Competition between abiogenic Al3+ and native Mg2+, Fe2+ and Zn2+ ions in protein binding sites: implications for aluminum toxicity

The Role of Axial Ligand in Determining the Mg2+/TM2+ (TM = Fe, Mn, Cu, Zn) Selectivity in Chlorophyll

Life on Earth is sustained due to plants, algae, and cyanobacteria's exquisite ability to store energy from light and convert it into a form that can be utilized by living organisms. In this process, the compound of immense significance, chlorophyll, actively participates. It consists of a chlorin unit with different substituents, depending on the type of chlorophyll molecule. The main element, however, is the magnesium cation bound to the center of the tetrapyrrole macrocycle. One additional axial ligand of diverse nature is often attached to the cation to complement the structure of the complex. The present study aims at elucidating the role of the additional ligand for determining the metal selectivity in chlorophyll molecules by implementing a widely applied methodology based on Density Functional Theory. The obtained results provide information about the thermodynamic outcome of the competition between Mg2+ and a series of transition biogenic metal cations such as Fe2+, Mn2+, Cu2+, and Zn2+ in model chlorophyll metal binding sites in two environments of different polarity, delineating the key factors that contribute to the process in the greatest extent. The results of calculations are discussed in light of known experimental data and hence shed light on the metal selectivity process in this system.

Carbonic Anhydrases: Different Active Sites, Same Metal Selectivity Rules

Carbonic anhydrases are mononuclear metalloenzymes catalyzing the reversible hydration of carbon dioxide in organisms belonging to all three domains of life. Although the mechanism of the catalytic reaction is similar, different families of carbonic anhydrases do not have a common ancestor nor do they exhibit significant resemblance in the amino acid sequence or the structure and composition of the metal-binding sites. Little is known about the physical principles determining the metal affinity and selectivity of the catalytic centers, and how well the native metal is protected from being dislodged by other metal species from the local environment. Here, we endeavor to shed light on these issues by studying (via a combination of density functional theory calculations and polarizable continuum model computations) the thermodynamic outcome of the competition between the native metal cation and its noncognate competitor in various metal-binding sites. Typical representatives of the competing cations from the cellular environments of the respective classes of carbonic anhydrases are considered. The calculations reveal how the Gibbs energy of the metal competition changes when varying the metal type, structure, composition, and solvent exposure of the active center. Physical principles governing metal competition in different carbonic anhydrase metal-binding sites are delineated.

Abnormalities in Copper Status Associated with an Elevated Risk of Parkinson's Phenotype Development

In the last 15 years, among the many reasons given for the development of idiopathic forms of Parkinson's disease (PD), copper imbalance has been identified as a factor, and PD is often referred to as a copper-mediated disorder. More than 640 papers have been devoted to the relationship between PD and copper status in the blood, which include the following markers: total copper concentration, enzymatic ceruloplasmin (Cp) concentration, Cp protein level, and non-ceruloplasmin copper level. Most studies measure only one of these markers. Therefore, the existence of a correlation between copper status and the development of PD is still debated. Based on data from the published literature, meta-analysis, and our own research, it is clear that there is a connection between the development of PD symptoms and the number of copper atoms, which are weakly associated with the ceruloplasmin molecule. In this work, the link between the risk of developing PD and various inborn errors related to copper metabolism, leading to decreased levels of oxidase ceruloplasmin in the circulation and cerebrospinal fluid, is discussed.

Electrostatic interactions - key determinants of the metal selectivity in La3+ and Ca2+ binding proteins

Nearly half of all known proteins contain metal co-factors. In the course of evolution two dozen metal cations (mostly monovalent and divalent species) have been selected to participate in processes of vital importance for living organisms. Trivalent metal cations have also been selected, although to a lesser extent as compared with their mono- and divalent counterparts. Notably, factors governing the metal selectivity in trivalent metal centers in proteins are less well understood than those in the respective divalent metal centers. Thus, the source of high La³⁺/Ca²⁺ selectivity in lanthanum-binding proteins, as compared with that of calcium-binding proteins (i.e., calmodulin), is still shrouded in mystery. The well-calibrated thermochemical calculations, performed here, reveal the dominating role of electrostatic interactions in shaping the metal selectivity in La³⁺-binding centers. The calculations also disclose other (second-order) determinants of metal selectivity in these systems, such as the rigidity and extent of solvent exposure of the binding site. All these factors are also implicated in shaping the metal selectivity in Ca²⁺-binding proteins.

