Silicon alleviates cadmium toxicity by enhanced photosynthetic rate and modified bundle sheath's cell chloroplasts ultrastructure in maize

Efficacy of malic and tartaric acid in mitigation of cadmium stress in Spinacia oleracea L. via modulations in physiological and biochemical attributes

The increasing level of cadmium (Cd) contamination in soil due to anthropogenic actions is a significant problem. This problem not only harms the natural environment, but it also causes major harm to human health via the food chain. The use of chelating agent is a useful strategy to avoid heavy metal uptake and accumulation in plants. In this study, randomized design pot experiment was conducted to evaluate potential role of malic acid (MA) and tartaric acid (TA) foliar spray to mitigate Cd stress in Spinacia oleracea L plants. For Cd stress, S. oleracea plants were treated with CdCl2 solution (100 µM). For control, plants were given distilled water. One week after Cd stress, MA and TA foliar spray was employed at concentration of 100 and 150 µM for both. The results of this study revealed that Cd stress (100 µM) significantly reduced growth attributes, photosynthetic pigments and related parameters and gas exchange attributes. Cadmium stress also stimulated antioxidant defense mechanism in S. oleracea. Cd stressed plants had elevated levels of Cd metal ions in root and consumable parts (i.e. leaves) and caused severe oxidative damages in the form of increased lipid peroxidation and electrolytic leakage. MA and TA supplements at both low and high levels (100 and 150 µM) effectively reversed the devastating effects of Cd stress and improved growth, photosynthesis and defense related attributes of S. oleracea plants. These supplements also prevented excessive accumulation of Cd metal ions as indicated by lowered Cd metal contents in MA and TA treated plants. These findings demonstrated that MA and TA treatments can potentially reduce Cdl induced phytotoxicity in plants by reducing its uptake and enhancing photosynthesis and defense related parameters.

Silicon might mitigate nickel toxicity in maize roots via chelation, detoxification, and membrane transport

Nickel is an essential micronutrient for plant growth and development. However, in excessive amounts caused by accidental pollution of soils, this heavy metal is toxic to plants. Although silicon is a non-essential nutrient, it accumulates in most monocots, particularly the vital crop maize (corn, Zea mays). In fact, this metalloid mineral can alleviate the toxicity of heavy metals, though the mechanism is not entirely clear yet. Herein, we measured proteome, gene expression, enzyme activities, and selected sugars to investigate such effect thoroughly. Deep proteomic analysis revealed a minor impact of 100 µM Ni, 2.5 mM Si, or their combination on roots in 12-day-old hydroponically grown maize seedlings upon 9 days of exposure. Nonetheless, we suggested plausible mechanisms of Si mitigation of excessive Ni: Chelation by metallothioneins and phytochelatins, detoxification by glycine betaine pathway, and restructuring of plasma membrane transporters. Higher activity of glutathione S-transferase confirmed its plausible involvement in reducing Ni toxicity in combined treatment. Accumulation of sucrose synthase and corresponding soluble sugars in Ni and combined treatment implied high energy requirements both during heavy metal stress and its mitigation. Expression analysis of genes coding a few differentially accumulated proteins failed to reveal concordant changes, indicating posttranscriptional regulation. Proposed mitigation mechanisms should be functionally validated in follow-up studies.

Nano-Fe3O4: Enhancing the tolerance of Elymus nutans to Cd stress through regulating programmed cell death

Cadmium (Cd) poses a significant threat to plant growth and the environment. Nano-Fe3O4 is effective in alleviating Cd stress in plants. Elymus nutans Griseb. is an important fodder crop on the Qinghai-Tibetan Plateau (QTP). However, the potential mechanism by which nano-Fe3O4 alleviates Cd stress in E. nutans is not well understood. E. nutans were subjected to single Cd, single nano-Fe3O4, and co-treatment with nano-Fe3O4 and Cd, and the effects on morphology, Cd uptake, antioxidant enzyme activity, reactive oxygen species (ROS) levels and programmed cell death (PCD) were studied to clarify the regulatory mechanism of nano-Fe3O4. The results showed that Cd stress significantly decreased the germination percentage and biomass of E. nutans. The photosynthetic pigment content decreased significantly under Cd stress. Cd stress also caused oxidative stress and lipid peroxidation, accumulation of excessive ROS, resulting in PCD, but the effect of nano-Fe3O4 was different. Seed germination, seedling growth, and physiological processes were analyzed to elucidate the regulatory role of nano-Fe3O4 nanoparticles in promoting photosynthesis, reducing Cd accumulation, scavenging ROS, and regulating PCD, to promote seed germination and seedling growth in E. nutans. This report provides a scientific basis for improving the tolerance of Elymus to Cd stress by using nano-Fe3O4.

Interactive effect of 24-epibrassinolide and silicon on the alleviation of cadmium toxicity in rice (Oryza sativa L.) plants

Cadmium (Cd) pollution is a serious threat to food safety and human health. Minimization of Cd uptake and enhancing Cd tolerance in plants are vital to improve crop yield and reduce hazardous effects to humans. In this study, we investigate the effect of a synergistic system with phytohormone (24-Epibrassinolide, EBL) and silicon (Si) on Cd toxicity and accumulation of rice plants. The results revealed that Si, EBL and their combination rescued Cd-induced growth inhibition, as evidenced by the increased dry weight of root and shoot. The chlorophyll content and photosynthetic performance were improved. The activity of antioxidant enzymes (SOD, POD and CAT) was increased and oxidative stress was alleviated. More importantly, Cd content in root was decreased by 20.25%, 17.72% and 27.84%, while Cd content in shoot decreased by 21.17%, 16.47% and 25.88%, respectively. Moreover, Si, EBL and Si + EBL treatment enriched cell wall-bound Cd and reduced Cd toxicity to functional organelles. Meanwhile, the residual form of Cd was enriched and the highly toxic forms of Cd (inorganic and water-soluble Cd) were decreased. The joint application showed better effects than applying Si and EBL alone. Collectively, this study provides an effective way for Cd toxicity mitigation in rice plants.

Effect of silicon spraying on rice photosynthesis and antioxidant defense system on cadmium accumulation

Cadmium (Cd) pollution is a serious threat to food safety and human health. Minimizing Cd uptake and enhancing Cd tolerance in plants are vital to improve crop yield and reduce hazardous effects to humans. In this study, we designed three Cd concentration stress treatments (Cd1: 0.20 mg·kg-1, Cd2: 0.60 mg·kg-1, and Cd3: 1.60 mg·kg-1) and two foliar silicon (Si) treatments (CK: no spraying of any material, and Si: foliar Si spraying) to conduct pot experiments on soil Cd stress. The results showed that spraying Si on the leaves reduced the Cd content in brown rice by 4.79-42.14%. Si application increased net photosynthetic rate (Pn) by 1.77-4.08%, stomatal conductance (Gs) by 5.27-23.43%, transpiration rate (Tr) by 2.99-20.50% and intercellular carbon dioxide (CO2) concentration (Ci) by 6.55-8.84%. Foliar spraying of Si significantly increased the activities of superoxide dismutase (SOD) and peroxidase (POD) in rice leaves by 9.84-14.09% and 4.69-53.09%, respectively, and reduced the content of malondialdehyde (MDA) by 7.83-48.72%. In summary, foliar Si spraying protects the photosynthesis and antioxidant system of rice canopy leaves, and is an effective method to reduce the Cd content in brown rice.

Silicon and iron nanoparticles protect rice against lead (Pb) stress by improving oxidative tolerance and minimizing Pb uptake

Lead (Pb) is toxic to the development and growth of rice plants. Nanoparticles (NPs) have been considered one of the efficient remediation techniques to mitigate Pb stress in plants. Therefore, a study was carried out to examine the underlying mechanism of iron (Fe) and silicon (Si) nanoparticle-induced Pb toxicity alleviation in rice seedlings. Si-NPs (2.5 mM) and Fe-NPs (25 mg L-1) were applied alone and in combination to rice plants grown without (control; no Pb stress) and with (100 µM) Pb concentration. Our results revealed that Pb toxicity severely affected all rice growth-related traits, such as inhibited root fresh weight (42%), shoot length (24%), and chlorophyll b contents (26%). Moreover, a substantial amount of Pb was translocated to the above-ground parts of plants, which caused a disturbance in the antioxidative enzyme activities. However, the synergetic use of Fe- and Si-NPs reduced the Pb contents in the upper part of plants by 27%. It reduced the lethal impact of Pb on roots and shoots growth parameters by increasing shoot length (40%), shoot fresh weight (48%), and roots fresh weight (31%). Both Si and Fe-NPs synergistic application significantly elevated superoxide dismutase (SOD), peroxidase (POD), catalase (CAT), and glutathione (GSH) concentrations by 114%, 186%, 135%, and 151%, respectively, compared to plants subjected to Pb stress alone. The toxicity of Pb resulted in several cellular abnormalities and altered the expression levels of metal transporters and antioxidant genes. We conclude that the synergistic application of Si and Fe-NPs can be deemed favorable, environmentally promising, and cost-effective for reducing Pb deadliness in rice crops and reclaiming Pb-polluted soils.

Cadmium negatively affects the growth and physiological status and the alleviation effects by exogenous selenium in silage maize (Zea mays L.)

