Altered post-mortem metabolism identified in very fast chilled lamb M. longissimus thoracis et lumborum using metabolomic analysis

LC-MS-based metabolomics reveals metabolite dynamic changes of beef after superchilling early post-mortem

To explore the underlying mechanisms by which superchilling (SC, -3 °C within 5 h of slaughter) improves beef tenderness, an untargeted metabolomics strategy was employed. M. Longissimus lumborum (LL) muscles from twelve beef carcasses were assigned to either SC or very fast chilling (VFC, 0 °C within 5 h of slaughter) treatments, with conventional chilling (CC, 0 ∼ 4 °C until 24 h post-mortem) serving as the control (6 per group). Biochemical properties and metabolites were investigated during the early post-mortem period. The results showed that the degradation of μ-calpain and caspase 3 occurred earlier in SC treated sample, which might be attributed to the accelerated accumulation of free Ca2+. The metabolomic profiles of samples from the SC and CC treatments were clearly distinguished based on partial least squares-discriminant analysis (PLS-DA) at each time point. It is noteworthy that more IMP and 4-hydroxyproline were found in the comparison between SC and CC treatments. According to the results of metabolic pathways analysis and the correlation analysis between traits related to tenderness and metabolites with significant differences (SC vs. CC), it can be suggested that the tenderization effect of the SC treatment may be related to the alteration of arginine and proline metabolism, and purine metabolism in the early post-mortem phase.

Molecular insights into quality and authentication of sheep meat from proteomics and metabolomics

Sheep meat (encompassing lamb, hogget and mutton) is an important source of animal protein in many countries, with a unique flavour and sensory profile compared to other red meats. Flavour, colour and texture are the key quality attributes contributing to consumer liking of sheep meat. Over the last decades, various factors from 'farm to fork', including production system (e.g., age, breed, feeding regimes, sex, pre-slaughter stress, and carcass suspension), post-mortem manipulation and processing (e.g., electrical stimulation, ageing, packaging types, and chilled and frozen storage) have been identified as influencing different aspects of sheep meat quality. However conventional meat-quality assessment tools are not able to elucidate the underlying mechanisms and pathways for quality variations. Advances in broad-based analytical techniques have offered opportunities to obtain deeper insights into the molecular changes of sheep meat which may become biomarkers for specific variations in quality traits and meat authenticity. This review provides an overview on how omics techniques, especially proteomics (including peptidomics) and metabolomics (including lipidomics and volatilomics) are applied to elucidate the variations in sheep meat quality, mainly in loin muscles, focusing on colour, texture and flavour, and as tools for authentication. SIGNIFICANCE: From this review, we observed that attempts have been made to utilise proteomics and metabolomics techniques on sheep meat products for elucidating pathways of quality variations due to various factors. For instance, the improvement of colour stability and tenderness could be associated with the changes to glycolysis, energy metabolism and endogenous antioxidant capacity. Several studies identify proteolysis as being important, but potentially conflicting for quality as the enhanced proteolysis improves tenderness and flavour, while reducing colour stability. The use of multiple analytical methods e.g., lipidomics, metabolomics, and volatilomics, detects a wider range of flavour precursors (including both water and lipid soluble compounds) that underlie the possible pathways for sheep meat flavour evolution. The technological advancement in omics (e.g., direct analysis-mass spectrometry) could make analysis of the proteins, lipids and metabolites in sheep meat routine, as well as enhance the confidence in quality determination and molecular-based assurance of meat authenticity.

