Antiidiotypic antibodies to HLA class I alloantibodies in normal individuals: a mechanism of tolerance to noninherited maternal HLA antigens

A specific immune tolerance toward offspring cells is to exist after the mother lymphocyte infusion

PURPOSE

To examine immune tolerance between maternal lymphocytes and offspring tissue after a donor lymphocyte infusion.

METHODS

Mouse models were established by mating female BALB/c mice with male C57BL mice. Splenic lymphocytes from donors of different genetic backgrounds were labeled with carboxyfluorescein succinimidyl ester (CFSE), and 1×10⁷ of the labeled cells were intravenously injected into a recipient. At 6h, 24h, 72h and 120h after the infusion, mononuclear cells in recipient spleen, liver, thymus, lymph nodes, and peripheral blood were collected. CFSE+, CFSE-, CD3+, CD8+, CD4+, CD19+, NK1.1+, CD25+, and CD127+ lymphocytes in those samples were analyzed by flow cytometry. The distribution of donor T cells, B cells, NK cells, helper T cells, cytotoxic T cells, and recipient regulatory T cells in the tissues were then analyzed.

RESULTS

Maternal lymphocytes were more likely to survive in offspring. At 120h after infusion, the percentages of maternal cells in the offspring were 0.52±0.11% in lymph nodes, 0.97±0.04% in peripheral blood, and 0.97±0.11% in the spleen. Few donor cells, if any, were detected in these tissues at 120h after aunt to child, father to child, and unrelated allogeneic infusions were performed. The subtype proportion of donor lymphocytes changed significantly in the recipient tissues. Recipient Treg cells increased in the mother to child group, but not in the aunt to child, father to child, and unrelated allogeneic groups, suggesting a decreased cellular immune response to allogeneic cells in the mother to child group. At 120h after the infusion, no donor cells were detected in the recipient livers and thymuses of all groups, implying that donor cells were barely able to colonize in the liver and thymus.

CONCLUSION

Specific immune tolerance to maternal lymphocytes exists in offspring. An infusion of maternal donor lymphocytes may produce a relatively persistent effect of adoptive immunotherapy with reduced side-effects.

Analysis of maternal-offspring HLA compatibility, parent-of-origin and non-inherited maternal effects for the classical HLA loci in type 1 diabetes

AIM

Type 1 diabetes (T1D) is a complex trait for which variation in the classical human leucocyte antigen (HLA) loci within the Major Histocompatibility Complex (MHC) significantly influences disease risk. To date, HLA class II DR-DQ genes confer the strongest known genetic effect in T1D. HLA loci may also influence T1D through additional inherited or non-inherited effects. Evidence for the role of increased maternal-offspring HLA compatibility, and both parent-of-origin (POO) and non-inherited maternal HLA (NIMA) effects in autoimmune disease has been previously established. The current study tested hypotheses that classical HLA loci influence T1D through these mechanisms, in addition to genetic transmission of particular risk alleles.

METHODS

The Type 1 Diabetes Genetics Consortium (T1DGC) cohort was of European descent and consisted of 2271 affected sib-pair families (total n = 11 023 individuals). Class I genes HLA-A, Cw and B, and class II genes HLA-DRB1, DQA1, DQB1, DPA1 and DPB1 were studied. The pedigree disequilibrium test was used to examine transmission of HLA alleles to individuals with T1D. Conditional logistic regression was used to model compatibility relationships between mother-offspring and father-offspring for all HLA loci. POO and NIMA effects were investigated by comparing frequencies of maternal and paternal transmitted and non-transmitted HLA alleles for each locus. Analyses were also stratified by gender of T1D-affected offspring.

RESULTS

Strong associations were observed for all classical HLA loci except for DPA1, as expected. Compatibility differences between mother-offspring and father-offspring were not observed for any HLA loci. Furthermore, POO and NIMA HLA effects influencing T1D were not present.

CONCLUSIONS

Maternal-offspring HLA compatibility, POO and NIMA effects for eight classical HLA loci were investigated. Results suggest that these HLA-related effects are unlikely to play a major role in the development of T1D.

