Viral and cellular factors that influence cell fusion induced by herpes simplex virus

Virus-Induced Cell Fusion and Syncytia Formation

Most enveloped viruses encode viral fusion proteins to penetrate host cell by membrane fusion. Interestingly, many enveloped viruses can also use viral fusion proteins to induce cell-cell fusion, both in vitro and in vivo, leading to the formation of syncytia or multinucleated giant cells (MGCs). In addition, some non-enveloped viruses encode specialized viral proteins that induce cell-cell fusion to facilitate viral spread. Overall, viruses that can induce cell-cell fusion are nearly ubiquitous in mammals. Virus cell-to-cell spread by inducing cell-cell fusion may overcome entry and post-entry blocks in target cells and allow evasion of neutralizing antibodies. However, molecular mechanisms of virus-induced cell-cell fusion remain largely unknown. Here, I summarize the current understanding of virus-induced cell fusion and syncytia formation.

Broadly Applicable, Virus-Free Dual Reporter Assay to Identify Compounds Interfering with Membrane Fusion: Performance for HSV-1 and SARS-CoV-2

Membrane fusion constitutes an essential step in the replication cycle of numerous viral pathogens, hence it represents an important druggable target. In the present study, we established a virus-free, stable reporter fusion inhibition assay (SRFIA) specifically designed to identify compounds interfering with virus-induced membrane fusion. The dual reporter assay is based on two stable Vero cell lines harboring the third-generation tetracycline (Tet3G) transactivator and a bicistronic reporter gene cassette under the control of the tetracycline responsive element (TRE3G), respectively. Cell–cell fusion by the transient transfection of viral fusogens in the presence of doxycycline results in the expression of the reporter enzyme secreted alkaline phosphatase (SEAP) and the fluorescent nuclear localization marker EYFPNuc. A constitutively expressed, secreted form of nanoluciferase (secNLuc) functioned as the internal control. The performance of the SRFIA was tested for the quantification of SARS-CoV-2- and HSV-1-induced cell–cell fusion, respectively, showing high sensitivity and specificity, as well as the reliable identification of known fusion inhibitors. Parallel quantification of secNLuc enabled the detection of cytotoxic compounds or insufficient transfection efficacy. In conclusion, the SRFIA reported here is well suited for high-throughput screening for new antiviral agents and essentially will be applicable to all viral fusogens causing cell–cell fusion in Vero cells.

Deletion of ER-retention motif on SARS-CoV-2 spike protein reduces cell hybrid during cell-cell fusion

Background

The novel SARS-CoV-2 has quickly become a global pandemic since the first reported case in December 2019, with the virus infecting millions of people to date. The spike (S) protein of the SARS-CoV-2 virus plays a key role in binding to angiotensin-converting enzyme 2 (ACE2), a host cell receptor for SARS-CoV-2. S proteins that are expressed on the cell membrane can initiate receptor-dependent syncytia formation that is associated with extensive tissue damage. Formation of syncytia have been previously observed in cells infected with various other viruses (e.g., HIV, Ebola, Influenza, and Herpesviruses). However, this phenomenon is not well documented and the mechanisms regulating the formation of the syncytia by SARS-CoV-2 are not fully understood.

Results

In this study, we investigated the possibility that cell fusion events mediated by the S protein of SARS-CoV-2 and ACE2 interaction can occur in different human cell lines that mimic different tissue origins. These cell lines were transduced with either wild-type (WT-S) S protein or a mutated variant where the ER-retention motif was removed (Δ19-S), as well as human ACE2 expression vectors. Different co-culture combinations of spike-expressing 293T, A549, K562, and SK-Hep1 cells with hACE2-expressing cells revealed cell hybrid fusion. However, only certain cells expressing S protein can form syncytial structures as this phenomenon cannot be observed in all co-culture combinations. Thus, SARS-CoV-2 mediated cell–cell fusion represents a cell type-dependent process which might rely on a different set of parameters. Recently, the Δ19-S variant is being widely used to increase SARS-CoV-2 pseudovirus production for in vitro assays. Comparison of cell fusion occurring via Δ19-S expressing cells shows defective nuclear fusion and syncytia formation compared to WT-S.

