Line Tension Controls Liquid-Disordered + Liquid-Ordered Domain Size Transition in Lipid Bilayers

Pattern formation of lipid domains in bilayer membranes

Phase separation plays an important role in spatial organization and material distribution of biological membranes, which are essential for crucial biological functions ranging from signaling and stress response to vesicle trafficking. Domains arising from demixing of molecules coarsen indefinitely unless growth is arrested at a finite size by additional mechanisms (e.g., membrane elasticity). The resulting finite-size domains self-organize into regular patterns such as stripes and dots, which are called modulated phases. Here, we examine the size and morphology of lipid domains with a minimal theoretical model that considers both the elastic deformation of the membrane and the chemical interactions between lipids, which are coupled by a preferred membrane curvature that depends on the local lipid composition. Microscopically, the coupling is caused by an asymmetry between leaflets which emerges after extra lipids (e.g., DPPC) are introduced to the outer leaflet. The additional lipid partitions preferentially to domains where it is enriched, creating a preferred curvature that depends on local composition. We use an amplitude expansion to determine the domain size and morphology of patterns that minimize the total free energy, which is validated by numerical simulations and compared against experiments in synthetic model membranes and cell-derived membranes. The morphology of patterns varies with membrane lipid composition following a complex morphological diagram, which is in good agreement with experiments. The domain size decreases monotonically with a membrane bending modulus but can be non-monotonic with surface tension. Our results offer testable predictions, such as pattern hysteresis upon cycling external stimuli, diverse pattern morphology near critical points, and non-monotonic dependence of the domain size on osmotic pressure, which motivate future experiments. The presented theoretical framework is generally applicable to pattern formation on deformable surfaces.

Structural dissection of ergosterol metabolism reveals a pathway optimized for membrane phase separation

Sterols are among the most abundant lipids in eukaryotic cells yet are synthesized through notoriously long metabolic pathways. It has been proposed that the molecular evolution of such pathways must have required each step to increase the capacity of its product to condense and order phospholipids. Here, we carry out a systematic analysis of the ergosterol pathway that leverages the yeast vacuole's capacity to phase separate into ordered membrane domains. In the post-synthetic steps specific to ergosterol biosynthesis, we find that successive modifications act to oscillate ordering capacity, settling on a level that supports phase separation while retaining fluidity of the resulting domains. Simulations carried out with each intermediate showed how conformers in the sterol's alkyl tail are capable of modulating long-range ordering of phospholipids, which could underlie changes in phase behavior. Our results indicate that the complexity of sterol metabolism could have resulted from the need to balance lipid interactions required for membrane organization.

The Importance of Bilayer Asymmetry in Biological Membranes: Insights from Model Membranes

This mini-review intends to highlight the importance of bilayer asymmetry. Biological membranes are complex structures that are a physical barrier separating the external environment from the cellular content. This complex bilayer comprises an extensive lipid repertory, suggesting that the different lipid structures might play a role in the membrane. Interestingly, this vast repertory of lipids is asymmetrically distributed between leaflets that form the lipid bilayer. Here, we discuss the properties of the plasma membrane from the perspective of experimental model membranes, consisting of simplified and controlled in vitro systems. We summarize some crucial features of the exoplasmic (outer) and cytoplasmic (inner) leaflets observed through investigations using symmetric and asymmetric membranes. Symmetric model membranes for the exoplasmic leaflet have a unique lipid composition that might form a coexistence of phases, namely the liquid disordered and liquid order phases. These phase domains may appear in different sizes and shapes depending on lipid composition and lipid-lipid interactions. In contrast, symmetric model membranes for the cytoplasmic leaflet form a fluid phase. We discuss the outcomes reported in the literature for asymmetric bilayers, which vary according to lipid compositions and, consequently, reflect different intra- and inter-leaflet interactions. Interestingly, the asymmetric bilayer could show induced domains in the inner leaflet, or it could decrease the tendency of the outer leaflet to phase separation. If cells regulate the lipid composition of the plasma membrane, they can adjust the existence and sizes of the domains by tuning the lipid composition.

Contact Angle Measurements of the Apparent Line Tension Are Spurious

Phenomena in diverse contexts such as wetting, biological assembly, and manufacturing are attributed to the three-phase line tension. However, decades of line tension estimates based on contact angles of droplets controversially span 6 orders of magnitude, raising the question of which measurements are authoritative. Here, we show with experiments and calculations that contact angles fail to estimate line tension regardless of length scale, technique, and measurement quality. Line tension measurements based on contact angles are driven by two distinct and spurious mechanisms: body forces under ideal conditions, and data scatter under noisy conditions.

Cryo-EM images of phase-separated lipid bilayer vesicles analyzed with a machine-learning approach

Lateral lipid heterogeneity (i.e., raft formation) in biomembranes plays a functional role in living cells. Three-component mixtures of low- and high-melting lipids plus cholesterol offer a simplified experimental model for raft domains in which a liquid-disordered (Ld) phase coexists with a liquid-ordered (Lo) phase. Using such models, we recently showed that cryogenic electron microscopy (cryo-EM) can detect phase separation in lipid vesicles based on differences in bilayer thickness. However, the considerable noise within cryo-EM data poses a significant challenge for accurately determining the membrane phase state at high spatial resolution. To this end, we have developed an image-processing pipeline that utilizes machine learning (ML) to predict the bilayer phase in projection images of lipid vesicles. Importantly, the ML method exploits differences in both the thickness and molecular density of Lo compared to Ld, which leads to improved phase identification. To assess accuracy, we used artificial images of phase-separated lipid vesicles generated from all-atom molecular dynamics simulations of Lo and Ld phases. Synthetic ground-truth data sets mimicking a series of compositions along a tieline of Ld + Lo coexistence were created and then analyzed with various ML models. For all tieline compositions, we find that the ML approach can correctly identify the bilayer phase with >90% accuracy, thus providing a means to isolate the intensity profiles of coexisting Ld and Lo phases, as well as accurately determine domain-size distributions, number of domains, and phase-area fractions. The method described here provides a framework for characterizing nanoscopic lateral heterogeneities in membranes and paves the way for a more detailed understanding of raft properties in biological contexts.

Cholesterol and Lipid Rafts in the Biogenesis of Amyloid-β Protein and Alzheimer's Disease

Cholesterol has been conjectured to be a modulator of the amyloid cascade, the mechanism that produces the amyloid-β (Aβ) peptides implicated in the onset of Alzheimer's disease. We propose that cholesterol impacts the genesis of Aβ not through direct interaction with proteins in the bilayer, but indirectly by inducing the liquid-ordered phase and accompanying liquid-liquid phase separations, which partition proteins in the amyloid cascade to different lipid domains and ultimately to different endocytotic pathways. We explore the full process of Aβ genesis in the context of liquid-ordered phases induced by cholesterol, including protein partitioning into lipid domains, mechanisms of endocytosis experienced by lipid domains and secretases, and pH-controlled activation of amyloid precursor protein secretases in specific endocytotic environments. Outstanding questions on the essential role of cholesterol in the amyloid cascade are identified for future studies.

