Analyzing Glycopeptide Isomers by Combining Differential Mobility Spectrometry with Electron- and Collision-Based Tandem Mass Spectrometry

Analysis of N- and O-linked site-specific glycosylation by ion mobility mass spectrometry: State of the art and future directions

Glycosylation, the major post-translational modification of proteins, significantly increases the diversity of proteoforms. Glycans are involved in a variety of pivotal structural and functional roles of proteins, and changes in glycosylation are profoundly connected to the progression of numerous diseases. Mass spectrometry (MS) has emerged as the gold standard for glycan and glycopeptide analysis because of its high sensitivity and the wealth of fragmentation information that can be obtained. Various separation techniques have been employed to resolve glycan and glycopeptide isomers at the front end of the MS. However, differentiating structures of isobaric and isomeric glycopeptides constitutes a challenge in MS-based characterization. Many reports described the use of various ion mobility-mass spectrometry (IM-MS) techniques for glycomic analyses. Nevertheless, very few studies have focused on N- and O-linked site-specific glycopeptidomic analysis. Unlike glycomics, glycoproteomics presents a multitude of inherent challenges in microheterogeneity, which are further exacerbated by the lack of dedicated bioinformatics tools. In this review, we cover recent advances made towards the growing field of site-specific glycosylation analysis using IM-MS with a specific emphasis on the MS techniques and capabilities in resolving isomeric peptidoglycan structures. Furthermore, we discuss commonly used software that supports IM-MS data analysis of glycopeptides.

Analysis of Sialic Acid Linkage in N-Linked Glycopeptides Using Liquid Chromatography-Electron-Activated Dissociation Time-of-Flight Mass Spectrometry

Herein, we report a novel liquid chromatography coupled with tandem mass spectrometry method to characterize N-acetylneuraminic acid (Neu5Ac, Sa) linkage in N-linked glycans in glycopeptides with no sialic acid derivatization. First, we established a separation in reversed-phase high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) using a higher formic acid concentration in the mobile phases, which separated the N-glycopeptides depending on the Sa linkage. We also demonstrated a novel characterization method of Sa linkages in N-glycopeptides using electron-activated dissociation. We found that hot electron capture dissociation using an electron beam energy higher than 5 eV cleaved glycosidic bonds in glycopeptides, resulting in each glycosidic bond in the antennas being broken on both sides of the oxygen atom. Such glycosidic bond cleavage at the reducing end (C-type ion) showed the difference in Sa linkages between Sa-Gal, Gal-GlcNAc, and GlcNAc-Man. We proposed a rule to characterize the Sa linkages using the Sa-Gal products. This method was applied to N-glycopeptides in tryptic fetuin digest separated by an optimized reversed-phase HPLC. We successfully identified a number of isomeric glycoforms in the glycopeptides with different Sa links, whose peptide backbones were also simultaneously sequenced by hot ECD.

MS-based glycomics and glycoproteomics methods enabling isomeric characterization

Glycosylation is one of the most significant and abundant posttranslational modifications in mammalian cells. It mediates a wide range of biofunctions, including cell adhesion, cell communication, immune cell trafficking, and protein stability. Also, aberrant glycosylation has been associated with various diseases such as diabetes, Alzheimer's disease, inflammation, immune deficiencies, congenital disorders, and cancers. The alterations in the distributions of glycan and glycopeptide isomers are involved in the development and progression of several human diseases. However, the microheterogeneity of glycosylation brings a great challenge to glycomic and glycoproteomic analysis, including the characterization of isomers. Over several decades, different methods and approaches have been developed to facilitate the characterization of glycan and glycopeptide isomers. Mass spectrometry (MS) has been a powerful tool utilized for glycomic and glycoproteomic isomeric analysis due to its high sensitivity and rich structural information using different fragmentation techniques. However, a comprehensive characterization of glycan and glycopeptide isomers remains a challenge when utilizing MS alone. Therefore, various separation methods, including liquid chromatography, capillary electrophoresis, and ion mobility, were developed to resolve glycan and glycopeptide isomers before MS. These separation techniques were coupled to MS for a better identification and quantitation of glycan and glycopeptide isomers. Additionally, bioinformatic tools are essential for the automated processing of glycan and glycopeptide isomeric data to facilitate isomeric studies in biological cohorts. Here in this review, we discuss commonly employed MS-based techniques, separation hyphenated MS methods, and software, facilitating the separation, identification, and quantitation of glycan and glycopeptide isomers.

