Joint toxicity of lead and cadmium on the behavior of zebrafish larvae: An antagonism

Morphological and cellular effects of lead, cadmium, and perfluorooctanoic acid on Gallus gallus embryonic development: Insights into cephalic region vulnerabilities

Lead (Pb), cadmium (Cd), and perfluorooctanoic acid (PFOA) are environmental pollutants with bioaccumulative properties, posing risks to embryonic development, particularly through cephalic region malformations. Despite their significance, few studies have investigated their effects at realistic concentrations or in mixtures. This study assessed the individual and combined effects of Pb, Cd, and PFOA on Gallus gallus embryos at relevant concentrations, focusing on the cephalic region at stages HH10 and HH14. Exposure to contaminant mixtures, particularly Pb + Cd, Pb + PFOA, and the full combination, resulted in a higher incidence of cranial malformations compared to single-compound exposures. Cd induced dose-dependent changes in cell morphology and significantly reduced proliferation in the head region. PFOA contributed additively to mixture toxicity, markedly impairing cell proliferation and modifying the expression of key adhesion molecules such as β-catenin and N-cadherin. Both embryonic stages exhibited aberrant cellular delamination from the neural tube, with HH10 embryos displaying heightened vulnerability. Systems biology analysis revealed distinct molecular responses to each contaminant, with Pb and Cd primarily affecting immune-related pathways, including complement activation, while PFOA operated through separate regulatory mechanisms. Integrative network analyses using STITCH 5 and the Comparative Toxicogenomics Database identified candidate genes potentially involved in developmental disruption. These findings underscore the complex interactions between pollutants, which may not be predicted solely by examining individual exposures and highlight the need for stricter environmental regulations to address the risks posed by contaminant mixtures.

Heterogeneous Single-Cell Distribution of Trace-Level Metal Mixtures in Tetrahymena thermophila Using Mass Cytometry

The uptake of heavy metals by unicellular organisms can lead to the bioaccumulation of these metals in higher organisms, detrimentally affecting organismal health and ultimately impacts the ecosystems. By studying the uptake and accumulation of heavy metals in unicellular organisms, we gain insights into potential risks associated with low-dose heavy metal exposure in aquatic environments. Thus, to investigate the accumulation characteristics of Mo, Ag, Cd, Sn, Sb, Hg, Tl, and Pb mixtures in single Tetrahymena thermophila cells, we developed a label-free approach for the simultaneous absolute quantification of multiple metals in a single cell using mass cytometry. Our results demonstrated the dynamic changes in metal concentrations in T. thermophila, and the competition between metals in uptake and excretory pathways resulted in heterogeneous accumulation and bioconcentration of these metals. Additionally, our findings revealed the limited capacity of T. thermophila to excrete Cd and Hg, suggesting a higher risk for T. thermophila cells when exposed to Cd and Hg over an extended period. Therefore, the current study provides valuable data for a more comprehensive understanding of the impact of low-dose heavy metals on aquatic ecosystems.

Swimming Into View: Zebrafish Uncover Targets, Mechanisms, and Therapies for Cadmium Toxicity

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

Cadmium (Cd) remains a persistent threat to human and environmental health. To better understand causal relationships between genotype and disease phenotypes, a genetically tractable model, zebrafish (Danio rerio) has emerged. We summarize recent empirical evidence on the targets, mechanisms, and potential therapies for Cd toxicity.

RECENT FINDINGS

Recent results show that waterborne Cd exhibits organ specific accumulation including in the eye, brain, heart, and gonads triggering oxidative stress, inflammation, gut dysbiosis, and altered methylation patterns that persist across generations. Novel mechanisms of Cd toxicity include the gut-brain axis, ionic antagonism, the Wnt/β-catenin pathway, and epigenetics, leading to potential therapeutics such as probiotics, selenium, and antioxidants. Based on the reviewed literature, more studies should examine the effects of dietary Cd on zebrafish behavior, brains, and cardiovascular function. Given that humans and wildlife are chronically exposed to Cd, leading to gonadal Cd accumulation, studies should conduct early-life exposures across the zebrafish lifespan and assess endpoints across generations to capture germline and epigenetic effects and mechanisms. The zebrafish's biomedical toolkit, along with high-content screening, should be utilized to develop and refine therapies.

