Search for biological/genetic markers in a long-term epidemiological and morbid risk study of affective disorders

Risk for Mood, Anxiety, and Psychotic Disorders in Individuals at High and Low Genetic Liability for Bipolar Disorder and Major Depression

Importance

The nature of the genetic relationship between major depression and bipolar disorder remains unclear and might be clarified by considering disorders outside of the mood spectrum.

Objective

To better understand the relationship between genetic liabilities for major depression (MD) and bipolar disorder (BD).

Design, Setting, and Participants

A cohort study was conducted with data for individuals born in Sweden to Swedish parents from 1960 to 1990, with follow-up through December 31, 2018. The data included family genetic risk scores for MD and BD and International Classification of Diseases codes for a range of disorders as reported in primary care, specialist, and hospital registries. Data analysis was conducted from April 2022 to July 2022.

Exposures

High and low genetic liability were defined as being in the upper and lower 2 risk deciles. Risk was compared in individuals at high genetic liability to (1) MD only, (2) BD only, and (3) both MD and BD and those at (4) high genetic liability to BD and low genetic liability to MD and (5) high genetic liability to MD and low genetic liability to BD.

Main Outcomes and Measures

Risk for nonpsychotic MD and BD, psychotic MD and BD, anxiety disorders, obsessive-compulsive disorder, schizoaffective disorder (SAD), schizophrenia, and other nonaffective psychosis.

Results

Data were included for 2 736 950 individuals with a mean (SD) age at follow-up of 43.9 (9.1) years. High genetic liability to only BD increased risk for nonpsychotic BD, psychotic BD, and SAD. High genetic liability to only MD augmented risk for nonpsychotic MD, anxiety disorders, and nonpsychotic BD. High genetic liability to both BD and MD had the strongest association with risk for nonpsychotic BD, anxiety disorders, and nonpsychotic MD. High genetic liability to BD and low genetic liability to MD increased risk for psychotic BD, nonpsychotic BD, and SAD with no increased risk for nonpsychotic MD or anxiety disorders. High genetic liability to MD and low genetic liability to BD increased risk for nonpsychotic MD, nonpsychotic BD, and anxiety disorders with no increased risk for psychotic BD.

Conclusions and Relevance

In this study, hypotheses that BD and MD are either genetically distinct or genetically closely interrelated were not supported. Both BD and MD were associated with a genetic vulnerability to mood disorders, but even that liability was partially selective. However, compared with individuals at high liability to MD, those at elevated genetic liability for BD had a substantially increased risk for psychosis. Compared with individuals at elevated genetic liability to BD, those at high genetic risk for MD had a considerably augmented risk for anxiety disorders. Clarifying genetic relationships between psychiatric syndromes can be substantially aided by the consideration of profiles of risk for a range of disorders.

Evaluation of major depression in a routine clinical assessment

BACKGROUND

Major depression is a disorder that significantly worsens a patient's morbidity and mortality. The association of depression and diabetes is well documented and has clinical impact in diabetes treatment's outcome. Patients usually aren't evaluated initially by a psychiatrist, so it is important that non-psychiatrists learn to evaluate major depression and its impact.

CONCLUSIONS

Major depression can and should be evaluated on a routine clinical assessment. Depression's impact on the patients' quality of life, productivity and social interactions is well documented. The initial diagnosis of depression should lead to its prompt treatment, and it has to be emphasized that the incorrect treatment can lead to worsening of the condition, relapses, recurrences or even chronification of major depression.

Difference in binocular rivalry rate between patients with bipolar I and bipolar II disorders

OBJECTIVE

When dissimilar figures are presented to each eye individually, perception alternates spontaneously between each monocular view. This phenomenon, known as binocular rivalry, has been used as a powerful tool to investigate conscious visual awareness. Of clinical relevance, Pettigrew and Miller (Proc Biol Sci 1998; 265: 2141-2148) found slow perceptual alternation rates in patients with bipolar I disorder (BD-I). For a better understanding of differences between BD-I and bipolar II disorder (BD-II), we examined whether perceptual alternation rates of binocular rivalry differ between the two subtypes of bipolar disorder.