Lanthanides as Calcium Mimetic Species in Calcium-Signaling/Buffering Proteins: The Effect of Lanthanide Type on the Ca2+/Ln3+ Competition

Lanthanides, the 14 4f-block elements plus Lanthanum, have been extensively used to study the structure and biochemical properties of metalloproteins. The characteristics of lanthanides within the lanthanide series are similar, but not identical. The present research offers a systematic investigation of the ability of the entire Ln3+ series to substitute for Ca2+ in biological systems. A well-calibrated DFT/PCM protocol is employed in studying the factors that control the metal selectivity in biological systems by modeling typical calcium signaling/buffering binding sites and elucidating the thermodynamic outcome of the competition between the “alien” La3+/Ln3+ and “native” Ca2+, and La3+ − Ln3+ within the lanthanide series. The calculations performed reveal that the major determinant of the Ca2+/Ln3+ selectivity in calcium proteins is the net charge of the calcium binding pocket; the more negative the charge, the higher the competitiveness of the trivalent Ln3+ with respect to its Ca2+ contender. Solvent exposure of the binding site also influences the process; buried active centers with net charge of −4 or −3 are characterized by higher Ln3+ over Ca2+ selectivity, whereas it is the opposite for sites with overall charge of −1. Within the series, the competition between La3+ and its fellow lanthanides is determined by the balance between two competing effects: electronic (favoring heavier lanthanides) and solvation (generally favoring the lighter lanthanides).

Discriminative 'Turn-on' Detection of Al3+ and Ga3+ Ions as Well as Aspartic Acid by Two Fluorescent Chemosensors

In this work, two Schiff-base-based chemosensors L1 and L2 containing electron-rich quinoline and anthracene rings were designed. L1 is AIEE active in a MeOH-H₂O solvent system while formed aggregates as confirmed by the DLS measurements and fluorescence lifetime studies. The chemosensor L1 was used for the sensitive, selective, and reversible 'turn-on' detection of Al³⁺ and Ga³⁺ ions as well as Aspartic Acid (Asp). Chemosensor L2, an isomer of L1, was able to selectively detect Ga³⁺ ion even in the presence of Al³⁺ ions and thus was able to discriminate between the two ions. The binding mode of chemosensors with analytes was substantiated through a combination of ¹H NMR spectra, mass spectra, and DFT studies. The 'turn-on' nature of fluorescence sensing by the two chemosensors enabled the development of colorimetric detection, filter-paper-based test strips, and polystyrene film-based detection techniques.

How Theoretical Evaluations Can Generate Guidelines for Designing/Engineering Metalloproteins with Desired Metal Affinity and Selectivity

Almost half of all known proteins contain metal co-factors. Crucial for the flawless performance of a metalloprotein is the selection with high fidelity of the cognate metal cation from the surrounding biological fluids. Therefore, elucidating the factors controlling the metal binding and selectivity in metalloproteins is of particular significance. The knowledge thus acquired not only contributes to better understanding of the intimate mechanism of these events but, also, significantly enriches the researcher's toolbox that could be used in designing/engineering novel metalloprotein structures with pre-programmed properties. A powerful tool in aid of deciphering the physical principles behind the processes of metal recognition and selectivity is theoretical modeling of metal-containing biological structures. This review summarizes recent findings in the field with an emphasis on elucidating the major factors governing these processes. The results from theoretical evaluations are discussed. It is the hope that the physical principles evaluated can serve as guidelines in designing/engineering of novel metalloproteins of interest to both science and industry.

A DFT/PCM Study on the Affinity of Salinomycin to Bind Monovalent Metal Cations

The affinity of the polyether ionophore salinomycin to bind IA/IB metal ions was accessed using the Gibbs free energy of the competition reaction between SalNa (taken as a reference) and its rival ions: [M+-solution] + [SalNa] → [SalM] + [Na+-solution] (M = Li, K, Rb, Cs, Cu, Ag, Au). The DFT/PCM computations revealed that the ionic radius, charge density and accepting ability of the competing metal cations, as well as the dielectric properties of the solvent, have an influence upon the selectivity of salinomycin. The optimized structures of the monovalent metal complexes demonstrate the flexibility of the ionophore, allowing the coordination of one or two water ligands in SalM-W1 and SalM-W2, respectively. The metal cations are responsible for the inner coordination sphere geometry, with coordination numbers spread between 2 (Au+), 4 (Li+ and Cu+), 5/6 (Na+, K+, Ag+), 6/7 (Rb+) and 7/8 (Cs+). The metals' affinity to salinomycin in low-polarity media follows the order of Li+ > Cu+ > Na+ > K+ > Au+ > Ag+ > Rb+ > Cs+, whereas some derangement takes place in high-dielectric environment: Li+ ≥ Na+ > K+ > Cu+ > Au+ > Ag+ > Rb+ > Cs+.

