Arsenic volatilization in flooded paddy soil by the addition of Fe-Mn-modified biochar composites

A review on As-contaminated soil remediation using waste biomass feedstock-based biochar and metal-modified biochar

Arsenic (As) is a carcinogen that threatens ecosystems and human health. Due to its high adsorption, and microporosity, biochar is widely available for soil remediation. This review significantly summarizes the current status of waste biomass feedstock-based biochar and metal-modified biochar for As-contaminated soil remediation. Firstly, this paper briefly describes the sources and hazards of As in soil, and secondly, lists eleven feedstocks for preparing biochar. Agricultural, domestic, and forestry wastes provide a plentiful source for biochar preparation. Single or multi-metal modifications such as iron (Fe), manganese (Mn), and cerium (Ce) can effectively improve the Arsenite [As(III)] and arsenate [As(V)] adsorption capacity of biochar. The primary mechanisms of As removal by waste biomass feedstock-based biochar and metal-modified biochar include ion exchange, electrostatic attraction, surface complexation, redox transformation, and H-bond formation. In conclusion, this review presents an in-depth discussion on both waste biomass feedstocks and metal modification, providing constructive suggestions for the future development of biochar to remediate As-contaminated soil.

Remediation of antimony and arsenic in co-contaminated soil by electrolytic manganese residue-biochar composite: Effects, mechanisms, and microbial response

Antimony (Sb) mining and smelting activities caused Sb and arsenic (As) pollution in the soil, posing a threat to the ecosystem and human health. To remediate Sb and As in co-contaminated soil and realize the resource utilization of typical industrial solid waste, electrolytic manganese residue (EMR)-biochar composite (EB) was prepared from EMR and distillers grains by a facile one-step pyrolysis method. The immobilization effect of EB on Sb and As in soil was studied using a column leaching experiment. Pot and soil incubation experiments were conducted to investigate the effects of EB on the bioavailability of Sb/As and microbial communities. The results showed that 4 wt% EB treatment reduced the accumulated contents of Sb and As in leachates by 29.21%-55.65% and 53.51%-68.95%, respectively, compared with the control. EB treatment (1 wt%) improved plant height, root length, phytomass, and chlorophyll content of Brassica campestris L. Compared to the untreated soils, 4 wt% EB treatment increased the well-crystallized hydrous oxides and residual fractions of Sb and As by 4.29%-6.23% and 4.09%-7.03%, respectively. The concentrations of bioavailable Sb and As in soil were reduced by 48.01%-71.92% and 52.31%-53.81%, respectively. EB interacted with As/Sb-resistant dominant microorganisms such as Proteobacteria in the soil, promoted their growth, and enhanced the immobilization of Sb/As. EB increased the relative abundance of redox-related bacteria of Sb and As (Thiobacillus and Sulfuriferula) by affecting soil EC and bioavailable Sb/As. The immobilization of As and Sb by EB include complexation, hydrogen bonding, and pore filling. These findings provide novel insights into the remediation of Sb and As co-contaminated soils.

Advancing modified biochar for sustainable agriculture: a comprehensive review on characterization, analysis, and soil performance

Biochar is a carbon-rich material produced through the pyrolysis of various feedstocks. It can be further modified to enhance its properties and is referred to as modified biochar (MB). The research interest in MB application in soil has been on the surge over the past decade. However, the potential benefits of MB are considerable, and its efficiency can be subject to various influencing factors. For instance, unknown physicochemical characteristics, outdated analytical techniques, and a limited understanding of soil factors that could impact its effectiveness after application. This paper reviewed the recent literature pertaining to MB and its evolved physicochemical characteristics to provide a comprehensive understanding beyond synthesis techniques. These include surface area, porosity, alkalinity, pH, elemental composition, and functional groups. Furthermore, it explored innovative analytical methods for characterizing these properties and evaluating their effectiveness in soil applications. In addition to exploring the potential benefits and limitations of utilizing MB as a soil amendment, this article delved into the soil factors that influence its efficacy, along with the latest research findings and advancements in MB technology. Overall, this study will facilitate the synthesis of current knowledge and the identification of gaps in our understanding of MB.

