A cross-sectional examination of the 24-hour movement behaviours in Canadian youth with physical and sensory disabilities

Canadian children and youth with disabilities are not meeting the 24-Hour Movement Guidelines: Cross-sectional results from the national physical activity measurement (NPAM) study for children and youth with disabilities

BACKGROUND

Understanding patterns of movement behaviours for physical activity (PA), screen time (ST) and sleep in children and youth with disabilities (CYD) can identify participation gaps that inform country-specific intervention and policy.

OBJECTIVE

To describe the 24-h movement behaviours and guideline adherence in CYD in Canada. The associations between age, gender, and disability type with meeting movement guidelines were also examined.

METHODS

Cross-sectional caregiver-reported data (N = 524 CYD, Mage = 10.3 ± 3.1 years; 70 % boys; 49 % developmental disabilities) were collected on child PA, ST, and sleep. Items were derived from the Health Behaviour in School-aged Children survey, International Physical Activity Questionnaire-Adolescents and the Childhood Obesity, Lifestyle, and the Environment Diet and Lifestyle Questionnaire. Movement behaviours were described for the total sample and by age, gender, and disability type. Logistic regressions tested predictors of meeting the movement guidelines.

RESULTS

CYD spent 34.2 ± 37.1 min in moderate-to-vigorous PA, 5.3 ± 3.9 h using screens, and 9.9 ± 1.1 h in sleep. 17.2 %, 20.3 %, and 89.0 % met the individual PA, ST, and sleep guidelines; 4.6 % met all three. Youth were less likely to meet the individual ST and sleep guidelines than children (OR = 0.16); participants with multiple disabilities were less likely to meet the ST guideline than those with developmental disabilities (OR = 0.33; ps < 0.001). Age, gender, and disability type did not significantly predict meeting the PA guideline.

CONCLUSION

Most CYD do not meet the Canadian guidelines for PA and ST and the majority meet recommended levels for sleep. Guideline adherence is lower for youth (ST and sleep) and those with multiple disabilities (ST only).

Validity of the Fitbit wearable activity monitor to estimate step counts in free-living conditions in ambulatory children and youth living with disability

PURPOSE

To assess the validity of the Fitbit ChargeHR versus a research-grade accelerometer (ActiGraph GT3X) for estimating daily step counts in free-living conditions in ambulatory children and youth living with physical and non-physical disabilities.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Children and youth living with disability (n = 29; median age 10 years (IQR: 8-13), 55% boys; n = 2 with mobility aid) wore the GT3X ActiGraph accelerometer (hip) and the Fitbit ChargeHR (wrist) for seven days. Inter-device agreement in steps/day was assessed by intraclass correlation coefficients (ICCs) and Bland-Altman plots. A receiver operating curve (ROC) was used to determine a Fitbit step-count cut-point that corresponds to meeting physical activity guidelines (defined as ≥60 min of moderate-to-vigorous physical activity per day).

RESULTS

Overall, we found an ICC = 0.861 (p < 0.001) between daily step counts measured by the two devices. Bland-Altman analyses revealed a mean difference ("bias") between the devices with the Fitbit recording, on average, 1,388 more steps/day than the accelerometer (Limits of Agreement (LoA) 1,741 to -4,518 steps per day). The ROC revealed a Fitbit cut-point of 12,272 steps/day corresponding to meeting guidelines.

CONCLUSIONS

Fitbit ChargeHR devices tend to overestimate daily step counts, but may still provide useful estimates of step counts and patterns in children and youth living with disability.

The 24-Hour Activity Checklist for Cerebral Palsy: Translation, Content Validity and Test-Retest Reliability of Portuguese Versions

BACKGROUND

The importance of 24-h movement behaviour, including sleep, physical activity (PA) and sedentary behaviour (SB), has gained prominence due to its significant impact on the health and development of children, including those with cerebral palsy (CP). The 24-h activity checklist for CP, a tool developed in the Netherlands to monitor the activity in CP paediatric population, requires translation and cultural adaptation to Portuguese for use in Brazil and Portugal.

