Ozone exposure- and flux-based response relationships with photosynthesis of winter wheat under fully open air condition

Alteration of carbon and nitrogen allocation in winter wheat under elevated ozone

Tropospheric ozone accelerates senescence and shortens grain filling, consequently affecting the remobilization and allocation efficiency of aboveground biomass and nutrients into grains in cereal crops. This study investigated carbon (C) and nitrogen (N) concentrations repeatedly in shoot biomass during the growth period and in grain after the harvest in eighteen wheat genotypes under control and ozone treatments in open-top chambers. Season-long ozone fumigation was conducted at an average ozone concentration of 70 ppb with three additional acute ozone episodes of around 150 ppb. Although there were no significant differences in straw C and N concentrations between the two treatments, the straw C:N ratio was significantly increased after long-term ozone fumigation, and the grain C:N ratio decreased under elevated ozone without significance. Grain N concentrations increased significantly under ozone stress, whereas N yield declined significantly due to grain yield losses induced by ozone. Moreover, different indicators of N use efficiency were significantly reduced with the exception of N utilization efficiency (NUtE), indicating that elevated ozone exposure reduced the N absorption from soil and allocation from vegetative to reproductive organs. The linear regression between straw C:N ratio and productivity indicated that straw C:N was not a suitable trait for predicting wheat productivity due to the low coefficient of determination (R2). Nitrogen harvest index (NHI) was not significantly affected by ozone stress among all genotypes. However, elevated ozone concentration changed the relationship between harvest index (HI) and NHI, and the reduced regression slope between them indicated that ozone exposure significantly affected the relationship of N and biomass allocation into wheat grains. The cultivar "Jenga" showed optimal ozone tolerance due to less yield reduction and higher NUE after ozone exposure. The genotypes with higher nutrient use efficiencies are promising to cope with ozone-induced changes in nitrogen partitioning.

Sensitivity of agricultural crops to tropospheric ozone: a review of Indian researches

Tropospheric ozone (O₃) is a long-range transboundary secondary air pollutant, causing significant damage to agricultural crops worldwide. There are substantial spatial variations in O₃ concentration in different areas of India due to seasonal and geographical variations. The Indo-Gangetic Plain (IGP) region is one of the most crop productive and air-polluted regions in India. The concentration of tropospheric O₃ over the IGP is increasing by 6-7.2% per decade. The annual trend of increase is 0.4 ± 0.25% year^-1 over the Northeastern IGP. High O₃ concentrations were reported during the summer, while they were at their minimum during the monsoon months. To explore future potential impacts of O₃ on major crop plants, the responses of different crops grown under ambient and elevated O₃ concentrations were compared. The studies clearly showed that O₃ is an important stress factor, negatively affecting the yield of crops. In this review, we have discussed yield losses in agricultural crops due to rising O₃ pollution and variations in O₃ sensitivity among cultivars and species. The use of ethylene diurea (EDU) as a research tool in assessing the losses in yield under ambient and elevated O₃ levels also discussed. Besides, an overview of interactive effects of O₃ and nitrogen on crop productivity has been included. Several recommendations are made for future research and policy development on rising concentration of O₃ in India.

Phenotypic variation in photosynthetic traits in wheat grown under field versus glasshouse conditions

Recognition of the untapped potential of photosynthesis to improve crop yields has spurred research to identify targets for breeding. The CO2-fixing enzyme Rubisco is characterized by a number of inefficiencies, and frequently limits carbon assimilation at the top of the canopy, representing a clear target for wheat improvement. Two bread wheat lines with similar genetic backgrounds and contrasting in vivo maximum carboxylation activity of Rubisco per unit leaf nitrogen (Vc,max,25/Narea) determined using high-throughput phenotyping methods were selected for detailed study from a panel of 80 spring wheat lines. Detailed phenotyping of photosynthetic traits in the two lines using glasshouse-grown plants showed no difference in Vc,max,25/Narea determined directly via in vivo and in vitro methods. Detailed phenotyping of glasshouse-grown plants of the 80 wheat lines also showed no correlation between photosynthetic traits measured via high-throughput phenotyping of field-grown plants. Our findings suggest that the complex interplay between traits determining crop productivity and the dynamic environments experienced by field-grown plants needs to be considered in designing strategies for effective wheat crop yield improvement when breeding for particular environments.