Graphical Abstract

Recent developments in modification of biochar and its application in soil pollution control and ecoregulation

Soil pollution has become a real threat to mankind in the 21st century. On the one hand, soil pollution has reduced the world's arable land area, resulting in the contradiction between the world's population expansion and the shortage of arable land. On the other hand, soil pollution has seriously disrupted the soil ecological balance and significantly affected the biodiversity in the soil. Soil pollutants may further affect the survival, reproduction and health of humans and other organisms through the food chain. Several studies have suggested that biochar has the potential to act as a soil conditioner and to promote crop growth, and is widely used to remove environmental pollutants. Biochar modified by physical, chemical, and biological methods will affect the treatment efficiency of soil pollution, soil quality, soil ecology and interaction with organisms, especially with microorganisms. Therefore, in this review, we summarized several main biochar modification methods and the mechanisms of the modification and introduced the effects of the application of modified biochar to soil pollutant control, soil ecological regulation and soil nutrient regulation. We also introduced some case studies for the development of modified biochars suitable for different soil conditions, which plays a guiding role in the future development and application of modified biochar. In general, this review provides a reference for the green treatment of different soil pollutants by modified biochar and provides data support for the sustainable development of agriculture.

A review of pristine and modified biochar immobilizing typical heavy metals in soil: Applications and challenges

In recent years, the application of biochar in the remediation of heavy metals (HMs) contaminated soil has received tremendous attention globally. We reviewed the latest research on the immobilization of soil HMs by biochar almost in the last 5 years (until 2021). The methods, effects and mechanisms of biochar and modified biochar on the immobilization of typical HMs in soil have been systematically summarized. In general, the HMs contaminating the soil can be categorized into two groups, the oxy-anionic HMs (As and Cr) and the cationic HMs (Pb, Cd, etc.). Reduction and precipitation of oxy-anionic HMs by biochar/modified biochar are the dominant mechanism for reducing HMs toxicity. Pristine biochar can effectively immobilize cationic HMs. The commonly applied modification method is to add substances that can precipitate HMs to the biochar. In addition, we assessed the risks of biochar applications. For instance, biochar may cause the leaching of certain HMs; biochar aging; co-transportation of biochar nanoparticles with HMs. Future work should focus on the artificial/intelligent design of biochar to make it suitable for remediation of multiple HMs contaminated soil.

Inhibition of methanogenesis leads to accumulation of methylated arsenic species and enhances arsenic volatilization from rice paddy soil

Flooded soils are important environments for the biomethylation and subsequent volatilization of arsenic (As), a contaminant of global concern. Conversion of inorganic to methylated oxyarsenic species is thought to be the rate-limiting step in the production and emission of volatile (methyl)arsines. While methanogens and sulfate-reducing bacteria (SRB) have been identified as important regulators of methylated oxyarsenic concentrations in anaerobic soils, the effects of these microbial groups on biovolatilization remain unclear. Here, microcosm and batch incubation experiments with an Arkansas, USA, rice paddy soil were performed in conjunction with metabolic inhibition to test the effects of methanogenic activity on As speciation and biovolatilization. Inhibition of methanogenesis with 2-bromoethanesulfonate (BES) led to the accumulation of methylated oxyarsenic species, primarily dimethylarsinic acid (DMAs(V)), and a four-fold increase in As biovolatilization compared to a control soil. Our results support a conceptual model that methanogenic activity suppresses biovolatilization by enhancing As demethylation rates. This work refines understanding of biogeochemical processes regulating As biovolatilization in anaerobic soil environments, and extends recent insights into links between methanogenesis and As metabolism to soils from the mid-South United States rice production region.

Goethite modified biochar simultaneously mitigates the arsenic and cadmium accumulation in paddy rice (Oryza sativa) L

Cadmium (Cd) and arsenic (As) contamination of paddy soils is a serious global issue because of the opposite geochemical behavior of Cd and As in paddy soils. Rice plant (Oryza sativa L.) cultivation in Cd- and As- contaminated paddy soil is regarded as one of the main dietary cause of Cd and As entry in human beings. This study aimed to determine the impact of goethite-modified biochar (GB) on bioavailability of both Cd and As in Cd- and As- polluted paddy soil. Contrary to control and biochar (BC) amendments, the application of GB amendments significantly impeded the accumulation of both Cd and As in rice plants. The results confirmed an obvious reduction in Cd and As content of rice grains by 85% and 77%, respectively after soil supplementation with GB 2% amendment. BC 3% application minimized the Cd uptake by 59% in the rice grains as compared to the control but exhibited a little impact on As accumulation in rice grains. Sequential extraction results displayed an increase in immobile Cd and As fractions of the soil by decreasing the bioavailable fractions of both elements after GB treatments. Fe-plaque formation on the root surfaces was significantly variable (P ˂ 0.05) among all the amendments. GB 2% treatment significantly increased the Fe content (10 g kg^-1) of root Fe-plaque by 48%, which ultimately enhanced the sequestration of Cd and As by Fe-plaque and minimized the transport of Cd and As in rice plants. Moreover, GB treatments significantly changed the relative abundance of the microbial community in the rice rhizosphere and minimized the metal(loid)s mobility in the soil. The relative abundance of Acidobacteria, Firmicutes and Verrucomicrobia increased with GB 2% treatment while those of Bacteroidetes and Choloroflexi decreased. Our findings confirmed improvement in the rice grains quality regarding enhanced amino acid contents with GB application. Overall, the results of this study demonstrated that GB amendment simultaneously alleviated the Cd and As concentrations in edible parts of rice plant and provided a new valuable method to protect the public health by effectively remediating the co-occurrence of Cd and As in paddy soils.

