Effects of biochar on soil microbial communities: A meta-analysis

Enhanced remediation of co-contaminated agricultural soils under cold stress by immobilized bacterial agents: A perspective based on abundance differences

This study explored the enhanced remediation effects and microbial mechanisms of the immobilized microbial agent B&Ma19, compared to the microbial agent Ma19, in cold-region farmland co-contaminated with antibiotics and heavy metals during winter. B&Ma19 achieved superior fluoroquinolone degradation and significantly reduced the bioavailability of copper and zinc, while Ma19 treatment only reduced the content of available zinc. Microbial community analysis revealed that B&Ma19 promoted the proliferation of Firmicutes and increased the relative abundance of rare taxa during the freeze-thaw and freezing phases. Functional predictions indicated that B&Ma19 enhanced the expression of proteins in the winter microbial community involved in resistance to antibiotics, metabolic activity, and nutrient acquisition capacity. A random forest model identified Sporosarcina as a potential key genus for co-contamination remediation. Moreover, increased in overall community dispersal limitation and reduced drift-driven succession were observed. The co-occurrence network became more stable, characterized by a higher proportion of moderately abundant keystone taxa. Mantel tests showed that B&Ma19 weakened the correlation between antibiotic resistance genes (ARGs) and mobile genetic elements, and reduced the impact of temperature fluctuations on contaminant concentrations. In contrast, Ma19 strengthened ARG-antibiotic associations. These findings provide a theoretical basis for bioremediation of co-contaminated farmland in cold regions.

Unraveling the synergistic effect of biochar and potassium solubilizing bacteria on potassium availability and rapeseed growth in acidic soil

Potassium (K) is an essential macronutrient for plant growth. However, its bioavailability is low in acidic soils. Excessive K fertilization deteriorates the soil health, thus highlighting the need for sustainable alternatives. In previous studies, biochar application has been proven to be an effective amendment. Meanwhile, various potassium solubilizing bacteria (KSB) have been identified in soil that contributes to K bioavailability. However, their interaction under combine (co) application in acidic soil and its effects on K availability remain poorly understood. Therefore, a pot experiment was conducted to investigate the synergistic effect of co-application of rice straw biochar (BC) and KSB consortium on K availability to promote rapeseed growth. The treatment plan consisted of CK (control), recommended K fertilizer, 2 % BC (2 % w/w), KSB consortium, KSB consortium + 2 % BC (2 % w/w). Results of soil analysis conducted after crop maturity showed that co-application of 2 % BC and KSB consortium significantly improved the soil pH and organic matter contents by 0.62 and 12.52 units respectively, relative to CK. Meanwhile, soil available nutrients were greatly enhanced, as available K content increased by 52.1 %, which indicated that co-application of 2 % BC and KSB consortium could facilitate the better conversion of different forms of soil K and make it available for plant uptake. Furthermore, it also improved extracellular enzymatic activities (26.7-71.6 %) and soil bacterial community (Actinobacteriota and Firmicutes). These improvements greatly enhanced plant biomass (46 %) and yield (31 %). Overall results proved that co-application of 2 % BC and KSB effectively enhanced K availability for sustainable plant growth. Still, there is a need to identify the most efficient KSB strains that, in conjugation with BC, reduce the K fertilizer usage.

The relevance of biochar and co-applied SynComs on maize quality and sustainability: Evidence from field experiments

Adoption of sustainable maize cropping practices is urgently needed. Synthetic microbial communities (SynComs) made of plant growth-promoting microorganisms (PGPMs), coupled with biochar from residual biomass, offer an environmentally compatible alternative to inorganic fertilizers and may improve soil fertility. This article extends in a two-year field trial with preliminary results obtained in previous pot experiments, monitoring plant physiology, soil biology and chemistry, and kernel metabolomics. Here, we report the synergistic effect of the co-application of biochar, SynComs, and arbuscular mycorrhizal fungi on the soil microbiome, maize growth, and kernel metabolomic profile. SynComs application did not affect the diversity and richness of soil microbial communities; therefore, it posed a low risk of long-term effects on soil microbial ecology. With SynComs and biochar co-application to the soil, the physiology of maize plants was characterized by higher chlorophyll content, ear weight, and kernel weight. The combination of SynComs and biochar also affected the kernel metabolome, resulting in enriched health-beneficial and anti-stress metabolites. Since the preliminary evidence on the environmental and economic impact of these new associations was more favorable than that of conventional fertilizers, it seems reasonable that their large-scale implementation can eventually favor the transition to more sustainable agriculture.