Increasing soil cadmium (Cd) contamination is a serious threat to human food health and safety. In order to reduce Cd uptake and Cd toxicity in silage maize, hydroponic tests were conducted to investigate the effect of exogenous Cd on the toxicity of silage maize in this study. In the study, a combination of Cd (5, 20, 50, 80, and 10 μM) treatments was applied in a hydroponic system. With increasing Cd concentration, Cd significantly inhibited the total root length (RL), root surface area (SA), root volume (RV), root tip number (RT), and branching number (RF) of maize seedlings, which were reduced by 28.1 to 71.3%, 20.2 to 64.9%, 11.2 to 56.5%, 43.7 to 63.4%, and 38.2 to 72.6%, respectively. The excessive Cd accumulation inhibited biomass accumulation and reduced silage maize growth, photosynthesis, and chlorophyll content and activated the antioxidant systems, including increasing lipid peroxidation and stimulating catalase (CAT) and peroxidase (POD), but reduced the activity of superoxide dismutase (SOD) and ascorbate peroxidase (APX) in the root. Besides, selenium (Se) significantly decreased the Cd concentration of the shoot and root by 27.1% and 35.1% under Cd50, respectively. Our results reveal that exogenously applied Cd reduced silage maize growth and impaired photosynthesis. Whereas silage maize can tolerate Cd by increasing the concentration of ascorbate and glutathione and activating the antioxidant defense system, the application of exogenous selenium significantly reduced the content of Cd in silage maize.

Silicon a key player to mitigate chromium toxicity in plants: Mechanisms and future prospective

Chromium is a serious heavy metal (HM) and its concentration in plant-soil interface is soaring due to anthropogenic activities, unregulated disposals, and lack of efficient treatments. High concentration of Cr is toxic to ecosystems and human health. Cr stress also diminishes the plant performance by changing the plant's vegetative and reproductive development that ultimately affects sustainable crop production. Silicon (Si) is the second-most prevalent element in the crust of the planet, and has demonstrated a remarkable potential to minimize the HM toxicity. Amending soils with Si mitigates adverse effects of Cr by improving plant physiological, biochemical, and molecular functioning and ensuring better Cr immobilization, compartmentation, and co-precipitation. However, there is no comprehensive review on the role of Si to mitigate Cr toxicity in plants. Thus, in this present review; the discussion has been carried on; 1) the source of Cr, 2) underlying mechanisms of Cr uptake by plants, 3) how Si affects the plant functioning to reduce Cr toxicity, 4) how Si can cause immobilization, compartmentation, and co-precipitation 5) strategies to improve Si accumulation in plants to counter Cr toxicity. We also discussed the knowledge gaps and future research needs. The present review reports up-to-date knowledge about the role of Si to mitigate Cr toxicity and it will help to get better crop productivity in Cr-contaminated soils. The findings of the current review will educate the readers on Si functions in reducing Cr toxicity and will offer new ideas to develop Cr tolerance in plants through the use of Si.

Variability in cadmium stress tolerance among four maize genotypes: Impacts on plant physiology, root morphology, and chloroplast microstructure

Cadmium (Cd) is detrimental to both plants and humans. Maize (Zea mays L.) genotypes exhibit variations in Cd accumulations. This study examined variations in Cd accumulation and tolerance among four maize genotypes with contrasting root morphology. The four maize genotypes were cultivated in a semi-hydroponic system with three Cd concentrations (0, 10, 20 μmol L-1). The effects of Cd on plant growth and physiology were assessed 39 days after transplanting. Results showed that root characteristics were positively correlated with root Cd accumulation and the bioconcentration factor under Cd20 treatment. Genotypes Shengrui999 and Zhengdan958 exhibited higher total Cd content than Xundan29 and Zhongke11 under Cd20 conditions. Cd toxicity led to membrane degradation of chloroplast mesophyll cells, loosening and swelling of grana lamella, and reduced starch reserves. The greater tolerance of Shengrui999 and Zhengdan958 was contributed to factors such as root biomass, shallower root depth, higher Cd content, accumulation of osmolyte such as soluble protein, antioxidant activities such as catalase (CAT), and the presence of phytohormone gibberellic acid. The study establishes a link between root morphology, Cd accumulation, and tolerance in maize plants, as demonstrated by the higher Cd accumulation and shallower root system in Cd-tolerant genotypes. This research provides a foundation for breeding maize cultivars better suited for adaptation to moderate Cd-contaminated environments.

Modulation of metal transporters, oxidative stress and cell abnormalities by synergistic application of silicon and titanium oxide nanoparticles: A strategy for cadmium tolerance in rice

Heavy metals, especially cadmium (Cd), cause severe toxicity symptoms in crop plants. Applying nanoparticles (NPs) as nano-fertilizers is a novel approach to mitigating plants' Cd stress. However, knowledge about the combinational use of silicon (Si) and titanium dioxide (TiO2) NPs to mitigate Cd stress, especially in rice, must be highlighted. TiO2-NPs (15 mg L-1) and Si-NPs (2.5 mM) were applied alone and in combination to rice plants grown without (control; no Cd stress) and with (100 μM) Cd concentration. Results revealed that compared to the control plants, root length, shoot length, shoot fresh weight, and root dry weight of rice seedlings were significantly decreased by 25.43%, 26.64%, 34.13%, and 29.87% under Cd exposure. However, the synergistic effect of TiO2- and Si-NPs increased rice plants' shoot length, root length, root dry weight, and shoot fresh weight by 24.62%, 29.81%, 36.16%, and 33.07%, respectively, under the Cd-toxicity. The concentration of malondialdehyde (MDA) and H2O2 were amplified due to Cd stress, which leads to damage to the subcellular structures. Si and TiO2-NPs co-application improved the anti-oxidative enzymatic activities (catalase, peroxidase, superoxide dismutase) and an elevated concentration of non-enzymatic glutathione in Cd-exposed rice. The Cd accumulation was condensed by 21.37% and 19.7% in the shoot, while 48.31% and 45.65% in root tissues under Si-NPs + Cd and TiO2-NPs + Cd treatments compared to Cd-alone treated seedlings, respectively. The expression patterns of metal transporters, such as OsNramp1 and OsHMA3, were the highest when rice plants were cultivated under Cd stress and significantly reduced when treated with sole and combined Si- and TiO2-NPs treatments. In conclusion, combining Si- and TiO2-NPs significantly improved the antioxidant enzymatic activities, chlorophyll contents, biomass production, and reduced cellular damage. Despite limitations, our findings guide future research, addressing risks, optimizing concentrations, and assessing long-term effects that can balance agricultural progress with environmental sustainability.

The role of arbuscular mycorrhizal fungi in the alleviation of cadmium stress in cereals: A multilevel meta-analysis

The symbiotic relationships between crop species and arbuscular mycorrhizal fungi (AMF) are crucial for plant health, productivity, and environmental sustainability. The roles of AMF in reducing crop stress caused by cadmium (Cd) toxicity and in the remediation of Cd-contaminated soil are not fully understood. Here we report on a meta-analysis that sought to identify the functions of AMF in cereals under Cd stress. A total of 54 articles published between January 1992 and September 2022 were used to create the dataset, which provided 7216 data sets on mycorrhizal cereals under Cd stress examined. AMF effects on colonization rate, biomass, physiological level, nutritional level, and plant Cd level were measured using the logarithmic response ratio (Ln R). The results showed that AMF overall greatly reduced 5.14 - 33.6 % Cd stress on cereals in greenhouse experiments under controlled conditions. AMF colonization significantly stimulated crop biomass by 65.7 %, boosted the formation of photosynthetic pigments (23.2 %), and greatly increased plant nitrogen (24.8 %) and phosphorus (58.4 %) uptake. The dilution effect of mycorrhizal plants made the Cd concentration decline by 25.2 % in AMF plants compared to non-mycorrhizal ones. AMF also alleviated Cd stress by improving osmotic regulators (soluble protein, sugar, and total proline, from 14.8 to 36.0 %) and lowering the membrane lipid peroxidation product (MDA, 12.9 %). Importantly, the results from the random forest and model selection analysis demonstrated that crop type, soil characteristics, chemical form, and Cd levels were the main factors determining the function of AMF in alleviating Cd stress. Additionally, there was a significant interaction between AMF colonization rate and Cd addition, but their interactive effect was less than the colonization rate alone. This meta-analysis demonstrated that AMF inoculation could be considered as a promising strategy for mitigation of Cd stress in cereals.

Heavy metal stress in plants: Ways to alleviate with exogenous substances

Accumulation and enrichment of excessive heavy metals due to industrialization and modernization not only devastate our ecosystem, but also pose a threat to the global vegetation, especially crops. To improve plant resilience against heavy metal stress (HMS), numerous exogenous substances (ESs) have been tried as the alleviating agents. After a careful and thorough review of over 150 recently published literature, 93 reported ESs and their corresponding effects on alleviating HMS, we propose that 7 underlying mechanisms of ESs be categorized in plants for: 1) improving the capacity of the antioxidant system, 2) inducing the synthesis of osmoregulatory substances, 3) enhancing the photochemical system, 4) detouring the accumulation and migration of heavy metals, 5) regulating the secretion of endogenous hormones, 6) modulating gene expressions, and 7) participating in microbe-involved regulations. Recent research advances strongly indicate that ESs have proven to be effective in mitigating a potential negative impact of HMS on crops and other plants, but not enough to ultimately solve the devastating problem associated with excessive heavy metals. Therefore, much more research should be focused and carried out to eliminate HMS for the sustainable agriculture and clean environmental through minimizing towards prohibiting heavy metals from entering our ecosystem, phytodetoxicating polluted landscapes, retrieving heavy metals from detoxicating plants or crop, breeding for more tolerant cultivars for both high yield and tolerance against HMS, and seeking synergetic effect of multiply ESs on HMS alleviation in our feature researches.