Response of soil characteristics to biochar and Fe-Mn oxide-modified biochar application in phthalate-contaminated fluvo-aquic soils

Biochar (BC) derived from agricultural biomass is effective at immobilizing phthalate in the agricultural soil environment. In this study, we assessed the effects of 0.5%, 1%, and 2% BC and Fe-Mn oxide-modified biochar (FMBC) addition on dibutyl phthalate (DBP) and di-(2-ethylhexyl) phthalate (DEHP) residues and biochemical characteristics in the rhizosphere soil of mature wheat polluted with DBP and DEHP using a pot experiment. Scanning electron microscopy showed that the surfaces and pores of BC and FMBC adhered soil mineral particles after remediation. Therefore, DBP and DEHP residues were increased in BC- and FMBC-treated soils. Illumina HiSeq sequencing showed that, compared with the control, BC and FMBC addition significantly enhanced the relative abundance of Firmicutes and reduced Proteobacteria. The abundance of Sphenodons and Pseudomonas, which degrade phthalates, tended to be higher in FMBC-amended soils than in BC-amended and control soils. This result may be related to an increase in available nutrients and organic matter following BC and FMBC application. Subsequently, the changes in soil bacterial abundance and community structure induced an increase in polyphenol oxidase, β-glucosidase, neutral phosphatase, and protease activity in BC and FMBC remediation. In comparison with the BC treatment, FMBC addition had a significantly positive effect on enzyme activity, and the microbial structure and was therefore more effective at immobilizing DBP and DEHP in the soil. Thus, our findings strongly suggest that FMBC is a reliable remediation material for phthalate-contaminated soil.

Effects of Fe-Mn impregnated biochar on enzymatic activity and bacterial community in phthalate-polluted brown soil planted with wheat

A pot experiment was carried out on brown soil polluted by dibutyl phthalate (DBP) and di-(2-ethylhexyl) phthalate (DEHP) to investigate the effects of biochar (BC) derived from corn straw and Fe-Mn oxide modified biochar composites (FMBC) on the bioavailability of DBP and DEHP, as well as ecosystem responses in rhizosphere soil after wheat ripening. The results indicate that the application of BC and FMBC significantly increases soil organic matter, pH, available nitrogen (AN), Olsen phosphorus, and available potassium (AK); reduces the bioavailability of DBP and DEHP; enhances the activities of dehydrogenase, urease, protease, β-glucosidase, and polyphenol oxidase; and decreases acid phosphatase activity. No changes in richness and diversity, which were measured by Illumina MiSeq sequencing, were observed following BC and FMBC application. The bacterial community structure and composition varied with DBP/DEHP concentrations and BC/FMBC additions in a nonsystematic way and no significant trends were observed. In addition, FMBC exhibited better performance in increasing soil properties and decreasing the bioavailability of DBP and DEHP compared with BC. Hence, the FMBC amendment may be a promising way of developing sustainable agricultural environmental management.

Effect of Fe-Mn-La-modified biochar composites on arsenic volatilization in flooded paddy soil