METHODS

This cross-sectional methodological study involved translating and culturally adapting the 24-h activity checklist for CP into Brazilian Portuguese (BP) and European Portuguese (EP) languages. The process included forward translation, synthesis and backward translation, expert panel evaluation and pretesting. Brazilian and Portuguese experts appraised content validity, assessed by the individual item (I-CVI) and scale level content validity index scores (S-CVI/Ave). Sixty parents of children with CP participated in the test-retest analysis, reported with the Intraclass Correlation Coefficients (ICCs).

RESULTS

I-CVI scores were higher than 0.78 for both versions. S-CVI/Ave scores were considered excellent for BP (0.91) and EP version (1.0). Expert's appraisal results in the inclusion of a question about sleep-related time indicators and the split of sleep, PA, and screen time questions for weekdays and weekends. Brazilian and Portuguese parents of children with CP reported understanding on instructions, questions, and answer options. The ICC values range from 0.81 to 0.99 and 0.6 to 0.98, for BP and EP, respectively.

CONCLUSIONS

The BP and EP versions of 24-h activity checklist for CP demonstrated good content validity and test-retest reliability, supporting its use in Brazil and Portugal. This tool can contribute to improving communication between families and healthcare professionals to monitor and develop tailored interventions for healthy movement behaviours in children with CP.

24-hour movement behavior adherence and associations with health outcomes: an umbrella review

Background

Physical activity, sedentary behavior, and sleep, collectively known as the 24-hour movement behaviors, demonstrate individual and joint benefits on physical and mental health. Examination of these behaviors has expanded beyond guideline adherence to reviews of isotemporal substitution models (ISM) and compositional data analysis (CoDA). This umbrella review sought to review existing systematic reviews to (1) characterize the breadth and scope, (2) examine prevalence estimates for 24-hour movement guideline adherence, and (3) examine the relationship between these behaviors with health outcomes based on various approaches.

Methods

Eight databases and multiple supplementary strategies were used to identify systematic reviews, meta-analyses and pooled analyses that included two or more of the three 24-hour movement behaviors and a multi-behavior assessment approach. Overall review characteristics, movement behavior definitions, approaches, and health outcomes assessed were extracted, and methodological quality was assessed using the AMSTAR2 tool. Review characteristics (Aim 1), guideline prevalence estimates (Aim 2), and associations with health outcomes (Aim 3) were examined.

Findings

Thirty-two reviews (20 systematic reviews, 10 meta-analyses, and 2 pooled analyses) were included. Reviews captured the entire lifespan, global regions, and several physical and mental health outcomes. Individual and total guideline adherence waned from preschool to adolescence, but reviews reported similar prevalence estimates and ranges (i.e., within 10%). Common approaches included ISM and CoDA, evaluating 24-hour movement behavior's interactive associations with health outcomes, guideline adherence, and profile-based analysis. Despite heterogeneous approaches, reviews found consistent evidence for beneficial associations between meeting all three guidelines and high amount of physical activity on physical and mental health outcomes, but varied assessment of sedentary behavior or sleep. Most reviews were rated as low or critically low quality.

Conclusions

The breadth and scope of current reviews on 24-hour movement behaviors was wide and varied in this umbrella review, including all ages and across the globe. Prevalence estimates among populations beyond children need to be synthesized. Amongst the variety of definitions and approaches, reviews found benefit from achieving healthy amounts of all three behaviors. Longitudinal multi-behavior original research studies with rigorous assessment of sleep and sedentary behavior may help improve future systematic reviews of these various approaches.

Supplementary Information

The online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1186/s44167-024-00064-6.

Compliance with the 24-hour movement behaviour guidelines among children and adolescents with disabilities: a systematic review and meta-analysis

BACKGROUND

Compliance with the 24-Hour Movement Guidelines (24-HMG: physical activity (PA), screen time (ST), and sleep) has been associated with numerous beneficial health outcomes among children and adolescents. However, there is a lack of consensus on the overall compliance with the 24-HMG specifically among children and adolescents with disabilities. Therefore, this systematic review and meta-analysis aimed to examine the extent to which children and adolescents with disabilities adhere to the 24-HMG globally.

