Assessment of "silent" restenosis and long-term follow-up after successful angioplasty in single vessel coronary artery disease: the value of quantitative exercise electrocardiography and quantitative coronary angiography

A comparative study of restenosis rates in bare metal and drug-eluting stents

BACKGROUND

Various studies have been performed throughout the world on the rate of restenosis using bare metal stents (BMS) and drug-eluting stents (DES). The prohibitive costs associated with DES generally dictate the type of stent used, especially in developing countries. Therefore, there was a need for a study to assess the effect of various risk factors on restenosis in BMS and DES in the Indian context. A study was performed in the premier institution of the Indian Armed Forces, the Army Hospital (Research and Referral), New Delhi, India, under the aegis of the Indian Council of Medical Research (New Delhi). The profile of patients in the armed forces is inherently diverse in terms of demography, ethnicity, genetics, etc, which reflects the diverse and varied nature of the population in India.

METHODS AND RESULTS

A total of 130 patients were included in the present study. Follow-up after stent implantation was scheduled for six to nine months following the procedure to assess symptoms, drug compliance, and treadmill test and coronary angiography results, and to ascertain the incidence of restenosis. However, only 80 patients returned for follow-up and, therefore, the final analysis was based on these patients. They were segregated into BMS (n=41) and DES (n=39) groups. Restenosis occurred in 29 patients (36.3%). Nine of 39 patients with DES (23.1%) and 20 of 41 patients with BMS (48.8%) developed restenosis. There was a statistically significant relationship between restenosis and female sex, clinical presentation before intervention and at the time of follow-up evaluation (unstable angina), hypertension, positive stress test and compliance with medical therapy (P<0.05). No statistically significant relationship was observed between restenosis and age, diabetes, smoking, obesity and diet (P>0.05).

CONCLUSIONS

DES appear to reduce the restenosis rate and clinical end points, and appear to be more cost effective than BMS. Patient-related factors (eg, sex, hypertension and unstable angina) are important variables that affect the restenosis rate. Noninvasive stress testing had high positive and negative predictive values. Therefore, based on the present study, noninvasive stress testing is suggested before routine angiography at follow-up, which will reduce the need for repeat coronary angiography.

Right-sided chest leads in exercise testing for detection of coronary restenosis

BACKGROUND

The incorporation of right-sided chest leads (V(3)R through V(5)R) into standard exercise testing has been reported to improve its diagnostic utility.

HYPOTHESIS

The purpose of this study was to evaluate any improvement in the ability of exercise testing in detecting restenosis, using additional V(3)R through V(5)R leads, in asymptomatic patients undergoing percutaneous coronary intervention (PCI) in the right coronary artery (RCA) or/and left circumflex (LCX).

METHODS

We studied 172 consecutive patients (54 +/- 7 years old, 106 males) undergoing PCI in RCA or/and LCX. A treadmill test had been performed before PCI. Six months later, all patients underwent a second treadmill test and arteriography in order to detect silent ischemia due to restenosis. Recordings during exercise were obtained with the standard 12-leads plus V(3)R through V(5)R.

RESULTS

Out of 172 patients, 106 had stenosis in RCA, 35 in LCX, and 31 in both vessels while 6 months later, restenosis was detected in 8 (for RCA), 3 (for LCX), and 3 (for both vessels) patients respectively. Sensitivity, specificity, positive prognostic value, negative prognostic value, and accuracy of exercise testing performed post PCI were ameliorated using V(3)R through V(5)R (79% vs 57%, 97% vs 80%, 69% vs 21%, 98% vs 95%, and 95% vs 78% respectively, P < .05 for all except negative prognostic value). Maximal exercise-induced ST-segment deviation (in mm) was not changed post PCI in 12 leads (1.4 +/- 0.2 vs 1.5 +/- 0.2, P = NS) while it was decreased in V(3)R through V(5)R (0.2 +/- 0.2 vs 1.2 +/- 0.3, P < .01).

CONCLUSIONS

The addition of V(3)R through V(5)R improves the diagnostic ability of standard exercise testing in detecting silent ischemia due to restenosis in patients undergoing PCI in RCA or/and LCX.

[Restenosis estimation at the clinical level: methodologic and angiographic aspects]

Quantitative coronary angiography is the most objective and reproducible method for estimating restenosis after coronary angioplasty. Unfortunately, it does not strictly reflect the clinical restenosis. Numerous angiographic criteria have been defined, from the binary restenosis (>50% stenosis at the site dilated) routinely used by the clinician, to more sophisticated quantitative criteria in order to quantify the intimal hyperplasia, more objective but requiring rigorous criteria. However, new quantitative coronary analysis softwares have not been developed during the last years and each team had to evaluate its intra and inter observer variability. However, angiographic method is still the gold standard method for restenosis estimation, the ideal would be to defined an angiographic restenosis clinically consistent and well correlated with major cardiovascular events.

A QRS score versus ST-segment changes during exercise testing: which is the most reliable ischaemic marker after myocardial revascularisation?

BACKGROUND

The diagnostic ability of exercise testing based on ST-segment changes is low for the detection of restenosis after percutaneous transluminal coronary angioplasty (PTCA) or ischaemia after bypass surgery (CABG). The aim of this study was to improve the diagnostic accuracy of exercise testing in patients with a history of PTCA or CABG, with the implementation of a QRS score.