As can be volatilized naturally; however, this has adverse environmental effects. In this study, we investigated As volatilization in flooded paddy soil with the addition of biochar (BC) and Fe-Mn-La-modified BC composites (FMLBCs). The addition of BC and FMLBCs caused decreases in total As volatilization in the soil over 7 weeks. Maximum volatilization was achieved in the third week followed by stabilization. Volatilization decreased by 21.9%, 18.8%, 20.8%, and 31.1% with the addition of BC, FMLBC₁, FMLBC₂, and FMLBC₃ (BC/Fe/Mn/La weight ratios different), respectively, in lightly contaminated soil, and by 15.2%, 20.5%, 17.6%, and 25.4%, respectively, in highly contaminated soil. The FMLBCs decreased the exchangeable As fractions and increased the non-swappable As in the soil. Furthermore, the addition of FMLBCs significantly reduced the As(III) concentration in a suspended solution (P < 0.05), whereas no significant changes were observed in the As(V) or methyl arsenic acid concentrations. Soil enzyme activity increased and the relative abundances of Proteobacteria and Actinobacteria changed with the addition of FMLBCs. Therefore, the mechanism by which FMLBCs affected As volatilization likely included the following two aspects: (1) FMLBCs affected the transformation and distribution of soil As and decreased As dissolution, crystallization, and methylation; (2) FMLBCs influenced soil properties, which directly affected microorganism activity, thereby affecting As volatilization. FMLBCs therefore can decrease As volatilization properties and be used to control As volatilization in As-contaminated paddy soils.

Increase in arsenic methylation and volatilization during manure composting with biochar amendment in an aeration bioreactor

Biochar is widely used as an amendment to optimize the composting process. In this study, we firstly investigated the effects of biochar amendment on methylation and volatilization of arsenic (As), and the microbial communities during manure composting. Biochar amendment was found to increase the concentrations of monomethylarsonic acid (MMA) and dimethylarsinic acid (DMA) during mesophilic (days 0-10) and early thermophilic (days 11-15) phases, and promote As volatilization during the maturing phase (days 60-80) of composting. In addition, the abundances of As(V) reductase (arsC) and As(III) S-adenosyl-L-methionine methyltransferase (arsM) genes were higher in the biochar treatment than that in the control. Moreover, biochar amendment influenced the microbial communities by promoting As methylation and volatilization via Ensifer and Sphingobium carrying arsC genes, and Rhodopseudomonas and Pseudomonas carrying arsM genes. This study emphasized the considerable role of biochar on methylation and volatilization of As during manure composting and provided an overall characterization of the community compositions of arsC and arsM genes during manure composting. It will broaden our insights in As biogeochemical cycle during manure composting with biochar amendment, which will facilitate the regulation of As during manure composting and its application in agricultural soil.

Fe-Mn oxide modified biochar decreases phthalate uptake and improves grain quality of wheat grown in phthalate-contaminated fluvo-aquic soil

We used a pot experiment to investigate the effectiveness of 0.5, 1.0, and 2.0% biochar (BC) or iron-manganese oxide modified biochar (FMBC) additions on the biomass, enzyme activity, and grain quality of wheat plants grown in dibutyl phthalate (DBP) and di-(2-ethylhcxyl) phthalate (DEHP) polluted fluvo-aquic soils, as well as the bioavailability of DBP and DEHP. BC and FMBC applications significantly reduced DBP and DEHP accumulation in grains, which enhanced the content of starch and protein-related enzyme, thereby improving yield, and starch and protein content in wheat grains and increasing the content of minerals including Fe, Mn, K and Ca. Molecular docking assays showed that DBP and DEHP could bind to starch synthase (GBSS) through hydrogen bonds and intermolecular forces, which may have hindered the entry of substrates or occupied the binding sites of the reactants, thus inhibiting the activity of GBSS. In addition, FMBC treatment had a better inhibitory effect on the phytotoxicity of DBP and DEHP on wheat grain than BC treatment. This result might be attributed to the fact that FMBC has more functional groups and porous structure, and larger specific surface area. In summary, these findings contribute to our understanding of the mechanism of phthalate phytotoxicity, which may help us prevent/reduce it in the future.

Effects of Fe-Mn oxide-modified biochar composite applications on phthalate esters (PAEs) accumulation in wheat grains and grain quality under PAEs-polluted brown soil