METHOD

Quantitative studies published in English until May 2023 were sought by searching seven electronic databases: Web of Science, PubMed, SPORTDiscus, CINAHL, MEDLINE, Scopus, Psychology and Behavioural Sciences Collection. This review included studies that identified participants as individuals with disabilities and reported the overall (non) compliance with the 24-HMG among children and adolescents with disabilities.

RESULTS

A total of 13 studies, involving 21,101 individuals (65.95% males), aged 6 to 21 years from 9 countries, were included in the analysis. In general, 7% (95%CI: 0.05-0.09, p < 0.01) of children and adolescents with disabilities met all three 24-HMG, while 16% (95%CI: 0.13-020, p < 0.01) did not meet any of the three recommendations. Regarding adherence to individual 24-hour movement behaviour, the rates of compliance were 22% (95%CI: 0.18-0.25, p < 0.01) for PA, 49% (95%CI: 0.41-0.56, p < 0.01) for ST, and 59% (95%CI: 0.56-0.61, p < 0.01) sleep. In relation to numbers of those meeting the 24-HMG, 43% (95%CI: 0.41-0.45, p < 0.01) met one guideline, while 32% (95%CI: 0.28-0.36, p < 0.01) met two guidelines.

CONCLUSION

There is a notable percentage of children and adolescents with disabilities who do not meet the recommended the 24-HMG, which encompasses PA, ST, and sleep. This underscores the pressing requirement to create and execute evidence-based strategies that effectively encourage and assist these individuals with disabilities in adopting and maintaining these movement behaviours.

Prevalence of meeting 24-hour movement guidelines and its associations with health indicators in people with disabilities: A systematic review and meta-analysis

BACKGROUND

Meeting the 24-h movement guidelines (i.e., physical activity, sedentary behavior, sleep) could generate health benefits to people with disabilities. However, no systematic reviews or meta-analyses have examined the prevalence of meeting these guidelines and associations with health indicators in this group.

OBJECTIVE

This systematic review and meta-analysis aimed to examine the prevalence of meeting the 24-h movement guidelines and associations with health indicators among people with disabilities.

METHODS

Six electronic databases were searched for studies published in English from inception to May 31, 2023. Meta-analyses with the random-effects model were used to determine the prevalence of meeting the 24-h movement guidelines. Qualitative syntheses were employed to describe the associations between meeting the guidelines and health indicators.

RESULTS

Twenty-four studies comprising 77510 participants (41.6% females) with disabilities aged 6-65 years from eight countries were identified. Overall, 6.97% of the participants with disabilities met all 24-h movement guidelines, and 16.65% met none of the guidelines. Significant age (P = 0.006) and disability type (P = 0.001) differences were found in meeting all guidelines. Participants with disabilities who met all guidelines reported better psychosocial health indicators (9/9 studies) than those met none or only one of the guidelines. There was limited evidence or research for other health indicators.

CONCLUSION

There is some evidence showing that the prevalence of meeting all 24-h movement guidelines in people with disabilities is low. Meanwhile, there is preliminary evidence suggesting that meeting all guidelines is associated with better psychosocial health than meeting none of the guidelines.

Adherence to 24-h movement guidelines among Chinese children and adolescents with intellectual disabilities

BACKGROUND

Meeting 24-h movement guidelines for children and adolescents has been associated with improved health indicators. However, the literature examining adherence to 24-h movement guidelines among Chinese children and adolescents with intellectual disability (ID) remains lacking. This study aims to investigate the prevalence of meeting the 24-h movement guidelines and its socio-demographic correlates for this population.

METHODS

The sample includes 319 Chinese students with ID. Accelerometers are used to measure moderate-to-vigorous physical activity time and sleep duration. Questionnaires are adopted to measure screen time (ST) and demographic factors. Associations among socio-demographic factors, body mass index and 24-h movement are analysed by using multivariable logistic regressions.

