Comparisons of psychophysical and neurophysiological studies of cochlear implants

Enhancement of interaural level differences for bilateral cochlear implant users

Bilateral cochlear implant (BiCI) users do not localize sounds as well as normal hearing (NH) listeners do. NH listeners rely on two binaural cues to localize sounds in the horizontal plane, namely interaural level differences (ILDs) and interaural time differences. BiCI systems, however, convey these cues poorly. In this work, we investigated two methods to improve the coding of ILDs in BiCIs. The first method enhances ILDs by applying an artificial current-versus-angle function to the clinical levels delivered by the basal electrodes of the CI contralateral to the target sound. The second method enhances ILDs by using bilaterally linked N-of-M band selection. Results indicate that the participants were able to discriminate the location of the sound more accurately at narrow azimuths when the ILD enhancement was applied, compared to when they were using natural ILDs. Also, the results show that linking the band selection had a positive effect on left/right discrimination accuracy at larger azimuths for three out of the 10 tested participants, when compared to unlinked band selection. Based on these results, we conclude that ILD enhancement besides linked N-of-M band selection can help some BiCI participants to discriminate sound sources on the frontal horizontal plane.

Comparison of Multi-Compartment Cable Models of Human Auditory Nerve Fibers

Background: Multi-compartment cable models of auditory nerve fibers have been developed to assist in the improvement of cochlear implants. With the advancement of computational technology and the results obtained from in vivo and in vitro experiments, these models have evolved to incorporate a considerable degree of morphological and physiological details. They have also been combined with three-dimensional volume conduction models of the cochlea to simulate neural responses to electrical stimulation. However, no specific rules have been provided on choosing the appropriate cable model, and most models adopted in recent studies were chosen without a specific reason or by inheritance. Methods: Three of the most cited biophysical multi-compartment cable models of the human auditory nerve, i.e., Rattay et al. (2001b), Briaire and Frijns (2005), and Smit et al. (2010), were implemented in this study. Several properties of single fibers were compared among the three models, including threshold, conduction velocity, action potential shape, latency, refractory properties, as well as stochastic and temporal behaviors. Experimental results regarding these properties were also included as a reference for comparison. Results: For monophasic single-pulse stimulation, the ratio of anodic vs. cathodic thresholds in all models was within the experimental range despite a much larger ratio in the model by Briaire and Frijns. For biphasic pulse-train stimulation, thresholds as a function of both pulse rate and pulse duration differed between the models, but none matched the experimental observations even coarsely. Similarly, for all other properties including the conduction velocity, action potential shape, and latency, the models presented different outcomes and not all of them fell within the range observed in experiments. Conclusions: While all three models presented similar values in certain single fiber properties to those obtained in experiments, none matched all experimental observations satisfactorily. In particular, the adaptation and temporal integration behaviors were completely missing in all models. Further extensions and analyses are required to explain and simulate realistic auditory nerve fiber responses to electrical stimulation.

Impedance measures for a better understanding of the electrical stimulation of the inner ear

The performance of cochlear implant (CI) listeners is limited by several factors among which the lack of spatial selectivity of the electrical stimulation. Recently, many studies have explored the use of multipolar strategies where several electrodes are stimulated simultaneously to focus the electrical field in a restricted region of the cochlea.

OBJECTIVE

These strategies are based on several assumptions concerning the electrical properties of the inner ear that need validation. The first, often implicit, assumption is that the medium is purely resistive and that the current waveforms produced by several electrodes sum linearly. The second assumption relates to the estimation of the contribution of each electrode to the overall electrical field. These individual contributions are usually obtained by stimulating each electrode and measuring the resulting voltage with the other inactive electrodes (i.e. the impedance matrix). However, measuring the voltage on active electrodes (i.e. the diagonal of the matrix) is not straightforward because of the polarization of the electrode-fluid interface. In existing multipolar strategies, the diagonal terms of the matrix are therefore inferred using linear extrapolation from measurements made at neighboring electrodes.

APPROACH

In experiment 1, several impedance measurements were carried out in vitro and in eight CI users using sinusoidal and pulsatile waveforms to test the resistivity and linearity hypotheses. In experiment 2, we used an equivalent electrical model including a constant phase element in order to isolate the polarization component of the contact impedance.

MAIN RESULTS

In experiment 1, high-resolution voltage recordings (1.1 MHz sampling) showed the resistivity assumption to be valid at 46.4 kHz, the highest frequency tested. However, these measures also revealed the presence of parasitic capacitive effects at high frequency that could be deleterious to multipolar strategies. Experiment 2 showed that the electrical model provides a better account of the high-resolution impedance measurements than previous approaches in the CI field that used resistor-capacitance circuit models.

SIGNIFICANCE

These results validate the main hypotheses underlying the use of multipolar stimulation but also suggest possible modifications to their implementation, including the use of an impedance model and the modification of the electrical pulse waveform.