METHODS

The subjects comprised 25 healthy controls, 11 patients with BD-I, and 17 patients with BD-II. They underwent binocular rivalry examination. One-way analysis of variance was conducted to determine differences in the phase duration of binocular rivalry between the control, BD-I, and BD-II groups.

RESULTS

Significant differences were observed in the mean phase duration of binocular rivalry between the groups. Although the medication administered did not differ significantly between the BD-I and BD-II patients, the phase duration was significantly longer among the BD-I patients than the BD-II patients and controls, whereas no significant difference was observed in the phase duration between the BD-II patients and controls.

CONCLUSION

The present results reveal a significant difference in the mean phase duration of binocular rivalry between subjects with BD-I and those with BD-II, suggesting the presence of some neurobiological difference between these two subtypes of bipolar disorder.

Bipolar II disorder: arguments for and against a distinct diagnostic entity

OBJECTIVE

As a commitment to the International Society for Bipolar Disorders (ISBD), a Task Force was developed to investigate the diagnostic value of bipolar II disorder.

METHODS

Task Force members worked jointly reviewing all relevant literature (original articles, reviews, letters, book chapters and congress presentations) that included 'bipolar II disorder' and/or 'hypomania' as key words.

RESULTS

Bipolar II disorder appears to be a reasonably valid and reliable diagnostic category yet often underdiagnosed or misdiagnosed as unipolar disorder or personality disorder. Moreover, it is officially recognized as a mental disorder in DSM-IV-TR but not in ICD-10, and many clinicians still regard it as a milder form of manic-depressive illness, despite data supporting high morbidity and mortality rates. In fact, bipolar II may be the most prevalent bipolar phenotype, although current diagnostic boundaries are seen as quite restrictive concerning the required duration for hypomania (4 days), the exclusion of hypomanic episodes potentially triggered by antidepressants and other substances, and the negligence of hypomanic mixed states. The course of bipolar II disorder is characterized by depressive predominant polarity, and its treatment is still controversial and poorly evidence-based.

CONCLUSIONS

Bipolar II disorder is supported as a distinct category within mood disorders, but the definition and boundaries deserve a greater clarification in the DSM-V and ICD-11.

A review of the evidence from family, twin and adoption studies for a genetic contribution to adult psychiatric disorders

Family, twin and adoption studies have provided major evidence for the role of genetics in numerous psychiatric disorders including obsessive-compulsive disorder, panic disorder, major depressive disorder, bipolar disorder, schizophrenia and Alzheimer's disease. As the search for patterns of inheritance and candidate genes of these complex disorders continues, we review relevant findings from quantitative genetic studies and outline the main challenges for the field of psychiatric genetics to focus on in order to more definitively establish the underpinnings of genetic and environmental influences of adult psychopathology.

Affective disorders in the first-degree relatives of bipolar probands: results from the South Island Bipolar Study

The current study was performed to document observed rates of affective disorders in the first degree relatives of probands with bipolar I or II disorder; to determine whether bipolar II probands have an excess of bipolar II relatives; and to determine whether bipolar probands with a history of one or more suicide attempts have more relatives who have also made suicide attempts. Bipolar probands with positive family histories of affective disorder were recruited from a variety of sources for a study on the molecular genetics of bipolar disorder. Probands and relatives were interviewed with the Diagnostic Interview for Genetic Studies (DIGS) and blood was obtained for DNA extraction and genetic analyses. Among 423 first-degree adult relatives of 153 bipolar probands, 7% (29) had bipolar I disorder, 7% had bipolar II disorder, and 7% had bipolar not otherwise specified (NOS) disorder, making 21% of relatives with any bipolar disorder. A further 42% of relatives had a depressive disorder and only 38% had no affective disorder. A suicide attempt by a proband was not associated with any increase in suicide attempts by relatives. We conclude that while unipolar depressive disorders are the most common affective disorders in the first-degree relatives of bipolar probands, extension of the bipolar phenotype to include bipolar spectrum disorders results in 21% of relatives having any bipolar disorder.