Identification of key genes responsible for green and white colored spathes in Anthurium andraeanum (Hort.)

Modern anthuriums, Anthurium andraeanum (Hort.) are among the most popular flowering plants and widely used for interior decoration. Their popularity is largely attributed to the exotic spathes with different colors. Previous studies have reported color development in red spathe cultivars, but limited information is available on key genes regulating white and green colored spathes. This study analyzed anthocyanin, chlorophyll, and carotenoid contents as well as transcript differences in spathes of eight cultivars that differed in spathe colors ranging from red to white and green. Results showed that increased expression of a transcription factor AaMYB2 was associated with elevated levels of anthocyanin in spathes, but decreased expression of AaMYB2 and increased expression of AaLAR (leucoanthocyanidin reductase) and AaANR (anthocyanidin reductase) were accompanied with the accumulation of colorless proanthocyanidin, thus the white spathe. As to the green colored spathe, chlorophyll content in the green spathe cultivar was substantially higher than the other cultivars. Correspondingly, transcripts of chlorophyll biosynthesis-related genes AaHemB (porphobilinogen synthase) and AaPor (protochlorophyllide oxidoreductase) were highly upregulated but almost undetectable in white and red spathes. The increased expression of AaHemB and AaPor was correlated with the expression of transcription factor AaMYB124. Subsequently, qRT-PCR analysis confirmed their expression levels in nine additional cultivars with red, white, and green spathes. A working model for the formation of white and green spathes was proposed. White colored spathes are likely due to the decreased expression of AaMYB2 which results in increased expression of AaLAR and AaANR, and the green spathes are attributed to AaMYB124 enhanced expression of AaHemB and AaPor. Further research is warranted to test this working model.

Do Antimonite and Silicon Share the Same Root Uptake Pathway by Lsi1 in Sorghum bicolor L. Moench?

A study was conducted to further develop our understanding of antimony (Sb) uptake in plants. Unlike other metal(loid)s, such as silicon (Si), the mechanisms of Sb uptake are not well understood. However, SbIII is thought to enter the cell via aquaglyceroporins. We investigated if the channel protein Lsi1, which aids in Si uptake, also plays a role in Sb uptake. Seedlings of WT sorghum, with normal silicon accumulation, and its mutant (sblsi1), with low silicon accumulation, were grown in Hoagland solution for 22 days in the growth chamber under controlled conditions. Control, Sb (10 mg Sb L^-1), Si (1mM) and Sb + Si (10 mg Sb L^-1 + 1 mM Si) were the treatments. After 22 days, root and shoot biomass, the concentration of elements in root and shoot tissues, lipid peroxidation and ascorbate levels, and relative expression of Lsi1 were determined. When mutant plants were exposed to Sb, they showed almost no toxicity symptoms compared to WT plants, indicating that Sb was not toxic to mutant plants. On the other hand, WT plants had decreased root and shoot biomass, increased MDA content and increased Sb uptake compared to mutant plants. In the presence of Sb, we also found that SbLsi1 was downregulated in the roots of WT plants. The results of this experiment support the role of Lsi1 in Sb uptake in sorghum plants.

Integrated physio-biochemical and transcriptomic analysis revealed mechanism underlying of Si-mediated alleviation to cadmium toxicity in wheat

Cadmium (Cd) contamination has resulted in serious reduction of crop yields. Silicon (Si), as a beneficial element, regulates plant growth to heavy metal toxicity mainly through reducing metal uptake and protecting plants from oxidative injury. However, the molecular mechanism underlying Si-mediated Cd toxicity in wheat has not been well understood. This study aimed to reveal the beneficial role of Si (1 mM) in alleviating Cd-induced toxicity in wheat (Triticum aestivum) seedlings. The results showed that exogenous supply of Si decreased Cd concentration by 67.45% (root) and 70.34% (shoot), and maintained ionic homeostasis through the function of important transporters, such as Lsi, ZIP, Nramp5 and HIPP. Si ameliorated Cd-induced photosynthetic performance inhibition through up-regulating photosynthesis-related genes and light harvesting-related genes. Si minimized Cd-induced oxidative stress by decreasing MDA contents by 46.62% (leaf) and 75.09% (root), and helped re-establish redox homeostasis by regulating antioxidant enzymes activities, AsA-GSH cycle and expression of relevant genes through signal transduction pathway. The results revealed molecular mechanism of Si-mediated wheat tolerance to Cd toxicity. Si fertilizer is suggested to be applied in Cd contaminated soil for food safety production as a beneficial and eco-friendly element.

How does phosphorus influence Cd tolerance strategy in arbuscular mycorrhizal - Phragmites australis symbiotic system?

To clarify how phosphorus (P) influences arbuscular mycorrhizal fungi (AMF) interactions with host plants, we measured the effects of variation in environmental P levels and AMF colonization on photosynthesis, element absorption, ultrastructure, antioxidant capacity, and transcription mechanisms in Phragmites australis (P. australis) under cadmium (Cd) stress. AMF maintained photosynthetic stability, element balance, subcellular integrity and enhanced antioxidant capacity by upregulating antioxidant gene expression. Specifically, AMF overcame Cd-induced stomatal limitation, and mycorrhizal dependence peaked in the high Cd-moderate P treatment (156.08%). Antioxidants and compatible solutes responded to P-level changes: the primary driving forces of removing reactive oxygen species (ROS) and maintaining osmotic balance were superoxide dismutase, catalase, and sugars at limited P levels and total polyphenol, flavonoid, peroxidase, and proline at abundant P levels, we refer to this phenomenon as "functional link." AMF and phosphorus enhanced Cd tolerance in P. australis, but the regulation of AMF was P-dependent. Phosphorus prevented increases in total glutathione content and AMF-induced GSH/GSSG ratio (reduced to oxidized glutathione ratio) by inhibiting the expression of assimilatory sulfate reduction and glutathione reductase genes. The AMF-induced flavonoid synthesis pathway was regulated by P, and AMF activated Cd-tolerance mechanisms by inducing P-dependent signaling.

Spirulina platensis improves growth, oil content, and antioxidant activitiy of rosemary plant under cadmium and lead stress

In the present study, a pot experiment was conducted to investigate the response of rosemary (Rosmarinus officinalis L.) plants to foliar application of Spirulina platensis at 0.0, 0.1, 0.2, and 0.4%; soil irrigation with heavy metals (Cd nitrate, Pb acetate, and Cd + Pb, each at 100 ppm), and Spirulina platensis at 0.1% + heavy metals. Spirulina platensis significantly improved growth parameters, oil yield/fed, photosynthetic pigments, and activity of superoxide dismutase (SOD), glutathione reductase (GR), catalase (CAT), and polyphenol oxidase (PPO) with a maximum promoting effect at 0.2% algal extract. On the other hand, heavy metal stress reduced growth criteria, photosynthetic pigments, and oil yield, while, significantly increased levels of antioxidant enzymes (SOD, CAT, GR) and corresponding non-enzymatic antioxidants (ascorbic acid, total antioxidant capacity, phenolics and flavonoids). Bioaccumulation factor (BF) and translocation factor (TF) indicated that Cd and Pb accumulated largely in the roots, with little transfer to the shoots. Nevertheless, compared with heavy metal treatments, S. platensis at 0.1% significantly increasing growth parameters, oil content, photosynthetic pigments, and the activity of non-enzymatic and enzymatic antioxidants, while, slightly reduced TF of Cd and Pb, alleviated membrane lipid peroxidation, and significantly lowered the content of malondialdehyde, hydrogen peroxide, and indole acetic acid oxidase (IAAO) activity in heavy metal (Cd, Pb, and Cd + Pb)-treated rosemary plants.

Galactoglucomannan oligosaccharides alleviate cadmium toxicity by improving physiological processes in maize

Phosphate fertilisers and past mining activity are significant source of cadmium (Cd) pollution; thus, the concentration of Cd in agricultural soils has been substantially rising. Various substances have been tested for their potential to alleviate the toxicity of Cd and stimulate the accumulation of Cd in plant organs. This study brought new insight of the impact of galactoglucomannan oligosaccharides (GGMOs) on the maize plants grown under/in Cd stress. The application of GGMOs reduced concentration of Cd in the maize leaves and thus GGMOs increased their growth (by 24%), concentration of photosynthetic pigments (up to 39.4%), effective quantum yield of photosystem II (up to 29.6%), and net photosynthetic rate (up to 19.6%). The concentrations of stress markers increased in the Cd and Cd + GGMOs treatment; however, significantly lower concentration was detected in the Cd + GGMOs treatment (malondialdehyde by 21.7%, hydrogen peroxide by 13%). The concentration of auxin increased almost by two-fold in the Cd + GGMOs treatment compared to the Cd treatment. The recovered auxin level and enhanced nutrient uptake are proposed mechanisms of GGMOs' action during stress. GGMOs are molecules with biostimulant potential that could support vitality of maize plants in Cd stress.

The mechanism of silicon on alleviating cadmium toxicity in plants: A review

Cadmium is one of the most toxic heavy metal elements that seriously threaten food safety and agricultural production worldwide. Because of its high solubility, cadmium can easily enter plants, inhibiting plant growth and reducing crop yield. Therefore, finding a way to alleviate the inhibitory effects of cadmium on plant growth is critical. Silicon, the second most abundant element in the Earth's crust, has been widely reported to promote plant growth and alleviate cadmium toxicity. This review summarizes the recent progress made to elucidate how silicon mitigates cadmium toxicity in plants. We describe the role of silicon in reducing cadmium uptake and transport, improving plant mineral nutrient supply, regulating antioxidant systems and optimizing plant architecture. We also summarize in detail the regulation of plant water balance by silicon, and the role of this phenomenon in enhancing plant resistance to cadmium toxicity. An in-depth analysis of literature has been conducted to identify the current problems related to cadmium toxicity and to propose future research directions.