Impact of modulating phase duration on electrically evoked auditory brainstem responses obtained during cochlear implantation

Objective To investigate the effect of increasing phase duration (pulse width, T-pulse) using a biphasic pulse composed of an initial anodic active phase followed by a balancing cathodic phase on the electrically evoked auditory brainstem responses (eABRs) recorded at the time of cochlear implantation. Design eABRs recorded during 188 surgeries for cochlear implantation from 1999 to 2006 in a single center were retrospectively reviewed by two independent observers. All patients were fitted with a NEURELEC cochlear implant (CI) device, initially DIGISONIC(®) then DIGISONIC SP(®) (2004-2006). Result Immediately following cochlear implantation, stimulation by the CI resulted in reliable wave III and V eABR waveforms (mean wave III latency 2.23 ± 0.38 ms SD and wave V latency 4.28 ± 0.42 ms SD). Latencies followed an apical to basal gradient (0.32 ms increase in mean eV latency and 0.12 ms for eIII latency). With increasing phase duration, wave III and wave V latencies significantly decreased in association with a shortening of the eIII-eV interwave gap, while amplitudes of both waves increased. Conclusion The impact of increasing phase duration on latency and amplitude of brainstem responses in a large set of patients implanted with NEURELEC CIs was reported.

Alternative pulse shapes in electrical hearing

Cochlear implants (CIs) stimulate the auditory nerve with trains of symmetric biphasic (BI) pulses. We review studies showing that more efficient stimulation can be achieved by modifying these pulses by (1) increasing the inter-phase gap (IPG) between the two phases of each pulse, thereby delaying the recovery of charge, (2) increasing the duration and decreasing the amplitude of one phase - so-called "pseudomonophasic (PS)" waveforms, and (3) combining the pseudomonophasic stimulus with an IPG in a "delayed pseudomonophasic" waveform (PS_IPG). These efficiency gains, measured using changes in threshold and loudness, occur at a wide range of pulse rates, including those commonly used in current CI systems. In monopolar mode, dynamic ranges are larger for PS and for long-IPG pulse shapes than for BI pulses, but this increase in DR is not accompanied by a higher number of discriminable loudness steps, and hence, in a better coding of loudness. Moreover, waveforms with relatively short and long interphase gaps do not yield different patterns of excitation despite the relatively large differences in threshold. Two important findings are that, contrary to data obtained in animal experiments, anodic currents are more effective than cathodic stimulation for human CI patients and that the thresholds decrease with increases in IPG over a much longer time course (more than 3 ms) than for animals. In this review it is discussed how these alternative pulse shapes may be beneficial in terms of reducing power consumption and channel interactions, which issues remain to be addressed, and how models contribute to guiding our research.

Electrode independence in intraneural cochlear nerve stimulation

OBJECTIVES/HYPOTHESIS

We have previously reported feline electrophysiological and anatomical studies focused on the development of an intraneural auditory neuroprosthesis. Because only the tips of the electrodes implanted in the cochlear nerve are the stimulating elements that abut the nerve axons, we hypothesize that intraneural stimulation will be highly focal in nature. In this article, we report the electrophysiological characterization of the selective activation of subpopulations of cochlear nerve fibers via electrodes implanted in feline cochlear nerve.

STUDY DESIGN

We have used a forward-masking paradigm to estimate the extent of stimulation overlap produced by pairs of electrodes implanted into the cochlear nerve.

METHODS

The technique uses sequential stimulation via masking and probe electrodes and monitoring of the electrically evoked auditory brain stem response as an index of cochlear nerve fiber recruitment. We investigated overlap in all possible electrode pair combinations.

RESULTS AND CONCLUSION

Many electrode pairs manifest virtually no overlap in the subpopulations of fibers excited by perithreshold stimuli, whereas most had considerable overlap at higher stimulation levels. However, we also noted that our measured overlap was similar across electrodes possibly because of lack of specificity of the whole nerve electrically evoked auditory brain stem response as an assay for this parameter. These findings indicate that direct cochlear nerve stimulation via intraneural electrodes provides selective excitation of small subpopulations of cochlear nerve fibers, and suggest that cochlear nerve stimulation may selectively evoke narrow-band frequency percepts.

A dual-process integrator-resonator model of the electrically stimulated human auditory nerve

A phenomenological dual-process model of the electrically stimulated human auditory nerve is presented and compared to threshold and loudness data from cochlear implant users. The auditory nerve is modeled as two parallel processes derived from linearized equations of conductance-based models. The first process is an integrator, which dominates stimulation for short-phase duration biphasic pulses and high-frequency sinusoidal stimuli. It has a relatively short time constant (0.094 ms) arising from the passive properties of the membrane. The second process is a resonator, which induces nonmonotonic functions of threshold vs frequency with minima around 80 Hz. The ion channel responsible for this trend has a relatively large relaxation time constant of about 1 ms. Membrane noise is modeled as a Gaussian noise, and loudness sensation is assumed to relate to the probability of firing of a neuron during a 20-ms rectangular window. Experimental psychophysical results obtained in seven previously published studies can be interpreted with this model. The model also provides a physiologically based account of the nonmonotonic threshold vs frequency functions observed in biphasic and sinusoidal stimulation, the large threshold decrease obtained with biphasic pulses having a relatively long inter-phase gap and the effects of asymmetric pulses.