Lipid droplets as substrates for protein phase separation

Membrane-associated protein phase separation plays critical roles in cell biology, driving essential cellular phenomena from immune signaling to membrane traffic. Importantly, by reducing dimensionality from three to two dimensions, lipid bilayers can nucleate phase separation at far lower concentrations compared with those required for phase separation in solution. How might other intracellular lipid substrates, such as lipid droplets, contribute to nucleation of phase separation? Distinct from bilayer membranes, lipid droplets consist of a phospholipid monolayer surrounding a core of neutral lipids, and they are energy storage organelles that protect cells from lipotoxicity and oxidative stress. Here, we show that intrinsically disordered proteins can undergo phase separation on the surface of synthetic and cell-derived lipid droplets. Specifically, we find that the model disordered domains FUS LC and LAF-1 RGG separate into protein-rich and protein-depleted phases on the surfaces of lipid droplets. Owing to the hydrophobic nature of interactions between FUS LC proteins, increasing ionic strength drives an increase in its phase separation on droplet surfaces. The opposite is true for LAF-1 RGG, owing to the electrostatic nature of its interprotein interactions. In both cases, protein-rich phases on the surfaces of synthetic and cell-derived lipid droplets demonstrate molecular mobility indicative of a liquid-like state. Our results show that lipid droplets can nucleate protein condensates, suggesting that protein phase separation could be key in organizing biological processes involving lipid droplets.

Phospholipid Membranes as Chemically and Functionally Tunable Materials

The sheet-like lipid bilayer is the fundamental structural component of all cell membranes. Its building blocks are phospholipids and cholesterol. Their amphiphilic structure spontaneously leads to the formation of a bilayer in aqueous environment. Lipids are not just structural elements. Individual lipid species, the lipid membrane structure, and lipid dynamics influence and regulate membrane protein function. An exciting field is emerging where the membrane-associated material properties of different bilayer systems are used in designing innovative solutions for widespread applications across various fields, such as the food industry, cosmetics, nano- and biomedicine, drug storage and delivery, biotechnology, nano- and biosensors, and computing. Here, the authors summarize what is known about how lipids determine the properties and functions of biological membranes and how this has been or can be translated into innovative applications. Based on recent progress in the understanding of membrane structure, dynamics, and physical properties, a perspective is provided on how membrane-controlled regulation of protein functions can extend current applications and even offer new applications.

Water Hydrogen-Bond Mediated Layer by Layer Alignment of Lipid Rafts as a Precursor of Intermembrane Processes

Lipid rafts, which are dynamic nanodomains in the plasma membrane, play a crucial role in intermembrane processes by clustering together and growing in size within the plane of the membrane while also aligning with each other across different membranes. However, the physical origin of layer by layer alignment of lipid rafts remains to be elucidated. Here, by using fluorescence imaging and synchrotron X-ray reflectivity in a phase-separated multilayer system, we find that the alignment of raft-mimicking Lo domains is regulated by the distance between bilayers. Molecular dynamics simulations reveal that the aligned state is energetically preferred when the intermembrane distance is small due to its ability to minimize the volume of surface water, which has fewer water hydrogen bonds (HBs) compared to bulk water. Our results suggest that water HB-driven alignment of lipid rafts plays a role as a precursor of intermembrane processes such as cell-cell fusion, virus entry, and signaling.

Shear-Induced Nonequilibrium Patterns in Lipid Bilayer Membranes Exhibiting Phase Separation

The nonequilibrium dynamics of a fluid lipid membrane under external stimuli is an important issue that spans disciplines such as soft matter, biophysical chemistry, and interface science. This study investigated the dynamic response of lipid vesicles with order-disorder phase separation, which mimics a plasma membrane heterogeneity, to shear flow. Lipid vesicles were immobilized in a microfluidic chamber, and shear-induced nonequilibrium patterns on the membrane surface were observed by an optical microscope. We found that phase-separated membranes exhibit a dissipative structure of stripe patterns along the vortex flow on the membrane surface, and the number of stripes increased with the flow rate. At a high flow rate, the membrane exhibited a stripe-to-wave transition, where striped domains often migrated and the replacement of two different phases happened at vortex centers with time. We obtained a dynamic phase diagram of the shear-induced wave pattern by changing the flow rate, membrane components, and temperature. These findings could provide insight into the dissipative structures of lipid membranes out of equilibrium and flow-mediated mechanotransduction of biological membranes.

The use of hemifusion to create asymmetric giant unilamellar vesicles: Insights on induced order domains

The natural asymmetry of the lipid bilayer in biological membranes is, in part, a testament to the complexity of the structure and function of this barrier limiting and protecting cells (or organelles). These lipid bilayers consist of two lipid leaflets with different lipid compositions, resulting in unique interactions within each leaflet. These interactions, combined with interactions between the two leaflets, determine the overall behavior of the membrane. Model membranes provide the most suitable option for investigating the fundamental interactions of lipids. This report describes a comprehensive method to make asymmetric giant unilamellar vesicles (aGUVs) using the technique of hemifusion. In this method, calcium ions induce the hemifusion of giant unilamellar vesicles (GUVs) with a supported lipid bilayer (SLB), both having different lipid compositions. During hemifusion, a stalk, or a more commonly seen hemifusion diaphragm, connects the outer leaflets of GUVs and the SLB. The lateral diffusion of lipids naturally promotes the lipid exchange between the connected outer leaflets. After calcium chelation to prevent further fusion, a mechanical shear detaches aGUVs from the SLB. A fluorescence quench assay is employed to test the extent of bilayer asymmetry. A fluorescence quenching assay tests bilayer asymmetry and verifies dye and lipid migration to a GUV's outer leaflet.

Synthesis, insertion, and characterization of SARS-CoV-2 membrane protein within lipid bilayers

Throughout history, coronaviruses have posed challenges to both public health and the global economy; nevertheless, methods to combat them remain rudimentary, primarily due to the absence of experiments to understand the function of various viral components. Among these, membrane (M) proteins are one of the most elusive because of their small size and challenges with expression. Here, we report the development of an expression system to produce tens to hundreds of milligrams of M protein per liter of Escherichia coli culture. These large yields render many previously inaccessible structural and biophysical experiments feasible. Using cryo-electron microscopy and atomic force microscopy, we image and characterize individual membrane-incorporated M protein dimers and discover membrane thinning in the vicinity, which we validated with molecular dynamics simulations. Our results suggest that the resulting line tension, along with predicted induction of local membrane curvature, could ultimately drive viral assembly and budding.

Nanoscopic lipid domains determined by microscopy and neutron scattering

Biological membranes are highly complex supramolecular assemblies, which play central roles in biology. However, their complexity makes them challenging to study their nanoscale structures. To overcome this challenge, model membranes assembled using reduced sets of membrane-associated biomolecules have been found to be both excellent and tractable proxies for biological membranes. Due to their relative simplicity, they have been studied using a range of biophysical characterization techniques. In this review article, we will briefly detail the use of fluorescence and electron microscopies, and X-ray and neutron scattering techniques used over the past few decades to study the nanostructure of biological membranes.