Antagonistic impact on cadmium stress in alfalfa supplemented with nano-zinc oxide and biochar via upregulating metal detoxification

Eco-toxicological estimation of cadmium induced damages by morpho-physiological and cellular response could be an insightful strategy to alleviate negative impact of Cd in agricultural crops. The current study revealed novel patterns of Cd-bioaccumulation and cellular mechanism opted by alfalfa to acquire Cd tolerance under various soil applied zinc oxide nanoparticles (nZnO) doses (0, 30, 60, 90 mg kg^-1), combined with 2% biochar (BC). Herein, the potential impact of these soil amendments was justified by decreased Cd and increased Zn-bioaccumulation into roots by 38 % and 48 % and shoots by 51 % and 72 % respectively, with co-exposure of nZnO with BC. As, the transmission electron microscopy (TEM) and scanning electron microscopy and energy dispersive spectroscopy (SEM-EDS) ultrastructural observations confirmed that Cd-exposure induced stomatal closure, and caused damage to roots and leaves ultrastructure as compared to the control group. On the contrary, the damages to the above-mentioned traits were reversed by a higher nZnO dose, and the impact was further aggravated by adding BC along nZnO. Furthermore, higher nZnO and BC levels efficiently alleviated the Cd-mediated reductions in alfalfa biomass, antioxidant enzymatic response, and gaseous exchange traits than control. Overall, soil application of 90 mg kg^-1 nZnO with BC (2 %) was impactful in averting Cd stress damages and ensuring better plant performance. Thereby, applying soil nZnO and BC emerge as promising green remediation techniques to enhance crop tolerance in Cd-polluted soil.

Alleviation of Cd-polluted paddy soils through Si fertilizer application and its effects on the soil microbial community

In this study, the effects of slag-based Si fertilizers on Cd-polluted paddy soils, soil microbial diversity, and functional properties were evaluated through a long-term field experiment conducted in a double-rice cropping system in southern China. The results showed that soil pH significantly increased from 5.15 to 6.13 after seven years of Si fertilization. Cd accumulation in both the soil and rice plants were significantly decreased for all the Si fertilizers treatments. Treatments using Si fertilizer in powder form exhibited the best alleviation effects, where soil available Cd decreased from 0.50 mg kg^-1 to 0.43 mg kg^-1, and Cd accumulation in rice roots, straw, and grains decreased by 32.2 %, 57.2 %, and 45.5 %, respectively, than that in the control. Following Si application, the soil microbial richness and Shannon diversity increased from 6731 to 7549 and 7.12 to 7.28, respectively. Proteobacteria, Nitrospirae, and Gemmatimonadetes, were significantly enriched in the Si-treated samples, whereas Verrucomicrobia, Chlamydiia, Ktedonobacteria and Candidatus_Saccharibacteria exhibited opposite patterns. Bioinformatics analysis using phylogenetic investigation of communities by reconstruction of unobserved states tools revealed that the varied microbial community induced functional adaption of soil microorganisms involved in metabolism, genetic information processing, cellular processes, and environmental information processing. The soil pH, NH₄-N, and available Cd and Si contents were the key factors that best explained the variations in bacterial community composition among different treatments. Slag-based Si fertilizers are effective for Cd detoxication and can benefit the growth of rice plants throng the regulation of soil microorganisms.

Growth, physiological, and temperature characteristics in chinese cabbage pakchoi as affected by Cd- stressed conditions and identifying its main controlling factors using PLS model

BACKGROUND

Although hormesis induced by heavy metals is a well-known phenomenon, the involved biological mechanisms are not fully understood. Cadmium (Cd) is a prevalent heavy metal in the environment. Exposure of Cd, via intake or consumption of Cd-contaminated air or food, poses a huge threat to human health. Chinese cabbage pakchoi (Brassica chinensis L.) is widely planted and consumed as a popular vegetable in China. Therefore, studying the response of Chinese cabbage pakchoi to Cd- stressed conditions is critical to assess whether cabbage can accumulate Cd and serve as an important Cd exposure pathway to human beings. In this study, we investigated the influence of Cd stress on growth, photosynthetic physiology, antioxidant enzyme activities, nutritional quality, anatomical structure, and canopy temperature in Chinese cabbage pakchoi. A partial least squares (PLS) model was used to quantify the relationship between physical and chemical indicators with Cd accumulation in cabbage, and identify the main controlling factors.

RESULTS

Results showed that Cd stress significantly inhibited cabbage's growth and development. When Cd stress was increased, the phenotypic indicators were significantly reduced. Meanwhile, Cd stress significantly enhanced the oxidative stress response of cabbage, such as the activities of catalase (CAT), superoxide dismutase (SOD), peroxidase (POD), ascorbate peroxidase (APX), and the content of malondialdehyde (MDA) in leaves. Such a change tended to increase fenestrated tissues' thickness but decrease the thickness of leaf and spongy tissues. Moreover, Cd stress significantly increased soluble sugar, protein, and vitamin C contents in leaves as well as the temperature in the plant canopy. The PLS model analysis showed that the studied phenotypic and physicochemical indicators had good relationships with Cd accumulation in roots, shoots, and the whole plant of cabbage, with high coefficient of determination (R²) values of 0.891, 0.811, and 0.845, and low relative percent deviation (RPD) values of 3.052, 2.317, and 2.557, respectively. Furthermore, through analyzing each parameter's variable importance for projection (VIP) value, the SOD activity was identified as a key factor for indicating Cd accumulation in cabbage. Meanwhile, the effects of CAT on Cd accumulation in cabbage and the canopy mean temperature were also high.

CONCLUSION

Cd stress has significant inhibitory effects and can cause damage cabbage's growth and development, and the SOD activity may serve as a key factor to indicate Cd uptake and accumulation in cabbage.

Exogenous acetone O-(4-chlorophenylsulfonyl) oxime alleviates Cd stress-induced photosynthetic damage and oxidative stress by regulating the antioxidant defense mechanism in Zea mays

Cadmium (Cd) toxicity in leaves decreases their photosynthetic efficiency by degrading photosynthetic pigments, reducing the activity of gas exchange parameters and photosystem II (PSII), and producing reactive oxygen species. Although acetone O-(4-chlorophenylsulfonyl) oxime (AO) alleviates stress due to heavy metals in plants, its effects on the photosynthetic apparatus and redox balance under Cd stress are not clear. Herein, the role of AO in modulating the relationship between the antioxidant defense system and photosynthetic performance including chlorophyll fluorescence and gas exchange in mitigating the stress damage caused by Cd in maize seedlings was investigated. Three-week-old maize seedlings were pre-treated with AO (0.66 mM) and exposed to 100 µM Cd stress. Our findings indicated that AO application increased Cd accumulation, thiobarbituric acid-reactive substances (TBARS), photosynthetic rate, hydrogen peroxide (H2O2), total chlorophyll and carotenoid, transpiration, stomatal conductance, maximum photochemical efficiency of PSII (Fv/Fm), effective quantum yield of PSII (ΦPSII), intercellular CO2 concentration, photochemical quenching (qP), superoxide dismutase, electron transport rate, proline, ascorbate peroxidase, catalase, guaiacol peroxidase, 4-hydroxybenzoic acid, catechol, and cinnamic acid in maize seedling under Cd stress. Conversely, AO significantly reduced oxidative damage levels (H2O2, TBARS). It was concluded that exogenous AO can overcome Cd-mediated oxidative damage and hence protect the photosynthetic machinery by providing stress tolerance and regulating the antioxidant defense mechanism, which includes proline, phenolic compounds, and antioxidant enzyme activities.

Supplementary Information

The online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1007/s12298-022-01258-5.

S-Methylmethionine Effectively Alleviates Stress in Szarvasi-1 Energy Grass by Reducing Root-to-Shoot Cadmium Translocation

S-methylmethionine (SMM) is a universal metabolite of higher plants derived from L-methionine that has an approved priming effect under different types of abiotic and biotic stresses. Szarvasi-1 energy grass (Elymus elongatus subsp. ponticus cv. Szarvasi-1) is a biomass plant increasingly applied in phytoremediation to stabilize or extract heavy metals. In this study, Szarvasi-1 was grown in a nutrient solution. As a priming agent, SMM was applied in 0.02, 0.05 and 0.1 mM concentrations prior to 0.01 mM Cd addition. The growth and physiological parameters, as well as the accumulation pattern of Cd and essential mineral nutrients, were investigated. Cd exposure decreased the root and shoot growth, chlorophyll concentration, stomatal conductance, photosystem II function and increased the carotenoid content. Except for stomatal conductance, SMM priming had a positive effect on these parameters compared to Cd treatment without priming. In addition, it decreased the translocation and accumulation of Cd. Cd treatment decreased K, Mg, Mn, Zn and P in the roots, and K, S, Cu and Zn in the shoots compared to the untreated control. SMM priming changed the pattern of nutrient uptake, of which Fe showed characteristic accumulation in the roots in response to increasing SMM concentrations. We have concluded that SMM priming exerts a positive effect on Cd-stressed Szarvasi-1 plants, which retained their physiological performance and growth. This ameliorative effect is suggested to be based on, at least partly, the lower root-to-shoot Cd translocation by the upregulated Fe uptake and transport.