Phosphorylation and acetylation responses of glycolytic enzymes in meat to different chilling rates

The aim of this study was to investigate the effects of chilling rate on phosphorylation and acetylation levels of the glycolytic enzymes in meat, including glycogen phosphorylase, phosphofructokinase, aldolase (ALDOA), triose-phosphate isomerase (TPI1), phosphoglycerate kinase, lactate dehydrogenase (LDH). The samples were assigned into three groups: Control, Chilling 1 and Chilling 2, corresponding to the chilling rates of 4.8 °C/h, 23.0 °C/h and 25.1 °C/h respectively. The contents of glycogen and ATP were significantly higher in samples from the chilling groups. The activity and phosphorylation level of the six enzymes were higher in samples at the chilling rate of 25.1 °C/h, while the acetylation level of ALDOA, TPI1 and LDH were inhibited. In brief, glycolysis was delayed and the activity of glycolytic enzymes were maintained at higher level by the changes of phosphorylation and acetylation levels at the chilling rates of 23.0 °C/h and 25.1 °C/h, which may partly explain why very fast chilling improves meat quality.

Microbial spoilage mechanisms of vacuum-packed lamb meat: A review

Lamb meat is an important export commodity, however chilled vacuum-packed (VP) lamb has approximately half the shelf-life of beef under the same storage conditions. This makes the industry more vulnerable to financial losses due to long shipping times and unexpected spoilage. Understanding the spoilage mechanisms of chilled VP lamb in relation to VP beef is important for developing effective strategies to extend the shelf-life of lamb. This review has discussed various key factors (i.e., pH, fat, and presence of bone) that have effects on microbial spoilage of VP lamb contributing to its shorter shelf-life relative to VP beef. A range of bacterial organisms and their metabolisms in relevance to lamb spoilage are also discussed. The data gap in the literature regarding the potential mechanisms of spoilage in VP red meat is highlighted. This review has provided the current understanding of key factors affecting the shelf-life of VP lamb relative to VP beef. It has also identified key areas of research to further understand the spoilage mechanisms of VP lamb. These include investigating the potential influence of fat and bone (including bone marrow) on the shelf-life, as well as assessing changes in the meat metabolome as the spoilage microbial community is developing using an integrated approach. Such new knowledge would aid the development of effective approaches to extend the shelf-life of VP lamb.

The underlying mechanisms of the effect of superchilling on the tenderness of beef Longissimus lumborum

This study investigated the effect of superchilling (-30 °C until the core temperature achieved -3 °C, then stored at -1 °C until 24 h, SC) on the tenderness of hot boned beef M. longissimus lumborum (LL), with very fast chilling (-30 °C until the core temperature achieved 0 °C, then stored at -1 °C until 24 h, VFC) and conventional chilling (0- 4 °C for 24 h, CC) as the controls. The lowest initial shear force values were obtained in SC samples compared to those from the VFC and CC treatments (P < 0.05). Clear freezing damage of muscle fibers and more myofibril fragmentation were found in SC samples compared with the other samples early post-mortem. Moreover, SC samples showed the highest level of inosine 5-monophosphate at 3 h post-mortem (P < 0.05). A reduced glycolysis rate (as evidenced by lactate content) was also found in SC treated samples suggesting little contribution of glycolysis on the tenderization of SC.

Comparative Analysis of the Composition of Fatty Acids and Metabolites between Black Tibetan and Chaka Sheep on the Qinghai-Tibet Plateau