Arguments for the genetic basis of the bipolar spectrum

Family members of bipolar probands have been repeatedly shown to have an increased risk for mood disorders. However, a range of different syndromes in the bipolar spectrum are commonly observed in these relatives. This suggests the hypothesis that these different syndromes may be genetically related. It further suggests that bipolar disorder may be better conceptualized from a genetic standpoint as a quantitative trait. In such a model, the same genes may predispose to a variety of phenotypes ranging from schizoaffective disorder to cyclothymic temperament. Previous attempts to test such a multifactorial model have provided some limited support. However, other studies argue that some forms of bipolar disorder such as bipolar II may be genetically distinct. In this review, various quantitative and categorical models of illness are considered and the data supporting them reviewed. It is proposed that the existing data may best fit a model in which different sets of genes predispose to overlapping phenotypes that are in part both quantitative and distinct in nature.

MRI-based measurements of temporal lobe and ventricular structures in patients with bipolar I and bipolar II disorders

OBJECTIVE

There have been relatively few quantitative MRI studies of temporal lobe structures and the lateral ventricles in bipolar patients and a lack of agreement across studies as to whether these structures differ significantly in size from control subjects. Also there have been no quantitative MRI studies of bipolar II patients. The present study measured temporal lobe and ventricular structures in both bipolar I and bipolar II patients, as well as control subjects.

METHOD

Twenty-five bipolar I patients, 22 bipolar II patients and 19 control subjects underwent MRI brain scans. The 5 mm coronal slices of each subject were coded and measured by a rater who was blind with respect to subject diagnosis. Volume estimates of the temporal lobe and hippocampus were calculated for each hemisphere by measuring the area of the structure in each slice in which it appears, multiplying by 5 mm and summing. In addition to these volume estimates, the area of the lateral ventricle and the inferior horn of the lateral ventricle, the lateral ventricle to cerebrum area ratio (LV/C) and the temporal lobe to cerebrum area ratio (TL/C), were calculated for each hemisphere in one reference slice only. The area of the third ventricle was also measured. Volume estimates and area ratios were then compared among diagnostic groups.

RESULTS

There were no significant differences in temporal lobe or hippocampal volume estimates, in the third ventricle and inferior horn of the lateral ventricle area measurements, and in the TL/C area ratio among diagnostic groups. The lateral ventricle area and LV/C area ratio were significantly larger in bipolar I patients than either bipolar II patients or control subjects only in the left hemisphere. Furthermore, these measures were approximately twice as large in the bipolar I patients as the other groups.

CONCLUSIONS

The current study adds to a growing literature that bipolar I disorder, particularly in males, may show different neurobiological alterations compared to bipolar II patients or control subjects. The pathophysiologic implications of this accumulating evidence of increased left ventricular size in bipolar I disorder remains to be further elucidated.

Searching high and low: a review of the genetics of bipolar disorder

OBJECTIVES

To review the methodologies and findings in the genetics of bipolar disorder (BPD), and to suggest future directions for research.

METHODS

Reports of family, twin, adoption, linkage, association, cytogenetic, and animal model studies, and segregation analyses in English, were identified from multiple MEDLINE searches. Hand searches were carried out in bibliographies from review articles.

RESULTS

Family, twin, and adoption studies have provided strong evidence for a genetic etiology in BPD. Early reports of linkage of BPD to DNA markers at several chromosomal sites have not proven robust, perhaps because of the complex nature of BPD inheritance. However, linkage findings in the 1990s, on chromosomes 18, 21q, 12q, and 4p, have provided leads that are being pursued through both genetic and physical mapping. No gene has yet been definitively implicated in BPD.

CONCLUSIONS

Strategies for increasing the power to detect BPD genes include: (1) dividing the phenotype into genetically meaningful subtypes to decrease heterogeneity: and (2) ascertaining a very large family sample--a multicenter study now in progress will collect 700 bipolar I sibling pairs. BPD may result from several genes acting in concert so that new multilocus statistical methods could enhance the capacity to detect loci involved. Family-based association studies using a very large number of newly identified single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) may allow for more efficient screening of the genome. As the Human Genome Project approaches its goal of isolating all genes by 2003, the data generated is likely to speed identification of candidate BPD genes.

