An anatomic study of coronoid cartilage thickness with special reference to fractures

Considerable variation in current coronoid height and fracture measurement techniques: a systematic review

BACKGROUND

Coronoid fractures usually occur in the presence of a significant osseoligamentous injury to the elbow. Fracture size and location correlate with degree of instability and many authors have attempted to analyze the effect of fracture variation on decision making and outcome. There remains no standardized technique for measuring coronoid height or fracture size. The aim of this study was to appraise the literature regarding techniques for coronoid height measurement in order to understand variation.

METHODS

Preferred Reporting Items of Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses guidelines were followed. A search was performed to identify studies with either a description of coronoid height, fracture size, or bone loss using the terms (Coronoid) AND (Measurement) OR (Size) OR (Height). Articles were shortlisted by screening for topic relevance based on title, abstract and, if required, full-text review. Exclusion criteria were non-English articles, those on nonhuman species or parts other than the ulna coronoid process, and studies that included patients with pre-existing elbow pathology. Shortlisted articles were grouped based on study type, imaging modality, measurement technique, and measurement parameter as well as its location along the coronoid.

RESULTS

Thirty out of the initially identified 494 articles met the inclusion criteria. Twenty-one articles were clinical studies, 8 were cadaveric studies, and 1 combined patients as well as cadavers. A variety of imaging modalities (plain radiographs, 2-dimensional computed tomography [CT], 3-dimensional CT, magnetic resonance imaging or a combination of these) were used with CT scan (either 2-dimensional images or 3-dimensional reconstructions or both) being the most common modality used by 21 studies. Measurement technique also varied from uniplanar linear measurements in 15 studies to multiplanar area and volumetric measurements in 6 studies to techniques describing various angles and indices as an indirect measure of coronoid height in 8 studies. Across the 30 shortlisted studies, 19 different measurement techniques were identified. Fifteen studies measured normal coronoid height while the other 15 measured intact coronoid and/or fracture fragment height. The location of this measurement was also variable between studies with measurements at the apex of the coronoid in 24/30 (80%) of studies. Measurement accuracy was assessed by only 1 study. A total of 12/30 (40%) studies reported on the interobserver and intraobserver reliability of their measurement technique.

CONCLUSION

The systemic review demonstrated considerable variability between studies that report coronoid height or fracture size measurements. This variability makes comparison of coronoid height or fracture measurements and recommendations based on these between studies unreliable. There is need for development of a consistent, easy to use, and reproducible technique for coronoid height and bone loss.

The Novel Hooked Kirschner Wire Technique for Ulna Coronoid Process Fractures

Background

The aim of this study was to introduce a novel technique to improve the ease of fixing of even small fragments of the coronoid process and report the clinical outcomes of this method.

Methods

Forty-nine patients with ulnar coronoid process fractures fixed using the hooked Kirschner wire (K-wire) technique at our hospital from 2007 to 2019 were reviewed. Radiological features and fracture union were assessed using simple radiographs. Functional outcomes of the treated elbows were evaluated at the final follow-up visit using the Mayo Elbow Performance Score (MEPS).

Results

All patients were examined at a mean follow-up of 17.7 months (range, 6-62 months). We observed bony union in patients at a mean of 10.9 weeks (range, 6-22 weeks). The mean flexion and extension ranges of the elbow were 132.0° (range, 106° -151°) and 4.5° (range, -20° to 30°), respectively. The mean pronation and supination ranges of the forearm were 81.1° (range, 60°-90°) and 88.3° (range, 60°-120°), respectively. The mean arc of the elbow was 127.4° (range, 78°-160°). All patients were evaluated using the MEPS at the final follow-up visit, with a mean score of 96.9 points (range, 80-100 points). One case of coronoid nonunion was observed and re-fixation was performed. One case of infection was observed and also treated with additional surgery. Three patients complained of ulnar nerve symptoms and 1 patient underwent surgical release for tardy ulnar nerve palsy.

