Clinical Course among Cases of Acute Liver Failure of Indeterminate Diagnosis

Preliminary experience of combined dual plasma molecular adsorption system and plasma exchange in pediatric acute liver failure: a retrospective case series

BACKGROUND

Pediatric acute liver failure (PALF) is a life-threatening condition with no definitive treatment. This study evaluated the combined use of the dual plasma molecular adsorption system (DPMAS) and plasma exchange (PE) to improve liver function and survival outcomes in PALF patients.

METHODS

A retrospective study was conducted on 7 PALF patients treated with DPMAS and PE. Data on liver function scores (Liver Injury Unit [LIU], Model for End-Stage Liver Disease [MELD], Model for End-Stage Liver Disease with Sodium [MELD-Na], MELD 3.0), bilirubin levels, and coagulation indices were collected before and after treatment.

RESULTS

DPMAS and PE treatments significantly reduced total bilirubin (382.2 µmol/L to 52.0 µmol/L) and improved coagulation indices. Liver injury scores decreased notably (e.g., LIU from 184 to 52 in one case). Five patients recovered, while two with severe comorbidities showed limited improvement.

CONCLUSION

The combination of DPMAS and PE therapy improves liver function and survival outcomes in PALF. These results support its use as a bridge to recovery or transplantation in PALF patients, though further studies with larger sample sizes are needed.

Paediatric acute liver failure: a multidisciplinary perspective on when a critically ill child is unsuitable for liver transplantation

Paediatric acute liver failure is a devastating condition with high morbidity and mortality, which is challenging to manage for the hepatologist, intensivist, and associated specialists. Emergency liver transplantation is required for 10-20% of patients, but for 10% of critically ill children, liver transplantation is deemed unsuitable; the child might be too unwell, or the underlying cause might carry a poor prognosis. Other social, logistical, or ethical considerations are often relevant. Liver transplantation when a patient is too unwell creates perioperative risk to the child that could lead to morbidity, mortality, and potential graft wastage, which is detrimental for others on the waiting list. Donor liver scarcity should prompt an evaluation of whether a transplant is justified through a holistic multidisciplinary lens that considers medical, social, logistical, and ethical concerns. In this Review, we explore, from a multidisciplinary perspective, why a critically unwell child with paediatric acute liver failure might be unsuitable for liver transplantation.

Improved mortality prediction for pediatric acute liver failure using dynamic prediction strategy

OBJECTIVES

To develop and validate a prediction tool for pediatric acute liver failure (PALF) mortality risks that captures the rapid and heterogeneous clinical course for accurate and updated prediction.

METHODS

Data included 1144 participants with PALF enrolled during three phases of the PALF registry study over 15 years. Using joint modeling, we built a dynamic prediction tool for mortality by combining longitudinal trajectories of multiple laboratory and clinical variables. The predictive performance for 7-day and 21-day mortality was assessed using the area under curve (AUC) through cross-validation and split-by-time validation.

RESULTS

We constructed a prognostic joint model that combines the temporal trajectories of international normalized ratio, total bilirubin, hepatic encephalopathy, platelet count, and serum creatinine. Dynamic prediction using updated information improved predictive performance over static prediction using the information at enrollment (Day 0) only. In cross-validation, AUC increased from 0.784 to 0.887 when measurements obtained between Days 1 and 2 were incorporated. AUC remained similar when we used the earlier subset of the sample for training and the later subset for testing.

CONCLUSIONS

Serial measurements of five variables in the first few days of PALF capture the dynamic clinical course of the disease and improve risk prediction for mortality. Continuous disease monitoring and updating risk prognosis are beneficial for timely and judicious medical decisions.

Future directions in acute liver failure

Acute liver failure (ALF) describes a clinical syndrome of rapid hepatocyte injury leading to liver failure manifested by coagulopathy and encephalopathy in the absence of pre-existing cirrhosis. The hallmark diagnostic features are a prolonged prothrombin time (ie, an international normalized ratio of prothrombin time of ≥1.5) and any degree of mental status alteration (HE). As a rare, orphan disease, it seemed an obvious target for a multicenter network. The Acute Liver Failure Study Group (ALFSG) began in 1997 to more thoroughly study and understand the causes, natural history, and management of ALF. Over the course of 22 years, 3364 adult patients were enrolled in the study registry (2614 ALF and 857 acute liver injury-international normalized ratio 2.0 but no encephalopathy-ALI) and >150,000 biosamples collected, including serum, plasma, urine, DNA, and liver tissue. Within the Registry study sites, 4 prospective substudies were conducted and published, 2 interventional ( N -acetylcysteine and ornithine phenylacetate), 1 prognostic [ 13 C-methacetin breath test (MBT)], and 1 mechanistic (rotational thromboelastometry). To review ALFSG's accomplishments and consider next steps, a 2-day in-person conference was held at UT Southwestern Medical Center, Dallas, TX, entitled "Acute Liver Failure: Science and Practice," in May 2022. To summarize the important findings in the field, this review highlights the current state of understanding of ALF and, more importantly, asks what further studies are needed to improve our understanding of the pathogenesis, natural history, and management of this unique and dramatic condition.

Severe acute hepatitis of unknown etiology in a large cohort of children

BACKGROUND

We evaluated the proportion, clinical features, and outcomes of previously healthy children presenting to a large Canadian quaternary pediatric center with severe acute hepatitis of unknown etiology.

