“It shouldn’t be something that's evil, it should be talked about”: A phenomenological approach to epilepsy and stigma

YouTube User Traffic to Paired Epilepsy Education Videos in English and Spanish: Comparative Study

Background

Effectively managing epilepsy in children necessitates the active engagement of parents, a factor that is reliant on their understanding of this neurological disorder. Widely available, high-quality, patient-focused, bilingual videos describing topics important for managing epilepsy are limited. YouTube Analytics is a helpful resource for gaining insights into how users of differing backgrounds consume video content.

Objective

This study analyzes traffic to paired educational videos of English and Spanish versions of the same content. By examining the use patterns and preferences of individuals seeking information in different languages, we gained valuable insights into how language influences the use of clinical content.

Methods

Physician experts created epilepsy management videos for the REACT (Reaching Out for Epilepsy in Adolescents and Children Through Telemedicine) YouTube channel about 17 subjects, with an English and Spanish version of each. The Children's Mercy Kansas City neurology clinic incorporated these into the department's educational process. YouTube Analytics enabled analysis of traffic patterns and video characteristics between September 2, 2021, and August 31, 2023.

Results

The Spanish group had higher engagement and click-through rates. The English versions of all videos had 141,605 total impressions, while impressions for the Spanish versions totaled 156,027. The Spanish videos had 11,339 total views, while the English videos had 3366. The views per month were higher for the Spanish videos (mean 472, SD 292) compared to the English set (mean 140, SD 91; P<.001). The two groups also differed in search behavior and external traffic sources, with WhatsApp driving more traffic to the Spanish videos than the English versions (94 views compared to 1). The frequency of search terms used varied by language. For example, "tonic clonic" was the most frequent term (n=372) resulting in views for English videos, while "tipos de convulsiones" (types of convulsions) was the most common expression (n=798) resulting in views for Spanish videos. We noted increased monthly views for all videos after adding tags on YouTube. Before tagging, the mean number of views per month for the English-language group was 61 (SD 28), which increased to 220 (SD 53) post tagging. A similar trend can be observed in the Spanish-language group as well. Before tagging, the mean number of monthly views was 201 (SD 71), which increased to 743 (SD 144) after tagging.

Conclusions

This study showed high traffic for Spanish video content related to epilepsy in a set of paired English/Spanish videos. This highlights the importance of bilingual health content and optimizing video content based on viewer preferences and search behavior. Understanding audience engagement patterns through YouTube Analytics can further enhance the dissemination of clinical video content to users seeking content in their primary language, and tagging videos can have a substantial impact on views.

Exploring religious coping strategies epilepsy patients in Turkey: A descriptive study

OBJECTIVE

It is seen that religious coping methods are used in the literature, but the existing literature on religious coping methods and coping strategies used by epilepsy patients is insufficient. Therefore, this study aimed to determine the positive and negative religious coping levels of epilepsy patients.

METHODS

This research is a descriptive research type. The research data were collected from patients with epilepsy living in a province in eastern Turkey between April and June 2024. The research population consists of epilepsy patients living in Erzurum province. The sample consisted of 154 patients who agreed to participate in the study. Data collection tools were "Questionnaire Form" and "Religious Coping Scale." Frequency, percentage calculations, mean and standard deviation values were used to evaluate the data. One Way Anova, Independent Sample t-test, Mann-Whitney U, and Pearson correlation tests were also used.

RESULTS

Positive religious coping scores (22.90 ± 5.35) and Negative religious coping scores (7.24 ± 3.25) of epilepsy patients were found to be at high levels. Participants' gender, marital status, occupation, income status, prayer, fasting, and Quran reading habits significantly affected their positive religious coping behaviors (p < 0.05). In addition, it was determined that as the age of the participants increased, they resorted to positive religious coping behaviors more (r: 0.215, p < 0.05).

CONCLUSIONS

The results of the study show that the positive and negative religious coping levels of epilepsy patients are high. In addition, the participants prefer positive religious coping behaviors more.

Individual and relational factors related to disclosure of epilepsy in the workplace

BACKGROUND

The decision to disclose epilepsy in the workplace is complex, as it entails both advantages and disadvantages. In this study, we aimed to identify the factors associated with disclosure of epilepsy in the workplace based on the disclosure decision-making model for patients who required underwent comprehensive assessment in the Epilepsy Monitoring Unit (EMU).

METHODS

This retrospective study included 193 patients with epilepsy (112 men, aged 18-66 years) who underwent comprehensive assessment, including long-term video-EEG monitoring, neuroimaging studies, and neuropsychological and psychosocial assessment in the Tohoku University Hospital EMU. Data were obtained from the medical records and self-reported questionnaires at our EMU. The outcome variable was disclosure of epilepsy. Predictive variables were selected based on the disclosure decision-making model: individual factors (i.e., age, sex, age at onset of epilepsy, seizure frequency, generalized tonic-clonic seizures or focal to bilateral tonic-clonic seizures in the last 2 years, experiences of viewing own seizure, and felt stigma), and relational factors (i.e., experiences of discrimination, enacted stigma, and social support). Data were analyzed using a logistic regression analysis model.

RESULTS

Our results indicated that 43.5% of patients disclosed epilepsy to their employer. The factors that associated with disclosure of epilepsy were experiences of discrimination (odds ratio [OR], 7.78; 95% confidence interval [CI], 2.84-21.34, p < 0.01), experiences of viewing own seizure (OR, 3.51; 95% CI, 1.27-9.72, p < 0.05), and level of enacted stigma (OR, 0.69; 95% CI, 0.48-0.99, p < 0.05).

CONCLUSION

This study indicated that the decision to disclose epilepsy was associated with both individual factors, such as experience of viewing own seizures, and relational factors, such as experience of discrimination and enacted stigma.

Living with epilepsy in adolescence and young adulthood transitioning from pediatric to adult hospital services: A systematic review and meta-synthesis of qualitative studies

BACKGROUND

Transition is characterized by developing greater self-identity and growing independence, but adolescents dealing with chronic illnesses encounter health-related and situational changes during transition. Despite the many suggestions made in recent years, the shift from pediatric to adult care continues to pose difficulties for adolescents and young adults with epilepsy (AWE). The holistic perspective of AWE's experiences and needs during transition is not as well understood.

AIM

To synthesize the qualitative evidence related to AWE's experiences and needs transitioning from pediatric to adult hospital care.

METHODS

This systematic review adhered to the rigorous Joanna Briggs methodology for qualitative evidence synthesis. A comprehensive search was conducted across multiple databases, including PubMed, CINAHL, Scopus, Embase, PsycINFO, and ProQuest Dissertations & Theses Global, from their inception to April 2024. The findings were critically appraised and aggregated using meta-synthesis.