The effect of Gaussian noise on the threshold, dynamic range, and loudness of analogue cochlear implant stimuli

The deliberate addition of Gaussian noise to cochlear implant signals has previously been proposed to enhance the time coding of signals by the cochlear nerve. Potentially, the addition of an inaudible level of noise could also have secondary benefits: it could lower the threshold to the information-bearing signal, and by desynchronization of nerve discharges, it could increase the level at which the information-bearing signal becomes uncomfortable. Both these effects would lead to an increased dynamic range, which might be expected to enhance speech comprehension and make the choice of cochlear implant compression parameters less critical (as with a wider dynamic range, small changes in the parameters would have less effect on loudness). The hypothesized secondary effects were investigated with eight users of the Clarion cochlear implant; the stimulation was analogue and monopolar. For presentations in noise, noise at 95% of the threshold level was applied simultaneously and independently to all the electrodes. The noise was found in two-alternative forced-choice (2AFC) experiments to decrease the threshold to sinusoidal stimuli (100 Hz, 1 kHz, 5 kHz) by about 2.0 dB and increase the dynamic range by 0.7 dB. Furthermore, in 2AFC loudness balance experiments, noise was found to decrease the loudness of moderate to intense stimuli. This suggests that loudness is partially coded by the degree of phase-locking of cochlear nerve fibers. The overall gain in dynamic range was modest, and more complex noise strategies, for example, using inhibition between the noise sources, may be required to get a clinically useful benefit.

Effects of pulse rate on thresholds and loudness of biphasic and alternating monophasic pulse trains in electrical hearing

Detection thresholds and most comfortable loudnesses (MCLs) were determined as a function of pulse rate for standard biphasic pulse trains (BP) and for anodic and cathodic monophasic phases alternating at fixed intervals (ALT-m). Three different phase durations were examined. With a 100-micros phase duration, thresholds for the ALT-m stimulus were substantially (up to 12 dB) lower than for the BP stimuli at relatively low rates (200 pps), but were similar to the BP thresholds at high rates (1000 pps). Thresholds for BP pulse trains decreased monotonically with increasing rate, whereas the function for ALT-m waveforms was non-monotonic with a maximum between 400 and 1000 pps. These trends occurred for three different cochlear implant devices, different electrode configurations, and, generally, for different phase durations (10.8, 25, and 100 micros/phase). However, at the shorter phase durations, thresholds remained lower for the ALT-m stimulus, even at 5000 pps, the highest rate studied. Dynamic ranges of the BP pulse trains increased with increasing rate, irrespective of the phase duration under test, but for the ALT-m stimuli this was only true at the shorter phase durations tested. At a 100-mus phase duration, dynamic ranges for the ALT-m waveforms did not differ significantly as a function of rate. The results confirm previous reports that delaying charge recovery, in this case by switching from a BP to an ALT-m wave shape, can substantially reduce thresholds [Van Wieringen, A., Carlyon, R.P., Laneau, J., Wouters, J., 2005. Effects of waveform shape on human sensitivity to electrical stimulation of the inner ear. Hear. Res. 200, 73-86; Carlyon, R.P., van Wieringen, A., Deeks, J.M., Long, C.J., Lyzenga, J, Wouters, J., 2005. Effect of inter-phase gap on the sensitivity of cochlear implant users to electrical stimulation. Hear. Res. 205, 210-224]. However, at high pulse rates, this advantage only occurs at short phase durations. In addition, we show that the complex interaction between the effects of pulse shape, rate, and phase duration on thresholds can be captured by the simple linear model described by Carlyon et al.

Effects of waveform shape on human sensitivity to electrical stimulation of the inner ear

Psychophysical measures of the electrically stimulated human auditory system were obtained for different types of symmetric and asymmetric charge-balanced waveforms. Absolute detection thresholds of biphasic, pseudomonophasic, and 'alternating monophasic' current waveforms delivered by a bipolar intra-cochlear electrode pair were determined for four subjects implanted with the LAURA device. Thresholds for alternating monophasic stimuli, in which anodic and cathodic phases alternated every 5 ms, were 5-8 dB lower than for the biphasic waveforms for all four subjects. For two of the four subjects, thresholds for the pseudomonophasic waveforms were also significantly lower than for the biphasic waveforms. These pseudomonophasic thresholds were greatly affected neither by a 500-micros gap inserted between the two phases, nor by whether the shorter phase preceded or followed the longer one. Loudness balancing measures performed at the most comfortable levels also showed that, for equal loudness, alternating monophasic stimuli required a lower level than biphasic and pseudomonophasic waveforms. For three of the four subjects, the dynamic ranges of the pseudomonophasic (but not alternating monophasic) waveforms were greater than those of the biphasic waveforms. The results demonstrate that thresholds and dynamic ranges of human cochlear implant users can be controlled by manipulating the way in which the charge produced by the initial phase of an electrical pulse is recovered.

Effect of inter-phase gap on the sensitivity of cochlear implant users to electrical stimulation

Human behavioral thresholds for trains of biphasic pulses applied to a single channel of Nucleus CI24 and LAURA cochlear implants were measured as a function of inter-phase gap (IPG). Experiment 1 used bipolar stimulation, a 100-pps pulse rate, and a 400-ms stimulus duration. In one condition, the two phases of each pulse had opposite polarity. Thresholds continued to drop by 9-10 dB as IPG was increased from near zero to the longest value tested (2900 micros for CI24, 4900 micros for LAURA). This time course is much longer than reported for single-cell recordings from animals. In a second condition, the two phases of each pulse had the same polarity, which alternated from pulse to pulse. Thresholds were independent of IPG, and similar to those in condition 1 at IPG=4900 micros. Experiment 2 used monopolar stimulation. One condition was similar to condition 1 of experiment 1, and thresholds also dropped up to the longest IPG studied (2900 micros). This also happened when the pulse rate was reduced to 20 pps, and when only a single pulse was presented on each trial. Keeping IPG constant at 8 micros and adding an extra biphasic pulse x ms into each period produced thresholds that were roughly independent of x, indicating that the effect of IPG in the other conditions was not due to a release from refractoriness at sites central to the auditory nerve. Experiment 3 measured thresholds at three IPGs, which were less than, equal to, and more than one half of the interval between successive pulses. Thresholds were lowest at the intermediate IPG. The results of all experiments could be fit by a linear model consisting of a lowpass filter based on the function relating threshold to the frequency of sinusoidal electrical stimulation. The data and model have implications for reducing the power consumption of cochlear implants.