Gamma-globulins prepared from sera of multiparous women bind anti-HLA antibodies and inhibit an established in vivo human alloimmune response

It has previously been shown that sera from multiparous women have increased levels of anti-idiotypic antibodies specific for anti-HLA molecules. gamma-Globulins prepared from these sera may be superior to commercial preparations of intravenous gamma-globulin (IVIg) for inhibiting HLA alloimmunization. To test this, F(ab')2 fragments prepared from either commercial IVIg or from the sera of men or multiparous women were coupled to CNBr-Sepharose and tested for their ability to bind F(ab')2 fragments derived from polyspecific anti-HLA sera. As determined by flow cytometry, compared with columns coated with F(ab')2 derived from commercial IVIg or sera from men, columns coated with F(ab')2 prepared from the sera of multiparous women bound significantly more anti-HLA. In addition, intact IgG molecules prepared from the sera of multiparous women significantly neutralized the reactivity of the anti-HLA F(ab')2 fragments. To determine whether the intact IgG molecules or their corresponding F(ab')2 fragments could affect in vivo alloimmunity, they were tested for their ability to inhibit an established IgG human alloimmune response in humanized severe combined immunodeficient (SCID) mice. Compared with commercial IVIg, when intact IgG or F(ab')2 fragments derived from multiparous women were administered to SCID mice making human anti-HLA antibodies, a significant reduction in anti-HLA reactivity was observed. The findings suggest that IgG molecules prepared from the sera of multiparous women have increased anti-idiotypic reactivity against anti-HLA antibodies, which can significantly inhibit an established human IgG alloimmune response in an Fc-independent manner.

Glutamate decarboxylase antibodies in non-diabetic pregnancy precedes insulin-dependent diabetes in the mother but not necessarily in the offspring

We studied the risk for diabetes of glutamate decarboxylase (GAD65Ab) and islet cell (ICA) autoantibodies in non-diabetic pregnant mothers and their children. Pregnancy and cord blood sera were collected in 1970-87 from about 35,000 mothers who delivered a child in the city of Malmö, Sweden. A total of 42 mothers were identified in 1988 who, 1-18 years after their pregnancies, had developed either insulin-dependent (n = 22) or non-insulin dependent (n = 20) diabetes mellitus. First, in 123 pregnant mothers selected as controls, 0.8% had GAD65Ab and 0.8% ICA. Second, among the mothers with non-insulin dependent diabetes, 7/20 (35%) had GAD65Ab eight months to 13 years, 10 months before clinical diagnosis. Third, in mothers who later developed insulin-dependent diabetes, 12/22 (55%) had GAD65Ab and 10/22 (45%) had ICA in pregnancies preceding the clinical diagnosis by 13 months to 9 years, 4 months. In 1996, none of the children born to the 42 mothers have developed diabetes. GAD65Ab and ICA in non-diabetic pregnancies may predict insulin-dependent diabetes in the mother but not necessarily in the offspring.

The impact of elevated serum IgA and race on primary recipient renal allograft survival

This study correlated overall serum IgA levels in pretransplant (preTx) sera with graft survival. IgA levels, determined by nephelometry, were normally distributed, with a mean level of 255 +/- 139 mg/dl and a median of 234 mg/dl in 631 adult primary kidney allograft recipients and a mean level of 213 +/- 123 mg/dl with a median of 196 mg/dl for 100 retransplant recipients. Improved 3-year survival was associated with a high preTx IgA serum level in primary recipients (Kaplan-Meier analysis, P = 0.01), but not in retransplant patients. After stratifying by race, IgA correlated with graft survival in Caucasian, Hispanic, and "other" (Middle Eastern, Indian subcontinent, and Asian) primary recipients (P < or = 0.04), but not in African Americans. Higher survival rates were not associated with IgA in primary recipients stratified for rejection episodes, blood transfusions, or HLA-DR mismatches. Graft survival was improved in patients with > 2 HLA-AB mismatches and serum IgA above the median. PreTx IgA level and IgA alpha-HLA activity were significantly associated in preTx sera of primary renal allograft recipients (chi 2 = 7.145, P = 0.01), although only 9% (12/133) of sera tested displayed IgA anti-HLA class I reactivity. Thus, enhanced graft survival mediated by elevated serum IgA levels may due in part to competition for allograft HLA class I binding with deleterious Ig subclasses or immune effector cells. Elevated serum IgA may also reflect an altered immunoregulatory state. The results suggest that, depending on the racial group, preTx serum IgA levels are a prognostic indicator of graft survival in primary renal allograft recipients.