The objective of this study was to investigate and compare fatty acids and metabolites in the longissimus dorsi muscle between Black Tibetan and Chaka sheep grazing in a highly saline environment. A total of eight castrated sheep (14 months old) with similar body weights (25 ± 2.2 kg) were selected. The experimental treatments included Black Tibetan (BT) and Chaka sheep (CK) groups, and each group had four replications. The experiment lasted for 20 months. All sheep grazed in a highly saline environment for the whole experimental period and had free access to water. The results showed that the diameter (42.23 vs. 51.46 μm), perimeter (131.78 vs. 166.14 μm), and area of muscle fibers (1328.74 vs. 1998.64 μm2) were smaller in Chaka sheep than in Black Tibetan sheep. The ash content in the longissimus dorsi was lower in Chaka sheep than in Black Tibetan sheep (p = 0.010), and the contents of dry matter (DM), ether extract (EE), and crude protein (CP) in the longissimus dorsi showed no differences (p > 0.05). For fatty acids, the proportions of C10:0, C15:0, and tC18:1 in the longissimus dorsi were higher in Chaka sheep than in Black Tibetan sheep (p < 0.05). However, all other individual fatty acids were similar among treatments, including saturated fatty acids (SFAs), unsaturated fatty acids (UFAs), monounsaturated fatty acids (MUFAs), polyunsaturated fatty acids (PUFAs), and the ratios of n-6 PUFAs to n-3 PUFAs and PUFAs to SFAs (p > 0.05). A total of 65 biomarkers were identified between the two breeds of sheep. Among these metabolites, 40 metabolic biomarkers were upregulated in the CK group compared to the BT group, and 25 metabolites were downregulated. The main metabolites include 30 organic acids, 9 amino acids, 5 peptides, 4 amides, 3 adenosines, 2 amines, and other compounds. Based on KEGG analysis, eight pathways, namely, fatty acid biosynthesis, purine metabolism, the biosynthesis of unsaturated fatty acids, renin secretion, the regulation of lipolysis in adipocytes, neuroactive ligand−receptor interaction, the cGMP-PKG signaling pathway, and the cAMP signaling pathway, were identified as significantly different pathways. According to the results on fatty acids and metabolites, upregulated organic acid and fatty acid biosynthesis increased the meat quality of Chaka sheep.

Effect of the combination of superchilling and super-chilled storage on shelf-life and bacterial community dynamics of beef during long-term storage

This study investigated the effect of superchilling (-30 °C until the core temperature achieved -3 °C, and - 1 °C until 24 h, SC) on shelf-life and bacterial community dynamics of beef loins, with a typical very fast chilling (-30 °C until the core temperature achieved 0 °C, and - 1 °C until 24 h, VFC) and conventional chilling (0- 4 °C for 24 h, CC) as controls. The super-chilled storage (-1 °C) was adopted after each chilling procedure, and physicochemical traits and microbiological quality were evaluated during a long-term storage. No remarkable adverse impact on meat color and lipid oxidation were observed in SC treatment. The bacterial composition results showed that Carnobacterium spp. were the main bacteria in SC treatment in the late storage period (63- 84 days). The loss of Lactobacillus spp., due to the "ultra-low temperature" during the superchilling, might be the reason that the SC did not result in a longer shelf-life compared with CC samples.

Effects of chilling rate on progression of rigor mortis in postmortem lamb meat

This work investigated the effects of chilling rate on the progression of rigor mortis and explored possible mechanisms. Silverside from 18 lamb carcasses was assigned to control group (1.94 °C/h), very fast chilling-I group (VFC-I, 12.19 °C/h) and VFC-II group (15.10 °C/h). The shear force, myofibril fragmentation index (MFI), actomyosin ATPase activity, protein degradation and actomyosin dissociation were determined. There was no increase in the shear force in VFC-II group. The activation of actomyosin ATPase at 2-4 h postmortem in VFC-II group resulted in super-contracted sarcomeres and an increase in MFI. The degradation of μ-calpain, troponin T and desmin in VFC-II group was higher than that in control group from 6 to 24 h postmortem. These results suggested that rigor mortis was influenced which resulted in decreased shear force at a chilling rate of 15.10 °C/h by activating actomyosin ATPase and μ-calpain at early postmortem and promoted actomyosin dissociation.