METHODS

All patients with serum alanine aminotransferase (ALT) > 500 U/L or aspartate aminotransferase (AST) > 500 U/L between June 1, 2018, and May 31, 2022, at The Hospital for Sick Children, were identified. Subjects with only AST > 500 U/L were excluded. Clinical characteristics, investigations, and outcomes for patients without clear etiology for ALT > 500 U/L (severe acute hepatitis of unknown etiology) for our study period and from October 1 to May 31 of each year 2018-2021 were reviewed.

RESULTS

Of 977 patients with ALT/AST> 500 U/L, 720 had only ALT > 500 U/L. We excluded age below 6 months (n = 99) or above 16 years (n = 66), known pre-existing liver conditions (n = 66), and ALT > 500 U/L in already admitted patients (n = 151). Among the remaining 338 children with ALT > 500 U/L at presentation, an etiology was identified in 303 subjects. 33 (9.8%) children [median age 6.1 y (range 0.5-15.5); 61% male] were confirmed as severe acute hepatitis of unknown etiology. Twenty patients (60.6%) were tested for blood adenovirus by PCR, and 1 (5%) was positive (serotype B7). Liver tissue specimens from 18 patients revealed no evidence of viral inclusions or adenovirus. Twelve (36.3%) presented with pediatric acute liver failure, with 8 (24.2%) requiring liver transplantation. There were no deaths. Hepatitis-associated aplastic anemia occurred in 5 (15%) patients.

CONCLUSIONS

Of children presenting with severe acute hepatitis to a quaternary children's hospital over a 48-month period, 9.8% had unknown etiology with no change over time. Liver transplantation remains an important treatment strategy for those presenting with pediatric acute liver failure phenotype. The frequency of cases associated with human adenovirus infection was noncontributory.

Outbreak of indeterminate acute liver failure in children with adenoviraemia - Not a new disease

BACKGROUND & AIMS

In the year 2022, an outbreak of indeterminate acute hepatitis and indeterminate paediatric acute liver failure (ID-PALF) in association with adenoviraemia in immunocompetent children was reported in the UK. We postulate that this association is not a new disease in immunocompetent children.

METHODS

Children with acute hepatitis during the outbreak who were referred to King's College Hospital, London for advice and management were included in the study. Data on the frequency of ID-PALF in 2022, as well as transplantation rates and the association with adenovirus infection, were obtained from electronic health records. The clinical presentation, histology and outcomes of children with ID-PALF and adenoviraemia in 2017-2021 were compared with those in 2022.

RESULTS

From January to June 2022, 65 patients with acute hepatitis were referred. Ten children were admitted with ID-PALF. ID-PALF constituted 26% of all PALF cases in 2017-2021, in contrast to 58.8% during the 2022 outbreak. During the outbreak, adenoviraemia was present in 52% of children with acute hepatitis without liver failure (in whom adenoviraemia test results were available) and in 100% of ID-PALF cases. Adenoviraemia was seen in immunocompetent children in 6/13 (46%) of all ID-PALF cases between 2017-2019, with a clear absence of adenoviraemia in the 6 ID-PALF cases during 2020-2021. Compared to ID-PALF with adenoviraemia in 2017-2019 (n = 6), ID-PALF with adenoviraemia during the outbreak (n = 10) was associated with more frequent hepatic encephalopathy, hypotension requiring vasoactive medications and higher plasma ammonia levels (admission and peak), with similar native liver survival.

CONCLUSIONS

The recent outbreak of ID-PALF with adenoviraemia in immunocompetent children does not appear to be a new disease, contrary to perception and other reports. The frequency of such cases over the years could be linked to background rates of adenovirus infections.

IMPACT AND IMPLICATIONS

Indeterminate paediatric acute liver failure (ID-PALF) associated with adenoviraemia in immunocompetent children is not a new disease specific to 2022. The exclusive role of human adenovirus infection in the causation of this outbreak of acute hepatitis seems unlikely. Indeed, we provide histological data from explants in transplanted patients that do not support direct viral cytotoxicity. The disease is probably mediated by immunological injury directed towards adenovirus infection and/or adeno-associated virus-2.

Assessing predictive discrimination performance of biomarkers in the presence of treatment-induced dependent censoring

In medical studies, some therapeutic decisions could lead to dependent censoring for the survival outcome of interest. This is exemplified by a study of paediatric acute liver failure, where death was subject to dependent censoring due to liver transplantation. Existing methods for assessing the predictive performance of biomarkers often pose the independent censoring assumption and are thus not applicable. In this work, we propose to tackle the dependence between the failure event and dependent censoring event using auxiliary information in multiple longitudinal risk factors. We propose estimators of sensitivity, specificity and area under curve, to discern the predictive power of biomarkers for the failure event by removing the disturbance of dependent censoring. Point estimation and inferential procedures were developed by adopting the joint modelling framework. The proposed methods performed satisfactorily in extensive simulation studies. We applied them to examine the predictive value of various biomarkers and risk scores for mortality in the motivating example.

High Prevalence of Hemophagocytic Lymphohistiocytosis in Acute Liver Failure of Infancy

OBJECTIVES

To investigate the prevalence of hemophagocytic lymphohistiocytosis (HLH) syndrome in pediatric acute liver failure (PALF) of infancy and assess the diagnostic role of rapid immunologic tests, genotype/phenotype correlations, and clinical outcomes.

