Are vegetated drainage ditches effective for nitrogen removal under cold temperatures?

Increased anaerobic conditions promote the denitrifying nitrogen removal potential and limit anammox substrate acquisition within paddy irrigation and drainage units

Microbial nitrogen (N) removal is crucial for purifying surface water quality in paddy irrigation and drainage units (IDUs). However, the spatiotemporal microbial N removal potential characteristics within these IDUs and the effects of changing anaerobic conditions on this potential remain insufficiently studied. In this study, we investigated the microbial N removal potential of conventional rice-wheat rotation and anaerobically enhanced rice-crayfish rotation IDUs using field measurements, isotope tracing techniques, and quantitative PCR. Our findings reveal that paddy fields were identified as hotspots for anammox activity, contributing to 76.0 %-97.4 % of the total anammox N removal potential in the IDU, while denitrification processes in ditches accounted for 43.5 %-77.4 % of the IDU's denitrification potential. During the rice transplanting period, the anammox N removal potential peaked, representing 35.8 % and 71.8 % of the total anammox N removal potential of the paddy fields in rice-wheat and rice-crayfish IDUs, respectively. An increase in anaerobic conditions diminished the anammox N removal potential while amplifying denitrification capabilities. The N removal potential in paddy fields decreased with increasing depth, contrasting with the relative stability in ditches. Spatiotemporal fluctuations in N removal potentials within these units are influenced by Fe2+ concentration, carbon and N content, WFPS, and pH levels. This study provides a scientific basis for improving nitrogen removal and water quality treatment in IDUs.

Enhanced nutrient removal in agro-industrial wastes-amended hybrid floating treatment wetlands treating real sewage: Laboratory microcosms to field-scale studies

The use of natural agro-industrial materials as suspended fillers (SFs) in floating treatment wetlands (FTWs) to enhance nutrient removal performance has recently been gaining significant attention. However, the knowledge concerning the nutrient removal performance enhancement by different SFs (alone and in mixtures) and the major removal pathways is so far inadequate. The current research, for the first time, carried out a critical analysis using five different natural agro-industrial materials (biochar, zeolite, alum sludge, woodchip, flexible solid packing) as SFs in various FTWs of 20 L microcosm tanks, 450 L outdoor mesocosms, and a field-scale urban pond treating real wastewater over 180 d. The findings demonstrated that the incorporation of SFs in FTWs enhanced the removal performance of total nitrogen (TN) by 20-57% and total phosphorus (TP) by 23-63%. SFs further enhanced macrophyte growth and biomass production, leading to considerable increases in nutrient standing stocks. Although all the hybrid FTWs showed acceptable treatment performances, FTWs set up with mixtures of all five SFs significantly enhanced biofilm formation and enriched the abundances of the microbial community related to nitrification and denitrification processes, supporting the detected excellent N retention. N mass balance assessment demonstrated that nitrification-denitrification was the major N removal pathway in reinforced FTWs, and the high removal efficiency of TP was attributable to the incorporation of SFs into the FTWs. Nutrient removal efficiencies ranked in the following order among the various trials: microcosm scale (TN: 99.3% and TP: 98.4%) > mesocosm scale (TN: 84.0% and TP: 95.0%) > field scale (TN: -15.0-73.7% and TP: -31.5-77.1%). These findings demonstrate that hybrid FTWs could be easily scaled up for the removal of pollutants from eutrophic freshwater systems over the medium term in an environmentally-friendly way in regions with similar environmental conditions. Moreover, it demonstrates hybrid FTW as a novel way of disposing of significant quantities of wastes, showing a win-win means with a huge potential for large-scale application.

Vegetated urban streams have sufficient purification ability but high internal nutrient loadings: Microbial communities and nutrient release dynamics

The release of nutrients back into the water column due to macrophyte litter decay could offset the benefits of nutrient removal by hydrophytes within urban streams. However, the influence of this internal nutrient cycling on the overlying water quality and bacterial community structure is still an open question. Hence, litter decomposition trials using six hydrophytes, Typha latifolia (TL), Phragmites australis (PAU), Hydrilla verticillata (HV), Oenanthe javanica (OJ), Myriophyllum aquaticum (MA), and Potamogeton crispus (PC), were performed using the litterbag approach to mimic a 150-day plant litter decay in sediment-water systems. Field assessment using simple in/out mass balances and uptake by plant species was carried out to show the potential for phytoremediation and its mechanisms. Results from two years of monitoring (2020-2021) indicated mean total nitrogen (TN) retention efficiencies of 7.2-60.14 % and 9.5-55.6 % for total phosphorus (TP) in the studied vegetated urban streams. Nutrient retention efficiencies showed temporal variations, which depended on seasonal temperature. Mass balance analysis indicated that macrophyte assimilation, sediment adsorption, and microbial transformation accounted for 10.31-41.74 %, 0.84-3.00 %, and 6.92-48.24 % removal of the inlet TN loading, respectively. Hydrophyte detritus decay induced alterations in physicochemical parameters while significantly increasing the N and P levels in the overlying water and sediment. Decay rates varied among macrophytes in the order of HV (0.00436 g day^-1) > MA (0.00284 g day^-1) > PC (0.00251 g day^-1) > OJ (0.00135 g day^-1) > TL (0.00095 g day^-1) > PAU (0.00057 g day^-1). 16S rRNA gene sequencing analysis showed an increase in microbial species richness and diversity in the early phase of litter decay. The abundances of denitrification (nirS and nirK) and nitrification (AOA and AOB) genes also increased in the early stage and then decreased during the decay process. Results of this study conducted in seven urban streams in northern China demonstrate the direct effects of hydrophytes in encouraging nutrient transformation and stream self-purification. Results also demonstrate that macrophyte detritus decay could drive not only the nutrient conversions but also the microbial community structure and activities in sediment-water systems. Consequently, to manage internal sources and conversions of nutrients, hydrophytic detritus (e.g., floating/submerged macrophytes) must be suppressed and harvested.