METHODS

We studied 128 post-PTCA patients (aged 49 +/- 8 years) and 104 post-CABG patients (aged 54 +/- 8 years), who had either positive exercise tests with or without angina, or negative exercise tests with continuing angina-like symptoms, and underwent cardiac catheterisation.

RESULTS

The univariate risk ratio of exercise-induced ST-segment deviation to detect restenosis was 3.05 (p = 0.005) and 0.83 (p = 0.690) in group A and group B patients, respectively. The univariate risk ratios of abnormal QRS score values to detect restenosis were 32.1 (p < 0.001) and 18.8 (p < 0.001) for group A and group B patients, respectively. The univariate risk ratios of the combination of exercise-induced ST-segment changes and of abnormal QRS score values to detect restenosis was 9.43 (p < 0.001) and 3.77 (p < 0.044) for group A and group B patients, respectively. The value of the area under the ROC curves is higher for the QRS score in group A patients, group B patients and for the whole study population.

CONCLUSIONS

QRS score values significantly improve the diagnostic ability of ST-segment change-based exercise testing, for the assessment of restenosis after PTCA or ischaemia after CABG.

Exercise stress testing, myocardial perfusion imaging and stress echocardiography for detecting restenosis after successful percutaneous transluminal coronary angioplasty: a review of performance

When chest symptoms recur in a patient who underwent percutaneous transluminal coronary angioplasty (PTCA), it is necessary to rule out restenosis (R). Three main noninvasive tests suggest the presence of R: exercise stress test (XT), myocardial perfusion imaging (MPI) and stress echocardiography (s-echo). The objectives of this review were: (1) to estimate the pretest probability of R as a function of time after PTCA in symptomatic patients and (2) to obtain an approximation of the diagnostic parameters of the XT, MPI and s-echo for detecting R. A MEDLINE search (English-language, years: 1980-2001) was conducted to identify studies examining post-PTCA functional testing for diagnosing R. Data from the studies were pooled. Comparing studies was often difficult due to varying methodology in the studies. Pretest probability of R in symptomatic patients increases in a nonlinear fashion from 20% or less at 1 month, to nearly 90% at 1-year postangioplasty. The approximated accuracy of the XT, MPI, and s-echo for detecting R was 62, 82 and 84%, respectively. During the first month after PTCA, none of the noninvasive modalities is able to accurately detect R. Late (7-9 months) after PTCA, the pretest probability of R is high and therefore the noninvasive measure may be spared. Our analysis suggests that MPI and s-echo should be preferred over the XT for diagnosing R.

Value of coronary stenotic flow velocity acceleration on the prediction of long-term improvement in functional status after angioplasty

BACKGROUND

The coronary flow velocity acceleration at the stenotic site (SVA), defined as a > or = 50% increase in resting stenotic velocity when compared with the reference segment, has been shown to be highly sensitive and specific for the diagnosis of a hemodynamically significant stenosis. In this study, we describe the value of postprocedural SVA for the prediction of a lack of improvement in functional activity at long-term follow-up balloon angioplasty (BA).

METHODS

We investigated the improvement in functional activity in patients undergoing single native vessel angioplasty and intracoronary Doppler (before BA, after BA, and again at 6-month follow-up) as part of the Doppler Endpoints Balloon Angioplasty Trial Europe (DEBATE) I trial. Lack of improvement was defined as no change in Duke Activity Status Index (DASI) at 6-month follow-up, whereas SVA was defined as > or = 50% elevation in resting velocity at the treated area compared with the distal measurement.

RESULTS

SVA was found more frequently in patients without improvement in DASI (45% vs 31%, P =.03). Similar percent diameter stenosis and coronary flow velocity reserve were observed in patients with and those without improvement in DASI at follow-up. By multivariate regression analysis, the presence of SVA (P = .029; odds ratio, 1.97; 95% confidence interval, 1.07 to 3.63) and an elevated DASI at baseline (P < .001; odds ratio, 1.05; 95% confidence interval, 1.03 to 1.07) were associated with a lack of improvement at follow-up.

CONCLUSIONS

The detection of SVA was associated with failure of improvement in functional activity at follow-up after coronary intervention.

Detection of coronary restenosis by exercise electrocardiography thallium-201 perfusion imaging and coronary angiography in asymptomatic patients after percutaneous transluminal coronary angioplasty

Noninvasive detection of restenosis in patients remaining asymptomatic after percutaneous transluminal coronary angioplasty (PTCA) remains a major clinical problem. The value of exercise electrocardiography (ECG) and exercise-redistribution thallium-201 single-photon emission computed tomography (SPECT) in detecting restenosis in such patients remains uncertain. Discordances between these tests and coronary angiography is a common situation. We studied 179 consecutive patients remaining asymptomatic after successful PTCA (208 vessels), who underwent 6 +/- 2 months of exercise ECG, SPECT, and coronary angiography. We sought to assess the diagnostic value of the noninvasive tests compared with coronary angiography, and identify the determinants of discordances between the tests. Restenosis (diameter stenosis >50%) was detected in 39% of patients and in 37% of vessels. The overall sensitivity, specificity, and accuracy for exercise ECG and SPECT in detecting restenosis in individual vessels were, respectively, 53% versus 63% (p = 0.06), 59% versus 77% (p = 0.0001), and 57% versus 72% (p = 0. 0001). On multivariate analysis, positive exercise ECG was associated with higher heart rate response (p = 0.02), incomplete revascularization (p = 0.004), and angiographic restenosis (p = 0. 03), whereas positive SPECT was associated with incomplete revascularization (p = 0.02), infarct-related artery PTCA (p = 0.01), and angiographic restenosis (p = 0.0001). Accuracies of the 2 tests were not significantly different in patients with incomplete revascularization or PTCA of an infarct-related vessel. Overall, SPECT is more accurate than exercise ECG in detecting asymptomatic restenosis. Nevertheless, incomplete revascularization and PTCA of an infarct-related artery could cause reversible perfusion defects regardless of restenosis, reducing the diagnostic value of SPECT in such patients.