Methods to improve quantitative glycoprotein coverage from bottom-up LC-MS data

Advances in mass spectrometry instrumentation, methods development, and bioinformatics have greatly improved the ease and accuracy of site-specific, quantitative glycoproteomics analysis. Data-dependent acquisition is the most popular method for identification and quantification of glycopeptides; however, complete coverage of glycosylation site glycoforms remains elusive with this method. Targeted acquisition methods improve the precision and accuracy of quantification, but at the cost of throughput and discoverability. Data-independent acquisition (DIA) holds great promise for more complete and highly quantitative site-specific glycoproteomics analysis, while maintaining the ability to discover novel glycopeptides without prior knowledge. We review additional features that can be used to increase selectivity and coverage to the DIA workflow: retention time modeling, which would simplify the interpretation of complex tandem mass spectra, and ion mobility separation, which would maximize the sampling of all precursors at a giving chromatographic retention time. The instrumentation and bioinformatics to incorporate these features into glycoproteomics analysis exist. These improvements in quantitative, site-specific analysis will enable researchers to assess glycosylation similarity in related biological systems, answering new questions about the interplay between glycosylation state and biological function.

Mass Spectrometry-Based Techniques to Elucidate the Sugar Code

Cells encode information in the sequence of biopolymers, such as nucleic acids, proteins, and glycans. Although glycans are essential to all living organisms, surprisingly little is known about the "sugar code" and the biological roles of these molecules. The reason glycobiology lags behind its counterparts dealing with nucleic acids and proteins lies in the complexity of carbohydrate structures, which renders their analysis extremely challenging. Building blocks that may differ only in the configuration of a single stereocenter, combined with the vast possibilities to connect monosaccharide units, lead to an immense variety of isomers, which poses a formidable challenge to conventional mass spectrometry. In recent years, however, a combination of innovative ion activation methods, commercialization of ion mobility-mass spectrometry, progress in gas-phase ion spectroscopy, and advances in computational chemistry have led to a revolution in mass spectrometry-based glycan analysis. The present review focuses on the above techniques that expanded the traditional glycomics toolkit and provided spectacular insight into the structure of these fascinating biomolecules. To emphasize the specific challenges associated with them, major classes of mammalian glycans are discussed in separate sections. By doing so, we aim to put the spotlight on the most important element of glycobiology: the glycans themselves.

Microflow Liquid Chromatography Coupled to Mass Spectrometry (μLC-MS) Workflow for O-Glycopeptides Isomers Analysis Combining Differential Mobility Spectrometry and Collision Induced and Electron Capture Dissociation

Peptide and protein O-glycosylation can occur mostly on any serine or threonine and could generate several positional isomers, which may coelute during liquid chromatography (LC) separation, challenging their characterization. Ion mobility has emerged as a technique of interest to separate isomeric compounds. In the different ion mobility techniques, differential ion mobility (DMS) includes the particular interest to tune ion separation by the possible addition of an organic modifier. Different microflow liquid chromatography coupled to mass spectrometry (μLC-MS) workflows were investigated for the analysis of a set of four model peptides made of three isomeric glycopeptides and a corresponding nonglycosylated peptide using differential mobility spectrometry (DMS), collision induced dissociation (CID), and electron capture dissociation (ECD). Neither DMS nor LC provided sufficient separation of the three isomeric O-glycopeptides while the nonmodified one was clearly separated by LC. The hyphenation of LC with DMS led to differentiating the three glycopeptides, and further detection and characterization (ECD/CID) with a chimeric collision cell were achieved in a single LC run. The position of the modification was determined from ECD data, while CID data characterized the sugar through its distinctive oxoniums ions in the low mass range.

Rapid separation of cannabinoid isomer sets using differential mobility spectrometry and mass spectrometry

With legalization and decriminalization of cannabis in many parts of the world comes the need for rapid separation and quantitation of the psychoactive ingredients.

