Mechanism and evolutionary origins of alanine-tail C-degron recognition by E3 ligases Pirh2 and CRL2-KLHDC10

Identification of microproteins with transactivation activity by polyalanine motif selection

Microproteins are an emerging class of proteins that are encoded by small open reading frames (smORFs) less than or equal to 100 amino acids. The functions of several microproteins have been illuminated through phenotypic screening or protein-protein interaction studies, but thousands of microproteins remain uncharacterized. The functional characterization of microproteins is challenging due to a lack of sequence homology. Here, we demonstrate a strategy to enrich microproteins that contain specific motifs as a means to more rapidly characterize microproteins. Specifically, we used the fact that polyalanine motifs are associated with nuclear proteins to select 58 candidate microproteins to screen for transactivation function. We identified three microproteins with transactivation activity when tested as GAL4-fusions in a cell-based luciferase assay. The results support the continued use of the motif selection strategy for the discovery of microprotein function.

Characteristics of the Kelch domain containing (KLHDC) subfamily and relationships with diseases

The Kelch protein superfamily is an evolutionary conserved family containing 63 alternate protein coding members. The superfamily is split into three subfamilies: Kelch like (KLHL), Kelch-repeat and bric-a-bracs (BTB) domain containing (KBTBD) and Kelch domain containing protein (KLHDC). The KLHDC subfamily is one of the smallest within the Kelch superfamily, containing 10 primary members. There is little known about the structures and functions of the subfamily; however, they are thought to be involved in several cellular and molecular processes. Recently, there have been significant structural and biochemical advances for KLHDC2, which has aided our understanding of other KLHDC family members. Furthermore, small molecules directly targeting KLHDC2 have been identified, which act as tools for targeted protein degradation. This review utilises this information, in conjunction with a thorough exploration of the structural aspects and potential biological functions to summarise the relationship between KLHDCs and human disease.

Structural basis for C-degron selectivity across KLHDCX family E3 ubiquitin ligases

Specificity of the ubiquitin-proteasome system depends on E3 ligase-substrate interactions. Many such pairings depend on E3 ligases binding to peptide-like sequences - termed N- or C-degrons - at the termini of substrates. However, our knowledge of structural features distinguishing closely related C-degron substrate-E3 pairings is limited. Here, by systematically comparing ubiquitylation activities towards a suite of common model substrates, and defining interactions by biochemistry, crystallography, and cryo-EM, we reveal principles of C-degron recognition across the KLHDCX family of Cullin-RING ligases (CRLs). First, a motif common across these E3 ligases anchors a substrate's C-terminus. However, distinct locations of this C-terminus anchor motif in different blades of the KLHDC2, KLHDC3, and KLHDC10 β-propellers establishes distinct relative positioning and molecular environments for substrate C-termini. Second, our structural data show KLHDC3 has a pre-formed pocket establishing preference for an Arg or Gln preceding a C-terminal Gly, whereas conformational malleability contributes to KLHDC10's recognition of varying features adjacent to substrate C-termini. Finally, additional non-consensus interactions, mediated by C-degron binding grooves and/or by distal propeller surfaces and substrate globular domains, can substantially impact substrate binding and ubiquitylatability. Overall, the data reveal combinatorial mechanisms determining specificity and plasticity of substrate recognition by KLDCX-family C-degron E3 ligases.

Mechanochemical forces regulate the composition and fate of stalled nascent chains

The ribosome-associated quality control (RQC) pathway resolves stalled ribosomes. As part of RQC, stalled nascent polypeptide chains (NCs) are appended with CArboxy-Terminal amino acids (CAT tails) in an mRNA-free, non-canonical elongation process. CAT tail composition includes Ala, Thr, and potentially other residues. The relationship between CAT tail composition and function has remained unknown. Using biochemical approaches in yeast, we discovered that mechanochemical forces on the NC regulate CAT tailing. We propose CAT tailing initially operates in an "extrusion mode" that increases NC lysine accessibility for on-ribosome ubiquitination. Thr in CAT tails enhances NC extrusion by preventing formation of polyalanine, which can form α-helices that lower extrusion efficiency and disrupt termination of CAT tailing. After NC ubiquitylation, pulling forces on the NC switch CAT tailing to an Ala-only "release mode" which facilitates nascent chain release from large ribosomal subunits and NC degradation. Failure to switch from extrusion to release mode leads to accumulation of NCs on large ribosomal subunits and proteotoxic aggregation of Thr-rich CAT tails.

Principles of paralog-specific targeted protein degradation engaging the C-degron E3 KLHDC2

PROTAC® (proteolysis-targeting chimera) molecules induce proximity between an E3 ligase and protein-of-interest (POI) to target the POI for ubiquitin-mediated degradation. Cooperative E3-PROTAC-POI complexes have potential to achieve neo-substrate selectivity beyond that established by POI binding to the ligand alone. Here, we extend the collection of ubiquitin ligases employable for cooperative ternary complex formation to include the C-degron E3 KLHDC2. Ligands were identified that engage the C-degron binding site in KLHDC2, subjected to structure-based improvement, and linked to JQ1 for BET-family neo-substrate recruitment. Consideration of the exit vector emanating from the ligand engaged in KLHDC2's U-shaped degron-binding pocket enabled generation of SJ46421, which drives formation of a remarkably cooperative, paralog-selective ternary complex with BRD3BD2. Meanwhile, screening pro-drug variants enabled surmounting cell permeability limitations imposed by acidic moieties resembling the KLHDC2-binding C-degron. Selectivity for BRD3 compared to other BET-family members is further manifested in ubiquitylation in vitro, and prodrug version SJ46420-mediated degradation in cells. Selectivity is also achieved for the ubiquitin ligase, overcoming E3 auto-inhibition to engage KLHDC2, but not the related KLHDC1, KLHDC3, or KLHDC10 E3s. In sum, our study establishes neo-substrate-specific targeted protein degradation via KLHDC2, and provides a framework for developing selective PROTAC protein degraders employing C-degron E3 ligases.

