Expression of cellular retinoic acid binding protein II (chick-CRABP II) in the chick embryo

Loss of FGF-dependent mesoderm identity and rise of endogenous retinoid signalling determine cessation of body axis elongation

By analyzing cellular and molecular changes in key cell populations in the tailbud during embryogenesis, this work uncovers critical signaling events that determine vertebrate body length.

The endogenous mechanism that determines vertebrate body length is unknown but must involve loss of chordo-neural-hinge (CNH)/axial stem cells and mesoderm progenitors in the tailbud. In early embryos, Fibroblast growth factor (FGF) maintains a cell pool that progressively generates the body and differentiation onset is driven by retinoid repression of FGF signalling. This raises the possibility that FGF maintains key tailbud cell populations and that rising retinoid activity underlies cessation of body axis elongation. Here we show that sudden loss of the mesodermal gene (Brachyury) from CNH and the mesoderm progenitor domain correlates with FGF signalling decline in the late chick tailbud. This is accompanied by expansion of neural gene expression and a similar change in cell fate markers is apparent in the human tailbud. Fate mapping of chick tailbud further revealed that spread of neural gene expression results from continued ingression of CNH-derived cells into the position of the mesoderm progenitor domain. Using gain and loss of function approaches in vitro and in vivo, we then show that attenuation of FGF/Erk signalling mediates this loss of Brachyury upstream of Wnt signalling, while high-level FGF maintains Brachyury and can induce ectopic CNH-like cell foci. We further demonstrate a rise in endogenous retinoid signalling in the tailbud and show that here FGF no longer opposes retinoid synthesis and activity. Furthermore, reduction of retinoid signalling at late stages elevated FGF activity and ectopically maintained mesodermal gene expression, implicating endogenous retinoid signalling in loss of mesoderm identity. Finally, axis termination is concluded by local cell death, which is reduced by blocking retinoid signalling, but involves an FGFR-independent mechanism. We propose that cessation of body elongation involves loss of FGF-dependent mesoderm identity in late stage tailbud and provide evidence that rising endogenous retinoid activity mediates this step and ultimately promotes cell death in chick tailbud.

The mechanism that determines body length is unknown but likely operates at the elongating tail end of vertebrate embryos. In the early embryo, fibroblast growth factor (FGF) signalling maintains a proliferative pool of cells in the tailbud that progressively generates the body. It also protects these cells from the differentiating influence of retinoic acid, which is produced by the maturing mesoderm tissues of the extending body. We show here, in the chick embryo, that the “endgame”—that is, the termination of body axis elongation—comes when the mesodermal gene brachyury is suddenly lost from axial stem cell population and presumptive mesoderm cells in the tailbud late in development. Using gain- and loss-of-function approaches, we demonstrate that this step is mediated by loss of FGF signalling. We present evidence that this is due to rising retinoid signalling in the tailbud and that FGF signalling in the tailbud no longer opposes retinoid synthesis and activity. Finally, we reveal that these events are followed by local cell death in the tailbud, which can be reduced by the attenuation of retinoid signalling but involves a mechanism that is independent of FGF signalling via its usual receptor. We propose that cessation of body elongation involves loss of FGF-dependent mesoderm identity in the late tailbud and that this is mediated by rising endogenous retinoid activity, which ultimately promotes cell death in the chick tailbud.

Sources and sink of retinoic acid in the embryonic chick retina: distribution of aldehyde dehydrogenase activities, CRABP-I, and sites of retinoic acid inactivation