Exposure to complex mixtures of urban sediments containing Tyre and Road Wear Particles (TRWPs) increases the germ-line mutation rate in Chironomus riparius

Tyre and road wear particles (TRWPs) are a significant yet often underestimated source of environmental pollution, contributing to the accumulation of microplastics and a complex mixture of contaminants in both terrestrial and aquatic ecosystems. Despite their prevalence, the long-term evolutionary effects of TRWPs, beyond their immediate toxicity, remain largely unknown. In this study, we assessed mutagenicity in the non-biting midge Chironomus riparius, upon exposure to urban sediment collected from a runoff sedimentation basin. To assess the extent of mutagenic effects over multiple generations, we combined the urban sediment exposure model with short-term mutation accumulation lines (MALs) and subsequent whole genome sequencing (WGS). The study was conducted over five generations, with urban sediment concentrations of 0.5 % and 10 %. Our results reveal that the exposure to urban sediment significantly increases mutation rates compared to control groups by 50 %, independent of concentration (0.5 % and 10 %). To infer potential causal processes, we conducted a comparative analysis using known mutational spectra from previous studies. This comparison showed that the mutation profiles induced by urban sediment clearly clustered with those caused by Benzo[a]Pyrene (BaP), a known Polycyclic Aromatic Hydrocarbon (PAH). A comprehensive chemical characterization of the sediment confirmed a considerable impact of road runoff and traffic-related contamination, including PAHs of primarily petrogenic origin. This suggests that PAH-like compounds present in urban sediments may play a significant role in the observed mutagenic effects. Our study shows that urban sediments influence mutation rates and alter mutational spectra in exposed organisms, potentially compromising genomic stability and shaping evolutionary trajectories. These genetic changes can have profound long-term effects on population dynamics and ecosystem health, underlining the importance of understanding the evolutionary consequences of environmental pollution. Additionally, we show that comparatively analysing of mutational spectra may provide valuable insights into mutational processes.

Parental (F0) exposure to Cadmium and Ketoprofen induces developmental deformities in offspring (F1): A transgenerational toxicity assessment in zebrafish model

In the aquatic environment, the primary pollutants of heavy metals and pharmaceuticals always occur in coexisting forms, and the research about combined impacts remains unclear, especially transgenerational effects. Cadmium (Cd) is a heavy metal that can damage the endocrine reproduction systems and cause thyroid dysfunction in fish. Meanwhile, ketoprofen (KPF) is a nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drug (NSAID) that can cause neurobehavioral damage and physiological impairment. However, to our knowledge, the combined exposure of Cd and KPF in transgenerational studies has not been reported. In this investigation, sexually mature zebrafish were subjected to isolated exposure and combined exposure to Cd (10 μg/L) and KPF (10 and 100 μg/L) at environmentally relevant concentrations for 42 days. In this background, breeding capacity, chemical accumulation rate in gonads, and tissue morphologies are investigated in parental fish. This is followed by examining the malformation rate, inflammation rate, and gene transcription in the F1 offspring. Our results indicate that combined exposure of Cd and KPF to the parental fish could increase the chemical accumulation rate and tissue damage in the gonads of fish and significantly reduce the breeding ability. Furthermore, these negative impacts were transmitted to its produced F1 embryos, reflected by hatching rate, body deformities, and thyroid axis-related gene transcription. These findings provide further insights into the harm posed by Cd in the presence of KPF to the aquatic ecosystems.

Embryonic exposures to cadmium and PAHs cause long-term and interacting neurobehavioral effects in zebrafish