Inheritance of MHC class II genes in IDDM studied in population-based affected and control families

The transmission of HLA-DR and DQ was compared between 46 families with at least one child affected by insulin dependent diabetes mellitis (IDDM) and 43 healthy control families. In the patient families, there was an increased transmission of DR4 (p < 0.025) and DQB1*0302 (p < 0.01) from both parents to the index patient. There was an increased transmission of DQB1*0302 (p < 0.03) from the mothers only. The non-inherited maternal haplotypes showed a significantly decreased frequency (p < 0.01) of positively associated haplotypes (DR4-DQA1* 0301-DQB1*0302, DR3-DQA1*0501-DQB1*0201) compared to all parental haplotypes in the control families. In the control families neither transmission rates nor frequencies of non-inherited haplotypes differed from those expected in the control families. In conclusion, the observed reduction of IDDM-positively associated haplotypes in patient non-inherited maternal haplotypes, but not in non-inherited paternal haplotypes, suggests that tolerance during fetal life to maternal non-inherited HLA molecules may be important to diabetes development.

Epitope fine specificity of human anti-HLA-A2 antibodies. Identification of four epitopes including a haptenlike epitope on HLA-A2 at lysine 127

Anti-HLA-A2 CREG antibodies were purified from seven individuals by affinity chromatography. The binding of the purified antibodies to single or multiple amino acid variants of HLA-A2.1 was measured with an inhibition RIA. Substitutions at 10 amino acid residues in the polymorphic alpha 1 and alpha 2 domains were important for human antibody binding; eight of these have previously been shown to be important in the binding of murine anti-HLA-A2 CREG antibodies. Unlike any previously reported murine mAbs, the binding of antibodies from two individuals was eliminated by a substitution at the HLA-A2, -24, -28 shared loop amino acid residue lysine 127. Conversely, when the asparagine at residue 127 on the non-cross-reactive HLA-A3 was replaced with lysine, antibody binding was completely restored. The results further suggest that both lambda- and kappa-containing human antibodies that bind to this region may recognize lysine 127 as a haptenlike epitope. Anti-HLA-A2 antibodies that recognized a conformational epitope defined by changes at glycine 62 in the alpha 1 domain were predominated by lambda light chains whereas those that recognize an epitope defined by a loop residue at tryptophan 107 in the alpha 2 domain were predominated by kappa light chains. The data are consistent with a model of restricted epitope recognition of HLA-A2 by human B cells that is similar to, but distinct from, epitope recognition by mouse B-cell hybridomas, and may help to explain the phenomenon of public or cross-reactive idiotypes in the HLA system.

Anti-idiotypic antibodies specific for HLA in heart and kidney allograft recipients

Chronic rejection is the major threat to both heart and renal allograft survival. We have explored the possibility that some patients with anti-donor HLA antibodies (Ab1) develop specific anti-idiotypic antibodies (Ab2) which suppress the production of Ab1, and subsequently, the progression of chronic rejection. Analysis of Ab2 in sera obtained from Ab1 producers showed that 22% of heart and 18% of kidney recipients produced Ab2. The 4- and 5-year actuarial graft survivals in Ab2 producers were 100% and 83%, respectively, compared to 57% in patients who formed Ab1 but not Ab2 (p < 0.004). Patients carrying the DR2 alleles, DRB1*1501, *1502 or *1601 were at a lower risk of producing anti-donor HLA antibodies.

Soluble HLA class I and class II concentrations in commercial immunoglobulin preparations

Soluble HLA class I (sHLA-ABC) and class II (sHLA-RQP) molecules were quantitated in 16 commercially available immunoglobulin (Ig) preparations by enzyme-linked immunosorbent assays. Whereas three Ig preparations contained no detectable sHLA-ABC, all preparations showed concomitant sHLA-RQP molecules. There was a considerable variability with regard to the individual sHLA concentrations. For sHLA-RQP the values exceeded that found in human plasma of healthy individuals, suggesting that the extraction procedure may concentrate not only Ig, but also HLA class II molecules. Based on the total dosage of intravenously administered immunoglobulins (i.v.Ig), contaminating sHLA molecules may become immunogenic. Furthermore, sHLA molecules are discussed in terms of participation in the well-known immunomodulating effects of i.v.Ig therapy.