Structural Changes Induced by Resveratrol in Monounsaturated and Polyunsaturated Phosphatidylcholine-Enriched Model Membranes

Resveratrol (Resv) is considered to exert a beneficial impact due to its radical scavenger, anti-microbial and anti-inflammatory properties through several mechanisms that could include its interaction with the cell plasma membrane. To address this issue, we investigated the influence of Resv on membrane lipid order and organization in large unilamellar vesicles composed of different lipids and ratios. The studied lipid membrane models were composed of phosphatidylcholine (PC) species (either palmitoyl-docosahexaenoyl phosphatidylcholine (PDPC) or palmitoyl-oleoyl phosphatidylcholine (POPC)), sphingomyelin (SM) and cholesterol (Chol). This study found that the addition of Resv resulted in complex membrane reorganization depending on the degree of fatty acid unsaturation at the sn-2 position, and the Lipid/Resv and SM/Chol ratios. Resv rigidified POPC-containing membranes and increased liquid-ordered (Lo) domain formation in 40/40/20 POPC/SM/Chol mixtures as this increase was lower at a 33/33/34 ratio. In contrast, Resv interacted with PDPC/SM/Chol mixtures in a bimodal manner by fluidizing/rigidifying the membranes in a dose-dependent way. Lo domain formation upon Resv addition occurred via the following bimodal mode of action: Lo domain size increased at low Resv concentrations; then, Lo domain size decreased at higher ones. To account for the variable effect of Resv, we suggest that it may act as a "spacer" at low doses, with a transition to a more "filler" position in the lipid bulk. We hypothesize that one of the roles of Resv is to tune the lipid order and organization of cell plasma membranes, which is closely linked to important cell functions such as membrane sorting and trafficking.

Natamycin interferes with ergosterol-dependent lipid phases in model membranes

Natamycin is an antifungal polyene macrolide that is used as a food preservative but also to treat fungal keratitis and other yeast infections. In contrast to other polyene antimycotics, natamycin does not form ion pores in the plasma membrane, but its mode of action is poorly understood. Using nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy of deuterated sterols, we find that natamycin slows the mobility of ergosterol and cholesterol in liquid-ordered (Lo) membranes to a similar extent. This is supported by molecular dynamics (MD) simulations, which additionally reveal a strong impact of natamycin dimers on sterol dynamics and water permeability. Interference with sterol-dependent lipid packing is also reflected in a natamycin-mediated increase in membrane accessibility for dithionite, particularly in bilayers containing ergosterol. NMR experiments with deuterated sphingomyelin (SM) in sterol-containing membranes reveal that natamycin reduces phase separation and increases lipid exchange in bilayers with ergosterol. In ternary lipid mixtures containing monounsaturated phosphatidylcholine, saturated SM, and either ergosterol or cholesterol, natamycin interferes with phase separation into Lo and liquid-disordered (Ld) domains, as shown by NMR spectroscopy. Employing the intrinsic fluorescence of natamycin in ultraviolet-sensitive microscopy, we can visualize the binding of natamycin to giant unilamellar vesicles (GUVs) and find that it has the highest affinity for the Lo phase in GUVs containing ergosterol. Our results suggest that natamycin specifically interacts with the sterol-induced ordered phase, in which it disrupts lipid packing and increases solvent accessibility. This property is particularly pronounced in ergosterol containing membranes, which could underlie the selective antifungal activity of natamycin.

Phase separation in a ternary DPPC/DOPC/POPC system with reducing hydration

The maintenance of plasma membrane structure is vital for the viability of cells. Disruption of this structure can lead to cell death. One important example is the macroscopic phase separation observed during dehydration associated with desiccation and freezing, often leading to loss of permeability and cell death. It has previously been shown that the hybrid lipid 1-palmitoyl-2-oleoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine (POPC) can act as a line-active component in ternary lipid systems, inhibiting macroscopic phase separation and stabilising membrane microdomains in lipid vesicles [1]. The domain size is found to decrease with increasing POPC concentration until complete mixing is observed. However, no such studies have been carried out at reduced hydration. To examine if this phase separation is unique to vesicles in excess water, we have conducted studies on several binary and ternary model membrane systems at both reduced hydration ("powder" type samples and oriented membrane stacks) and in excess water (supported lipid bilayers) at 0.2 mol fraction POPC, in the range where microdomain stabilisation is reported. Differential scanning calorimetry (DSC) and Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy (FTIR) are used to map phase transition temperatures, with X-ray and neutron scattering providing details of the changes in lipid packing and phase information within these boundaries. Atomic force microscopy (AFM) is used to image bilayers on a substrate in excess water. In all cases, macroscopic phase separation was observed rather than microdomain formation at this molar ratio. Thus POPC does not stabilise microdomains under these conditions, regardless of the type of model membrane, hydration or temperature. Thus we conclude that the driving force for separation under these conditions overcomes any linactant effects of the hybrid lipid.

Serinc5 Restricts HIV Membrane Fusion by Altering Lipid Order and Heterogeneity in the Viral Membrane

The host restriction factor, Serinc5, incorporates into budding HIV particles and inhibits their infection by an incompletely understood mechanism. We have previously reported that Serinc5 but not its paralogue, Serinc2, blocks HIV cell entry by membrane fusion, specifically by inhibiting fusion pore formation and dilation. A body of work suggests that Serinc5 may alter the conformation and clustering of the HIV fusion protein, Env. To contribute an additional perspective to the developing model of Serinc5 restriction, we assessed Serinc2 and Serinc5's effects on HIV pseudoviral membranes. By measuring pseudoviral membrane thickness via cryo-electron microscopy and order via the fluorescent dye, FLIPPER-TR, Serinc5 was found to increase membrane heterogeneity, skewing the distribution toward a larger fraction of the viral membrane in an ordered phase. We also directly observed for the first time the coexistence of membrane domains within individual viral membrane envelopes. Using a total internal reflection fluorescence-based single particle fusion assay, we found that treatment of HIV pseudoviral particles with phosphatidylethanolamine (PE) rescued HIV pseudovirus fusion from restriction by Serinc5, which was accompanied by decreased membrane heterogeneity and order. This effect was specific for PE and did not depend on acyl chain length or saturation. Together, these data suggest that Serinc5 alters multiple interrelated properties of the viral membrane─lipid chain order, rigidity, line tension, and lateral pressure─which decrease the accessibility of fusion intermediates and disfavor completion of fusion. These biophysical insights into Serinc5 restriction of HIV infectivity could contribute to the development of novel antivirals that exploit the same weaknesses.

Nano-scale domains in the plasma membrane are like macroscopic domains in asymmetric bilayers

Unfavorable lipid-lipid pairwise interactions between HiTm and LowTm lipids drive liquid-disordered (Ld) + liquid-ordered (Lo) phase separation. Large size of phase domains is opposed by lipid dipole repulsions, which are more significant compared with the pairwise interactions for naturally abundant LowTm lipids such as palmitoyl oleoyl phosphatidylcholine. During the nano-to-macro domain size transition, no lipid phase transition occurs, and measured properties of Ld + Lo nanodomains are found to be essentially the same as those of macrodomains. Use of macrodomains in mixtures to model cell plasma membranes (PM) is helpful, enabling study by optical microscopy. Use of asymmetric giant unilamellar vesicles to model a PM reveals that ordered phase domains in one leaflet induce ordered domains in an otherwise uniform phase in the apposing leaflet that models a cytoplasmic leaflet. Because macro and nano phase properties are so similar, we conclude that a cell PM that has nano-scale Ld + Lo phase domains in the exoplasmic leaflet is likely to induce nano-scale ordered domains in the cytoplasmic leaflet.