Developmental exposure to either polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs) or heavy metals has been shown to cause persisting and overlapping neurobehavioral effects in animal models. However, interactions between these compounds have not been well characterized, despite their co-occurrence in a variety of environmental media. In two companion studies, we examined the effects of developmental exposure to cadmium (Cd) with or without co-exposure to prototypic PAHs benzo[a]pyrene (BaP, Exp. 1) or fluoranthene (FA, Exp. 2) using a developing zebrafish model. Zebrafish embryos were exposed to Cd (0-0.3 μM), BaP (0-3 μM), FA (0-1.0 μM), or binary Cd-PAH mixtures from 5 to 122 h post fertilization (hpf). In Exp. 1, Cd and BaP produced independent effects on an array of outcomes and interacting effects on specific outcomes. Notably, Cd-induced deficits in dark-induced locomotor stimulation were attenuated by BaP co-exposure in the larval motility test and BaP-induced hyperactivity was attenuated by Cd co-exposure in the adolescent novel tank test. Likewise, in Exp. 2, Cd and FA produced both independent and interacting effects. FA-induced increases on adult post-tap activity in the tap startle test were attenuated by co-exposure with Cd. On the predator avoidance test, FA- and 0.3 μM Cd-induced hyperactivity effects were attenuated by their co-exposure. Taken together, these data indicate that while the effects of Cd and these representative PAHs on zebrafish behavior were largely independent of one another, binary mixtures can produce sub-additive effects for some neurobehavioral outcomes and at certain ages. This research emphasizes the need for detailed risk assessments of mixtures containing contaminants of differing classes, and for clarity on the mechanisms which allow cross-class toxicant interactions to occur.

Combined toxicity of trifloxystrobin and fluopyram to zebrafish embryos and the effect on bone development

Trifloxystrobin (TRI) is a methacrylate fungicide, and fluopyram (FLU) is a new pyridylethylbenzamide fungicide and nematicide. Both are often detected in water bodies and may be highly toxic to many aquatic organisms. Unfortunately, the aquatic biological risks of single FLU or a mixture of trifloxystrobin and fluopyram have not been reported. In this study, zebrafish was selected as the test organism to investigate the combined toxicity of trifloxystrobin and fluopyram to zebrafish. After zebrafish embryos exposed to three pesticide solutions, Alcian-blue staining, Alizarin-red staining and quantitative PCR (qPCR) were performed. The results indicated that 96h-LC50 of TRI was 0.159 mg·L-1 to zebrafish embryo, which was highly toxic. The 96h-LC50 of FLU to zebrafish embryos was 4.375 mg·L-1, being moderately toxic. The joint toxicity to zebrafish embryos(FLU at 96h-LC50 and TRI at 96h-LC50 in a 1:1 weight ratio to form a series of concentration treatment groups) was antagonistic. Both trifloxystrobin and fluopyram also inhibited the skeletal development of zebrafish and showed to be antagonistic. The results of qPCR indicated upregulations of different genes upon three different treatments. TRI mainly induced Smads up-expression, which may affect the BMP-smads pathway. FLU mainly induced an up-expression of extracellular BMP ligands and type I receptor (Bmpr-1a), which may affect the BMP ligand receptor pathway. The 1:1 mixture (weight ratio) of trifloxystrobin and fluopyram induced a reduction of the genes of extracellular BMP ligand (Smads) and type I receptor (Bmpr1ba), which may down-regulate BMP signaling and thus attenuating cartilage hyperproliferation, hypertrophy and mineralization. The results warren an interest in further studying the effect of the two fungicides in a mixture on zebrafish.

Predicting the Metal Mixture Toxicity with a Toxicokinetic-Toxicodynamic Model Considering the Time-Dependent Adverse Outcome Pathways

Chemicals mainly exist in ecosystems as mixtures, and understanding and predicting their effects are major challenges in ecotoxicology. While the adverse outcome pathway (AOP) and toxicokinetic-toxicodynamic (TK-TD) models show promise as mechanistic approaches in chemical risk assessment, there is still a lack of methodology to incorporate the AOP into a TK-TD model. Here, we describe a novel approach that integrates the AOP and TK-TD models to predict mixture toxicity using metal mixtures (specifically Cd-Cu) as a case study. We preliminarily constructed an AOP of the metal mixture through temporal transcriptome analysis together with confirmatory bioassays. The AOP revealed that prolonged exposure time activated more key events and adverse outcomes, indicating different modes of action over time. We selected a potential key event as a proxy for damage and used it as a measurable parameter to replace the theoretical parameter (scaled damage) in the TK-TD model. This refined model, which connects molecular responses to organism outcomes, effectively predicts Cd-Cu mixture toxicity over time and can be extended to other metal mixtures and even multicomponent mixtures. Overall, our results contribute to a better understanding of metal mixture toxicity and provide insights for integrating the AOP and TK-TD models to improve risk assessment for chemical mixtures.

