Treatment of micropollutants in wastewater: Balancing effectiveness, costs and implications

Water circularity index: A novel approach for authorities and operators

The "transition to a circular economy" is frequently articulated in conventional frameworks regarding water use efficiency, predominantly emphasizing quantitative dimensions. However, water is ubiquitous, and its various applications are often directly or indirectly interlinked. Examining water quantity and quality within the water usage cycle is imperative to ensure security and optimise added value throughout the process while promoting the natural values of the surrounding environment. The present study introduces an innovative metric known as the Water Circularity Index (IC) that encompasses the complex balance between water quantity and quality throughout the water cycle at urban and industrial installation levels. The methodology for developing the IC is supported by a Multi-Criteria Decision Analysis, where key factors are divided into sub-factors categorised and weighted. The IC comprises eleven key factors, including freshwater consumption, wastewater discharge, water reuse, best management practices and technologies, hazardous substances defined under the Water Framework Directive, microplastics and emerging contaminants, biodiversity, nutrient recovery, internal industrial symbiosis, sludge management, and voluntary or incentive-based instruments. For each key factor, inputs are classified as negative, neutral, or positive, with final results categorised into five levels: negative circularity, no circularity, and low, medium, or high circularity. The index was applied to facilities across seven countries, encompassing fourteen installations across various industrial sectors and urban wastewater treatment plants, showing the versatility of the index in promoting best practices in multiple processes. In one case study involving a pulp mill, the IC was computed before and after the revision of its environmental permit. This assessment facilitated an evaluation of the measures implemented during the transition from a discharge permit aligned exclusively with the Industrial Emissions Directive principles to an integrated water management approach that integrated both directives' frameworks. The findings revealed a substantial improvement in the plant's performance, progressing from negative to medium circularity.

Mapping Emerging Contaminants in Wastewater Effluents through Multichromatographic Platform Analysis and Source Correlations

This study explores the correlation of contaminants of emerging concern (CECs) in wastewater effluents using liquid chromatography (LC), supercritical fluid chromatography (SFC), and comprehensive two-dimensional gas chromatography (GC × GC) with derivatization, all coupled to high-resolution mass spectrometry (HRMS). Over 300 compounds, including frequently overlooked highly polar and nonpharmaceutical CECs, were identified. Monitoring programs mainly focus on reducing variability and assessing pollution in wastewater treatment plant (WWTP) effluents under dry weather conditions, often neglecting wet-weather discharges. In this study, correlation analysis revealed the complex impact of rainfall on wastewater effluent composition, identifying clusters of CECs introduced through rain runoff and discharges from retention basins. Rain events affected the removal efficiency of easily degradable CECs, with variations between WWTPs. Persistent compounds such as PFAS demonstrated strong intragroup correlations, reflecting their common sources and environmental stability. These findings provide valuable insights into the diverse profiles of CECs in wastewater and demonstrate the potential of correlation-based approaches to optimize treatment strategies to the specific challenges of individual WWTPs.

Laccase-based biocatalytic systems application in sustainable degradation of pharmaceutically active contaminants

The outflow of pharmaceutically active chemicals (PhACs) exerts a negative impact on biological systems even at extremely low concentrations. For instance, enormous threats to human and aquatic species have resulted from the widespread use of antibiotics in ecosystems, which stimulate the emergence and formation of antibiotic-resistant bacterial species and associated genes. Additionally, it is challenging to eliminate these PhACs by employing conventional physicochemical water treatment techniques. Enzymatic approaches, including laccase, have been identified as a promising alternative to eliminate a broad array of PhACs from water matrices. However, their application in environmental bioremediation is hindered by several factors, including the enzyme's stability and its location in the aqueous environment. Such obstacles may be surmounted by employing laccase immobilization, which enables enhanced stability (including inactivation caused by the substrate), and thus improved catalysis. This review emphasizes the potential hazards of PhACs to aquatic organisms within the detection concentration range of ngL-1 to µgL-1, as well as the deployment of laccase-based multifunctional biocatalytic systems for the environmentally friendly mitigation of anticancer drugs, analgesics/NSAIDs, antibiotics, antiepileptic agents, and beta blockers as micropollutants. This approach could reduce the underlying toxicological consequences. In addition, current developments, potential applications, and viewpoints have focused on computer-assisted investigations of laccase-PhACs binding at enzyme cavities and degradability prediction.