Conclusions

Despite its limitations, the hooked K-wire technique was a useful method for even smaller coronoid process fractures. K-wires were also a useful temporary intraoperative fixation method and could provide permanent fixation.

Greater sigmoid notch dysplasia causing elbow instability: Lateral ligament reconstruction and Stamp osteotomy

The coronoid is one of the elbow's primary static stabilisers, and the importance of reconstruction following fracture with instability has been established. In the developing elbow, instability can lead to greater sigmoid notch dysplasia that can make reconstruction challenging. A novel technique to improve osseous stability with an opening wedge 'stamp osteotomy' reconstruction of the coronoid is described combined with a lateral ligament reconstruction, in two patients with recurrent posteromedial rotatory instability. The technique improves congruity and coverage of the greater sigmoid notch with the trochlea whilst maintaining articular cartilage. Extra-articular iliac crest bone graft is used to maintain the position with buttress plate support. The surgical technique is described and the clinical and radiographic outcome reported in two patients. Level of evidence: IV.

Computed tomography analysis of the relationship between the coronoid and the radial head

BACKGROUND

The coronoid process is an important stabilizer of the elbow, and its anatomy has been extensively studied. However, data documenting the relationship of the coronoid relative to the radial head (RH) are limited. The latter is a good landmark for the surgeon when débriding or reconstructing the coronoid. This imaging-based study quantified the anatomic relationship between the coronoid and the proximal radius and ulna.

METHODS

We investigated 80 cadaveric upper extremities (18 paired elbows) by 3-dimensional digital analysis of computed tomography data. After construction of a standardized coordinate system, the relationships between the coronoid, the anterior-most point of the RH, the deepest point of the articular surface of the RH, the top of the lesser sigmoid notch, and the deepest point of the guiding ridge of the trochlear notch were analyzed.

RESULTS

The mean height of the tip of the coronoid was 36 ± 4 mm (range, 26-43 mm). The mean height of the anterior-most point of the RH was 40 ± 4 mm (range, 28-47 mm). The mean distance between the tip of the coronoid and the anterior-most point of the RH was 4.5 ± 1 mm (range, 2-10 mm). For paired elbows, the heights of the tip of the coronoid and the anterior-most point of the RH were similar between sides.

CONCLUSION

This study described the relationship between the coronoid and RH. This information should prove useful when reconstructing a coronoid from a medial approach in the case of an intact RH. The difference in radiographic height between the tip of the coronoid and anterior RH in the normal elbow averages 5 mm. However, when we account for the normal cartilage thickness of the RH and coronoid, a 3- to 6-mm difference in height would be seen at surgery depending on whether the cartilage of the coronoid process is intact or removed. The distance between the tip of the coronoid and the anterior-most point of the RH is similar to the size of shavers used when débriding osteophytes during arthroscopy.

The Effect of Forearm Position on Wrist Joint Biomechanics

PURPOSE

All active motion wrist joint simulators have been designed to simulate physiologic wrist motion; however, a main difference among them is the orientation of the forearm (horizontal or vertical with respect to gravity). Moreover, the effect of forearm orientation on experimental results has yet to be quantified, but it may be an important variable. Thus, the purpose of this study was to determine the effect of forearm orientation on wrist kinematics and contact mechanics.

METHODS

Eight cadaveric upper limbs were cycled through a flexion-extension motion using an active motion wrist simulator. Motion trials were performed in 3 forearm orientations (gravity-neutral, gravity-flexion, and gravity-extension). A computed tomography-based joint congruency technique was used to examine radiocarpal joint contact and joint contact centroid translation in the 3 tested orientations.

RESULTS

At full wrist extension and wrist flexion, radioscaphoid contact area was greatest in the gravity-extension orientation. Radiolunate contact area was similar among all 3 forearm orientations. The radioscaphoid contact centroid was consistent among the 3 tested positions with the wrist in neutral wrist position. In contrast, the radioscaphoid contact centroid translated radially in the gravity-neutral position relative to the gravity-flexion position in extreme extension. There were no differences in radiolunate centroid contact position in the 3 forearm orientations.

