Qualitative differences in tuberculin reactivity in patients with tuberculosis, occupational contacts and non-contacts

Early delayed hypersensitivity responses in tuberculin skin tests after heavy occupational exposure to tuberculosis

The early (six hours) reaction to tuberculin skin testing was studied in 33 Indonesian hospital workers with frequent occupational exposure to M tuberculosis and compared with responses maximal at the usual time (48 hours) in factory workers, from the same locality but with only occasional occupational exposure, to determine the nature of the early reaction. The early reaction had the same general histopathological appearance as that seen in the conventional (48 hour) reaction, and both had an infiltrate consisting largely of T lymphocytes and macrophages. The cell densities were lower in the six hour reactions, but the relative concentration of macrophages was greater in the earlier response. These histometric measurements suggested that the six hour reaction was an accelerated delayed hypersensitivity reaction. Moreover, the absence of a specific IgE response or of particulate masses of Ig or complement, made it unlikely an anaphylactoid or Arthus-type reaction could have been responsible. It is concluded that those with frequent occupational exposure to M tuberculosis have larger numbers of circulating T cells reactive with mycobacterial antigens, so that the development of the skin test response to tuberculin is less dependent on "by-stander" cell infiltration to mediate the delayed hypersensitivity reaction than the reactions in those with less intense and less frequent natural exposure. The skin test response maximal at six hours is probably a hyperimmune reaction to an antigen recognised by T cells.

Spectrum of immune reactivity to mycobacterial (BCG) antigens in healthy hospital contacts in south India

In an effort to study the immunological responses to antigens of tubercle bacilli, 49 tuberculin positive and 41 tuberculin negative hospital contacts aged 20-29 years (staff nurses and students working in Government Rajaji Hospital, Madurai, South India) were studied for serum antibodies (IgG, IgM and IgA classes) to BCG by ELISA and diameter of induration to PPD by Mantoux procedures. The two immunological parameters were correlated in regression analysis. The results have revealed higher anti-BCG serum antibody levels in hospital contacts than in non-contacts, significantly higher antibodies in tuberculin negative hospital contacts than in tuberculin positive hospital contacts, an inverse correlation of tuberculin reactivity and antibodies and a bimodal decline (regression) of antibodies against the increase in skin test induration. This study has thus suggested the existence of an immunological spectrum in hospital contacts from south India; persons at one pole of the spectrum were tuberculin negative and possessed significantly elevated antibody levels and those at the other pole of the spectrum were tuberculin positive and possessed low antibody levels. Thus the spectrum of immune reactivity may be due to an inherent susceptibility/resistance of an individual to Mycobacterium tuberculosis.

Skin changes in the tuberculin test

This review describes the recent advances in knowledge of the nature and range of physiological changes that occur in the skin at the site of a positive tuberculin reaction. The infiltration of T-cells and monocyte/macrophages shows a marked compartmentalisation suggesting that the functions of particular cell types depend on their localisation. The extent of cutaneous oedema (detectable as induration) is not closely related to other features of the reaction or to systemic indicators of cell mediated immunity. The intensity of hyperaemia is maximal at the centre of the reaction and is correlated in most cases with the density of cellular infiltration in the dermis suggesting a functional coordination. Despite this correlation between cell numbers and velocity of blood flow, the reaction normally shows hypoxia, hypercapnia and local acidosis, but this metabolic modification may not be a wholly disadvantageous effect since these conditions appear to facilitate the growth and metabolism of activated lymphocytes and macrophages. In very strong reactions, there is central relative slowing of the circulation and this may lead to necrosis in extreme cases. There are however a minority of cases where cell infiltration occurs but induration is not palpable: this situation has been named pseudoanergy, and its pathogenesis has not yet been established. The occurrence of pseudoanergy must throw some doubt on the conventional criteria for positivity in the reading of tuberculin skin tests (induration greater than 5 mm) and this may have relevance to future strategies for assessment of new vaccines.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

The effect of exposure of hospital employees to patients with tuberculosis on dermal reactivity to four new tuberculins

An early (6-8 h) erythematous response to Purified Protein Derivative and to sonicate antigens (new tuberculins) prepared from Mycobacterium tuberculosis, M. vaccae, M. scrofulaceum, and M. leprae occurred much more frequently amongst hospital employees exposed to patients with tuberculosis than amongst factory workers. Biopsies taken from the skin test sites at 48 h revealed a more intense inflammatory cell infiltrate in response to PPD and the sonicate of M. tuberculosis, but not to the antigens of the other mycobacteria, amongst the hospital employees thus indicating a degree of specificity. The early response appears to be directed towards species specific antigens, but not, apparently, to the same as those that elicit the 48 h reactions. The hospital employees also had higher peripheral blood B-cell counts and total IgG levels, suggestive of an adjuvant effect. It is postulated that the early reaction results from repeated exposure to tubercle bacilli and the possible nature of the reaction is discussed.

A clinical evaluation of the diagnostic usefulness of an early dermal reaction to tuberculin: a failure to distinguish between tuberculosis and other respiratory disease

An early (6-8 hour) reaction to RT23 tuberculin which was previously found to distinguish between patients with active tuberculosis and healthy tuberculin positive individuals failed to distinguish between such patients and those with other respiratory diseases. It also failed to distinguish between radiologically active and inactive cases of tuberculosis. Such early reactions were frequent among healthy hospital workers but not among other healthy subjects.

Haptoglobin: an immunoregulatory role in tuberculosis?

A significant correlation was found between levels of haptoglobin in sera from Indonesian patients with tuberculosis and the extent to which these sera suppressed mitogen-driven activation of normal lymphocytes in vitro. As in a previous study we showed that there was an inverse relationship between haptoglobin levels and the circulating lymphocyte count in the same group of patients, it is now suggested that this protein has an immunoregulatory role in tuberculosis. Similar observations have been made by other workers on patients with cancer. There was no difference in the distribution of the 3 allotypes of haptoglobin in patients and healthy subjects nor was there any association between such allotypes and the lymphocyte count, the dermal reactivity to tuberculin or the degree of suppression.