Conserved quality control mechanisms of mitochondrial protein import

Mitochondria carry out essential functions for the cell, including energy production, various biosynthesis pathways, formation of co-factors and cellular signalling in apoptosis and inflammation. The functionality of mitochondria requires the import of about 900-1300 proteins from the cytosol in baker's yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae and human cells, respectively. The vast majority of these proteins pass the outer membrane in a largely unfolded state through the translocase of the outer mitochondrial membrane (TOM) complex. Subsequently, specific protein translocases sort the precursor proteins into the outer and inner membranes, the intermembrane space and matrix. Premature folding of mitochondrial precursor proteins, defects in the mitochondrial protein translocases or a reduction of the membrane potential across the inner mitochondrial membrane can cause stalling of precursors at the protein import apparatus. Consequently, the translocon is clogged and non-imported precursor proteins accumulate in the cell, which in turn leads to proteotoxic stress and eventually cell death. To prevent such stress situations, quality control mechanisms remove non-imported precursor proteins from the TOM channel. The highly conserved ubiquitin-proteasome system of the cytosol plays a critical role in this process. Thus, the surveillance of protein import via the TOM complex involves the coordinated activity of mitochondria-localized and cytosolic proteins to prevent proteotoxic stress in the cell.

Poly-alanine-tailing is a modifier of neurodegeneration caused by Listerin mutation

The surveillance of translation is critical for the fitness of organisms from bacteria to humans. Ribosome-associated Quality Control (RQC) is a surveillance mechanism that promotes the elimination of truncated polypeptides, byproducts of ribosome stalling during translation. In canonical mammalian RQC, NEMF binds to the large ribosomal subunit and recruits the E3 ubiquitin ligase Listerin, which marks the nascent-chains for proteasomal degradation. NEMF additionally extends the nascent-chain's C-terminus with poly-alanine ('Ala-tail'), exposing lysines in the ribosomal exit tunnel for ubiquitination. In an alternative, Listerin-independent RQC pathway, released nascent-chains are targeted by Ala-tail-binding E3 ligases. While mutations in Listerin or in NEMF selectively elicit neurodegeneration in mice and humans, the physiological significance of Ala-tailing and its role in disease have remained unknown. Here, we report the analysis of mice in which NEMF's Ala-tailing activity was selectively impaired. Whereas the Nemf homozygous mutation did not affect lifespan and only led to mild motor defects, genetic interaction analyses uncovered its synthetic lethal phenotype when combined with the lister neurodegeneration-causing mutation. Conversely, the lister phenotype was markedly improved when Ala-tailing capacity was partially reduced by a heterozygous Nemf mutation. Providing a plausible mechanism for this striking switch from early neuroprotection to subsequent neurotoxicity, we found that RQC substrates that evade degradation form amyloid-like aggregates in an Ala-tail dependent fashion. These findings uncover a critical role for Ala-tailing in mammalian proteostasis, and deepen our molecular understanding of pathophysiological roles of RQC in neurodegeneration.

Mechanisms of Translation-coupled Quality Control

Stalling of ribosomes engaged in protein synthesis can lead to significant defects in the function of newly synthesized proteins and thereby impair protein homeostasis. Consequently, partially synthesized polypeptides resulting from translation stalling are recognized and eliminated by several quality control mechanisms. First, if translation elongation reactions are halted prematurely, a quality control mechanism called ribosome-associated quality control (RQC) initiates the ubiquitination of the nascent polypeptide chain and subsequent proteasomal degradation. Additionally, when ribosomes with defective codon recognition or peptide-bond formation stall during translation, a quality control mechanism known as non-functional ribosomal RNA decay (NRD) leads to the degradation of malfunctioning ribosomes. In both of these quality control mechanisms, E3 ubiquitin ligases selectively recognize ribosomes in distinct translation-stalling states and ubiquitinate specific ribosomal proteins. Significant efforts have been devoted to characterize E3 ubiquitin ligase sensing of ribosome 'collision' or 'stalling' and subsequent ribosome is rescued. This article provides an overview of our current understanding of the molecular mechanisms and physiological functions of ribosome dynamics control and quality control of abnormal translation.

Peptidyl-tRNA hydrolase is the nascent chain release factor in bacterial ribosome-associated quality control

Rescuing stalled ribosomes often involves their splitting into subunits. In many bacteria, the resultant large subunits bearing peptidyl-tRNAs are processed by the ribosome-associated quality control (RQC) apparatus that extends the C termini of the incomplete nascent polypeptides with polyalanine tails to facilitate their degradation. Although the tailing mechanism is well established, it is unclear how the nascent polypeptides are cleaved off the tRNAs. We show that peptidyl-tRNA hydrolase (Pth), the known role of which has been to hydrolyze ribosome-free peptidyl-tRNA, acts in concert with RQC factors to release nascent polypeptides from large ribosomal subunits. Dislodging from the ribosomal catalytic center is required for peptidyl-tRNA hydrolysis by Pth. Nascent protein folding may prevent peptidyl-tRNA retraction and interfere with the peptide release. However, oligoalanine tailing makes the peptidyl-tRNA ester bond accessible for Pth-catalyzed hydrolysis. Therefore, the oligoalanine tail serves not only as a degron but also as a facilitator of Pth-catalyzed peptidyl-tRNA hydrolysis.