Use of QT dispersion measured on treadmill exercise electrocardiograms for detecting restenosis after percutaneous transluminal coronary angioplasty

BACKGROUND

Treadmill exercise electrocardiography (ECG) has been used to detect restenosis in patients following percutaneous transluminal coronary angioplasty (PTCA). However, the level of sensitivity achieved using conventional criteria of ST-segment depression is too low to be clinically useful in this population.

HYPOTHESIS

QT dispersion is a sensitive method for detecting myocardial ischemia and may improve the accuracy of treadmill exercise ECG testing for detecting restenosis after PTCA.

METHODS

We evaluated 104 patients who underwent PTCA for the treatment of single-vessel coronary artery disease and who had no history of myocardial infarction. Treadmill exercise ECG and coronary angiograms were performed 3 months after PTCA to determine the accuracy of diagnosis restenosis based on standard ST-segment depression and QT dispersion criteria.

RESULTS

Restenosis was observed in 37 of the 104 patients (36%) 3 months after PTCA. QT dispersion immediately after exercise was significantly greater in patients with than in those without restenosis, as was the difference in QT dispersion before and immediately after exercise. The sensitivity, specificity, and accuracy of ST-segment depression criteria were 59, 64, and 63%, respectively. Measurements of QT dispersion immediately after exercise (> or = 50 ms: positive, < 50 ms: negative) improved the sensitivity, specificity, and accuracy of treadmill ECG for predicting restenosis to 81, 87, and 85%, respectively.

CONCLUSIONS

This novel diagnostic method using QT dispersion-based criteria significantly improves the clinical usefulness of treadmill exercise ECG for detecting the presence of restenosis after PTCA.

Value of exercise electrocardiography in the detection of restenosis after coronary angioplasty in patients with one-vessel disease

Exercise treadmill testing (ETT) is considered an unreliable method for detection of restenosis after percutaneous transluminal coronary angioplasty (PTCA). The studies on which this belief is based have used quantitative coronary angiography (QCA) as a reference. The inherent limitations of angiography have been demonstrated by intravascular ultrasound (IVUS). To determine the value of ETT for detecting restenosis when IVUS criteria are used to define restenosis, we studied 29 patients with angiographically documented 1-vessel coronary disease (<35% stenosis in all nondilated segments) who underwent angioplasty. ETT was performed < or =2 weeks before follow-up angiography and IVUS imaging. Only patients without any abnormalities precluding an accurate reading of the ST segment during ETT were included. Restenosis was defined as a > or =50% diameter stenosis by QCA criteria and as a cross-sectional area narrowing of > or =75% by IVUS. The ETT was positive in 12 patients and restenosis was documented by QCA and IVUS in 38% and 48% of cases, respectively. Sensitivity, specificity, and positive and negative predictive values of ETT when QCA was used as a reference were 55%, 67%, 50%, and 71%, respectively. This corresponded to an accuracy of 62% when compared with QCA. Sensitivity, specificity, and positive and negative predictive values were 79%, 93%, 92%, and 82% when ETT was compared with IVUS, with an accuracy of 86% (p = 0.002). Thus, ETT is a reliable noninvasive method for detecting the presence of restenosis after PTCA in patients with 1-vessel coronary artery disease. The presence of > or =75% cross-sectional narrowing shown by IVUS is well correlated with > or =1-mm ST-segment depression at follow-up ETT after PTCA.

Reliability of the exercise-induced ST-segment changes to detect restenosis three months after coronary angioplasty: significance of the appearance in other leads

BACKGROUND

Exercise-induced ST-segment changes 3 months after angioplasty may sometimes show a false-positive result.

METHODS

We therefore analyzed the ST changes observed during the exercise tests performed before and 3 months after angioplasty in 118 patients with single-vessel coronary artery disease.

RESULTS

Ninety-two (78%) of the 118 patients had ST changes in the same lead before and after angioplasty, whereas the remaining 26 (22%) patients had ST changes in other leads in the postangioplasty test when compared with the preangioplasty exercise test. Restenosis was found in 44 (48%) of the 92 patients with ST changes in the some lead but in only four (15%) of the 26 patients with ST changes in other leads.

CONCLUSIONS

Exercise-induced ST-segment changes are not reliable markers of restenosis 3 months after angioplasty. ST-segment changes observed in other leads after angioplasty compared with the preangioplasty exercise test may show a false-positive result.

