Low frequency of broadly neutralizing HIV antibodies during chronic infection even in quaternary epitope targeting antibodies containing large numbers of somatic mutations

Identification of a mimotope of a complex gp41 human immunodeficiency virus epitope related to a non-structural protein of Hepacivirus previously implicated in Kawasaki disease

Current HIV vaccine strategies are hampered by difficulty with recapitulating heavily mutated broadly neutralizing antibodies. We have previously isolated a highly mutated antibody termed "group C 76-Q13-6F5" (6F5) that uses immunoglobulin heavy chain variable region (VH)1-02. 6F5 targets a conformational epitope on HIV gp41 and mediates Ab-dependent cell cytotoxicity (ADCC). Reverting the group C 76 antibodies' variable chain to VH1-02 germline in antibody 76Canc showed retained ADCC activity. A vaccine targeting an epitope functionally recognized by germline antibodies offers a distinct advantage. Due to the 76Canc germline antibody ability to retain anti-HIV function, we sought to identify a protein target that could form the basis of a vaccine. 76Canc specifically recognized a number of acidic peptides on a microarray containing 29,127 linear peptides. Meme analysis identified a peptide sequence similar to a non-structural protein of Hepacivirus previously implicated in Kawasaki disease (KD). Binding was confirmed to significant peptides, including the Hepacivirus-related and KD-related peptide. On serum competition studies using samples from children with KD compared to controls, targeting of this epitope showed no specific correlation to the clinical syndrome of KD. Yeast-displayed human protein microarray autoantigen screening was also reassuring. This study identifies a peptide that can mimic the gp41 epitope targeted by 76C group antibodies (i.e., a mimotope). We show little risk of autoimmune targeting inclusive of inflammation similar to KD, implying non-specific humoral immunity targeting of similar peptides during KD. Development of an HIV vaccine based on such peptides should proceed, but with continued caution.

IMPORTANCE

The development of protective HIV vaccines continues to remain a significant challenge. Many of the broadly neutralizing antibodies require a significant number of mutations, suggesting that traditional vaccines will not be able to recapitulate these types of responses. We have discovered an antibody that has Ab dependent cell cytotoxicity (ADCC) activity against HIV even when mutating the heavy chain of that antibody to germline. As a potential target for vaccines, this offers a distinct advantage: a few immunizations should directly stimulate B cells harboring those specific germline variable chains for expansion. This study sought to identify potential peptide targets that could be formulated into such a vaccine. We identified a peptide that both germline and mature antibodies can recognize. Initial autoantigen screens and consideration of inflammatory disorders suggest this identified antigen is a feasible approach to move forward into pre-clinical models.

Identification of a mimotope of a complex gp41 Human Immunodeficiency VIrus epitope related to a non-structural protein of Hepacivirus previously implicated in Kawasaki disease

Background

We have previously isolated a highly mutated VH1-02 antibody termed group C 76-Q13-6F5 (6F5) that targets a conformational epitope on gp41. 6F5 has the capacity to mediate Ab dependent cell cytotoxicity (ADCC). When the VH1-02 group C 76 antibodies variable chain sequence was reverted to germline (76Canc), this still retained ADCC activity. Due to this ability for the 76Canc germline antibody to functionally target this epitope, we sought to identify a protein target for vaccine development.

Methods

Initially, we interrogated peptide targeting by screening a microarray containing 29,127 linear peptides. Western blot and ELISAs were used to confirm binding and explore human serum targeting. Autoimmune targeting was further interrogated on a yeast-displayed human protein microarray.

Results

76Canc specifically recognized a number of acidic peptides. Meme analysis identified a peptide sequence similar to a non-structural protein of Hepacivirus previously implicated in Kawasaki disease (KD). Binding was confirmed to top peptides, including the Hepacivirus-related and KD-related peptide. On serum competitions studies using samples from children with KD compared to controls, targeting of this epitope showed no specific correlation to having KD. Human protein autoantigen screening was also reassuring.

Conclusions

This study identifies a peptide that can mimic the gp41 epitope targeted by 76C group antibodies (i.e. a mimotope). We show little risk of autoimmune targeting including any inflammation similar to KD, implying non-specific targeting of this peptide during KD. Development of such peptides as the basis for vaccination should proceed cautiously.