STUDY DESIGN

We retrospectively analyzed 78 children with PALF aged <24 months referred over almost 2 decades. The studied patients with a phenotype of HLH syndrome had a comprehensive immunologic workup, including additional genetic analysis for primary immunologic causes.

RESULTS

Thirty of the 78 children had the HLH phenotype and underwent genetic assessment, which demonstrated positive findings in 19 (63.3%), including 9 (30%) with biallelic primary HLH mutations and 10 (33.3%) with heterozygous mutations and/or polymorphisms. The most common form of primary HLH was familial hemophagocytic lymphohistiocytosis (FHL)-2, diagnosed in 6 children, 4 of whom had a c.50delT (p.Leu17ArgfsTer34) mutation in the PRF1 gene. Three patients with primary HLH received genetic diagnoses of FHL-3, Griscelli syndrome, and LRBA (lipopolysaccharide-responsive vesicle trafficking, beach- and anchor-containing) protein deficiency. Overall mortality in the series was 52.6% (10 of 19), and mortality in children with a documented biallelic pathogenic HLH mutation (ie, primary HLH) was 66.6% (6 of 9). Two children underwent liver transplantation, and 4 children underwent emergency hematopoietic stem cell transplantation; all but 1 child survived medium term.

CONCLUSIONS

Primary HLH can be diagnosed retrospectively in approximately one-third of infants with indeterminate PALF (iPALF) who meet the clinical criteria for HLH, often leading to their death. The most common HLH type in iPALF is FHL-2, caused by biallelic mutations in PRF-1. The clinical relevance of observed heterozygous mutations and variants of uncertain significance requires further investigation. Prompt hematopoietic stem cell transplantation could be life-saving in infants who survive the liver injury.

Etiology, outcome and prognostic indicators of acute liver failure in Asian children

OBJECTIVE

Outcome of pediatric acute liver failure (PALF) in countries with limited availability of LT is not well described. We evaluated the outcome and prognostic indicators of PALF in Malaysia where emergency LT for ALF is limited.

METHODS

In this retrospective review on children < 18 years with PALF, we compared clinical and laboratory parameters between survival after supportive treatment and after LT or succumbed without LT. The predictive values of Liver Injury Unit (LIU; peak laboratory values for international normalized ratio [INR], ammonia, total bilirubin) and upon admission (aLIU) on outcome of PALF was evaluated using receiver operator characteristic (ROC) curves.

RESULTS

Of 77 children (39 males [51%]; median age 2.8 years) with PALF, the overall survival was 55% (n = 42); 52% (n = 40) survived with supportive management, 2.6% (n = 2) after LT. As compared to children who survived without LT, children who had LT/died had lower hemoglobin, aspartate transferase, γ-glutamyl transpeptidase (GGT), and higher serum bilirubin, alkaline phosphatase, ammonia, and serum sodium (p < 0.05). On multivariate analysis, significant independent predictor for death or LT were peak bilirubin > 452 μmol/L and peak GGT < 96 IU/L. The C-index of LIU and aLIU score were 0.79 and 0.68, respectively, indicating that LIU score was a good model in predicting outcome of PALF.

CONCLUSIONS

Overall survival of PALF remained poor. High peak bilirubin and low GGT predict poor outcome of PALF. LIU score is a good model in predicting outcome of PALF and maybe useful in selecting children for emergency LT.

An Update on Pediatric Acute Liver Failure: Emerging Understanding of the Impact of Immune Dysregulation and Novel Opportunities for Intervention

Pediatric acute liver failure (PALF) is a complex, unpredictable, often rapidly progressive, potentially devastating clinical syndrome that occurs in infants, children, and adolescents without pre-existing liver disease. PALF is characterized by acute onset of hepatocellular injury and liver-based coagulopathy, frequently accompanied by hepatic encephalopathy. Etiologies include drug and toxin exposures, metabolic and genetic disorders, infections, and immune-mediated disease. PALF management primarily involves early contact with and consideration of transfer to a pediatric liver transplant center and intensive supportive multidisciplinary clinical care, with targeted therapies available for a subset of causes. Outcomes include survival with native liver, death, and liver transplantation. Efforts to develop reliable clinical prognostic tools to predict PALF outcomes early in the course of disease have not yet been fulfilled, and the possibility remains that some transplanted PALF patients might have survived without transplantation.

Indeterminate pediatric acute liver failure: Clinical characteristics of a temporal cluster of five children in the Netherlands in the spring of 2022

There is increasing global concern of severe acute hepatitis of unknown etiology in young children. In early 2022, our center for liver transplantation in the Netherlands treated five children who presented in short succession with indeterminate acute liver failure. Four children underwent liver transplantation, one spontaneously recovered. Here we delineate the clinical course and comprehensive diagnostic workup of these patients. Three of five patients showed a gradual decline of liver synthetic function and had mild neurological symptoms. Their clinical and histological findings were consistent with hepatitis. These three patients all had a past SARS-CoV-2 infection and two of them were positive for adenovirus DNA. The other two patients presented with advanced liver failure and encephalopathy and underwent dialysis as a bridge to transplantation. One of these children spontaneously recovered. We discuss this cluster of patients in the context of the currently elevated incidence of severe acute hepatitis in children.