Conclusions

This distinction between the Δ19-S variant and WT-S protein may have downstream implications for studies that utilize pseudovirus-based entry assays. Additionally, this study suggest that spike protein expressed by vaccines may affect different ACE2-expressing host cells after SARS-CoV-2 vaccine administration. The long-term effects of these vaccines should be monitored carefully. Δ19-S mRNA may represent a safer mRNA vaccine design in the future.

Supplementary Information

The online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1186/s13578-021-00626-0.

Deletion of ER-retention Motif on SARS-CoV-2 Spike Protein Reduces Cell Hybrid During Cell-cell Fusion

The novel SARS-CoV-2 has quickly become a global pandemic since the first reported case in December 2019, with the virus infecting millions of people to date. The spike (S) protein of the SARS-CoV-2 virus plays a key role in binding to angiotensin-converting enzyme 2 (ACE2), a host cell receptor for SARS-CoV-2. S proteins that are expressed on the cell membrane can initiate receptor-dependent syncytia formation that is associated with extensive tissue damage. Formation of syncytia have been previously observed in cells infected with various other viruses (e.g., HIV, Ebola, Influenza, and Herpesviruses). However, this phenomenon is not well documented and the mechanisms regulating the formation of these syncytia by SARS-CoV-2 are not fully understood. In this study, we investigated the possibility that cell fusion events mediated by the S protein of SARS-CoV-2 and ACE2 interaction can occur in different human cell lines that mimic different tissue origins. These cell lines were stably transduced with either wild-type (WT-S) S protein or a mutated variant where the ER-retention motif was removed (Δ19-S), or human ACE2 vectors. Different co-culture combinations of spike-expressing 293T, A549, K562, and SK-Hep1 cells with hACE2-expressing cells revealed cell hybrid fusion. However, only certain cells expressing S protein can form syncytial structures as this phenomenon cannot be observed in all co-culture combinations. Thus, SARS-CoV-2 mediated cell-cell fusion represents a cell type-dependent process which might rely on a different set of parameters. Recently, the Δ19-S variant is being widely used to increase SARS-CoV-2 pseudovirus production for in vitro assays. Comparison of cell fusion occurring via Δ19-S expressing cells shows defective nuclear fusion and syncytia formation compared to WT-S. This distinction between the Δ19-S variant and WT-S protein may have downstream implications for studies that utilize pseudovirus-based entry assays. Additionally, this study suggest that spike protein expressed by vaccines may affect different ACE2-expressing host cells after SARS-CoV-2 vaccine administration. The long-term effects of these vaccines should be monitored carefully.

Virus-Mediated Cell-Cell Fusion

Cell-cell fusion between eukaryotic cells is a general process involved in many physiological and pathological conditions, including infections by bacteria, parasites, and viruses. As obligate intracellular pathogens, viruses use intracellular machineries and pathways for efficient replication in their host target cells. Interestingly, certain viruses, and, more especially, enveloped viruses belonging to different viral families and including human pathogens, can mediate cell-cell fusion between infected cells and neighboring non-infected cells. Depending of the cellular environment and tissue organization, this virus-mediated cell-cell fusion leads to the merge of membrane and cytoplasm contents and formation of multinucleated cells, also called syncytia, that can express high amount of viral antigens in tissues and organs of infected hosts. This ability of some viruses to trigger cell-cell fusion between infected cells as virus-donor cells and surrounding non-infected target cells is mainly related to virus-encoded fusion proteins, known as viral fusogens displaying high fusogenic properties, and expressed at the cell surface of the virus-donor cells. Virus-induced cell-cell fusion is then mediated by interactions of these viral fusion proteins with surface molecules or receptors involved in virus entry and expressed on neighboring non-infected cells. Thus, the goal of this review is to give an overview of the different animal virus families, with a more special focus on human pathogens, that can trigger cell-cell fusion.