Comprehensive analysis of pharmaceutical and illicit drugs contamination in thermal swimming pools: Occurrence, distribution, and potential impact

The contamination of aquatic environments by micropollutants, including pharmaceuticals and illicit drugs, is a growing global issue with significant implications for environmental and public health. This study addresses a critical knowledge gap by examining pharmaceutical and drug contamination in thermal swimming pools, which are often legally discharged into water bodies without treatment. A total of 49 water samples from 19 distinct thermal pools were analysed, targeting 101 compounds, including pharmaceuticals, illicit drugs, and their metabolites. High-frequency contaminants were identified including caffeine, theophylline, cardiovascular medications (bisoprolol, metoprolol, telmisartan), antidepressants (venlafaxine, citalopram), antihistamines (cetirizine, diphenhydramine), the analgesic tramadol, the antiepileptic carbamazepine, and the illicit drug methamphetamine. The study revealed that these substances were present in more than 30% of the samples, with some occurring at relatively high maximum concentrations, e.g. caffeine (69 μg/L), and methamphetamine (1.8 μg/L). Notably, certain categories of targeted micropollutants, such as cardiovascular medications and illicit drugs, were found to be more prevalent in specific pools. A higher occurrence of cardiovascular drugs has been observed in a pool predominantly designed for relaxation and thus probably preferred by older people. In this pool also notably high levels of illicit drugs were found. The presence of illegal drugs was also confirmed in the children's pool. This study contributes valuable insights into the patterns of micropollutant distribution in thermal pools and emphasises the necessity for enhanced monitoring and management strategies to mitigate environmental and public health risks posed by micropollutants, as well as the possible further impact on aquatic ecosystems.

Advancements in wastewater treatment: A comprehensive review of ozone microbubbles technology

Microbubbles (MBs) possess unique characteristics, including exceptional stability, a high specific surface area, and increased internal pressure. When combined with ozone, these properties significantly enhance the mass transfer and utilization efficiency of ozone, resulting in improved removal of organic pollutants. In recent years, the innovative application of the ozone MBs process has garnered attention as an effective method for wastewater treatment. However, research on its application effects and oxidation mechanisms in this field remains relatively limited. This article provides a comprehensive review of the ozone MBs process, detailing the principles of various MB generation techniques, the oxidation mechanisms of ozone MBs, and the practical applications of this process. Additionally, we address existing controversies and highlight the unique features, efficacy, and limitations of this technology in wastewater treatment. Future research should urgently investigate the pollutant removal mechanisms of the ozone MBs process through device optimization and bubble dynamics, with the aim of enhancing processing efficiency and reducing operating costs. This study presents a viable direction for the advancement and exploration of ozone MB technology, providing scientific support and guidance for its future applications in wastewater treatment.

Elucidating molecular characteristics of organic compounds during ozone micro-bubbles treatment based on GC × GC-QTOF-MS and non-targeted analysis

The ozone micro-bubbles (OCBs) technology is increasingly gaining traction as a promising alternative method for organic compounds removal in wastewater. Nevertheless, there is a scarcity of literature addressing the molecular-level transformation of organic compounds during OCBs treatment. In this work, the secondary effluent from a wastewater treatment plant was treated with ozone milli-bubbles (OLBs) and OCBs, and the fate of organic compounds at the molecular level was investigated using comprehensive two-dimensional gas chromatography quadrupole time-of-flight mass spectrometry (GC × GC-QTOF-MS). The findings revealed that, compared to OLBs, OCBs increased the total mass transfer coefficient by 1.46 times and the half-life of ozone by 4 times. Consequently, OCBs enhanced the removal rates of CODcr, NH4+-N, UV254, and TOC at the 30-min mark by 8.91%, 8.65%, 10.11%, and 2.15%, respectively. In the raw water, 710 organic compounds were detected, decreasing to 668 and 478 after treatment with OLBs and OCBs, respectively. Furthermore, the organic compounds with higher molecular weight and unsaturation degree were more prone to mineralization in the OCBs process. It was also identified that OCBs exhibited nearly 100% removal of amines, unsaturated hydrocarbons, aldehydes, phenols, and aromatic amides. It is noteworthy that, among the 15 identified emerging contaminants (ECs), the removal efficiency of OCBs (53.3%) was higher than that of OLBs (33.3%), with fewer by-products. More deeply, based on 30 common reactions, the primary reactions occurring in OLBs treatment were dealkylations, whereas the abundant hydroxyl radicals in OCBs treatment facilitated the oxidation reaction (+O). This study contributes to the exploration of the potential of OCBs technology in treating secondary effluent, providing invaluable insights for its rational application in practical scenarios.

The Impact of Organic Micropollutants on the Biochemical Composition and Stress Markers in Wolffia arrhiza

For many years, there has been a growing pollution of the aquatic environment with personal care products and industrial chemicals, the main source of which is municipal and industrial wastewater. This raises the need to assess the impact of these pollutants on ecosystems, including plants living in the aquatic environment. It is important to develop methods for their removal from wastewater, among which using plants for phytoremediation is a promising solution. This study aimed to evaluate the response of the aquatic plant Wolffia arrhiza (Lemnaceae) to low concentrations of bisphenol A (BPA), N,N-diethyl-m-toluamide (DEET), triclosan (TRC), benzophenone (BPH), endosulfan alpha (α-END), and endosulfan beta (β-END). The plant growth, the content of cellular components, and oxidative stress markers were assessed in response to plant contact with single compounds at concentrations of 0.1 mg/L and 1 mg/L, and their mixture at a total concentration of 1 mg/L. All of the pollutants used in the study inhibited the W. arrhiza growth and stimulated the degradation of proteins but enhanced the level of saccharides. TRC, BPH, α-END, and β-END had a negative impact on the content of photosynthetic pigments. Increased concentrations of the oxidative stress markers MDA and H2O2 were registered in the plants exposed to BPA, TRC, and β-END. The mixture of pollutants had higher toxic effects than individual substances.

