Allogeneic grafts of fetal dopamine neurons: behavioral indices of immunological interactions

L-dopa-Dependent Effects of GLP-1R Agonists on the Survival of Dopaminergic Cells Transplanted into a Rat Model of Parkinson Disease

Cell therapy is a promising treatment for Parkinson's disease (PD), however clinical trials to date have shown relatively low survival and significant patient-to-patient variability. Glucagon Like Peptide-1 receptor (GLP-1R) agonists have potential neuroprotective effects on endogenous dopaminergic neurons. This study explores whether these agents could similarly support the growth and survival of newly transplanted neurons. 6-OHDA lesioned Sprague Dawley rats received intra-striatal grafts of dopaminergic ventral mesencephalic cells from embryonic day 14 Wistar rat embryos. Transplanted rats then received either saline or L-dopa (12 mg/kg) administered every 48 h prior to, and following cell transplantation. Peripheral GLP-1R agonist administration (exendin-4, 0.5 μg/kg twice daily or liraglutide, 100 μg/kg once daily) commenced immediately after cell transplantation and was maintained throughout the study. Graft survival increased under administration of exendin-4, with motor function improving significantly following treatment with both exendin-4 and liraglutide. However, this effect was not observed in rats administered with L-dopa. In contrast, L-dopa treatment with liraglutide increased graft volume, with parallel increases in motor function. However, this improvement was accompanied by an increase in leukocyte infiltration around the graft. The co-administration of L-dopa and exendin-4 also led to indicators of insulin resistance not seen with liraglutide, which may underpin the differential effects observed between the two GLP1-R agonists. Overall, there may be some benefit to the supplementation of grafted patients with GLP-1R agonists but the potential interaction with other pharmacological treatments needs to be considered in more depth.

The immunogenicity of midbrain dopaminergic neurons and the implications for neural grafting trials in Parkinson's disease

Dopaminergic (DA) cell replacement therapies are a promising experimental treatment for Parkinson’s disease (PD) and a number of different types of DA cell-based therapies have already been trialled in patients. To date, the most successful have been allotransplants of foetal ventral midbrain but even then, the results have been inconsistent. This coupled to the ethical and logistical problems with using this tissue has meant that an alternative cell source has been sought of which human pluripotent stem cells (hPSCs) sources have proven very attractive. Robust protocols for making mesencephalic DA (mesDA) progenitor cells from hPSCs now exist and the first in-human clinical trials have or are about to start. However, while their safety and efficacy are well understood, relatively little is known about their immunogenicity and in this review, we briefly summarise this with reference mainly to the limited literature on human foetal DA cells.

Primary tissue for cellular brain repair in Parkinson's disease: Promise, problems and the potential of biomaterials

The dopamine precursor, levodopa, remains the "gold standard" treatment for Parkinson's disease, and, although it provides superlative efficacy in the early stages of the disease, its long-term use is limited by the development of severe motor side effects and a significant abating of therapeutic efficacy. Therefore, there remains a major unmet clinical need for the development of effective neuroprotective, neurorestorative or neuroreparatory therapies for this condition. The relatively selective loss of dopaminergic neurons from the nigrostriatal pathway makes Parkinson's disease an ideal candidate for reparative cell therapies, wherein the dopaminergic neurons that are lost in the condition are replaced through direct cell transplantation into the brain. To date, this approach has been developed, validated and clinically assessed using dopamine neuron-rich foetal ventral mesencephalon grafts which have been shown to survive and reinnervate the denervated brain after transplantation, and to restore motor function. However, despite long-term symptomatic relief in some patients, significant limitations, including poor graft survival and the impact this has on the number of foetal donors required, have prevented this therapy being more widely adopted as a restorative approach for Parkinson's disease. Injectable biomaterial scaffolds have the potential to improve the delivery, engraftment and survival of these grafts in the brain through provision of a supportive microenvironment for cell adhesion, growth and immune shielding. This article will briefly review the development of primary cell therapies for brain repair in Parkinson's disease and will consider the emerging literature which highlights the potential of using injectable biomaterial hydrogels in this context.