Coexpression of UL20p and gK inhibits cell-cell fusion mediated by herpes simplex virus glycoproteins gD, gH-gL, and wild-type gB or an endocytosis-defective gB mutant and downmodulates their cell surface expression

Syncytium formation in cells that express herpes simplex virus glycoprotein B (gB), gD, gH, and gL is blocked by gK (E. Avitabile, G. Lombardi, and G. Campadelli-Fiume, J. Virol. 77:6836-6844, 2003). Here, we report the results of two series of experiments. First, UL20 protein (UL20p) expression weakly inhibited cell-cell fusion. Coexpression of UL20p and gK drastically reduced fusion in a cell-line-dependent manner, with the highest inhibition in BHK cells. Singly expressed UL20p and gK localized at the endoplasmic reticulum and nuclear membranes. When they were coexpressed, both proteins relocalized to the Golgi apparatus. Remarkably, in cells that coexpressed UL20p and gK, the antifusion activity correlated with a downmodulation of gD, gB, gH, and gL cell surface expression. Second, gB(Delta867) has a partial deletion in the cytoplasmic tail that removed endocytosis motifs. Whereas wild-type (wt) gB was internalized in vesicles lined with the endosomal marker Rab5, gB(delta867) was not internalized, exhibited enhanced cell surface expression, and was more efficient in mediating cell-cell fusion than wt gB. The antifusion activity of UL20p and gK was also exerted when gB(delta867) replaced wt gB in the cell fusion assay. These studies show that the gB C tail carries a functional endocytosis motif(s) and that the removal of the motif correlated with increased gB surface expression and increased fusion activity. We conclude that cell-cell fusion in wt-virus-infected cells is negatively controlled by at least two mechanisms. The novel mechanism described here involves the concerted action of UL20p and gK and correlates with a moderate but consistent reduction in the cell surface expression of the fusion glycoproteins. This mechanism is independent of the one exerted through endocytosis-mediated downmodulation of gB from the plasma membrane.

HveA (herpesvirus entry mediator A), a coreceptor for herpes simplex virus entry, also participates in virus-induced cell fusion

The purpose of this study was to determine whether a cell surface protein that can serve as coreceptor for herpes simplex virus type 1 (HSV-1) entry, herpesvirus entry mediator (previously designated HVEM but renamed HveA), also mediates HSV-1-induced cell-cell fusion. We found that transfection of DNA from KOS-804, a previously described HSV-1 syncytial (Syn) strain whose Syn mutation was mapped to an amino acid substitution in gK, induced numerous large syncytia on HveA-expressing Chinese hamster ovary cells (CHO-HVEM12) but not on control cells (CHO-C8). Antibodies specific for gD as well as for HveA were effective inhibitors of KOS-804-induced fusion, consistent with previously described direct interactions between gD and HveA. Since mutations in gD determine the ability of HSV-1 to utilize HveA for entry, we examined whether the form of virally expressed gD also influenced the ability of HveA to mediate fusion. We produced a recombinant virus carrying the KOS-804 Syn mutation and the KOS-Rid1 gD mutation, which significantly reduces viral entry via HveA, and designated it KOS-SR1. KOS-SR1 DNA had a markedly reduced ability to induce syncytia on CHO-HVEM12 cells and a somewhat enhanced ability to induce syncytia on CHO-C8 cells. These results support previous findings concerning the relative abilities of KOS and KOS-Rid1 to infect CHO-HVEM12 and CHO-C8 cells. Thus, HveA mediates cell-cell fusion as well as viral entry and both activities of HveA are contingent upon the form of gD expressed by the virus.

Herpes simplex virus type 1 glycoprotein K is not essential for infectious virus production in actively replicating cells but is required for efficient envelopment and translocation of infectious virions from the cytoplasm to the extracellular space