Development of a rapid zebrafish model for lead poisoning research and drugs screening

Lead (Pb) contamination is a worldwide public health threaten. Besides close restraint of lead exposure, it's emergency to discover compounds that could help to cue toxicities caused by lead. Zebrafish embryos and early larvae can serve as valuable screening tools in early pre-clinical phase of drug screening and research. In order to establish a zebrafish lead poisoning model that could be used for drug screening and research, zebrafish embryos at 6 h post-fertilization (hpf) were treated with lead at different concentrations by soaking intermittently, raised in lead work solution at night while in fish water during the day. After treated for 90 h, death and severe trunk curvature were observed on zebrafish in 640 μM group, obvious dysplasia, blood toxicity, excessive reactive oxygen species (ROS), severe neurotoxicity, such as shorter length of peripheral motor neurons, neuronal apoptosis, and axonal injury, and neurobehavior impairment were induced by lead at 80, 160 and 320 μM, similar to phenotypes reported in rodent. Moreover, the mRNA level of genes related to neurodevelopment, memory, and antioxidation were significantly down regulated, and apoptosis-related genes were up regulated, consistent to zebrafish phenotypic change. Finally, zebrafish were intermittently exposed to 80 μM lead solution to establish the lead poisoning model, and the efficacy of a safe chelating agent Meso-2,3-Dimercaptosuccinic acid (DMSA) was tested at a series of concentrations to validate the zebrafish model. The result showed concentration-dependent decrease of lead content in zebrafish in DMSA treated groups compared with model group. The above data fully demonstrated a zebrafish model of lead poisoning suitable for drug screening was successfully developed, which was expected to provide a rapid and economic tools for discovering antidotes of lead and drugs of neuroprotection.

Zebrafish as model organisms for toxicological evaluations in the field of food science

Food safety has long been an area of concern. The selection of stable and efficient model organisms is particularly important for food toxicology studies. Zebrafish (Danio rerio) are small model vertebrates, and 70% of human genes have at least one zebrafish ortholog. Zebrafish have advantages as model organisms due to their short life cycle, strong reproductive ability, easy rearing, and low cost. Zebrafish embryos have the advantage of being sensitive to the breeding environment and thus have been used as biosensors. Zebrafish and their embryos have been widely used for food toxicology assessments. This review provides a systematic and comprehensive summary of food toxicology studies using zebrafish as model organisms. First, we briefly introduce the multidimensional mechanisms and structure-activity relationship studies of food toxicological assessment. Second, we categorize these studies according to eight types of hazards in foods, including mycotoxins, pesticides, antibiotics, heavy metals, endocrine disruptors, food additives, nanoparticles, and other food-related ingredients. Finally, we list the applications of zebrafish in food toxicology studies in line with future research prospects, aiming to provide a valuable reference for researchers in the field of food science.

Effects of Single and Combined Ciprofloxacin and Lead Treatments on Zebrafish Behavior, Oxidative Stress, and Elements Content

Even though the toxic effects of antibiotics and heavy metals have been extensively studied in the last decades, their combined adverse impact on aquatic organisms is poorly understood. Therefore, the objective of this study was to assess the acute effects of a ciprofloxacin (Cipro) and lead (Pb) mixture on the 3D swimming behavior, acetylcholinesterase (AChE) activity, lipid peroxidation level (MDA-malondialdehyde), activity of some oxidative stress markers (SOD-superoxide dismutase and GPx-glutathione peroxidase), and the essential elements content (Cu-copper, Zn-zinc, Fe-iron, Ca-calcium, Mg-magnesium, Na-sodium and K-potassium) in the body of zebrafish (Danio rerio). For this purpose, zebrafish were exposed to environmentally relevant concentrations of Cipro, Pb, and a mixture for 96 h. The results revealed that acute exposure to Pb alone and in mixture with Cipro impaired zebrafish exploratory behavior by decreasing swimming activity and elevating freezing duration. Moreover, significant deficiencies of Ca, K, Mg, and Na contents, as well as an excess of Zn level, were observed in fish tissues after exposure to the binary mixture. Likewise, the combined treatment with Pb and Cipro inhibited the activity of AChE and increased the GPx activity and MDA level. The mixture produced more damage in all studied endpoints, while Cipro had no significant effect. The findings highlight that the simultaneous presence of antibiotics and heavy metals in the environment can pose a threat to the health of living organisms.