Potential involvement of proline and flavonols in plant responses to ozone

Ozone is considered to be a major phytotoxic pollutant. It is an oxidizing molecule with harmful effects that can affect human health and vegetation. Due to its phytotoxicity, it constitutes a threat to food security in a context of climate change. Proline accumulation is induced in response to numerous stresses and is assumed to be involved in plant antioxidant defense. We therefore addressed the question of the putative involvement of proline in plant ozone responses by analyzing the responses of two Arabidopsis mutants (obtained in the Col-0 genetic background) altered in proline metabolism and different ecotypes with various degrees of ozone sensitivity, to controlled ozone treatments. Among the mutants, the p5cs1 mutant plants accumulated less proline than the double prodh1xprodh2 (p1p2) mutants. Ozone treatments did not induce accumulation of proline in Col-0 nor in the mutant plants. However, the variation of the photosynthetic parameter Fv/Fm in the p1p2 mutant suggests a positive effect of proline. Proline accumulation induced by ozone was only observed in the most ozone-sensitive ecotypes, Cvi-0 and Ler. Contrary to our expectations, proline accumulation could not be correlated with variations in protein oxidation (carbonylation). On the other hand, flavonols content, measured here, using non-destructive methods, reflected exactly the genotypes ranking according to ozone sensitivity.

Wheat Cultivar Growth, Biochemical, Physiological and Yield Attributes Response to Combined Exposure to Tropospheric Ozone, Particulate Matter Deposition and Ascorbic Acid Application

In the present study wheat (Triticum aestivum) cultivar HD 2967 was exposed to ambient and elevated levels of O₃ and PM deposition, with and without exogenous application of ascorbic acid (AA). Cultivar HD 2967 exposed to eight treatments in free air O₃ enrichment facility and the assessed results showed that wheat cultivar, growth, biochemical, physiological and yield attributes were variably but adversely affected by combined exposure to O₃ and PM deposition. PM deposition clogged stomata and enhanced leaf temperature. However, plants exposed to O₃ and PM deposition and treated with AA exhibited less reduction in yield as compared to plants exposed to O₃ and PM deposition without AA treatment. The decline in grain yield of HD 2967 due to combined exposure of O₃ and PM deposition were in the range of 4%-17%. AA spray partially mitigated ozone and PM deposition adverse impact and enhanced wheat yield by 16%.

Combined Acute Ozone and Water Stress Alters the Quantitative Relationships between O3 Uptake, Photosynthetic Characteristics and Volatile Emissions in Brassica nigra

Ozone (O₃) entry into plant leaves depends on atmospheric O₃ concentration, exposure time and openness of stomata. O₃ negatively impacts photosynthesis rate (A) and might induce the release of reactive volatile organic compounds (VOCs) that can quench O₃, and thereby partly ameliorate O₃ stress. Water stress reduces stomatal conductance (g_s) and O₃ uptake and can affect VOC release and O₃ quenching by VOC, but the interactive effects of O₃ exposure and water stress, as possibly mediated by VOC, are poorly understood. Well-watered (WW) and water-stressed (WS) Brassica nigra plants were exposed to 250 and 550 ppb O₃ for 1 h, and O₃ uptake rates, photosynthetic characteristics and VOC emissions were measured through 22 h recovery. The highest O₃ uptake was observed in WW plants exposed to 550 ppb O₃ with the greatest reduction and poorest recovery of g_s and A, and elicitation of lipoxygenase (LOX) pathway volatiles 10 min-1.5 h after exposure indicating cellular damage. Ozone uptake was similar in 250 ppb WW and 550 ppb WS plants and, in both treatments, O₃-dependent reduction in photosynthetic characteristics was moderate and fully reversible, and VOC emissions were little affected. Water stress alone did not affect the total amount and composition of VOC emissions. The results indicate that drought ameliorated O₃ stress by reducing O₃ uptake through stomatal closure and the two stresses operated in an antagonistic manner in B. nigra.

Toward an impact assessment of ozone on plant carbon fixation using a process-based plant growth model: A case study of Fagus crenata grown under different soil nutrient levels

