria in sediments. In addition, the effect of the TWP leachate was studied with all the nine bacterial strains and the toxicity-causing substances in the leachate was investigated using Bacillus subtilis. Exposure to TWPs could lead to a shift in bacteria community and affect nitrogen metabolism in marine sediments. Aged TWPs were more toxic than pristine TWPs due to changes in particle surface characteristics. The leachate exhibited greater toxicity than TWPs as well, and Zn was identified to be the major toxicity-causing substance. The overall results of this study are important for understanding the effects of TWPs and the leachates on microorganisms in marine sediments.

Biofouling impacts on polyethylene density and sinking in coastal waters: A macro/micro tipping point?

Biofouling causing an increase in plastic density and sinking is one of the hypotheses to account for the unexpectedly low amount of buoyant plastic debris encountered at the ocean surface. Field surveys show that polyethylene and polypropylene, the two most abundant buoyant plastics, both occur below the surface and in sediments, and experimental studies confirm that biofouling can cause both of these plastics to sink. However, studies quantifying the actual density of fouled plastics are rare, despite the fact that density will determine the transport and eventual fate of plastic in the ocean. Here we investigated the role of microbial biofilms in sinking of polyethylene microplastic and quantified the density changes natural biofouling communities cause in the coastal waters of the North Sea. Molecular data confirmed the variety of bacteria and eukaryotes (including animals and other multicellular organisms) colonizing the plastic over time. Fouling communities increased the density of plastic and caused sinking, and the plastic remained negatively buoyant even during the winter with lower growth rates. Relative surface area alone, however, did not predict whether a plastic piece sank. Due to patchy colonization, fragmentation of sinking pieces may result in smaller pieces regaining buoyancy and returning to the surface. Our results suggest that primarily multicellular organisms cause sinking of plastic pieces with surface area to volume ratios (SA:V) below 100 (generally pieces above a couple hundred micrometers in size), and that this is a "tipping point" at which microbial biofilms become the key players causing sinking of smaller pieces with higher SA:V ratios, including most fibers that are too small for larger (multicellular) organisms to colonize.