Foetal Cell Transplantation for Parkinson's Disease: Focus on Graft-Induced Dyskinesia

Transplantation of dopamine- (DA-) rich foetal ventral mesencephalic cells emerged as a promising therapy for Parkinson's disease (PD), as it allowed significant improvement of motor symptoms in several PD patients in open-label studies. However, double-blind clinical trials have been largely disappointing. The general agreement in the field is that the lack of standardization of tissue collection and preparation, together with the absence of postsurgical immunosuppression, played a key role in the failure of these studies. Moreover, a further complication that emerged in previous studies is the appearance of the so-called graft-induced dyskinesia (GID), in a subset of grafted patients, which resembles dyskinesia induced by L-DOPA but in the absence of medication. Preclinical evidence pointed to the serotonin neurons as possible players in the appearance of GID. In agreement, clinical investigations have shown that grafted tissue may contain a large number of serotonin neurons, in the order of half of the DA cells; moreover, the serotonin 5-HT1A receptor agonist buspirone has been found to produce significant dampening of GID in grafted patients. In this paper, we will review the recent preclinical and clinical studies focusing on cell transplantation for PD and on the mechanisms underlying GID.

Cyclosporin promotes neurorestoration and cell replacement therapy in pre-clinical models of Parkinson's disease

BACKGROUND

The early clinical trials using fetal ventral mesencephalic (VM) allografts in Parkinson's disease (PD) patients have shown efficacy (albeit not in all cases) and have paved the way for further development of cell replacement therapy strategies in PD. The preclinical work that led to these clinical trials used allografts of fetal VM tissue placed into 6-OHDA lesioned rats, while the patients received similar allografts under cover of immunosuppression in an α-synuclein disease state. Thus developing models that more faithfully replicate the clinical scenario would be a useful tool for the translation of such cell-based therapies to the clinic.

RESULTS

Here, we show that while providing functional recovery, transplantation of fetal dopamine neurons into the AAV-α-synuclein rat model of PD resulted in smaller-sized grafts as compared to similar grafts placed into the 6-OHDA-lesioned striatum. Additionally, we found that cyclosporin treatment was able to promote the survival of the transplanted cells in this allografted state and surprisingly also provided therapeutic benefit in sham-operated animals. We demonstrated that delayed cyclosporin treatment afforded neurorestoration in three complementary models of PD including the Thy1-α-synuclein transgenic mouse, a novel AAV-α-synuclein mouse model, and the MPTP mouse model. We then explored the mechanisms for this benefit of cyclosporin and found it was mediated by both cell-autonomous mechanisms and non-cell autonomous mechanisms.

CONCLUSION

This study provides compelling evidence in favor for the use of immunosuppression in all grafted PD patients receiving cell replacement therapy, regardless of the immunological mismatch between donor and host cells, and also suggests that cyclosporine treatment itself may act as a disease-modifying therapy in all PD patients.

Direct comparison of autologous and allogeneic transplantation of iPSC-derived neural cells in the brain of a non-human primate

Induced pluripotent stem cells (iPSCs) provide the potential for autologous transplantation using cells derived from a patient's own cells. However, the immunogenicity of iPSCs or their derivatives has been a matter of controversy, and up to now there has been no direct comparison of autologous and allogeneic transplantation in the brains of humans or nonhuman primates. Here, using nonhuman primates, we found that the autologous transplantation of iPSC-derived neurons elicited only a minimal immune response in the brain. In contrast, the allografts caused an acquired immune response with the activation of microglia (IBA-1(+)/MHC class II(+)) and the infiltration of leukocytes (CD45(+)/CD3(+)). Consequently, a higher number of dopaminergic neurons survived in the autografts. Our results suggest that the autologous transplantation of iPSC-derived neural cells is advantageous for minimizing the immune response in the brain compared with allogeneic grafts.

Understanding and prevention of "therapy-" induced dyskinesias

L-dopa is the most effective, currently available treatment for Parkinson's disease (PD), but it leads to the development of involuntary movements known as L-dopa-induced dyskinesia (LID) in the majority of patients after long-term use. Both gene and cell therapy approaches are the subject of multiple ongoing studies as potential ways of relieving symptoms of PD without the complication of dyskinesia. However, the spectre of dyskinesia in the absence of L-dopa, the so-called "off-phase" or graft-induced dyskinesia (GID), remains a major obstacle particularly in the further development of cell therapy in PD, but it is also a concern for proponents of gene therapy approaches. LID results from nonphysiological dopamine release, supersensitivity of dopamine receptors, and consequent abnormal signalling through mechanisms of synaptic plasticity. Restoration of physiological circuitry within the basal ganglia loops is ultimately the aim of all cell and gene therapy approaches but each using distinctive strategies and accompanied by risks of exacerbation of LID or development of "off-phase"/GID. In this paper we discuss the details of what is understood regarding the development of dyskinesias with relevance to cell and gene therapy and potential strategies to minimize their occurrence.

