The decay accelerating factor mutation I197V found in hemolytic uraemic syndrome does not impair complement regulation

Complement Dysregulation and Disease: Insights from Contemporary Genetics

The vertebrate complement system consists of sequentially interacting proteins that provide for a rapid and powerful host defense. Nearly 60 proteins comprise three activation pathways (classical, alternative, and lectin) and a terminal cytolytic pathway common to all. Attesting to its potency, nearly half of the system's components are engaged in its regulation. An emerging theme over the past decade is that variations in these inhibitors predispose to two scourges of modern humans. One, occurring most often in childhood, is a rare but deadly thrombomicroangiopathy called atypical hemolytic uremic syndrome. The other, age-related macular degeneration, is the most common form of blindness in the elderly. Their seemingly unrelated clinical presentations and pathologies share the common theme of overactivity of the complement system's alternative pathway. This review summarizes insights gained from contemporary genetics for understanding how dysregulation of this powerful innate immune system leads to these human diseases.

Autoantibodies to CD59, CD55, CD46 or CD35 are not associated with atypical haemolytic uraemic syndrome (aHUS)

Autoantibody formation against Factor H (FH) is found in 7-10% of patients who are diagnosed with atypical haemolytic uraemic syndrome (aHUS). These autoantibodies predominately target the C-terminal cell binding recognition domain of FH and are associated with absence of FHR1. Additional autoantibodies have also been identified in association with aHUS, for example autoantibodies to Factor I. Based on this, and that there are genetic mutations in other complement regulators and activators associated with aHUS, we hypothesised that other complement regulator proteins, particularly surface bound regulators in the kidney, might be the target for autoantibody formation in aHUS. Therefore, we assayed serum derived from 89 patients in the Newcastle aHUS cohort for the presence of autoantibodies to CD46 (membrane cofactor protein, MCP), CD55 (decay accelerating factor, DAF), CD35 (complement receptor type 1, CR1; TP10) and CD59. We also assayed 100 healthy blood donors to establish the normal levels of reactivity towards these proteins in the general population. Recombinant proteins CD46 and CD55 (purified from Escherichia coli) as well as soluble CR1 (CD35) and oligomeric C4BP-CD59 (purified from eukaryotic cell media) were used in ELISA to detect high responders. False positive results were established though Western blot and flow cytometric analysis. After excluding false positive responders to bacterial proteins in the CD46 and CD55 preparations, and responses to blood group antigens in CD35, we found no significant level of patient serum IgG reactivity with CD46, CD55, CD35 or CD59 above that detected in the normal population. These results suggest that membrane anchored complement regulators are not a target for autoantibody generation in aHUS.

Complement factor B mutations in atypical hemolytic uremic syndrome-disease-relevant or benign?

Atypical hemolytic uremic syndrome (aHUS) is a genetic ultrarare renal disease associated with overactivation of the alternative pathway of complement. Four gain-of-function mutations that form a hyperactive or deregulated C3 convertase have been identified in Factor B (FB) ligand binding sites. Here, we studied the functional consequences of 10 FB genetic changes recently identified from different aHUS cohorts. Using several tests for alternative C3 and C5 convertase formation and regulation, we identified two gain-of-function and potentially disease-relevant mutations that formed either an overactive convertase (M433I) or a convertase resistant to decay by FH (K298Q). One mutation (R178Q) produced a partially cleaved protein with no ligand binding or functional activity. Seven genetic changes led to near-normal or only slightly reduced ligand binding and functional activity compared with the most common polymorphism at position 7, R7. Notably, none of the algorithms used to predict the disease relevance of FB mutations agreed completely with the experimental data, suggesting that in silico approaches should be undertaken with caution. These data, combined with previously published results, suggest that 9 of 15 FB genetic changes identified in patients with aHUS are unrelated to disease pathogenesis. This study highlights that functional assessment of identified nucleotide changes in FB is mandatory to confirm disease association.

Increased expression of complement regulators CD55 and CD59 on peripheral blood cells in patients with EAHEC O104:H4 infection

Background

An outbreak of Shiga Toxin 2 (Stx-2) producing enterohemorrhagic and enteroaggregative E.coli (EAHEC) O104H4 infection in May 2011 caused enterocolitis and an unprecedented high 22% rate of hemolytic uremic syndrome (HUS). The monoclonal anti-C5 antibody Eculizumab (ECU) has been used experimentally in EAHEC patients with HUS but treatment efficacy is uncertain. ECU can effectively prevent hemolysis in paroxysmal nocturnal hemoglobinuria (PNH) caused by a lack of complement-regulating CD55 and CD59 on blood cells. We hypothesized a low expression of CD55 and CD59, as seen in PNH, might correlate with HUS development in EAHEC patients.