RESULTS

The search yielded a total of 3,985 studies, and twenty-one were included in the review. Two of the included studies were undertaken in a program where a transition clinic was established. The meta-synthesis reveals that the transition experience of AWE is more than a change from one clinic to another and is interwoven into a pattern of developmental, health-illness, situational, and organizational transition issues. Five synthesized findings were developed: 1) Feeling different from others and striving to address the impact of epilepsy in everyday life; 2) the transition from pediatric to adult care - a problematic intersection point; 3) the family's role - support or parental overprotectiveness 4) seeking knowledge and being familiar with epilepsy supported by healthcare professionals and technologies, and 5) development of independence and responsibility through involvement and support from healthcare professionals and parents.

CONCLUSION

During the transition from pediatric to adult hospital care, AWEs encounter a loss of familiarity, increased responsibility, and feelings of not belonging. Therefore, it is essential to create an environment where they can thrive beyond the limitations of their illness. Understanding, acceptance, and inclusivity should characterize this environment to support AWEs in facilitating the development of responsibility, independence, and confidence as they navigate transitions.

Stamp Out Stigma: a national campaign to decrease stigma and increase behavioral health in fire service

Firefighters are at risk for behavioral health problems; however, mental health stigma is a barrier to seeking treatment. Although effective treatments exist, many firefighters report that internal stigma prohibits presentation for effective care. This study aimed to decrease stigma about behavioral health in fire service through the development and delivery of a peer-led anti-stigma intervention campaign called Stamp Out Stigma (SOS). SOS consisted of three related phases. During Phase 1 (n = 12), we produced testimonials and piloted the videos with firefighters to determine which were most compelling. During Phase 2 (n = 23), we beta-tested our training curriculum with two departments, resulting in a significant decrease in internalized stigma but not in self-stigma. During Phase 3 (n = 73), we presented the curriculum to two cohorts of firefighters. Participation in the SOS workshop was associated with a significant decrease in firefighters' self-stigma from pre-, M = 22.7, SD = 6.3, to post-workshop, M = 20.8, SD = 5.5, t(66) = 3.2, p = 0.002. Participation in the SOS workshop was associated with a significant decrease in firefighters' internalized stigma, M = 2.0, SD = 0.5, to post-workshop, M = 1.8, SD = 0.4, t(66) = 2.8, p = 0.007. The SOS approach to stigma reduction is promising for modifying negative attitudes toward mental health and treatment seeking among professional firefighters.

Shame, stigma, and social exclusion: The lived experiences of epileptic patients in a health facility in Ilorin, Nigeria

BACKGROUND

The highest number of persons living with epilepsy (PLWE) are in Africa and the majority live in deplorable conditions, while dealing with varying layers of stigma, social exclusion, and discrimination.

OBJECTIVE

This study explored the lived experiences of PLWE in Ilorin.

METHODS

Adopting a qualitative design and a phenomenological lens, 10 PLWE between the ages of 18 and 60 were purposively selected from the University of Ilorin Teaching Hospital (UITH) for in-depth interviews.

RESULTS

Findings suggest that PLWE bear multiple and intersecting burdens, including physical injuries; institutional, cultural, and economic constraints; psychological strain; social exclusion; and stigma. These disadvantages are often sustained and reproduced by various assumptions about epilepsy; as such, PLWE conceal their condition, and this implicatively reinforce stigma. Difficulty sustaining intimate relationships, overt physical scars, and inferiority complexes are recurrent challenges for PLWE. The study showed that adherence to drugs, self-management, personal precautions towards seizure signs, and family support are important coping strategies.

CONCLUSION

The study recommends that it is imperative to enhance and sustain systems, processes, and attitudes that prioritise the physical, social, and emotional needs of PLWE, because this is significant for their enhanced quality of life (QoL).

Stigma experiences of patients living with gastroparesis

INTRODUCTION

Stigmatization toward chronic digestive diseases is well documented. Patients perceive others hold negative stereotypes toward their disease and may internalize these beliefs as true. Because of this, stigmatization is associated with poor outcomes across disease-related and psychosocial domains. No study to date evaluates stigmatization toward patients living with gastroparesis (GP), a poorly understood disease affecting gastric motility. We aimed to gain deep understanding of stigma in patients living with gastroparesis.

METHODS

Patients with GP were recruited from two university-based gastroenterology practices as well as patient advocacy support groups. Participants underwent a semi-structured qualitative interview about their experiences with stigma related to their GP diagnosis, which were audio-recorded and transcribed to text for analysis using a grounded theory approach. Major themes with representative quotations were documented.

RESULTS

Twenty-three patients participated. The majority were White, female, with idiopathic GP under the care of a gastroenterologist. All patients reported stigma related to GP. Seven major themes were found: stigma from healthcare providers, stigma within interpersonal relationships, GP as an invisible disease, blame, unsolicited suggestions on how to manage disease, disclosure, and stigma resistance.

CONCLUSIONS

This is the first study to describe stigma experiences in patients with GP. The results suggest patients experience considerable stigmatization toward their condition from multiple sources. Patients also demonstrated resistance to negative beliefs, which can serve as a protective factor for the negative effects of disease stigma. Clinicians should be aware of stigma in GP patients, including their own potential internal biases and behaviors.

Experiences of stigma in people with epilepsy: A meta-synthesis of qualitative evidence

OBJECTIVE

Stigma is reported to cause as much distress and effect on quality of life for individuals with epilepsy as the physical symptoms of seizures. Existing quantitative reviews have focused on describing levels of stigma in epilepsy, but no qualitative review has been undertaken despite the increasing number of relevant studies. We provide a qualitative synthesis to aid the understanding of stigma experiences in adults with epilepsy across different sociocultural contexts.

METHODS

A systematic database search yielded an initial set of 3,032 relevant papers, of which 28 were included. A meta-synthesis was conducted according to a meta-ethnographic approach which has been adapted for health research.

RESULTS

Five themes were generated: 1) Societal negative perceptions of epilepsy result in discrimination and rejection; 2) Internal attributions of blame lead to negative self-perception and shame; 3) Stigma impacts everyday life and contributes to reliance on others; 4) Stigma is managed through concealment and avoidance; 5) Support from others is beneficial but dependant on own and others' understandings of epilepsy. These themes highlighted the key individual experiences of epilepsy stigma, which appeared to some degree culture-specific. Culturally-informed misconceptions of epilepsy were readily internalised, resulting in emotional challenges and affecting participants' lives. Strategies for coping with this were also described.

SIGNIFICANCE

This synthesis characterised the experiences of stigma among adults with epilepsy and highlighted key similarities and differences in these experiences across sociocultural contexts. Educational programmes to inform communities about epilepsy hold importance going forward.