We characterized the glycoprotein K (gK)-null herpes simplex virus type 1 [HSV-1] (KOS) delta gK and compared it to the gK-null virus HSV-1 F-gKbeta (L. Hutchinson et al., J. Virol. 69:5401-5413, 1995). delta gK and F-gKbeta mutant viruses produced small plaques on Vero cell monolayers at 48 h postinfection. F-gKbeta caused extensive fusion of 143TK cells that was sensitive to melittin, a specific inhibitor of gK-induced cell fusion, while delta gK virus did not fuse 143TK cells. A recombinant plasmid containing the truncated gK gene specified by F-gKbeta failed to rescue the ICP27-null virus KOS (d27-1), while a plasmid with the delta gK deletion rescued the d27-1 virus efficiently. delta gK virus yield was approximately 100,000-fold lower in stationary cells than in actively replicating Vero cells. The plaquing efficiencies of delta gK and F-gKbeta virus stocks on VK302 cells were similar, while the plaquing efficiency of F-gKbeta virus stocks on Vero cells was reduced nearly 10,000-fold in comparison to that of delta gK virus. Mutant delta gK and F-gKbeta infectious virions accumulated within Vero and HEp-2 cells but failed to translocate to extracellular spaces. delta gK capsids accumulated in the nuclei of Vero but not HEp-2 cells. Enveloped delta gK virions were visualized in the cytoplasms of both Vero and HEp-2 cells, and viral capsids were found in the cytoplasm of HEp-2 cells within vesicles. Glycoproteins B, C, D, and H were expressed on the surface of delta gK-infected Vero cells in amounts similar to those for KOS-infected Vero cells. These results indicate that gK is involved in nucleocapsid envelopment, and more importantly in the translocation of infectious virions from the cytoplasm to the extracellular spaces, and that actively replicating cells can partially compensate for the envelopment but not for the cellular egress deficiency of the delta gK virus. Comparison of delta gK and F-gKbeta viruses suggests that the inefficient viral replication and plaquing efficiency of F-gKbeta virus in Vero cells and its syncytial phenotype in 143TK- cells are most likely due to expression of a truncated gK.

Herpes simplex virus glycoprotein K is known to influence fusion of infected cells, yet is not on the cell surface

Syncytial mutants of herpes simplex virus (HSV) cause extensive fusion of cultured cells, whereas wild-type HSV primarily causes cell rounding and aggregation. A large fraction of syncytial viruses contain mutations in the UL53 gene, which encodes glycoprotein K (gK). Previously, we demonstrated that wild-type and syncytial forms of gK are expressed at similar levels and possess identical electrophoretic mobilities. Using immunofluorescence, we show that gK is not transported to the surfaces of cells infected with either wild-type or syncytial HSV. Instead, gK accumulates in the perinuclear and nuclear membranes of cells. This finding is in contrast to the behavior of all other HSV glycoproteins described to date, which reach the cell surface. When gK was expressed in the absence of other HSV proteins, using a recombinant adenovirus vector, a similar perinuclear and nuclear pattern was observed. In addition, gK remained sensitive to endoglycosidase H, consistent with the hypothesis that gK does not reach the Golgi apparatus and is retained in the endoplasmic reticulum and nuclear envelope. Therefore, although gK mutations promote fusion between the surface membranes of HSV-infected cells, the glycoprotein does not reach the plasma membrane and, thus, must influence fusion indirectly.

Recurrent male herpes genitalis with two different strains of herpes simplex virus type 2

A case of a 50-year-old man with recurrent herpes genitalis with two different isolated strains of herpes simplex virus (HSV) type 2 is reported. Morphologically, two types of cytopathic effects (CPE) induced by viruses were observed in the Vero cell cultures, one being a syncytial giant cell formation and the other a rounded cell formation without cell adhesion resembling the CPE induced by ordinary HSV type 2. In this case, it is clinically interesting that the patient complained of persistent pain on the glans and urethra without recurrence of herpetic lesions even after the involution of enanthema. The correlation between the persistent pain and neurovirulence of the two different HSV strains is discussed.

Visualization of glycoproteins after tunicamycin and monensin treatment of herpes simplex virus infected cells

The effects of tunicamycin and monensin on the morphogenesis of herpes simplex virus type 1 and on the ultrastructure and function of host cell membranes was investigated by conventional technics of electron microscopy and cytochemical localization of glycoproteins with thiocarbohydrazide-SO2. Infected RS 537 rabbit fibroblasts were treated with tunicamycin, which inhibits the glycosylation of many glycoproteins, or monensin, which inhibits the transport of proteins to the cell surface, and were compared with untreated infected cells. Tunicamycin treatment almost entirely suppresses the perinuclear envelopment of viral capsids, induces the nuclear export of unusually numerous naked viral capsids, and prevents the proliferation of the Golgi apparatus. On the other hand, perinuclear envelopment of viral capsids still occurs following a monensin treatment; however, enveloped viral capsids are not released into the extracellular space; in addition this treatment induces the proliferation of the rough endoplasmic reticulum (RER). The number of structures stained for glycoproteins in tunicamycin-treated cells is markedly lower than that in nontreated infected cells, whereas an unusual additional staining of the entire outer nuclear membrane and of the RER occurs following monensin treatment.