Structural diversity of photoswitchable sphingolipids for optodynamic control of lipid microdomains

Sphingolipids are a structurally diverse class of lipids predominantly found in the plasma membrane of eukaryotic cells. These lipids can laterally segregate with other rigid lipids and cholesterol into liquid-ordered domains that act as organizing centers within biomembranes. Owing the vital role of sphingolipids for lipid segregation, controlling their lateral organization is of utmost significance. Hence, we made use of the light-induced trans-cis isomerization of azobenzene-modified acyl chains to develop a set of photoswitchable sphingolipids with different headgroups (hydroxyl, galactosyl, phosphocholine) and backbones (sphingosine, phytosphingosine, tetrahydropyran-blocked sphingosine) that are able to shuttle between liquid-ordered and liquid-disordered regions of model membranes upon irradiation with UV-A (λ = 365 nm) and blue (λ = 470 nm) light, respectively. Using combined high-speed atomic force microscopy, fluorescence microscopy, and force spectroscopy, we investigated how these active sphingolipids laterally remodel supported bilayers upon photoisomerization, notably in terms of domain area changes, height mismatch, line tension, and membrane piercing. Hereby, we show that the sphingosine-based (Azo-β-Gal-Cer, Azo-SM, Azo-Cer) and phytosphingosine-based (Azo-α-Gal-PhCer, Azo-PhCer) photoswitchable lipids promote a reduction in liquid-ordered microdomain area when in the UV-adapted cis-isoform. In contrast, azo-sphingolipids having tetrahydropyran groups that block H-bonding at the sphingosine backbone (lipids named Azo-THP-SM, Azo-THP-Cer) induce an increase in the liquid-ordered domain area when in cis, accompanied by a major rise in height mismatch and line tension. These changes were fully reversible upon blue light-triggered isomerization of the various lipids back to trans, pinpointing the role of interfacial interactions for the formation of stable liquid-ordered domains.

Serotonergic drugs modulate the phase behavior of complex lipid bilayers

Serotonin is an endogenous neurotransmitter involved in both physiological and pathophysiological processes. Traditionally, serotonin acts as a ligand for G protein-coupled receptors (GPCRs) leading to subsequent cell signaling. However, serotonin can also bind to lipid membranes with high affinity and modulate the phase behavior in 1-palmitoyl-2-oleoyl-glycero-3-phosphocholine (POPC)/N-palmitoyl-D-erythro-sphingosylphosphorylcholine (PSM)/cholesterol model membranes mimicking the outer leaflet of the plasma membrane. Here, we investigated if serotonergic drugs containing the pharmacophore from serotonin would also modulate phase behavior in lipid membranes in a similar fashion. We used ²H NMR spectroscopy to explore the phase behavior of POPC/PSM/cholesterol (4/4/2 molar ratio) mixtures in the presence of the serotonergic drugs aripiprazole, BRL-54443, BW-723C86, and CP-135807 at a lipid to drug molar ratio of 10:1. POPC and PSM were perdeuterated in the palmitoyl chain, respectively, and prepared in individual samples. Numerical lineshape simulations of the ²H NMR spectra were used to calculate the order parameter profiles and projected lengths of the saturated acyl chains. All serotonergic drugs induce two components in ²H NMR spectra, indicating that they increased the hydrophobic mismatch between the thickness of the coexisting lipid phases leading to larger domain sizes, relatively similarly to serotonin. AFM force indentation and Raman spectral studies, which interrogate membrane mechanical properties, also indicate changes in membrane order in the presence of these drugs. These findings highlight how serotonergic drugs alter membrane phase behavior and could modulate both target and other membrane proteins, possibly explaining the side effects observed for serotonergic and other clinically relevant drugs.

Improving our picture of the plasma membrane: Rafts induce ordered domains in a simplified model cytoplasmic leaflet

By study of asymmetric membranes, models of the cell plasma membrane (PM) have improved, with more realistic properties of the asymmetric lipid composition of the membrane being explored. We used hemifusion of symmetric giant unilamellar vesicles (GUVs) with a supported lipid bilayer (SLB) to engineer bilayer leaflets of different composition. During hemifusion, only the outer leaflets of GUV and SLB are connected, exchanging lipids by simple diffusion. aGUVs were detached from the SLB for study. In general these aGUVs are formed with one leaflet that phase-separates into Ld (liquid disordered) + Lo (liquid ordered) phases, and another leaflet with lipid composition that would form a single fluid phase in a symmetric bilayer. We observed that ordered phases of either Lo or Lβ (gel phase) induce an ordered domain in the apposed fluid leaflet that lacks high melting lipids. Results suggest both an inter-leaflet and an intra-leaflet redistribution of cholesterol. We used C-Laurdan spectral images to investigate the lipid packing/order of aGUVs, finding that cholesterol partitions into the induced ordered domains. We suggest this behavior to be commonplace, that when Ld + Lo phase separation occurs in a cell PM exoplasmic leaflet, an induced order domain forms in the cytoplasmic leaflet.

Phase Separation in Liposomes Determined by Ergosterol and Classified Using Machine Learning

Recent studies indicated that ergosterol (Erg) helps form strongly ordered lipid domains in membranes that depend on their chemical characters. However, direct evidence of concentration-dependent interaction of Erg with lipid membranes has not been reported. We studied the Erg concentration-dependent changes in the phase behaviors of membranes using cell-sized liposomes containing 1,2-Dioleoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine (DOPC)/1,2-dipalmitoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine (DPPC). We observed the concentration range of phase separation in ternary membranes was significantly wider when Erg rather than cholesterol (Chol) was used as the sterol component. We used machine learning for the first time to analyze microscopic images of cell-sized liposomes and identify phase-separated structures. The automated method was successful in identifying homogeneous membranes but performance remained data-limited for the identification of phase separation domains characterized by more complex features.

Control of Line Tension at Phase-Separated Lipid Domain Boundaries: Monounsaturated Fatty Acids with Different Chain Lengths and Osmotic Pressure

Line tension at phase-separated lipid domain boundaries is an important factor that governs the stability of the phase separation. We studied the control of the line tension in lipid membranes composed of dioleoylphosphocholine (DOPC), dipalmitoylphosphocholine (DPPC), and cholesterol (Chol) by the addition of the following three monounsaturated fatty acids (MUFAs) with different chain lengths: palmitoleic acid (PaA), oleic acid (OA), and eicosenoic acid (EiA). In addition, we attempted to alter the line tension by applying osmotic pressure. The phase behavior of the MUFA-containing lipid membranes in the presence and absence of osmotic stress was observed by fluorescence and confocal laser scanning microscopy. The line tension was quantitatively measured from the domain boundary fluctuation by flicker spectroscopy, and the interactions between the lipids and MUFAs were examined by differential scanning calorimetry. PaA and OA, which are shorter MUFAs, decreased the line tension, whereas EiA changed the liquid domain to a solid domain. The osmotic pressure increased the line tension, even in the presence of MUFAs. It may be possible to control the line tension by combining the chemical approach of MUFA addition and the physical approach of applying osmotic pressure.

Domain Size Regulation in Phospholipid Model Membranes Using Oil Molecules and Hybrid Lipids

The formation of domains in multicomponent lipid mixtures has been suggested to play a role in moderating signal transduction in cells. Understanding how domain size may be regulated by both hybrid lipid molecules and impurities is important for understanding real biological processes; at the same time, developing model systems where domain size can be regulated is crucial to enable systematic studies of domain formation kinetics and thermodynamics. Here, we perform a model study of the effects of oil molecules, which swell the bilayer, and line-active hybrid phospholipids using a thermally induced liquid-solid phase separation in planar, free-standing lipid bilayers consisting of DOPC and DPPC (1,2-dioleoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine and 1,2-dipalmitoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine, respectively). The experiments show that the kinetics of domain growth are significantly affected by the type and molecular structure of the oil (squalene, hexadecane, or decane), with the main contributing factors being the degree of swelling of the bilayer and the changes in line tension induced by the different oils, with smaller domains resulting from systems with smaller values of the line tension. POPC (1-palmitoyl-sn-2-oleoyl-glycero-3-phosphocholine), on the other hand, acts as a line-active hybrid lipid, reducing the domain size when added in small amounts and slowing down domain coarsening. Finally, we show that despite the regulation of domain size by both methods, the phase transition temperature is influenced by the presence of oil molecules but not significantly by the presence of hybrid lipids. Overall, our results show how to regulate domain size in binary membrane model systems, over a wide range of length scales, by incorporating oil molecules and hybrid lipids.