Identification of Anti-gp41 Monoclonal Antibodies That Effectively Target Cytotoxic Immunoconjugates to Cells Infected with Human Immunodeficiency Virus, Type 1

We are developing cytotoxic immunoconjugates (CICs) targeting the envelope protein (Env) of the Human Immunodeficiency Virus, type 1 (HIV) to purge the persistent reservoirs of viral infection. We have previously studied the ability of multiple monoclonal antibodies (mAbs) to deliver CICs to an HIV-infected cell. We have found that CICs targeted to the membrane-spanning gp41 domain of Env are most efficacious, in part because their killing is enhanced in the presence of soluble CD4. The ability of a mAb to deliver a CIC does not correlate with its ability to neutralize nor mediate Ab-dependent cellular cytotoxicity. In the current study, we seek to define the most effective anti-gp41 mAbs for delivering CICs to HIV-infected cells. To do this, we have evaluated a panel of human anti-gp41 mAbs for their ability to bind and kill two different Env-expressing cell lines: persistently infected H9/NL4-3 and constitutively transfected HEK293/92UG. We measured the binding and cytotoxicity of each mAb in the presence and absence of soluble CD4. We found that mAbs to the immunodominant helix-loop-helix region (ID-loop) of gp41 are most effective, whereas neutralizing mAbs to the fusion peptide, gp120/gp41 interface, and the membrane proximal external region (MPER) are relatively ineffective at delivering CICs. There was only a weak correlation between antigen exposure and killing activity. The results show that the ability to deliver an effective IC and neutralization are distinct functions of mAbs.

Highly mutated monoclonal antibody 3F2 targets a conformational and strain-restricted epitope in human immunodeficiency virus gp41 with significant antibody-dependent cell cytotoxicity

Identifying epitope targets by studying the native antibody (Ab) response can identify potential novel vaccine constructs. Studies suggest that long-term non-progressor (LTNP) subjects have inherent immune mechanisms that help to control viremia and disease progression. To explore a role for antibodies (Abs) in LTNP progression, our lab has previously characterized a number of highly mutated Abs that target conformational epitopes of the human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) envelope protein from a single LTNP subject (10076). One Ab clone, 10076-Q3-2C6, had significant cross-clade Ab-dependent cell cytotoxicity. To assess if other LTNP subjects produced similar Abs, we expressed another highly mutated Ab from another subject; subject 10002, clone 10002-Q1-3F2 (variable heavy chain, 63.2% amino acid sequence identity to predicted germline). After expression with its native light chain, the recombinant Ab 3F2 bound to the trimeric envelope protein of HIV (trimer), as well as to the ectodomain of gp41. 3F2 binding to gp41 peptide libraries was consistent with non-linear epitope binding and showed possible overlap with the epitope of 2C6. Ab competition assays suggested that 3F2 may bind near the immunodominant epitope 1 loop region (ID1) of gp41. 2C6 blocked the binding of ID1-loop-binding Abs and 3F2 to the trimer, but 3F2 failed to block 2C6 binding. Together, these results suggest that 3F2 binds to a non-linear conformational epitope primarily localized between the epitope of 2C6 and the ID1. Since they are targeted by functional Abs, a more complete understanding of these ID1 and near-ID1 epitopes may be exploited in future immunization strategies.

Humoral cross-coronavirus responses against the S2 region in children with Kawasaki disease

Multisystem Inflammatory Syndrome in Children (MIS-C), a post infectious complication of SARS CoV-2 infection, shares enough features with Kawasaki Disease (KD) that some have hypothesized cross-coronavirus (CoV) immunity may explain the shared pathology. Recent studies have shown that humoral cross-reactivity of the CoVs, particularly of OC43, is focused on the S2 region of the Spike protein.

Due to efforts utilizing CoV S2 regions to produce a cross-CoV vaccine, we wished to assess SARS-CoV-2 S2 reactivity in children with KD and assess if cardiac involvement in KD correlated with S2 CoV antibody targeting. The presence of cross-reactivity does not distinguish KD from febrile controls and does not correlate with cardiac involvement in KD. These findings support that, in relation to cardiac vascular inflammation, vaccines targeting the S2 region appear to be a safe approach, but there is disparity in the ability of CoV species to raise cross-reactive S2 targeted antibodies.