Methods

76 EAHEC patients (34 only gastrointestinal symptoms [GI], 23: HUS, 19: HUS and neurological symptoms [HUS/N]) and 12 healthy controls (HC) were tested for the expression of CD55 and CD59 on erythrocytes and leukocytes retrospectively. Additionally, the effect of Stx-2 on CD55 and CD59 expression on erythrocytes and leukocytes was studied ex vivo.

Results

CD55 expression on erythrocytes was similar in all patient groups and HC while CD59 showed a significantly higher expression in HUS and HUS/N patients compared to HC and the GI group. CD55 and CD59 expression on leukocytes and their subsets was significantly higher in all patient groups compared to HC regardless of treatment type. However, CD59 expression on erythrocytes was significantly higher in HUS and HUS/N patients treated combined with plasma separation (PS) and ECU compared to HC. Adding Stx-2 ex vivo had no effect on CD55 and CD59 expression on leukocytes from HC or patients.

Conclusion

HUS evolved independently from CD55 and CD59 expression on peripheral blood cells in EAHEC O104:H4 infected patients. Our data do not support a role for CD55 and CD59 in HUS development during EAHEC O104:H4 infection and point to a different mechanism within the complement system for HUS development in EAHEC patients.

Structural and functional characterization of the product of disease-related factor H gene conversion

Numerous complement factor H (FH) mutations predispose patients to atypical hemolytic uremic syndrome (aHUS) and other disorders arising from inadequately regulated complement activation. No unifying structural or mechanistic consequences have been ascribed to these mutants beyond impaired self-cell protection. The S1191L and V1197A mutations toward the C-terminus of FH, which occur in patients singly or together, arose from gene conversion between CFH encoding FH and CFHR1 encoding FH-related 1. We show that neither single nor double mutations structurally perturbed recombinant proteins consisting of the FH C-terminal modules, 19 and 20 (FH19-20), although all three FH19-20 mutants were poor, compared to wild-type FH19-20, at promoting hemolysis of C3b-coated erythrocytes through competition with full-length FH. Indeed, our new crystal structure of the S1191L mutant of FH19-20 complexed with an activation-specific complement fragment, C3d, was nearly identical to that of the wild-type FH19-20:C3d complex, consistent with mutants binding to C3b with wild-type-like affinity. The S1191L mutation enhanced thermal stability of module 20, whereas the V1197A mutation dramatically decreased it. Thus, although mutant proteins were folded at 37 °C, they differ in conformational rigidity. Neither single substitutions nor double substitutions increased measurably the extent of FH19-20 self-association, nor did these mutations significantly affect the affinity of FH19-20 for three glycosaminoglycans, despite critical roles of module 20 in recognizing polyanionic self-surface markers. Unexpectedly, FH19-20 mutants containing Leu1191 self-associated on a heparin-coated surface to a higher degree than on surfaces coated with dermatan or chondroitin sulfates. Thus, potentially disease-related functional distinctions between mutants, and between FH and FH-related 1, may manifest in the presence of specific glycosaminoglycans.

Factor I autoantibodies in patients with atypical hemolytic uremic syndrome: disease-associated or an epiphenomenon?

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES

Atypical hemolytic uremic syndrome is a disease associated with mutations in the genes encoding the complement regulators factors H and I. In addition, factor H autoantibodies have been reported in ∼10% of patients with atypical hemolytic uremic syndrome. This study searched for the presence of factor I autoantibodies in atypical hemolytic uremic syndrome.

DESIGN, SETTING, PARTICIPANTS, & MEASUREMENTS

This study screened 175 atypical hemolytic uremic syndrome patients for factor I autoantibodies using ELISA with confirmatory Western blotting. Functional studies using purified immunoglobulin from one patient were subsequently undertaken.