A reengineered common chain cytokine augments CD8+ T cell-dependent immunotherapy

Cytokine therapy is limited by undesirable off-target side effects as well as terminal differentiation and exhaustion of chronically stimulated T cells. Here, we describe the signaling properties of a potentially unique cytokine by design, where T cell surface binding and signaling are separated between 2 different families of receptors. This fusion protein cytokine, called OMCPmutIL-2, bound with high affinity to the cytotoxic lymphocyte-defining immunoreceptor NKG2D but signaled through the common γ chain cytokine receptor. In addition to precise activation of cytotoxic T cells due to redirected binding, OMCPmutIL-2 resulted in superior activation of both human and murine CD8+ T cells by improving their survival and memory cell generation and decreasing exhaustion. This functional improvement was the direct result of altered signal transduction based on the reorganization of surface membrane lipid rafts that led to Janus kinase-3-mediated phosphorylation of the T cell receptor rather than STAT/AKT signaling intermediates. This potentially novel signaling pathway increased CD8+ T cell response to low-affinity antigens, activated nuclear factor of activated T cells transcription factors, and promoted mitochondrial biogenesis. OMCPmutIL-2 thus outperformed other common γ chain cytokines as a catalyst for in vitro CD8+ T cell expansion and in vivo CD8+ T cell-based immunotherapy.

Purified myelin lipids display a critical mixing point at low surface pressure

Lipids extracted from Purified Myelin Membranes (LPMM) were spread as monomolecular films at the air/aqueous interface. The films were visualized by Brewster Angle Microscopy (BAM) at different lateral pressures (π) and ionic environments. Coexistence of Liquid-Expanded (LE) and cholesterol-enriched (CE) rounded domains persisted up to π ≈ 5 mN/m but the monolayers became homogeneous at higher surface pressures. Before mixing, the domains distorted to non-rounded domains. We experimentally measured the line tension (λ) for the lipid monolayers at the domain borders by a shape relaxation technique using non-homogeneous electric fields. Regardless of the subphase conditions, the obtained line tensions are of the order of pN and tended to decrease as lateral pressure increased toward the mixing point. From the mean square displacement of nested trapped domains, we also calculated the dipole density difference between phases (μ). A non-linear drop was detected in this parameter as the mixing point is approached. Here we quantitively evaluated the π-dependance of both parameters with proper power laws in the vicinity of the critical mixing surface pressure, and the exponents showed to be consistent with a critical phenomenon in the two-dimensional Ising universality class. This idea of bidimensionality was found to be compatible only for simplified lipidic systems, while for whole myelin monolayers, that means including proteins, no critical mixing point was detected. Finally, the line tension values were related with the thickness differences between phases (Δt) near the critical point.

Hybrid polymer/lipid vesicles: Influence of polymer architecture and molar mass on line tension

Hybrid polymer/lipid vesicles are self-assembled structures that have been the subject of an increasing number of studies in recent years. They are particularly promising tools in the development of cell membrane models because they offer the possibility to fine-tune their membrane structure by adjusting the distribution of components (presence or absence of "raft-like" lipid domains), which is of prime importance to control their membrane properties. Line tension in multiphase membranes is known to be a key parameter on membrane structuration, but remains unexplored, either experimentally or by computer modeling for hybrid polymer/lipid vesicles. In this study, we were able to measure the line tension on different budded hybrid vesicles, using a micropipette aspiration technique, and show the influence of the molar mass and the architecture of block copolymers on line tension and its consequences for membrane structuration.

Amphipathic Peptides Impede Lipid Domain Fusion in Phase-Separated Membranes

Cell membranes are heterogeneous in lipid composition which leads to the phase separation with the formation of nanoscopic liquid-ordered domains, also called rafts. There are multiple cell processes whereby the clustering of these domains into a larger one might be involved, which is responsible for such important processes as signal transduction, polarized sorting, or immune response. Currently, antimicrobial amphipathic peptides are considered promising antimicrobial, antiviral, and anticancer therapeutic agents. Here, within the framework of the classical theory of elasticity adapted for lipid membranes, we investigate how the presence of the peptides in a phase-separated membrane influences the fusion of the domains. We show that the peptides tend to occupy the boundaries of liquid-ordered domains and significantly increase the energy barrier of the domain-domain fusion, which might lead to misregulation of raft clustering and adverse consequences for normal cell processes.

Structural responses of model biomembranes to Mars-relevant salts

Lipid membranes are a key component of contemporary living systems and are thought to have been essential to the origin of life. Most research on membranes has focused on situations restricted to ambient physiological or benchtop conditions. However, the influence of more extreme conditions, such as the deep subsurface on Earth or extraterrestrial environments are less well understood. The deep subsurface environments of Mars, for instance, may harbor high concentrations of chaotropic salts in brines, yet we know little about how these conditions would influence the habitability of such environments for cellular life. Here, we investigated the combined effects of high concentrations of salts, including sodium and magnesium perchlorate and sulfate, and high hydrostatic pressure on the stability and structure of model biomembranes of varying complexity. To this end, a variety of biophysical techniques have been applied, which include calorimetry, fluorescence spectroscopies, small-angle X-ray scattering, dynamic light scattering, and microscopy techniques. We show that the structure and phase behavior of lipid membranes is sensitively dictated by the nature of the salt, in particular its anion and its concentration. We demonstrate that, with the exception of magnesium perchlorate, which can also induce cubic lipid arrangements, long-chain saturated lipid bilayer structures can still persist at high salt concentrations across a range of pressures. The lateral organization of complex heterogeneous raft-like membranes is affected by all salts. For simple, in particular bacterial membrane-type bilayer systems with unsaturated chains, vesicular structures are still stable at Martian brine conditions, also up to the kbar pressure range, demonstrating the potential compatibility of environments containing such ionic and pressure extremes to lipid-encapsulated life.

Ionic environment, thickness and line tension as determinants of phase separation in whole Purified Myelin Membranes monolayers

Purified myelin membranes (PMM) were spread as monomolecular films at the air/aqueous solution interface, and visualized by Brewster Angle Microscopy (BAM) at different lateral pressures (π) on three specific aqueous solutions: absence of salts, physiological conditions and presence of calcium. Coexistence of Liquid-Expanded (LE) and Liquid Ordered (LO) phases persisted up to collapse in the presence of salts, whereas monolayers became homogeneous at π ≥ 35-40 mN/m when salts are absent. This PMM phase-mixing behavior in monolayers is similar to the previously reported behavior of PMM multilamellar vesicles. Reflectivities (R_p) of p-polarized light from both phases were assessed throughout the whole π -range, and film thicknesses (t) were calculated from the R_p values and measured film refractive indices (n). The LO phase was found to be more reflective and thicker than the LE phase at π ≤ 15 mN/m, but less reflective and thinner at higher π. We also determined the line tension (λ) of PMM monolayers at the domain boundaries from the rate of domain shape relaxation, which turned out to be of the order of picoNewtons (pN) and decreased as π increased. A correlation between λ and thickness differences (Δt) was found, suggesting that Δt is a molecular determinant for λ in PMM monolayers. Both λ and Δt were found to increase markedly when calcium was present in the subphase. This result corroborates the concept of divalent cations as a stabilizing factor for phase separation, in line with earlier studies on this mixture forming multilamellar membrane arrangements.