Outcomes Analyses of Pediatric Acute Liver Failure Subjects Listed for Liver Transplantation

BACKGROUND

We characterized recent outcomes in US pediatric acute liver failure (PALF) subjects listed for liver transplantation (LT) using the Scientific Registry of Transplant Recipients (SRTR) database.

METHODS

Pediatric subjects listed for LT from 2002 to 2015 were assigned to the "PALF" group based on status 1/1A listing, INR >2, no hepatic artery thrombosis, and no primary graft nonfunction (N = 397). Subjects were assigned to the "non-PALF" group if listed with any status other than 1/1A (N = 4509).

RESULTS

The PALF group had more infants <3 months of age and males at listing for LT compared to the non-PALF group. Two-thirds of PALF subjects had an indeterminate etiology. LT waitlist survival was significantly worse in the PALF group compared to the non-PALF group. Likelihood of removal from the LT waitlist for being "too sick" was higher, while that of removal for "spontaneous recovery" was lower in PALF subjects. Post-LT short-term (30 days) and long-term (60 months) outcomes were also significantly worse in PALF versus non-PALF subjects. PALF subjects who underwent living-donor-liver-transplant (LDLT) had similar LT waitlist times and post-LT survival compared to those undergoing deceased-donor-liver-transplant (DDLT). Over the study period, we observed a decreased number of liver transplants, and increase in LT waitlist- and short-term post-LT-survival in PALF subjects.

CONCLUSION

LT waitlist and post-LT outcomes are worse in PALF subjects compared to non-PALF subjects. PALF subjects who undergo LDLT have similar waitlist times and post-LT outcomes compared to those undergoing DDLT.

Prevalence, severity, duration and resolution of cholestasis after acute liver failure

OBJECTIVE

Persistent cholestasis may follow acute liver failure (ALF), but its course remains unknown. We aimed to describe the prevalence, onset, severity, duration and resolution of post-ALF cholestasis.

DESIGN

Cohort of 127 adult patients with ALF at a liver transplantation centre identified using electronic databases. We obtained laboratory data every 6 hours for the first week, daily until day 30 and weekly, when documented, until day 180.

RESULTS

Median age was 40.7 (IQR 31.0-52.4) years, median peak alanine aminotransferase level was 5494 (2521-8819) U/L and 87 (68.5%) cases had paracetamol toxicity. Overall, 12.6% underwent transplantation (3.4% for paracetamol vs 32.5% for non-paracetamol; p<0.001). Ninety-day mortality was 20.7% for paracetamol versus 30.0% for non-paracetamol patients. All non-transplanted survivors reached a bilirubin level>50 µmol/L, which peaked 3.5 (1.0-10.1) days after admission at 169.0 (80.0-302.0) µmol/L. At hospital discharge, 18.8% of patients had normal bilirubin levels and, at a median follow-up time from admission to last measurement of 16 (10-30) days, 46.9% had normal levels. Similarly, there was an increase in alkaline phosphatase (ALP) (207.0 (148.0-292.5) U/L) and gamma-glutamyl transferase (GGT) (336.0 (209.5-554.5) U/L) peaking at 4.5 days, with normalised values in 40.3% and 8.3% at hospital discharge.

CONCLUSION

Post-ALF cholestasis is ubiquitous. Bilirubin, ALP and GGT peak at 3 to 5 days and, return to baseline in the minority of patients at median follow-up of 16 days. These data inform clinical expectations of the natural course of this condition.

Proceedings of ESPGHAN Monothematic Conference 2020: "Acute Liver Failure in Children": Diagnosis and Initial Management

OBJECTIVES

The Hepatology Committee of the European Society for Pediatric Gastroenterology, Hepatology and Nutrition (ESPGHAN) aims to educate pediatric gastroenterologists, members of ESPGHAN and professionals from other specialties promoting an exchange of clinical expertise in the field of pediatric hepatology. Herewith we have concentrated on detailing the recent advances in acute liver failure in infants and children.

METHODS

The 2020 ESPGHAN monothematic three-day conference on pediatric hepatology disease, entitled "acute liver failure" (ALF), was organized in Athens, Greece. ALF is a devastating disease with high mortality and most cases remain undiagnosed. As knowledge in diagnosis and treatment of ALF in infants and children has increased in the past decades, the objective was to update physicians in the field with the latest research and developments in early recognition, curative therapies and intensive care management, imaging techniques and treatment paradigms in these age groups.

RESULTS

In the first session, the definition, epidemiology, various causes of ALF, in neonates and older children and recurrent ALF (RALF) were discussed. The second session was dedicated to new aspects of ALF management including hepatic encephalopathy (HE), coagulopathy, intensive care interventions, acute on chronic liver failure, and the role of imaging in treatment and prognosis. Oral presentations by experts in various fields are summarized highlighting key learning points.

CONCLUSIONS

The current report summarizes the major learning points from this meeting. It also identifies areas where there is gap of knowledge, thereby identifying the research agenda for the near future.

Acute Liver Dysfunction Criteria in Critically Ill Children: The PODIUM Consensus Conference

CONTEXT

Develop evidence-based criteria for individual organ dysfunction.