Auditory detection and discrimination in deaf cats: psychophysical and neural thresholds for intracochlear electrical signals

More than 30,000 hearing-impaired human subjects have learned to use cochlear implants for speech perception and speech discrimination. To understand the basic mechanisms underlying the successful application of contemporary speech processing strategies, it is important to investigate how complex electrical stimuli delivered to the cochlea are processed and represented in the central auditory system. A deaf animal model has been developed that allows direct comparison of psychophysical thresholds with central auditory neuronal thresholds to temporally modulated intracochlear electrical signals in the same animals. Behavioral detection thresholds were estimated in neonatally deafened cats for unmodulated pulse trains (e.g., 30 pulses/s or pps) and sinusoidal amplitude-modulated (SAM) pulse trains (e.g., 300 pps, SAM at 30 Hz; 300/30 AM). Animals were trained subsequently in a discrimination task to respond to changes in the modulation frequency of successive SAM signals (e.g., 300/8 AM vs. 300/30 AM). During acute physiological experiments, neural thresholds to pulse trains were estimated in the inferior colliculus (IC) and the primary auditory cortex (A1) of the anesthetized animals. Psychophysical detection thresholds for unmodulated and SAM pulse trains were virtually identical. Single IC neuron thresholds for SAM pulse trains showed a small but significant increase in threshold (0.4 dB or 15.5 microA) when compared with thresholds for unmodulated pulse trains. The mean difference between psychophysical and minimum neural thresholds within animals was not significant (mean = 0.3 dB). Importantly, cats also successfully discriminated changes in the modulation frequencies of the SAM signals. Performance on the discrimination task was not affected by carrier rate (100, 300, 500, 1,000, or 1,500 pps). These findings indicate that 1) behavioral and neural response thresholds are based on detection of the peak pulse amplitudes of the modulated and unmodulated signals, and 2) discrimination of successive SAM pulse trains is based on temporal resolution of the envelope frequencies. Overall, our animal model provides a robust framework for future studies of behavioral discrimination and central neural temporal processing of electrical signals applied to the deaf cochlea by a cochlear implant.

Different clinical characteristics of aminoglycoside-induced profound deafness with and without the 1555 A-->G mitochondrial mutation

Recent genetic studies have shown that hereditary susceptibility to aminoglycoside antibiotics is caused by the 1555 A-->G mitochondrial mutation. We found the 1555 mutation in 4 out of 68 postlingual deaf patients who were candidates for cochlear implantation. All 4 patients developed bilateral profound hearing loss following administration of aminoglycosides. The pedigree of the family shows exclusively maternal transmission of hearing impairment in each case. On comparison with neuro-otological findings from aminoglycoside-induced deaf patients without the 1555 mutation, four distinct characteristics were noted: (1) a progressive nature of hearing loss; (2) better residual pure-tone thresholds; (3) lower thresholds for electrical promontory stimulation, and (4) well-preserved vestibular function. Although other factors such as differing dosages and/or administration routes may also be involved, profound hearing loss associated with the 1555 mutation may be due to a different pathogenic mechanism, i.e., strial dysfunction rather than a direct insult to the hair cells.

Investigating perceptual features of electrode stimulation via a multidimensional scaling paradigm

To achieve the most effective speech processing for individuals with cochlear implants, it is important to understand the perceptual features associated with the stimulation parameters. In general, when electrodes are stimulated in order from apex to base, the pitch of the perceived sound changes in an orderly fashion from low to high. Some deviations from this assumed order have been documented. Also, pitch is the dominant perceptual attribute of a sound when the stimuli associated with different electrodes have been accurately loudness balanced. In this study, the results of a multidimensional scaling (MDS) paradigm were compared to the results of a pitch-ranking procedure for six subjects implanted with multichannel cochlear prostheses. Results indicate that there may be multiple percepts that change with electrode location. Not surprisingly, the dominant percept is strongly correlated with pitch. The results also indicate that the structure of the second percept is consistent across subjects, although not interpretable using the data measured in this study. Furthermore, results indicate that MDS data can be used to pinpoint indiscriminable electrodes more accurately than pitch data. The results of this study may have importance for the design of the next generation of speech processors.