Burden of epilepsy in Latin America and The Caribbean: a trend analysis of the Global Burden of Disease Study 1990 - 2019

Background

The epilepsy prevalence in Latin America and the Caribbean (LAC) had remained high over the last 20 years. Data on the burden of epilepsy are needed for healthcare planning and resource allocation. However, no systematic analysis had been performed for epilepsy burden in LAC.

Methods

We extracted data of all LAC countries from the Global Burden of Disease (GBD) study from 1990 to 2019. Epilepsy burden was measured as prevalence, mortality, and disability-adjusted life-years (DALYs; defined by the sum of years of life lost [YLLs] for premature mortality and years lived with disability [YLDs]), by age, sex, year, and country. Absolute numbers, rates, and 95% uncertainty intervals were reported. We performed correlational analyses among burden metrics and Socio-demographic Index (SDI).

Findings

The burden of epilepsy decreased around 20% in LAC, led by YLLs reduction. In 2019, 6·3 million people were living with active epilepsy of all causes (95% UI 5·3 - 7·4), with 3·22 million (95% UI 2·21 - 4·03) and 3·11 million (95% UI 2·21 to 4·03) cases of epilepsy with identifiable aetiology and idiopathic epilepsy, respectively. The number of DALYs represented the 9·51% (1.37 million, 95% UI 0·99 -1·86) of the global epilepsy burden in 2019. The age-standardized burden was 175·9 per 100 000 population (95% UI 119·4 - 253·3), which tend to have a bimodal age distribution (higher in the youth and elderly) and was driven by high YLDs estimates. The burden was higher in men and older adults, primarily due to high YLLs and mortality. Alcohol use was associated with 17% of the reported DALYs. The SDI estimates significantly influenced this burden (countries with high SDI have less epilepsy burden and mortality, but not prevalence or disability).

Interpretation

The epilepsy burden has decreased in LAC over the past 30 years. Even though, LAC is still ranked as the third region with the highest global epilepsy burden. This reduction was higher in children, but burden and mortality increased for older adults. The epilepsy burden is disability predominant; however, the mortality-related estimates are still higher than in other regions. Alcohol consumption and countries' development are important determinants of this burden. There is an urgent need to improve access to epilepsy care in LAC, particularly for older adults. Strengthening primary care with online learning and telemedicine tools, and promoting risk factors modification should be prioritized in the region.

Funding

This research was self-funded by the authors.

"Do I still have epilepsy?" Epilepsy identity 15-20 years after anterior temporal lobectomy

OBJECTIVE

Identity is a multifaceted construct, comprising personal identity (sense of being a unique individual) and social identity (the sense-of-self derived from membership of social groups). Social identity involves explicit identification with a group ("I am …") and implicit behaviors or attitudes associated with group membership. Following successful treatment with surgery, patients with epilepsy can undergo a complex and lasting change in personal identity. To date, there has been no research into postoperative social epilepsy identity (SEI). We sought to examine SEI 15-20 years post-surgery, and the relationship between SEI and satisfaction with surgery, psychosocial improvements, mood, and health-related quality of life (HRQoL).

METHODS

Thirty-two patients who underwent anterior temporal lobectomy (ATL; 19 female) were recruited, with a median follow-up of 18 years (interquartile range [IQR] = 2.5). Using a novel interactive online program, we collected data on SEI, satisfaction with surgery, and perceived psychosocial improvements, alongside standardized measures of mood (Neurological Disorders Depressio Inventory-Epilepsy; Patient Health Questionnaire-Generalised Anxiety Disorder-7 item) and HRQoL (Quality of Life in Epilepsy-31 item). Non-parametric analyses were used to analyse the data.

RESULTS

Twenty-five percent of patients were free of disabling seizures since surgery, yet 65% stated they no longer had epilepsy and >90% reported satisfaction with surgery. Explicitly discarding SEI was positively associated with HRQoL at long-term follow-up, over and above seizure outcome. Implicit SEI was expressed as (a) acceptance of epilepsy, (b) a sense of belonging to the epilepsy community, and (c) difficulty disclosing and discussing epilepsy. Difficulty disclosing and discussing epilepsy was associated with increased anxiety and lower HRQoL.

SIGNIFICANCE

At long-term follow-up, over half of our patients reported an explicit change in SEI, which could promote better HRQoL. In contrast, difficulty with disclosure of epilepsy was associated with increased anxiety and reduced HRQoL, possibly reflecting the ongoing effects of stigma. These findings highlight the importance of understanding changes in patient social identity for promoting long-term well-being after surgery.

Stigma experienced by patients with epilepsy: A systematic review and meta-synthesis of qualitative studies

BACKGROUND

Epilepsy, one of the most common and serious chronic neurological diseases, is accompanied by a series of complex psychosocial problems. A number of qualitative studies have investigated the stigma experiences among patients with epilepsy (PWE). However, the findings are different and complementary to a certain degree. We conducted a systematic review to investigate and synthesize existing qualitative research findings to fully identify stigma experienced by PWE. The aim was to develop anti-stigma interventions and reduce any adverse sequelae.

OBJECTIVE

To synthesize qualitative evidence on the stigma experiences of PWE.

METHODS

This was a systematic review and qualitative evidence synthesis guided by the Joanna Briggs Methodology. Systematic literature search for primary studies was conducted in PubMed, PsychINFO, EMBASE, and Web of Science databases until December 2019. Findings from the included qualitative studies were extracted, assessed for quality, and aggregated using meta-synthesis.

RESULTS

Twenty-six studies were included in the review. Four distinct synthesized findings were identified from the original researches: 'stigma experienced in daily life'; 'stigma perceived from others'; 'psychological reactions to stigma'; and 'strategies to address stigma'.

CONCLUSION

The present meta-synthesis thoroughly investigated the stigma experienced by PWE. The findings suggest that appropriate multi-level interventions targeting the general public, health professionals, caregivers, and patients themselves are warranted to reduce the harmful impacts of stigma.

Factors associated with self-efficacy among patients with epilepsy in Turkey

PURPOSE

This study aimed to determine the self-efficacy levels of individuals with epilepsy and also compare individuals' self-efficacy with sociodemographic and epilepsy-related characteristics.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

The cross-sectional study was carried out with 200 individuals with epilepsy who were suitable for the inclusion criterias. Data were collected using patient information form which includes sociodemographic and clinical characteristics and Epilepsy Self-Efficacy Scale for evaluating epilepsy-related self-efficacy levels of patients.

