Structure and functional regulation of the CD38 promoter

Ovarian Transcriptomic Analysis Reveals Differential Expression Genes Associated with Cell Death Process after Selection for Ovulation Rate in Rabbits

Simple Summary

Transcriptomic analysis showed nineteen potential biomarkers in ovarian tissue from females belonged to a rabbit line selected for ovulation rate for 10 generations and the control line. These females differed not only in ovulation rate but also in prenatal survival since similar litter size were observed.

Abstract

Litter size is an essential trait in rabbit meat production but with low heritability. A selection experiment for ovulation rate has been performed for 10 generations to improve litter size in rabbits. The selected line increased two ova more than the control line but nevertheless a negative correlation was observed with prenatal survival. A transcriptomic study was performed, using microarrays, in ovarian tissue from females belonging to the selected line and the control line. Our results showed 1357 differential expressed genes and nineteen potential biomarkers associated with prenatal mortality, which could explain differences between litter size in rabbits. Cell death was the most relevant process.

CD38: A Potential Therapeutic Target in Cardiovascular Disease

Substantial research has demonstrated the association between cardiovascular disease and the dysregulation of intracellular calcium, ageing, reduction in nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide NAD+ content, and decrease in sirtuin activity. CD38, which comprises the soluble type, type II, and type III, is the main NADase in mammals. This molecule catalyses the production of cyclic adenosine diphosphate ribose (cADPR), nicotinic acid adenine dinucleotide phosphate (NAADP), and adenosine diphosphate ribose (ADPR), which stimulate the release of Ca²⁺, accompanied by NAD+ consumption and decreased sirtuin activity. Therefore, the relationship between cardiovascular disease and CD38 has been attracting increased attention. In this review, we summarize the structure, regulation, function, targeted drug development, and current research on CD38 in the cardiac context. More importantly, we provide original views about the as yet elusive mechanisms of CD38 action in certain cardiovascular disease models. Based on our review, we predict that CD38 may serve as a novel therapeutic target in cardiovascular disease in the future.

Mitochondria Are Dynamically Transferring Between Human Neural Cells and Alexander Disease-Associated GFAP Mutations Impair the Astrocytic Transfer

Mitochondria are the critical organelles for energy metabolism and cell survival in eukaryotic cells. Recent studies demonstrated that mitochondria can intercellularly transfer between mammalian cells. In neural cells, astrocytes transfer mitochondria into neurons in a CD38-dependent manner. Here, using co-culture system of neural cell lines, primary neural cells, and human pluripotent stem cell (hPSC)-derived neural cells, we further revealed that mitochondria dynamically transferred between astrocytes and also from neuronal cells into astrocytes, to which CD38/cyclic ADP-ribose signaling and mitochondrial Rho GTPases (MIRO1 and MIRO2) contributed. The transfer consequently elevated mitochondrial membrane potential in the recipient cells. By introducing Alexander disease (AxD)-associated hotspot mutations (R79C, R239C) into GFAP gene of hPSCs and subsequently inducing astrocyte differentiation, we found that GFAP mutations impaired mitochondrial transfer from astrocytes and reduced astrocytic CD38 expression. Thus, our study suggested that mitochondria dynamically transferred between neural cells and revealed that AxD-associated mutations in GFAP gene disrupted the astrocytic transfer, providing a potential pathogenic mechanism in AxD.

Design of new CD38 inhibitors based on CoMFA modelling and molecular docking analysis of 4‑amino-8-quinoline carboxamides and 2,4-diamino-8-quinazoline carboxamides

In this study, based on molecular docking analysis and comparative molecular field analysis (CoMFA) modelling of a series of 71 CD38 inhibitors including 4‑amino-8-quinoline carboxamides and 2,4-diamino-8-quinazoline carboxamides, new CD38 inhibitors were designed. The interactions of the molecules with the greatest and the lowest activities with the nicotinamide mononucleotide (NMN) binding site were investigated by molecular docking analysis. A CoMFA model with four partial least squares regression (PLSR) components was developed to predict the CD38 inhibitory activity of the molecules. The r² values for the training and test sets were 0.89 and 0.82, respectively. The Q² values for leave-one-out cross-validation (LOO-CV) and leave-many-out cross-validation (LMO-CV) tests on the training set were 0.65 and 0.64, respectively. The CoMFA model was validated by calculating several statistical parameters. CoMFA contour maps were interpreted, and structural features that influence the CD38 inhibitory activity of molecules were determined. Finally, seven new CD38 inhibitors with greater activity with respect to the greatest active molecules were designed.