Metabolomic analysis indicates that higher drip loss may be related to the production of methylglyoxal as a by-product of glycolysis

The aim of the present study was to assess applicability of metabolomics analysis of exudate from chicken breast muscle to explanation of differences in drip loss. The research was carried out on the skinless breast fillets sourced from 60 broiler carcasses (7-wk-old male Ross broilers). In the meat samples the pH value, color parameters, drip loss, chemical composition, and sensory quality were evaluated. After measuring, the samples were divided into 2 groups taking into consideration the volume of drip loss (low ≤2% and high >2% drip loss). The muscle juice samples were collected during 24 h muscle storage and metabolomic analysis was performed. The results showed that chickens with higher drip loss were characterized by heavier carcasses. The meat with higher drip loss proved to be more acid, lighter, less red, and more yellow with higher level of glucose as well as glycolytic potential. That meat was also characterized by lower cooking loss, protein content and worse overall sensory quality as well as oxidation of lipids. The metabolomics analyses have shown that in the group with higher drip loss from muscle tissue the increase of metabolism of energy transformations taking place in muscle tissue after slaughter was observed and that differences between groups are related to 11 metabolic pathways, mainly carbohydrate metabolism (glycolysis, gluconeogenesis, pentose phosphate pathway) adenine and adenosine salvage, adenosine nucleotides degradation, arsenate detoxification, methylglyoxal degradation. Finally, the results indicate that in the group with higher drip loss and with deeper glycolysis, more methylglyoxal (as a by-product of carbohydrate metabolism) is produced which may lead to changes of muscle proteins properties and contribute to an increase in drip loss.

Dark-cutting beef: A brief review and an integromics meta-analysis at the proteome level to decipher the underlying pathways

Comprehensive characterization of the post-mortem muscle proteome defines a fundamental goal in meat proteomics. During the last decade, proteomics tools have been applied in the field of foodomics to help decipher factors underpinning meat quality variations and to enlighten us, through data-driven methods, on the underlying mechanisms leading to meat quality defects such as dark-cutting meat known also as dark, firm and dry (DFD) meat. In cattle, several proteomics studies have focused on the extent to which changes in the post-mortem muscle proteome relate to dark-cutting beef development. The present data-mining study firstly reviews proteomics studies which investigated dark-cutting beef, and secondly, gathers the protein biomarkers that differ between dark-cutting versus beef with normal-pH in a unique repertoire. A list of 130 proteins from eight eligible studies was curated and mined through bioinformatics for Gene Ontology annotations, molecular pathways enrichments, secretome analysis and biological pathways comparisons to normal beef color from a previous meta-analysis. The major biological pathways underpinning dark-cutting beef at the proteome level have been described and deeply discussed in this integromics study.

MEATabolomics: Muscle and Meat Metabolomics in Domestic Animals

In the past decades, metabolomics has been used to comprehensively understand a variety of food materials for improvement and assessment of food quality. Farm animal skeletal muscles and meat are one of the major targets of metabolomics for the characterization of meat and the exploration of biomarkers in the production system. For identification of potential biomarkers to control meat quality, studies of animal muscles and meat with metabolomics (MEATabolomics) has been conducted in combination with analyses of meat quality traits, focusing on specific factors associated with animal genetic background and sensory scores, or conditions in feeding system and treatments of meat in the processes such as postmortem storage, processing, and hygiene control. Currently, most of MEATabolomics approaches combine separation techniques (gas or liquid chromatography, and capillary electrophoresis)-mass spectrometry (MS) or nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) approaches with the downstream multivariate analyses, depending on the polarity and/or hydrophobicity of the targeted metabolites. Studies employing these approaches provide useful information to monitor meat quality traits efficiently and to understand the genetic background and production system of animals behind the meat quality. MEATabolomics is expected to improve the knowledge and methodologies in animal breeding and feeding, meat storage and processing, and prediction of meat quality.

Metabolomic approach to measuring quality of chilled chicken meat during storage

The metabolites of stored, chilled chicken meat were analyzed using liquid chromatograph-mass spectrometry and metabolomics. The results showed significant differences in the metabolites of chicken meat stored at 4°C for 0 D and meat stored for longer periods of 2 D, 4 D, 6 D, and 10 D, when analyzed based on a variable of importance >2 and P < 0.05. These changed metabolites included amino acids, amines, nucleosides, nucleotides, carbohydrates, organic acids, and other substances. The data from this study provide a holistic understanding of food quality changes in chicken meat during deterioration in storage.