RESULTS

The self-efficacy levels of the patients were moderate. Education, gender, occupational status, income, seizure frequency, regular use of medication, the number of drugs used, patient behavior following a drug-related problem, family support, the ability to obtain information about the illness, and hiding the illness from other people were significant factors determining scores on the epilepsy self-efficacy scale.

CONCLUSION

This study confirms the findings of previous studies that were conducted to determine factors affecting self-efficacy. In order to increase self-efficacy, the findings show that there is a need for social support, education of epilepsy individuals, and information and awareness in society.

"I Don't Like to Make a Big Thing out of It": A Qualitative Interview-Based Study Exploring Factors Affecting Whether Young People Tell or Do Not Tell Their Friends about Their IBD

Inflammatory Bowel Disease (IBD) describes a group of conditions that includes Crohn's disease and ulcerative colitis. Unlike some chronic conditions, to a greater or lesser extent, IBD is hidden from or invisible to others which enables concealment of the condition, especially when stigma is associated with the condition. Concealment or nondisclosure allows a means of identity management. Disclosure of a chronic condition is not a single event, and it is dependent on many factors. There is little literature that specifically addresses stigma and/or disclosure in relation to children and young people with IBD. An in-depth qualitative study was undertaken, framed by Interpretive Description and using interviews, friendship maps, and photographs within a participatory framework. Public and patient involvement and engagement (PPIE) was undertaken throughout (inception to dissemination) the study. Young people aged 14-25 years with IBD who had participated in the survey phase of the larger study self-selected to participate in interviews that focused broadly on friendship and feelings of social connectedness. Data were analysed using an iterative, interpretive approach. Preliminary themes were developed and these were explored further, and then tentative theoretical connections about friendship were developed. One superordinate theme focused on disclosure. Thirty-one young people (16 males, 15 females, mean age 18.7 years; 24 Crohn's, 7 colitis) participated in the interviews (of these, five created friendship maps and six utilised photographs). Three discrete, but interlinked, themes were generated, revealing young people's experiences of disclosure: to tell or not to tell; controlling the flow: the who, when, what, and how of telling; and reactions and responses to telling: anticipated and actual. Decisions about telling friends about having IBD are challenging for many young people. Having control over disclosure is not always possible, and the potential consequences can feel risky. However, most young people had positive experiences of disclosure and gained support from friends and romantic partners. Most young people downplayed the seriousness of their IBD, revealing some facets of their condition, aiming to sustain their self-identity. Only one young person had been given professional support to disclose. Provision of support and opportunities to discuss whether, when, who, and how to tell friends and what the risks and benefits may be is something that could be woven into an ongoing and wider person-centred dialogue between young people and health professionals within routine clinic visits.

Experience of epilepsy: Coping strategies and health outcomes among Ghanaians living with epilepsy

PURPOSE

The purpose of this study was to assess the coping strategies of people living with epilepsy (PLWEs) and their health outcomes.

METHODS

This was a descriptive-exploratory, qualitative study. Face-to-face, in-depth interviews were carried out on a purposive sample of 13 PLWEs using a semi-structured interview guide. Interviews were audiotaped and transcribed verbatim, and the data were analyzed using the content analysis approach.

RESULTS

Positive coping strategies adopted included problem-focused coping, faith in God, social support, and lifestyle changes. Negative coping strategies adopted were thinking and worrying and concealing diagnosis. Treatment modalities for epilepsy were spiritual intervention, traditional, or orthodox medicines or a combination of two or more. A reduction in the frequency and severity of seizures was a positive outcome, and the worsening of seizures was a negative outcome.

CONCLUSION

The consultation of spiritualists and herbalists for treatment was a reflection of their beliefs about the causes of epilepsy among the participants. There is a need for increased education on epilepsy in Ghana.

Disclosure strategies in adults with epilepsy when telling, "I have epilepsy": The How2tell study

OBJECTIVE

To generate evidence-based knowledge about the strategies that adult people with epilepsy (PWEs) use in the process of telling others about their epilepsy.

METHODS

In-depth, one-to-one interviews explored PWEs' first-hand experiences of self-disclosure (or not), and grounded theory methods of inductive-deductive analysis were used to identify strategies used in disclosing. Interviews were audio-recorded, transcribed, coded, and independently recoded by two researchers using a coding framework specifically developed in this study. To account for maximum variation, PWEs (aged 18+ years) with different life experiences and situations relating to (1) gender, (2) age, (3) employment status, (4) personal relationships, (5) family relationship, (6) support group involvement, and (7) seizure frequency were included. Given the many variables and psychosocial issues associated with epilepsy, demographic details and validated measures including Quality of Life in Epilepsy-10-P, Coping Inventory of Stressful Situations-Adult, and Patient Health Questionnaire-9 were used to describe the characteristics of participants and to contextualize the results.

RESULTS

Forty-nine adults with epilepsy participated. Data analysis revealed six interrelated categories (with subcategories) of the strategies that PWEs reported using in the process of disclosure: (1) concerns about disclosing; (2) weighing up who and when to tell; (3) opportunities for telling; (4) moment of disclosure-how to construct the message; (5) tailoring the message to audience needs-altering the message when telling family members, partner, friends, children, or employer and workplace colleagues; and (6) managing reactions by making it ordinary.

SIGNIFICANCE

People with epilepsy use a range of different strategies during the process of disclosing their epilepsy. These strategies were used to inform the development of the How2tell multimedia self-management resource for PWEs on self-disclosure in everyday social and life situations. How2tell is designed to benefit PWEs by empowering them with practical information about the process of telling another person, "I have epilepsy."

Perceived interpersonal and institutional discrimination among persons with disability in the U.S.: Do patterns differ by age?

RATIONALE

One-third of U.S. adults have an activity-limiting health condition and this proportion increases with age. However, it is unclear whether functional limitation renders one vulnerable to institutional and interpersonal discrimination, and whether this vulnerability differs over the life course. Stigma theories suggest disability would be more discrediting to younger persons relative to older adults, as it violates cultural norms and expectations regarding able-bodied working-age adults.

OBJECTIVE

We evaluate whether U.S. adults with functional impairment report higher levels of perceived interpersonal mistreatment and institutional discrimination relative to persons without impairment, and whether these patterns differ across age groups.

METHOD

We use data from the second wave of the National Survey of Midlife Development in the United States (MIDUS II), collected between 2004 and 2006 (n = 3931). We estimate OLS and logistic regression models to predict interpersonal and institutional discrimination, respectively.

RESULTS

Persons with impairment report more frequent encounters of disrespectful treatment, insults, and being treated as if they have a character flaw, and elevated odds of workplace- and service-related discrimination, net of sociodemographic, and physical and mental health characteristics. Effects are significantly larger among early (age 40-49) and late (age 50-64) midlife versus older (age 65+) adults.