Reliability of exercise-induced ST segment changes to detect restenosis 3 months after coronary angioplasty: significance of the appearance in other leads

Exercise-induced ST-segment changes 3 months after angioplasty sometimes may show a false-positive result. We therefore analyzed the ST changes observed during the exercise tests performed before and 3 months after angioplasty in 118 patients with single-vessel coronary artery disease. Ninety-two (78%) of the 118 patients had ST changes in the same lead before and after angioplasty, whereas the remaining 26 (22%) patients had ST changes in other leads in the postangioplasty exercise test when compared with the preangioplasty test. Restenosis was found in 44 (48%) of the 92 patients with ST changes in the same lead but in only 4 (15%) of the 26 patients with ST changes in other leads. We conclude that exercise-induced ST segment changes are not reliable markers of restenosis 3 months after angioplasty. ST segment changes observed in other leads after angioplasty may show a false-positive result when compared with the preangioplasty exercise test.

Diagnostic value of exercise electrocardiography and angina after coronary artery stenting. Benestent Study Group

To determine whether metallic stent implantation within a coronary artery modifies the accuracy of angina or exercise test results in predicting stenosis, we studied 172 patients assigned to stent implantation and 153 patients assigned to balloon angioplasty enrolled in the Benestent trial comparing de novo stenting with conventional balloon angioplasty. Sensitivity and specificity curves were constructed for the prediction of percentage diameter stenosis and minimal lumen diameter. Receiver-operator curves were constructed for comparison of diagnostic accuracy. Identical exercise load and duration were achieved in the two groups, despite a better angiographic result in patients treated with a stent. Similarly, the diagnostic accuracy of clinical symptoms or exercise test results as a function of the angiographic results were similar in patients with and patients without a stent. The intersection points of the sensitivity and specificity curves for recurrent angina or ST-segment depression were 72% to 77%. The corresponding cut-off points for percentage diameter stenosis were, respectively, 52% and 50% for patients with and without a stent (1.35 and 1.50 mm for minimal lumen diameter). We conclude that the presence of an intracoronary stent does not affect the diagnostic accuracy of recurrent angina or exercise-induced ST depression in predicting residual stenosis. We also conclude that exercise tolerance is similar after balloon angioplasty, with or without stenting, despite a better angiographic outcome in the group receiving a stent, suggesting a minimal threshold beyond which the patient is no longer at risk for ischemia during exercise.

Strategy of diagnostic imaging before and after PTCA

It is now widely accepted that percutaneous transluminal coronary angioplasty (PTCA) is an effective nonsurgical technique for achieving coronary revascularization. Exercise electrocardiography remains the standard procedure for functional evaluation before, early, and late after angioplasty because of its availability, safety, and limited cost. The drawback of exercise testing is its low specificity and the fact that the attainment of diagnostically useful data requires a level of exercise that substantially increases myocardial oxygen demand. Exercise thallium imaging has been shown to be highly predictive of restenosis and adverse events after angioplasty, but it is possible that myocardial perfusion may not return to normal immediately after successful revascularization. Stress echocardiography has many practical advantages over scanning tests, as result of its lower cost, shorter imaging time, and the absence of radiation exposure. Dipyridamole echocardiography testing (DET) is an exercise-independent method of evaluating patients who have to undergo coronary angioplasty. Before PTCA, DET allows the clinician to localize the site and extent of myocardial ischemia anatomically. Early after a successful procedure, DET identifies a group at high risk for the late recurrence of symptoms. Late after PTCA, DET is more accurate than exercise electrocardiography in detecting restenosis or disease progression. In asymptomatic patients with exercise-induced ST depression, DET has the same good diagnostic accuracy as thallium scintigraphy. For these reasons, as well as because of its noninvasive nature and availability, DET should be considered an attractive option for the evaluation of patients after anatomically successful angioplasty.

The value of exercise electrocardiography testing in the identification of coronary restenosis: a probability analysis

We studied by means of probability analysis the role of exercise ECG in identifying coronary restenosis. A total of 213 patients were independently evaluated by clinical history, conventional assessment of the exercise ECG ('yes or no' statement), D score (a discriminant function derived from exercise ECG), and coronariography, 5.4 +/- 2.8 months after successful coronary angioplasty. The initial probability of restenosis (30%), that is, the prevalence of the condition, was radically changed by the result of clinical history (77% for patients with angina vs. 17% for those without angina). By contrast, ECG binary assessment, due to its low accuracy (70% vs 82% of clinical history, P < 0.005), was unable to significantly change the established probabilities after symptomatic evaluation. Finally, D score, which greatly enhanced specificity (92% vs. 76% of bivariate assessment, P < 0.0001), proved to be useful in changing the probability (from 32% to 76% or to 25%) of patients (n = 34) with a discordant result (no angina/positive exercise ECG). When this stepwise approach was tested in 46 new patients, predicted and observed probabilities were actually very similar. We conclude that exercise ECG has a very limited role in identifying coronary restenosis if positive responses are not adjusted with a weighted score which takes into account other exercise derived factors.

Limited value of exercise testing in the detection of silent restenosis after successful coronary angioplasty

We studied the diagnostic value of exercise electrocardiographic (ECG) testing in 191 patients who were completely asymptomatic 6 months after a successful percutaneous transluminal coronary angioplasty procedure. With > 70%- and > 50%-diameter stenosis at follow-up as restenosis criteria, the sensitivities of exercise ECG testing were 29% and 21%; the specificities 89% and 91%; the positive predictive values 20% and 52%; the negative predictive values 93% and 70%; the accuracies 83% and 68%; and the risk ratios 2.8 and 1.7, for prevalences of 9% and 33%, respectively. There were no significant differences in the diagnostic value of exercise ECG testing between men and women, patients receiving or not receiving beta-blocking agents, and the presence or absence of pathologic Q waves. Significant differences in systolic blood pressure and the rate-pressure product at peak exercise were found between patients with and without restenosis. For individual patients, however, no practical conclusions can be drawn from these values. In conclusion, the diagnostic value of exercise ECG testing for silent restenosis is low, and supplementation with other techniques seems to be warranted.