RESULTS

Factor I autoantibodies were detected in three patients. In one patient with a high titer of autoantibody, the titer was tracked over time and was found to have no association with disease activity. This study found evidence of an immune complex of antibody and factor I in this patient, but purified IgG, isolated from current serum samples, had only a minor effect on fluid phase and cell surface complement regulation. Genetic analysis of the three patients with factor I autoantibodies revealed that they had two copies of the genes encoding factor H-related proteins 1 and 3 and therefore, did not have a deletion commonly associated with factor H autoantibodies in atypical hemolytic uremic syndrome. Two patients, however, had functionally significant mutations in complement factor H.

CONCLUSIONS

These findings reinforce the concept of multiple concurrent risk factors being associated with atypical hemolytic uremic syndrome but question whether autoantibodies per se predispose to atypical hemolytic uremic syndrome.

Too Much of a Good Thing at the Site of Tissue Injury: The Instructive Example of the Complement System Predisposing to Thrombotic Microangiopathy

The interplay between the complement and coagulation systems is just beginning to be explored and characterized. This interaction, however, is ancient. For example, if endotoxin is added to the hemolymph of the horseshoe crab, a protease is activated that triggers both the coagulation and complement systems. However, in extant mammals, these 2 cascades have diverged. These infamous “terrible C's” are the scourge of many a medical student (and possibly even a few hematologists). They also are intimately involved in the pathophysiology of thrombomicroangiopathies (TMAs). The complement system generates a procoagulant microenvironment and the coagulation system forms a clot in the renal microvasculature, and thus the 2 systems are partners in mediating multiple pathophysiological conditions.

Allelic variants of complement genes associated with dense deposit disease

The alternative pathway of the complement cascade plays a role in the pathogenesis of dense deposit disease (DDD). Deficiency of complement factor H and mutations in CFH associate with the development of DDD, but it is unknown whether allelic variants in other complement genes also associate with this disease. We studied patients with DDD and identified previously unreported sequence alterations in several genes in addition to allelic variants and haplotypes common to patients with DDD. We found that the likelihood of developing DDD increases with the presence of two or more risk alleles in CFH and C3. To determine the functional consequence of this finding, we measured the activity of the alternative pathway in serum samples from phenotypically normal controls genotyped for variants in CFH and C3. Alternative pathway activity was higher in the presence of variants associated with DDD. Taken together, these data confirm that DDD is a complex genetic disease and may provide targets for the development of disease-specific therapies.

Production of biologically active complement factor H in therapeutically useful quantities

Human complement factor H (FH), an abundant 155-kDa plasma glycoprotein with 40 disulphide bonds, regulates the alternative-pathway complement cascade. Mutations and single nucleotide polymorphisms in the FH gene predispose to development of age-related macular degeneration, atypical haemolytic uraemic syndrome and dense deposit disease. Supplementation with FH variants protective against disease is an enticing therapeutic prospect. Current sources of therapeutic FH are restricted to human blood plasma highlighting a need for recombinant material. Previously FH expression in cultured plant, mammalian or insect cells yielded protein amounts inadequate for full characterisation, and orders of magnitude below therapeutic usefulness. Here, the V62,Y402 variant of FH has been produced recombinantly (rFH) in Pichia pastoris cells. Codon-optimisation proved essential whilst exploitation of the yeast mating α-factor peptide ensured secretion. We thereby produced multiple 10s-of-milligram of rFH. Following endoglycosidase H digestion of N-linked glycans, rFH (with eight residual N-acetylglucosamine moieties) was purified on heparin-affinity resin and anion-exchange chromatography. Full-length rFH was verified by mass spectrometry and Western blot using monoclonal antibodies to the C-terminus. Recombinant FH is a single non-aggregated species (by dynamic light scattering) and fully functional in biochemical and biological assays. An additional version of rFH was produced in which eight N-glycosylation sequons were ablated by Asn-Gln substitutions resulting in a glycan-devoid product. Successful production of rFH in this potentially very highly expressing system makes production of therapeutically useful quantities economically viable. Furthermore, ease of genetic manipulation in P. pastoris would allow production of engineered FH versions with enhanced pharmacokinetic and pharmacodynamic properties.