CONCLUSIONS

We discuss implications for policy and practice, and underscore that stigmatization processes may further amplify health and socioeconomic disparities between those with versus without functional limitations.

The misdiagnosis of functional disorders as other neurological conditions

BACKGROUND

Several studies have shown that when patients with functional neurological disorders are followed up, it is rare to find another neurological condition that better explains the initial symptoms in hindsight. No study has examined the reverse, studying patients with a range of neurological disease diagnoses with the aim of assessing how often a new diagnosis of functional disorder better explains the original symptoms.

METHODS

A prospective multi-centre cohort study of 2637 new neurology outpatient referrals from primary care in Scotland. Neurologists provided initial diagnoses and a rating of the extent to which their symptoms were explained by an 'organic' neurological disease. Patients were followed up 19 months later with a questionnaire to their primary care physician asking about diagnostic change, and when indicated also by discussion with the original assessing neurologist and review of secondary care records.

RESULTS

Valid responses were obtained for 2378 out of 2637 patients (90%) with symptoms 'largely' or 'completely' explained by organic disease at baseline. At follow-up, we found diagnostic errors in 48 patients. Of those, ten (0.4%) had a functional diagnosis and 38 patients (1.6%) had a different 'organic' diagnosis which better explained the original symptoms.

CONCLUSIONS

Patients diagnosed with neurological disease sometimes have a functional diagnosis at follow-up which, with hindsight, better explains the original symptoms. This occurs at a frequency similar to the misdiagnosis of 'organic' neurological disease as functional disorder. Misdiagnosis can harm patients in either direction, especially as we enter an era of evidence-based treatment for functional neurological disorders.

Does public attitude change by labeling a person as epileptic, person with epilepsy or the acronym PWE? A systematic review

PURPOSE

It is still unknown if attitudinal differences by diverse labeling of persons with epilepsy could be universally accepted with the actual literature evidence. The manner in which questions are constructed could also have an impact in final results. The purpose of this systematic review was to examine the published articles regarding changes in public´s attitude towards epilepsy by labeling a person as epileptic, person with epilepsy or with the acronym PWE.

METHODS

We undertook a systematic review of the literature using common databases with specific keywords and combinations searching for original articles, meta-analysis and systematic reviews. Sociodemographic variables, attitude results and questions style were analyzed in included articles.

RESULTS

Four original articles were found. Significant attitudinal changes were described in three studies with the label person with epilepsy. One study failed to demonstrate an attitudinal change by distinct labeling of a person with epilepsy. All questions were formulated in a personal way. Few neutral and mostly induced questions were found in the studies.

CONCLUSION

By the use of the label "person with epilepsy" there is a trend towards positive changes in public's attitudes, although evidence is scarce to consider this tendency as universally applicable. More studies are needed considering widespread social and cultural backgrounds and patient opinion. Language power by wording type could be a key consideration for future studies.

Muslim Women's use of contraception in the United States

Background

American Muslim women are an understudied population; thus, significant knowledge gaps exist related to their most basic health behaviors and indicators. Considering this, we examined American Muslim women’s contraception utilization patterns.

Methods

Self-reported data collected in late 2015 were analyzed. Women who identified as Muslim, were at least 18 years old, sexually active, and current residents of the United States (n = 224) met the inclusion criteria. Convenience sampling was employed. Multivariate logistic regression models estimated associations between demographics, marital status, ethnicity, nativity, health insurance, religious practice, and contraception use.

Results

Identifying as Muslim, in general, was significantly associated with greater odds of using contraception in general and condoms compared to American Muslim women who identify as Sunni. Identifying as Shia was associated with greater odds of using oral contraceptive pills relative to Sunni respondents. South Asian ethnicity was associated with higher odds of using oral contraceptive pills compared to those of Middle Eastern or North African ethnicity.

Conclusions

Findings suggest American Muslim women’s contraception utilization patterns share certain similarities with both American women in general and disadvantaged racial and ethnic minority groups in the United States, implying that factors that influence American Muslim women’s use of contraceptives are possibly countervailing and likely multifaceted. More research is needed to accurately identify associates of contraceptive use in this population. This work serves as a starting point for researchers and practitioners seeking to better understand reproductive health decision in this understudied population.

‘I’d rather you didn’t come’: The impact of stigma on exercising with epilepsy

Epilepsy is a common but hidden disorder, leading to stigma in everyday life. Despite stigma being widely researched, little is known about the impact of stigma for people with epilepsy within a sports and exercise setting. Using constructionist grounded theory, we explored the barriers and adaptations to exercise for people with epilepsy. Three focus groups (2–3 participants per group) and three semi-structured interviews were conducted (11 participants in total). Stigma negatively impacted joining team sports, running groups, and disclosure to others. The effect of stigma was reduced by educating others about epilepsy, thus creating more awareness and understanding.

Barriers and facilitators to epilepsy self-management for patients with physical and psychological co-morbidity

Objectives This exploratory study identifies barriers and facilitators to self-management to inform future epilepsy self-management interventions for persons who have epilepsy complicated by co-morbid mental health conditions and serious medical events. Methods Focus group methods were used in a series of community advisory board meetings. Analysis was conducted using a thematic, constant comparative approach aiming to describe the range of barriers and facilitators salient to participants. There were a total of 22 participants, including 8 health professionals, 9 patients with epilepsy, and 5 care partners. Mean age was 49.1 (SD = 11.0, range 32-69), 11 (50%) were female, and 11 (50%) were male. For those with epilepsy, mean years having epilepsy was 24.7 (SD = 19.9, range 1-58 years). Results Individual psychological barriers (mental illness, fatigue, and psychological distress) prominently interfered with health behaviors. Community and family barriers included stigma, lack of epilepsy knowledge, and poor social support. Facilitators included planning for seizures, learning about medications, stress management, socializing with others, and talking with other epilepsy patients. Discussion Qualitative evidence in this study suggests a linkage between social integration and positive health behaviors. Future efforts to embed patients with epilepsy and their caregivers into clinical care processes could offset barriers and enhance facilitators.

A day in the life of a Ménière's patient: understanding the lived experiences and mental health impacts of Ménière's disease

Concepts of social practice are increasingly being used to understand experiences of everyday life, particularly in relation to consumption and healthy lifestyles. This article builds on this in the context of lives disrupted and reshaped by chronic illness. It uses social practice theory to examine the lived experiences of individuals with Ménière's disease; a long-term progressive vestibular disorder, defined by episodes of severe and debilitating vertigo, aural fullness, tinnitus and sensorineural hearing loss. Drawing on the findings of 20 in-depth narrative interviews with Ménière's patients, and eight spousal/partner interviews, we explore the impacts of the condition on sensory, temporal, spatial and social dimensions of the body. In doing so, we highlight the intensely embodied sensory and emotional work required to maintain connections between the 'competences', 'materials' and 'meanings' that constitute and sustain the performance of both mundane and meaningful social practices over time. As connections between these elements of social practice are disrupted during more active phases of the condition, affected individuals may be defected from old practices and recruited to new ones, often requiring both time and social support to find meaning or pleasure in these alternative ways of being in the world.