Silicon and nitric oxide-mediated mechanisms of cadmium toxicity alleviation in wheat seedlings

The individual impact of silicon (Si) and nitric oxide (NO, as sodium nitroprusside) on metal toxicity in various plant species has been well documented; however, their combined action in the regulation of metal stress has never been tested yet. Therefore, this study investigates the effects of the combined application of Si and NO in the mitigation of Cd toxicity in wheat seedlings. Seedlings grown on Cd has a significantly declined growth due to an increased accumulation of Cd and oxidative stress markers (due to downregulation of antioxidant defense system particularly ascorbate-glutathione cycle) and a decreased accumulation of NO and Si. Additionally, the altered leaf and root structures resulted into a declined photosynthetic efficiency. However, the addition of Si and NO alone as well as combined significantly alleviated Cd toxicity in wheat seedlings by lowering the accumulation of Cd and oxidative stress markers and improving leaf and root structures, which are collectively responsible for a better photosynthetic rate under Cd toxicity, and hence an improved growth was noticed. Particularly, the application of Si and NO in combination lowered the oxidative stress markers via upregulating the antioxidant defense system (particularly AsA-GSH cycle) suggesting the increased efficacy of Si + NO against the Cd toxicity in wheat seedlings as compared to their alone treatments.

Toxicity and tissue accumulation characteristics of the herbicide pendimethalin under silicon application in ginger (Zingiber officinale Roscoe)

Environmental health and food safety issues potentially caused by the dinitroaniline herbicide pendimethalin (PM) are a worldwide concern. The toxicity response of ginger and tissue accumulation effects of PM on ginger biomass were studied by utilizing PM (CK (clean water), PM1 (0.4%), PM2 (0.67%), PM3 (1.0%), and PM4 (1.67%)) in a dose-response study. It significantly reduced the biomass of ginger under PM4, which is attributed to root damage. The net photosynthetic rate of ginger under PM4 was 11.37% lower than that of CK, which is mainly caused by stomatal limitation. In addition, the ultrastructure of chloroplasts has changed. PM4 caused the accumulation of reactive oxygen species (ROS) in ginger. The activity of superoxide dismutase (SOD) and peroxidase (POD) increased accordingly, maintaining the dynamic balance of ROS content. PM had no significant effect on the expression of ginger α-tubulin genes. PM was significantly accumulated in ginger roots, but not rhizomes. Si increased the productivity of ginger under PM4, which is mainly related to the increase of root development (root application of silicon) and photosynthetic efficiency (foliar application of silicon). Si reduced the ROS content due to the increase in SOD, POD, and catalase (CAT) activity and photosynthetic efficiency.

Biochar Alleviates Phytotoxicity by Minimizing Bioavailability and Oxidative Stress in Foxtail Millet (Setaria italica L.) Cultivated in Cd- and Zn-Contaminated Soil

Soil contamination with multiple heavy metals is a global environmental issue that poses a serious threat to public health and ecological safety. Biochar passivation is an efficient and economical technology to prevent heavy metal contamination of Cd; however, its effects on compound-contaminated and weakly alkaline soil remain unclear. Further, the mechanisms mediating the immobilization effects of biochar have not been evaluated. In this study, three biochar treated at different pyrolytic temperatures [300°C (BC300), 400°C (BC400), and 500°C (BC500)] were applied to Cd-/Zn-contaminated soils, and their effects on plant growth, photosynthetic characteristics, Cd/Zn accumulation and distribution in foxtail millet were evaluated. Further, the effect of biochar application on the soil physicochemical characteristics, as well as the diversity and composition of the soil microbiota were investigated. Biochar significantly alleviated the phytotoxicity of Cd and Zn. DTPA (diethylenetriamine pentaacetic acid)-Cd and DTPA-Zn content was significantly reduced following biochar treatment via the transformation of exchangeable components to stable forms. BC500 had a lower DTPA-Cd content than BC300 and BC400 by 42.87% and 39.29%, respectively. The BC500 passivation ratio of Cd was significantly higher than that of Zn. Biochar application also promoted the growth of foxtail millet, alleviated oxidative stress, and reduced heavy metal bioaccumulation in shoots, and transport of Cd from the roots to the shoots in the foxtail millet. The plant height, stem diameter, biomass, and photosynthetic rates of the foxtail millet were the highest in BC500, whereas the Cd and Zn content in each organ and malondialdehyde and hydrogen peroxide content in the leaves were the lowest. Moreover, biochar application significantly increased the abundance of soil bacteria and fungi, as well as increasing the fungal species richness compared to no-biochar treatment. Overall, biochar was an effective agent for the remediation of heavy metal-contaminated soil. The passivation effect of biochar exerted on heavy metals in soil was affected by the biochar pyrolysis temperature, with BC500 showing the best passivation effect.

Exogenous ascorbic acid application alleviates cadmium toxicity in seedlings of two wheat (Triticum aestivum L.) varieties by reducing cadmium uptake and enhancing antioxidative capacity

The aggravation of soil cadmium (Cd) pollution is a serious threat to human food health and safety. To reduce Cd uptake and alleviate Cd toxicity in staple food of wheat, a completely random experiment was performed to investigate the effect of exogenous ascorbic acid (AsA) on Cd toxicity in two wheat varieties (L979 and H27). In this study, the treatments with combinations of Cd (0, 5, and 10 µmol L^-1) and AsA (0, 50, and 200 µmol L^-1) were applied in a hydroponic system. Toxicity induced by Cd inhibited biomass accumulation; decreased wheat growth, photosynthesis, and chlorophyll content; increased lipid peroxidation; and reduced activity of superoxide dismutase (SOD), but stimulated catalase (CAT) and peroxidase (POD). The addition of AsA significantly improved the growth status by increasing the wheat biomass, chlorophyll content, photosynthetic rate, protein concentrations, and antioxidant enzyme activity. Besides, AsA significantly decreased Cd concentration of shoot and root by 14.1-53.9% and 20.8-59.5% in L979 and 23.7-58.8% and 22.1-58.1% in H27 under Cd5, and 23.7-53.6% and 16.6-57.1% in L979 and 21.5-51.6% and 15.3-54.0% in H27 under Cd10, respectively. Malondialdehyde (MDA) accumulation was decreased remarkably with the addition of AsA by 31.2-32.9% in L979 and 27.1-45.2% in H27 under Cd10, respectively. Overall, exogenous application of AsA alleviated the Cd toxicity in wheat plants by improving the wheat growth, soluble protein content, photosynthesis, and antioxidant defense systems, and decreasing MDA accumulation.

Multiple effects of silicon on alleviation of arsenic and cadmium toxicity in hyperaccumulator Isatis cappadocica Desv

Arsenic (As) and cadmium (Cd) belong to the group of major pollutants extremely toxic to plants. Metal hyperaccumulating plants play an important role in phytoextraction of heavy metals. Silicon (Si) plays an important role in the amelioration of heavy metal stress through physio-biochemical mechanisms, which remain poorly understood in hyperaccumulators. The main purpose of this study was to determine the impact of Si on growth and performance of As hyperaccumulator Isatis cappadocica Desv., exposed to As and Cd. Results showed that Si (especially at 1 mM level) alleviated the harmful impact of As/Cd and significantly increased the root and shoot biomass, root and shoot length and chlorophyll contents of I. cappadocica by enhancing the plant defense mechanisms. Between the two investigated harmful elements, As was accumulated in plant parts significantly more than Cd, however with considerably lower toxic growth effects. The As/Cd concentration, bioaccumulation and translocation factor and total As content both in roots and shoots of Si-supplied plant were significantly reduced as a protective mechanism, especially in Cd exposed plant. In comparison with single As/Cd treatment, Si supply reduced H₂O₂ content, increased total soluble protein content and enhanced glutathione S-transferase activity in shoots. The results of this study clearly showed that Si minimized As/Cd uptake and root to shoot translocation, and therefore Si cannot enhance the phytoextraction potential of this plant species. Additionally, Si-improved growth and reduced oxidative damages caused by excess of As and Cd suggested that the similar mechanisms of metal(loid) alleviation are adopted in hyperaccumulators as well as non-hyperaccumulating plants.

Silicon alleviates antimony phytotoxicity in giant reed (Arundo donax L.)

Silicon enhances photosynthetic efficiency, biomass, and lignification of root structures possibly limiting antimony translocation and mitigating phytotoxicity in giant reed plants. Antimony (Sb) is a non-essential metalloid causing toxic effects in plants. Silicon has been reported to impart tolerance against biotic and abiotic stress in plants. Fast-growing plant, giant reed (Arundo donax L.) is a promising energy crop, can be a suitable plant for phytoremediation. However, information regarding the tolerance capacity with respect to Sb toxicity and potential of Si to mitigate the Sb phytotoxicity in giant reed are very scarce. Rhizomes of giant reed were grown for ten weeks in hydroponics exposed to Sb, Si, and their combination wherein treatment without Sb/Si served as control. Effect of these treatments on rate of net photosynthesis and photosynthetic pigments, phytoextraction ability of Sb, Si and Sb uptake, plant biomass, and lignification and suberization of roots along with localization of Sb and Si were analysed. We found that Si considerably improved the growth and biomass of giant reed under Sb toxicity. Antimony reduced the photosynthesis and decreased the content of photosynthetic pigments, which was completely alleviated by Si. Silicon amendment to Sb treated plants enhanced root lignification. Silicon enhanced lignification of root structures probably restricted the Sb translocation. However, co-localization of Sb with Si has not been observed neither at the shoot nor at the root levels. Similarly, Sb was also not detected in leaf phytoliths. These findings suggest that Si treatment promotes overall plant growth by improving photosynthetic parameters and decreasing Sb translocation from root to shoot in giant reed by improving root lignification.