Modulated use of high-concentration invasive biochar in waste-to-energy strategies: Impact analysis on microbial communities

As a potential amendment, biochar has attracted considerable attention for its impact on soil microbial communities. However, there is little consensus regarding the impacts of biochar derived from invasive plants on microbial communities in coastal saline wetland soils. In this study, we used Juglans regia biochar (JBC) and two other invasive plant biochar, Spartina alterniflora biochar (SBC) and Flaveria bidentis biochar (FBC) to saline soils at rates of 1%, 3%, and 5% (w/w). The results demonstrated that the application of biochar led to a reduction in microbial community diversity, particularly evident in the 5% SBC and FBC treatments. Furthermore, the 5% FBC treatment resulted in a notable decline in community richness. With regard to species composition, the addition of SBC and FBC resulted in a notable impact on the relative abundance of Acidobacteria in comparison to JBC. Additionally, 5% SBC led to a reduction in the relative abundance of Bacteroidetes by 21.49%-23.90%, and 5% FBC reduced the relative abundance of Nitrospirae by 14.71%-17.86%. The addition of biochar enhanced the overall complexity of the community. Specifically, adding 5% SBC boosted the complexity of the microbial network and encouraged cooperative relationships among microorganisms. However, this community became more vulnerable to environmental changes and exhibited weaker anti-interference capabilities. Moreover, 5% JBC and 5% SBC altered the community assembly process from deterministic to stochastic. We emphasize the importance of carefully selecting biochar types during soil remediation, with particular attention to the application of high concentrations of biochar. This paper lays the groundwork for long-term practice in soil remediation through the approach of "treating waste with waste".

Effect of anaerobic digested sludge biochar on soil quality improvement: An insight into mechanisms, microbial composition, and toxicity risk assessment

Biochar is widely acknowledged for its remarkable impact on soil conditioning. However, the influence of different sources of biochar, particularly anaerobic digested sludge biochar (ADBC) derived from anaerobic digested sludge and biochar derived from waste activated sludge, on alkaline soil remains largely unexplored. To address this knowledge gap, a comprehensive field experiment was conducted over a period of 180 days to investigate the effects of ADBC on slightly alkaline soil. This study evaluated various aspects, including soil properties, nutrient content, microbial composition, and soil toxicity. The results demonstrated significant improvements in the quality of alkaline soil following the application of ADBC. Notably, soil pH decreased from 8.24 to 7.5, while conductivity increased from 56.7 μs/cm to 249.0 μs/cm, total organic carbon from 13.5 g/kg to 19.9 g/kg, available nitrogen from 45.5 g/kg to 237.5 g/kg, and available phosphorus from 549.5 g/kg to 1396.7 g/kg. Moreover, ADBC substantially increased the relative abundance of functional bacteria associated with nutrient cycling, such as Proteobacteria, Actinobacteriota, and Bacteroidota. Conversely, the assessment of biotoxicity revealed a decrease in toxicity with increasing preparation temperature and particle size. These findings highlight the promising potential of ADBC for improving the key properties of alkaline and nutrient-poor soils crucial for overall soil productivity.

Optimizing the dual role of biochar for phosphorus availability and arsenic immobilization in soils

Soil Phosphorus (P) fixation and Arsenic (As) contamination pose significant challenges to agriculture and environmental health. Biochar has emerged as a promising soil amendment capable of enhancing P availability while immobilizing As. This review explored the mechanisms by which biochar influences P dynamics and As sequestration. Biochar enhances P availability by reducing fixation, stimulating P-solubilizing microorganisms, and gradually releasing the adsorbed P. Specific biochars, such as Mg-modified and La-modified types, demonstrate high P adsorption capacities, reaching up to 263 mg/g, while cerium and iron-modified biochars show As adsorption efficiencies up to 99 % under certain conditions. Biochar's surface functional groups are essential for P and As adsorption through mechanisms such as surface adsorption, ligand exchange, and inner-sphere complexation. The competitive adsorption between P and As is influenced by pH, biochar modification, and co-existing anions. Under acidic conditions, As shows a higher affinity for biochar, forming stable complexes with metal oxides like iron and aluminum. Biochars modified with calcium, magnesium, lanthanum, zinc, cerium, and iron demonstrate enhanced adsorption capacities. In neutral to alkaline conditions, calcium- and magnesium-modified biochars benefit P retention, while iron-modified biochar is preferable for As adsorption. Additionally, biochar promotes microbial activity and enzymatic processes that facilitate As transformation and P mineralization, enhancing overall soil health. These findings underscore biochar's dual role in increasing nutrient availability and reducing contaminant risks, making it a valuable tool for sustainable agriculture. Field-scale applications should be prioritized in future research to optimize biochar's impact on soil fertility and environmental remediation.