Cytotoxicity and changes in gene expression under aluminium potassium sulfate on Spodoptera frugiperda 9 cells

Aluminium, a substance found in large amounts in nature, has been widely used for various purposes, especially food additives. The effects of long-term and excessive exposure to aluminium on human health are receiving increasing attention. The extensive human use of aluminium food additives can also cause aluminium to enter the ecosystem, where it has significant impacts on insects. This study explored the cytotoxicity and changes in gene expression under aluminium potassium sulfate toward Spodoptera frugiperda 9 cells. We found that high concentrations of aluminium resulted in cell enlargement and cell membrane breakage, decreased cell vitality, and apoptosis. Through RNA-Seq transcriptomics, we found that aluminium ions may inhibit the expression of regulatory-associated protein of mTOR, tdIns-dependent protein kinase-1, and small heat shock proteins (heat shock 70 kDa protein and crystallin alpha B), leading to changes in mTOR-related pathways (such as the longevity regulation pathway and PI3K-Akt signalling pathway), and promoting cell apoptosis. On the other hand, aluminium ions lead to the overexpression of GSH S-transferase, prostaglandin-H2 D-isomerase and pyrimidodiazepine synthase, and induce intracellular oxidative damage, which ultimately affects cell growth and apoptosis through a series of cascade reactions.

Ca2+/Sr2+ Selectivity in Calcium-Sensing Receptor (CaSR): Implications for Strontium's Anti-Osteoporosis Effect

The extracellular calcium-sensing receptor (CaSR) controls vital bone cell functions such as cell growth, differentiation and apoptosis. The binding of the native agonist (Ca2+) to CaSR activates the receptor, which undergoes structural changes that trigger a cascade of events along the cellular signaling pathways. Strontium (in the form of soluble salts) has been found to also be a CaSR agonist. The activation of the receptor by Sr2+ is considered to be the major mechanism through which strontium exerts its anti-osteoporosis effect, mostly in postmenopausal women. Strontium-activated CaSR initiates a series of signal transduction events resulting in both osteoclast apoptosis and osteoblast differentiation, thus strengthening the bone tissue. The intimate mechanism of Sr2+ activation of CaSR is still enigmatic. Herewith, by employing a combination of density functional theory (DFT) calculations and polarizable continuum model (PCM) computations, we have found that the Ca2+ binding sites 1, 3, and 4 in the activated CaSR, although possessing a different number and type of protein ligands, overall structure and charge state, are all selective for Ca2+ over Sr2+. The three binding sites, regardless of their structural differences, exhibit almost equal metal selectivity if they are flexible and have no geometrical constraints on the incoming Sr2+. In contrast to Ca2+ and Sr2+, Mg2+ constructs, when allowed to fully relax during the optimization process, adopt their stringent six-coordinated octahedral structure at the expense of detaching a one-backbone carbonyl ligand and shifting it to the second coordination layer of the metal. The binding of Mg2+ and Sr2+ to a rigid/inflexible calcium-designed binding pocket requires an additional energy penalty for the binding ion; however, the price for doing so (to be paid by Sr2+) is much less than that of Mg2+. The results obtained delineate the key factors controlling the competition between metal cations for the receptor and shed light on some aspects of strontium's therapeutic effects.

Calcium in Signaling: Its Specificity and Vulnerabilities toward Biogenic and Abiogenic Metal Ions

Divalent calcium ion (Ca²⁺) plays an indispensable role as a second messenger in a myriad of signal transduction processes. Of utmost importance for the faultless functioning of calcium-modulated signaling proteins is their binding selectivity of the native metal cation over rival biogenic/abiogenic metal ion contenders in the intra/extracellular fluids. In this Perspective, we summarize recent findings on the competition between the cognate Ca²⁺ and other biogenic or abiogenic divalent cations for binding to Ca²⁺-signaling proteins or organic cofactors. We describe the competition between the two most abundant intracellular biogenic metal ions (Mg²⁺ and Ca²⁺) for Ca²⁺-binding sites in signaling proteins, followed by the rivalry between native Ca²⁺ and "therapeutic" Li⁺ as well as "toxic" Pb²⁺. We delineate the key factors governing the rivalry between the native and non-native cations in proteins and highlight key implications for the biological performance of the respective proteins/organic cofactors.