Role of cholesterol in substrate recognition by [Formula: see text]-secretase

[Formula: see text]-Secretase is an enzyme known to cleave multiple substrates within their transmembrane domains, with the amyloid precursor protein of Alzheimer's Disease among the most prominent examples. The activity of [Formula: see text]-secretase strictly depends on the membrane cholesterol content, yet the mechanistic role of cholesterol in the substrate binding and cleavage remains unclear. In this work, we used all-atom molecular dynamics simulations to examine the role of cholesterol in the initial binding of a direct precursor of [Formula: see text]-amyloid polypeptides by [Formula: see text]-secretase. We showed that in cholesterol-rich membranes, both the substrate and the enzyme region proximal to the active site induce a local membrane thinning. With the free energy methods we found that in the presence of cholesterol the substrate binds favorably to the identified exosite, while cholesterol depletion completely abolishes the binding. To explain these findings, we directly examined the role of hydrophobic mismatch in the substrate binding to [Formula: see text]-secretase, showing that increased membrane thickness results in higher propensity of the enzyme to bind substrates. Therefore, we propose that cholesterol promotes substrate binding to [Formula: see text]-secretase by increasing the membrane thickness, which leads to the negative hydrophobic mismatch between the membrane and binding partners.

Model Membrane Systems Used to Study Plasma Membrane Lipid Asymmetry

It is well known that the lipid distribution in the bilayer leaflets of mammalian plasma membranes (PMs) is not symmetric. Despite this, model membrane studies have largely relied on chemically symmetric model membranes for the study of lipid–lipid and lipid–protein interactions. This is primarily due to the difficulty in preparing stable, asymmetric model membranes that are amenable to biophysical studies. However, in the last 20 years, efforts have been made in producing more biologically faithful model membranes. Here, we review several recently developed experimental and computational techniques for the robust generation of asymmetric model membranes and highlight a new and particularly promising technique to study membrane asymmetry.

On the small size of liquid-disordered + liquid-ordered nanodomains

Four-component phase diagrams reveal that Liquid-disordered + liquid-ordered (Ld + Lo) nanodomains are exclusively found adjacent to a three-phase region, and so cannot be a one-phase microemulsion. Of importance for understanding biological membranes, a small change in lipid bilayer composition can change the size of these coexisting phase domains hundreds of fold, between tens of nanometers and microns. Nanodomain diameter, measured from small angle neutron scattering, is in the range 15-35 nm, consistent with stabilization by repulsive dipole fields. Ld/Lo line tension controls the Ld + Lo domain size transition. Other than size, chemical and physical properties of the phase domains do not seem to change during the transition. Unfavorable lipid-lipid pairwise interactions, rather than phase thickness mismatch, seem to be the main reason for Ld + Lo immiscibility. Pairwise interactions of cholesterol-phospholipid seem to be favorable, whereas pairwise interactions of high-melting phospholipid with low-melting phospholipid are unfavorable. Measured Ld/Lo line tension, like the phase separation, is created mainly by unfavorable lipid-lipid pairwise interactions. Lipid dipole-dipole repulsion opposes these unfavorable lipid-lipid pairwise interactions and thus, in a sense, is the reason that nanodomains form. Bilayer physical and chemical properties measured from macroscopic domains of coexisting Ld + Lo phases should be good approximations for the properties of coexisting nanoscopic domains.

Investigation of the domain line tension in asymmetric vesicles prepared via hemifusion

The plasma membrane (PM) is asymmetric in lipid composition. The distinct and characteristic lipid compositions of the exoplasmic and cytoplasmic leaflets lead to different lipid-lipid interactions and physical-chemical properties in each leaflet. The exoplasmic leaflet possesses an intrinsic ability to form coexisting ordered and disordered fluid domains, whereas the cytoplasmic leaflet seems to form a single fluid phase. To better understand the interleaflet interactions that influence domains, we compared asymmetric model membranes that capture salient properties of the PM with simpler symmetric membranes. Using asymmetric giant unilamellar vesicles (aGUVs) prepared by hemifusion with a supported lipid bilayer, we investigate the domain line tension that characterizes the behavior of coexisting ordered + disordered domains. The line tension can be related to the contact perimeter of the different phases. Compared to macroscopic phase separation, the appearance of modulated phases was found to be a robust indicator of a decrease in domain line tension. Symmetric GUVs of 1,2-distearoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine (DSPC)/1,2-dioleoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine (DOPC)/1-palmitoyl-2-oleoyl-glycero-3-phosphocholine (POPC)/cholesterol (chol) were formed into aGUVs by replacing the GUV outer leaflet with DOPC/chol = 0.8/0.2 in order to create a cytoplasmic leaflet model. These aGUVs revealed lower line tension for the ordered + disordered domains of the exoplasmic model leaflet.

Particle-based Ising model

We characterize equilibrium properties and relaxation dynamics of a two-dimensional lattice containing, at each site, two particles connected by a double-well potential (dumbbell). Dumbbells are oriented in the orthogonal direction with respect to the lattice plane and interact with each other through a Lennard-Jones potential truncated at the nearest neighbor distance. We show that the system's equilibrium properties are accurately described by a two-dimensional Ising model with an appropriate coupling constant. Moreover, we characterize the coarsening kinetics by calculating the cluster size as a function of time and compare the results with Monte Carlo simulations based on Glauber or reactive dynamics rate constants.

Measuring Gaussian Rigidity Using Curved Substrates

The Gaussian (saddle splay) rigidity of fluid membranes controls their equilibrium topology but is notoriously difficult to measure. In lipid mixtures, typical of living cells, linear interfaces separate liquid ordered (LO) from liquid disordered (LD) bilayer phases at subcritical temperatures. Here, we consider such membranes supported by curved substrates that thereby control the membrane curvatures. We show how spectral analysis of the fluctuations of the LO-LD interface provides a novel way of measuring the difference in Gaussian rigidity between the two phases. We provide a number of conditions for such interface fluctuations to be both experimentally measurable and sufficiently sensitive to the value of the Gaussian rigidity, while remaining in the perturbative regime of our analysis.