Effects of cadmium and lead co-exposure on glucocorticoid levels in rural residents of northwest China

Cadmium (Cd) and lead (Pb) are important environmental endocrine disruptors that are associated with adverse health problems. However, the effects of co-exposure to Cd and Pb on glucocorticoids (GCs) in the body at environmental levels are limited. A total of 468 subjects from the Dongdagou-Xinglong cohort (DDG-XL) were included in this study. We measured the serum levels of two representative endogenous GCs [cortisol (CRL) and cortisone (CRN)], and whole blood levels of Cd and Pb. Multiple linear regression models were constructed to explore the associations of single or combined Cd and Pb exposure with serum CRL and CRN levels. The interactive effects of Cd and Pb on GCs were further assessed using mediation analysis and moderation analysis. Single-heavy metal exposure analysis with adjustment for potential confounders showed that the serum CRL level decreased when the blood Cd or Pb concentration gradually increased (P trend <0.01). Additionally, subjects with high Cd or Pb exposure (Q4) had significantly reduced serum CRN levels compared to those with low Cd or Pb exposure (Q1) (P < 0.05). In Cd and Pb co-exposure analysis, significant negative dose-response relationships were observed between co-exposure to Cd and Pb and serum CRL and CRN levels. Furthermore, mediation analysis showed that Cd completely mediated the relationship between Pb and GCs, and moderation analysis suggested that Pb might weaken the negative relationship between Cd and GCs. These findings suggest that single or combined exposure to Cd and Pb interferes with the homeostasis of serum CRL and CRN levels. Furthermore, we innovatively propose that Cd and Pb may have interactive effects on GCs levels, and Pb can antagonize the negative relationship between Cd and GCs, which may provide clues for further studies on endocrine and metabolic disorders related to these heavy metals.

Zebrafish as a Potential Model for Neurodegenerative Diseases: A Focus on Toxic Metals Implications

In the last century, industrial activities increased and caused multiple health problems for humans and animals. At this moment, heavy metals are considered the most harmful substances for their effects on organisms and humans. The impact of these toxic metals, which have no biological role, poses a considerable threat and is associated with several health problems. Heavy metals can interfere with metabolic processes and can sometimes act as pseudo-elements. The zebrafish is an animal model progressively used to expose the toxic effects of diverse compounds and to find treatments for different devastating diseases that human beings are currently facing. This review aims to analyse and discuss the value of zebrafish as animal models used in neurological conditions, such as Alzheimer's disease (AD), and Parkinson's disease (PD), particularly in terms of the benefits of animal models and the limitations that exist.

Early Exposure to Environmental Pollutants: Imidacloprid Potentiates Cadmium Toxicity on Zebrafish Retinal Cells Death

In the present study, we analyzed the combination of non-toxic concentrations per se, of Cd and a pesticide the imidacloprid (IMI) (10 and 50 μM for Cd and 195 μM for IMI), to highlight early developmental toxicity and possible damage to retinal cells. Co-exposure to Cd and IMI showed a toxic effect in zebrafish larval development, with lowered degrees of survival and hatching, and in some cases the induction of structural alterations and edema. In addition, co-exposure to 50 and 195 μM, respectively, for Cd and IMI, also showed increased apoptosis in eye cells, accompanied by up regulation of genes associated with antioxidant markers (cat, sod1, nrf2 and ho-1). Thus, the present study aims to highlight how the presence of multiple contaminants, even at low concentrations, can be a risk factor in a model of zebrafish (Danio rerio). The presence of other contaminants, such as IMI, can cause an enhancement of the toxic action of Cd on morphological changes in the early life stage of zebrafish, but more importantly disrupt the normal development of the retina, eventually triggering apoptosis.