Life cycle assessment and life cycle costing of full-scale ozonation for micropollutants removal from wastewater. Case study in the Netherlands

Wastewater management is one of the main factors that affect drinking water quality. Therefore, the removal of micropollutant from urban wastewaters is receiving an increased attention. This study conducts a comprehensive life cycle assessment (LCA) and life cycle costing of a full-scale ozonation advanced wastewater treatment for micropollutant removal to identify the main impact contributors. The study includes the whole life cycle of the plant, which has been divided into three stages: (1) construction, (2) use and maintenance, and (3) decommissioning. The functional unit is the treatment of 400 m3/h of effluent with ozone, for the removal of 70 % of the micro-pollutants initially present in the effluent. The Environmental Footprint 3.0 was used to assess the environmental impacts based on the collected data. Results showed that ozone generation was the primary contributor to both, environmental impacts as well as operational costs, followed by the construction of the plant. End of life was the lowest contributor, with processes like material recovery and energy generation partially offsetting these impacts. Scenario analyses were performed to identify potential areas of optimization, and results indicated that reusing materials and utilizing renewable energy could significantly reduce environmental burdens. The LCA results provide valuable insights for the design, construction and future advancements in full-scale advanced wastewater treatment installation.

Emerging organic micropollutants as serious environmental problem: A comprehensive review

The escalating problem of environmental pollution can be attributed to the accelerated pace of global development, which often prioritizes human needs over planetary health. Despite huge global attempts endeavours to mitigate legacy pollutants, the uninterrupted introduction of novel substances such as the emerging organic micropollutants (EOMs) represents a significant menace to the natural environment and all forms of life on the earth. The widespread occurrence of EOMs in water and wastewater is a consequence of both their growing consumption as well as the limitations of the conventional wastewater treatment methods containing such pollutants resulting in deterioration of water quality and its supplies as well as this is a significant challenge for researchers and the scientific community alike. EOMs possibility to bioaccumulate, their toxic properties, resistance to degradation, and the limitations of conventional wastewater treatment methods for quantitative removal of EOMs at low concentrations give a significant environmental risk. These compounds are not commonly monitored, which exacerbates further the problem. Therefore the wide knowledge concerning EOMs properties, their occurrence as well as awareness about their migration in the environment and harmful effects is also extremely important. Therefore the EOMs characterization of various types, their classification and sources, concentrations in the aquatic systems and wastewaters, existing regulatory guidelines and their impacts on the environment and human health are thoroughly vetted in this review. Although the full extent of EOMs' effects on aquatic ecosystems and human health is still in the process of investigations, there are evident indications of their potential acute and chronic impacts, which warrant urgent attention. In practical terms the results of the research presented in this paper will help to fill the knowledge gaps concerning EOMs as a serious problem and to raise public awareness of actions to move to sustainable pollution management practices to protect our planet for future generations are vital.

Challenges and Current Trends in Preventing Antimicrobial Resistance in EU Water Law Context

The increasing consumption of pharmaceuticals, including antibiotics, and their improper disposal have resulted in both pharmaceuticals and their metabolites being released into the environment, where they pose a risk to both ecosystems and human health. One of the most serious threats to public health associated with the presence of antibiotics in the environment is antimicrobial resistance (AMR). In order to combat AMR, the legal aspect of water protection becomes a critical area of action. This article analyzes the current challenges and legislative developments in the European Union (EU) aimed at mitigating pharmaceutical contamination in aquatic environments, particularly with regard to AMR. It traces the evolution of EU water protection policies from the initial surface and groundwater directives to the recent updates of the Water Framework Directive, Groundwater Directive and Environmental Quality Standards Directive, focusing on the integration of pharmaceutical contaminants into the regulatory framework. In addition, these changes include the update of the Watch List system for monitoring emerging contaminants, the adoption of effects-based methods (EBMs) in the assessment of water status and the streamlining of the legislative process to respond more quickly to emerging threats in the aquatic environment. The EU's strategic approach to pharmaceuticals in the environment is emphasized as a key framework for harmonizing the environmental standards and addressing the problem of AMR through more sustainable pharmaceutical practices. This study advocates for a proactive, integrated approach to water policy that aligns regulatory actions with scientific advancements to protect public health and ecosystem integrity.