Transtorno bipolar

Os resultados de estudos de famílias sugerem que o transtorno bipolar tenha uma base genética. Essa hipótese foi reforçada em estudos de adoção e de gêmeos. A herança do transtorno bipolar é complexa, envolve vários genes, além de apresentar heterogeneidade e interação entre fatores genéticos e não-genéticos. Achados, que já foram replicados, já implicaram os cromossomos 4, 12, 18 e 21, entre outros, na busca por genes de suscetibilidade. Os resultados mais promissores foram obtidos através de estudos de ligação. Por outro lado, os estudos de associação geraram dados interessantes, mas ainda vagos. Os estudos de populações de pacientes homogêneos e a melhor definição do fenótipo deverão contribuir para avanços futuros. A identificação dos genes relacionados ao transtorno bipolar irá permitir o melhor entendimento e tratamento dessa doença.

Platelet 5-HT and plasma MHPG levels in patients with bipolar I and bipolar II depressions and normal controls

BACKGROUND

It has been suggested that platelet serotonin (5-HT) content may reflect aspects of the presynaptic reuptake of 5-HT, while plasma 3-methoxy-4-hydroxy-phenylglycol (MHPG) levels may provide an index of central noradrenergic function.

METHODS

In order to determine if there is a biological distinction in 5-HT or noradrenergic function within bipolar I and bipolar II depressions, we measured levels of platelet 5-HT and plasma MHPG in 12 patients with bipolar I depression, 12 patients with bipolar II depression, and 20 normal healthy controls. All subjects were medication free for at least 4 weeks prior to the study.

RESULTS

There was a trend towards higher platelet 5-HT in bipolar I or II depressions when compared to normal controls, whereas there was no difference in platelet 5-HT levels between bipolar I and II depressed patients. When bipolar I and II patients were pooled, there was a significant increase in platelet 5-HT levels in bipolar depressives compared to normal controls, and there was a trend towards a weak positive correlation between platelet 5-HT and 21-item HAMD scores in the patient group. In contrast, there was no difference in plasma MHPG levels between the three groups.

LIMITATIONS

This study was limited to a small sample size, single point sampling and did not match seasons.

CONCLUSIONS

Our findings did not provide supportive evidence for a distinctive 5-HT or noradrenergic function within bipolar I and bipolar II depressions. However, the finding of increased platelet 5-HT levels in bipolar depressed patients compared to normal controls is consistent with the results of previous studies, and may suggest an increase in presynaptic 5-HT reuptake, presumably resulting from diminished synaptic 5-HT availability in this condition.

Structural changes in the brain of patients with bipolar affective disorder by MRI: a review of the literature

1. Current literature was searched to evaluate the use of magnetic resonance imaging in patients with bipolar disorder. 2. The presence of white matter hyperintensities, differences in temporal lobe and hippocampal structures, and ventricular enlargement in patients with bipolar disorder was assessed. 3. Further use of MRI in patients with bipolar disorder is reviewed.

Genetic epidemiologic methods to screen for matrilineal inheritance in mitochondrial disorders

We propose a method to screen for the matrilineal inheritance in mitochondrial disorders by comparing the risk of disease in a person whose mother is affected or whose maternal grandmother or aunt or uncle is affected to the risk of disease in a person whose father is affected or whose paternal grandmother or aunt or uncle is affected using a modification of the reconstructed cohort design. Sampling of pedigrees is accomplished via probands and must not be influenced by family history. The cohort of the proband's offspring, and offspring of the proband's siblings, can be analyzed using survival analysis. Cox proportional hazards model, Bonney's [(1986) Biometrics 42:611-625] model, and Liang's [(1991) Genet Epidemiol 8:329-338] model. Mitochondrial transmission can be distinguished from X-linked transmission by examining sex-specific patterns of disease expression in matrilineally transmitted diseases. To illustrate our epidemiologic method, we apply our screening method to pedigrees of two disorders which have been proposed to have a mitochondrial DNA component to their inheritance.

The epidemiology of bipolar affective disorder

This paper reviews the current position of studies on the epidemiology of bipolar affective disorder. A disorder that cannot be recognized until sometime after its onset poses special difficulties for epidemiological study. These are discussed and attempts made to solve them. Community psychiatric surveys suggest a morbid risk of bipolar disorder of around 2-2.5%, but probably include many false-positives. Studies of treated cases indicate a morbid risk of 0.5%, but will miss untreated cases. It is probably reasonable to suggest a compromise value of 1-1.5%; bipolar disorder is thus still a rare condition. It is possible to quantify the unipolar-bipolar conversion rate, which is of the order of 5%, and is of particular interest that female sufferers have proportionately fewer manic episodes. Age at onset, possible cohort phenomena, comorbidity, and sociodemographic correlates are discussed.