Prevention of restenosis after coronary balloon angioplasty: rationale and design of the Fluvastatin Angioplasty Restenosis (FLARE) Trial. The FLARE Study Group

Prevention of restenosis after successful percutaneous transluminal coronary balloon angioplasty (PTCA) continues to present the greatest therapeutic challenge in interventional cardiology. Experimental and pathological studies describe restenosis as no more than the biologic healing response to arterial injury. Studies of serial quantitative coronary angiography have demonstrated that this biologic process may be measured as the loss in minimal luminal diameter (MLD) from post-PTCA to follow-up angiography and that it is essentially ubiquitous and normally distributed. Thus, quantitative coronary angiography has become the gold standard for evaluation of the angiographic outcome of clinical trials of new agents and devices aimed at prevention of restenosis. The 3-hydroxy-3-methylglutaryl-coenzyme A (HMG-CoA) reductase inhibitors inhibit biosynthesis of mevalonate, a precursor of non-sterol compounds involved in cell proliferation, and thus may control the neointimal response, which forms the kernel of restenosis. Experimental evidence suggests that fluvastatin may exert a greater direct inhibitory effect on proliferating vascular myocytes than other HMG-CoA reductase inhibitors, independent of any lipid-lowering action. The Fluvastatin Angioplasty Restenosis (FLARE) Trial was conceived, in collaboration between the Thoraxcenter, Erasmus University, Rotterdam, The Netherlands, and Sandoz Pharma, to evaluate the ability of fluvastatin 40 mg twice daily to reduce restenosis after successful single-lesion PTCA. Treatment of suitable patients begins 2 weeks before PTCA and continues after successful PTCA (residual diameter stenosis < 50%, without major cardiac complications) to follow-up angiography at 26 +/- 2 weeks. Restenosis is measured by quantitative coronary angiography at a core laboratory as the loss in MLD from post-PTCA to follow-up angiography. It is calculated (90% power, alpha = 0.05) that 730 evaluable patients will be needed to test the hypothesis that fluvastatin will reduce the expected post-PTCA loss in MLD by 40%. Serial lipid analysis will be carried out at a central laboratory. Trial evaluation is focused on the primary endpoint (change in MLD) but includes primary clinical endpoints (death, myocardial infarction, or the need for coronary artery bypass graft surgery or reintervention up to 40 weeks after PTCA) as well as secondary and tertiary clinical, angiographic, and laboratory endpoints. According to this methodologic approach, the effect of fluvastatin in luminal renarrowing and clinical events after successful PTCA as well as possible associations of lipid parameters with restenosis can be comprehensively investigated.

Predictive factors of restenosis after multivessel percutaneous transluminal coronary angioplasty

To evaluate the rate and predictive factors of restenosis after multivessel percutaneous transluminal coronary angioplasty (PTCA), 122 consecutive patients with multivessel PTCA performed in the same setting were included in a prospective study. Systematic angiographic control at 6 months was performed in 112 patients (92%). Restenosis (increase > 20% and stenosis > 50%) was found in 62 patients (55%) and 82 of 254 segments (32%) were dilated. Statistical analysis identified the number of successfully dilated segments as the only predictor of restenosis by patient (2.4 +/- 0.7 vs 2.0 +/- 0.7; p < 0.03), and the greater degree of residual stenosis as the only predictor of restenosis by lesion (30 +/- 14% vs 23 +/- 12%; p < 0.005). Twenty-two of 62 restenosed patients (35%) were asymptomatic (group 1). Baseline clinical and angiographic characteristics of these patients were similar to those with symptomatic restenosis (n = 40; group 2) and without restenosis (n = 50; group 3). Repeat revascularization for restenosis was used only in symptomatic patients (re-PTCA in 36; bypass surgery in 4). After a mean follow-up of 75 +/- 24 months, clinical status, and rates of cardiac death and myocardial infarction were similar in the 3 groups. Medical care was similar in groups 1 and 3, and higher in group 2. However, the rate of repeat revascularization for progression of disease was similar in the 3 groups (29%). In conclusion, restenosis is a frequent event after multivessel PTCA and is strongly related to the number of successfully dilated segments.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Restenosis revisited: insights provided by quantitative coronary angiography

In this editorial, the problem of restenosis after coronary balloon angioplasty and other transluminal interventions is reviewed from the perspective of quantitative coronary angiography. The review is largely based on the experience of the Thoraxcentre in the application of quantitative angiography to the study of restenosis over the past decade, with incorporation and discussion of relevant and significant contributions from other groups. Current discrepancies in the angiographic definition of restenosis are highlighted and the use of percent diameter stenosis or MLD as the measurement parameter of choice is objectively addressed. Perspectives on the pathologic paradigm of restenosis are briefly reviewed as a basis from which to evaluate quantitative angiographic information provided by various studies. Particular attention is then paid, in chronologic fashion, to discussion and elaboration of insights to the restenosis process provided by quantitative angiographic studies, which have led to the introduction of some new methodological approaches to the comparison of short- and long-term angiographic luminal changes after various interventions. A word of caution on the potential pitfalls of quantitative angiographic studies is provided and counterbalanced with a discussion of clinical correlations of quantitative angiographic measurements. Finally, a proposal is made for the application of quantitative angiographic measurements to randomized clinical trials for the purpose of comparing new interventional devices.