Antibody dependent cell cytotoxicity is maintained by the unmutated common ancestor of 6F5, a Gp41 conformational epitope targeting antibody that utilizes heavy chain VH1-2

In studies on monoclonal IgG antibodies (mAbs) from long-term non-progressors (LTNPs), our laboratory has previously described highly mutated Abs against a complex conformational epitope with contributions from both gp41 the N terminal and C terminal heptad repeat helices. Despite using the VH1-2 gene segment, known to contribute to some of the broadest neutralizing Abs against HIV, members of these Abs, termed group 76C Abs, did not exhibit broad neutralization. Because of the high number of mutations and use of VH1-2, our goal was to characterize the non-neutralizing functions of Abs of group 76C, to assess if targeting of the epitope correlates with LTNP, and to assess the maturation of these Abs by comparison to their predicted common ancestor. Serum competition assays showed group 76C Abs were enriched in LTNPs, in comparison to VRC-01. Specific group 76C clones 6F5 and 6F11, expressed as recombinant Abs, both have robust ADCC activity, despite their sequence disparity. Sequence analysis predicted the common ancestor of this clonal group would utilize the germline non-mutated variable gene. We produced a recombinant ancestor Ab (76Canc) with a heavy chain utilizing the germline variable gene sequence paired to the 6F5 light chain. Competition with group 76C recombinant Ab 6F5 confirms 76Canc binds HIV envelope constructs near the original group C epitope. 76Canc demonstrates comparable ADCC to 6F5 and 6F11 when using gp41 constructs of both clade B and clade C. The functional capability of Abs utilizing germline VH1-2 has implications for disease control and vaccine development.

Clonal expansion and markers of directed mutation of IGHV4-34 B cells in plasmablasts during Kawasaki disease

Kawasaki disease (KD) is the leading cause of acquired heart disease in children. The cause remains unknown; however, epidemiologic and demographic data support a single preceding infectious agent may lead to KD. A variety of pathophysiologic responses have been proposed, including direct invasion of the coronary arteries, a superantigen response, and a post-infectious autoimmune phenomenon. A role for B cell responses during KD are supported by numerous findings including B cell specific markers identified in genome wide association studies. We have recently published data showing children with KD have similar plasmablast (PB) responses to children with infections. Since during other infections, cells expressing antibodies against the preceding infection are enriched in PBs, we sought to explore the specific antibodies encoded by PBs during KD. In one child we see a massive expansion in IGHV4-34 utilizing antibodies, which has been associated with autoimmunity in the past. We further explored this expansion of IGHV4-34 utilization during the peripheral PB rise with next generation sequencing (NGS) analysis and utilizing newer techniques of chromium chip single cell separation (10x Genomics®). We also utilized peptide array screening to attempt to identify an antigen to the most prolific clones.

B Cell Receptor Repertoire Analysis in Malaria-Naive and Malaria-Experienced Individuals Reveals Unique Characteristics of Atypical Memory B Cells

Malaria, caused by parasites of the Plasmodium genus, is responsible for significant morbidity and mortality globally. Chronic Plasmodium falciparum exposure affects the B cell compartment, leading to the accumulation of atypical memory B cells (atMBCs). IgM-positive (IgM+) and IgG+ atMBCs have not been compared in-depth in the context of malaria, nor is it known if atMBCs in malaria-experienced individuals are different from phenotypically similar B cells in individuals with no known history of Plasmodium exposure. To address these questions, we characterized the B cell receptor (BCR) repertoire of naive B cells (NBCs), IgM+ and IgG+ classical MBCs (cMBCs), and IgM+ and IgG+ atMBCs from 13 malaria-naive American adults and 7 malaria-experienced Ugandan adults. Our results demonstrate that P. falciparum exposure mainly drives changes in atMBCs. In comparison to malaria-naive adults, the BCR repertoire of Plasmodium-exposed adults showed increased levels of somatic hypermutation in the heavy chain V region in IgM+ and IgG+ atMBCs, shorter heavy chain complementarity-determining region 3 (HCDR3) in IgG+ atMBCs, and increased usage of IGHV3-73 in IgG+ cMBCs and both IgM+ and IgG+ atMBCs. Irrespective of Plasmodium exposure, IgM+ atMBCs closely resembled NBCs, while IgG+ atMBCs resembled IgG+ cMBCs. Physicochemical properties of the HCDR3 seemed to be intrinsic to cell type and independent of malaria experience. The resemblance between atMBCs from Plasmodium-exposed and naive adults suggests similar differentiation pathways regardless of chronic antigen exposure. Moreover, these data demonstrate that IgM+ and IgG+ atMBCs are distinct populations that should be considered separately in future analyses. IMPORTANCE Malaria, caused by Plasmodium parasites, still contributes to a high global burden of disease, mainly in children under 5 years of age. Chronic and recurrent Plasmodium infections affect the development of B cell memory against the parasite and promote the accumulation of atypical memory B cells (atMBCs), which have an unclear function in the immune response. Understanding where these cells originate from and whether they are beneficial in the immune response to Plasmodium will help inform vaccination development efforts. We found differences in B cell receptor (BCR) properties of atMBCs between malaria-naive and malaria-experienced adults that are suggestive of divergent selection processes, resulting in more somatic hypermutation and differential immunoglobulin heavy chain V (IGHV) gene usage. Despite these differences, atMBCs from malaria-naive and malaria-experienced adults also showed many similarities in BCR characteristics, such as physicochemical properties of the HCDR3 region, suggesting that atMBCs undergo similar differentiation pathways in response to different pathogens. Our study provides new insights into the effects of malaria experience on the B cell compartment and the relationships between atMBCs and other B cell populations.