CONCLUSIONS

This study demonstrates that forearm orientation affects contact mechanics and end-range carpal kinematics. Future biomechanical studies should report forearm orientation and discuss the implication of the forearm orientation used on the experimental results.

CLINICAL RELEVANCE

This study provides evidence that the wrist joint is sensitive to forearm positions consistent with activities of daily living and rehabilitation protocols.

Management of anteromedial coronoid fractures according to a protocol focused on instability assessment provides good outcomes with infrequent need for coronoid fixation

BACKGROUND

Anteromedial coronoid fractures (AMCFs) are associated with persistent elbow instability and post-traumatic arthritis if managed incorrectly. It is unclear exactly which AMCFs require surgical intervention and how to make this decision. The aims of this study were to report outcomes of AMCFs managed using a protocol based on reproduction of instability using radiographic and clinical testing and to ascertain a threshold size of AMCF associated with instability.

METHODS

Forty-three AMCFs were studied. Thirty-two patients formed the primary study group (group A). All were treated using a protocol in which the decision to perform coronoid fixation was based on the presence of radiographic or clinical evidence of instability. Functional outcomes (Oxford Elbow Score), radiographic outcomes, complications, and reoperations were collected, and a receiver operating characteristic curve analysis was performed to assess the optimal coronoid fracture height to recommend coronoid fixation. The results were compared with a historical group of 11 patients with AMCFs not treated according to the protocol (group B).

RESULTS

Of the patients, 23 had an isolated AMCF and 20 had a concurrent radial head injury. Complete nonoperative treatment of the elbow was performed in 16 patients (37%) (11 of 32 [34%] in group A vs. 5 of 11 [45%] in group B, P = .46). In 10 patients (23%), only repair of the lateral collateral ligament was performed (9 in group A and 1 in group B), whereas 8 patients (19%) underwent repair of the lateral collateral ligament and radial head fixation or replacement (6 in group A and 2 in group B). Acute coronoid fixation was performed in 9 patients (21%) (6 in group A and 3 in group B). At a mean follow-up of 20 months (range, 12-56 months), group A showed a significantly better Oxford Elbow Score (42 vs. 31, P = .02), lower complication rate (3 of 32 [9%] vs. 8 of 11 [72%], P < .001), and lower reoperation rate (1 of 32 [3%] vs. 6 of 11 [54%], P < .001) than group B. Persistent instability was found in 6 patients in group B and none in group A. The receiver operating characteristic curve analysis demonstrated 6.5 mm to be the optimal AMCF size for surgery to prevent persistent instability.

CONCLUSION

Patients treated according to a protocol in which preoperative reproduction of instability determined the degree of surgical intervention had good clinical and radiographic outcomes. Our study demonstrated that AMCFs > 6.5 mm are likely to be more unstable and require intervention. If these principles are followed, a specifically defined subset of AMCFs can be treated nonsurgically without adverse outcomes.

Prediction of the Size of the Fragment in Comminuted Coronoid Fracture Using the Contralateral Side: An Analysis of Similarity of Bilateral Ulnar Coronoid Morphology

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate the morphological similarity of bilateral coronoid process.

METHODS

A total of 128 sets of computed tomography images of bilateral coronoid process from patients between January 2015 and December 2016 were acquired for three-dimensional reconstruction to generate a coronoid process model. The patients were aged between 31.4 ± 9.3 years. The upper 40% of the coronoid process was trimmed as targeted fragment for morphological analysis. The height, length, width as well as the radius of the medial and lateral facet of the targeted fragment were compared in terms of laterality, age, and gender. To evaluate the similarity of the articular surface of the coronoid process, a local coordinate was created and coordinate transformation algorithm was developed to realign the bilateral coronoid process for the following matching. Then Delaunay triangulation was introduced for calculation of the area of the articular surface. After matching of articular surface of the upper 40% of bilateral coronoid process, the overlapping area of the articular surface was quantified to assess the similarity in morphology and compared in regard to age and gender.