Effective discrimination of gas-phase peptide conformers using TIMS-ECD-ToF MS/MS

In the present work, four, well-studied, model peptides (e.g., substance P, bradykinin, angiotensin I and AT-Hook 3) were used to correlate structural information provided by ion mobility and ECD/CID fragmentation in a TIMS-q-EMS-ToF MS/MS platform, incorporporating an electromagnetostatic cell (EMS). The structural heterogeneity of the model peptides was observed by (i) multi-component ion mobility profiles (high ion mobility resolving power, R ∼115-145), and (ii) fast online characteristic ECD fragmentation patterns per ion mobility band (∼0.2 min). Particularly, it was demonstrated that all investigated species were probably conformers, involving cis/trans-isomerizations at X-Pro peptide bond, following the same protonation schemes, in good agreement with previous ion mobility and single point mutation experiments. The comparison between ion mobility selected ECD spectra and traditional FT-ICR ECD MS/MS spectra showed comparable ECD fragmentation efficiencies but differences in the ratio of radical (˙)/prime (') fragment species (H˙ transfer), which were associated with the differences in detection time after the electron capture event. The analysis of model peptides using online TIMS-q-EMSToF MS/MS provided complementary structural information on the intramolecular interactions that stabilize the different gas-phase conformations to those obtained by ion mobility or ECD alone.

Putting the pieces together: mapping the O-glycoproteome

Protein glycosylation is the most diverse and omnipresent protein modification. Glycosylation provides glycoproteins with important structural and functional properties to facilitate critical biological processes. Despite the significance of protein glycosylation, the investigation of glycoproteome, especially O-linked glycoproteome, remains elusive due to the lack of a comprehensive methodology to conform with the diversity of O-linked glycoforms of O-linked glycoproteins. In recent years, mass spectrometry has become an indispensable tool for the characterization of O-linked glycosylated proteins across biological systems. We herein highlight the recent developments in MS-based O-linked glycoproteomic technologies, quantitative data acquisition strategy and bioinformatic tools, with a special focus on mucin-type O-linked glycosylation.

UVPD Spectroscopy of Differential Mobility-Selected Prototropic Isomers of Rivaroxaban

Two ion populations of protonated Rivaroxaban, [C₁₉H₁₈ClN₃O₅S + H]⁺, are separated under pure N₂ conditions using differential mobility spectrometry prior to characterization in a hybrid triple quadrupole linear ion trap mass spectrometer. These populations are attributed to bare protonated Rivaroxaban and to a proton-bound Rivaroxaban-ammonia complex, which dissociates prior to mass-selecting the parent ion. Ultraviolet photodissociation (UVPD) and collision-induced dissociation (CID) studies indicate that both protonated Rivaroxaban ion populations are comprised of the computed global minimum prototropic isomer. Two ion populations are also observed when the collision environment is modified with 1.5% (v/v) acetonitrile. In this case, the protonated Rivaroxaban ion populations are produced by the dissociation of the ammonium complex and by the dissociation of a proton-bound Rivaroxaban-acetonitrile complex prior to mass selection. Again, both populations exhibit a similar CID behavior; however, UVPD spectra indicate that the two ion populations are associated with different prototropic isomers. The experimentally acquired spectra are compared with computed spectra and are assigned to two prototropic isomers that exhibit proton sharing between distal oxygen centers.