OBJECTIVES

Evaluate current evidence and develop contemporary consensus criteria for acute liver dysfunction with associated outcomes in critically ill children.

DATA SOURCES

Electronic searches of PubMed and Embase conducted from January 1992 to January 2020, used medical subject heading terms and text words to characterize acute liver dysfunction and outcomes.

STUDY SELECTION

Studies evaluating critically ill children with acute liver dysfunction, assessed screening tools, and outcomes were included. Studies evaluating adults, infants ≤36 weeks gestational age, or animals or were reviews/commentaries, case series with sample size ≤10, or non-English language studies were excluded.

DATA EXTRACTION

Data were abstracted from each eligible study into a data extraction form along with risk of bias assessment by a task force member.

RESULTS

The systematic review supports criteria for acute liver dysfunction, in the absence of known chronic liver disease, as having onset of symptoms <8 weeks, combined with biochemical evidence of acute liver injury, and liver-based coagulopathy, with hepatic encephalopathy required for an international normalized ratio between 1.5 and 2.0.

LIMITATIONS

Unable to assess acute-on-chronic liver dysfunction, subjective nature of hepatic encephalopathy, relevant articles missed by reviewers.

CONCLUSIONS

Proposed criteria identify an infant, child, or adolescent who has reached a clinical threshold where any of the 3 outcomes (alive with native liver, death, or liver transplant) are possible and should prompt an urgent liaison with a recognized pediatric liver transplant center if liver failure is the principal driver of multiple organ dysfunction.

North American Society for Pediatric Gastroenterology, Hepatology, and Nutrition Position Paper on the Diagnosis and Management of Pediatric Acute Liver Failure

ABSTRACT

Pediatric acute liver failure (PALF) is a rare, rapidly progressive clinical syndrome with significant morbidity and mortality. The phenotype of PALF manifests as abrupt onset liver dysfunction, which can be brought via disparate etiology. Management is reliant upon intensive clinical care and support, often provided by the collaborative efforts of hepatologists, critical care specialists, and liver transplant surgeons. The construction of an age-based diagnostic approach, the identification of a potential underlying cause, and the prompt implementation of appropriate therapy can be lifesaving; however, the dynamic and rapidly progressive nature of PALF also demands that diagnostic inquiries be paired with monitoring strategies for the recognition and treatment of common complications of PALF. Although liver transplantation can provide a potential life-saving therapeutic option, the ability to confidently determine the certainness that liver transplant is needed for an individual child has been hampered by a lack of adequately tested clinical decision support tools and accurate predictive models. Given the accelerated progress in understanding PALF, we will provide clinical guidance to pediatric gastroenterologists and other pediatric providers caring for children with PALF by presenting the most recent advances in diagnosis, management, pathophysiology, and associated outcomes.

Resolution of recurrent pediatric acute liver failure with liver transplantation in a patient with NBAS mutation

BACKGROUND

Pediatric acute liver failure (PALF) remains an enigmatic process of rapid end-organ dysfunction associated with a variety of pathologic conditions though the predominant cause is indeterminate. A growing body of research has identified mutations in the NBAS gene to be associated with recurrent acute liver failure and multi-systemic disease including short stature, skeletal dysplasia, facial dysmorphism, immunologic abnormalities, and Pelger-Huët anomaly.

METHODS AND RESULTS

Here, we describe a 4-year-old girl who presented with dehydration in the setting of acute gastroenteritis and fever but went on to develop PALF on day 2 of hospitalization. She clinically recovered with supportive measures, but after discharge, had at least 2 additional episodes of PALF. Ultimately, she underwent liver transplant and her recurrent episodes of PALF did not recur throughout a 6-year follow-up period. Whole-exome sequencing post-liver transplant initially revealed two variants of uncertain significance in the NBAS gene. Parental studies confirmed the c.1549C > T(p.R517C; now likely pathogenic) variant from her mother and a novel c.4646T > C(p.L1549P) variant from her father. In silico analyses predicted these variants to have a deleterious effect on protein function. Consistent with previously characterized NBAS mutation-associated disease (NMAD), our patient demonstrated the following features: progeroid facial features, hypoplasia of the 12th ribs, Pelger-Huët anomaly on peripheral blood smear, and abnormal B and NK cell function.

CONCLUSION

Altogether, we describe a novel pathogenic variant in the NBAS gene of a patient with NMAD and report the resolution of recurrent PALF secondary to NMAD following liver transplantation.

Four Biomarkers Linked to Activation of Cluster of Differentiation 8-Positive Lymphocytes Predict Clinical Outcomes in Pediatric Acute Liver Failure

BACKGROUND AND AIMS

Immune dysregulation contributes to the pathogenesis of pediatric acute liver failure (PALF). Our aim was to identify immune activation markers (IAMs) in PALF that are associated with a distinct clinical phenotype and outcome.