Previous experiments in mice and zebrafish led to the hypothesis that an asymmetric distribution of the transcriptional activator retinoic acid (RA) causes ventral-dorsal polarity in the vertebrate eye anlage. A high concentration of RA in the ventral retinal neuroepithelium has been suggested to induce developmental events that finally establish topographic order in the retinotectal projection along the vertical eye axis. In the present study we have investigated potential sources and sinks of RA during embryonic development of the chick retina. At embryonic day (E)1 to E2, when the spatial determination of the eye primordia takes place, no RA synthesis by aldehyde dehydrogenases was detectable, and neither immunoreactivity for retinaldehyde dehydrogenase RALDH-2 nor for cellular retinoic acid binding protein CRABP-I was observed. These components of RA signal transduction appeared in the eye between E3 and E5. At later stages, RA-measurements with a reporter cell line showed highest synthesis in the retinal pigment epithelium (RPE) and at the ventral and dorsal poles of the retina. RA degradation occurred mostly in a horizontal region in the middle of the retina with only small differences along the nasal-temporal axis. CRABP-I immunoreactivity appeared first in differentiating retinal ganglion cells with no indication of a spatial gradient across the ventral-dorsal eye axis. RA-production depended on three NAD+-dependent enzyme activities, which could be competitively inhibited by citral. One enzyme, located in the dorsal retina (corresponding to mouse RALDH-1), and one enzyme in the RPE (RALDH-2) were aldehyde dehydrogenases of the same molecular weight (monomers about 55 kDa) but with different isoelectric points (6.5-6.9; 4.9-5.4). The third RA-synthesizing activity (pI 6.0-6.3) was limited to the ventral retina, and likely corresponded to mouse RALDH-3. The restricted localization of retinoid-metabolizing activities along the dorsal-ventral axis of the embryonic chick retina does support the idea that RA is involved in dorsal-ventral eye patterning. However, the late time of appearance of aldehyde dehydrogenase activities and CRABP-I points to functions in cellular differentiation that are distinct from the initiation of the dorsal-ventral polarity.

Stage- and region-dependent responses of chick wing-bud mesenchymal cells to retinoic acid in serum-free microcultures

Retinoic acid (RA) has been shown to affect skeletal patterning in vivo in both developing and regenerating limbs. Regional differences in RA concentrations alone cannot account for the region-specific cell behaviors involved in limb-skeletal morphogenesis. The present study explores a role for regional differences in signal interpretation in RA's effects along the anteroposterior and proximodistal axes of stage 21-22 and 23-24 chick wing-buds. Mesenchymal cells isolated from specific limb regions were grown in chemically defined medium and exposed to 5 or 50 ng/ml of RA for 4 days in high-density microtiter cultures. Previous studies showed that RA's effects on chondrogenesis and growth in such cultures differed depending on the position along the limb's proximodistal axis from which the cells were isolated. The present study is the first to show that such differences in RA-responsiveness also exist along the limb's anteroposterior axis, especially in the distal subridge mesenchyme. The region-dependent relationships between RA's effects on growth and chondrogenesis suggest that RA affects these two behaviors through different mechanisms. The regional differences in the responsiveness of these cells to exogenous RA are discussed with respect to their correspondence to the in vivo patterns of expression of RA-binding proteins, RA-receptors, and other patterning-related genes.

Distribution of cellular retinoic acid-binding proteins I and II in the chick embryo and their relationship to teratogenesis

The distribution of cellular retinoic acid-binding proteins I and II (CRABP I and II) during the first 6 days of chick development has been investigated using immunoblotting. Since retinoic acid (RA) is teratogenic to some parts of the embryo, stimulatory to other parts, and has no effect on others it may be that the distribution of cytoplasmic proteins such as CRABP I and II plays some role in this differential activity. Neither protein is expressed in the day 2 embryo, but from day 3 onwards both proteins are expressed and CRABP I is in considerable excess over CRABP II. Within the day 4 embryo there is some significant variation in the distribution according to tissue type. Neural tissues, neural crest derivatives, and limb buds most strongly express CRABP I whilst other tissues contain only moderate levels, and heart and epidermis do not express CRABP I at all. CRABP II has a widespread distribution, although at a lower level than CRABP I, with the exception of somites and ectoderm which do not express it at all. In the limb buds, there is a significant variation in CRABP I levels across the anteroposterior axis which suggests that these two CRABPs may have different functions during development. The relationship of these distributions in the embryo to the role of endogenous RA and the teratogenic effects of RA is discussed.