Ozone (O₃) in the troposphere, an air pollutant with phytotoxicity, is considered as a driver of global warming, because it reduces plant carbon fixation. Recently, a process-based plant growth model has been used in evaluating the O₃ impacts on plants (Schauberger et al., 2019). To make the evaluation more rigorous, we developed a plant growth model and clarified the key factors driving O₃-induced change in the whole-plant carbon fixation amount (C_fix). Fagus crenata seedlings were exposed to three O₃ levels (charcoal-filtered air or 1.0- or 1.5-folds ambient [O₃]) with three soil fertilization levels (non-, low-, or high-fertilized), i.e., a total of nine treatments. The C_fix was reduced in non- and low-fertilized treatments but was unaffected in high-fertilized treatment by O₃ fumigation. Our plant growth model could simulate C_fix accurately (<10% error) by considering the impacts of O₃ on plant leaf area and photosynthetic capacities, including maximum velocities of carboxylation and electron transport (V_cmax and J_max, respectively), and the initial slope and convexity of the curve of the electron transport velocity response to photosynthetic photon flux density (φ and θ, respectively). Furthermore, the model revealed that changes in V_cmax and J_max, φ and θ, or leaf area, caused by 1.5-folds the ambient [O₃] fumigation resulted in the following C_fix changes: -1.6, -5.8, or -16.4% in non-fertilized seedlings, -4.1, -4.4, or -9.3% in low-fertilized seedlings, and -4.6, -7.6, or +5.8% in high-fertilized seedlings. Therefore, photosynthetic capacities (particularly φ and θ) and leaf area are important factors influencing the impact of O₃ on C_fix of F. crenata seedlings grown under various fertilization levels. Further, the impacts of O₃ and soil nutrient on these photosynthetic capacities and plant leaf area should be considered to predict O₃-induced changes in carbon fixation by forest tree species using the process-based plant growth model.

Effect of water deficit stress on an Indian wheat cultivar (Triticum aestivum L. HD 2967) under ambient and elevated level of ozone

The response of a wheat cultivar (HD 2967) under the combination of elevated ozone (O₃) and water deficit stress (WS) was evaluated in terms of morphological, physiological and yield parameters along with nutrient uptake and their redistribution to different plant parts. An open-top chamber experiment has been conducted under O₃ exposures (ambient (A) and ambient +20 ppb O₃ (E)) along with two different water regimes (well-watered; WW and water deficit with 50% of soil capacity; WS). Most of the growth parameters showed significant reductions due to elevated O₃ under both WW and WS conditions. Stomatal conductance and assimilation rate reduced significantly under the combined stress as compared to their controls (AWW). The maximum decrease in grain yield was observed under the additive effect of both the stresses of water deficit and elevated O₃ (-43.6%), followed by water deficit stress (-19.8%) and elevated O₃ (-17.9%) as compared to the control (AWW). Furthermore, the study displayed that reduced water availability has checked the uptake of nutrients in the roots, shoot and leaves, while, a higher carbon accumulation has been observed with subsequent increases in C: N and C: K ratios in the leaves. Such limitation of nutrients uptake and photosynthates availability weakened the antioxidative defense system of the test cultivar, making it more sensitive against combined stresses. Besides, the study displayed that the defense system has been remarkably suppressed under the presence of interactive stress factors, which allowed us to predict that the distribution of limited carbon pool has inverse relationship between the plant's defense system and growth.

Photons to food: genetic improvement of cereal crop photosynthesis

Photosynthesis has become a major trait of interest for cereal yield improvement as breeders appear to have reached the theoretical genetic limit for harvest index, the mass of grain as a proportion of crop biomass. Yield improvements afforded by the adoption of green revolution dwarfing genes to wheat and rice are becoming exhausted, and improvements in biomass and radiation use efficiency are now sought in these crops. Exploring genetic diversity in photosynthesis is now possible using high-throughput techniques, and low-cost genotyping facilitates discovery of the genetic architecture underlying this variation. Photosynthetic traits have been shown to be highly heritable, and significant variation is present for these traits in available germplasm. This offers hope that breeding for improved photosynthesis and radiation use efficiency in cereal crops is tractable and a useful shorter term adjunct to genetic and genome engineering to boost yield potential.

Genetic variation for photosynthetic capacity and efficiency in spring wheat

One way to increase yield potential in wheat is screening for natural variation in photosynthesis. This study uses measured and modelled physiological parameters to explore genotypic diversity in photosynthetic capacity (Pc, Rubisco carboxylation capacity per unit leaf area at 25 °C) and efficiency (Peff, Pc per unit of leaf nitrogen) in wheat in relation to fertilizer, plant stage, and environment. Four experiments (Aus1, Aus2, Aus3, and Mex1) were carried out with diverse wheat collections to investigate genetic variation for Rubisco capacity (Vcmax25), electron transport rate (J), CO2 assimilation rate, stomatal conductance, and complementary plant functional traits: leaf nitrogen, leaf dry mass per unit area, and SPAD. Genotypes for Aus1 and Aus2 were grown in the glasshouse with two fertilizer levels. Genotypes for Aus3 and Mex1 experiments were grown in the field in Australia and Mexico, respectively. Results showed that Vcmax25 derived from gas exchange measurements is a robust parameter that does not depend on stomatal conductance and was positively correlated with Rubisco content measured in vitro. There was significant genotypic variation in most of the experiments for Pc and Peff. Heritability of Pc reached 0.7 and 0.9 for SPAD. Genotypic variation and heritability of traits show that there is scope for these traits to be used in pre-breeding programmes to improve photosynthesis with the ultimate objective of raising yield potential.