Responses of inferior colliculus neurons to amplitude-modulated intracochlear electrical pulses in deaf cats

Current cochlear prostheses use amplitude-modulated pulse trains to encode acoustic signals. In this study we examined the responses of inferior colliculus (IC) neurons to sinusoidal amplitude-modulated pulses and compared the maximum unmodulated pulse rate (Fmax) to which they responded with the maximum modulation frequency (maxFm) that they followed. Consistent with previous results, responses to unmodulated pulses were all low-pass functions of pulse rate. Mean Fmax to unmodulated pulses was 104 pulses per second (pps) and modal Fmax was 60 pps. Above Fmax IC neurons ceased responding except for an onset burst at the beginning of the stimulus. However, IC neurons responded to much higher pulse rates when these pulses were amplitude modulated; 74% were relatively insensitive to carrier rate and responded to all modulated carriers including those exceeding 600 pps. In contrast, the responses of these neurons (70%) were low-pass functions of modulation frequency, and the remaining (30%) had band-pass functions with a maxFm of 42 and 34 Hz, respectively. Thus temporal resolution of IC neurons for modulated frequencies is significantly lower than that for unmodulated pulses. These two measures of temporal resolution (Fmax and maxFm) were uncorrelated (r(2) = 0.101). Several parameters influenced the amplitude and temporal structure of modulation responses including modulation depth, overall intensity and modulation-to-carrier rate ratio. We observed distortions in unit responses to amplitude-modulated signals when this ratio was 1/4 to 1/6. Since most current cochlear implant speech processors permit ratios that are significantly greater than this, severe distortion and signal degradation may occur frequently in these devices.

Electrical cochlear stimulation in the deaf cat: comparisons between psychophysical and central auditory neuronal thresholds

Cochlear prostheses for electrical stimulation of the auditory nerve ("electrical hearing") can provide auditory capacity for profoundly deaf adults and children, including in many cases a restored ability to perceive speech without visual cues. A fundamental challenge in auditory neuroscience is to understand the neural and perceptual mechanisms that make rehabilitation of hearing possible in these deaf humans. We have developed a feline behavioral model that allows us to study behavioral and physiological variables in the same deaf animals. Cats deafened by injection of ototoxic antibiotics were implanted with either a monopolar round window electrode or a multichannel scala tympani electrode array. To evaluate the effects of perceptually significant electrical stimulation of the auditory nerve on the central auditory system, an animal was trained to avoid a mild electrocutaneous shock when biphasic current pulses (0.2 ms/phase) were delivered to its implanted cochlea. Psychophysical detection thresholds and electrical auditory brain stem response (EABR) thresholds were estimated in each cat. At the conclusion of behavioral testing, acute physiological experiments were conducted, and threshold responses were recorded for single neurons and multineuronal clusters in the central nucleus of the inferior colliculus (ICC) and the primary auditory cortex (A1). Behavioral and neurophysiological thresholds were evaluated with reference to cochlear histopathology in the same deaf cats. The results of the present study include: 1) in the cats implanted with a scala tympani electrode array, the lowest ICC and A1 neural thresholds were virtually identical to the behavioral thresholds for intracochlear bipolar stimulation; 2) behavioral thresholds were lower than ICC and A1 neural thresholds in each of the cats implanted with a monopolar round window electrode; 3) EABR thresholds were higher than behavioral thresholds in all of the cats (mean difference = 6.5 dB); and 4) the cumulative number of action potentials for a sample of ICC neurons increased monotonically as a function of the amplitude and the number of stimulating biphasic pulses. This physiological result suggests that the output from the ICC may be integrated spatially across neurons and temporally integrated across pulses when the auditory nerve array is stimulated with a train of biphasic current pulses. Because behavioral thresholds were lower and reaction times were faster at a pulse rate of 30 pps compared with a pulse rate of 2 pps, spatial-temporal integration in the central auditory system was presumably reflected in psychophysical performance.

Behavioral and neurophysiological thresholds for electrical cochlear stimulation in the deaf cat

Psychophysical detection thresholds for unmodulated electrical pulse trains or for sinusoidally amplitude-modulated (SAM) pulse trains were estimated in deaf juvenile cats using a conditioned avoidance paradigm. Biphasic current pulses (0.2 ms/phase) were delivered by scala tympani electrodes consisting of 4-8 electrode contacts driven as bipolar pairs. Electrical auditory brainstem response (EABR) thresholds were obtained periodically, and at the conclusion of behavioral training, response thresholds were obtained for neurons in the inferior colliculus (IC) and the primary auditory cortex (A1) in acute physiological experiments in the same animals. The results of the study include: (1) detection thresholds for unmodulated pulse trains and for SAM pulse trains were virtually identical; (2) EABR thresholds and behavioral thresholds were significantly correlated, although EABR thresholds consistently overestimated behavioral thresholds; (3) the lowest thresholds in the IC and the A1 were significantly correlated with behavioral thresholds, and (4) mean lowest thresholds in the IC and the A1 were essentially the same as the mean psychophysical detection threshold in the trained deaf cats.

The effects of stochastic neural activity in a model predicting intensity perception with cochlear implants: low-rate stimulation

Most models of auditory nerve response to electrical stimulation are deterministic, despite significant physiological evidence for stochastic activity. Furthermore, psychophysical models and analyses of physiological data using deterministic descriptions do not accurately predict many psychophysical phenomena. In this paper we investigate whether inclusion of stochastic activity in neural models improves such predictions. To avoid the complication of interpulse interactions and to enable the use of a simpler and faster auditory nerve model we restrict our investigation to single pulses and low-rate (< 200 pulses/s) pulse trains. We apply signal detection theory to produce direct predictions of behavioral threshold, dynamic range and intensity difference limen. Specifically, we investigate threshold versus pulse duration (the strength-duration characteristics), threshold and uncomfortable loudness (and the corresponding dynamic range) versus phase duration, the effects of electrode configuration on dynamic range and on strength-duration, threshold versus number of pulses (the temporal-integration characteristics), intensity difference limen as a function of loudness, and the effects of neural survival on these measures. For all psychophysical measures investigated, the inclusion of stochastic activity in the auditory nerve model was found to produce more accurate predictions.