Becoming comfortable with "my" epilepsy: Strategies that patients use in the journey from diagnosis to acceptance and disclosure

OBJECTIVE

Proponents of resilience theory have highlighted the importance of understanding the processes of resilience. The objective of the study was to explore how people with epilepsy reach a stage of being comfortable with their epilepsy. Identifying the processes used is important to developing effective self-management for people who are newly diagnosed with epilepsy.

METHOD

A grounded theory approach involving forty-nine consenting adult people with epilepsy (18 years and over), was used to explore their first-hand experiences of coming to terms with their epilepsy. Data were collected using one-to-one interview to elicit in-depth personal accounts of people with epilepsy's experiences of adjusting to their diagnosis of epilepsy. Using grounded theory's systematic inductive-deductive process data of analysis, the core findings that emerged from the open coding and inductive phase were analyzed independently by two researchers to ensure that findings were verified and validated across the interview dataset.

FINDINGS

Three core categories emerged as central to the journey that people experience after receiving their diagnosis of epilepsy towards becoming comfortable with their epilepsy. These were: i) meaning of "my" epilepsy diagnosis, to capture people with epilepsy's feelings, reactions and concerns after being diagnosed with epilepsy, ii) useful strategies, to identify what people with epilepsy did to become comfortable with their diagnosis, and iii) being comfortable with my epilepsy, to account for the frame of mind of people with epilepsy when they reach a point of accepting their diagnosis.

DISCUSSION

The findings provide important insights into the personal experiences of people with epilepsy after receiving their diagnosis and identifies a range of strategies they find useful in helping them reach a position of acceptance and being 'comfortable with my epilepsy'.

The experience of epilepsy in later life: A qualitative exploration of illness representations

The objective of this study was to explore how older people living with epilepsy appraise their condition through their lived-experience. The common-sense model of illness representations (CSMIR) provides a framework to explain how individuals make sense of and manage health threats. Semi-structured in-depth interviews based on the CSMIR were conducted with ten people with epilepsy who were above the age of 65. The results were analyzed using Interpretative Phenomenological Analysis. Three overarching themes emerged from the analysis: 'the power of epilepsy', 'they say you can live a normal life but you can't' and 'attempts to adjust and cope'. Epilepsy was described as a threatening, persistent, and unpredictable condition associated with distressing experiences. Participants described a process of balancing negative psychosocial consequences including stigma, loss of control, and reliance on other people and medication with parallel co-existing coping strategies. These attempts to manage the condition were characterized by a desire for acceptance and increased awareness of epilepsy, strategies to restore loss of control, and strength derived from supportive relationships. We conclude that there is large scope for psychosocial interventions in healthcare provision for this patient group. The roles of specialist nursing, relationship-centered models, psychotherapy, educational, and self-management programs are highlighted.

Living in the epilepsy treatment gap in rural South India: A focused ethnography of women and problems associated with stigma

In India, women with epilepsy face unique challenges. A focused ethnography of six women within the epilepsy treatment gap was conducted in rural South India. Women were asked to describe their day-to-day lives. Data were collected through open-ended, semistructured interview questions, participant observation, and field notes. Thematic analysis was done. The disease-related stigma contributed to the women's physical, psychological, and emotional struggles; the women and their family members made every effort to conceal the disease. Educational interventions to create awareness could help women seek effective treatments for their seizures, thereby reducing the stigma and improving the quality of their lives.

Muslim Women's Experiences with Stigma, Abuse, and Depression: Results of a Sample Study Conducted in the United States

PURPOSE

The aim of this study was to explore associations between internalized stigma, exposure to physical abuse, experiences with sexual abuse, and depression in Muslim women residing in the United States.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

We analyzed self-reported data collected online in late 2015. Women who self-identified as Muslim, were at least 18 years old, and were residents of the United States met the inclusion criteria (n = 373). Logistic regression models were used to estimate associations between socioeconomic status, nativity, and the abovementioned indicators.

RESULTS

Internalized stigma measured through heightened vigilance was associated with depression. Each increase in the abbreviated heightened vigilance scale (higher scores indicate lower vigilance) was associated with 7.6% lower odds of meeting the Center for Epidemiologic Studies Depression Scale 10 (CES-D 10) cutoff for depression (OR = 0.924, 95% CI = 0.888-0.962, p < 0.001). Among individual factors, education, household income, experience with physical abuse, and exposure to sexual abuse were associated with depression. Respondents who reported experiencing physical abuse had almost two times higher odds of meeting the cutoff for depression relative to respondents who had not experienced physical abuse (OR = 1.994, 95% CI = 1.180-3.372, p < 0.01). Likewise, respondents who reported exposure to sexual abuse had over two times higher odds of depression compared with respondents who had not been exposed to sexual abuse (OR = 2.288, 95% CI = 1.156-4.528, p < 0.05).

CONCLUSIONS

These findings were from a group of well educated wealthy respondents; however, experience with negative exposures and rates of depression were high. Further research replicating these findings and evaluating evidence-based interventions designed to improve screening for mental illnesses and retention in care with this hard-to-reach population could produce valuable outcomes, particularly for clinicians and public health practitioners committed to improving population health.

How Does Stigma Affect People Living with HIV? The Mediating Roles of Internalized and Anticipated HIV Stigma in the Effects of Perceived Community Stigma on Health and Psychosocial Outcomes

Few researchers have attempted to examine the mechanisms through which HIV-related stigma in the community is processed and experienced at an individual level by people living with HIV. We examined how the effects of perceived HIV stigma in the community on health outcomes for people living with HIV are mediated by internalized stigma and anticipated stigma. Participants (N = 203) from an HIV clinic completed self-report measures and their clinical data were obtained from medical records. Results suggested that the association between perceived community stigma and affective, cognitive, and mental health outcomes (self-esteem, depressive symptoms, avoidance coping, self-blame) are mediated by internalized stigma. Furthermore, a serial mediation model suggested that perceived community stigma leads to internalized stigma, which leads to anticipated community stigma, which in turn leads to lower medication adherence. The associations between perceived community stigma and interpersonal outcomes (social support, trust in physicians) were mediated by internalized stigma and anticipated stigma, again in a serial fashion (perceived community stigma leads to internalized stigma, which leads to anticipated stigma, which in turn leads to interpersonal outcomes). These results suggest that perceived HIV-related stigma in the community may cause people living with HIV to internalize stigma and anticipate stigmatizing experiences, resulting in adverse health and psychosocial outcomes-information that can be used to shape interventions.