Linkage analysis between manic-depressive illness and 35 classical markers

The present study used carefully established phenotypes, several methods to reduce misclassification, and conservative genetic parameters. For the 35 markers investigated no evidence of linkage to manic-depressive illness was found, especially not to the markers on chromosomes 4q, 9q, and 19, which earlier has been suggested as possibly being linked to subtypes of manic-depressive illness. Close linkage to FY and SS (GYPB) was excluded for all chosen phenotypic models and to ACP1 and ADA for broader phenotypic models.

The genetics of bipolar disorder

Growing interest in the application of molecular biological techniques to psychiatric disorders has reinvigorated interest in the genetics of the psychoses. It is therefore timely to review the current state of knowledge of the genetics of bipolar disorder. Family, twin and adoption studies are all consistent in confirming the strongly heritable nature of this condition. As segregation analyses have been unable to determine the mode of transmission of bipolar disorder, ongoing linkage analyses using DNA markers will be crucial in determining whether this condition is due to a single major gene, a small number of genes, or multifactorial polygenic inheritance.

Suggestion of linkage between manic-depressive illness and the enzyme phosphoglycolate phosphatase (PGP) on chromosome 16p

Two large Danish pedigrees with manic-depressive illness (MDI) were ascertained through bipolar probands. The pedigrees include bipolar as well as unipolar cases. An autosomal dominant mode of inheritance with incomplete penetrance was assumed. Linkage relationships between MDI and 37 autosomal serum, enzyme and blood group markers were investigated. For phosphoglycolate phosphatase, a maximum lod score of 2.20 at 0% recombination was found for the largest family. The other family was not informative. This may suggest assignment of a major gene for MDI to chromosome 16p13.

Current perspectives on the genetics of unipolar depression

Evidence regarding the heritability of unipolar depression is evaluated. The data reviewed here support the involvement of genetic factors in the etiology of unipolar depression and its suitability for independent genetic inquiry, despite our inability to identify the mode(s) of transmission or identify a candidate locus. Continued progress in testing etiologic hypotheses requires (a) clarification of the mode of transmission; (b) resolution of phenotypic and potential genotypic heterogeneity; (c) general agreement on a "gold standard" for assessment of the unipolar phenotype; (d) the continued application of available quantitative methods to take into account the effects of ascertainment bias, sex effects, cohort effects, and variable/late age at onset; and (e) incorporation of quantitative indicators correlated with liability in multivariate analysis to improve the stability/validity of phenotypic determinations in segregation and linkage analysis. We present several recommendations regarding the extension of current methodologies in human population and quantitative genetics to help resolve these issues.

Evidence for possible linkage between genetic markers and affective disorders

Studies of the underlying components of affective disorders are particularly difficult because of the confounding effects of both genetic and environmental factors. Linkage analysis is a useful tool in delineating the etiology of affective disorders, as it is unlikely that linkage between behavioral traits and blood group polymorphisms could result from environmental effects. The present study used the robust Haseman and Elston sibpair method to analyze linkage between 24 genetic markers and affective disorder in 34 nuclear families from 25 pedigrees (195 people). The probands were ascertained as part of the ongoing NIMH Collaborative Depression Study. Indications of linkage between familial pure depressive disease and MNS and depression spectrum disease and ORM were found, as had been previously suggested. There was also suggestive evidence for linkage between the latter and GC. Results are discussed in terms of methodological differences with previous studies.

A linkage study of primary affective disorder

Marker loci in 113 members of nine unrelated multiplex families identified by a bipolar proband were tested for linkages with primary affective disorder. Linkage was excluded between the disease locus (assuming that it was a single autosomal dominant gene) and the HLA loci at a recombination fraction of 0.2, the ABO, Rh, and Lu loci at almost 0.05 and the Fy and P loci at 0.001.