RESULTS

In this study, the height of the target fragment was 12.40 ± 2.74 mm, which was 12.62 ± 2.06 mm for male patients and 12.13 ± 3.76 mm for female patients (t = 0.94, P = 0.35). The height of the target fragment was 12.79 ± 1.76 mm for patients >40 years and 13.23 ± 3.16 mm for patients <40 years (t = 1.11, P = 0.27). The height of the target fragment of left and right coronoid process was 12.26 ± 3.40 mm and 12.74 ± 2.79 mm (t = 1.15, P = 0.25). The length of the target fragment was 23.81 ± 2.67 mm, which was 23.86 ± 2.11 mm for male patients and 23.76 ± 2.85 mm for female patients (t = 0.23, P = 0.82). The length of the target fragment was 22.92 ± 1.96 mm for patients >40 years and 23.23 ± 2.14 mm for patients <40 years (t = 0.76, P = 0.45). The length of the target fragment of left and right coronoid process was 22.52 ± 2.89 mm and 21.66 ± 3.01 mm, respectively (t = 1.00, P = 0.32). The width of the target fragment was 23.12 ± 1.92 mm on average, which was 23.06 ± 1.54 mm for male patients and 23.19 ± 2.82 mm for female patients (t = 0.33, P = 0.74). The width of the target fragment was 24.82 ± 2.23 mm for patients >40 years and 23.46 ± 3.38 mm for patients <40 years (t = 1.56, P = 0.12). The width of target fragment of left and right coronoid process was 24.42 ± 2.22 mm and 24.47 ± 2.69 mm, respectively (t = 1.31, P = 0.19). The radius of medial facet was 6.44 ± 1.01 mm, which was 6.41 ± 1.39 mm for male patients and 6.47 ± 0.95 mm for female patients (t = 0.28, P = 0.78). The radius of medial facet was 6.82 ± 1.28 mm for patients >40 years and 6.46 ± 0.94 mm for patients <40 years (t = 1.31, P = 0.19). The radius of medial facet of left and right coronoid process was 6.43 ± 1.24 mm and 6.64 ± 1.34 mm (t = 1.60, P = 0.11). The radius of lateral facet was 11.84 ± 3.71 mm, which was 11.61 ± 4.24 mm for male patients and 12.11 ± 3.09 mm for female patients (t = 0.74, P = 0.46). The radius of medial facet was 11.82 ± 3.28 mm for patients >40 years and 12.46 ± 3.94 mm for patients <40 years (t = 1.02, P = 0.31). The radius of lateral facet of left and right coronoid process was 11.97 ± 5.31 mm and 10.29 ± 3.29 mm, respectively (t = 1.70, P = 0.09). The covering percentage of the articular surface of the upper 40% of bilateral coronoid process was 87% ± 12% with the covering percentage as 85.3% ± 14.2% for male patients and 90.0% ± 11.2% for female patients (t = 0.75, P = 0.41). The covering percentage was 88.2% ± 11.7% for patients >40 years and it was 87.4% ± 13.2% for patients <40 years (t = 0.98, P = 0.33).

CONCLUSIONS

The present study suggested that bilateral coronoid process shares high similarity in terms of 3D structure and articular surface morphology, which suggested that the osseous architecture of the coronoid process with comminuted fracture could be predicted by the morphological information of the contralateral side.

Regional Distribution of Articular Cartilage Thickness in the Elbow Joint: A 3-Dimensional Study in Elderly Humans

During elbow procedures, reconstruction of the joint (including the articular cartilage) is important in order to restore elbow function; however, the regional distribution of elbow cartilage is not completely understood. The purpose of the present study was to investigate the 3-dimensional (3-D) distribution patterns of cartilage thickness of elbow bones (including the distal part of the humerus, proximal part of the ulna, and radial head) in order to elucidate the morphological relationship among them.