Silent ischemia after percutaneous transluminal coronary angioplasty: incidence and prognostic significance

OBJECTIVES

The objective of this observational study was to assess the incidence and prognostic significance of silent ischemia after percutaneous transluminal coronary angioplasty.

BACKGROUND

Apart from coronary angioplasty, prognosis of patients with silent ischemia is similar to that of patients with angina pectoris. However, similar data concerning silent ischemia associated with restenosis after coronary angioplasty are missing.

METHODS

A consecutive series of 490 patients was investigated for asymptomatic ischemia on thallium-201 scintigraphy 6 months after successful coronary angioplasty. Repeat angiography was performed in a subgroup of patients with ischemia and repeat angioplasty was performed when clinically indicated. Patients were followed up for 2.2 +/- 0.8 years for cardiac events.

RESULTS

Six months after coronary angioplasty, ischemia was present in 112 (28%) of 405 patients, and 60% of these 112 were asymptomatic. Ischemia was associated with significant stenosis in 97%; in contrast, results of exercise electrocardiography were negative in 74% of patients with scintigraphic ischemia and angiographic restenosis. The degree of restenosis was similar in patients with symptomatic or silent ischemia (80 +/- 16% vs. 81 +/- 21%). The long-term prognosis of patients with silent ischemia was remarkably similar to that of symptomatic patients. A worse outcome of symptomatic patients was found only if repeat coronary angioplasty for restenosis was considered a separate event (p < 0.01). Silent and symptomatic ischemia predicted an increased risk for recurrent ischemic events but not for death.

CONCLUSIONS

Thus, absence of symptoms and negative findings on an exercise electrocardiogram may not reflect a good angioplasty result. In addition, silent ischemia due to restenosis after coronary angioplasty has a significant prognostic importance for recurrent symptomatic ischemic events that may be reduced by repeat angioplasty.

Usefulness of exercise SPECT-thallium to detect asymptomatic restenosis in patients who had angina before coronary angioplasty

The usefulness of exercise single photon emission computed tomography (SPECT)-thallium for detecting asymptomatic restenosis was assessed prospectively in 62 patients with angina before angioplasty, who underwent < or = 6-month re-angiography and exercise SPECT-thallium imaging. Among patients with restenosis, nine had recurrence of angina but eight did not. These two subgroups had equivalent percentages of restenosis (71 +/- 16% vs 64 +/- 16%, NS) and extent of reversible thallium defects (2.8 +/- 1.7 vs 4.1 +/- 2.6, NS), and both subgroups had poorer hemodynamic responses to exercise compared with patients without restenosis (maximal) rate-pressure product [X 100], 258 +/- 54 and 239 +/- 33 vs 302 +/- 61; p < 0.05 and p < 0.01, respectively). Exercise testing detected fewer patients with restenosis compared to exercise SPECT-thallium imaging, especially among asymptomatic patients (25% vs 100%, p < 0.005). Asymptomatic restenosis occurs frequently, induces an amount of stress ischemia equivalent to that of symptomatic restenosis, and is efficiently detected by exercise SPECT-thallium with rest-reinjection but not by exercise testing.

Exercise thallium scintigraphy versus high-dose dipyridamole echocardiography testing for detection of asymptomatic restenosis in patients with positive exercise tests after coronary angioplasty

The usefulness of high-dose (< or = 0.84 mg/kg over 10 minutes) dipyridamole echocardiography testing was compared with that of exercise thallium-201 scintigraphy in detecting restenosis (> 70% lumen reduction) in 50 asymptomatic patients with ST-segment depression during maximal exercise testing 3 months after successful coronary angioplasty. Dipyridamole echocardiography testing and exercise thallium scintigraphy showed a similar sensitivity (75 vs 83%; p = NS) and specificity (90 vs 84%; p = NS) for the detection of restenoses, which occurred in 12 patients. It is concluded that dipyridamole echocardiography testing is as accurate as exercise thallium testing for the noninvasive detection of severe restenosis in patients with exercise-induced asymptomatic ST-segment depression after successful angioplasty. Furthermore, the site, extent and severity of the thallium perfusion defects during exercise are correlated to those of the dyssynergy during dipyridamole echocardiography.

Indications for routine heart-catheterization after CABG and PTCA

Routine heart-catheterization after Coronary Artery Bypass Graft surgery (CABG) or Percutaneous Transluminal Coronary Angioplasty (PTCA) has been advocated to determine the change in bypass graft or dilated coronary artery and native coronary artery status, the effective disease remaining after CABG or PTCA and the relation between progression of disease, left ventricular function and symptomatology. Results of angiographic follow-up data after CABG and PTCA are presented and the practical implications are discussed. The reliability of symptoms, invasive and non-invasive test for the detection of ischemia are considered. Finally, recommendations are made for the indication of routine heart-catheterization after CABG and PTCA.