Overexpression of a cellular retinoic acid binding protein (xCRABP) causes anteroposterior defects in developing Xenopus embryos

We have isolated the first Xenopus laevis cDNA coding for a cellular retinoic acid binding protein (xCRABP). xCRABP contains a single open reading frame, coding for an approximately 15 × 10(3) M(r) protein. Northern blot analysis shows that this cDNA hybridizes to a mRNA that is expressed both maternally and zygotically and which already reaches maximal expression during gastrulation (much earlier than previously described CRABP genes from other species). In situ hybridisation showed that at the onset of gastrulation, xCRABP mRNA is localised at the dorsal side of the embryo, in the ectoderm and in invaginating mesoderm. xCRABP expression then rapidly resolves into two domains; a neural domain, which becomes localised in the anterior hindbrain, and a posterior domain in neuroectoderm and mesoderm. These two domains were already evident by the mid-gastrula stage. We investigated the function of xCRABP by injecting fertilized eggs with an excess of sense xCRABP mRNA and examined the effects on development. We observed embryos with clear antero-posterior defects, many of which resembled the effects of treating Xenopus gastrulae with all-trans retinoic acid. Notably, the heart was deleted, anterior brain structures and the tail were reduced, and segmentation of the hindbrain was inhibited. The effects of injecting xCRABP transcripts are compatible with the idea that xCRABP overexpression modulates the action of an endogenous retinoid, thereby regulating the expression of retinoid target genes, such as Hox genes. In support of this, we showed that the expression of two Xenopus Hoxb genes, Hoxb-9 and Hoxb-4, is strongly enhanced by xCRABP over-expression. These results suggest that xCRABP expression may help to specify the anteroposterior axis during the early development of Xenopus laevis.

Changes of the expression and distribution of retinoic acid receptors during neurogenesis in mouse embryos

The expression and distribution of three retinoic acid receptors, alpha, beta, and gamma, were investigated in the CNS of mouse embryos during development. mRNAs and protein of RAR-beta that were expressed in the spinal cord of the 12.5-day mouse embryo decreased during development but they were not decreased in the brain. The RAR-beta-positive cells were already present in the ventral region of the spinal cord of 10.5-day mouse embryos, gradually appeared in the dorsal region during development and then disappeared from the spinal cord after birth. In the brain, RAR-beta-positive cells were detected in the mesencephalon and rhombencephalon but not in the telencephalon of the 12.5-day mouse embryos. RAR-beta-positive cells were present in the hippocampus and cingulum but not in the neocortex of 14.5-day mouse embryos. Most neurons in the hippocampus of 16.5-day mouse embryos and the cortex of newborn mice were RAR-beta-positive. In the spinal cord, RAR-alpha mRNAs and proteins also decreased during development but more gradually than RAR-beta mRNAs and proteins. During development, the distributions of RAR-alpha and -beta in the spinal cord and brain did not differ substantially. The main difference was the appearance of a subtypes of RAR-alpha, a 52-kDa protein, in the brain of newborn mice. On the other hand, RAR-gamma proteins were only faintly detected in the spinal cord and the brain of the mice during the embryonal stages but these increased after birth. The distribution of RAR-alpha- or -beta-positive cells were consistent with the neurogenesis during development in the spinal cord and brain.

Retinoids and state of differentiation modulate CRABP II gene expression in a skin equivalent

Cellular retinoic acid-binding proteins (CRABPs) are a family of proteins that specifically bind retinoic acid (RA) and have been implicated in mediating its action, although their exact function is still unknown. Two CRABPs have been identified and cloned. CRABP I is present in many tissues and cultured cells; CRABP II, first detected in embryonic and neonatal skin of rats and chicks, is now recognized as the predominant form in human epidermis. Using a human living skin equivalent model composed of a dermis and an epidermis and human cDNAs recently cloned in our laboratory, we have studied the effects of 10(-6) M RA and etretin (ET) on the expression of CRABPs under different culture conditions intended to favor greater or lesser degrees of epidermal differentiation. Total cellular RNA was isolated separately from the dermis and epidermis and processed for northern blot analysis. At a presumptive physiologic RA concentration, only the gene for CRABP II, and not for CRABP I, was expressed. CRABP II transcripts were far more abundant on a per cell basis in epidermal keratinocytes than in dermal fibroblasts under all conditions studied. Epidermal differentiation, stimulated by air exposure of the cultures, tended to enhance CRABP II expression, and treatment with presumptive therapeutic concentrations of the two retinoid compounds tended to decrease CRABP II expression. Opposite effects of air exposure and retinoid treatment were observed on steady state levels of mRNA for selected markers of epidermal differentiation: involucrin, transglutaminase, and spr I. These results are consistent with earlier work at the protein level examining the effect of retinoids on CRABP activity and state of differentiation both in vivo and in vitro. Thus, the skin equivalent appears to be an excellent model system for investigating the role of CRABPs in mediating retinoid effects at the cellular and molecular levels.