Insertional anatomy of the anterior medial collateral ligament on the sublime tubercle of the elbow

BACKGROUND

Acute injuries to the anterior medial collateral ligament (AMCL) can occur due to valgus trauma or during other dislocating events to the elbow. AMCL lesions are often associated with bony lesions, such as radial head fractures or fractures of the coronoid process. We analyzed the insertion of the AMCL on the sublime tubercle in relation to surrounding osseous structures. We aimed to increase the understanding of the involvement of the AMCL in bony lesions to the sublime tubercle.

METHODS

We investigated 86 elbows from 43 embalmed human specimens. We measured the most ventral extensions of the AMCL at the sublime tubercle in relation to a clearly defined and reproducible landmark. We used as our landmark a horizontal line (baseline) originating on the lesser sigmoid notch in a right angle to the ulnar ridge.

RESULTS

The mean distance of the coronoid process tip to the baseline was 4.0 mm (standard deviation [SD], 1.3 mm; range, 1.4-6.7 mm). The mean distance of the ventral extension of the AMCL to the horizontal line was 3.7 mm (SD, 2.6 mm; range: 9.4-2.2 mm). The mean horizontal distance between the ventral aspect of the AMCL and the coronoid tip was 13.7 mm (SD, 2.5 mm; range, 7.7-20.5 mm).

CONCLUSIONS

We present a detailed description of the insertional anatomy of the AMCL at the sublime tubercle. These values could be helpful for classifications of coronoid fractures and to estimate the involvement of the AMCL in fractures of the sublime tubercle.

Regional Variations in Cartilage Thickness of the Radial Head: Implications for Prosthesis Design

PURPOSE

To characterize the regional variations in cartilage thickness around the radial head.

METHODS

We dissected 27 cadaveric radii and scanned them with computed tomography in neutral position. Three-dimensional cartilage and subchondral bone surface models were generated from computed tomography scans and 2 independent observers processed them through a computer program to obtain cartilage thickness measurements. These measurements were taken at 41 predetermined landmarks around the periphery of the radial head and within the articular dish.

RESULTS

At the periphery of the radial head, cartilage was thickest in the posteromedial region. Thickness values within the articular dish were similar but increased toward the rim. Regional variations within the rim (range, 0.76-1.73 mm) were also detected with the thickest region located anteriorly and thinnest region laterally. In addition, cartilage was significantly thicker in male relative to female specimens.

CONCLUSIONS

Regional variations in cartilage thickness are present around the periphery and rim and within the articular dish of the radial head.

CLINICAL RELEVANCE

Cartilage thickness across the articular dish may contribute to dish depth and the radius of curvature. This may be clinically important for the design of anatomic implants, because accounting for such subtle contours could help to restore radiocapitellar concavity-compression stability better.

The ulnar greater sigmoid notch "coverage angle": bone and cartilage contribution. Magnetic resonance imaging anatomic study on 78 elbows

BACKGROUND

To study the degree of coverage provided by the greater sigmoid notch (GSN) to the humeral trochlea, as well as the contribution of the olecranon and coronoid process cartilage tips to this angle, and its variations.

METHODS

We recruited 39 healthy volunteers, comprising 19 women and 20 men, with a mean age of 28 years (range, 21-32 years). High-definition magnetic resonance images were obtained for the right and left elbows. Four angles were measured on the sagittal plane passing through the coronoid and olecranon tips: angle A, identified by 2 lines from the trochlea center to the olecranon bone-cartilage junction and olecranon cartilage tip; angle B, identified by 2 lines from the trochlea center to the olecranon and coronoid bone-cartilage junction; angle C, identified by 2 lines from the trochlea center to the coronoid bone-cartilage junction and coronoid cartilage tip; and GSN coverage angle (GSN-ca), defined as the sum of angles A, B, and C. Pearson correlation tests, t tests, and intraclass correlation coefficients were used for statistical analyses.