Impact of feeding regimens on the composition of gut microbiota and metabolite profiles of plasma and feces from Mongolian sheep

Mongolian sheep are an indigenous ruminant raised for wool and meat production in China. The gut microbial community plays an important role in animal performance and metabolism. The objective of this study was to investigate the effects of two feeding regimens on the diversity and composition of gut microbiota and metabolite profiles of feces and plasma from Mongolian sheep. A total of 20 Mongolian sheep were assigned to one of two feeding regimens: free grazing (FG) and barn confinement (BC). When samples were collected, the average live weights of the sheep were 31.28 ± 1.56 kg and 34.18 ± 1.87 kg for the FG and BC groups, respectively. At the genus level, the FG group showed higher levels of Bacteroides, RC9_gut_group, Alistipes, Phocaeicola, Barnesiella, and Oscillibacter, and lower levels of Succinivibrio, Treponema, and Prevotella, compared to the BC group. The butyric acid content in feces was lower in the FG group (P > 0.05). Higher levels of palmitic acid, oleic acid, alpha-linolenic acid, L-carnitine, L-citrulline, and L-histidine, and lower levels of L-tyrosine, L-phenylalanine, and L-kynurenine were found in the plasma of the FG sheep. Moreover, there were substantial associations between several gut microbiota genera and alterations in feces and plasma metabolites especially those involved in the metabolism of butyric acid, linolenic acid, and L-tyrosine. Feeding regimens can not only influence the composition of gut microbiota, but also alter metabolic homeaostasis in sheep.

Effect of Carcass Chilling on the Palatability Traits and Safety of Fresh Red Meat

Chilling procedures have been widely used in livestock abattoirs since the development of refrigeration systems. The major criteria when applying chilling regimes is not only complying with regulations, but economic concerns, and also meat safety and quality assurance requirements. Given recent developments, an updated review is required to guide the industry to choose the best chilling method and to inspire the development of new approaches to chilling. Thus in this paper, the quality and microbial safety of beef, lamb, pork, venison, and bison resulting from different chilling treatments has been reviewed, as well as the underlying mechanism(s) for the different impacts on meat quality traits as a result of different chilling regimes. The effect of fast chilling on the tenderness of beef and lamb is a focus, as some new findings, have recently been reported, while multistep chilling is highlighted as it incorporates the advantages of fast chilling to reduce carcass weight loss, resulting in similar quality improvements as found with slow chilling. It is, suggested, that if spray chilling can be combined with the second phase of multi-step chilling, it will benefit the meat industry in terms of both meat quality and safety. Future studies should focus on combinations of chilling methods with new technologies, such as medium voltage electrical stimulation, muscle stretching, or ultrasound and so on, to move meat quality and safety to a new level.

The combination of four analytical methods to explore skeletal muscle metabolomics: Better coverage of metabolic pathways or a marketing argument?

OBJECTIVES

Metabolomics is an emerging science based on diverse high throughput methods that are rapidly evolving to improve metabolic coverage of biological fluids and tissues. Technical progress has led researchers to combine several analytical methods without reporting the impact on metabolic coverage of such a strategy. The objective of our study was to develop and validate several analytical techniques (mass spectrometry coupled to gas or liquid chromatography and nuclear magnetic resonance) for the metabolomic analysis of small muscle samples and evaluate the impact of combining methods for more exhaustive metabolite covering.