APPROACH AND RESULTS

Among 47 PALF study participants, 12 IAMs collected ≤6 days after enrollment were measured by flow cytometry and IMMULITE assay on blood natural killer and cluster of differentiation 8-positive (CD8⁺ ) lymphocytes and subjected to unsupervised hierarchical analyses. A derivation cohort using 4 of 12 IAMs which were available in all participants (percent perforin-positive and percent granzyme-positive CD8 cells, absolute number of CD8 cells, soluble interleukin-2 receptor level) were sufficient to define high (n = 10), medium (n = 15), and low IAM (n = 22) cohorts. High IAM was more frequent among those with indeterminate etiology than those with defined diagnoses (80% versus 20%, P < 0.001). High IAM was associated with higher peak serum total bilirubin levels than low IAM (median peak 21.7 versus 4.8 mg/dL, P < 0.001) and peak coma grades. The 21-day outcomes differed between groups, with liver transplantation more frequent in high IAM participants (62.5%) than those with medium (28.2%) or low IAM (4.8%) (P = 0.002); no deaths were reported. In an independent validation cohort (n = 71) enrolled in a prior study, segregation of IAM groups by etiology, initial biochemistries, and short-term outcomes was similar, although not statistically significant. High serum aminotransferases, total bilirubin levels, and leukopenia at study entry predicted a high immune activation profile.

CONCLUSION

Four circulating T-lymphocyte activation markers identify a subgroup of PALF participants with evidence of immune activation associated with a distinct clinical phenotype and liver transplantation; these biomarkers may identify PALF participants eligible for future clinical trials of early targeted immunosuppression.

Activated CD8 T-cell Hepatitis in Children With Indeterminate Acute Liver Failure: Results From a Multicenter Cohort

OBJECTIVES

In many pediatric acute liver failure (PALF) cases, a diagnosis is not identified, and the etiology is indeterminate (IND-PALF). Our pilot study found dense CD8 T-cell infiltrates and increased T-cell clonality in liver specimens from IND-PALF patients. We aimed to validate these findings in a multicenter cohort with investigators blinded to diagnosis.

METHODS

PALF Study Group registry subjects with IND-PALF (n = 37) and known diagnoses (DX-PALF) (n = 18), ages 1 to 17 years, with archived liver tissue were included. Liver tissue slides were stained for T cells (CD8 and CD4), B cells (CD20), macrophages (CD163), perforin, and tissue resident-memory T cells (Trm, CD103), and scored as minimal, moderate, or dense. Lymphocytes were isolated from frozen liver tissue for T-cell receptor beta (TCRβ) sequencing.

RESULTS

Dense hepatic CD8 staining was found in significantly more IND-PALF (n = 29, 78%) compared with DX-PALF subjects (n = 5, 28%) (P = 0.001). IND-PALF subjects were more likely to have dense or moderate perforin (88% vs 50%, P = 0.03) and CD103 (82% vs 40%, P = 0.02) staining compared with DX-PALF subjects. TCRβ sequencing of 15 IND-PALF cases demonstrated increased clonal overlap compared with 6 DX-PALF cases (P = 0.002).

CONCLUSIONS

Dense infiltration of effector Trm CD8 T cells characterizes liver tissue from IND-PALF subjects. Increased clonality suggests the T-cell expansion is antigen(s)-driven as opposed to a nonspecific inflammatory response. These findings support CD8 staining as a new biomarker of the activated CD8 T-cell PALF phenotype. Future studies are needed to characterize potential antigens, host risk factors, and inflammatory pathways with the goal of developing targeted therapies.

Development of a Prognostic Score to Predict Mortality in Patients With Pediatric Acute Liver Failure

OBJECTIVES

This study aims to develop a new prognostic score based on changes in serial laboratory data from patients with pediatric acute liver failure (PALF).

METHODS

We retrospectively reviewed data on 146 patients with PALF at the Seoul National University Children Hospital (SNUCH) and the Asan Medical Center (AMC). Daily morning laboratory records were obtained for up to 7 days after diagnosis of PALF: total bilirubin (TB) (mg/dL), international normalized ratio for prothrombin time (INR) at enrolment; peak TB, peak INR, peak ammonia (μmol/L); the difference between the peak TB and TB at enrollment (ie, Δpeak TB), the difference between the peak INR and INR at enrollment (ie, Δpeak INR), the maximum change in serial TB (ie, Δdaily TB), the maximum change in serial INR level (ie, Δdaily INR). We assigned nontransplanted patients in SNUCH and AMC to derivation and validation cohorts, respectively.

RESULTS

Δpeak TB, Δdaily TB, Δpeak INR, and Δdaily INR were significantly higher in the nonsurvival group. We developed a new score that can predict mortality in nontransplanted patients (derivation cohort n = 42, validation cohort n = 33). PALF-Delta score (PALF-Ds) = [0.232 × Δpeak TB (mg/dL)] + [2.263 × Δdaily INR] + [0.013 × peak ammonia (μmol/L)] - 4.498. The score yielded AUC 0.918 in the derivation cohort (sensitivity 81%, specificity 91%) and AUC 0.947 in the validation cohort (sensitivity 100%, specificity 89%).

CONCLUSION

A prognostic scoring system using the change of TB/INR may be useful for predicting mortality in patients with PALF.

Corticosteroid Therapy for Indeterminate Pediatric Acute Liver Failure and Aplastic Anemia with Acute Hepatitis

OBJECTIVE

To examine the characteristics and outcomes of a multicenter patient cohort with indeterminate pediatric acute liver failure (IND-PALF) and with aplastic anemia with acute hepatitis treated with corticosteroids.

STUDY DESIGN

Retrospective study of patients age 1-17 years with IND-PALF and aplastic anemia with acute hepatitis who presented between 2009 and 2018 to 1 of 4 institutions and were treated with corticosteroids for presumed immune dysregulation.