Food waste biochar for sustainable agricultural use: Effects on soil enzymes, microbial community, lettuce, and earthworms

This study investigates the effects of food waste biochar (FWB) on the biological properties of soil, including the microbial community structure, enzyme activities, lettuce growth, and earthworm ecotoxicity. This holistic assessment of various soil organisms was used to assess the potential of FWB as a soil amendment strategy. Pot experiments were carried out over a 28-d period using various FWB concentrations in soil (0-3% w/w). The presence of FWB enhanced the activity of alkaline phosphatase and beta-glucosidase in proportion to the FWB concentration. Similarly, the dehydrogenase activity after 28 d was positively correlated with the FWB concentration. Notably, the application of FWB improved the bacterial diversity in the soil, particularly among hydrocarbonoclastic bacteria, while also prompting a shift in the fungal community structure at the class level. Measures of lettuce growth, including total fresh weight, shoot length, and leaf number, also generally improved with the addition of FWB, particularly at higher concentrations. Importantly, FWB did not adversely affect the survival or weight of earthworms. Collectively, these findings suggest that FWB can enhance soil microbial enzyme activity and support plant growth-promoting rhizobacteria, potentially leading to increased crop yields. This highlights the potential of FWB as an eco-friendly soil amendment strategy.

Biochar alters the soil fauna functional traits and community diversity: A quantitative and cascading perspective

With the widespread use of biochar, the cascading effects of biochar exposure on soil fauna urgently require deeper understanding. A meta-analysis quantified hierarchical changes in functional traits and community diversity of soil fauna under biochar exposure. Antioxidant enzymes (24.1 %) did not fully mitigate the impact of MDA (13.5 %), leading to excessive DNA damage in soil fauna (21.2 %). Concurrently, reproduction, growth, and survival rates decreased by 20.2 %, 8.5 %, and 21.2 %, respectively. Due to a 39.7 % increase in avoidance behavior of soil fauna towards biochar, species richness ultimately increased by 80.2 %. Compared to other feeding habits, biochar posed a greater threat to the survival of herbivores. Additionally, macrofauna were the most sensitive to biochar. The response of soil fauna also depended on the type, size, concentration, and duration of biochar exposure. It should be emphasized that as exposure concentration increased, the damage to soil fauna became more severe. Furthermore, the smaller the biochar sizes, the greater the damage to soil fauna. To mitigate the adverse effects on soil fauna, this study recommens applying biochar at appropriate times and selecting large sizes in low to medium concentrations. These findings confirm the threat of biochar to soil health from the perspective of soil fauna.

Removal of environmental pollutants using biochar: current status and emerging opportunities

In recent times, biochar has emerged as a novel approach for environmental remediation due to its exceptional adsorption capacity, attributed to its porous structure formed by the pyrolysis of biomass at elevated temperatures in oxygen-restricted conditions. This characteristic has driven its widespread use in environmental remediation to remove pollutants. When biochar is introduced into ecosystems, it usually changes the makeup of microbial communities by offering a favorable habitat. Its porous structure creates a protective environment that shields them from external pressures. Consequently, microorganisms adhering to biochar surfaces exhibit increased resilience to environmental conditions, thereby enhancing their capacity to degrade pollutants. During this process, pollutants are broken down into smaller molecules through the collaborative efforts of biochar surface groups and microorganisms. Biochar is also often used in conjunction with composting techniques to enhance compost quality by improving aeration and serving as a carrier for slow-release fertilizers. The utilization of biochar to support sustainable agricultural practices and combat environmental contamination is a prominent area of current research. This study aims to examine the beneficial impacts of biochar application on the absorption and breakdown of contaminants in environmental and agricultural settings, offering insights into its optimization for enhanced efficacy.

The effect of AMF combined with biochar on plant growth and soil quality under saline-alkali stress: Insights from microbial community analysis

Arbuscular mycorrhizal fungi (AMF) and biochar application individually can enhance plant tolerance to saline-alkali stress and promote plant growth efficiency. However, little is known about the potential synergistic effects of their combination on improving plant growth and soil quality under saline-alkali stress. This experiment adopted the potted method to explore the effects of four treatments on switchgrass growth and soil quality: biochar (BC), Rhizophagus irregularis (Ri), biochar + Ri (BR) and a control without biochar or Ri (CK). Compared to the CK treatment, the switchgrass biomass increased by 92.4 %, 148.6 %, and 177.3 % in the BC, Ri, and BR treatment groups, respectively. Similarly, the rhizosphere soil quality index increased by 29.33 %, 22.7 %, and 49.1 % in the respective treatment groups. The BR treatment significantly altered the rhizosphere soil microbial composition and diversity. Notably, compared to the other treatments, the archaeal α-diversity in the BR group showed a significant decrease. BR treatment significantly increased the relative abundance of bacteria, fungi and archaea at the genus level (e.g., Bacillus, Trichome and candidatus_methanopenens). Network analysis showed that the complexity and closeness of interactions between different microbial taxa were stronger in the BC, Ri and BR treatments than in the CK treatment, with BR being the more prominent. In summary, biochar combined with Ri has a better effect on promoting the growth of switchgrass under saline-alkali stress, improving the quality of saline-alkali soil, and increasing soil microbial diversity. This study provides a new approach for the efficient development and utilization of saline-alkali land.