Across-species comparisons of psychophysical detection thresholds for electrical stimulation of the cochlea: II. Strength-duration functions for single, biphasic pulses

This paper compares psychophysical detection threshold data (new and previously published) for pulsatile electrical stimulation of the deafened inner ear, obtained from different human and nonhuman subjects. Subjects were grouped according to species. Other variables, however, such as the electrode array type and method of deafening, varied within and across species. Detection threshold levels and slopes of threshold versus phase duration functions for presentations of single, biphasic pulsatile stimuli (strength-duration functions) were compared for humans, macaques, cats, and guinea pigs. For bipolar stimulation, statistically significant differences in threshold level were observed between human subjects and all other species. The species difference did not depend on the phase duration tested. For monopolar stimulation, only nonhuman species were tested. Effects of electrode configuration on both the level and slope of psychophysical strength-duration functions were statistically significant across nonhuman species, but there was not a statistically significant interaction between species and electrode configuration. The similarity in function shape and relative paucity of significant differences in psychophysical functions across species support the continued use of multiple species for cochlear implant research.

Across-species comparisons of psychophysical detection thresholds for electrical stimulation of the cochlea: I. Sinusoidal stimuli

Several species have been, and continue to be, used as subjects in studies of electrical stimulation of the cochlea. Few attempts, however, have been made to determine if data obtained from different species are quantitatively or qualitatively similar. The present work compares psychophysical absolute detection threshold vs. frequency functions for sinusoidal stimuli obtained from humans, nonhuman primates, cats, and guinea pigs. Threshold data for monopolar and bipolar electrode configurations from both previously published and unpublished studies are compared. In general, within all four species, significant intersubject variation in detection threshold level was found, but slopes of threshold vs. frequency functions were relatively well conserved within a species, under the conditions studied. With one exception (cat bipolar stimulation), threshold functions reached a minimum at or near 100 Hz across species and electrode configurations. In all cases, thresholds were significantly lower for monopolar, as compared with bipolar, configurations. Statistically, there were no significant differences in absolute threshold level across species. Threshold levels increased with frequency above 100 Hz at a rate of 3.0-7.9 dB/octave, depending on both electrode configuration and species. Slopes were steeper for monopolar than for bipolar configurations. When slopes were averaged between 200 and 2000 Hz, no statistically significant differences in overall slopes were found, nor was there a significant interaction between electrode configuration and species. There were, however, consistent species differences within more restricted regions of the function. Human functions for both monopolar and bipolar stimulation were steeper than all animal functions in the range of 100-300 Hz. Within this range, the differences between slopes for human and nonhuman subjects were statistically significant. In addition, differences were noted in the frequency at which slope decreased, with slopes for nonhuman subjects showing the decrease at higher frequencies than did those for human subjects. These differences may be true species differences, or may reflect the influence of confounding variables associated with each experimental-subject model.

Single unit activity in the inferior colliculus of the rat elicited by electrical stimulation of the cochlea

The activity of single neurons (n = 182) of the central nucleus of the inferior colliculus (CIC) of the rat was recorded in response to unilateral electrical stimulation of the left cochlea and/or acoustical stimulation of the right ear. The probability of response to both modes of stimulation was comparable (90 per cent for contralateral and 60 per cent for ipsilateral presentation). Response patterns consisted predominantly of onset excitations. Response latencies to electrical stimuli ranged from 3 to 21 ms, with an average value of 9.7 ms (SD = 3.5 ms) in the ipsilateral CIC and 6.6 ms (SD = 3.4 ms) in the contralateral CIC. With respect to binaural inputs, the majority of units were excited by stimulation of either ear (EE; about 60 per cent) while about one third were influenced by one ear only (EO). Units excited by one ear and inhibited by the other (EI) were rare. The main difference between the present implanted rats and normal animals was the virtual absence here of inhibitory effects for both types of stimuli when they were delivered to the ipsilateral ear (very few EI units).

Behavioral and electrophysiological responses to electrical stimulation in the cat. I. Absolute thresholds

Estimates of electrical auditory brainstem response (EABR) thresholds are compared with behavioral thresholds for electrical stimulation in the same subject using identical stimuli and electrode configurations. Four cats were behaviorally trained to measure acoustic auditory thresholds using food as a reward in an operant reinforcement paradigm. One of the animals was then implanted, in an otherwise normal ear, with a scaled-UCSF multi-contact electrode array containing four intracochlear electrodes. Three animals were implanted with an electrode array containing eight intracochlear contacts and one extracochlear contact under the temporalis muscle following unilateral cochlear perfusion with 10% neomycin solution. Stimuli for the behavioral studies were single presentations of 200 us/phase biphasic current pulses. For the EABR studies, the same stimulus was presented at a rate of 32/s. In general, for the animal with the four-contact array and two of the three subjects with the eight-contact implant, changes in electrode configuration produced well-differentiated changes in threshold. For these three subjects, comparisons of behavioral and EABR thresholds for the majority of monopolar and bipolar electrode configurations tested showed excellent agreement (r2 = 0.88). Correlations between behavioral and EABR measures in these animals were comparable for bipolar and monopolar arrangements (r2 = 0.88 for bipolar and 0.87 for monopolar). For one subject with the eight-contact electrode, who showed similar monopolar and bipolar electrode behavioral thresholds for all tested electrode spacings or configurations, most EABR thresholds were substantially higher than, and poorly correlated with, behavioral thresholds (r2 = 0.15; r2 = 0.28 for monopolar arrangements, and r2 = 0.12 for bipolar arrangements).