Review: Complement and its regulatory proteins in kidney diseases

Complement is a part of the body's innate immune system that helps defend the host from microbial infection. It is tightly controlled by a number of cell surface and fluid-phase proteins so that under normal circumstances injury to autologous tissues is avoided. In many pathological settings, such as when the complement regulatory mechanisms are dysfunctional or overwhelmed, complement attack of autologous tissues can occur with severe, sometimes life-threatening consequences. The kidney appears to be particularly vulnerable to complement-mediated inflammatory injury and many kidney pathologies have been linked to abnormal complement activation. Clinical and experimental studies have shown that complement attack can be a primary cause in rare, genetically predisposed kidney diseases or a significant contributor to kidney injury caused by other etiological factors. Here we provide a brief review of recent advances on the activation and regulation of the complement system in kidney disease, with a particular emphasis on the relevance of complement regulatory proteins.

Alternative complement pathway assessment in patients with atypical HUS

The atypical Hemolytic Uremic Syndrome (aHUS) is a rare thrombotic microangiopathy leading to end stage renal disease in approximately 60% of patients. Over the last decade, a clear link has been demonstrated between this disease and defective complement regulation. The hallmark of the aHUS is the association with mutations in complement alternative pathway genes. Endothelial damage is related to complement dysregulation, but the exact mechanism is just starting to be elucidated. Screening for and characterization of mutations in the components of the C3 convertase (C3 and FB) or its regulators (FH, FI, MCP, and Thrombomodulin) or anti-FH antibodies has become an indispensable part of the disease's diagnostic. This review will initially summarize current knowledge on the understanding of complement activation and regulation, followed by a description on the genetic analysis as well as the methods used for complement protein quantification. Another part of this review will focus on the mechanisms of action of aHUS-associated mutations. We will emphasize on when and why some mutations lead to protein deficiency, while others result in - to dysfunctional but normally expressed proteins. Finally, we will discuss how the therapy of aHUS patients can be modified according to the functional consequences of each particular genetic defect.

Genetics and complement in atypical HUS

Central to the pathogenesis of atypical hemolytic uremic syndrome (aHUS) is over-activation of the alternative pathway of complement. Following the initial discovery of mutations in the complement regulatory protein, factor H, mutations have been described in factor I, membrane cofactor protein and thrombomodulin, which also result in decreased complement regulation. Autoantibodies to factor H have also been reported to impair complement regulation in aHUS. More recently, gain of function mutations in the complement components C3 and Factor B have been seen. This review focuses on the genetic causes of aHUS, their functional consequences, and clinical effect.

A novel non-synonymous polymorphism (p.Arg240His) in C4b-binding protein is associated with atypical hemolytic uremic syndrome and leads to impaired alternative pathway cofactor activity

Atypical hemolytic uremic syndrome (aHUS) is a disorder characterized by hemolytic anemia, thrombocytopenia, and acute renal failure. Mutations, polymorphisms, and copy number variation in complement factors and inhibitors are associated with aHUS. In this study, we report the first functional non-synonymous polymorphism in the complement inhibitor C4b-binding protein (C4BP) alpha-chain (c.719G>A; p.Arg240His), which is associated with aHUS. This heterozygous change was found in 6/166 aHUS patients compared with 5/542 normal (chi2 = 6.021; p = 0.014), which was replicated in a second cohort of aHUS patients in which we found 5/170 carriers. The polymorphism does not decrease expression efficiency of C4BP. p.Arg240His is equally efficient as the wild type in binding and supporting degradation of C4BP but its ability to bind C3b and act as cofactor to its degradation both in fluid phase and on surfaces is impaired. This observation supports the hypothesis that dysregulation of the alternative pathway of complement is pivotal for aHUS. Three of the patients carry also mutations in membrane cofactor protein and factor H strengthening the hypothesis that individuals may carry multiple susceptibility factors with an additive effect on the risk of developing aHUS.

Complement regulatory genes and hemolytic uremic syndromes

Hemolytic uremic syndrome is a triad of microangiopathic hemolytic anemia, thrombocytopenia, and acute renal failure. It is one of a group of conditions termed the thrombotic microangiopathies, which are characterized by prominent endothelial cell injury. It may be diarrheal-associated or atypical (aHUS). Evidence for a pathogenic role of the alternative pathway of complement was first suggested in 1974. Mutations in the complement regulatory proteins factor H, membrane cofactor protein (CD46), and factor I predispose to aHUS development. Mutations of the activating components factor B and complement C3 have also been reported. Penetrance is approximately 50%, suggesting other genetic and environmental modifiers are needed for disease expression. Identification of mutations is important owing to differences in mortality, renal survival, and outcome of renal transplantation. Current treatment is plasma infusion/exchange, but complement inhibitor therapy provides hope for the future.