Interactive effects of gibberellic acid and NPK on morpho-physio-biochemical traits and organic acid exudation pattern in coriander (Coriandrum sativum L.) grown in soil artificially spiked with boron

It was aimed to examine the role of gibberellic acid (GA₃) and NPK fertilizer in alleviating boron (B) toxicity in coriander (Coriandrum sativum L.) plants. Two weeks old C. sativum seedlings were subjected to different NPK fertilizers [low NPK (30 kg ha^-1) and normal NPK (60 kg ha^-1)], which were also supplied by GA₃ (50 mg L^-1), under varying levels of B i.e., 0, 200 and 400 mg kg^-1 in the soil. Results revealed that B toxicity led to a substantial decreased in the plant growth and biomass, photosynthetic pigments, gas exchange characteristics, sugars and essential nutrients in the roots and shoots of C. sativum seedlings. However, B toxicity boosted the production of reactive oxygen species (ROS) by increasing the contents of malondialdehyde (MDA), which is the indication of oxidative stress in C. sativum seedlings and was also manifested by hydrogen peroxide (H₂O₂) contents and electrolyte leakage (EL) to the membrane bounded organelles. Although, activities of various antioxidative enzymes like superoxidase dismutase (SOD), peroxidase (POD), catalase (CAT) and ascorbate peroxidase (APX), non-enzymatic antioxidants like phenolic, flavonoid, ascorbic acid and anthocyanin contents and organic acids from the roots such as oxalic acid, malic acid, formic acid, citric acid, acetic acid and fumaric acid contents were increased with the increasing levels of B in the soil. The application if NPK and GA₃ mitigated B toxicity by stimulated plant growth and biomass, photosynthetic efficiency, nutritional status and antioxidant machinery of the plant by decreasing MDA contents, H₂O₂ initiation and EL (%) in the roots and leaves of C. sativum seedlings. In addition, the application of NPK and GA₃ further decreased the organic acids exudation contents in the roots C. sativum seedlings. Research findings, therefore, suggested that NPK and GA₃ application can ameliorate B toxicity in C. sativum seedlings and resulted in improved plant growth and composition under B stress as depicted by balanced contents of organic acids.

Effect of soil sulfamethoxazole on strawberry (Fragaria ananassa): Growth, health risks and silicon mitigation

The negative impact of antibiotic pollution on the agricultural system and human health is a hot issue in the world. However, little information is available on the antibiotics toxicity mechanism and the role of silicon (Si) to alleviate the antibiotics toxicity. In this study, strawberry (Fragaria ananassa) showed excitatory response to low-dose SMZ (1 mg L^-1), but strawberry root and photosynthetic efficiency were damaged under high level. When SMZ level exceeded 10 mg L^-1, H₂0₂, O₂^-, MDA and relative conductivity increased, while SOD and CAT activities first increased and then decreased. SMZ accumulated more in roots and fruits, but less in stems, and the accumulation increased with the increase of SMZ-dose. Under 1 mg L^-1 SMZ, the SMZ accumulation in fruits was 110.54 μg kg^-1, which exceeded the maximum residue limit. SMZ can induce the expression of sul1, sul2 and intI1, and intI1 had the highest abundance. Exogenous application of Si alleviated the toxicity of SMZ, which is mainly related to the degradation of SMZ in soil and the reduction of SMZ absorption by strawberry. In addition, Si relieved root damage, promoted the increase of photosynthetic efficiency, and improved the antioxidant system to resist SMZ toxicity.

Comparison of the single and combined effects of arsenic and antimony on growth and physiology of giant reed (Arundo donax L.)

Fast-growing plant, giant reed (Arundo donax L.) has been gaining a lot of popularity in the phytoremediation of metal-polluted soils. However, information regarding the physiological background of tolerance and accumulation capacity of A. donax with respect to antimony (Sb), arsenic (As), and their co-contamination are very limited. Rooted stem cuttings were grown for 5 months in hydroponics exposed to Sb (10 mg L^-1), As (10 mg L^-1), and their combined toxicity (Sb 5 mg L^-1 + As 5 mg L^-1) wherein treatment without As/Sb served as control. Effect of these treatments on key photosynthetic parameters (rate of net photosynthesis, effective quantum yield of photosystem II, chlorophyll fluorescence, and photosynthetic pigments), phytoextraction ability of metalloids, nutrient uptake, root growth, and lignification were analyzed. Arsenic-containing treatments severely affected root morphology of A. donax compared to Sb/control and plants exposed to As showed intensive lignification already in young apical part of the root in the present study. Shoot concentration was found to be 11.35±0.75 Sb mg kg^-1 and 8.97±0.52 As mg kg^-1 compared to root concentration of 1028.3±19.1 Sb mg kg^-1 and 705.3±69.9 As mg kg^-1 in the treatments of Sb and As. Even though Sb and As were translocated to the shoots in relatively small amount, both metalloids significantly decreased the shoot and root growth of A. donax and negatively affected the photosynthetic parameters. Moreover, co-contamination of Sb and As proved to be severely toxic to growth and physiology of A. donax even though the magnitudes of the metalloids used were lower than those of Sb/As alone treatments. In conclusion, Sb and As caused a marked reduction in growth and physiological characteristics of A. donax, opposing its use in phytoremediation of highly contaminated soils. Tolerance capacity of plants to simultaneous presence of As and Sb in the environment is crucial for the successful implementation of phytoremediation since the co-contamination by As and Sb might reduce the efficiency of phytoremediation when using this fast-growing and high biomass-producing plant species.

Effect of silicon on the young maize plants exposed to nickel stress

Nickel (Ni) is involved in several physiological processes in plants but its excess in environment has many phytotoxic effects. Silicon (Si), an element required for optimal plant performance, has been shown to have beneficial effects for plants coping with various types of stresses. Here we studied the alleviative potential of Si (2.5 mM) added to hydroponically grown maize (Zea mays L.) plants under Ni (100 μM) stress. Ni decreased most of the growth parameters, total chlorophyll (Chl) and leaf relative water content (RWC), and catalase (CAT; EC 1.11.1.6) activity, while leaf water loss (LWL), contents of proline (Pro), hydrogen peroxide (H₂O₂) and ascorbate (AsA), membrane lipid peroxidation and activities of peroxidase (POX; EC 1.11.1.7) and superoxide dismutase (SOD; EC 1.15.1.1) were increased. Supplementation of Si to Ni-treated plants enhanced the leaf area, Chl content, RWC, CAT and POX (only in younger leaf) activities and decreased LWL, the contents of Pro (in younger leaf), H₂O₂ (roots) and AsA, lipid peroxidation and POX and SOD activities. We may conclude that Si mitigated the Ni-induced stress in maize by amelioration of the leaf water deficient status (Pro, RWC, LWL), enhancing membrane stability (MDA) and influencing enzymatic (SOD, POX, CAT) and non-enzymatic (Pro, AsA) defence systems. The increased Chl content and leaf area improve overall plant performance.

Salicylic acid underpins silicon in ameliorating chromium toxicity in rice by modulating antioxidant defense, ion homeostasis and cellular ultrastructure

Chromium (Cr) phytotoxicity affirmed the need of mitigation strategies to remediate polluted soils and restricts its accumulation in the food chains. Salicylic acid (SA) and silicon (Si) play pivotal roles in stimulating the plant performance and stress resilience. So far, their interactive effects against Cr-phytotoxicities are less known. Thus, we evaluated the beneficial roles of alone or/and combine applications of SA and Si in mitigating the toxic effects of Cr in the leaves and roots of rice (Oryza sativa) seedlings. Results indicated that SA (10 μM) and/or Si (5 μM) markedly retrieved the Cr (100 μM) induced toxicities by minimizing the Cr-accretion in both leaves and roots, enhancing the performance of light harvesting pigments (total chlorophylls and carotenoids), water retention and accumulation of osmolytes (water-soluble protein and total soluble sugars) and ultimately improved the growth and biomass. Additionally, SA and/or Si maintained the ionic balance by enhancing the nutrients transport, upregulated the ascorbate-glutathione (AsA-GSH) cycle enzymes, minimized the extra accumulation of reactive oxygen species (ROS) (H₂O₂ and O₂^•‒), malondialdehyde (MDA), recovered the membrane stability and damages in cellular ultrastructure in Cr-stressed rice plants. Overall findings suggested that SA underpins Si in mitigating the Cr-induced phytotoxicities on the above-reported parameters and combined applications of SA and Si were more effective than alone treatments. The uptake or cellular accumulation of Cr, osmoprotectants level and antioxidant defense system against oxidative stress can be considered as key toxicity biomarkers for the safe cultivation of rice in Cr-contaminated soils.