Towards structure-focused glycoproteomics

Facilitated by advances in the separation sciences, mass spectrometry and informatics, glycoproteomics, the analysis of intact glycopeptides at scale, has recently matured enabling new insights into the complex glycoproteome. While diverse quantitative glycoproteomics strategies capable of mapping monosaccharide compositions of N- and O-linked glycans to discrete sites of proteins within complex biological mixtures with considerable sensitivity, quantitative accuracy and coverage have become available, developments supporting the advancement of structure-focused glycoproteomics, a recognised frontier in the field, have emerged. Technologies capable of providing site-specific information of the glycan fine structures in a glycoproteome-wide context are indeed necessary to address many pending questions in glycobiology. In this review, we firstly survey the latest glycoproteomics studies published in 2018–2020, their approaches and their findings, and then summarise important technological innovations in structure-focused glycoproteomics. Our review illustrates that while the O-glycoproteome remains comparably under-explored despite the emergence of new O-glycan-selective mucinases and other innovative tools aiding O-glycoproteome profiling, quantitative glycoproteomics is increasingly used to profile the N-glycoproteome to tackle diverse biological questions. Excitingly, new strategies compatible with structure-focused glycoproteomics including novel chemoenzymatic labelling, enrichment, separation, and mass spectrometry-based detection methods are rapidly emerging revealing glycan fine structural details including bisecting GlcNAcylation, core and antenna fucosylation, and sialyl-linkage information with protein site resolution. Glycoproteomics has clearly become a mainstay within the glycosciences that continues to reach a broader community. It transpires that structure-focused glycoproteomics holds a considerable potential to aid our understanding of systems glycobiology and unlock secrets of the glycoproteome in the immediate future.

A Pragmatic Guide to Enrichment Strategies for Mass Spectrometry-Based Glycoproteomics

Glycosylation is a prevalent, yet heterogeneous modification with a broad range of implications in molecular biology. This heterogeneity precludes enrichment strategies that can be universally beneficial for all glycan classes. Thus, choice of enrichment strategy has profound implications on experimental outcomes. Here we review common enrichment strategies used in modern mass spectrometry-based glycoproteomic experiments, including lectins and other affinity chromatographies, hydrophilic interaction chromatography and its derivatives, porous graphitic carbon, reversible and irreversible chemical coupling strategies, and chemical biology tools that often leverage bioorthogonal handles. Interest in glycoproteomics continues to surge as mass spectrometry instrumentation and software improve, so this review aims to help equip researchers with the necessary information to choose appropriate enrichment strategies that best complement these efforts.

High-Resolution Ion Mobility Separations of Isomeric Glycoforms with Variations on the Peptide and Glycan Levels

Glycosylation is a ubiquitous post-translational modification (PTM) that strongly affects the protein folding and function. Glycosylation patterns are impacted by many diseases, making promising biomarkers. Glycans are also the most complex PTMs, exhibiting isomers (linkage, anomers, and those with isomeric moieties). Permuted with localization variants that occur for all PTMs, these produce numerous isomeric glycoforms. Characterizing them by mass spectrometry and ion mobility spectrometry (IMS) has been a challenge. High-definition differential IMS (FAIMS) had robustly disentangled isomeric peptides involving other PTMs but was not evaluated for glycopeptides that featured multilevel isomerism. Here, we apply it to representative mucin glycopeptides with O-linked glycans: three GalNAc localization variants, a pair with α/β GalNAc anomers, and another with GalNAc/GlcNAc isomers. The first two classes were separated baseline with the resolution exceeding previous benchmarks by 10-fold, and the last pair was partly resolved. The recently demonstrated straightforward coupling to ultrahigh-resolution MS and electron-transfer dissociation makes high-definition FAIMS an attractive tool for glycoproteomics.

Composition and charge state influence on the ion-neutral collision cross sections of protonated N-linked glycopeptides: an experimental and theoretical deconstruction of coulombic repulsion vs. charge solvation effects

Ion mobility spectrometry (IMS) is of significant interest as a platform for glycoanalysis. While much attention has been focused on the resolution of isomeric carbohydrates and glycoconjugates, another appealing aspect of IMS is the ability to sort different classes of biomolecules into distinct regions of mass vs. mobility space. This capability has potential to greatly simplify glycoproteomic analyses, as glycosylated and non-glycosylated peptides can be rapidly partitioned in the gas phase. Nevertheless, the physical and chemical characteristics of glycopeptides that dictate their mass vs. mobility loci have yet to be systematically investigated. This report presents an IMS study of model protonated glycopeptide ions with systematically varied oligosaccharide topologies, polypeptide sequences, and charge states. In all, over 110 ion-neutral collision cross sections (CCSs) were measured and analyzed in the context of the physicochemical characteristics of the analytes. Glycan size and composition emerged as a decisive factor in dictating the CCS space occupied by the glycopeptides and exerted this influence in a charge state dependent fashion. Furthermore, elongation of the glycan group was found to either increase or decrease glycopeptide CCSs depending on the ion charge state and the size of the glycan. Molecular dynamics (MD) simulations of the gas phase structures and CCSs of selected glycopeptides revealed that the experimental observations were consistent with a glycan size and charge state dependent interplay between destabilizing coulombic repulsion effects (tending to result in more extended structures) and stabilizing charge solvation effects in which the glycan plays a major role (tending to result in more compact structures). Taken together, these IMS and MD findings suggest the possibility of predicting and delineating glycopeptide-enriched regions of mass vs. mobility space for applications in glycoproteomics.