Adaptation in the compound action potential response of the guinea pig VIIIth nerve to electric stimulation

An experimental study, carried out in guinea pigs, was designed to investigate whether forward masking measured psychophysically in 3M-House cochlear implant users might have a correlate in VIIIth nerve activity. The study was based on electrically evoked VIIIth nerve compound action potentials (ECAPs), using a masking paradigm comparable to the one used in the psychophysical study. Trains of 50 maskers with inter-masker-intervals of 509 ms appeared to induce a long-term fatigue effect that could influence the recovery from adaptation measurements. Fatigue stabilized within about 1 to 3 min when masker trains were repeated with intervening silent intervals of 10.5 s. The change in amplitude of probe-evoked ECAPs with increasing masker-probe delays was determined within the steady fatigue state. The recovery-from-adaptation functions obtained from these measurements resembled the forward masking functions found in 3M-House cochlear implant users. No correlate of psychophysical backward masking was found at the VIIIth nerve level. To examine whether hair cells were involved in fatigue and recovery from adaptation, the measurements described above were carried out in intact cochleas and in cochleas without hair cells. Results were essentially the same in the different preparations. The results suggest that processes at the level of the VIIIth nerve could, at least partly, account for forward masking found in 3M-House cochlear implant users. Backward masking must be attributed to mechanisms located centrally to the VIIIth nerve.

Discharge pattern in the auditory nerve evoked by vowel stimuli: a comparison between acoustical and electrical stimulation

Single channel cochlear implants only transmit the time structure of the electrically coded input signal. All nerve fibres show similar thresholds for monopolar round window stimulation, i.e., activation does not depend on their site of origin. To investigate the fine structure of the firing pattern elicited by stimulation with an analogue coded speech processing system (VIENNA 1-channel implant), cats were electrically stimulated with German steady-state vowels at the round window. Single fibre activity was recorded from primary auditory fibres and period histograms were calculated. The electrically evoked impulse patterns were compared with those from acoustic stimulation with the same vowels. With acoustic stimulation, the response of a fibre depends on the individual characteristic frequency (CF) with regard to the fundamental F0 and the formants F1, F2 and F3 of the vowels, the spontaneous activity of the fibre and the sound level. The evoked firing pattern was used to calculate period histograms, the frequency content of which was analysed by Fourier transformation. With electrical stimulation in the threshold range, an action potential is strongly synchronized to a cathodic peak of the current within one period of F0. With increasing current level 3-5 impulses can be locked to the same period. The timing of the short intervals is determined by the relative refractory period and current peaks (negative or positive) caused by the dominant higher formant F2 or F3. The acoustically evoked patterns are specific for the CF of the neuron and represent the spectral information of the different vowels.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Middle latency responses to electrical stimulation of the auditory nerve in unanaesthetized guinea pigs

Middle latency responses (MLR) to sinusoidal and pulsatile electrical stimulation (ES) of the cochlea and to acoustical stimulation (AS) were evaluated in awake guinea pigs with chronically implanted electrodes. The ear, which was later electrically stimulated, was deafened by local intracochlear application of gentamicin, the opposite ear was left intact. Waveforms and P1-P2 interpeak intervals of the electrically evoked MLR (ES-MLR) were similar to those evoked by acoustical stimulation of the intact ear (AS-MLR) and the latencies of the ES-MLR were shorter by about 1-3 ms. Thresholds of ES-MLR in the frequency range 0.5-32 kHz increased with increasing ES frequency (slope 3.2 dB/octave), thresholds were 3.5-9.5 dB lower for intracochlear than for extracochlear ES. Dynamic ranges for ES-MLR varied between 6-20 dB. MLR amplitude-intensity functions for ES were steeper (slope 2-12 microV/dB) than those for AS (slope 0.2-2 microV/dB). Maximal ES-MLR amplitudes exceeded usually 1.5-3 times the amplitudes of the acoustically evoked MLR. Both types of stimulations evoked larger MLR amplitudes to contralateral stimulation than to ipsilateral stimulation (average ratio = 4.1 +/- 2.2 for AS and 3.3 +/- 2.2 for ES). Because of the relatively long latency and therefore insensitivity to electrical artifact, the ES-MLR can be used for the evaluation of different strategies of the electrical stimulation of the cochlea in awake guinea pig.