RESULTS

Of 28 patients with IND-PALF (median of 4.0 years of age [range 1-16] and 71% male) 71% (n = 20) were treated with 0.5-4 mg/kg/day of intravenous methylprednisolone, and 8 patients received 10 mg/kg/day followed by a taper. By 21 days postcorticosteroid initiation, 14 patients (50%) underwent liver transplantation, 13 patients (46%) recovered with their native liver, and 1 patient (4%) died. Patients who recovered with their native liver received a median of 139 days (range 19-749) of corticosteroid therapy, with a median of 12 days (range 1-240) to international normalized ratio ≤1.2. Patients with aplastic anemia with acute hepatitis (n = 6; median of 9.5 years of age [range 1-12], 83% male), received 1-2 mg/kg/day of methylprednisolone for a median of 100 days (range 63-183), and all recovered with their native liver. One patient with IND-PALF and 2 patients with aplastic anemia with acute hepatitis developed a serious infection within 90 days postcorticosteroid initiation.

CONCLUSIONS

Many patients with IND-PALF or aplastic anemia with acute hepatitis that were treated with corticosteroids improved, but survival with native liver may not be different from historical reports. A randomized controlled trial exploring the benefits and risks of steroid therapy is needed before it is adopted broadly.

Liver Transplant Listing in Pediatric Acute Liver Failure: Practices and Participant Characteristics

Liver transplant (LT) decisions in pediatric acute liver failure (PALF) are complex. Three phases of the PALF registry, containing data on 1,144 participants over 15 years, were interrogated to characterize clinical features associated with listing status. A decrease in the cumulative incidence of listing (P < 0.005) and receiving (P < 0.05) LT occurred without an increase in the cumulative incidence of death (P = 0.67). Time to listing was constant and early (1 day; quartiles 1-3 = 0-2; P = 0.88). The most frequent reasons for not listing were "not sick enough" and "medically unsuitable." Participants listed for LT were more likely male, with coma grade scores >0; had higher international normalized ratio, bilirubin, lactate, and venous ammonia; and had lower peripheral lymphocytes and transaminase levels compared to those deemed "not sick enough." Participants listed versus those deemed "medically unsuitable" were older; had higher serum aminotransferase levels, bilirubin, platelets, and albumin; and had lower lactate, venous ammonia, and lymphocyte count. An indeterminate diagnosis was more prevalent in listed participants. Ventilator (23.8%) and vasopressor (9.2%) support occurred in a significant portion of listed participants but less frequently than in those who were not "medically suitable." Removal from the LT list was a rare event. Conclusion: The cumulative incidence of listing for and receiving LT decreased throughout the PALF study without an increase in the cumulative incidence of death. While all participants fulfilled entry criteria for PALF, significant differences were noted between participants listed for LT and those deemed "not sick enough" as well as those who were "medically unsuitable." Having an indeterminate diagnosis and a requirement for cardiopulmonary support appeared to influence decisions toward listing; optimizing listing decisions in PALF may reduce the frequency of LT without increasing the frequency of death.

Acute Liver Failure: An Update

Pediatric acute liver failure (PALF) is a dynamic, life-threatening condition of disparate etiology. Management of PALF is dependent on intensive collaborative clinical care and support. Proper recognition and treatment of common complications of liver failure are critical to optimizing outcomes. In parallel, investigations to identify underlying cause and the implementation of timely, appropriate treatment can be life-saving. Predicting patient outcome in the era of liver transplantation has been unfulfilling and better predictive models must be developed for proper stewardship of the limited resource of organ availability.

A Learning Collaborative Approach Increases Specificity of Diagnosis of Acute Liver Failure in Pediatric Patients

BACKGROUND & AIMS

Many pediatric patients with acute liver failure (PALF) do not receive a specific diagnosis (such as herpes simplex virus or Wilson disease or fatty acid oxidation defects)-they are left with an indeterminate diagnosis and are more likely to undergo liver transplantation, which is contraindicated for some disorders. Strategies to facilitate complete diagnostic testing should increase identification of specific liver diseases and might reduce liver transplantation. We investigated whether performing recommended age-specific diagnostic tests (AS-DTs) at the time of hospital admission reduces the percentage PALFs with an indeterminate diagnosis.

METHODS

We performed a multinational observational cohort study of 658 PALF participants in the United States and Canada, enrolled at 10 medical centers, during 3 study phases from December 1999 through December 2014. A learning collaborative approach was used to implement AS-DT using an electronic medical record admission order set at hospital admission in phase 3 of the study. Data from 10 study sites participating in all 3 phases were compared before (phases 1 and 2) and after (phase 3) diagnostic test recommendations were inserted into electronic medical record order sets.

RESULTS

The percentage of subjects with an indeterminate diagnosis decreased significantly between phases 1-2 (48.0%) and phase 3 (to 30.8%) (P = .0003). The 21-day cumulative incidence rates for liver transplantation were significantly different among phase 1 (34.6%), phase 2 (31.9%), and phase 3 (20.2%) (P = .030). The 21-day cumulative incidence rates for death did not differ significantly among phase 1 (17.9%), phase 2 (11.9%), and phase 3 (11.3%) (P = .20).