Retinoic acid ambivalently regulates the expression of MyoD1 in the myogenic cells in the limb buds of the early developmental stages

The expression of MyoD1 in myogenic cells located in the muscle prospective region of the limb bud at stage 20-22 was highly sensitive to retinoic acid. Unlike RAR-beta, the expression of MyoD1 mRNA in the muscle precursor cells was significantly increased by retinoic acid at lower concentrations (0.1-10 nM), but inhibited by it at higher concentrations (0.1-1 microM). The ambivalent modulation of MyoD1 expression suggested that MyoD1 expression is regulated by not only the retinoic acid receptor and its response element, but also by other factors. Retinoic acid may be involved in the differentiation of the myogenic cells during early development.

Cellular retinoic acid binding protein type II was preferentially localized in medium and posterior parts of the progress zone of the chick limb bud

The expression and distribution of cellular retinoic acid binding protein II (CRABP II) was examined in chick limb buds. CRABP II was detected in the limb buds at Hamburger and Hamilton (1) stage 21 and the amount of CRABP II was gradually increased during stages 21-27 and thereafter decreased. CRABP II was mainly located in the progress zone, and the dorsal and ventral premuscular mass in the proximal region of the limb buds at stage 23. CRABP II was preferentially localized in the medium and posterior parts rather than the anterior part of the progress zone; The content of CRABP II in the medium and posterior parts was 8-9 times more than that in the anterior part.

Control of Epidermal Differentiation by a Retinoid Analogue Unable to Bind to Cytosolic Retinoic Acid-Binding Proteins (CRABP)

The role played by cytosolic retinoic acid-binding proteins (CRABP) in the control of differentiation and morphogenesis by retinoids remains unclear, which contrasts with the presence of these binding proteins in tissues known to be targets for retinoic acid effects. Human epidermis represents a good system to address this question because 1) the effect of retinoids on keratinocyte differentiation is well documented; 2) epidermis contains CRABP, and the amount of these proteins is modulated both by keratinization and retinoids; 3) the architecture of epidermis obtained in vitro by growing adult human keratinocytes on a dermal substrate can be modulated by retinoids added to the culture medium in a dose-dependent manner; and 4) most markers of epidermal differentiation are also modulated by retinoids in a dose-dependent manner. In this study, we compared, in dose-response experiments, the biologic activities of retinoic acid and CD271, a substance unable to bind to CRABP, but able to bind to nuclear retinoic acid receptors (RAR). Our results show that retinoic acid and CD271 exert similar controls on epidermal morphogenesis and keratinocyte differentiation, as shown by the inhibition of the synthesis of suprabasal keratins, filaggrin, and transglutaminase. Therefore, we exclude a qualitative role for CRABP in the control exerted by retinoids on the differentiation and morphogenesis of cultured human keratinocytes. Instead of being involved in the pathway via which retinoids control epidermal gene expression, CRABP might regulate the amount of intracellular-active retinoic acid and thus control quantitatively the intensity of biologic effects.