Effects of phase duration on detection of electrical stimulation of the human cochlea

Detection thresholds for biphasic symmetric pulses were measured in fourteen human subjects implanted with the Cochlear Corporation Nucleus 22 Implant. The effects of phase duration on thresholds were studied using single pulses, and 500 ms pulse trains at 100 pps. Psychophysical detection thresholds decreased as a function of phase duration with a change in slope at approximately 0.5 ms/phase. Mean single-pulse and pulse-train slopes were -3.60 and -4.25 dB/doubling of phase duration for pulse durations of less than about 0.5 ms/phase. For pulse durations greater than 0.5 ms/phase, mean slopes were -5.71 and -7.54 dB/doubling for single pulses and pulse trains, respectively. Thresholds for pulse trains decreased as a function of stimulus duration for durations up to at least 300 ms, with the rate of decrease being dependent on the phase duration of the pulse. Effects of stimulus duration were greater for longer phase duration signals. We hypothesize that the longer phase duration pulses activate multiple spikes in a single fiber and/or more effective patterns of spikes across fibers, which may explain why slopes of psychophysical threshold functions are steeper than those of functions for single auditory nerve fibers for longer duration pulses. Thresholds were compared to respective speech perception scores (CID sentences) since thresholds for long phase duration signals have been shown previously to be correlated with nerve survival patterns, and nerve survival patterns may affect speech perception. Correlation coefficients ranged from -0.59 to -0.81, depending on stimulus parameters and subject selection.

Psychophysical studies using a multiple-electrode cochlear implant in patients who were deafened early in life

Psychophysical studies were conducted on 10 cochlear implant patients, between 5 and 23 years of age at the time of surgery, who were deafened prior to 4 years of age. The multiple-electrode prosthesis manufactured by Cochlear Ltd. was used. Identification studies, the recognition of 2-4 stimuli after some training, were conducted on 3 of the 10 patients. For current level and repetition rate identification, performance was comparable to that observed for postlingual adult patients. For electrode position identification, however, performance was much poorer than that observed for postlingual adults. In general, the difference limens for current level, repetition rate and duration, and the gap detection thresholds were similar to those observed for postlingual adults. For 3 patients whose etiology was Usher's syndrome, the repetition rate limens at higher rates were larger than those of the other patients. The limens for electrode position, measured in a discrimination task, were 1-3 electrodes for most patients. However, for 3 patients, limens of 6-10 electrodes were recorded. For numerosity judgements, the counting of stimuli in a temporal series as a function of the rate of presentation, the patients were less successful at counting for rates of 3-8/s than for lower rates (1-2/s).

Effects of preoperative electrical stimulability and historical factors on performance with multichannel cochlear implant

We investigated the relationship between results of preoperative transtympanic electrical promontory stimulation, duration of deafness, postoperative implanted psychophysical results, and postoperative speech and speech sound recognition as indicated by a battery of five tests. Our subjects were 10 patients implanted with the Cochlear Corporation multielectrode implant, 1 year postimplantation, with a minimum of 17 active electrodes programmed in the bipolar + 1 mode. The results indicated that preoperative promontory thresholds, the slope of the threshold function, and the duration of auditory deprivation are excellent predictors of postoperative speech and speech sound recognition in the auditory (processor alone) mode. These results have significant implications for patient selection and counseling.

Changes over time in thresholds for electrical stimulation of the cochlea

The purpose of this paper is to better characterize changes over time that occurred in psychophysical detection thresholds for electrical stimulation of the cochlea. Threshold changes observed in nonhuman primates implanted with cochlear electrode arrays can be divided into at least three types based on the patterns of change over time. Short-term increases and subsequent decreases in threshold were commonly observed during the first months after implantation and were often followed by periods of long-term threshold stability. Long-term slow increases in thresholds and more rapid increases after a period of threshold stability have also been observed. The threshold changes may be divided into at least two classes based on their dependence on the waveforms used for the threshold measurements. Some changes occurred primarily in thresholds for long phase-duration signals while other changes were equal in magnitude (in decibels) for all tested stimuli. This suggests that at least two mechanisms underlay these threshold changes. The observed changes in thresholds have implications for experimental studies of electrical stimulation and for clinical application of auditory prostheses.

Effects of level on nonspectral frequency difference limens for electrical and acoustic stimuli

The purpose of this experiment was to study the effects of stimulus level on discrimination of frequency as represented in the temporal waveforms of acoustic and electrical signals. The subjects were four nonhuman primates in which one ear had been deafened and implanted with an electrode array and the other ear was untreated. Frequency difference limens for 100 Hz electrical sinusoidal stimulation via a cochlear implant in the deafened ear were compared to those for 100 Hz sinusoidally amplitude-modulated white noise (SAM noise) acoustic stimuli to the normal-hearing contralateral ear. To correct for loudness cues, levels of the test stimuli were varied relative to the reference-stimulus level. The test-stimulus levels at which the percent responses were minimum were determined. These levels were used to measure the frequency difference limens. Frequency difference limens for the electrical stimuli decreased as a function of reference-stimulus level through most of the dynamic range, while those for the acoustic stimuli reached a minimum at 20 dB to 40 dB above threshold. For the electrical stimuli the slopes and relative positions of the frequency difference limen vs. level functions varied from subject to subject, and with changes in electrode configuration within a subject. These differences were related to threshold level and dynamic range. At higher levels of stimulation, frequency difference limens for acoustic and electrical stimuli fell in the same range. The slopes and relative positions of the frequency difference limen vs. level functions for electrical stimuli did not parallel those of level difference limen vs. level functions collected simultaneously from the same ears. The data suggest that nonspectral frequency discrimination may depend on the number of nerve fibers stimulated. With prostheses in cochleas with less than a full complement of auditory nerve fibers, the data suggest that stimulation level is an important variable influencing discriminability.