CONCLUSIONS

In a multinational study of children with acute liver failure, we found that incorporating diagnostic test recommendations into electronic medical record order sets accessed at time of admission reduced the percentage with an indeterminate diagnosis that may have reduced liver transplants without increasing mortality. Widespread use of this approach could significantly enhance care of acute liver failure in children.

Indeterminate pediatric acute liver failure is uniquely characterized by a CD103+ CD8+ T-cell infiltrate

The cause of pediatric acute liver failure (PALF) is unknown in up to 40% of cases. Evidence suggests that aberrant immune system activation may play a role. We hypothesized that indeterminate PALF cases would exhibit a unique pattern of hepatic inflammation. This was a retrospective and prospective study of PALF cases due to indeterminate (iPALF), autoimmune hepatitis, or known diagnosis (dPALF) etiology. Liver tissue sections were stained with immunohistochemical markers for cytotoxic T-cells (cluster of differentiation 8 [CD8]), perforin, and tissue resident memory T-cells (CD103) and scored as minimal, moderate, or dense. Lymphocytes were isolated from liver tissue for T-cell receptor beta sequencing and flow-cytometric studies. Thirty-three iPALF, 9 autoimmune hepatitis, and 14 dPALF cases were included. Dense hepatic infiltrates of CD8⁺ T-cells were found in 27 (82%) iPALF cases compared to 1 (7%) dPALF case (P < 0.0001). Perforin staining was dense or moderate in 19 (73%) of 26 iPALF cases compared to minimal in all 7 dPALF cases (P = 0.004); 16 (62%) of 26 iPALF cases had dense CD103 staining compared to none of the 6 dPALF cases (P = 0.001). T-cell receptor beta sequencing of iPALF cases demonstrated increased clonality compared to dPALF and control cases. Flow cytometry and immunohistochemistry revealed that iPALF intrahepatic leukocytes were predominantly tissue resident memory CD8⁺ T-cells.

CONCLUSION

Indeterminate PALF is characterized by a dense CD8⁺ T-cell hepatic infiltrate consistent with expansion of a tissue resident memory T-cell phenotype; CD8⁺ T-cells are a biomarker of immune dysregulation in iPALF and may be used to better identify and define this group. (Hepatology 2018).

Using time-varying models to estimate post-transplant survival in pediatric liver transplant recipients

PURPOSE

To distinguish clinical factors that have time-varying (as opposed to constant) impact upon patient and graft survival among pediatric liver transplant recipients.

METHODS

Using national data from 2002 through 2013, we examined potential clinical and demographic covariates using Gray's piecewise constant time-varying coefficients (TVC) models. For both patient and graft survival, we estimated univariable and multivariable Gray's TVC, retaining significant covariates based on backward selection. We then estimated the same specification using traditional Cox proportional hazards (PH) models and compared our findings.

RESULTS

For patient survival, covariates included recipient diagnosis, age, race/ethnicity, ventilator support, encephalopathy, creatinine levels, use of living donor, and donor age. Only the effects of recipient diagnosis and donor age were constant; effects of other covariates varied over time. We retained identical covariates in the graft survival model but found several differences in their impact.

CONCLUSION

The flexibility afforded by Gray's TVC estimation methods identify several covariates that do not satisfy constant proportionality assumptions of the Cox PH model. Incorporating better survival estimates is critical for improving risk prediction tools used by the transplant community to inform organ allocation decisions.

NBAS mutations cause acute liver failure: when acetaminophen is not a culprit

Background

Pediatric acute-liver-failure due to acetaminophen (APAP) administration at therapeutic dosage is rare, while viral infections and metabolic defects are the prevalent causes. Yet, as acetaminophen is routinely used in febrile illnesses, it may be mistakenly held responsible for the acute liver damage.

Case presentation

An 11 month old boy had been on acetaminophen for 10 days (total dose 720 mg = 72 mg/kg) when he developed acute-liver-failure with encephalopathy. As he rapidly improved on N-acetylcysteine (NAC) infusion, it was concluded that chronic acetaminophen administration in an infant had lead to acute-liver-failure even at therapeutic doses, that N-acetylcysteine infusion had been life-saving and should be immediately started in similar circumstances. The child, however, had two further episodes of acute liver damage over a 34-month period, without having been given acetaminophen, as the parents carefully avoided using it. His clinical, laboratory and radiological findings between the acute episodes were unremarkable. His features and skeletal surveys were not suggestive of a syndromic condition. He then went on to suffer another episode of acute-liver-failure with multi-organ failure, necessitating an urgent liver transplant. All efforts to come to a diagnosis for the causes of his recurrent episodes of liver failure had been unsuccessful, until a biallelic mutation in the NBAS gene was reported to be associated with recurrent acute-liver-failure in children. The boy’s DNA analysis revealed compound heterozygous pathogenic mutations in the NBAS gene. Liver failure episodes in these patients are triggered and worsened by fever, most likely due to thermal susceptibility of hepatocytes, hence APAP, rather than being a culprit, is part of the supportive treatment.

Conclusions

We suggest that, in acute-liver-failure with a history of acetaminophen exposure at therapeutic dosage, clinicians should not be contented with administering NAC, but should consider an alternative etiology, above all if the episodes are recurrent, and actively start supportive and antipyretic treatment while seeking the advice of a specialist unit.