Comparing combined application of biochar and nitrogen fertilizer in paddy and upland soils: Processes, enhancement strategies, and agricultural implications

Recently, biochar and N fertilizers have been used to tackle low N use efficiency (NUE) in crops across diverse environmental conditions. The coupling of biochar and N fertilizer may impact crop N utilization through different pathways in various soil types. However, there is currently a lack of comprehensive assessment of how coupling effects specifically influence N utilization in paddy and upland crops. We conducted a meta-analysis of 175 peer-reviewed studies to assess the responses of soil properties and crop traits in paddy and upland fields under coupling effects. The results indicate that NUE (+26.1 %) and N uptake (+15.0 %) in paddy fields increase more than in upland fields (+23.7 % and +8.0 %, respectively), with the coupling effect providing NH4+ predominantly for rice and NO3- for upland crops. NH4+ increases in paddy fields (+6.9 %) but decreases in upland fields (-0.7 %), while microbial biomass carbon (MBC) decreases in paddy fields (-2.9 %) and increases in upland fields (+36.0 %). These findings suggest that coupling effects supply soil inorganic nutrients in paddies and affect microbes in uplands, thereby positively affecting crop N utilization. Specifically, the greatest increase in paddy crop yield and N use efficiency occurs when the ratio of N fertilizer to biochar exceeds 1.5 %, and in uplands, it manifests when applying 10-20 t·ha-1 of biochar and <150 kg·ha-1 N fertilizer. In conclusion, this meta-analysis explores the differential effects of biochar and N fertilizer coupling in different arable land types, offering novel insights into the utilization strategies of biochar in agricultural fields.

A systematic review of biochar aging and the potential eco-environmental risk in heavy metal contaminated soil

Biochar is widely accepted as a green and effective amendment for remediating heavy metals (HMs) contaminated soil, but its long-term efficiency and safety changes with biochar aging in fields. Currently, some reviews have qualitatively summarized biochar aging methods and mechanisms, aging-induced changes in biochar properties, and often ignored the potential eco-environmental risk during biochar aging process. Therefore, this review systematically summarizes the study methods of biochar aging, quantitatively compares the effects of different biochar aging process on its properties, and discusses the potential eco-environmental risk due to biochar aging in HMs contaminated soil. At present, various artificial aging methods (physical aging, chemical aging and biological aging) rather than natural field aging have been applied to study the changes of biochar's properties. Generally, biochar aging increases specific surface area (SSA), pore volume (PV), surface oxygen-containing functional group (OFGs) and O content, while decreases pH, ash, H, C and N content. Chemical aging method has a greater effect on the properties of biochar than other aging methods. In addition, biochar aging may lead to HMs remobilization and produce new types of pollutants, such as polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs), environmentally persistent free radicals (EPFRs) and colloidal/nano biochar particles, which consequently bring secondary eco-environmental risk. Finally, future research directions are suggested to establish a more accurate assessment method and model on biochar aging behavior and evaluate the environmental safety of aged biochar, in order to promote its wider application for remediating HMs contaminated soil.

Biochar dose-dependent impacts on soil bacterial and fungal diversity across the globe

Biochar, a widely used material for soil amendment, has been found to offer numerous advantages in improving soil properties and the habitats for soil microorganisms. However, there is still a lack of global perspectives on the influence of various levels of biochar addition on soil microbial diversity and primary components. Thus, in our study, we performed a global meta-analysis of studies to determine how different doses of biochar affect soil total carbon (C), nitrogen (N), pH, alpha- and beta-diversity, and the major phyla of both bacterial and fungal communities. Our results revealed that biochar significantly increased soil pH by 4 %, soil total C and N by 68 % and 22 %, respectively, in which the positive effects increased with biochar doses. Moreover, biochar promoted soil bacterial richness and evenness by 3-8 % at the biochar concentrations of 1-5 % (w/w), while dramatically shifting bacterial beta-diversity at the doses of >2 % (w/w). Specifically, biochar exhibited significantly positive effects on bacterial phyla of Acidobacteria, Bacteroidetes, Gemmatimonadetes, and Proteobacteria, especially Deltaproteobacteria and Gammaproteobacteria, by 4-10 % depending on the concentrations. On the contrary, the bacterial phylum of Verrucomicrobia and fungal phylum of Basidiomycota showed significant negative responses to biochar by -8 % and -24 %, respectively. Therefore, our meta-analysis provides theoretical support for the development of optimized agricultural management practices by emphasizing biochar application dosing.