A radioresistant fraction of acute promyelocytic leukemia cells exhibit CD38 cell-surface antigen and mRNA expression

In the present study, the cell viability and cluster of differentiation (CD)38 mRNA expression were evaluated in radioresistant (Res)-HL60 acute promyelocytic leukemia (APL) cells. Cell viability in Res-HL60 cells was higher compared with wild-type HL60 cells, but did not differ between high and mid/low CD38 antigen expression groups in Res-HL60 cells. A higher expression of CD38 mRNA in Res-HL60 cells was observed, particularly in the CD38^high cell subpopulation. Furthermore, the expression of CD38 mRNA was upregulated following exposure to X-irradiation. In contrast, the characteristic expression of CD45 and CCAAT/enhancer-binding protein α mRNA were not altered. These results suggest that the accumulation of CD38 protein in radioresistant APL cells, resulting from the constant expression of CD38 mRNA induced by X-irradiation, is a characteristic response of the radioresistant-surviving fraction; however, the accumulation of CD38 did not influence the extent of radioresistant behavior.

CD38/cADPR Signaling Pathway in Airway Disease: Regulatory Mechanisms

Asthma is an inflammatory disease in which proinflammatory cytokines have a role in inducing abnormalities of airway smooth muscle function and in the development of airway hyperresponsiveness. Inflammatory cytokines alter calcium (Ca²⁺) signaling and contractility of airway smooth muscle, which results in nonspecific airway hyperresponsiveness to agonists. In this context, Ca²⁺ regulatory mechanisms in airway smooth muscle and changes in these regulatory mechanisms encompass a major component of airway hyperresponsiveness. Although dynamic Ca²⁺ regulation is complex, phospholipase C/inositol tris-phosphate (PLC/IP3) and CD38-cyclic ADP-ribose (CD38/cADPR) are two major pathways mediating agonist-induced Ca²⁺ regulation in airway smooth muscle. Altered CD38 expression or enhanced cyclic ADP-ribosyl cyclase activity associated with CD38 contributes to human pathologies such as asthma, neoplasia, and neuroimmune diseases. This review is focused on investigations on the role of CD38-cyclic ADP-ribose signaling in airway smooth muscle in the context of transcriptional and posttranscriptional regulation of CD38 expression. The specific roles of transcription factors NF-kB and AP-1 in the transcriptional regulation of CD38 expression and of miRNAs miR-140-3p and miR-708 in the posttranscriptional regulation and the underlying mechanisms of such regulation are discussed.

NAD and the aging process: Role in life, death and everything in between

Life as we know it cannot exist without the nucleotide nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide (NAD). From the simplest organism, such as bacteria, to the most complex multicellular organisms, NAD is a key cellular component. NAD is extremely abundant in most living cells and has traditionally been described to be a cofactor in electron transfer during oxidation-reduction reactions. In addition to participating in these reactions, NAD has also been shown to play a key role in cell signaling, regulating several pathways from intracellular calcium transients to the epigenetic status of chromatin. Thus, NAD is a molecule that provides an important link between signaling and metabolism, and serves as a key molecule in cellular metabolic sensoring pathways. Importantly, it has now been clearly demonstrated that cellular NAD levels decline during chronological aging. This decline appears to play a crucial role in the development of metabolic dysfunction and age-related diseases. In this review we will discuss the molecular mechanisms responsible for the decrease in NAD levels during aging. Since other reviews on this subject have been recently published, we will concentrate on presenting a critical appraisal of the current status of the literature and will highlight some controversial topics in the field. In particular, we will discuss the potential role of the NADase CD38 as a driver of age-related NAD decline.