Leaf application of 24-epibrassinolide mitigates cadmium toxicity in young Eucalyptus urophylla plants by modulating leaf anatomy and gas exchange

Cadmium (Cd2+) soil pollution is a global environmental problem caused by the high toxicity of Cd. 24-Epibrassinolide (EBR) is a biodegradable plant steroid involved in response modulation to biotic and abiotic stresses. The aim of this study was to evaluate if the leaf-application of EBR improves the gas exchange and possible repercussions on leaf anatomy in young Eucalyptus urophylla plants exposed to Cd toxicity. The experiment involved six treatments, which included three Cd concentrations (0, 450, and 900 μM) and two EBR concentrations (0 and 100 nM, described as - EBR and + EBR, respectively). Plants exposed to Cd toxicity suffered decreases in leaf anatomical and gas exchange parameters. However, the plants treated with EBR + 900 μM Cd showed an increase of 46%, 40%, and 54% in the net photosynthetic rate, water-use efficiency, and instantaneous carboxylation efficiency, respectively. The EBR application-induced improvements in gas exchange parameters, causing beneficial effects on the photosynthetic apparatus, mainly the effective quantum yield of photosystem II (PSII) photochemistry and electron transport rate. Furthermore, this steroid mitigated the effect of Cd toxicity on leaf anatomical variables, more specifically palisade and spongy parenchyma, which are intrinsically related to stomatal density, and stimulated the net photosynthetic rate of plants.

Mitigation of climate change and environmental hazards in plants: Potential role of the beneficial metalloid silicon

In the last decades, the concentration of atmospheric CO₂ and the average temperature have been increasing, and this trend is expected to become more severe in the near future. Additionally, environmental stresses including drought, salinity, UV-radiation, heavy metals, and toxic elements exposure represent a threat for ecosystems and agriculture. Climate and environmental changes negatively affect plant growth, biomass and yield production, and also enhance plant susceptibility to pests and diseases. Silicon (Si), as a beneficial element for plants, is involved in plant tolerance and/or resistance to various abiotic and biotic stresses. The beneficial role of Si has been shown in various plant species and its accumulation relies on the root's uptake capacity. However, Si uptake in plants depends on many biogeochemical factors that may be substantially altered in the future, affecting its functional role in plant protection. At present, it is not clear whether Si accumulation in plants will be positively or negatively affected by changing climate and environmental conditions. In this review, we focused on Si interaction with the most important factors of global change and environmental hazards in plants, discussing the potential role of its application as an alleviation strategy for climate and environmental hazards based on current knowledge.

Silicon nanoparticles elicit an increase in lemongrass (Cymbopogon flexuosus (Steud.) Wats) agronomic parameters with a higher essential oil yield

Lemongrass (Cymbopogon flexuosus (Steud.) Wats) is an aromatic grass with great industrial potential. It is cultivated for its essential oil (EO) which has great economical value due to its numerous medicinal, cosmetic and culinary applications. The present study was conducted on silicon nanoparticles (SiNPs) application to lemongrass with the objective of overall agronomic enhancements. Graded concentrations (50-200 mg L^-1) of SiNPs were exogenously applied to lemongrass leaves. The physiological and biochemical analyses revealed that 150 mg L^-1 SiNPs is the optimum concentration for lemongrass plants. This concentration triggered photosynthetic variables, gas exchange modules and activities of enzymes involved in EO (geraniol dehydrogenase) and nitrogen (nitrate reductase) metabolism as well as in the antioxidant system (catalase, peroxidase and superoxide dismutase). These SiNPs-induced metabolic changes altogether significantly (p ≤ 0.05) enhanced overall plant growth and yield. Moreover, SiNPs treatments assisted in palliating lipid peroxidation and H₂O₂ content in lemongrass leaves which added further advantage to plant metabolism. Overall, data indicates SiNPs elicit beneficial effects on lemongrass growth and yield through inducing various physiological and biochemical responses. This renders high possibility that similar objectives could be achieved with SiNPs biotechnological application on further related agronomic crops as well as in diverse industries.

Silicon-mediated abiotic and biotic stress mitigation in plants: Underlying mechanisms and potential for stress resilient agriculture

Silicon (Si) is a beneficial macronutrient for plants. The Si supplementation to growth media mitigates abiotic and biotic stresses by regulating several physiological, biochemical and molecular mechanisms. The uptake of Si from the soil by root cells and subsequent transport are facilitated by Lsi1 (Low silicon1) belonging to nodulin 26-like major intrinsic protein (NIP) subfamily of aquaporin protein family, and Lsi2 (Low silicon 2) belonging to putative anion transporters, respectively. The soluble Si in the cytosol enhances the production of jasmonic acid, enzymatic and non-enzymatic antioxidants, secondary metabolites and induces expression of genes in plants under stress conditions. Silicon has been found beneficial in conferring tolerance against biotic and abiotic stresses by scavenging the reactive oxygen species (ROS) and regulation of different metabolic pathways. In the present review, Si transporters identified in various plant species and mechanisms of Si-mediated abiotic and biotic stress tolerance have been presented. In addition, role of Si in regulating gene expression under various abiotic and biotic stresses as revealed by transcriptome level studies has been discussed. This provides a deeper understanding of various mechanisms of Si-mediated stress tolerance in plants and may help in devising strategies for stress resilient agriculture.

Structural modifications of plant organs and tissues by metals and metalloids in the environment: A review

At the dawn of the industrial revolution, the exorbitant use of heavy metals and toxic elements by mankind unfurls a powerful and complex web of hazard all around the world that significantly contributed to unprecedented trends in environmental degradation. Plants as sessile organisms, that cannot escape from the stress directly, have adapted to this environment via concurrent configurations of several traits. Among them the anatomy has been identified as much more advanced field of research that brought the explosion of interest among the expertise and its prodigious importance in stress physiology is unavoidable. In conjunction with various other disciplines, like physiology, biochemistry, genomics and metabolomics, the plant anatomy provides a large data sets that are paving the way towards a comprehensive and holistic understanding of plant growth, development, defense and productivity under heavy metal and toxic element stress. Present paper advances our recent knowledge about structural alterations of plant tissues induced by metals and metalloids, like antimony (Sb), arsenic (As), aluminium (Al), copper (Cu), cadmium (Cd), chromium (Cr), lead (Pb), manganese (Mn), mercury (Hg), nickel (Ni) and zinc (Zn) and points on essential role of plant anatomy and its understanding for plant growth and development in changing environment. Understanding of anatomical adaptations of various plant organs and tissues to heavy metals and metalloids could greatly contribute to integral and modern approach for investigation of plants in changing environmental conditions. These findings are necessary for understanding of the whole spectra of physiological and biochemical reactions in plants and to maintain the crop productivity worldwide. Moreover, our holistic perception regarding the processes underlying the plant responses to metal(loids) at anatomical level are needed for improving crop management and breeding techniques.

Modulation of Key Physio-Biochemical and Ultrastructural Attributes after Synergistic Application of Zinc and Silicon on Rice under Cadmium Stress

Excessive industrialization and the usage of pesticides plague the farming soils with heavy metals, reducing the quality of arable land. Assessing phytoavailability of cadmium (Cd) from growth medium to plant system is crucial and necessitates precise and timely monitoring of Cd to ensure food safety. Zinc (Zn) and silicon (Si) have singularly demonstrated the potential to ameliorate Cd toxicity and are important for agricultural production, human health, and environment in general. However, Zn-Si interaction on Cd toxicity alleviation, their effects and underlying mechanisms are still fragmentarily understood. Seven treatments were devised besides control to evaluate the single and combined effects of Zn and Si on the physio-biochemical attributes and ultrastructural fingerprints of Cd-treated rice genotypes, i.e., Cd tolerant “Xiushui-110” and Cd sensitive “HIPJ-1”. Supplementation of both Zn and Si promoted plant biomass, photosynthetic parameters, ionic balance, and improved chloroplast ultrastructure with minimized Cd uptake and malondialdehyde (MDA) content due to the activation of antioxidant enzymes in Cd stressed plants. The combined effects of 10 μM Zn and 15 μM Si on 15 μM Cd displayed a greater reduction in Cd uptake and root-leaf MDA content, while enhancing photosynthetic activity, superoxide dismutase (SOD) activity and root-leaf ultrastructure particularly in HIPJ-1, whilst Xiushui-110 had an overall higher leaf catalase (CAT) activity and a higher root length and shoot height was observed in both genotypes compared to the Cd 15 µM treatment. Alone and combined Zn and Si alleviation treatments reduced Cd translocation from the root to the stem for HIPJ-1 but not for Xiushui-110. Our results confer that Zn and Si singularly and in combination are highly effective in reducing tissue Cd content in both genotypes, the mechanism behind which could be the dilution effect of Cd due to improved biomass and competitive nature of Zn and Si, culminating in Cd toxicity alleviation. This study could open new avenues for characterizing interactive effects of simultaneously augmented nutrients in crops and provide a bench mark for crop scientists and farmers to improve Cd tolerance in rice.

Alleviation mechanisms of metal(loid) stress in plants by silicon: a review

Silicon (Si), although not considered as an essential element for plants in general, can ameliorate the phytotoxicity induced by excess metal(loid)s whether non-essential (e.g. Cd, Pb, Cr, Al, As, and Sb) or essential (e.g. Cu, Ni, and Zn). The Si-enhanced resistance allowing plants to cope with this type of abiotic stress has been developed at multiple levels in plants. Restriction of root uptake and immobilization of metal(loid)s in the rhizosphere by Si is probably one of the first defence mechanism. Further, retention of elements in the root apoplasm might enhance the resistance and vigour of plants. At the cellular level, the formation of insoluble complexes between Si and metal(loid)s and their storage within cell walls help plants to decrease available element concentration and restrict symplasmic uptake. Moreover, Si influences the oxidative status of plants by modifying the activity of various antioxidants, improves membrane stability, and acts on gene expression, although its exact role in these processes is still not well understood. This review focuses on all currently known plant-based mechanisms related to Si supply and involved in amelioration of stress caused by excess metal(loid)s.