Does rice straw addition and/or Vallisneria natans (Lour.) planting contribute to enhancement in nitrate nitrogen and phosphorus removal in constructed wetlands under low temperature?

It is a global concern that nitrogen and phosphorus removal performances of constructed wetlands (CWs) are limited during cold weather. This study analyzed nutrient removal efficiencies and mechanisms in six CWs including combinations between evergreen submerged vegetation planting and rice straw adding under low temperature. The results showed that both unvegetated and vegetated CWs achieved the highest removal rates of total nitrogen (TN) (85.1-86.6%) and NO₃^--N (98.2-98.7%) with increases of approximately 56% and 68% by adding rice straw in water, respectively. Moreover, microbial denitrification accounted for reduction in over 70% of influent TN load. Planting vegetation, adding rice straw or their combination could all improve total phosphorus removal. Compared with adding rice straw in sediment, more diversifying bacterial community and higher abundances of some anaerobic fermentative species in the rice straw biofilm might have contributed to higher nitrogen removal in CWs with rice straw added in water.

Characterizing the impacts of macrophyte-dominated ponds on nitrogen sources and sinks by coupling multiscale models

Macrophyte-dominated ponds, widely distributed in lowland areas, play an important role in nitrogen (N) retention for nonpoint source pollution. However, their impacts on N sources and sinks are scarcely quantified at a watershed scale. This study aimed to investigate N dynamics (sources, sinks, transport, etc.) of macrophyte-dominated ponds and their driving factors in a typical lowland artificial watershed (the Zhong River Watershed) in East China. For this purpose, an hourly-scale pond model (nitrogen dynamic model for macrophyte-dominated ponds, NDP-Pond) was developed, and coupled with a daily scale watershed model (Nitrogen Dynamic Polder model, NDP) to simulate N dynamics, and estimate N retention in macrophyte-dominated ponds. A comparison with the measured water level and total nitrogen (TN) revealed an acceptable model performance (coefficient of determination (R²) > 0.53) for these two models. Based on the N source/sink simulations, we found that 1) macrophyte-dominated ponds showed a large TN removal capacity with a rate of 55%, and a TN loading removal rate of 67 kg·ha^-1·yr^-1. 2) Denitrification was the main pathway for N removal with a contribution of 57.7%, followed by the uptake of macrophytes (35.8%) and sedimentation (6.5%). 3) The optimal coverage of macrophytes (Alternanthera philoxeroides) to enhance N removal is 2-4 kg·m^-2. 4) During the macrophyte-growth period, the TN removal capacity of the pond was higher with a retention time of 1-10 days. Increasing the pond retention time would decrease the N removal efficiency. This study revealed the high value of coupling multiscale models to gain in-depth insights into N retention in macrophyte-dominated pond ecosystems.

Effects of water level on nitrous oxide emissions from vegetated ditches

Nitrous oxide (N₂O) is considered a powerful greenhouse gas. Vegetated ditches are an important source of N₂O emissions in the agricultural systems. However, few studies have examined on the relationship between N₂O emissions and the water level in vegetated ditches. To investigate the effect of water level on the N₂O emissions, three pilot-scale ditches vegetated with Myriophyllum aquaticum were constructed with low (LW), medium (MW), and high (HW) water levels. The examined results indicated that the M. aquaticum ditches decreased N₂O emissions by 38.4% and 67.9% in MW and HW, respectively, as compared to the LW ditch. In addition, the N₂O emission factor decreased with increasing water level in the order of: LW (0.18%) > MW (0.11%) > HW (0.06%). The MW and HW ditches reduced the N₂O emissions by controlling the sediment nitrogen contents, in which the ammonia nitrogen increased with increasing the level of water, while nitrate nitrogen decreased with increasing the level of water. The increase in the level of water significantly reduced the gene abundance of ammonia-oxidizing archaea (AOA) (p < 0.05), thereby reducing the N₂O emissions in the MW and HW conditions due to the positive correlation between N₂O emissions and AOA gene abundances. The unclassified_k_norank_d_Bacteria was the dominant denitrifying bacterial genus observed in the M. aquaticum ditches, and its highly relative abundance yielded low N₂O emissions in the HW ditch. These findings indicate that reducing N₂O emissions may be achieved by controlling the water level in vegetated ditches.