Social Behavioral Problems and the Health-Related Quality of Life in Children and Adolescents with Epilepsy

OBJECTIVE

The purpose of this study was to investigate the impact of specific behavioral problems on the health-related quality of life (HRQOL) in children and adolescents with epilepsy.

METHODS

Children and adolescents with epilepsy (n=92; age range=6-17 years) and their mothers completed questionnaires about behavioral problems, HRQOL, socio-demographics, and epilepsy-related variables. To determine significant predictor variables of the HRQOL, the stepwise regression analyses and partial correlations were performed to adjust for other behavioral problems and covariates.

RESULTS

The analyses revealed that an increase in social behavioral problems and delinquent behavior was associated with a decrease in the HRQOL. Lower levels of maternal education and the number of antiepileptic drugs were also associated with a decline in the HRQOL; the HRQOL and social behavioral problems remained significantly correlated after adjusting for maternal education level, number of antiepileptic drugs, and non-social behavioral problems.

CONCLUSION

Parents and practitioners should provide intervention if behavioral problems, particularly social behavioral problems, are observed in children or adolescents with epilepsy.

Experiences of university students disclosing epilepsy to peers: ‘It's a shared thing now’

Introduction

While disclosure of concealable conditions like epilepsy can create social support, it may cause relationships to disintegrate. Friendship in young adulthood is pivotal in the transition to emotional autonomy, yet little is known about peer disclosure by university students with epilepsy. This qualitative study aimed to map key features in the process of epilepsy disclosure.

Method

Semi-structured interviews were completed with eight young adults (aged 18–25 years) with epilepsy enrolled in or recently graduated from Irish universities.

Findings

Thematic analysis yielded four main themes: (1) Assessing the disclosure recipient; (2) Managing the presentation of epilepsy; (3) Forging alliances; and (4) Feeling more positive. The process of disclosure centred on enlisting the support of allies deemed trustworthy by participants. Disclosure messages presented epilepsy neutrally to bolster allies' commitment to the role. Although participants viewed disclosure as beneficial to wellbeing, concern was expressed about acquiring a stigmatised social identity.

Conclusion

Occupational therapists are well placed to support young adults through the process of disclosure. Promoting a positive collective identity through peer mentorship promises to disrupt stigma. More broadly, partnerships between occupational therapists and epilepsy organisations or disability support services in third level education could establish an academic culture where supports are readily available to people with concealable illnesses.

Determinants of felt stigma in epilepsy

The present study aimed to determine the level of felt stigma, overprotection, concealment, and concerns related to epilepsy in different life domains by using culturally-specific scales for Turkish individuals with epilepsy. Also, it aimed to detect relations among the study variables and to determine the variables which predict felt stigma. For this purpose, felt stigma scale, overprotection scale, concealment of epilepsy scale, and concerns of epilepsy scale were administered to two hundred adult persons with epilepsy (PWE). The results showed that almost half of the participants reported felt stigma, overprotection, concealment of epilepsy, concerns related to future occupation, and concerns related to social life. Almost all the study variables show correlations with each other. Concealment of epilepsy, concerns related to social life, and concerns related to future occupation were found as the predictors of felt stigma.

Determining the disease management process for epileptic patients: A qualitative study

BACKGROUND

Epilepsy exposes patients to many physical, social, and emotional challenges. Thus, it seems to portray a complex picture and needs holistic care. Medical treatment and psychosocial part of epilepsy remain central to managing and improving the patient's qualify of life through team efforts. Some studies have shown the dimensions of self-management, but its management process of epilepsy patients, especially in Iran, is not clear. This study aimed to determine the disease management process in patients with epilepsy in Iran.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

This qualitative approach and grounded theory study was conducted from January 2009 to February 2012 in Isfahan city (Iran). Thirty-two participants were recruited by the goal-oriented, and snowball sample selection and theoretical sampling methods. After conducting a total of 43 in-depth interviews with the participants, the researchers reached data saturation. Data were analyzed using Strauss and Corbin method.

RESULTS

With a focus on disease management process, researchers found three main themes and seven sub-themes as a psychosocial process (PSP). The main themes were: perception of threat to self-identity, effort to preserve self-identity, and burn out. The psychosocial aspect of the disease generated one main variable "the perception of identity loss" and one central variable "searching for self-identity."

CONCLUSIONS

Participants attributed threat to self-identity and burn out to the way their disease was managed requiring efforts to preserve their identity. Recommendations consist of support programs and strategies to improve the public perception of epilepsy in Iran, help patients accept their condition and preserve self-identity, and most importantly, enhance medical management of epilepsy.

Do expressed emotions result in stigma? A potentially modifiable factor in persons with epilepsy in India

OBJECTIVE

Feeling stigmatized or having comorbid depression in a PWE may significantly influence epilepsy care and treatment. An important contributory factor to this can be the expressed emotions (EEs) from family, friends, or society. The present study aimed at understanding the influence of EEs, as exhibited by close relatives, on the perception of stigma and comorbid depression experienced by PWEs.

METHOD

Eighty PWEs aged 18 years and above, both genders, visiting neurology OPD in AIIMS Hospital, were recruited. Using the PHQ-09, we subdivided them into Group I (PWEs with comorbid depression) and Group II (PWEs without comorbid depression), followed by administration of Levels of Expressed Emotions Scale and Stigma Scale for Epilepsy, respectively.

RESULTS

The comparative analysis, using independent t-test (for categorical data), Pearson's correlation (for continuous data), and multivariate regression analysis, reflected significant influence of EEs on depression and stigma, with more than 20% of the participants reporting comorbid depression, out of which more than 50% further expressed feelings of inferiority or disgrace due to the ways in which family or society discriminated them from healthy persons, thereby highlighting a greater associations of high EEs as opposed to low EEs from key individuals on patients' perception of stigma or feeling of depression.

CONCLUSION

The result suggested that EEs from a relative might go unnoticed but may significantly overwhelm the patient, thereby making him succumb to depression or feeling stigmatized. The analysis of such a clinical profile and relationship between EEs and perceived stigma/depression may help us understand the pattern of attribution styles adopted by PWEs, thereby utilizing it further for enhancing the efficacy of cognitive-behavioral therapy for facilitating sustained recovery and improved quality of life for PWEs.