CD38 in the pathogenesis of allergic airway disease: Potential therapeutic targets

CD38 is an ectoenzyme that catalyzes the conversion of β-nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide (β-NAD) to cyclic adenosine diphosphoribose (cADPR) and adenosine diphosphoribose (ADPR) and NADP to nicotinic acid adenine dinucleotide phosphate (NAADP) and adenosine diphosphoribose-2'-phosphate (ADPR-P). The metabolites of NAD and NADP have roles in calcium signaling in different cell types including airway smooth muscle (ASM) cells. In ASM cells, inflammatory cytokines augment CD38 expression and to a greater magnitude in cells from asthmatics, indicating a greater capacity for the generation of cADPR and ADPR in ASM from asthmatics. CD38 deficient mice develop attenuated airway responsiveness to inhaled methacholine following allergen sensitization and challenge compared to wild-type mice indicating its potential role in asthma. Regulation of CD38 expression in ASM cells is achieved by mitogen activated protein kinases, specific isoforms of PI3 kinases, the transcription factors NF-κB and AP-1, and post-transcriptionally by microRNAs. This review will focus on the role of CD38 in intracellular calcium regulation in ASM, contribution to airway inflammation and airway hyperresponsiveness in mouse models of allergic airway inflammation, the transcriptional and post-transcriptional mechanisms of regulation of expression, and outline approaches to inhibit its expression and activity.

Molecular docking and CoMFA studies of thiazoloquin(az)olin(on)es as CD38 inhibitors: determination of inhibitory mechanism, pharmacophore interactions, and design of new inhibitors

In this research, molecular docking and 3D-QSAR studies were carried out on a series of 79 thiazoloquin(az)olin(on)es as CD38 inhibitors. Based on docking results, four interactions including hydrogen bonding with main chain of GLU-226 (H-M-GLU-226), Van der Waals interactions with side chain of TRP-125 (V-S-TRP-125), TRP-189 (V-S-TRP-189), and THR-221 (V-S-THR-221) were considered as pharmacological interactions. Active conformation of each ligand was extracted from docking studies and was used for carrying out 3D-QSAR modeling. Comparative molecular field analysis (CoMFA) was performed on CD38 inhibitory activities of these compounds on human and mouse. We developed CoMFA models with five components as optimum models for both data-sets. For human data-set, a model with high predictive power was developed. R², RMSE, and F-test values for training set of this model were .94, .24, and 179.58, respectively, and R² and RMSE for its test set were .92 and .32, respectively. The q² and RMSE values for leave-one-out cross validation test on training set were .78 and .46, respectively, that demonstrate created model is robust. Based on extracted steric and electrostatic contour maps for this model, three inhibitors with pIC₅₀ larger than 8.85 were designed.

CD38 and airway hyper-responsiveness: studies on human airway smooth muscle cells and mouse models

Asthma is an inflammatory disease in which altered calcium regulation, contractility, and airway smooth muscle (ASM) proliferation contribute to airway hyper-responsiveness and airway wall remodeling. The enzymatic activity of CD38, a cell-surface protein expressed in human ASM cells, generates calcium mobilizing second messenger molecules such as cyclic ADP-ribose. CD38 expression in human ASM cells is augmented by cytokines (e.g., TNF-α) that requires the activation of MAP kinases and the transcription factors, NF-κB and AP-1, and is post-transcriptionally regulated by miR-140-3p and miR-708 by binding to 3' Untranslated Region of CD38 as well as by modulating the activation of signaling mechanisms involved in its regulation. Mice deficient in Cd38 exhibit reduced airway responsiveness to inhaled methacholine relative to the response in wild-type mice. Intranasal challenge of Cd38-deficient mice with TNF-α or IL-13, or the environmental fungus Alternaria alternata, causes significantly attenuated methacholine responsiveness compared with wild-type mice, with comparable airway inflammation. Reciprocal bone marrow transfer studies revealed partial restoration of airway hyper-responsiveness to inhaled methacholine in the Cd38-deficient mice. These studies provide evidence for CD38 involvement in the development of airway hyper-responsiveness; a hallmark feature of asthma. Future studies aimed at drug discovery and delivery targeting CD38 expression and (or) activity are warranted.

Population variability in CD38 activity: correlation with age and significant effect of TNF-α -308G>A and CD38 184C>G SNPs