Antidepressants and COVID-19: Increased use, occurrence in water and effects and consequences on aquatic environment. A review

The COVID-19 pandemic changed the consumption of many drugs, among which antidepressants stand out. This review evaluated the frequency of antidepressant use before and after COVID-19. Once the most consumed antidepressants were identified, detecting a variation in the frequency of consumption on the different continents, an overview of their life cycle was carried out, specifying which antidepressants are mostly detected and the places where there is a greater concentration. In addition, the main metabolites of the most used antidepressants were also investigated. A correlation between the most consumed drugs and the most detected was made, emphasizing the lack of information on the occurrence of some of the most consumed antidepressants. Subsequently, studies on the effects on aquatic life were also reviewed, evaluated through different living beings (fish, crustaceans, molluscs, planktonic crustaceans and algae). Likewise, many of the most used antidepressants lack studies on potential adverse effects on aquatic living beings. This review underscores the need for further research, particularly focusing on the life cycle of the most prescribed antidepressants. In particular, it is a priority to know the occurrence and adverse effects in the aquatic environment of the most used antidepressants after the pandemic.

Efficient removal of succinic acid by continuous hydrodynamic cavitation combined with ozone and side influent injection

Micropollutants (MPs) encompass a range of human-made pollutants present in trace amounts in environmental systems. MPs include pharmaceuticals, personal care products, pesticides, persistent organic pollutants, micro- and nano-plastics, and artificial sweeteners, all posing ecological risks. Conventional municipal wastewater treatment methods often face challenges in completely removing MPs due to their chemical characteristics, stability, and resistance to biodegradation. In this research, an Advanced Oxidation Process, combining hydrodynamic cavitation (HC) with dissolved ozone (O3) and side injection, was employed to efficiently degrade succinic acid (SA), an ozone-resistant compound and common byproduct. The HC/O3 process was run to treat different synthetic effluents, focusing on evaluating the influence of O3-to-total organic carbon (TOC) ratio, cavitation number (Cv) and O3 dosage. Notably, the results from a series of 14 experiments highlighted the critical significance of a low O3-to-TOC ratio value of 0.08 mg/mg and Cv value of 0.056 in HC for achieving efficient SA removal of 41.2% from an initial SA solution (106.3 mg/L). Regarding a series of four proof-of-concept experiments and their replications, the average TOC removal reached 62% when treating wastewater treatment plant effluent spiked with SA. This significant removal rate was achieved under initial conditions: Cv of 0.02, O3-to-TOC ratio set at 0.77 mg/mg, TOC concentration of 47.7 mg/L, 106 mg/L of SA, and a temperature of 25 °C. Notably, the electrical energy per order required for the 62% reduction in TOC was a modest 12.5 kWh/m3/order, indicating the potential of the continuous HC/O3 process as a promising approach for degrading a wide range of MPs.

Comparative life cycle assessment of non-thermal plasma for the removal of pharmaceuticals from wastewater

Wastewater effluents are a continuous source of pharmaceuticals in water bodies, which pose a serious environmental threat to aquatic ecosystems. This work provides a comprehensive technical, environmental and cost assessments of different advanced quaternary treatments for wastewater effluents, with special focus on novel Non-Thermal Plasma technology. For this porpouse Non-Thermal Plasma, Sand Filtration + Ozonation, Ultrafiltration, Ultrafiltration + Nanofiltration and Ultrafiltration + Reverse Osmosis technologies were compared with UV disinfection-based technology. This work applies the Life Cycle Analysis tool for the impact environmental assessment using both ReciPE 2016(H) method and, for a more detailed analysis of the contribution of pharmaceuticals to freshwater ecotoxicity category of impact, the USETOX method, which was integrated with 7 new characterisation factors. The results obtained showed overall removal efficiency of pharmaceuticals always higher than 80%, with performances in descending order of Ultrafiltration + Reverse Osmosis > Sand Filtration + Ozonation > Ultrafiltration + Nanofiltration > Non-Thermal Plasma, being Sand Filtration + Ultraviolet disinfection and standalone Ultrafiltration comparatively not suitable for pharmaceuticals removal. Regarding the target pharmaceuticals proposed on the EU Directive 271/91 revision, the Non-Thermal Plasma perform better towards venlafaxine than Sand Filtration + Ozonation, and towards diclofenac and carbamazepine than Ultrafiltration + Nanofiltration. Ultrafiltration + Nanofiltration and Non-Thermal Plasma showed better environmental performance than Sand Filtration + Ozonation and Ultrafiltration + Reverse Osmosis in 7 out of 18 categories of impact (ReciPe method), with Ultrafiltration + Nanofiltration being more advantageous than Non-Thermal Plasma in human and ecotoxicity-related categories of impact, and Non-Thermal Plasma more advantageous in Global Warming, Fossil Resource Scarcity, and Fine Particulate Matter Formation. Regrading Freshwater Ecotoxicity (USEtox method), the quaternary treatment configuration and its energy demand affect the Freshwater final value of impact more than the presence of pharmaceuticals. Under the conditions tested, the Non-Thermal Plasma provided the lower OPEX (0.24 € m-3) than other tested technologies, showing an interesting compromise between pharmaceuticals removal efficiency, environmental impacts, and economic operational cost.