RESULTS

The proportions of participants who meet none, moderate-to-vigorous physical activity, ST, sleep duration and all three recommendations are 8.15%, 33.54%, 54.23%, 75.55% and 17.55%, respectively. In general, multivariable logistic regression analysis indicates that older participants are less likely to meet the ST guidelines [odds ratio (OR): 0.931; 95% confidence interval (CI): 0.869-0.998] and more likely to meet the sleep guidelines (OR: 1.106; 95% CI: 1.016-1.204) than younger individuals. Participants with moderate ID are less likely to meet the sleep guidelines (OR: 0.345; 95% CI: 0.140-0.850) than those with profound ID. Individuals from families with middle-income (OR: 0.434; 95% CI: 0.226-0.836) and high-income (OR: 0.219; 95% CI: 0.080-0.605) levels were less likely to meet the physical activity guidelines than those from low-income families. Furthermore, participants from high-income families were less likely to meet ST (OR: 0.426; 95% CI: 0.187-0.969) and all three movement guidelines (OR: 0.083; 95% CI: 0.010-0.659) than those in the low household income groups.

CONCLUSIONS

Interventions that improve the health-related behaviours of children and adolescents with ID are needed, particularly those that target their increased engagement in physical activity.

Accelerometer-measured physical activity, sedentary behavior, and sleep in children with cerebral palsy and their adherence to the 24-hour activity guidelines

AIM

To measure and describe the 24-hour activities (i.e. physical activity, sedentary behavior, and sleep) and to examine adherence to the 24-hour activity guidelines among children with cerebral palsy (CP) using actigraphy.

METHOD

Children's 24-hour activities were recorded over 7 days using hip- and wrist-worn ActiGraph wGT3X-BT accelerometers.

RESULTS

In total, 362 days and 340 nights from 54 children with CP (Gross Motor Function Classification System [GMFCS] levels I-III; 44% females; median age [range] 6 years 6 months [3-12 years]) were included. Mean (SD) daily wear time was 746.2 (48.9) minutes, of which children spent on average 33.8% in light physical activity (251.6 [58.7] minutes per day), 5.2% in moderate-to-vigorous physical activity (38.5 [20.1] minutes per day), and the remaining 61.1% being sedentary (456.1 [80.4] minutes per day). Physical activity decreased while sedentary behavior increased with increasing GMFCS level. In total, 13% of all children met the physical activity recommendations, and 35% met the age-appropriate sleep duration recommendation. The proportion of children meeting the combined 24-hour guidelines for physical activity and sleep was low (5.9%), especially in those classified in GMFCS level III (0%).

INTERPRETATION

The observed low 24-hour guideline adherence rates emphasize the importance of considering the entire continuum of movement behaviors in the care of children with CP, in efforts to promote healthy lifestyle behaviors and prevent negative health outcomes.

Meeting the 24-Hour Movement Guidelines and Outcomes in Adolescents with ADHD: A Cross-Sectional Observational Study

According to the 24-Hour Movement Guidelines, meeting daily recommendations for physical activity, sleep, and screen time is important for obtaining optimal health benefits. This cross-sectional observational study aimed to examine (a) the prevalence of meeting the movement guidelines; and (b) the associations between meeting the guidelines and selected outcomes in adolescents with attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD). Data from the 2018–2019 National Survey for Children’s Health dataset was used. Participants were adolescents (10–17 years) with ADHD and without other chronic conditions. Outcomes were flourishing, school engagement, and body weight status. Exposures of interest were adherence to the movement guidelines. The frequency of the participants’ adherence to the guidelines was estimated, and regression analyses were conducted to examine the associations between adherence to the guidelines and outcomes, adjusting for potential confounders. Complete observations were available for 634 adolescents with ADHD. Overall, 46.8% of the participants met at least one movement guideline, but only 6.5% met all three. The number of guidelines met had a significant and positive association with flourishing and school engagement (β = 0.21/0.17, p_trend < 0.001). Compared with meeting all three guidelines, significant associations with lower flourishing levels were found in participants who met none, sleep only, and sedentary time only (β = −0.38–−0.13, p < 0.05). Similar findings were identified in the school engagement outcome. Adherence to the guidelines was, however, not significantly associated with the odds of being overweight or obese. Collectively, the findings suggest the movement guidelines may be appropriate for extending to adolescents with ADHD and there is a need to increase adherence to the guidelines in this group.