Clinical assessment following coronary revascularization

There remains a need to establish adequate protocols for investigating the short- and long-term follow-up of revascularization procedures. For coronary angioplasty the most reliable basis for decision-making in managing patients is the symptomatology of the patient. For bypass surgery a protocol should be established to evaluate patients late, at 5 to 10 years following bypass surgery, in particular those with saphenous vein grafting, as graft and patient survival begins to fall after this period. Investigation after this may be too late for many patients who may already have several occluded grafts and poor left ventricular function, two of the most important prognostic factors post bypass surgery. The improvement and refinement of non-invasive investigations has led to a better understanding of the value and limitations of many of these tests, but it is particularly important that the limitations of many investigation are fully appreciated when they are used to influence clinical decisions. In this regard, a study comparing and integrating the predictive value of the persistence or return to symptoms, a positive non-invasive test, and a positive invasive test would surely prove invaluable.

Early and late exercise testing. Usefulness after percutaneous transluminal coronary angioplasty

Seventy-five patients 36 to 68 years of age were studied after undergoing successful single-vessel percutaneous transluminal coronary angioplasty (PTCA). In all cases exercise tests (ETs) were made prior to the procedure and 2 to 4 days and 6 months thereafter. Angiographic controls were performed on patients with positive ET. Both early and late ET carried out after dilatation lasted significantly longer. Patients were able to tolerate greater work loads and their heart rates and arterial blood pressures also were higher. The ETs conducted prior to PTCA were positive in 62 patients. After dilatation, the early test was positive in 18 and the late test, in 10. Angiographic controls revealed restenosis in 75 percent of patients with single-vessel disease and positive ET. Thus, the results of ETs in patients with single-vessel disease tend to become negative after successful PTCA. Early and late positive ETs are associated with restenosis, while negative ETs indicate a good prognosis.

Detection of restenosis with dobutamine stress test after coronary angioplasty

Dobutamine ECG tests were serially performed before, at 15 days, and at 2 and 6 months after successful coronary angioplasty in 58 patients. The dose of dobutamine was progressively increased from 5 micrograms/kg/min to a maximum of 40 micrograms/kg/min every 5 minutes, with ECG and blood pressure control. Coronary angiography was performed at the end of the study. At 15 days after coronary angioplasty, the dobutamine test was of little value for the diagnosis or prediction of restenosis. At the end of the study, both the presence of angina and the results of the dobutamine test were related to coronary angiography, and their accuracy was calculated for the detection of mild (> or = 50%) and severe (> or = 70%) restenosis or new coronary lesions. The accuracy of angina was 68% for the detection of mild lesions and 70% for that of severe lesions, whereas the accuracy of the dobutamine test was 78% for mild lesions and 80% for severe lesions. It is concluded that the dobutamine stress test is a simple and useful method for the detection of restenosis when it is performed at 2 and 6 months after coronary angioplasty. However, it cannot distinguish between restenosis or new coronary lesions.

Midterm outcome of patients with asymptomatic restenosis after coronary balloon angioplasty

Although many patients with restenosis after balloon coronary angioplasty have recurrence of angina, others remain asymptomatic. To assess the clinical implications of asymptomatic coronary restenosis, we analyzed clinical and angiographic characteristics of 277 consecutive patients with restenosis, 133 (48%) of whom were asymptomatic (group I) and 144 (52%) symptomatic (group II). Restenosis was documented 6 to 9 months after the index procedure, or earlier if angina recurred, and was defined as a greater than 50% lumen narrowing (visual estimation). Group I (asymptomatic group) included fewer female (9% vs. 18%, p less than 0.05) and hypertensive patients (38% vs. 56%, p less than 0.005) and more patients with a previous myocardial infarction (48% vs. 28%, p less than 0.05) and single-vessel disease (67% vs. 55%, p less than 0.05). Before angioplasty, symptoms had lasted for a shorter period (10 +/- 25 vs. 23 +/- 42 months, p less than 0.001), ischemia after a recent infarction was a more frequent indication (21% vs. 10%, p less than 0.05) and total revascularization more frequently obtained (74% vs. 63%, p less than 0.05) in group I than in group II patients. Only a normal blood pressure, previous myocardial infarction, single-vessel disease and a shorter duration of symptoms were independent correlates of asymptomatic restenosis. No differences were found in stenosis severity before angioplasty (90% in both groups) or after angioplasty (22% +/- 12% vs. 24% +/- 16%).(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Safety and clinical use of exercise testing one to three days after percutaneous transluminal coronary angioplasty

To evaluate both the safety and clinical use of predischarge symptom-limited exercise testing after successful uncomplicated percutaneous transluminal coronary angioplasty (PTCA), 100 patients were randomized to undergo exercise testing (n = 50) or no exercise testing (n = 50). There were no differences in clinical or angiographic characteristics between the groups. Exercise testing was performed 38 +/- 14 hours after PTCA. Patients who exercised achieved 71 +/- 12% of predicted maximal heart rate, with 38% reaching greater than or equal to stage III of the Bruce protocol. No patient in either group developed cardiac complications during 48-hour follow-up. Of the 11 patients with a positive test result, 92% had angiographically incomplete revascularization. Attending physicians (n = 16) were questioned both before and after exercise testing about when, after discharge, they would allow their patient to perform each of 11 specific activities of daily living. Questionnaires were administered to physicians at similar time frames for patients in the no-exercise group. Comparison of the responses between initial and repeat questionnaires showed that patients in the exercise group (with a test result negative for ischemia) were allowed to perform 7 of 11 activities, including return to work, earlier (p less than 0.05) than the no-exercise patients. These data indicate that in this well-defined group of patients, symptom-limited exercise testing early after PTCA appears to be safe, and alters physician management in allowing patients with a negative test result to return to various activities at an earlier date. Such testing may be useful in counseling patients after PTCA.