The molecular cloning and expression of two CRABP cDNAs from human skin

Retinoic acid (RA) is known to have a profound effect on the growth and differentiation of human epidermal cells in vivo and in vitro. One of the proteins thought to be involved in mediating the action of RA is the cellular retinoic acid-binding protein (CRABP). We have used PCR technology to generate cDNAs for two distinct CRABPs from human skin and skin-derived cells. One is highly homologous to the CRABP I cDNAs previously cloned from bovine and murine sources. The second shares extensive deduced amino acid homology with CRABP II, a protein recently described in newborn rat and embryonic chick. Although both mRNAs can be detected in neonatal foreskin, CRABP II mRNA is the predominant one in this tissue, as well as in cultured newborn fibroblasts and keratinocytes. Northern blot analysis showed CRABP II mRNA level was only slightly reduced by addition of 10(-6) or 10(-5) M RA to cultures of neonatal foreskin-derived fibroblasts, as was the CRABP I mRNA level in cultured human gut epithelial cells. In contrast, expression of CRABP II mRNA by cultured neonatal keratinocytes was strongly downregulated by RA. We conclude that CRABP II is the predominant CRABP in human skin, at least in the newborn period, and that it is differentially regulated in fibroblasts versus keratinocytes. Our data are consistent with a role for CRABP in regulating the amount of RA delivered to the nucleus.

Temporal distribution of retinoic acid and cellular retinoic acid-binding protein (CRABP) in the fetal hamster

The temporal relationship between the distribution of retinoic acid, a known human and rodent teratogen, and that of cellular retinoic acid-binding protein (CRABP) was investigated from Day 11 to Day 14 of hamster prenatal development. The 11,12-(3)H2 and 15(-14C) forms of all-trans-retinoic acid were used for quantitative distribution studies and autoradiography, respectively, and were evaluated 15 min after a single intravenous injection. Radioactivity was detected in all fetal tissues examined (brain, liver, heart, spinal cord, limb, and skin), and at Day 14, approximately 66% of the total radioactivity was present as parent all-trans-retinoic acid. High concentrations of total radioactivity were observed by autoradiography in the midbrain and hindbrain (mesencephalon, metencephalon, and myelencephalon) and spinal cord, but not in the forebrain. At the earliest time studied, limb buds showed relatively high concentrations of radioactivity. Levels of radioactivity were also high in portions of the developing face, nose, and tongue. Immunohistochemical analyses indicated that the amount of CRABP in Day 14 tissues was the highest in spinal cord followed by limb and skin; heart and liver contained only relatively small amounts of this protein. From Day 11 to Day 14, the amount of CRABP, as measured by high-performance size-exclusion liquid chromatography, in the whole body decreased as gestation progressed. Microscopic immunohistochemical localization of CRABP found the highest concentration in the ventral midbrain and in the ventral and lateral sides of the hindbrain and spinal cord; CRABP was also abundant in tongue, limb, and skin. The distribution of CRABP-positive cells in the central nervous system was similar to the distribution of retinoic acid. The data presented here indicate that fetal CRABP appears to play a role in differential accumulation of retinoic acid in certain structures of the developing hamster. The patterns of tissue retinoid and CRABP distribution observed here are consistent with the patterns of congenital malformations induced by prenatal retinoid exposure.

Transport and storage of vitamin A

The requirement of vitamin A (retinoids) for vision has been recognized for decades. In addition, vitamin A is involved in fetal development and in the regulation of proliferation and differentiation of cells throughout life. This fat-soluble organic compound cannot be synthesized endogenously by humans and thus is an essential nutrient; a well-regulated transport and storage system provides tissues with the correct amounts of retinoids in spite of normal fluctuations in daily vitamin A intake. An overview is presented here of current knowledge and hypotheses about the absorption, transport, storage, and metabolism of vitamin A. Some information is also presented about a group of ligand-dependent transcription factors, the retinoic acid receptors, that apparently mediate many of the extravisual effects of retinoids.

Retinoic acid receptor in the chick limb buds in the early developmental stages

Two retinoic acid-binding proteins, a high molecular weight one (90-100 kDa) (peak A) and CRABP (peak B), were obtained on gel filtration column chromatography of extracts of limb buds of chick embryos. The presence of a retinoic acid receptor (RAR) (45 kDa) and the absence of chick-CRABP type II (16.2 kDa) in the peak A fractions suggested that the 45 kDa RAR forms a homo- or hetero-dimeric structure (90-100 kDa) with other RARs or other nuclear proteins, but not with chick-CRABP type II, in the limb buds of chick embryos. We also demonstrated that there were no significant differences in the amount of RAR in the anterior, middle and posterior parts of limb buds (stages 23-25).