Phthalate esters (PAEs), such as dibutyl phthalate (DBP) and di-(2-ethylhexyl) phthalate (DEHP), are used extensively as additives and plasticizers, and have become ubiquitous in the environment. PAEs in the soil could have adverse effects on crop plants as well as humans via accumulations in food chain. Thus, it is important to explore strategies to reduce the bioavailability of phthalate esters. We investigated the effects of Fe-Mn oxide-modified biochar composite (FMBC) applications on the quality of wheat grown in DBP- and DEHP-polluted brown soil. The application of FMBC and biochar (BC) increased the wheat grain biomass by 9.71-223.01% and 5.40-120.15% in the DBP-polluted soil, and 10.52-186.21% and 4.50-99.53% in the DEHP-spiked soil in comparison to the controls. All FMBC treatments were better than the BC treatments, in terms of decreasing DBP and DEHP bioavailability for the wheat grains. The activities of the glutamine synthetase and glutamic-pyruvic transaminase in the flag leaves at the filling stage and of granule-bound starch synthase, soluble starch synthase, and adenosine diphosphate-glucose pyrophosphorylase in the grains at maturity increased significantly with increases in either the BC or FMBC applications. This, in turn, increased the starch, protein, and amino acid content in the wheat grains. Compared with the BC treatment, the FMBC amendment induced only slight increases in the aforementioned factors. This study offers novel insights into potential strategies for decreasing PAEs bioavailability in soil, with potential positive implications for crop quality and environmental health improvements.

Effect of biochar addition on CO2 exchange in paddy fields under water-saving irrigation in Southeast China

Biochar has been widely applied to paddy fields to improve soil fertility, crop productivity and carbon sequestration, thereby leading to variations in the CO₂ exchange between the paddy fields under flooding irrigation and the atmosphere, as indicated by many previous reports. However, few relevant reports have focused on paddy fields under water-saving irrigation. This study conducted a field experiment to investigate the effects of three biochar addition rates (0, 20 and 40 t ha^-1) on the CO₂ exchange between paddy fields under controlled irrigation (CI, a water-saving irrigation technique) and the atmosphere in the Taihu Lake region of Southeast China. Our results showed that biochar addition increased the paddy field ecosystem respiration (R_eco) and the soil respiration rate (R_s) in the CI paddy fields. And biochar application increased the total CO₂ emissions and the total soil CO₂ emissions, especially at a rate of 40 t ha^-1. In contrast, gross primary productivity (GPP) was decreased and the net ecosystem exchange of CO₂ (NEE) was increased with biochar addition. However, biochar addition at a rate of 20 t ha^-1 significantly increased the total CO₂ absorption and the net CO₂ absorption of the CI paddy fields (p < 0.05), whereas biochar addition at a rate of 40 t ha^-1 had no effect on the total CO₂ absorption and decreased the total net CO₂ absorption. At the same time, biochar addition significantly increased soil catalase, invertase and urease activities and contributed substantially to the increase in soil invertase activity. In addition, the soil bacterial, fungal and actinomycetal abundances were evidently increased with biochar addition, of which the soil fungal abundance showed the greatest increase. A high correlation was observed between soil catalase and invertase activities and soil microbial abundance. R_eco was highly correlated with air and soil temperatures and soil enzyme activity. A significant quadratic polynomial correlation was observed between GPP and leaf area index (p < 0.01). The combination of biochar addition at a rate of 20 t ha^-1 and water-saving irrigation has the potential to increase the size of the carbon sink and promote soil enzyme and microbial activities in paddy field ecosystems.

Preparation, environmental application and prospect of biochar-supported metal nanoparticles: A review

Biochar is a low-cost, porous, and carbon-rich material and it exhibits a great potential as an adsorbent and a supporting matrix due to its high surface activity, high specific surface area, and high ion exchange capacity. Metal nanomaterials are nanometer-sized solid particles which have high reactivity, high surface area, and high surface energy. Owing to their aggregation and passivation, metal nanomaterials will lose excellent physiochemical properties. Carbon-enriched biochar can be applied to overcome these drawbacks of metal nanomaterials. Combining the advantages of biochar and metal nanomaterials, supporting metal nanomaterials on porous and stable biochar creates a new biochar-supported metal nanoparticles (MNPs@BC). Therefore, MNPs@BC can be used to design the properties of metal nanoparticles, stabilize the anchored metal nanoparticles, and facilitate the catalytic/redox reactions at the biochar-metal interfaces, which maximizes the efficiency of biochar and metal nanoparticles in environmental application. This work detailedly reviews the synthesis methods of MNPs@BC and the effects of preparation conditions on the properties of MNPs@BC during the preparation processes. The characterization methods of MNPs@BC, the removal/remediation performance of MNPs@BC for organic contaminants, heavy metals and other inorganic contaminants in water and soil, and the effect of MNPs@BC properties on the remediation efficiency were discussed. In addition, this paper summarizes the effect of various parameters on the removal of contaminants from water, the effect of MNPs@BC remediation on soil properties, and the removal/remediation mechanisms of the contaminants by MNPs@BC in water and soil. Moreover, the potential directions for future research and development of MNPs@BC have also been discussed.