Facing the unique challenges of dyskinesias in Parkinson’s disease

Dyskinesia is among the most challenging complications of levodopa and dopaminergic drug therapy in advanced Parkinson’s disease. This symptom has a negative impact on the quality of life of patients with Parkinson’s disease and is hard to manage. Current advances in our understanding of the diverse phenomenology and complicated pathophysiology of dyskinesia have led to a number of novel strategies aimed at better control of this complication. Further insight has been gained from focusing on the characteristics of the rating scale used for assessment of dyskinesia and from the inherent susceptibility of dyskinesia to placebo effect. Here, we will briefly review the phenomenology, pathophysiology and the treatment of dyskinesia in Parkinson’s disease.

Human embryonic stem cell therapy for Parkinson's disease

Human embryonic stem cells (hESCs) may serve as the most enduring source of transplantable cells for Parkinson's disease patients. Accumulating experience in the transplantation of fetal midbrain tissue or cells into Parkinson's disease patients has set the stage for hESC therapy, but has also opened new controversies on the value and appropriate design of cell therapy. hESCs can be directed to differentiate into nigral dopaminergic neurons with high efficiency. The clinical use of hESCs will depend on their growth in controlled conditions, on whether safety can be proven, and on improving the survival of hESC-derived dopaminergic neurons in the host brain.

Factors affecting the clinical outcome after neural transplantation in Parkinson's disease

Intrastriatal grafts of embryonic mesencephalic tissue can survive in the brains of patients with Parkinson's disease, but the degree of symptomatic relief is highly variable and some cases develop troublesome dyskinesias. Here we explored, using clinical assessment and 18F-dopa and 11C-raclopride PET, factors which may influence the functional outcome after transplantation. We observed increased 18F-dopa uptake in the grafted putamen, signifying continued survival of the transplanted dopaminergic neurons, in parallel with a progressive reduction of 18F-dopa uptake in non-grafted regions for the whole patient group. The patients with the best functional outcome after transplantation exhibited no dopaminergic denervation in areas outside the grafted areas either preoperatively or at 1 or 2 years post-operatively. In contrast, patients with no or modest clinical benefit showed reduction of 18F-dopa in ventral striatum prior to or following transplantation, which may have limited graft-induced improvement. We obtained no evidence that dyskinesias were caused by abnormal dopamine (DA) release from the grafts. As has been observed for intrinsic dopaminergic neurons, there was a significant correlation between 18F-dopa uptake and methamphetamine-induced change of 11C-raclopride binding (as a measure of DA release) in the putamen containing the graft. Furthermore, we observed no correlation between 11C-raclopride binding in anterior, posterior or entire putamen under basal conditions or after methamphetamine, and dyskinesia severity scores in the contralateral side of the body. Withdrawal of immunosuppression at 29 months after transplantation caused no reduction of 18F-dopa uptake or worsening of UPDRS motor score, indicating continued survival and function of the graft. However, patients showed increased dyskinesia scores, which might have been caused either by growth of the graft or worsening of a low-grade inflammation around the graft. These findings indicate that poor outcome after transplantation is associated with progressive dopaminergic denervation in areas outside the grafts, a process which may have started already before surgery. Also, that the development of dyskinesias after transplantation is not associated with excessive DA release from the grafts. Finally, our data provide evidence that long-term immunosuppression can be withdrawn without interfering with graft survival or the motor recovery induced by transplantation.

Cell therapy in Parkinson's disease

The clinical studies with intrastriatal transplants of fetal mesencephalic tissue in Parkinson's disease (PD) patients have provided proof-of-principle for the cell replacement strategy in this disorder. The grafted dopaminergic neurons can reinnervate the denervated striatum, restore regulated dopamine (DA) release and movement-related frontal cortical activation, and give rise to significant symptomatic relief. In the most successful cases, patients have been able to withdraw L-dopa treatment after transplantation and resume an independent life. However, there are currently several problems linked to the use of fetal tissue: 1) lack of sufficient amounts of tissue for transplantation in a large number of patients, 2) variability of functional outcome with some patients showing major improvement and others modest if any clinical benefit, and 3) occurrence of troublesome dyskinesias in a significant proportion of patients after transplantation. Thus, neural transplantation is still at an experimental stage in PD. For the development of a clinically useful cell therapy, we need to define better criteria for patient selection and how graft placement should be optimized in each patient. We also need to explore in more detail the importance for functional outcome of the dissection and cellular composition of the graft tissue as well as of immunological mechanisms. Strategies to prevent the development of dyskinesias after grafting have to be developed. Finally, we need to generate large numbers of viable DA neurons in preparations that are standardized and quality controlled. The stem cell technology may provide a virtually unlimited source of DA neurons, but several scientific issues need to be addressed before stem cell-based therapies can be tested in PD patients.