Serotonin Alters the Phase Equilibrium of a Ternary Mixture of Phospholipids and Cholesterol

Unsaturated and saturated phospholipids tend to laterally segregate, especially in the presence of cholesterol. Small molecules such as neurotransmitters, toxins, drugs etc. possibly modulate this lateral segregation. The small aromatic neurotransmitter serotonin (5-HT) has been found to bind to membranes. We studied the lipid structure and packing of a ternary membrane mixture consisting of palmitoyl-oleoyl-phosphatidylcholine, palmitoyl-sphingomyelin, and cholesterol at a molar ratio of 4/4/2 in the absence and in the presence of 5-HT, using a combination of solid-state 2H NMR, atomic force microscopy, and atomistic molecular dynamics (MD) simulations. Both NMR and MD report formation of a liquid ordered (L o ) and a liquid disordered (L d ) phase coexistence with small domains. Lipid exchange between the domains was fast such that single component 2H NMR spectra are detected over a wide temperature range. A drastic restructuring of the domains was induced when 5-HT is added to the membranes at a 9 mol% concentration relative to the lipids. 2H NMR spectra of all components of the mixture showed two prominent contributions indicative of molecules of the same kind residing both in the disordered and the ordered phase. Compared to the data in the absence of 5-HT, the lipid chain order in the disordered phase was further decreased in the presence of 5-HT. Likewise, addition of serotonin increased lipid chain order within the ordered phase. These characteristic lipid chain order changes were confirmed by MD simulations. The 5-HT-induced larger difference in lipid chain order results in more pronounced differences in the hydrophobic thickness of the individual membrane domains. The correspondingly enlarged hydrophobic mismatch between ordered and disordered phases is assumed to increase the line tension at the domain boundary, which drives the system into formation of larger size domains. These results not only demonstrate that small membrane binding molecules such as neurotransmitters have a profound impact on essential membrane properties. It also suggests a mechanism by which the interaction of small molecules with membranes can influence the function of membrane proteins and non-cognate receptors. Altered membrane properties may modify lateral sorting of membrane protein, membrane protein conformation, and thus influence their function as suspected for neurotransmitters, local anesthetics, and other small drug molecules.

FRET from phase-separated vesicles: An analytical solution for a spherical geometry

Förster resonance energy transfer (FRET) is a powerful tool for investigating heterogeneity in lipid bilayers. In model membrane studies, samples are frequently unilamellar vesicles with diameters of 20-200 nm. It is well-known that FRET efficiency is insensitive to vesicle curvature in uniformly mixed lipid bilayers, and consequently theoretical models for FRET typically assume a planar geometry. Here, we use a spherical harmonic expansion of the acceptor surface density to derive an analytical solution for FRET between donor and acceptor molecules distributed on the surface of a sphere. We find excellent agreement between FRET predicted from the model and FRET calculated from corresponding Monte Carlo simulations, thus validating the model. An extension of the model to the case of a non-uniform acceptor surface density (i.e., a phase-separated vesicle) reveals that FRET efficiency depends on vesicle size when acceptors partition between the coexisting phases, and approaches the efficiency of a uniformly mixed bilayer as the vesicle size decreases. We show that this is an indirect effect of constrained domain size, rather than an intrinsic effect of vesicle curvature. Surprisingly, the theoretical predictions were not borne out in experiments: we did not observe a statistically significant change in FRET efficiency in phase-separated vesicles as a function of vesicle size. We discuss factors that likely mask the vesicle size effect in extruded samples.

Bilayer compositional asymmetry influences the nanoscopic to macroscopic phase domain size transition

The eukaryotic plasma membrane (PM) exhibits lipid mixing heterogeneities known as lipid rafts. These lipid rafts, the result of liquid-liquid phase separation, can be modeled by coexisting liquid ordered (Lo) and liquid disordered (Ld) domains. Four-lipid component systems with a high-melting lipid, a nanodomain-inducing low-melting lipid, a macrodomain-inducing low-melting lipid, and cholesterol (chol) can give rise to domains of different sizes. These four-component systems have been characterized in experiments, yet there are few studies that model the asymmetric distribution of lipids actually found in the PM. We used molecular dynamics (MD) simulations to analyze the transition from nanoscopic to macroscopic domains in symmetric and in asymmetric model membranes. Using coarse-grained MD simulations, we found that asymmetry promotes macroscopic domain growth in a case where symmetric systems exhibit nanoscopic domains. Also, macroscopic domain formation in symmetric systems is highly dependent on registration of like phases in the cytoplasmic and exoplasmic leaflets. Using united-atom MD simulations, we found that symmetric Lo domains are only slightly more ordered than asymmetric Lo domains. We also found that large Lo domains in our asymmetric systems induce a slight chain ordering in the apposed cytoplasmic regions. The chol fractions of phase-separated Lo and Ld domains of the exoplasmic leaflet were unchanged whether the system was symmetric or asymmetric.

Microscopic Picture of Calcium-Assisted Lipid Demixing and Membrane Remodeling Using Multiscale Simulations

The specificity of anionic phospholipids-calcium ion interaction and lipid demixing has been established as a key regulatory mechanism in several cellular signaling processes. The mechanism and implications of this calcium-assisted demixing have not been elucidated from a microscopic point of view. Here, we present an overview of atomic interactions between calcium and phospholipids that can drive nonideal mixing of lipid molecules in a model lipid bilayer composed of zwitterionic (1-palmitoyl-2-oleoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine (POPC)) and anionic (1-palmitoyl-2-oleoyl-sn-glycero-3-phospho-l-serine (POPS)) lipids with computer simulations at multiple resolutions. Lipid nanodomain formation and growth were driven by calcium-enabled lipid bridging of the charged phosphatidylserine (PS) headgroups, which were favored against inter-POPS dipole interactions. Consistent with several experimental studies of calcium-associated membrane sculpting, our analyses also suggest modifications in local membrane curvature and cross-leaflet couplings as a response to such induced lateral heterogeneity. In addition, reverse mapping to a complementary atomistic description revealed structural insights in the presence of anionic nanodomains, at timescales not accessed by previous computational studies. This work bridges information across multiple scales to reveal a mechanistic picture of calcium ion's impact on membrane biophysics.

Degeneracy in molecular scale organization of biological membranes

The scale-rich spatiotemporal organization in biological membranes has its origin in the differential inter- and intra-molecular interactions among their constituents. In this work, we explore the molecular-origin behind that variety and possible degeneracy in lateral organization in membranes. For our study, we post-process microsecond long all-atom molecular dynamics trajectories for three systems that exhibit fluid phase coexistence: (i) PSM/POPC/Chol (0.47/0.32/0.21), (ii) PSM/DOPC/Chol (0.43/0.38/0.19) and (iii) DPPC/DOPC/Chol (0.37/0.36/0.27). To distinguish the liquid ordered and disordered regions at molecular scales, we calculate the degree of non-affineness of individual lipids in their neighbourhood and track their topological rearrangements. Disconnectivity graph analysis with respect to membrane organization shows that the DPPC/DOPC/Chol and PSM/DOPC/Chol systems exhibit funnel-like energy landscapes as opposed to a highly frustrated energy landscape for the more biomimetic PSM/POPC/Chol system. We use these measurements to develop a continuous lattice Hamiltonian and evolve that using Monte Carlo simulated annealing to explore the possibility of structural degeneracy in membrane organization. Our data show that model membranes with lipid constituents that are biomimetic (PSM/POPC/Chol) have the ability to access a large range of membrane sub-structure space (higher degeneracy) as compared to the other two systems, which form only one kind of substructure even with changing composition. Since the spatiotemporal organization in biological membranes dictates the "molecular encounters" and in turn larger scale biological processes such as molecular transport, trafficking and cellular signalling, we posit that this structural degeneracy could enable access to a larger repository to functionally important molecular organization in systems with physiologically relevant compositions.