Identification of bifucosylated glycoforms using low-energy CID spectra

We have used tandem mass spectrometry (MS/MS)-based analysis of glycopeptides in order to identify the composition and structure of rare glycoforms. The results illustrate utility of low-energy MS/MS for structure identification. We have shown the presence of bifucosylated and trifucosylated glycoforms in human α-1-acid glycoprotein (AGP), a major plasma glycoprotein. Fucosylation in the case of AGP always occurs on the antennae; core fucosylation was not observed.

Separation of Sialylated Glycan Isomers by Differential Mobility Spectrometry

Mass spectrometry has proven itself to be an important technology for characterizing intact glycoproteins, glycopeptides, and released glycans. However, these molecules often present significant challenges during analysis. For example, glycans of identical molecular weights can be present in many isomeric forms, with one form having dramatically more biological activity than the others. Discriminating among these isomeric forms using mass spectrometry alone can be daunting, which is why orthogonal techniques, such as ion mobility spectrometry, have been explored. Here, we demonstrate the use of differential mobility spectrometry (DMS) to separate isomeric glycans differing only in the linkages of sialic acid groups (e.g., α 2,3 versus α 2,6). This ability extends from a small trisaccharide species to larger biantennary systems and is driven, in part, by the role of intramolecular solvation of the charge site(s) on these ions within the DMS environment.

Isomer Information from Ion Mobility Separation of High-Mannose Glycan Fragments

Extracted arrival time distributions of negative ion CID-derived fragments produced prior to traveling-wave ion mobility separation were evaluated for their ability to provide structural information on N-linked glycans. Fragmentation of high-mannose glycans released from several glycoproteins, including those from viral sources, provided over 50 fragments, many of which gave unique collisional cross-sections and provided additional information used to assign structural isomers. For example, cross-ring fragments arising from cleavage of the reducing terminal GlcNAc residue on Man₈GlcNAc₂ isomers have unique collision cross-sections enabling isomers to be differentiated in mixtures. Specific fragment collision cross-sections enabled identification of glycans, the antennae of which terminated in the antigenic α-galactose residue, and ions defining the composition of the 6-antenna of several of the glycans were also found to have different cross-sections from isomeric ions produced in the same spectra. Potential mechanisms for the formation of the various ions are discussed and the estimated collisional cross-sections are tabulated. Graphical Abstract ᅟ.

Linear and Differential Ion Mobility Separations of Middle-Down Proteoforms

Comprehensive characterization of proteomes comprising the same proteins with distinct post-translational modifications (PTMs) is a staggering challenge. Many such proteoforms are isomers (localization variants) that require separation followed by top-down or middle-down mass spectrometric analyses, but condensed-phase separations are ineffective in those size ranges. The variants for "middle-down" peptides were resolved by differential ion mobility spectrometry (FAIMS), relying on the mobility increment at high electric fields, but not previously by linear IMS on the basis of absolute mobility. We now use complete histone tails with diverse PTMs on alternative sites to demonstrate that high-resolution linear IMS, here trapped IMS (TIMS), broadly resolves the variants of ∼50 residues in full or into binary mixtures quantifiable by tandem MS, largely thanks to orthogonal separations across charge states. Separations using traveling-wave (TWIMS) and/or involving various time scales and electrospray ionization source conditions are similar (with lower resolution for TWIMS), showing the transferability of results across linear IMS instruments. The linear IMS and FAIMS dimensions are substantially orthogonal, suggesting FAIMS/IMS/MS as a powerful platform for proteoform analyses.