DESIGN AND METHODS

We evaluated the muscle metabolome from the same pool of mouse muscle samples after 2 metabolite extraction protocols. Four analytical methods were used: targeted flow injection analysis coupled with mass spectrometry (FIA-MS/MS), gas chromatography coupled with mass spectrometry (GC-MS), liquid chromatography coupled with high-resolution mass spectrometry (LC-HRMS), and nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) analysis. We evaluated the global variability of each compound i.e., analytical (from quality controls) and extraction variability (from muscle extracts). We determined the best extraction method and we reported the common and distinct metabolites identified based on the number and identity of the compounds detected with low analytical variability (variation coefficient<30%) for each method. Finally, we assessed the coverage of muscle metabolic pathways obtained.

RESULTS

Methanol/chloroform/water and water/methanol were the best extraction solvent for muscle metabolome analysis by NMR and MS, respectively. We identified 38 metabolites by nuclear magnetic resonance, 37 by FIA-MS/MS, 18 by GC-MS, and 80 by LC-HRMS. The combination led us to identify a total of 132 metabolites with low variability partitioned into 58 metabolic pathways, such as amino acid, nitrogen, purine, and pyrimidine metabolism, and the citric acid cycle. This combination also showed that the contribution of GC-MS was low when used in combination with other mass spectrometry methods and nuclear magnetic resonance to explore muscle samples.

CONCLUSION

This study reports the validation of several analytical methods, based on nuclear magnetic resonance and several mass spectrometry methods, to explore the muscle metabolome from a small amount of tissue, comparable to that obtained during a clinical trial. The combination of several techniques may be relevant for the exploration of muscle metabolism, with acceptable analytical variability and overlap between methods However, the difficult and time-consuming data pre-processing, processing, and statistical analysis steps do not justify systematically combining analytical methods.

Metabolomics Profiling to Determine the Effect of Postmortem Aging on Color and Lipid Oxidative Stabilities of Different Bovine Muscles

The objective of this study was to identify metabolites that could be associated with oxidative stability of aged bovine muscles. Three muscles (longissimus lumbrum (LL), semimembranosus (SM), and psoas major (PM)) from seven beef carcasses at 1 day postmortem were divided into three sections and assigned to three aging periods (9, 16, and 23 days). Although an increase in discoloration was found in all muscles with aging, LL was the most color/lipid oxidative stable, followed by SM and PM (P < 0.05). Lower myoglobin and nonheme iron contents were observed in LL compared to those in SM and PM (P < 0.05). The HPLC-ESI-MS-based metabolomics analysis identified metabolites that were significantly responsive to aging and/or muscle type, such as acyl carnitines, free amino acids, nucleotides, nucleosides, and glucuronides. The results from the current study suggest that color and oxidative stability could be associated with aging but are also muscle-specific. Further studies determining the exact role of the identified metabolites in the color and oxidative stability of beef muscles are warranted.

Metabolite Profile Differences between Beef Longissimus and Psoas Muscles during Display

The objective of this research was to compare metabolite profiles between beef longissimus and psoas muscles during display. Beef short loins were collected 3 d postmortem (n = 10). Steaks were cut from each longissimus lumborum (LL) and psoas major (PM) muscle and displayed under retail conditions for 7 d. Surface color, biochemical properties, and metabolites were analyzed during storage. PM decreased in redness (P < 0.05) by d 3 of display compared with LL. There were differences in metabolite concentrations (P < 0.05) between each muscle type at each time point. Sugars, amino acids, tricarboxylic acid cycle intermediates, and glycolytic substrates were detected in both muscles. Glycolytic metabolites such as pyruvic acid, glucose–6–phosphate, and fructose were greater (P < 0.05) in LL than PM at all display times. On d 0, the intensity of pyruvic acid in LL and PM were 142 and 42, respectively. Citric acid and succinic acid were lower on d 0, but were greater (P < 0.05) in LL compared with PM by d 7 of display. Carnitine was lower (P < 0.05) in LL than PM at all display times. On d 7, carnitine level in LL was 4.1 while in PM was 13,500. The results suggest that in addition to muscle-specific differences in mitochondrial and enzyme activities, inherent metabolite differences also may contribute to muscle color stability.