A comparison of the mechanisms and performances of Acorus calamus, Pontederia cordata and Alisma plantagoaquatica in removing nitrogen from farmland wastewater

This study examined the performances of Acorus calamus, Pontederia cordata, and Alisma plantagoaquatica in removing nitrogen (N) from farmland wastewater. P. cordata showed the fastest rate of N removal, followed by A. plantagoaquatica, whereas that of A. calamus was slowest. P. cordata and A. plantagoaquatica achieving a greater rate of TN reduction in soil than that by A. calamus. A. plantagoaquatica demonstrated the highest N adsorption capacity, 32.6% and 392.1% higher than that of P. cordata and A. calamus, respectively. The higher potential nitrification and denitrification rate, and abundance of functional genes in the P. cordata microcosm resulted in a stronger process of nitrification-denitrification, which accounted for 65.99% of TN loss. Plant uptake and nitrification-denitrification were responsible for 50.06% and 49.94% of TN removed within the A. plantagoaquatica. Nitrification-denitrification accounted for 86.35% of TN loss in A. calamus. These findings helped to insight into N removal mechanisms in different plants.

Nutrient dynamics and retention in a vegetated drainage ditch receiving nutrient-rich sewage at low temperatures

Vegetated agricultural drainage ditches (VDs) are a relatively new best management practice for pesticide and nutrient mitigation that is receiving increasing global interest. However, VDs are seldom used during winter due to considerable deterioration of pollutants reduction efficiencies driven by low-temperature effects. Limited knowledge on the internal loading of nutrient in VDs due to vegetation decomposition calls for further evaluation. Here, we assessed plants growth characteristics and nutrient dynamics in a field-scale VD receiving nutrient-rich sewage and planted with the overwintering plants: Acorus gramineus, Myriophyllum aquaticum and Iris sibirica. Water purification performance showed average TN, NH₄-N, NO₃-N, TP and PO₄-P reduction efficiencies of 44, 46, 43, 52 and 46%, respectively, over the winter period. Maximum reduction rates of TN and TP were 5.31 and 0.34 g^-2 d^-1, respectively. Of the total nutrient removal by plants of 5.37 × 10³ kg N y^-1 and 0.65 × 10³ kg P y^-1 from the VD system, A. gramineus contributed 65.7% and 72.1%, respectively. Nonetheless, substantial amounts of N and P retained within the aboveground biomass were released into the water column as ditch plant shoots decayed to deteriorate the water quality. All three species, A. gramineus, M. aquaticum and I. sibirica demonstrated considerable nutrient accumulation during winter and facilitated nutrient retention in the VD system. Consequently, they can be considered effective overwintering species of choice in VDs for purifying nutrient-rich water and potentially appropriate for vulgarizing elsewhere, particularly throughout the winter season.

Effects of plants competition on critical bacteria selection and pollutants dynamics in a long-term polyculture constructed wetland

The effects of mix planting on the functions of plants, microorganisms, and their interactions were studied in a CW planted with Phragmites australis and Typha orientalis over six years. Findings show notable competition among plant species, with excessive overgrowth of the dominant species (P. australis) over T. orientalis. The excessive outcompeting by P. australis resulted in significantly higher plant density and biomass of 20.1 times and 11.2 times, respectively than that of T. orientalis. Interspecific competition appeared to considerably intensify plants contributions to nitrogen and phosphorus removal, which increased from circa 9% in the first year up to 42% in the sixth year. High-throughput pyrosequencing and network analyses demonstrated that the dominant species stands harbor diverse bacterial communities that could enhance the wetland performance through carbon degradation, nutrient cycling, and supporting plant growth. These results provide useful insights into the interactive effects of plants and bacteria in polyculture constructed wetlands.

Pollutant removal from agricultural drainage water using a novel double-layer ditch with biofilm carriers

Agricultural drainage ditches can prevent flooding and mitigate agricultural pollution; however, the performance is unsatisfactory in plateau areas like the Dianchi Lake basin. Thus, a novel double-layer ditch system (DDS) with a fibrous packing as biofilm carriers was developed to form the carrier-attached biofilms and enhance the pollutant removal. The results indicated the DDS performed better than a single-layer ditch system, and annual average removal efficiencies of TN, NO₃^--N, NH₄⁺-N, TP, COD and SS were 18.61%, 17.13%, 7.74%, 11.90%, 11.95% and 23.71%, respectively. High amount and carbon, nitrogen and phosphorus contents of biofilms are favourable to pollutant removal by DDS. Although bacterial diversity of biofilms remained relatively stable throughout the year, the relative abundance of dominant assemblages varied greatly. Denitrifying microorganisms affiliated with Bacteroidetes might contribute to effective NO₃^--N reduction. This study demonstrates DDS performed well and provides a novel method for application of biofilm carriers in drainage ditches.