Update on evaluating complement in hemolytic uremic syndrome

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

The last few years have seen the decoding of the genetic basis for atypical hemolytic uremic syndrome.

RECENT FINDINGS

Mutations in complement factor H were the first to be associated with atypical hemolytic uremic syndrome. These mutations cluster in the C-terminus of complement factor H. This year has seen the publication of a transgenic mouse model lacking the C-terminus of complement factor H, which spontaneously develops atypical hemolytic uremic syndrome. This mouse model regulated C3 activation in plasma but failed to bind to endothelial cells in an analogous manner to the mutations seen in atypical hemolytic uremic syndrome patients. This year has also seen the emergence of genotype-phenotype correlations in atypical hemolytic uremic syndrome. Patients with membrane cofactor protein mutations have a good prognosis and in those who do develop endstage renal disease, recurrence after transplantation is rare. By contrast, the outcome for patients with complement factor H and complement factor I mutations is poor and the rate of recurrence after transplantation is high. New complement genes associated with atypical hemolytic uremic syndrome have also been described in the past year including factor B, C3, C4b-binding protein, FHR1 and FHR3.

SUMMARY

Genetic screening is now providing prognostically significant information in predicting survival, renal recovery and transplant outcome. It paves the way for the use of complement inhibitors in the future.

Where next with atypical hemolytic uremic syndrome?

Hemolytic uremic syndrome (HUS) is a systemic disease characterized by damage to endothelial cells, erythrocytes and kidney glomeruli. A "typical" form of HUS follows gastrointestinal infection with enterohemorrhagic E. coli (e.g. O157:H7). Atypical HUS (aHUS) is not associated with gastrointestinal infections but is sporadic or familial in nature. Approximately 50% of aHUS cases are associated with a mutation in one or more genes coding for proteins involved in regulation or activation of the alternative pathway of complement. The link between the disease and the mutations shows the important balance of the alternative pathway between activation and regulation on host cell surfaces. It also demonstrates the power of this pathway in destroying cellular targets in general. In this review we discuss the current knowledge on pathogenesis, classification, diagnostics and management of this disease. We indicate a comprehensive diagnostic approach for aHUS based on the latest knowledge on complement dysregulation to gain both immediate and future patient benefit by assisting in choosing more appropriate therapy for each patient. We also indicate directions in which therapy of aHUS might improve and indicate the need to re-think the terminology and categorisation of the HUS-like diseases so that any advantage in the understanding of complement regulatory problems can be applied to patients accurately.

Inherited complement regulatory protein deficiency predisposes to human disease in acute injury and chronic inflammatory statesthe examples of vascular damage in atypical hemolytic uremic syndrome and debris accumulation in age-related macular degeneration

In this chapter, we examine the role of complement regulatory activity in atypical hemolytic uremic syndrome (aHUS) and age-related macular degeneration (AMD). These diseases are representative of two distinct types of complement-mediated injury, one being acute and self-limited, the other reflecting accumulation of chronic damage. Neither condition was previously thought to have a pathologic relationship to the immune system. However, alterations in complement regulatory protein genes have now been identified as major predisposing factors for the development of both diseases. In aHUS, heterozygous mutations leading to haploinsufficiency and function-altering polymorphisms in complement regulators have been identified, while in AMD, polymorphic haplotypes in complement genes are associated with development of disease. The basic premise is that a loss of function in a plasma or membrane inhibitor of the alternative complement pathway allows for excessive activation of complement on the endothelium of the kidney in aHUS and on retinal debris in AMD. These associations have much to teach us about the host's innate immune response to acute injury and to chronic debris deposition. We all experience cellular injury and, if we live long enough, will deposit debris in blood vessel walls (atherosclerosis leading to heart attacks and strokes), the brain (amyloid proteins leading to Alzheimer's disease), and retina (lipofuscin pigments leading to AMD). These are three common causes of morbidity and mortality in the developed world. The clinical, genetic, and immunopathologic understandings derived from the two examples of aHUS and AMD may illustrate what to anticipate in related conditions. They highlight how a powerful recognition and effector system, the alternative complement pathway, reacts to altered self. A response to acute injury or chronic debris accumulation must be appropriately balanced. In either case, too much activation or too little regulation promotes undesirable tissue damage and human disease.