Nanomaterial Texture-Based Machine Learning of Ciprofloxacin Adsorption on Nanoporous Carbon

Drug substances in water bodies and groundwater have become a significant threat to the surrounding environment. This study focuses on the ability of the nanoporous carbon materials to remove ciprofloxacin from aqueous solutions under specific experimental conditions and on the development of the mathematical model that would allow describing the molecular interactions of the adsorption process and calculating the adsorption capacity of the material. Thus, based on the adsorption measurements of the 87 carbon materials, it was found that, depending on the porosity and pore size distribution, adsorption capacity values varied between 55 and 495 mg g-1. For a more detailed analysis of the effects of different carbon textures and pores characteristics, a Quantitative nano-Structure-Property Relationship (QnSPR) was developed to describe and predict the ability of a nanoporous carbon material to remove ciprofloxacin from aqueous solutions. The adsorption capacity of potential nanoporous carbon-based adsorbents for the removal of ciprofloxacin was shown to be sufficiently accurately described by a three-parameter multi-linear QnSPR equation (R2 = 0.70). This description was achieved only with parameters describing the texture of the carbon material such as specific surface area (Sdft) and pore size fractions of 1.1-1.2 nm (VN21.1-1.2) and 3.3-3.4 nm (VN23.3-3.4) for pores.

Development of a probabilistic risk model for pharmaceuticals in the environment under population and wastewater treatment scenarios

Preparing for future environmental pressures requires projections of how relevant risks will change over time. Current regulatory models of environmental risk assessment (ERA) of pollutants such as pharmaceuticals could be improved by considering the influence of global change factors (e.g., population growth) and by presenting uncertainty more transparently. In this article, we present the development of a prototype object-oriented Bayesian network (BN) for the prediction of environmental risk for six high-priority pharmaceuticals across 36 scenarios: current and three future population scenarios, combined with infrastructure scenarios, in three Norwegian counties. We compare the risk, characterized by probability distributions of risk quotients (RQs), across scenarios and pharmaceuticals. Our results suggest that RQs would be greatest in rural counties, due to the lower development of current wastewater treatment facilities, but that these areas consequently have the most potential for risk mitigation. This pattern intensifies under higher population growth scenarios. With this prototype, we developed a hierarchical probabilistic model and demonstrated its potential in forecasting the environmental risk of chemical stressors under plausible demographic and management scenarios, contributing to the further development of BNs for ERA. Integr Environ Assess Manag 2024;20:1715-1735. © 2024 The Authors. Integrated Environmental Assessment and Management published by Wiley Periodicals LLC on behalf of Society of Environmental Toxicology & Chemistry (SETAC).

To spread or not to spread? Assessing the suitability of sewage sludge and other biogenic wastes for agriculture reuse

Sewage sludge (biosolids) management represents a worldwide issue. Due to its valuable properties, approximately one half of the EU production is recovered in agriculture. Nevertheless, growing attention is given to potential negative effects deriving from the presence of harmful pollutants. It is recognized that a (even very detailed) chemical characterization is not able to predict ecotoxicity of a mixture. However, this can be directly measured by bioassays. Actually, the choice of the most suitable tests is still under debate. This paper presents a multilevel characterization protocol of sewage sludge and other organic residues, based on bioassays and chemical-physical-microbiological analyses. The detailed description of the experimental procedure includes all the involved steps: the criteria for selecting the organic matrices to be tested and compared; the sample pre-treatment required before the analyses execution; the chemical, physical and microbiological characterisation; the bioassays, grouped in three classes (baseline toxicity; specific mode of action; reactive mode of action); data processing. The novelty of this paper lies in the integrated use of advanced tools, and is based on three pillars:•the direct ecosafety assessment of the matrices to be reused.•the adoption of innovative bioassays and analytical procedures.•the original criteria for data normalization and processing.

Chronic toxicity of pharmaceuticals to the benthic green alga Closterium ehrenbergii

Pharmaceuticals in the environment have emerged to a topic of global concern. Since these substances are designed to be biologically active, hazardous effects on non-target organisms are frequently reported. Here, the effects of five pharmaceuticals, one radiocontrast agent, and one degradation product on the freshwater green alga Closterium ehrenbergii were evaluated after chronic exposure of 168 h. Growth and maximum quantum yield (FV/FM) were used as endpoints and complemented by the assessment of morphology and chlorophyll fluorescence. We found that the tested antibiotics Ciprofloxacin and Ofloxacin impaired chloroplast integrity, resulting in a reduction of FV/FM from 0.1 mg/L. The disintegration of chloroplasts at higher concentrations (c = 0.3 and 0.8 mg/L, respectively) was visualized by brightfield and fluorescence microscopy. In contrast, Sulfamethoxazole interfered with cell division, leading to malformation of cells from 0.8 mg/L. Furthermore, the antibiotics exhibited a latency period of 72 h after which they started to reveal their true effects. Therefore, the importance of long-term toxicity testing is outlined in order to avoid underestimation of toxic effects of pharmaceuticals. Based on the EC10 values obtained, the antibiotics were considered to meet the criteria for classification as toxic to aquatic life with long lasting effects. The other test substances were found to exert no effects on C. ehrenbergii or only at very high concentrations and were classified as nontoxic.