RESULTS

The mean angle A, angle B, and angle C values were 6° (range, 2°-12°), 182° (range, 153°-204°), and 9° (range, 2°-16°), respectively. No correlations were found between these 3 angles. The mean GSN-ca was 198° (range, 167°-222°), and the GSN-ca was less than 180° in 8% of the cases. No significant differences emerged for side or gender or for total length of the ulna.

CONCLUSION

The GSN showed significantly different shapes on the sagittal plane that we defined as closed type when the GSN-ca was greater than 180° (92%) and as open type when the GSA-ca was less than 180° (8%). The cartilage tip contribution varied and was not correlated with that of bone.

An original internal fixation technique by tension band wiring with steel wire in fractures of the coronoid process

Fractures of the coronoid process, which is a key element in anterior elbow joint stability, represent 14% of proximal ulnar fractures. Optimal treatment should stabilize all fractures associated with elbow instability. Different techniques have been described: suture repair, screws, plates… We propose a series of 5 patients who were treated with an original, easy, tension band wiring fixation technique using steel wire with easy hardware removal.

Accuracy assessment of 3D bone reconstructions using CT: an intro comparison

Computed tomography provides high contrast imaging of the joint anatomy and is used routinely to reconstruct 3D models of the osseous and cartilage geometry (CT arthrography) for use in the design of orthopedic implants, for computer assisted surgeries and computational dynamic and structural analysis. The objective of this study was to assess the accuracy of bone and cartilage surface model reconstructions by comparing reconstructed geometries with bone digitizations obtained using an optical tracking system. Bone surface digitizations obtained in this study determined the ground truth measure for the underlying geometry. We evaluated the use of a commercially available reconstruction technique using clinical CT scanning protocols using the elbow joint as an example of a surface with complex geometry. To assess the accuracies of the reconstructed models (8 fresh frozen cadaveric specimens) against the ground truth bony digitization-as defined by this study-proximity mapping was used to calculate residual error. The overall mean error was less than 0.4 mm in the cortical region and 0.3 mm in the subchondral region of the bone. Similarly creating 3D cartilage surface models from CT scans using air contrast had a mean error of less than 0.3 mm. Results from this study indicate that clinical CT scanning protocols and commonly used and commercially available reconstruction algorithms can create models which accurately represent the true geometry.

In vitro assessment of the contact mechanics of reverse-engineered distal humeral hemiarthroplasty prostheses

BACKGROUND

Distal humeral hemiarthroplasty alters cartilage contact mechanics, which may predispose to osteoarthritis. Current prostheses do not replicate the native anatomy, and therefore contribute to these changes. We hypothesized that prostheses reverse-engineered from the native bone shape would provide similar contact patterns as the native articulation.

METHODS

Reverse-engineered hemiarthroplasty prostheses were manufactured for five cadaveric elbows based on CT images of the distal humerus. Passive flexion trials with constant muscle forces were performed with the native articulation intact while bone motions were recorded using a motion tracking system. Motion trials were then repeated after the distal humerus was replaced with a corresponding reverse-engineered prosthesis. Contact areas and patterns were reconstructed using computer models created from CT scan images combined with the motion tracker data. The total contact areas, as well as the contact area within smaller sub-regions of the ulna and radius, were analyzed for changes resulting from hemiarthroplasty using repeated-measures ANOVAs.

FINDINGS

Contact area at the ulna and radius decreased on average 42% (SD 19%, P=.008) and 41% (SD 42%, P=.096), respectively. Contact area decreases were not uniform throughout the different sub-regions, suggesting that contact patterns were also altered.

INTERPRETATION

Reverse-engineered prostheses did not reproduce the same contact pattern as the native joints, possibly because the thickness of the distal humerus cartilage layer was neglected when generating the prosthesis shapes or as a consequence of the increased stiffness of the metallic implants. Alternative design strategies and materials for hemiarthroplasty should be considered in future work.