Adverse Effects of the COVID-19 Pandemic on Movement and Play Behaviours of Children and Youth Living with Disabilities: Findings from the National Physical Activity Measurement (NPAM) Study

All children and youth require ample physical activity (PA), low levels of sedentary behaviour (SB), and adequate sleep to stay healthy. Children and youth living with disabilities (CYWD) tend to have fewer opportunities for participation in PA and outdoor play compared with their typically developing peers. In turn, CYWD are typically less active and more sedentary, on average, compared with their peers. The COVID-19 pandemic reduced opportunities for many children and youth to participate in PA and outdoor play. The purpose of this study was to assess parent-perceived changes in PA (including outdoor play), SB (including screen time), and sleep quality and quantity, due to COVID-19 and related restrictions, in a national cohort of Canadian CYWD. We recruited parents of school-aged CYWD (N = 151) in May 2020. In an online survey, parents reported their child's previous 7-day PA, SB, and sleep, as well as perceived changes in their child's movement and play behaviours due to COVID-19 and related restrictions. Parent-perceived parental support for their child's movement and play behaviours during the pandemic was also assessed. We used descriptive statistics to describe the child's movement behaviours and assessed the association between movement behaviours and parental factors using Pearson and point-biserial correlations. Few (5.3%) CYWD met PA recommendations and 13.2% met screen time recommendations during the acute period of the COVID-19 pandemic. More CYWD (66.2%) were meeting sleep recommendations. Overall, only 1.3% of CYWD were meeting the combined movement guidelines. Parent encouragement was positively associated with the child's outdoor PA (0.23), wheeling, walking, and biking (0.19), indoor PA (0.16), and family-based PA (0.26). Parental co-play was similarly positively associated with the child's outdoor PA (0.26), wheeling, walking, and biking (0.39), indoor PA (0.16), and family-based PA (0.26). Parents perceived their CYWD to be less active and more sedentary as a result of COVID-19 and the related restrictions. Parents of CYWD have an important role in encouraging healthy movement behaviours. Return to movement and play post-COVID guidelines should include tailored strategies for CYWD and their families to mitigate the negative impacts of the pandemic.

Implications of Disability Severity on 24-Hour Movement Guideline Adherence Among Children With Neurodevelopmental Disorders in the United States

BACKGROUND

Research has established beneficial associations between 24-hour movement guideline adherence and several health outcomes in typically developing (TD) children, but these relationships are poorly understood in children with neurodevelopmental disorders (NDD). This study examined (1) 24-hour movement guideline adherence, (2) the influence of disability severity, and (3) associations between guideline adherence and health outcomes of TD children and children with NDD.

METHODS

This cross-sectional study used data from the 2018 and 2019 cycles of the US National Survey of Children's Health. Parental/caregiver reports of movement behaviors (physical activity, screen time, and sleep), disability severity (limitations to daily activities), and health outcomes (general health status, anxiety, and depression) were provided for 8554 children with NDD and 19,669 TD children aged 6-17 years.

RESULTS

Children with NDD had significantly lower odds of meeting each movement behavior guideline compared to TD children; these effects were most pronounced for those who experienced consistent limitations to daily activities. Meeting at least 2 guidelines significantly lowered the odds for anxiety and depression, and increased the odds for better general health for children with NDD.

DISCUSSION

These findings suggest that degree of disability severity has a strong influence on adherence to 24-hour movement guidelines among children with NDD.