Sphingomyelin Acyl Chains Influence the Formation of Sphingomyelin- and Cholesterol-Enriched Domains

The segregation of lipids into lateral membrane domains has been extensively studied. It is well established that the structural differences between phospholipids play an important role in lateral membrane organization. When a high enough cholesterol concentration is present in the bilayer, liquid-ordered (L_o) domains, which are enriched in cholesterol and saturated phospholipids such as sphingomyelin (SM), may form. We have recently shown that such a formation of domains can be facilitated by the affinity differences of cholesterol for the saturated and unsaturated phospholipids present in the bilayer. In mammalian membranes, the saturated phospholipids are usually SMs with different acyl chains, the abundance of which vary with cell type. In this study, we investigated how the acyl chain structure of SMs affects the formation of SM- and cholesterol-enriched domains. From the analysis of trans-parinaric acid fluorescence emission lifetimes, we could determine that cholesterol facilitated lateral segregation most with the SMs that had 16 carbon-long acyl chains. Using differential scanning calorimetry and Förster resonance energy transfer techniques, we observed that the SM- and cholesterol-enriched domains with 16 carbon-long SMs were most thermally stabilized by cholesterol. The Förster resonance energy transfer technique also suggested that the same SMs also form the largest L_o domains. In agreement with our previously published data, the extent of influence that cholesterol had on the propensity of lateral segregation and the properties of L_o domains correlated with the relative affinity of cholesterol for the phospholipids present in the bilayers. Therefore, the specific SM species present in the membranes, together with unsaturated phospholipids and cholesterol, can be used by the cell to fine-tune the lateral structure of the membranes.

Sphingomyelins and ent-Sphingomyelins Form Homophilic Nano-Subdomains within Liquid Ordered Domains

Sphingomyelin (SM), a major component of small domains (or lipid rafts) in mammalian cell membranes, forms a liquid-ordered phase in the presence of cholesterol (Cho). However, the nature of molecular interactions within the ordered SM/Cho phase remains elusive. We previously revealed that stearoyl-SM (SSM) and its enantiomer (ent-SSM) separately form nano-subdomains within the liquid-ordered phase involving homophilic SSM-SSM and ent-SSM-ent-SSM interactions. In this study, the details of the subdomain formation by SSMs at the nanometer range were examined using Förster resonance energy transfer (FRET) measurements in lipid bilayers containing SSM and ent-SSM, dioleoyl-phosphatidylcholine and Cho. Although microscopy detected a stereochemical effect on partition coefficient favoring stereochemically homophilic interactions in the liquid-ordered state, it showed no significant difference in large-scale liquid-ordered domain formation by the two stereoisomers. In contrast to the uniform domains seen microscopy, FRET analysis using fluorescent donor- and acceptor-labeled SSM showed distinct differences in SM and ent-SM colocalization within nanoscale distances. Donor- and acceptor-labeled SSM showed significantly higher FRET efficiency than did donor-labeled SSM and acceptor-labeled ent-SSM in lipid vesicles composed of “racemic” (1:1) mixtures of SSM/ent-SSM with dioleoylphosphatidylcholine and Cho. The difference in FRET efficiency indicated that SSM and ent-SSM assemble to form separate nano-subdomains. The average size of the subdomains decreased as temperature increased, and at physiological temperatures, the subdomains were found to have a single-digit nanometer radius. These results suggest that (even in the absence of ent-SM) SM-SM interactions play a crucial role in forming nano-subdomains within liquid-ordered domains and may be a key feature of lipid microdomains (or rafts) in biological membranes.

To Hop or not to Hop: Exceptions in the FCS Diffusion Law

Diffusion obstacles in membranes have not been directly visualized because of fast membrane dynamics and the occurrence of subresolution molecular complexes. To understand the obstacle characteristics, mobility-based methods are often used as an indirect way of assessing the membrane structure. Molecular movement in biological plasma membranes is often characterized by anomalous diffusion, but the exact underlying mechanisms are still elusive. Imaging total internal reflection fluorescence correlation spectroscopy (ITIR-FCS) is a well-established mobility-based method that provides spatially resolved diffusion coefficient maps and is combined with FCS diffusion law analysis to examine subresolution membrane organization. In recent years, although FCS diffusion law analysis has been instrumental in providing new insights into the membrane structure below the optical diffraction limit, there are certain exceptions and anomalies that require further clarification. To this end, we correlate the membrane structural features imaged by atomic force microscopy (AFM) with the dynamics measured using ITIR-FCS. We perform ITIR-FCS measurements on supported lipid bilayers (SLBs) of various lipid compositions to characterize the anomalous diffusion of lipid molecules in distinct obstacle configurations, along with the high-resolution imaging of the membrane structures with AFM. Furthermore, we validate our experimental results by performing simulations on image grids with experimentally determined obstacle configurations. This study demonstrates that FCS diffusion law analysis is a powerful tool to determine membrane heterogeneities implied from dynamics measurements. Our results corroborate the commonly accepted interpretations of imaging FCS diffusion law analysis, and we show that exceptions happen when domains reach the percolation threshold in a biphasic membrane and a network of domains behaves rather like a meshwork, resulting in hop diffusion.

Osmotic-Tension-Induced Membrane Lateral Organization

Alteration of lipid raft organization manifesting as phase separation is important for cellular processes, such as signaling and trafficking. Such behaviors and dynamics of lipid membranes can be affected by external stimuli including both physical and chemical stimuli. In this study, we focused on osmotic-tension-induced phase separation. The effects of osmotic tension on the phase behaviors of vesicles consisting of dioleoylphosphocholine (DOPC)/dipalmitoylphosphocholine (DPPC)/cholesterol (Chol) were quantitatively studied at different temperatures by fluorescence microscopy. We determined the ternary phase diagrams and found that tension leads to a shift in the miscibility temperature. Cholesterol plays a key role in determining the extent of this shift. In addition, we found that osmotic tension can enhance the line tension. The physicochemical mechanism of osmotic-pressure-induced phase separation is discussed.

Elastic deformations mediate interaction of the raft boundary with membrane inclusions leading to their effective lateral sorting

Liquid-ordered lipid domains represent a lateral inhomogeneity in cellular membranes. These domains have elastic and physicochemical properties different from those of the surrounding membrane. In particular, their thickness exceeds that of the disordered membrane. Thus, elastic deformations arise at the domain boundary in order to compensate for the thickness mismatch. In equilibrium, the deformations lead to an incomplete register of monolayer ordered domains: the elastic energy is minimal if domains in opposing monolayers lie on the top of each other, and their boundaries are laterally shifted by about 3 nm. This configuration introduces a region, composed of one ordered and one disordered monolayers, with an intermediate bilayer thickness. Besides, a jump in a local monolayer curvature takes place in this intermediate region, concentrating here most of the elastic stress. This region can participate in a lateral sorting of membrane inclusions by offering them an optimal bilayer thickness and local curvature conditions. In the present study, we consider the sorting of deformable lipid inclusions, undeformable peripheral and deeply incorporated peptide inclusions, and undeformable transmembrane inclusions of different molecular geometry. With rare exceptions, all types of inclusions have an affinity to the ordered domain boundary as compared to the bulk phases. The optimal lateral distribution of inclusions allows relaxing the elastic stress at the boundary of domains.

Lipid Rafts: Controversies Resolved, Mysteries Remain

The lipid raft hypothesis postulates that lipid-lipid interactions can laterally organize biological membranes into domains of distinct structures, compositions, and functions. This proposal has in equal measure exhilarated and frustrated membrane research for decades. While the physicochemical principles underlying lipid-driven domains has been explored and is well understood, the existence and relevance of such domains in cells remains elusive, despite decades of research. Here, we review the conceptual underpinnings of the raft hypothesis and critically discuss the supporting and contradicting evidence in cells, focusing on why controversies about the composition, properties, and even the very existence of lipid rafts remain unresolved. Finally, we highlight several recent breakthroughs that may resolve existing controversies and suggest general approaches for moving beyond questions of the existence of rafts and towards understanding their physiological significance.