Three-dimensional suitability assessment of three types of osteochondral autograft for ulnar coronoid process reconstruction

BACKGROUND

Osteochondral autografts with use of the olecranon tip, lateral radial head, or proximal radial head have been employed for coronoid process reconstruction. However, it is unclear which autograft is most suitable for coronoid articular configuration. We assessed 3-dimensional articular facet suitability of 3 osteochondral autografts for coronoid process reconstruction.

METHODS

We performed 3-dimensional computed tomography of 20 elbows to compare the articular facet configuration between the coronoid process and the ipsilateral olecranon tip, lateral radial head, and proximal radial head. We measured the area of the proximity region (≤2.0 mm) between the articular facets of the coronoid process and 3 osteochondral autografts, the covering rate defined as the percentage area of the coronoid articular facet occupied by the proximity region, the location of the proximity region center, and the percentage of the removed ulnohumeral articular facet.

RESULTS

The covering rate was significantly higher with an olecranon graft than with radial head grafts. The regional center of a proximal radial head graft was significantly medial compared with that of olecranon and lateral radial head grafts. The olecranon graft used an average of 13.8% of the ulnohumeral articular facet.

CONCLUSIONS

An olecranon graft was most suitable for defects of the coronoid process involving the tip, and a proximal radial head graft was most suitable for defects of the coronoid process involving the anteromedial rim. The use of an olecranon graft for reconstruction of 50% of the height of the coronoid process does not cause concern for gross elbow instability.

Use of fine-threaded K-wires in the treatment of coronoid fractures in complex elbow instability

The coronoid process is one of the main elbow constraints that provides ulnohumeral joint stability. Coronoid fractures may be fixed using multiple techniques, including transosseous sutures, screws, and plates. The goal of this study was to analyze the clinical and radiographic outcomes in a series of patients with complex elbow instability in whom coronoid fractures were repaired using fine-threaded K-wires. Eight men and 10 women (mean age, 47 years) were followed prospectively for a mean of 26 months. Surgical treatment consisted of open reduction and internal fixation of all fractures; radial head replacement in Mason III injuries; lateral collateral ligament repair in all patients; and, in cases of persistent instability, medial collateral ligament repair, hinged fixator application, or both. Coronoid fixation was performed using 2 or more fine-threaded K-wires, depending on the fragment size, inserted from the posterior aspect of the ulna and directed toward the coronoid fragment using a 1-step fixation technique. At last follow-up, mean extension was 15°, mean flexion was 133°, mean pronation was 78°, and mean supination was 69°; mean Disabilities of the Arm, Shoulder and Hand score was 9.7, mean American Shoulder and Elbow Surgeons score was 85, and mean Mayo Elbow Performance Score was 89. According to the Mayo Elbow Performance Index, 10 excellent, 7 good, and 1 fair result were recorded. All but 1 patient had a stable elbow. Fracture healing was observed in all but 1 patient. No secondary coronoid fragment dislocation or implant failures were reported. This study shows that using fine-threaded K-wires provides easy, minimally invasive, stable, and successful 1-step fixation that can be used to obtain osteosynthesis of coronoid fractures in patients with complex elbow instability.

The effect of a coronoid prosthesis on restoring stability to the coronoid-deficient elbow: a biomechanical study

PURPOSE

The coronoid process has been recognized as a critical component in maintaining elbow stability. In the case of comminuted coronoid fractures, where repair is not possible or has failed, a prosthesis may be beneficial in restoring the osseous integrity of the elbow joint. The hypothesis of this in vitro biomechanical study was that a coronoid prosthesis would restore stability to the coronoid-deficient elbow.

METHODS

An anatomically shaped metallic coronoid prosthesis was designed and developed based on computed tomography-derived measurements and optimized to account for average cartilage thickness. Elbow kinematics and stability were determined for 8 cadaveric arms in active and passive elbow flexion in the varus, valgus, horizontal, and vertical positions using an elbow motion simulator. Varus-valgus angulation and internal-external rotation of the ulna relative to the humerus were quantified in the intact state, after collateral ligament sectioning and repair (control state), after a simulated 40% transverse coronoid fracture, and after implantation of the coronoid prosthesis.