Double-blind, randomized, controlled trial of fish oil supplements in prevention of recurrence of stenosis after coronary angioplasty

BACKGROUND

Previous studies suggest that recurrence of coronary stenosis after percutaneous transluminal coronary angioplasty (PTCA) might be prevented with dietary supplements rich in omega-3 fatty acids. The purpose of the present study was to evaluate this hypothesis. In addition, the relation between usual dietary consumption of omega-3 fatty acids and restenosis was assessed.

METHODS AND RESULTS

A double-blind, randomized, controlled trial was conducted in which 205 patients undergoing a first PTCA received 15 capsules per day containing 1 g of either fish oil (2.7 g/day of eicosapentaenoic acid, 1.8 g/day of docosahexaenoic acid) or olive oil. The treatment was started 3 weeks before PTCA and continued for 6 months thereafter. Dietary intake was assessed by food frequency questionnaire. At 6 months after PTCA, patients underwent a control angiography. All angiographic lesions were measured by quantitative computer analysis. Four criteria were used to define restenosis. Restenosis occurred less often in the fish oil group (22.0-35.6% depending on the definition) than in the control group (40.0-53.3%). After controlling for other risk factors of restenosis, the association of fish oil supplementation with a lower frequency of restenosis was statistically significant (p = 0.03) for three of four definitions. After adjustment, a dietary intake of omega-3 fatty acids of more than 0.15 g/day was also associated with a lower frequency of restenosis (p less than or equal to 0.03).

CONCLUSIONS

This trial documented the protective effect of fish oil supplements on the recurrence of coronary stenosis 6 months after PTCA. The study results suggest that a dietary intervention could be useful in preventing restenosis.

Restenosis after coronary angioplasty: the paradox of increased lumen diameter and restenosis

Restenosis after coronary angioplasty is the single complication that most limits this revascularization procedure in clinical practice. The process is largely unpredictable and the lesion-related factors predisposing to restenosis are poorly understood, with little consensus in published reports. In this study using detailed quantitative angiographic measurements to assess 490 lesions, the simple lesion characteristics associated with restenosis were defined and the relation to the restenosis process documented. Restenosis was defined as an absolute deterioration in the minimal lumen diameter by greater than or equal to 0.72 mm, a criterion based on the 95% confidence intervals for repeat angiographic measurements. This was chosen in an attempt to separate spurious changes due to a poor angiographic result and the variability of angiographic measurements from significant changes due to the restenosis process. The principal determinants of restenosis were found to be a large improvement in the minimal lumen diameter at the time of dilation (1.13 mm for the restenosis group compared with 0.86 mm for the no restenosis group [p less than 0.0001]) and an optimal postangioplasty result (minimal lumen diameter 2.28 mm in the restenosis group compared with 2.05 mm [p less than 0.001] in the no restenosis group, corresponding to a 25% and a 30% diameter stenosis, respectively [p less than 0.0001]). These observations reported for the first time suggest that the distinction needs to be made between a "clinical restenosis" of greater than or equal to 50% diameter stenosis and the "restenosis process" as measured by the absolute changes occurring during and after angioplasty.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Silent ischemia after coronary angioplasty: evaluation of restenosis and extent of ischemia in asymptomatic patients by tomographic thallium-201 exercise imaging and comparison with symptomatic patients

One hundred sixteen patients were evaluated to determine the ability of single photon emission computed tomographic (SPECT) thallium-201 exercise and redistribution imaging to detect silent ischemia secondary to restenosis in asymptomatic patients after single and multiple vessel percutaneous transluminal coronary angioplasty and the findings were compared with SPECT imaging detection of restenosis in symptomatic patients. The value of exercise electrocardiography (ECG) and the amount of ischemic myocardium in symptomatic and asymptomatic patients were determined. Forty-one patients were asymptomatic after angioplasty; 77% of these had chest pain before angioplasty. Seventy-five patients had chest pain after angioplasty; 99% of these had chest pain before angioplasty. Restenosis occurred in 61% of asymptomatic and 59% of symptomatic patients and in 46% of the vessels in both asymptomatic and symptomatic patients. Sensitivity, specificity and accuracy for detection of restenosis by SPECT in individual patients were 96%, 75% and 88% versus 91%, 77% and 85%, respectively, in the asymptomatic versus symptomatic groups (p = NS). Sensitivity, specificity and accuracy for restenosis detection in individual vessels were 90%, 89% and 89% versus 84%, 77% and 84%, respectively, in the asymptomatic and symptomatic groups (p = NS), with similar results for the three major arteries. Sensitivity and accuracy of exercise ECG were significantly less than those of SPECT imaging for the patients with silent (40% and 44%) and symptomatic (59% and 64%) ischemia (p less than 0.001). Restenosis of vessels in the patients with silent and symptomatic ischemia was associated with an equal amount and degree of severity of ischemic myocardium in the two groups.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)