CD38 (EC 3.2.2.6, NAD(+)-glycohydrolase) is a multifunctional enzyme catalyzing the synthesis and hydrolysis of cyclic ADP-ribose from NAD(+) to ADP-ribose. The loss of CD38 function is associated with impaired immune responses, metabolic disturbances, and behavioral modifications. Notably, it has been linked to HIV infection, leukemias, myelomas, solid tumors, Type II Diabetes mellitus, bone metabolism, as well as Autism Spectrum Disorder. Taking into account the crucial role played by CD38 in many diseases and in clinical practice, here we assessed the distribution of CD38 NADase activity in a healthy population (104 sex-matched unrelated individuals, 12-98 years) and determined its main predictors among genetic and physiological factors (age and sex). The mean value of CD38 NADase activity was 0.051±0.023 mU/mg (0.010-0.099 mU/mg), following a normal distribution in the study population (Kolmogorov-Smirnov test P=0.200). The TNF-α -308G>A (rs1800629) resulted the main predictor (β=0.364, P=0.00008), followed by Age (β=0.280, P=0.002) and the CD38 184C>G (rs6449182) (β=0.193, P=0.033). Our study contributes to understanding CD38 enzyme physiological functions, by reporting, for the first time, its activity distribution in healthy individuals and demonstrating a significant positive correlation with age. Moreover, the possible use of TNF-α -308G>A (rs1800629) and the CD38 184C>G (rs6449182) SNPs as predictive genetic markers of CD38 activity, clearly point toward possible pharmacogenomic applications and to a more refined use of CD38 in clinical settings.

Differential induction of CD38 expression by TNF-{alpha} in asthmatic airway smooth muscle cells

The ADP-ribosyl cyclase activity of CD38, a membrane protein expressed in human airway smooth muscle (ASM) cells, generates cyclic ADP-ribose (cADPR), a Ca²(+)-mobilizing agent. cADPR-mediated Ca²(+) responses to agonists are augmented in human ASM cells by TNF-α. CD38-deficient mice fail to develop airway hyperresponsiveness following intranasal TNF-α or IL-13 challenge, suggesting a role in asthma. The role of CD38 in human asthma remains unknown. We hypothesized that CD38 expression will be elevated in ASM cells from asthmatic donors (ASMA cells). CD38 mRNA and ADP-ribosyl cyclase activity were measured in cells maintained in growth-arrested conditions and exposed to vehicle or TNF-α (10-40 ng/ml). TNF-α-induced induction of CD38 expression was greater in ASMA than in ASM cells from nonasthmatic donors (ASMNA). In four of the six donors, basal and TNF-α-induced ERK and p38 MAPK activation were higher in ASMA than ASMNA cells. JNK MAPK activation was lower in ASMA than ASMNA cells. Nuclear NF-κB (p50 subunit) and phosphorylated c-Jun were comparable in cells from both groups, although nuclear c-Fos (part of the AP-1 complex) levels were lower in ASMA than ASMNA cells. NF-κB or AP-1 binding to their consensus sequences was comparable in ASMNA and ASMA cells, as are the decay kinetics of CD38 mRNA. The findings suggest that the differential induction of CD38 by TNF-α in ASMA cells is due to increased transcriptional regulation involving ERK and p38 MAPK activation and is independent of changes in NF-κB or AP-1 activation. The findings suggest a potential role for CD38 in the pathophysiology of asthma.

Transaldolase deficiency influences the pentose phosphate pathway, mitochondrial homoeostasis and apoptosis signal processing

TAL (transaldolase) was originally described in the yeast as an enzyme of the PPP (pentose phosphate pathway). However, certain organisms and mammalian tissues lack TAL, and the overall reason for its existence is unclear. Recently, deletion of Ser(171) (TALDeltaS171) was found in five patients causing inactivation, proteasome-mediated degradation and complete deficiency of TAL. In the present study, microarray and follow-up Western-blot, enzyme-activity and metabolic studies of TALDeltaS171 TD (TAL-deficient) lymphoblasts revealed co-ordinated changes in the expression of genes involved in the PPP, mitochondrial biogenesis, oxidative stress, and Ca(2+) fluxing. Sedoheptulose 7-phosphate was accumulated, whereas G6P (glucose 6-phosphate) was depleted, indicating a failure to recycle G6P for the oxidative branch of the PPP. Nucleotide analysis showed depletion of NADPH and NAD(+) and accumulation of ADP-ribose. TD cells have diminished Deltapsi(m) (mitochondrial transmembrane potential) and increased mitochondrial mass associated with increased production of nitric oxide and ATP. TAL deficiency resulted in enhanced spontaneous and H(2)O(2)-induced apoptosis. TD lymphoblasts showed increased expression of CD38, which hydrolyses NAD(+) into ADP-ribose, a trigger of Ca(2+) release from the endoplasmic reticulum that, in turn, facilitated CD20-induced apoptosis. By contrast, TD cells were resistant to CD95/Fas-induced apoptosis, owing to a dependence of caspase activity on redox-sensitive cysteine residues. Normalization of TAL activity by adeno-associated-virus-mediated gene transfer reversed the elevated CD38 expression, ATP and Ca(2+) levels, suppressed H(2)O(2)- and CD20-induced apoptosis and enhanced Fas-induced cell death. The present study identified the TAL deficiency as a modulator of mitochondrial homoeostasis, Ca(2+) fluxing and apoptosis.