Cell transplantation in Parkinson's disease: how can we make it work?

Previous open-label clinical trials have provided proof of principle that intrastriatal transplants of fetal dopaminergic neurons can induce substantial and long-lasting functional benefits in patients with Parkinson's disease. However, in two recent NIH-sponsored double-blind trials, functional improvements were only marginal and the primary endpoints were not met. Severe off-phase dyskinesias were observed in a significant proportion of the transplanted patients, raising doubts about the viability of the cell-transplantation approach. Here, we discuss the problems raised by the NIH-sponsored trials and point to several shortcomings that might explain the overall poor outcome, and we identify several crucial issues that remain to be resolved to develop cell replacement into an effective and safe therapy.

Xenografting human T2 sympathetic ganglion from hyperhidrotic patients provides short-term restoration of catecholaminergic functions in hemiparkinsonian athymic rats

Previous studies have suggested that allografting peripheral sympathetic ganglia, such as superior cervical ganglia, partially relieves clinical or behavioral deficits in parkinsonian patients and animals. However, removal of these ganglia can cause Homer's syndrome, which limits the utilization of this approach. Hyperhidrosis, a disease of excessive sweating, is commonly seen in young Orientals. Treatment of hyperhidrosis often involves surgical removal of the second thoracic sympathetic ganglia (T2G), which contain catecholaminergic neurons. The purpose of our study was to investigate behavioral responses and tyrosine hydroxylase (TH) immunoreactivity in hemiparkinsonian rats at different time points after transplantation of human T2G from hyperhidrotic patients. Athymic Fisher 344 rats were injected unilaterally with 6-hydroxydopamine into the medial forebrain bundle to destroy the nigrostriatal dopaminergic (DA) pathway. The effectiveness of lesions was tested by measuring methamphetamine (MA)-induced rotations. These unilaterally lesioned rats were later transplanted with T2G or T2 fiber tract (T2F) obtained from adult hyperhidrotic patients. Animals grafted with T2G showed a reduction in MA-induced rotation by 2 weeks; however, rotation returned to the pregrafting levels by 3 months. Animals receiving T2F grafts did not show any reduction of rotation over a 3-month period. Animals were later sacrificed for TH immunostaining at different time points. Tyrosine hydroxylase-positive [TH(+)] cell bodies and fibers were found in the lesioned striatum 2-4 weeks after T2G grafting, suggesting the survival of transplants. Two to 3 months after grafting, TH(+) fibers were still found in almost all the recipients. However, TH(+) cell bodies were found in only three of seven rats studied. Animals receiving T2F grafting did not show any TH immunoreactivity in the lesioned striatum over the 3-month period. These data indicate that T2G transplants from adult hyperhidrotic patients can survive and provide transient normalization of the motor behavior in the hemiparkinsonian athymic rats. Because of the short-term improvement in behavior after grafting, the use of T2G in human trials should be cautious at the present time. Further laboratory research is required.

Cyclosporine-A increases locomotor activity in rats with 6-hydroxydopamine-induced hemiparkinsonism: relevance to neural transplantation

BACKGROUND

The immunosuppressant cyclosporine-A (CsA) is the primary drug for neural transplantation in Parkinson's disease. However, little is known of its direct effects on movement disorders. Our previous observation of increased locomotor activity in normal rats injected with CsA prompted us to investigate further the effects of CsA on hemiparkinsonian rats.

METHODS

We examined the effects of CsA with 6-hydroxydopamine-induced hemiparkinsonism. The animals were randomly assigned to either intraperitoneal injections of CsA (15 mg/kg) or olive oil (the vehicle used for CsA) for 32 days. All animals were tested using the elevated body swing test, and the spontaneous and the amphetamine-induced rotational tests prior to and following the 32-day drug regimen.