Biochar addition promotes soil organic carbon sequestration dominantly contributed by macro-aggregates in agricultural ecosystems of China

Soil aggregates play pivotal roles in soil organic carbon (SOC) preservation and climate change. Biochar has been widely applied in agricultural ecosystems to improve soil physicochemical properties. However, the underlying mechanisms of SOC sequestration by soil aggregation with biochar addition are not well understood at a large scale. Here, we conducted a meta-analysis of 2335 pairwise data from 45 studies to explore how soil aggregation sequestrated SOC after biochar addition in agricultural ecosystems of China. Biochar addition markedly enhanced the proportions of macro-aggregates and aggregate stability, and the production of organic binding agents positively facilitated the formation of macro-aggregates and aggregate stability. Soil aggregate-associated organic carbon (OC) indicated a significantly increasement by biochar addition, which was attributed to direct and indirect inputs of OC from biochar and organic residues, respectively. Biochar stimulated SOC sequestration dominantly contributed by macro-aggregates, and it could be interpreted by a greater improvement in proportions and OC protection of macro-aggregates. Furthermore, the SOC sequestration of soil aggregation with biochar addition was regulated by climate conditions (mean annual temperature and precipitation), biochar attributes (biochar C/N ratio and pH), experimental practices (biochar addition level and duration), and agronomic managements (land type, cropping intensity, fertilization condition, and crop type). Collectively, our synthetic analysis emphasized that biochar promoted the SOC sequestration by improving soil aggregation in agricultural ecosystems of China.

Biochar improves fertility in waste derived manufactured soils, but not resilience to climate change

We present a soil manufactured from waste materials, which could replace the use of peat and topsoil in plant production and reduce the pressure on natural soil resources. We tested the effect of the manufactured soil on ecosystem functions and microbial communities with and without plants present, and with and without biochar addition (Experiment 1). The resilience of the soil in response to drought and flooding, and also the effect of biochar was also tested (Experiment 2). Biochar increased soil C and N regardless of plant presence and negated the effect of the plant on soil peroxidase enzyme activity. The manufactured soil was largely resilient to drought, but not flooding, with negative impacts on microbial communities. Results indicate that biochar could improve soil properties, but not resilience to climatic perturbations. Results suggest that manufactured soils amended with biochar could offer a useful alternative to natural soil in many contexts.

Magnetic biochar enhanced copper immobilization in agricultural lands: Insights from adsorption precipitation and redox

Biochar has exceeded expectations for heavy metal immobilization and has been prepared from widely available sources and inexpensive materials. In this research, coconut shell biochar (CSB), bamboo biochar (BC), magnetic coconut shell charcoal (MCSB), and magnetic bamboo biochar (MBC) were manufactured via co-pyrolysis, and their adsorption properties were tested. The pseudo-secondary (R2 = 0.980-0.985) adsorption kinetic fittings for the four biochas were superior to the pseudo-primary kinetics (R2 = 0.969-0.982). Unmodified biochar adsorption isotherms were more consistent with the Freundlich model, while magnetic biochar fitted Langmuir models better. The maximum adsorption capacity of MCSB for Cu(Ⅱ) reached 371.50 mg g-1. The adsorption mechanisms quantitatively analysis of the biochar indicated that chemical precipitation and ion exchange contributed to the adsorption, in which the magnetic biochar metal-π complexation also enhanced the adsorption. The pot experiment revealed that MCSB (2.0 %DW) significantly enhanced the biomass of lettuce, and facilitated the immobilization of DTPA-Cu (p < 0.05). SEM-EDS, XPS, and FTIR were utilized for morphological characterization and functional group identification, and the increased active adsorption sites (-OH, -COOH, CO, and Fe-O) of MCSB enhanced chemisorption and π-π EDA complexation with Cu(Ⅱ). EEM-PARAFAC and RDA analysis further elucidated that magnetic biochar immobilized copper and reduced biotoxicity (efficiency: 76.12%) by adjusting soil pH, phosphate, and SOM release (negative correlation). The presence of iron oxides (FeOx) promoted in situ adsorption of metallic copper and offered new insights into soil remediation.