Aberrant B cell repertoire selection associated with HIV neutralizing antibody breadth

A goal of HIV vaccine development is to elicit antibodies with neutralizing breadth. Broadly neutralizing antibodies (bNAbs) to HIV often have unusual sequences with long heavy-chain complementarity-determining region loops, high somatic mutation rates and polyreactivity. A subset of HIV-infected individuals develops such antibodies, but it is unclear whether this reflects systematic differences in their antibody repertoires or is a consequence of rare stochastic events involving individual clones. We sequenced antibody heavy-chain repertoires in a large cohort of HIV-infected individuals with bNAb responses or no neutralization breadth and uninfected controls, identifying consistent features of bNAb repertoires, encompassing thousands of B cell clones per individual, with correlated T cell phenotypes. These repertoire features were not observed during chronic cytomegalovirus infection in an independent cohort. Our data indicate that the development of numerous B cell lineages with antibody features associated with autoreactivity may be a key aspect in the development of HIV neutralizing antibody breadth.

Assessment of Antibody Interference of Enfuvirtide (T20) Function Shows Assay Dependent Variability

Background:

During HIV infection, fusion of the viral and cellular membranes is dependent on folding of the gp41 trimer into a six-helix bundle. Fusion inhibitors, such as the antiretroviral Enfuvirtide (T20), interfere with the formation of the gp41 six-helix bundle. Recent in vitro studies reveal that the gp41 immunodominant region one targeting antibody 3D6 can block T20 interference, but the clinical and pathophysiologic significance of this finding is unclear.

Objective/Method:

We have previously characterized a number of antibodies that target conformational epitopes on gp41and herein characterized their ability to interfere with T20 in multiple assays and assess their prevalence in HIV infected subjects.

Results:

The T20 interference by antibody 3D6 was confirmed in a CHO-HXB2 envelope/ HeLaT4+ cell culture assay. Antibodies that target an immunodominant region one epitope, as well as a gp41 discontinuous epitope, also interfered in this assay, however, not all antibodies that targeted these epitopes showed T20 interference. This response was not due to the direct binding of T20 by the antibodies and could not be replicated utilizing TZM-bl and HL2/3 cells. Notably, serum competition studies on a panel of HIV subjects demonstrate that these conformational targeting antibodies are common in the HIV population.

Conclusion:

The relatively common nature of antibodies targeting these epitopes, the disparate in vitro results, and lack of reported clinical failures ascribed to such antibodies leads us to conclude that antibody interference of T20 is likely not clinically relevant. However, this warrants continued consideration with the advancement of other fusion inhibitors.

Monoclonal Antibody 2C6 Targets a Cross-Clade Conformational Epitope in gp41 with Highly Active Antibody-Dependent Cell Cytotoxicity

Previous studies in our laboratory characterized a panel of highly mutated HIV-specific conformational epitope-targeting antibodies (Abs) from a panel of HIV-infected long-term nonprogressors (LTNPs). Despite binding HIV envelope protein and having a high number of somatic amino acid mutations, these Abs had poor neutralizing activity. Because of the evidence of antigen-driven selection and the long CDR3 region (21 amino acids [aa]), we further characterized the epitope targeting of monoclonal Ab (MAb) 76-Q3-2C6 (2C6). We confirmed that 2C6 binds preferentially to trimeric envelope and recognizes the clades A, B, and C SOSIP trimers. 2C6 binds gp140 constructs of clades A, B, C, and D, suggesting a conserved binding site that we localized to the ectodomain of gp41. Ab competition with MAb 50-69 suggested this epitope localizes near aa 579 to 613 (referenced to HXB2 gp160). Peptide library scanning showed consistent binding in this region but to only a single peptide. Lack of overlapping peptide binding supported a nonlinear epitope structure. The significance of this site is supported by 2C6 having Ab-dependent cell cytotoxicity (ADCC) against envelope proteins from two clades. Using 2C6 and variants, alanine scanning mutagenesis identified three amino acids (aa 592, 595, and 596) in the overlapping region of the previously identified peptide. Additional amino acids at sites 524 and 579 were also identified, helping explain its conformational requirement. The fact that different amino acids were included in the epitope depending on the targeted protein supports the conclusion that 2C6 targets a native conformational epitope. When we mapped these amino acids on the trimerized structure, they spanned across oligomers, supporting the notion that the epitope targeted by 2C6 lies in a recessed pocket between two gp41 oligomers. A complete understanding of the epitope specificity of ADCC-mediating Abs is essential for developing effective immunization strategies that optimize protection by these Abs.IMPORTANCE This paper further defines the function and area of the HIV trimeric envelope protein targeted by the monoclonal antibody 2C6. 2C6 binding is influenced by amino acid mutations across two separate gp41 sections of the envelope trimer. This epitope is recognized on multiple clades (variant groups of circulating viruses) of gp41, gp140 trimers, and SOSIP trimers. For the clades tested, 2C6 has robust ADCC. As the target of 2C6 is available in the major clades of HIV and has robust ADCC activity, further definition and appreciation of targeting of antibodies similar to 2C6 during vaccine development should be considered.