RESULTS

As revealed by the elevated body swing test, CsA-treated rats had significantly higher mean percent contralateral (to the lesion) swings compared to their pretreatment level (p < 0.01) or to vehicle-treated rats at posttreatment (p < 0.005). In the spontaneous rotational test, CsA-treated rats displayed ipsilateral (to the lesion) rotations which were significantly higher than their pretreatment rotational behavior (p < 0.005) or the posttreatment rotational behavior of olive oil-treated rats (p < 0.0001). Similarly, CsA-treated rats displayed significantly more amphetamine-induced ipsilateral rotations compared to their or the olive oil-treated rats pretreatment level (p < 0.05).

CONCLUSION

Our present observations extend our previous findings on motor alterations produced by CsA on normal rats to hemiparkinsonian rats. These results taken together would suggest that CsA may interact with the locomotor effects observed following neural transplantation with adjunctive CsA immunosuppression.

Interactions of neurotrophic factors GDNF and NT-3, but not BDNF, with the immune system following fetal spinal cord transplantation

Glial cell line-derived neurotrophic factor (GDNF) is known to stimulate survival of dopaminergic and spinal cord motor neurons. However, little is known of the possible immune sequelae of GDNF exposure, or that of other putative trophic factors. To address these questions we utilized in oculo grafts of spinal cord, wherein we could induce different levels of immune responses via allogeneic vs. syngeneic combinations. Adult female Sprague-Dawley and Fisher rats were used as hosts for allogeneic and syngeneic grafts, respectively. Embryonic age 14-15-day-old fetuses were taken from pregnant dams of each strain, and cervical spinal cords were removed and dissected. Pieces of the spinal cord were transplanted into the anterior chamber of the eye within each strain. At 5-day intervals, 0.5 microgram of GDNF, brain-derived neurotrophic factor (BDNF), neurotrophin-3 (NT-3) or cytochrome c (CC) was injected into the anterior chamber of the eye and the sizes of the transplants were measured for the Sprague-Dawley rats. The same injections and measurements, but only for GDNF and CC, were carried out using Fisher rats. As expected, GDNF increased transplant survival and growth in both the Sprague-Dawley and Fisher animals. At day 41-42, all rats were sacrificed. Cameral graft appearance was evaluated by cresyl violet and immunohistochemically using antibodies against neurofilament (NF), calcitonin gene-related peptide (CGRP) and glial fibrillary acidic protein (GFAP). To monitor immune responses, the following monoclonal antibodies were used: OX38 against CD4, OX18 against MHC class I (MHCI), OX8 against CD8, OX6 against MHC class II (MHCII), OX42 against CD11b, R73 against alpha and beta T cell receptor (TcR), and ED1. In the Sprague-Dawley grafts, significantly higher amounts of CD8+, T lymphocyte+, MHCI+ and MHCII+ antigen-presenting cells (APC) were observed in GDNF-treated transplants. These markers were also increased in NT-3-treated groups. There were two types of OX-42+ cells, one was the ordinary ramified microglial cell, the other appeared to be a phagocytic cell, looking like the interstitial proliferating variety. Interestingly, the phagocytic OX-42+ cells had the same distribution as ED1+ and MHCII+ cells. In contrast, there were few immunoreactive cells after GDNF treatment in the inbred Fisher animals, similar to the CC control group. These results suggest that GDNF and to some extent NT-3, can activate the immune system in allogeneic graft combinations, but that these trophic factors do not produce overt rejection, and do not per se induce immune responses.

Allogeneic grafts of fetal dopamine neurons: immunological reactions following active and adoptive immunizations

To define the importance of adoptive sensitization and duration of graft residence on transplant alloimmunization, behavioral and histochemical parameters were examined in unilaterally 6-OHDA-lesioned F344 rat hosts which received fetal ventral mesencephalic (VM) grafts from Wistar-Furth (WF) donors. In all animals which showed increased rotations after alloimmunization, increased numbers of T cell receptor (TcR) positive, CD8+ lymphocytes were detected in the grafts. In addition, an increased density of class I MHC antigens was seen in the graft and in the adjacent host brain. Lesser numbers of CD4+, CD11b+, and MHCII+ positive elements were also seen. Perivascular cuffing was often found in actively immunized animals. An increase in TcR+ and MHC class I+ elements was also seen in animals only adoptively immunized. The tyrosine hydroxylase positive graft area was also markedly reduced in actively immunized animals and the extent of reduction correlated with the number of cells used for immunization. These studies indicate that established allografts can evade rejection as long as host lymphocytes are not activated against graft alloantigens. In addition, increasing graft residence time in the host and adoptive immunization render the graft more susceptible to subsequent rejection.