The single base pair substitution responsible for the Syn phenotype of herpes simplex virus type 1, strain MP

Nucleotide sequences were determined for portions of the genomes of the syncytial (Syn) mutant of herpes simplex virus type 1, strain MP, and the related wild-type strain mP. Comparisons of the nucleotide sequences showed only 1 bp difference between the DNAs of strains MP and mP in the region to which the Syn mutation of MP had previously been mapped. This base pair substitution in MP (at map coordinate 0.737) eliminates a ThaI restriction endonuclease recognition site that is present in mP DNA. Analyses of MP X mP recombinant viruses showed that presence of the ThaI site correlates with the Syn+ phenotype and absence of the ThaI site correlates with the Syn phenotype as predicted. We conclude that the base pair substitution at map coordinate 0.737 is responsible for the Syn phenotype of MP. This mutation could alter translation in four of the six reading frames, causing amino acid substitutions. From only one of these reading frames is a product likely to be expressed. The 338-amino acid polypeptide that could be expressed has features characteristic of membrane-associated proteins, including hydrophobic domains, potential sites for the attachment of N-linked carbohydrate, and a potential cleavable signal sequence.

Processing of herpes simplex virus-1 glycans in cells defective in glycosyl transferases of the Golgi system: relationship to cell fusion and virion egress

We studied herpes simplex virus-1 (HSV-1) glycan structure and the expression of HSV-1 functions regulated by viral glycoproteins in Ric21 cells (P. VISCHER and R. C. HUGHES, Eur. J. Bioch. 117, 275-284, 1981). This is a line of ricin-resistant mutant BHK cells defective in the enzymes of the Golgi system which add terminal sugars to N-linked glycans. Two kinds of alterations were observed in the glycosylation of HSV glycoproteins in Ric21 cells. First, there was a defective processing of complex glycans leading to a reduction of biantennary and triantennary species and an increase of incompletely processed monosialylated oligosaccharides. Second, there was an overall reduction in the accumulation of HSV-1 glycoproteins. We found that (i) the release of herpesvirions from Ric21 cells was markedly lower than that from BHK cells, possibly reflecting reduced terminal sugar addition which, in turn, might affect the intracellular transport of glycoproteins. (ii) HSV-1 (MP)-infected Ric21 cells fused with a low efficiency. Furthermore, polycaryocytosis was reduced or abolished in BHK and in Ric21 cells exposed to neuraminidase, indicating that the presence of sialic acid residues in the cell surface glycans is essential for cells to interact in a fashion that brings cell fusion. (iii) Although capsid assembly was comparable, the rate of accumulation of infectious virus decreased in Ric21 cells. Infectivity of released virions from Ric21 and BHK cells was similar, in agreement with previous studies showing that complex-type glycans do not appear to be required for herpesvirion infectivity. The decrease in infectious HSV-1 yield seems to correlate with overall reduced ability to synthesize glycoproteins.

Expression of herpes simplex virus glycoprotein C from a DNA fragment inserted into the thymidine kinase gene of this virus

Previous reports have described mutants of herpes simplex virus type 1 that fail to produce or accumulate one of the major glycoproteins, glycoprotein C (gC). This defect is not lethal in cell culture, has been associated with the syncytial plaque morphology of some mutants, and may result from mutations that map to a region on the genome noncontiguous with the structural gene for gC. To investigate the conditions required for, and consequences of, gC expression in a specific genetic background, we have inserted a wild-type allele of the gC gene into the thymidine kinase gene (tk) of a gC- fusion-inducing viral mutant, strain MP. This was accomplished by identifying cloned viral DNA fragments homologous to gC mRNA, inserting the appropriate fragments into the viral tk cloned in pBR322, and then cotransfecting cells with the recombinant plasmids and DNA from strain MP, for selection of insertional TK- mutants. All TK- mutants containing insertions of appropriate sequences (in either orientation) into tk were found to express gC while maintaining the syncytial plaque morphology of strain MP. Elimination of the insertion from one of the TK- mutants was accompanied by loss of ability to produce gC. Our results permit more precise mapping of the DNA sequence encoding gC, to a subfragment of Sal I fragment R (map coordinates 0.620-0.640) and indicate also that promoter sequences for the gC gene may be located in this fragment. Moreover, we can conclude that the previously described regulatory mutation of strain MP does not prevent expression of gC from the DNA inserted into its gene tk and that the syncytial phenotype of MP cannot be due solely to absence of gC.