RESULTS

Internal rotation of the ulna increased with a 40% coronoid fracture in the horizontal and varus positions. Increases in varus angulation after coronoid fracture were also observed in the horizontal and varus positions, during active and passive flexion, respectively. Following implantation of the coronoid prosthesis, elbow kinematics were restored similar to control levels in all elbow positions.

CONCLUSIONS

Our findings support our hypothesis that an anatomically shaped coronoid prosthesis would be effective in restoring stability to the coronoid-deficient elbow.

CLINICAL RELEVANCE

This study provides evidence that the use of an anatomical implant restores stability to the coronoid-deficient elbow and rationale for further study and development of this method. For comminuted coronoid fractures, where repair is not possible or has failed, our research indicates that a prosthesis may be a feasible treatment option.

Investigation of the geometries of the coronoid process and the fibular allograft as a potential surgical replacement

BACKGROUND

The proximal tibiofibular joint can be used as a source of osteochondral autograft with little to no morbidity at the harvest site.

METHODS

CT scans of fourteen left and seven right fibular heads, seven right and six left ulnas obtained from healthy subjects were volume-scaled and analyzed. Ipsilateral ulnar articular surfaces were compared between subjects and contralateral ulnas were compared within the same subject. The average deviations between the surfaces were measured. Manual registration and best-fit alignment were used to locate the area on the fibular heads that would best-fit the 50% coronoid process surface.

FINDINGS

The average deviations in the articular surface between subjects were (mean (SD) 0.79mm (0.17) and 0.76mm (0.14) for the left and right ulnas respectively and 0.35mm (0.07) in the same subject. The average coronoid process height of the scaled ulnas was 15.92mm (1.15). When comparing the 50% coronoid process with the ispsilateral fibular head geometries, the maximum deviations for all subjects were smaller than 2.0mm. Two locations were identified as the best-fit locations.

INTERPRETATION

When volume-scaled, the articular congruency of the proximal ulna articular surfaces between subjects is within the allowable limit for a typical intra-articular fracture step. Results suggest it is possible to use the CT scan of a patient's contralateral elbow as a template to estimate the morphology of the affected side. The fibular head could be an alternative replacement for damaged coronoid process since it is covered by articular cartilage and has locations with a similar curvature as the coronoid process.

Reconstruction of the coronoid using an extended prosthesis: an in vitro biomechanical study

BACKGROUND

When repair of comminuted coronoid fractures is not possible, prosthetic replacement may restore elbow stability. The purpose of this biomechanical study was to determine whether a coronoid implant with an extended tip would improve elbow stability compared with an anatomic prosthesis in the setting of collateral ligament insufficiency.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Passive elbow extension was performed in 7 cadaveric arms in the varus and valgus positions and active and passive extension in the horizontal position by use of an elbow motion simulator. Varus-valgus laxity of the ulna relative to the humerus was quantified with a tracking system with a native coronoid, a 40% coronoid deficiency, an anatomic prosthesis, and an extended prosthesis, with the collateral ligaments sectioned and repaired.

RESULTS

Laxity significantly increased after a 40% coronoid deficiency with both repaired and sectioned collateral ligaments (P ≤ .01). With the ligaments repaired, there was no significant difference in laxity between the native coronoid, the anatomic implant, or the extended implant. Ligament sectioning alone produced severe instability, with a mean laxity of 42.75° ± 11.54° (P < .01). With insufficient ligaments, the anatomic prosthesis produced no change in laxity compared with the native coronoid, whereas the extended implant significantly reduced laxity by 21.56° ± 17.70° (P = .02).

CONCLUSIONS

An anatomic coronoid implant with ligament repair restores stability to the coronoid-deficient elbow to intact levels. In the setting of ligament insufficiency, an extended implant improves stability relative to an anatomic implant, but the elbow remains significantly less stable than an intact elbow. Studies are needed to evaluate the feasibility of these designs.