Strontium Binding to α-Parvalbumin, a Canonical Calcium-Binding Protein of the "EF-Hand" Family

Strontium salts are used for treatment of osteoporosis and bone cancer, but their impact on calcium-mediated physiological processes remains obscure. To explore Sr²⁺ interference with Ca²⁺ binding to proteins of the EF-hand family, we studied Sr²⁺/Ca²⁺ interaction with a canonical EF-hand protein, α-parvalbumin (α-PA). Evaluation of the equilibrium metal association constants for the active Ca²⁺ binding sites of recombinant human α-PA (‘CD’ and ‘EF’ sites) from fluorimetric titration experiments and isothermal titration calorimetry data gave 4 × 10⁹ M⁻¹ and 4 × 10⁹ M⁻¹ for Ca²⁺, and 2 × 10⁷ M⁻¹ and 2 × 10⁶ M⁻¹ for Sr²⁺. Inactivation of the EF site by homologous substitution of the Ca²⁺-coordinating Glu in position 12 of the EF-loop by Gln decreased Ca²⁺/Sr²⁺ affinity of the protein by an order of magnitude, whereas the analogous inactivation of the CD site induced much deeper suppression of the Ca²⁺/Sr²⁺ affinity. These results suggest that Sr²⁺ and Ca²⁺ bind to CD/EF sites of α-PA and the Ca²⁺/Sr²⁺ binding are sequential processes with the CD site being occupied first. Spectrofluorimetric Sr²⁺ titration of the Ca²⁺-loaded α-PA revealed presence of secondary Sr²⁺ binding site(s) with an apparent equilibrium association constant of 4 × 10⁵ M⁻¹. Fourier-transform infrared spectroscopy data evidence that Ca²⁺/Sr²⁺-loaded forms of α-PA exhibit similar states of their COO⁻ groups. Near-UV circular dichroism (CD) data show that Ca²⁺/Sr²⁺ binding to α-PA induce similar changes in symmetry of microenvironment of its Phe residues. Far-UV CD experiments reveal that Ca²⁺/Sr²⁺ binding are accompanied by nearly identical changes in secondary structure of α-PA. Meanwhile, scanning calorimetry measurements show markedly lower Sr²⁺-induced increase in stability of tertiary structure of α-PA, compared to the Ca²⁺-induced effect. Theoretical modeling using Density Functional Theory computations with Polarizable Continuum Model calculations confirms that Ca²⁺-binding sites of α-PA are well protected against exchange of Ca²⁺ for Sr²⁺ regardless of coordination number of Sr²⁺, solvent exposure or rigidity of sites. The latter appears to be a key determinant of the Ca²⁺/Sr²⁺ selectivity. Overall, despite lowered affinity of α-PA to Sr²⁺, the latter competes with Ca²⁺ for the same EF-hands and induces similar structural rearrangements. The presence of a secondary Sr²⁺ binding site(s) could be a factor contributing to Sr²⁺ impact on the functional activity of proteins.

Competition between abiogenic and biogenic metal cations in biological systems: Mechanisms of gallium's anticancer and antibacterial effect

Metal cations are key players in a plethora of essential biological processes. Over the course of evolution specific biological functions have been bestowed upon two dozen of (biogenic) metal species, some of the most frequently found being sodium, potassium, magnesium, calcium, zinc, manganese, iron, and copper. On the other hand, there is a group of less studied abiogenic metals like lithium, strontium and gallium that possess not known functions in living organisms, but, by mimicking the native ions and/or competing with them for binding to key metalloenzymes, may exert beneficial effect on humans in particular medical conditions. This review summarizes and critically examines the mechanisms of gallium's therapeutic action in anticancer and antibacterial therapies by exploiting the tools of molecular modeling and experimental biochemistry. These approaches allow for identifying key factors for Ga³⁺ beneficial effect such as the electrostatic interactions with the protein ligands, substrates or bacterial siderophores, intramolecular hydrogen bond formation, and pH and dielectric properties of the medium. Several intriguing questions concerning the gallium competition with the native ferric ion have found their answers.

Factors governing the competition between group IA and IB cations for monensin A: a DFT/PCM study

The results obtained suggest that the metal selectivity of monensin can be modulated by changing the solvents used.

How mechanical forces can modulate the metal affinity and selectivity of metal binding sites in proteins

The results obtained reveal that applying mechanical forces with a given strength and directionality can modulate the metal affinity and selectivity of metal binding sites in metalloproteins.

Electric field influence on the helical structure of peptides: insights from DFT/PCM computations

The switching of the electric field with a particular directionality could be used for the healing of misfolded proteins.

How an electric field can modulate the metal ion selectivity of protein binding sites: insights from DFT/PCM calculations

An electric field (internal or external) is a potent force that can modulate the metal selectivity of a protein binding site.