Contemporary glycomic approaches using ion mobility-mass spectrometry

Characterization of complex oligosaccharides has historically required extensive sample handling and separations before analysis using nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy and electron impact mass spectra following hydrolysis, derivatization, and gas chromatographic separation. Advances in liquid chromatography separations and tandem mass spectrometry have expanded the range of intact glycan analysis, but carbohydrate structure and conformation-integral chemical characteristics-are often difficult to assess with minimal amounts of sample in a rapid fashion. Because ion mobility spectrometry (IMS) separates analytes based upon an effective 'size-to-charge' ratio, IMS is, by extension, highly applicable to glycomics. Furthermore, the speed of IMS, its growing levels of separation efficiency, and direct compatibility with all forms of mass spectrometry, illustrates is core role in the future of glycomics efforts. This review assesses the current state of ion mobility-mass spectrometry applied to glycan, glycoprotein, and glycoconjugate analysis. Currently, assessing optimal ion polarity and adduct type for a glycan class along with the appropriate tandem mass spectrometry technique underpin many of the current glycan analysis efforts using ion mobility-mass spectrometry (IMMS). Once determined, these parameters have enabled a growing and impressive range of glycomics campaigns employing this technique. Additionally, the combination of IMS with tandem mass spectrometry, and even spectroscopic methods, further expands the dimensionality of hybrid instrumentation to provide a more comprehensive assessment of glycan structure across a wide dynamic range. Continued computational efforts to complement experimental and instrumental advancements also serve as a core component of IMMS workflows applied to glycomics and promise to maximize the information gained from mobility separations.

Recent advances in ion mobility-mass spectrometry for improved structural characterization of glycans and glycoconjugates

Glycans and glycoconjugates are involved in regulating a vast array of cellular and molecular processes. Despite the importance of glycans in biology and disease, characterization of glycans remains difficult due to their structural complexity and diversity. Mass spectrometry (MS)-based techniques have emerged as the premier analytical tools for characterizing glycans. However, traditional MS-based strategies struggle to distinguish the large number of coexisting isomeric glycans that are indistinguishable by mass alone. Because of this, ion mobility spectrometry coupled to MS (IM-MS) has received considerable attention as an analytical tool for improving glycan characterization due to the capability of IM to resolve isomeric glycans before MS measurements. In this review, we present recent improvements in IM-MS instrumentation and methods for the structural characterization of isomeric glycans. In addition, we highlight recent applications of IM-MS that illustrate the enormous potential of this technology in a variety of research areas, including glycomics, glycoproteomics, and glycobiology.

Structural Characterization of Intact Glycoconjugates by Tandem Mass Spectrometry Using Electron-Induced Dissociation

Characterizing the structures of glycoconjungates is important because of glycan heterogeneity and structural complexity of aglycon. The presence of relatively weak glycosidic linkages leads to preferential cleavages that limit the acquisition of structural information under typical mass spectrometry dissociation conditions, such as collision-induced dissociation (CID) and infrared multiphoton dissociation. In this paper, we explored the dissociation behaviors of different members of glycoconjugates, including glycopeptides, glycoalkaloids, and glycolipids, under electron-induced dissociation (EID) conditions. Using CID spectra as references, we found that EID is not only a complementary method to CID, but also a method that can generate extensive fragment ions for the structural characterization of all intact glycoconjugates studied. Furthermore, isomeric ganglioside species can be differentiated, and the double bond location in the ceramide moiety of the gangliosides can be identified through the MS³ approach involving sequential CID and EID processes.

Glycosaminoglycan Analysis by Cryogenic Messenger-Tagging IR Spectroscopy Combined with IMS-MS

We combine ion mobility spectrometry with cryogenic, messenger-tagging, infrared spectroscopy and mass spectrometry to identify different isomeric disaccharides of chondroitin sulfate (CS) and heparan sulfate (HS), which are representatives of two major subclasses of glycosaminoglycans. Our analysis shows that while CS and HS disaccharide isomers have similar drift times, they can be uniquely distinguished by their vibrational spectrum between ∼3200 and 3700 cm-1 due to their different OH hydrogen-bonding patterns. We suggest that this combination of techniques is well suited to identify and characterize glycan isomers directly, which presents tremendous challenges for existing methods.