Elucidating silicon-mediated distinct morpho-physio-biochemical attributes and organic acid exudation patterns of cadmium stressed Ajwain (Trachyspermum ammi L.)

Soil contamination with toxic heavy metals [such as cadmium (Cd)] is becoming a serious global problem due to rapid development of social economy. Silicon (Si), being an important fertilizer element, has been found effective in enhancing plant tolerance against biotic and abiotic stresses. The present study investigated the extent to which different levels of Si modulated the Cd tolerance of Ajwain (Trachyspermum ammi L.) seedlings when maintained in artificially Cd spiked regimes. A pot experiment was conducted under controlled conditions for four weeks, by using sand, mixed with different levels of Cd i.e., 0, 1.5 and 3 mM together with the application of Si at 0, 1.5 and 3 mM levels to monitor different growth, gaseous exchange, oxidative stress, antioxidative responses, minerals accumulation, organic acid exudation patterns of T. ammi seedlings. Our results depicted that Cd addition to growth medium significantly decreased plant growth and biomass, gaseous exchange attributes and minerals uptake by T. ammi seedlings as compared to the plants grown without addition of Cd. However, Cd toxicity boosted the production of reactive oxygen species (ROS) by increasing the contents of malondialdehyde (MDA), which is the indication of oxidative stress in T. ammi seedlings and was also manifested by hydrogen peroxide (H₂O₂) contents and electrolyte leakage to the membrane bounded organelles. Although, activities of various antioxidative enzymes like superoxidase dismutase (SOD), peroxidase (POD), catalase (CAT) and ascorbate peroxidase (APX) initially increased up to a Cd level of 1.5 mM but were significantly diminished at the highest Cd level of 3 mM. Results revealed that the anthocyanin and soluble proteins contents were decreased in seedlings grown under elevating Cd levels but increased the Cd accumulation of T. ammi roots and shoots. The negative impacts of Cd injury were reduced by the application of Si which increased plant growth and biomass, improved photosynthetic apparatus, antioxidant enzymes, minerals uptake together with diminished exudation of organic acids as well as oxidative stress indicators in roots and shoots of T. ammi by decreasing Cd retention in different plant parts. Research findings, therefore, suggested that Si application can ameliorate Cd toxicity in T. ammi seedlings and resulted in improved plant growth and composition under metal stress as depicted by balanced exudation of organic acids.

Dose dependent differential effects of toxic metal cadmium in tomato roots: Role of endogenous hydrogen sulfide

In this study, hydroponic experiments were conducted to elucidate mechanism(s) that are associated with differential effects of low (5 μM) and high (25 μM) dose of cadmium (Cd) stress in tomato. Furthermore, emphasis has also been focused on any involvement of endogenous hydrogen sulfide (H₂S) in differential behaviour of low and high doses of Cd stress. At low dose of Cd, root growth i.e. root fresh weight, length and fitness did not significantly alter when compared to the control seedlings. Though at low dose of Cd, cellular accumulation of Cd was slightly increased but this was accompanied by higher endogenous H₂S and phytochelatins, _L-cysteine desulfhydrase (DES) activity, activities of glutathione biosynthetic and AsA-GSH cycle enzymes, and maintained redox status of ascorbate and glutathione. However, addition of hypotaurine (HT, a scavenger of H₂S) resulted in greater toxicity, even at low dose of Cd, and these responses resembled with higher dose of Cd stress such as greater decline in root growth, endogenous H₂S and phytochelatins, activities of DES, glutathione biosynthesis and AsA-GSH cycle enzymes, disturbed redox status of ascorbate and glutathione which collectively led to higher oxidative stress in tomato roots. Moreover, addition of HT with higher dose of Cd also further enhanced its toxicity. Collectively, the results showed that differential behaviour of low and high dose of Cd stress is mediated by differential regulation of biochemical attributes in which endogenous H₂S has a crucial role.

Direct inhibition of photosynthesis by Cd dominates over inhibition caused by micronutrient deficiency in the Cd/Zn hyperaccumulator Arabidopsis halleri

This work reveals, by imaging in vivo measurements in the Cd/Zn hyperaccumulator Arabidopsis halleri, in how far Cd stress affects macronutrient (Ca, K) and micronutrient (Fe, Zn) distribution in the leaves. We directly correlate these changes with biophysics of the photosynthetic light reactions. Plants were grown for 2 months at 10 μM Zn (=control), and supplemented with 10, 15, 50 or 75 μM Cd. Direct imaging of OJIP transients revealed that bundle sheath cells were more sensitive to Cd toxicity than mesophyll cells further from the vein. Progressive inhibition of photosystem (PS) II reaction centres and decrease in quantum yield of electron transport between Q_A and Q_B and further to PSI acceptors was observed. This was correlated with the decreased dynamics of Q_A re-oxidation and lower operating efficiency of PSII. Analysis by a benchtop micro X-ray fluorescence device showed that Cd mostly accumulated in the veins, and restricted Fe and Zn distribution from the veins, especially in the 75 μM Cd, while K concentration increased in the whole leaf. Calcium distribution was apparently not affected by Cd, but Cd excess inhibited trichome formation and thereby diminished total Ca concentration in the leaves. The results point to differential tissue sensitivity to Cd, evident by heterogeneous inhibition of photosynthesis. Part of this may be a result of selective disturbances in the leaf nutrient homeostasis. The better photosynthetic performance away from the veins compared to the bundle sheath cells, however, indicates that direct inhibition of photosynthesis by Cd dominates over inhibition caused by micronutrient deficiency.

The cadmium tolerance development of poplar callus is influenced by silicon

Cadmium-tolerant plants were studied for their possible usage in phytoremediation techniques. However, their response to cadmium cations at a cellular level has not been properly studied. Silicon is a beneficial element that seems to change the plant's response to the Cd²⁺ presence. The aim of the present study was to investigate the Cd²⁺ tolerance patterns of poplar callus cells exposed to Cd⁺² and/or Si over short and long cultivation periods. We determined the growth parameters of the callus, the growth dynamics, cell vitality, photosynthetic pigment concentrations and the activity of antioxidant enzymes. The effects were studied over short (21 days) and long (63 days) cultivation periods. The most important result proved that the poplar callus tissue is able to build up a tolerance to Cd²⁺ after a longer cultivation period. On the 63^rd day of the cultivation, Cd²⁺ stressed calli showed improvement in studied parameters and the callus cells accumulated Cd²⁺ more efficiently than on the 21^st day. Supplementation with Si in higher concentrations (2.5 mM and 5 mM) heightened the Cd-tolerance potential of the tissue. The treatment of Cd²⁺, and Si in a 2.5 mM concentration was the most efficient variant for Cd²⁺ removal from medium. The activity of antioxidant enzymes showed that poplar callus cells effectively develop tolerance against Cd²⁺ after a longer cultivation period.

Acetylcholine ameliorates the adverse effects of cadmium stress through mediating growth, photosynthetic activity and subcellular distribution of cadmium in tobacco (Nicotiana benthamiana)

Acetylcholine (ACh), a well-known major neurotransmitter, plays a potential role in response to abiotic stresses. However, the mechanism of ACh-mediated cadmium (Cd) toxicity in tobacco seedlings is largely uncharacterized. In this study, a hydroponics experiment was conducted under 100 μM Cd stress in the presence or absence of ACh (50 μM) to investigate the potential effects of ACh on Cd toxicity. The results revealed that ACh application effectively alleviated Cd-induced reductions in plant growth, photosynthetic pigments and gas exchange attributes and improved the photosystem II activity. Ultrastructural observation indicated that Cd exposure ruptured the internal structure of chloroplasts, and even caused the accumulation of osmiophilic granules in chloroplasts, whereas these phenomena were alleviated by the addition of ACh. Cd stress also caused a marked increase in oxidative stress, as evidenced by the accumulation of O2- and H2O2, which were efficiently minimized after ACh application by up-regulating antioxidant enzyme activities (superoxide dismutase, SOD; catalase, CAT; ascorbate peroxidase, APX; glutathione reductase, GR). Besides, Cd stress considerably increased the levels of glutathione (GSH), Non-protein thiols (NPTs) and phytochelatins (PCs), whereas ACh application to Cd-stressed seedlings further increased those contents, thereby enhancing the tolerance of Cd-stressed plants. Moreover, exogenously applied ACh declined the accumulation of Cd and minimized the damage from Cd toxicity by modulating the distribution of Cd in the vacuole and cell wall. Therefore, these results provide insights into the ameliorative effects of ACh on Cd-induced a series of physiological reactions.

Efficiency of various silicon rich amendments on growth and cadmium accumulation in field grown cereals and health risk assessment

Cadmium (Cd) contamination of arable soils and its subsequent accumulation in food is one of the global issues which needs urgent attention. Field experiments were conducted to explore the impacts of ten silicon (Si) rich amendments on Cd bioavailability and accumulation by maize and wheat irrigated with sewage effluents. Results depicted that applied amendments decreased the total Cd accumulation in shoots and grains of both crops with and the maximum decrease was observed in rice husk biochar (RHB) treatment. The RHB was able to significantly decrease the translocation factor, Cd harvest and health risk indexes. All amendments differentially affected the soil pH, EC, CaCl₂-extractable Si, and decreased the AB-DTPA-extractable soil Cd. Overall, suitable Si rich amendments (like RHB and CSB etc.) can be employed to mitigate the health risks associated with dietary Cd in untreated sewage irrigated fields. However, the cost-benefit analysis such Si rich amendments should be considered before final recommendations.