Glucocorticoid regulation of CD38 expression in human airway smooth muscle cells: role of dual specificity phosphatase 1

The enzymatic activity of CD38, ADP-ribosyl cyclase, synthesizes the calcium mobilizing molecule cyclic ADP-ribose from beta-NAD. In human airway smooth muscle (HASM) cells, CD38 expression is augmented by the inflammatory cytokine, TNF-alpha, causing increased intracellular calcium response to agonists. The transcriptional and posttranscriptional regulation of CD38 expression involves signaling through MAPKs and requires activation of NF-kappaB and activator protein-1 (AP-1). The cytokine-augmented CD38 expression is decreased by anti-inflammatory glucocorticoids due to inhibition of NF-kappaB activation and other mechanisms. In this study, we investigated glucocorticoid regulation of CD38 expression in HASM cells through the MKP-1. In HASM cells, dexamethasone and TNF-alpha induced MKP-1 expression (both mRNA and protein) rapidly. Dexamethasone decreased TNF-alpha-induced phosphorylation of the major MAPKs, i.e., ERK, p38, and JNK, and decreased the activation of NF-kappaB and AP-1. Dexamethasone also decreased CD38 expression induced by TNF-alpha, and part of this effect was attributable to decreased transcript stability. In cells transfected with MKP-1-specific small interfering RNAs (siRNAs), there was significant attenuation of MKP-1 expression and partial, but nonsignificant, reversal of dexamethasone inhibition of CD38 expression. These results indicate that regulation of CD38 expression in HASM cells by glucocorticoids involves decreased signaling through MAPKs and activation of transcription factors. The glucocorticoid effects on decreased CD38 expression and function result from regulation through transcription and transcript stability.

Regulation of the cd38 promoter in human airway smooth muscle cells by TNF-alpha and dexamethasone

Background

CD38 is expressed in human airway smooth muscle (HASM) cells, regulates intracellular calcium, and its expression is augmented by tumor necrosis factor alpha (TNF-α). CD38 has a role in airway hyperresponsiveness, a hallmark of asthma, since deficient mice develop attenuated airway hyperresponsiveness compared to wild-type mice following intranasal challenges with cytokines such as IL-13 and TNF-α. Regulation of CD38 expression in HASM cells involves the transcription factor NF-κB, and glucocorticoids inhibit this expression through NF-κB-dependent and -independent mechanisms. In this study, we determined whether the transcriptional regulation of CD38 expression in HASM cells involves response elements within the promoter region of this gene.

Methods

We cloned a putative 3 kb promoter fragment of the human cd38 gene into pGL3 basic vector in front of a luciferase reporter gene. Sequence analysis of the putative cd38 promoter region revealed one NF-κB and several AP-1 and glucocorticoid response element (GRE) motifs. HASM cells were transfected with the 3 kb promoter, a 1.8 kb truncated promoter that lacks the NF-κB and some of the AP-1 sites, or the promoter with mutations of the NF-κB and/or AP-1 sites. Using the electrophoretic mobility shift assays, we determined the binding of nuclear proteins to oligonucleotides encoding the putative cd38 NF-κB, AP-1, and GRE sites, and the specificity of this binding was confirmed by gel supershift analysis with appropriate antibodies.

Results

TNF-α induced a two-fold activation of the 3 kb promoter following its transfection into HASM cells. In cells transfected with the 1.8 kb promoter or promoter constructs lacking NF-κB and/or AP-1 sites or in the presence of dexamethasone, there was no induction in the presence of TNF-α. The binding of nuclear proteins to oligonucleotides encoding the putative cd38 NF-κB site and some of the six AP-1 sites was increased by TNF-α, and to some of the putative cd38 GREs by dexamethasone.