A thorough analysis of the occurrence, removal and environmental risks of organic micropollutants in a full-scale hybrid membrane bioreactor fed by hospital wastewater

The Urban Wastewater Treatment Directive recent draft issued last October 2022 pays attention to contaminants of emerging concern including organic micropollutants (OMPs) and requires the removal of some of them at large urban wastewater treatment plants (WWTPs) calling for their upgrading. Many investigations to date have reported the occurrence of a vast group of OMPs in the influent and many technologies have been tested for their removal at a lab- or pilot-scale. Moreover, it is well-known that hospital wastewater (HWW) contains specific OMPs at high concentration and therefore its management and treatment deserves attention. In this study, a 1-year investigation was carried out at a full-scale membrane bioreactor (MBR) treating mainly HWW. To promote the removal of OMPs, powdered activated carbon (PAC) was added to the bioreactor at 0.1 g/L and 0.2 g/L which resulted in the MBR operating as a hybrid MBR. Its performance was tested for 232 target and 90 non-target OMPs, analyzed by UHPLC-QTOF-MS using a direct injection method. A new methodology was defined to select the key compounds in order to evaluate the performance of the treatments. It was based on their frequency, occurrence, persistence to removal, bioaccumulation and toxicity. Finally, an environmental risk assessment of the OMP residues was conducted by means of the risk quotient approach. The results indicate that PAC addition increased the removal of most of the key OMPs (e.g., sulfamethoxazole, diclofenac, lidocaine) and OMP classes (e.g., antibiotics, psychiatric drugs and stimulants) with the highest loads in the WWTP influent. The hybrid MBR also reduced the risk in the receiving water as the PAC dosage increased mainly for spiramycin, lorazepam, oleandomycin. Finally, uncertainties and issues related to the investigation being carried out at full-scale under real conditions are discussed.

The Future of Municipal Wastewater Reuse Concentrate Management: Drivers, Challenges, and Opportunities

Water reuse is rapidly becoming an integral feature of resilient water systems, where municipal wastewater undergoes advanced treatment, typically involving a sequence of ultrafiltration (UF), reverse osmosis (RO), and an advanced oxidation process (AOP). When RO is used, a concentrated waste stream is produced that is elevated in not only total dissolved solids but also metals, nutrients, and micropollutants that have passed through conventional wastewater treatment. Management of this RO concentrate─dubbed municipal wastewater reuse concentrate (MWRC)─will be critical to address, especially as water reuse practices become more widespread. Building on existing brine management practices, this review explores MWRC management options by identifying infrastructural needs and opportunities for multi-beneficial disposal. To safeguard environmental systems from the potential hazards of MWRC, disposal, monitoring, and regulatory techniques are discussed to promote the safety and affordability of implementing MWRC management. Furthermore, opportunities for resource recovery and valorization are differentiated, while economic techniques to revamp cost-benefit analysis for MWRC management are examined. The goal of this critical review is to create a common foundation for researchers, practitioners, and regulators by providing an interdisciplinary set of tools and frameworks to address the impending challenges and emerging opportunities of MWRC management.

Ecotoxicological mixture risk assessment of 35 pharmaceuticals in wastewater effluents following post-treatment with ozone and/or granulated activated carbon

Reducing the risk posed by mixtures of pharmaceuticals is a goal of current initiatives such as the European Green Deal to reduce anthropological environmental impacts. Wastewater effluent typically contains large numbers of active pharmaceutical ingredients (APIs). For some APIs, existing technology such as conventional activated sludge (CAS) wastewater treatment plants (WWTPs) have removal rates below 20 %, thus the WWTP discharges are adding to the toxic burden of receiving waters. We present an environmental risk assessment of mixtures of 35 APIs in effluent samples from 82 Northern European WWTPs using the concentration addition model, and identify the respective risk-driving APIs. This is then compared to a corresponding mixture risk assessment of effluent samples from the Danish Hillerød WWTP subjected to post-treatment with varying specific ozone doses (0.15-1.05 mgO3/mgDOC) and/or granulated activated carbon (GAC). All 82 WWTP effluent samples exceeded risk thresholds by at least a factor of 30, with a median RQSUM of 92.9, highlighting the need for effluent post-treatment and/or a substantial dilution in the recipient waters. Antibiotics, analgesics and anti-depressants were among the top risk drivers with 99 % of the average mixture risk attributable to azithromycin, diclofenac, venlafaxine, clarithromycin and mycophenolic acid. Effluent mixture risk was reduced by ozonation in a concentration-dependent manner, decreasing below threshold levels to a median RQSUM of 0.83 following treatment with 0.65 mgO3/mg DOC. Fresh GAC was also effective at reducing the mixture risk both alone and with ozone treatment, with median RQSUM of 0.04 and 0.07 respectively. To our knowledge, this is the first study to present a risk assessment of pharmaceutical mixtures in effluent comparing "conventional" WWTP processes with additional post-treatment with ozone and/or GAC for reducing the joint risks of pharmaceutical mixtures for recipient waters. We demonstrate the need for additional WWTP treatment technologies, and the efficacy of GAC and ozonation in decreasing the risk to the aquatic environment from pharmaceutical mixtures to below acceptable threshold limits.