Identification of HIV gp41-specific antibodies that mediate killing of infected cells

Antibodies that mediate killing of HIV-infected cells through antibody-dependent cellular cytotoxicity (ADCC) have been implicated in protection from HIV infection and disease progression. Despite these observations, these types of HIV antibodies are understudied compared to neutralizing antibodies. Here we describe four monoclonal antibodies (mAbs) obtained from one individual that target the HIV transmembrane protein, gp41, and mediate ADCC activity. These four mAbs arose from independent B cell lineages suggesting that in this individual, multiple B cell responses were induced by the gp41 antigen. Competition and phage peptide display mapping experiments suggested that two of the mAbs target epitopes in the cysteine loop that are highly conserved and a common target of HIV gp41-specific antibodies. The amino acid sequences that bind these mAbs are overlapping but distinct. The two other mAbs were competed by mAbs that target the C-terminal heptad repeat (CHR) and the fusion peptide proximal region (FPPR) and appear to both target a similar unique conformational epitope. These gp41-specific mAbs mediated killing of infected cells that express high levels of Env due to either pre-treatment with interferon or deletion of vpu to increase levels of BST-2/Tetherin. They also mediate killing of target cells coated with various forms of the gp41 protein, including full-length gp41, gp41 ectodomain or a mimetic of the gp41 stump. Unlike many ADCC mAbs that target HIV gp120, these gp41-mAbs are not dependent on Env structural changes associated with membrane-bound CD4 interaction. Overall, the characterization of these four new mAbs that target gp41 and mediate ADCC provides evidence for diverse gp41 B cell lineages with overlapping but distinct epitopes within an individual. Such antibodies that can target various forms of envelope protein could represent a common response to a relatively conserved HIV epitope for a vaccine.

Human Antibodies that Recognize Novel Immunodominant Quaternary Epitopes on the HIV-1 Env Protein

Numerous broadly neutralizing antibodies (Abs) target epitopes that are formed or enhanced during mature HIV envelope formation (i.e. quaternary epitopes). Generally, it is thought that Env epitopes that induce broadly neutralizing Abs are difficult to access and poorly immunogenic because of the characteristic oligomerization, conformational flexibility, sequence diversity and extensive glycosylation of Env protein. To enhance for isolation of quaternary epitope-targeting Abs (QtAbs), we previously used HIV virus-like particles (VLPs) to bind B cells from long-term non-progressor subjects to identify a panel of monoclonal Abs. When expressed as recombinant full-length Abs, a subset of these novel Abs exhibited the binding profiles of QtAbs, as they either failed to bind to monomeric Env protein or showed much higher affinity for Env trimers and VLPs. These QtAbs represented a significant proportion of the B-cell response identified with VLPs. The Ab genes of these clones were highly mutated, but they did not neutralize common HIV strains. We sought to further define the epitopes targeted by these QtAbs. Competition-binding and mapping studies revealed these Abs targeted four separate epitopes; they also failed to compete for binding by Abs to known major neutralizing epitopes. Detailed epitope mapping studies revealed that two of the four epitopes were located in the gp41 subunit of Env. These QtAbs bound pre-fusion forms of antigen and showed differential binding kinetics depending on whether oligomers were produced as recombinant gp140 trimers or as full-length Env incorporated into VLPs. Antigenic regions within gp41 present unexpectedly diverse structural epitopes, including these QtAb epitopes, which may be targeted by the naturally occurring Ab response to HIV infection.