Conclusion

The EMSA results and the cd38 promoter-reporter assays confirm the functional role of NF-κB, AP-1 and GREs in the cd38 promoter in the transcriptional regulation of CD38.

Platelet-Derived Growth Factor Receptor Regulates Myeloid and Monocytic Differentiation of HL-60 Cells

Here, we show that the platelet-derived growth factor receptor (PDGFR) regulates myeloid and monocytic differentiation of HL-60 myeloblastic leukemia cells in response to retinoic acid (RA) and vitamin D3 (D3), respectively. Both RA and D3 decreased the expression of PDGFR-alpha and PDGFR-beta throughout differentiation. When cells were treated with the PDGFR inhibitor AG1296 in addition to RA or D3, signs of terminal differentiation such as inducible oxidative metabolism and cell substrate adhesion were enhanced. These changes were accompanied by an increased extracellular signal-regulated kinase 1/2 activation. AG1296 also resulted in elevated expression of differentiation markers CD11b and CD66c when administered with RA or D3. Interestingly, other markers did not follow the same pattern. Cells receiving AG1296 in addition to RA or D3 showed decreased G1-G0 arrest and CD14, CD38, and CD89 expression. We thus provide evidence that certain sets of differentiation markers can be enhanced, whereas others can be inhibited by the PDGFR pathway. In addition, we found calcium levels to be decreased by RA and D3 but increased when AG1296 was given in addition to RA or D3, suggesting that calcium levels decrease during myeloid or monocytic differentiation, and elevated calcium levels can disturb the expression of certain differentiation markers.

TNF-alpha induced CD38 expression in human airway smooth muscle cells: role of MAP kinases and transcription factors NF-kappaB and AP-1

In human airway smooth muscle (HASM) cells, the expression of CD38, which synthesizes the calcium-mobilizing molecule cyclic ADP-ribose, is augmented by TNF-alpha, a cytokine implicated in asthma. We determined the role of mitogen-activated protein kinase (MAPK) in the activation of NF-kappaB and AP-1 in the regulation of CD38 expression in HASM cells. In HASM cells exposed to TNF-alpha (40 ng/ml), the inhibitors of extracellular signal-regulated kinase (ERK), p38, or c-Jun NH(2)-terminal kinase (JNK) decreased CD38 expression and ADP-ribosyl cyclase activity. Transfection of HASM cells with a dominant negative MEK decreased while a wild-type ERK increased TNF-alpha-induced CD38 expression. Electrophoretic mobility shift assays (EMSAs) were performed using nuclear proteins and consensus sequences to detect the effect of the MAPKs on NF-kappaB and AP-1 activation. EMSAs confirmed the role of p38 and JNK in mediating NF-kappaB and AP-1 activation. Transfection of a dominant negative c-Jun decreased TNF-alpha-induced CD38 expression indicating involvement of AP-1. Stability of TNF-alpha-induced CD38 transcripts were determined in the presence of MAPK inhibitors after arresting the transcription with actinomycin D. Transcript stability decreased in the presence of ERK and p38 MAPK, but not the JNK, inhibitors. These results indicate that regulation of CD38 expression through p38 and JNK MAPKs involves NF-kappaB and AP-1 activation, and ERK and p38 MAPKs also regulate expression posttranscriptionally through message stability.

Selective upregulation of the ADP-ribosyl cyclases CD38 and CD157 by TNF but not by RANK-L reveals differences in downstream signaling

In macrophages and osteoclast precursors, the cytokines TNF and RANK-L induce similar downstream pathways and share some of the same adaptor molecules. However, despite these similarities, no defined signaling schematic has emerged to show how each cytokine favors particular pathways. In this report, we investigate whether TNF and RANK-L differentially regulate ADP-ribosyl cyclases-enzymes that are unique in being crucial for immunological function yet detrimental to osteoclastogenesis. TNF but not RANK-L led to the sustained upregulation of both CD38 and CD157 as demonstrated by real-time PCR and flow cytometry. Further investigation demonstrated that this upregulation was a result of continuous, direct TNF signaling and involved JNK, and more critically PKC and NF-κB. Using this approach allowed us to highlight the relative importance of the PKC, NF-κB, and JNK pathways in actualizing proper outcomes of TNF signaling. Albeit speculative, we believe that differences between TNF- and RANK-l-induced activation of downstream signaling pathways, in particular PKC, are crucial for determining whether progenitor cells become geared for immunity or bone resorption.