European-wide spatial analysis of sewage treatment plants and the possible benefits to nature of advanced treatment to reduce pharmaceutical emissions

Pharmaceuticals are known to widely occur in the environment and to affect the health of ecosystems. Sewage treatment plants (STPs) are main emission pathways for pharmaceuticals, which are often not sufficiently removed during wastewater treatment. In Europe, STP treatment requirements are specified under the Urban WasteWater Treatment Directive (UWWTD). The introduction of advanced treatment techniques, such as ozonation and activated carbon, under the UWWTD is expected to be an important option to reduce pharmaceutical emissions. In this study, we present a European-wide analysis of STPs reported under the UWWTD, their current treatment level and potential to remove a set of 58 prioritised pharmaceuticals. Three different scenarios were analysed to show 1) UWWTD present effectiveness, 2) the effectiveness at full UWWTD compliance, and 3) the effectiveness when advanced treatment is implemented at STPs with a treatment capacity of >100.000 person equivalents. Based on a literature study, the potential of individual STPs to reduce pharmaceutical emissions ranged from an average of 9% for STPs with primary treatment to 84% for STPs applying advanced treatment. Results of our calculations show that European-wide emission of pharmaceuticals can be reduced with 68% when large STPs are updated with advanced treatment, but spatial differences exist. We argue that adequate attention should also be paid with regards to preventing environmental impacts of STPs with a capacity <100.000 p.e. Circa 44% of total STP effluent is emitted near Natura2000 sites (EU nature protection areas). Of all surface waters receiving STP effluent for which the ecological status has been assessed under the Water Framework Directive, 77% have a status of less than good. Relatively often only primary treatment is applied to wastewater emitted into coastal waters. This analysis can be used to further model pharmaceutical concentrations in European surface waters, to identify STPs for which more advanced treatment might be required and to protect EU aquatic biodiversity.

Hybrid system coupling ozonation and nanofiltration with functionalized catalytic ceramic membrane for ibuprofen removal

The investigations on the removal of ibuprofen (IBU) in a hybrid system coupling ozonation and nanofiltration with functionalized catalytic ceramic membrane are presented. The gaseous ozone into feed water in concentration of 11 g Nm^-3 was supplied. Positive influence of catalytic ozonation on ibuprofen decomposition was observed. The application of catalytic nanofiltration membrane led to the ibuprofen removal of 91% after the first 15 min from the beginning of the O₃/NF process, while at the same time, for the pristine membrane, it was equal to 76%. The investigations revealed incomplete degradation of drug under pH 3 after 2 h, i.e., 89%. On the other hand, the addition of inorganic salts did not affect the catalytic ibuprofen removal efficiency. Under acidic pH, the highest permeate flux decline (26%) was noted, whereas no differences between permeate flux measured under natural and alkaline conditions were observed. During the treatment process, three IBU by-products were detected, which significantly affected the permeate toxicity; however, after 2 h of catalytic nanofiltration, the product of treatment process was found as non-toxic.

The Minus Approach Can Redefine the Standard of Practice of Drinking Water Treatment

Chlorine-based disinfection for drinking water treatment (DWT) was one of the 20th century's great public health achievements, as it substantially reduced the risk of acute microbial waterborne disease. However, today's chlorinated drinking water is not unambiguously safe; trace levels of regulated and unregulated disinfection byproducts (DBPs), and other known, unknown, and emerging contaminants (KUECs), present chronic risks that make them essential removal targets. Because conventional chemical-based DWT processes do little to remove DBPs or KUECs, alternative approaches are needed to minimize risks by removing DBP precursors and KUECs that are ubiquitous in water supplies. We present the "Minus Approach" as a toolbox of practices and technologies to mitigate KUECs and DBPs without compromising microbiological safety. The Minus Approach reduces problem-causing chemical addition treatment (i.e., the conventional "Plus Approach") by producing biologically stable water containing pathogens at levels having negligible human health risk and substantially lower concentrations of KUECs and DBPs. Aside from ozonation, the Minus Approach avoids primary chemical-based coagulants, disinfectants, and advanced oxidation processes. The Minus Approach focuses on bank filtration, biofiltration, adsorption, and membranes to biologically and physically remove DBP precursors, KUECs, and pathogens; consequently, water purveyors can use ultraviolet light at key locations in conjunction with smaller dosages of secondary chemical disinfectants to minimize microbial regrowth in distribution systems. We describe how the Minus Approach contrasts with the conventional Plus Approach, integrates with artificial intelligence, and can ultimately improve the sustainability performance of water treatment. Finally, we consider barriers to adoption of the Minus Approach.