Infectivity and glycoprotein processing of herpes simplex virus type 1 grown in a ricin-resistant cell line deficient in N-acetylglucosaminyl transferase I

We report on the replication of herpes simplex virus type 1 (HSV-1) and viral glycoprotein processing in RicR14 cells, a mutant ricin-resistant cell line defective in N-acetylglucosaminyl transferase I activity. In these cells HSV-1(MP) and (F) replicated to yields very similar to those in parental BHK cells. The kinetics of HSV-1 adsorption in mutant and in parent cells was also essentially identical. Progeny virions from ricin-resistant and wild-type cells displayed comparable specific infectivities. However, in the mutant cells the efficiency of plating of progeny virus from both RicR14 and BHK cells was reduced. HSV-1(MP) failed to induce syncytia in RicR14 cells either in a plaque assay or after a high-multiplicity infection. Moreover, the fully glycosylated forms of glycoproteins (gB, gC, and gD) were totally absent, and only the partially glycosylated precursors (pgC, pgD. and a triplet in the gB-gA region) accumulated in HSV-1-infected ricin-resistant cells and in herpesvirions made in these cells. Consistent with these results analysis of pronase glycopeptides from cells labeled with [14C]glucosamine showed a strong decrease of sialylated complex-type oligosaccharides and a dramatic accumulation of the neutral mannose-rich chains. The latter chains predominate in partially glycosylated precursors, whereas the complex acidic chains predominate in the fully processed forms of HSV glycoproteins. These results taken together indicate that (i) host-cell N-acetylglucosaminyl transferase I participates in the processing of HSV glycoproteins; and (ii) infectivity of herpesvirions does not necessarily require the mature form of gB. The absence of HSV-1(MP)-induced fusion in RicR14 cells is discussed.

Characterization of an herpes simplex virus type 2 mutant, which is resistant to acycloguanosine and causes fusion of BSC1 cells

A mutant of herpes simplex virus type 2, which induces low levels of thymidine-kinase activity in infected BSC1 cells and consequently able to grow in the presence of acycloguanosine, was isolated. This mutant has also been shown to cause fusion of BSC1 cells. In BSC1 cells, co-infected with the wild-type strain and the mutant, the yield of each of the two viruses was normal but the rounding and aggregation of cells observed, resembled that found in wild-type infected cultures. When the mixed infection was performed in the presence of acycloguanosine (100 micrometers), the growth of the two virus strains was inhibited, as well as the cytopathic effect in the cultures. It is suggested that under these conditions, the thymidine-kinase which was induced in the infected cells by the wild-type strain, phosphorylated acycloguanosine and the activated drug formed, inhibited the growth of the two viruses by interference in their DNA syntheses.

Microtubules and microfilaments in HSV-Infected rabbit-kidney cells

In rabbit kidney cells infected with strains of Herpes simplex virus producing either cell-rounding or polycaryocytosis. Vinblastine induced paracrystals. This could be shown by phase-contrast- and electron-microscopy. Infections were done under one-step-growth conditions or at low MOI. 90 per cent noninfected cells contained stress fibers as detected by Servablue R250-staining. Shortly after recruitment into polycaryocytes, stress fibres of normal length appearing in criss-cross arrangement can be seen in the periphery of these cells. Later they polymerize to very long fibers and finally they are partially destroyed. The time of destruction depends on the MOI employed. By using Actinomycin D and/or Cycloheximide as blocking agents, it could be shown that polymerization of microfilaments correlates in time with giant cell formation. In view of the fact that the virus synthesis is accompanied in parallel by a special rearrangement of microfilaments as well as polycaryocytosis, both these processes have to be considered as caused by early (and late ?) protein-synthesis (beta-/gamma-proteins) but not as induced by "very-early" proteins (alpha-proteins).