Effects of ozone on maize (Zea mays L.) photosynthetic physiology, biomass and yield components based on exposure- and flux-response relationships

Since the Industrial Revolution, the global ambient O3 concentration has more than doubled. Negative impact of O3 on some common crops such as wheat and soybeans has been widely recognized, but there is relatively little information about maize, the typical C4 plant and third most important crop worldwide. To partly compensate this knowledge gap, the maize cultivar (Zhengdan 958, ZD958) with maximum planting area in China was exposed to a range of chronic ozone (O3) exposures in open top chambers (OTCs). The O3 effects on this highly important crop were estimated in relation to two O3 metrics, AOT40 (accumulated hourly O3 concentration over a threshold of 40 ppb during daylight hours) and POD6 (Phytotoxic O3 Dose above a threshold flux of 6 nmol O3 m-2 s-1 during a specified period). We found that (1) the reduced light-saturated net photosynthetic rate (Asat) mainly caused by non-stomatal limitations across heading and grain filling stages, but the stomatal limitations at the former stage were stronger than those at the latter stage; (2) impact of O3 on water use efficiency (WUE) of maize was significantly dependent on developmental stage; (3) yield loss induced by O3 was mainly due to a reduction in kernels weight rather than in the number of kernels; (4) the performance of AOT40 and POD6 was similar, according to their determination coefficients (R2); (5) the order of O3 sensitivity among different parameters was photosynthetic parameters > biomass parameters > yield-related parameters; (6) Responses of Asat to O3 between heading and gran filling stages were significantly different based on AOT40 metric, but not POD6. The proposed O3 metrics-response relationships will be valuable for O3 risk assessment in Asia and also for crop productivity models including the influence of O3.

Ozone exposure- and flux-yield response relationships for maize

A stomatal ozone (O₃) flux-response relationship for relative yield of maize was established by parameterizing a Jarvis stomatal conductance model. For the function (f_VPD) describing the limitation of stomatal conductance by vapor pressure deficit (VPD, kPa), cumulative VPD during daylight hours was superior to hourly VPD. The latter function is proposed as a methodological improvement of this multiplicative model when stomatal conductance peaks during the morning and it is reduced later as it is the case of maize in this experiment. The model agreed relatively well with the measured stomatal conductance (R² = 0.63). Based on the comparison of R² values of the response functions, POD₆ (Phytotoxic Ozone Dose over an hourly threshold 6 nmol m^-2 s^-1) and AOT40 (accumulated hourly O₃ concentrations over a threshold of 40 ppb) performed similarly. The critical levels based on POD₆ and AOT40 for 5% reduction in maize yield were 1.17 mmol m^-2 PLA and 8.70 ppm h, respectively. In comparison with other important crops, the ranking of sensitivity of maize strongly differed depending on the O₃ metric used, AOT40 or POD₆. The newly proposed response functions are relevant for O₃ risk assessment for this crop in Asia.

Predicting the effect of ozone on vegetation via linear non-threshold (LNT), threshold and hormetic dose-response models

The nature of the dose-response relationship in the low dose zone and how this concept may be used by regulatory agencies for science-based policy guidance and risk assessment practices are addressed here by using the effects of surface ozone (O₃) on plants as a key example for dynamic ecosystems sustainability. This paper evaluates the current use of the linear non-threshold (LNT) dose-response model for O₃. The LNT model has been typically applied in limited field studies which measured damage from high exposures, and used to estimate responses to lower concentrations. This risk assessment strategy ignores the possibility of biological acclimation to low doses of stressor agents. The upregulation of adaptive responses by low O₃ concentrations typically yields pleiotropic responses, with some induced endpoints displaying hormetic-like biphasic dose-response relationships. Such observations recognize the need for risk assessment flexibility depending upon the endpoints measured, background responses, as well as possible dose-time compensatory responses. Regulatory modeling strategies would be significantly improved by the adoption of the hormetic dose response as a formal/routine risk assessment option based on its substantial support within the literature, capacity to describe the entire dose-response continuum, documented explanatory dose-dependent mechanisms, and flexibility to default to a threshold feature when background responses preclude application of biphasic dose responses.

CAPSULE

The processes of ozone hazard and risk assessment can be enhanced by incorporating hormesis into their principles and practices.