Elucidating the Differences in Metal Toxicity by Quantitative Adverse Outcome Pathways

Numerous studies have reported that the toxicity differences among metals are widespread; however, little is known about the mechanism of differences in metal toxicity to aquatic organisms due to the lack of quantitative understanding of their adverse outcome pathway. Here, we investigated the effects of Cd and Cu on bioaccumulation, gene expression, physiological responses, and apical effects in zebrafish larvae. RNA sequencing was conducted to provide supplementary mechanistic information for the effects of Cd and Cu exposure. On this basis, we proposed a quantitative adverse outcome pathway (qAOP) suitable for metal risk assessment of aquatic organisms. Our work provides a mechanistic explanation for the differences in metal toxicity where the strong bioaccumulation of Cu enables the newly accumulated Cu to reach the threshold that causes different adverse effects faster than Cd in zebrafish larvae, resulting in a higher toxicity of Cu than that of Cd. Furthermore, we proposed a parameter C_IT/BCF (the ratio of internal threshold concentration and bioaccumulation factor) that helps to understand the toxicity differences by combining the information of bioaccumulation and internal threshold of adverse effects. This work demonstrated that qAOP is an effective quantitative tool for understanding the toxicity mechanism and highlight the importance of toxicokinetics and toxicodynamics at different biological levels in determining the metal toxicity.

Neurotoxicity and gene expression alterations in zebrafish larvae in response to manganese exposure

Manganese (Mn) is an essential trace element, but excessive exposure can damage mental, cognitive, and motor functions. Although many studies have reported the toxicity of Mn, the underlying mechanism remains unclear. Here, wild-type and/or Tg(NBT:DsRed) zebrafish embryos/larvae were exposed to different dosages of Mn to determine the effects on mortality, malformation, and hatching rates. A video tracking system was used to analyze the locomotor activities of zebrafish larvae. The terminal deoxynucleotidyl transferase dUTP nick end labeling assay and acridine orange staining were performed to monitor cell apoptosis, while dopamine transporter and tyrosine hydroxylase (TH) expression were detected by immunohistochemical staining. Meanwhile, transcriptome sequencing of the head tissues of zebrafish larvae was performed to search for molecular targets of Mn neurotoxicity. The results showed that Mn exposure increased the mortality and malformation rates of zebrafish larvae, and significantly reduced swim distance and velocity. In addition, the proportion of apoptotic dopaminergic neurons increased, while TH expression significantly decreased. The results of transcriptome sequencing showed that a large number of differentially expressed genes associated with apoptosis and DNA damage repair were upregulated, consistent with the above results. Meanwhile, Western blot analysis showed that higher exposure level of Mn could induce activation of MAPK pathway. These data demonstrate that Mn exposure can damage dopaminergic neurons and cause apoptosis, which has detrimental effects on the motor abilities of zebrafish larvae.

Developmental exposure to environmental levels of cadmium induces neurotoxicity and activates microglia in zebrafish larvae: From the perspectives of neurobehavior and neuroimaging

Cadmium (Cd) is a worldwide environmental pollutant that postures serious threats to humans and ecosystems. Over the years, its adverse effects on the central nervous system (CNS) have been concerned, whereas the underlying cellular/molecular mechanisms remain unclear. In this study, taking advantages of zebrafish model in high-throughput imaging and behavioral tests, we have explored the potential developmental neurotoxicity of Cd at environmentally relevant levels, from the perspectives of neurobehavior and neuroimaging. Briefly, Cd²⁺ exposure resulted in a general impairment of zebrafish early development. Zebrafish neurobehavioral patterns including locomotion and reactivity to environmental signals were significantly perturbed upon Cd²⁺ exposure. Importantly, a combination of in vivo two-photon neuroimaging, flow cytometry and gene expression analyses revealed notable neurodevelopmental disorders as well as neuroimmune responses induced by Cd²⁺ exposure. Both cell-cycle arrest and apoptosis contributed jointly to a significant decrease of neuronal density in zebrafish larvae exposed to Cd²⁺. The dramatic morphological alterations of microglia from multi-branched to amoeboid, the microgliosis, as well as the modulation of gene expression profiles demonstrated a strong activation of microglia and neuroinflammation triggered by environmental levels of Cd²⁺. Together, our study points to the developmental toxicity of Cd in inducing CNS impairment and neuroinflammation thereby providing visualized etiological evidence of this heavy metal induced neurodevelopmental disorders. It's tempting to speculate that this research model might represent a promising tool not only for understanding the molecular mechanisms of Cd-induced neurotoxicity, but also for developing pharmacotherapies to mitigate the neurological damage resulting from exposure to Cd, and other neurotoxicants.