Condition-Based Failure-Free Time Estimation of a Pump

Reliable and continuous operation of the equipment is expected in the wastewater treatment plant, as any perturbations can lead to environmental pollution and the need to pay penalties. Optimization and minimization of operating costs of the pump station cannot, therefore, lead to a reduction in reliability but rather should be based on preventive works, the necessity of which should be foreseen. The purpose of this paper is to develop an accurate model to predict a pump's mean time to failure, allowing for rational planning of maintenance. The pumps operate under the supervision of the automatic control system and SCADA, which is the source of historical data on pump operation parameters. This enables the research and development of various methods and algorithms for optimizing service activities. In this case, a multiple linear regression model is developed to describe the impact of historical data on pump operation for pump maintenance. In the literature, the least squares method is used to estimate unknown regression coefficients for this data. The original value of the paper is the application of the genetic algorithm to estimate coefficient values of the multiple linear regression model of failure-free time of the pump. Necessary analysis and simulations are performed on the data collected for submersible pumps in a sewage pumping station. As a result, an improvement in the adequacy of the presented model was identified.

Ozone Diffusion through a Hollow Fiber Membrane Contactor for Pharmaceuticals Removal and Bromate Minimization

Recently, ozonation has been advocated as a solution to tackle emerging contaminants. Hollow fiber membrane contactors (HFMC) have a lower residual ozone concentration than bubble reactors that could limit the formation of potential ozonation by-products, especially bromates that are regulated in drinking water. The aim of this study was to evaluate ozonation with HFMC for pharmaceutical abatement and bromate minimization compared to bubble columns in wastewater. A HFMC, composed of 65 polytetrafluoroethylene hollow fibers with a 0.45 mm/0.87 mm inner/external diameter and a 0.107 m² exchange surface, was used for the ozonation of real-treated wastewater spiked with 2 µM of p-chlorobenzoic acid (p-CBA) and 3 mg.L^-1 of bromide. p-CBA was tracked to monitor the production of strongly-oxidant hydroxyl radicals from the decomposition of the molecular ozone. At 100% p-CBA abatement, 1600 µg.L^-1 of bromate was formed with the HFMC, whereas 3486 µg.L^-1 was formed with the bubble column. These results demonstrate that HFMC can produce a significant amount of hydroxyl radicals while limiting bromate formation in real-treated wastewater. The test water was also spiked with carbamazepine and sulfamethoxazole to evaluate the abatement efficiency of the process. Short contact times (approximately 2s) achieved high rates of pharmaceuticals removal without bromate formation.

European scale assessment of the potential of ozonation and activated carbon treatment to reduce micropollutant emissions with wastewater

Micropollutants (MPs) in wastewater pose a growing concern for their potential adverse effects on the receiving aquatic environment, and some countries have started requiring that wastewater treatment plants remove them to a certain extent. Broad spectrum advanced treatment processes, such as ozonation, activated carbon or their combination, are expected to yield a significant reduction in the toxicity of effluents. Here we quantify the reduction of effluent toxicity potentially achieved by implementing these advanced treatment solutions in a selection of European wastewater treatment plants. To this end, we refer to a list of "total pollution proxy substances" (TPPS) composed of 1337 chemicals commonly found in wastewater effluents according to a compilation of datasets of measured concentrations. We consider these substances as an approximation of the "chemical universe" impinging on the European wastewater system. We evaluate the fate of the TPPS in conventional and advanced treatment plants using a compilation of experimental physicochemical properties that describe their sorption, volatilization and biodegradation during activated sludge treatment, as well as known removal efficiency in ozonation and activated carbon treatment, while filling the gaps through in silico prediction models. We estimate that the discharge of micropollutants with wastewater effluents in the European Union has a cumulative MP toxicity to the environment equal to the discharge of untreated wastewater of ca. 160 million population equivalents (PE), i.e. about 30 % of the generated wastewater in the EU. If all plants above a capacity of 100,000 PE were equipped with advanced treatment, we show that this load would be reduced to about 95 million PE. In addition, implementing advanced treatment in wastewater plants above 10,000 PE discharging to water bodies with an average dilution ratio smaller than 10 would yield a widespread improvement in terms of exposure of freshwater ecosystems to micropollutants, almost halving the part of the stream network exposed to the highest toxic risks. Our analysis provides background for a cost-effectiveness appraisal of advanced treatment "at the end of the pipe", which could lead to optimized interventions. This should not be regarded as a stand-alone solution, but as a complement to policies for the control of emissions at the source for the most problematic MPs.