Qualitative research and its methods in epilepsy: Contributing to an understanding of patients' lived experiences of the disease

This review paper makes the case for the usefulness of qualitative research methods in the context of epilepsy research. It begins with an assessment of the current state of epilepsy literature and identifies gaps especially in the following: research in 'developing' countries and research around surgery for adults with epilepsy. It makes the case that disclosure of people's behaviors, actions, and reactions in different, often complex health-care situations can indicate how they bring meaning to their disease experiences and support needs. It shows the value of encouraging work that clarifies how patients manage their illness and how they understand changes in their health and well-being over the life course of their illness and how health-care professionals and other stakeholder groups care for those with epilepsy. The paper suggests a range of methods for addressing gaps in the literature and highlights a range of data collection, data analysis, and data interpretation and synthesis techniques that are appropriate in this context. It pays particular attention to the strengths of qualitative applications in mixed-methods research using an example from a recent ulcerative colitis drug trial that indicates how they can be integrated into study findings, add rich description, and enhance study outcomes. Ethnographic methodology is also presented, as a way of offering rare access to the 'lived experience' dimension, before the paper concludes with an assessment of the qualitative criteria of credibility, dependability, transferability, and confirmability for judging a study's 'trustworthiness'. The criteria evidence not only the trustworthiness of data and findings but also the ways in which a study has approached any challenges inherent in its research design.

Bullying, internalized hepatitis (Hepatitis C virus) stigma, and self-esteem: Does spirituality curtail the relationship in the workplace

The objective of this study was to examine the impact of workplace bullying on self-esteem, including the mediating effect of internalized stigma and the moderating effect of spirituality, among hepatitis C virus patients. Data were collected from 228 employed hepatitis C virus patients who had been admitted to Gastroenterology and Hepatology wards in Pakistani hospitals. We found support for the hypothesis that workplace bullying is associated with low self-esteem via internalized stigma. In addition, spirituality moderated the association such that participants with greater spirituality were buffered from the impact of stigma on self-esteem.

Perceived Stigma Among People With Chronic Health Conditions

Objectives:

This study addresses whether age, functional limitation and other stressor exposure, and psychosocial coping resources influence variation in perceived stigma and the form this influence takes (i.e., independent and/or interdependent).

Methods:

Using data from two waves of a large community study of adults (age 20–93) with chronic health conditions ( n = 417), a residual change regression analysis considers direct and moderating factors influencing perceived stigma over a 3-year period.

Results:

Age, functional limitation, the experience of discrimination, and self-esteem independently account for variation in perceived stigma. Moderation tests reveal that age is associated with a greater increase in stigma in the context of greater functional limitation and increases in limitation. Functional limitation and stressor exposure are also associated with declines in stigma in the context of greater mastery and self-esteem.

Discussion:

Multiple processes bear on perceived stigma among people with chronic health conditions. Implications for stigma and stress research are discussed.

Patients' perception of epilepsy and threat to self-identity: a qualitative approach

INTRODUCTION

A clinical diagnosis of epilepsy often carries a silent social stigma and is associated with metaphysical forces. This qualitative study aimed to explore the Iranian patients' perception of epilepsy where clinical aspects are more benign than the social implications with long-term psychological consequences. Historically, epilepsy has been known as a form of insanity, madness, sorcery, and possession by evil spirits.

METHOD

Thirty participants consisting of 21 patients with epilepsy, 5 family members, and 4 medical staff were selected from urban and rural medical and health care centers, hospitals, physician offices, outpatient clinics, and the Iranian Epilepsy Association. Unstructured and semistructured interviews were applied to obtain data. Transcribed interviews and field notes were analyzed using qualitative content analysis method.

FINDINGS

Categories and subcategories emerged from the participants' perceptions of epilepsy and its disruptive effects on their self-identity. The main categories derived from data were 1) a different perspective about epilepsy, 2) self-debasement, and 3) being a burden. The major theme found in this study was "identity loss".

CONCLUSION

Our study results highlight the importance of public awareness among community members and healthcare professionals on how patients with epilepsy experience their disease with psychosocial implications. Understanding patients' perspectives can be essential to developing a comprehensive and holistic care plan for patients with epilepsy and addressing their multidimensional needs.

Conceptual distinctions between reflex and nonreflex precipitated seizures in the epilepsies: a systematic review of definitions employed in the research literature

Seizure precipitation is a defining characteristic of reflex seizures and epilepsies, but seizure precipitants are also commonly reported for patients with epilepsies not considered to be reflex in nature. This raises the questions of exactly how reflex and nonreflex epilepsies with seizure precipitants are defined, and how these concepts are differentiated from one another in current practice. In this systematic literature review, definitions of reflex seizures, reflex epilepsies, and precipitation in a nonreflex context were extracted from published primary research papers. Content analysis was applied to these definitions to identify their main features, allowing comparisons to be made between definitions of the different concepts. Results indicated that there was little consistency within definitions of a given term, and that although some differences in definition content were found between terms, it was evident that clear defining characteristics to differentiate them from one another were lacking. These findings are discussed in the context of current debates regarding classification of the reflex epilepsies and the extent to which the distinction between reflex and nonreflex epilepsies is a meaningful one. Suggestions are made for how clarity might be increased in ongoing research in this area.

Patient Reported Outcome (PRO) assessment in epilepsy: a review of epilepsy-specific PROs according to the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) regulatory requirements

Despite collection of patient reported outcome (PRO) data in clinical trials of antiepileptic drugs (AEDs), PRO results are not being routinely reported on European Medicines Agency (EMA) and Food and Drug Administration (FDA) product labels. This review aimed to evaluate epilepsy-specific PRO instruments against FDA regulatory standards for supporting label claims. Structured literature searches were conducted in Embase and Medline databases to identify epilepsy-specific PRO instruments. Only instruments that could potentially be impacted by pharmacological treatment, were completed by adults and had evidence of some validation work were selected for review. A total of 26 PROs were reviewed based on criteria developed from the FDA regulatory standards. The ability to meet these criteria was classified as either full, partial or no evidence, whereby partial reflected some evidence but not enough to comprehensively address the FDA regulatory standards. Most instruments provided partial evidence of content validity. Input from clinicians and literature was common although few involved patients in both item generation and cognitive debriefing. Construct validity was predominantly compromised by no evidence of a-priori hypotheses of expected relationships. Evidence for test-retest reliability and internal consistency was available for most PROs although few included complete results regarding all subscales and some failed to reach recommended thresholds. The ability to detect change and interpretation of change were not investigated in most instruments and no PROs had published evidence of a conceptual framework. The study concludes that none of the 26 have the full evidence required by the FDA to support a label claim, and all require further research to support their use as an endpoint. The Subjective Handicap of Epilepsy (SHE) and the Neurological Disorders Depression Inventory for Epilepsy (NDDI-E) have the fewest gaps that would need to be addressed through additional research prior to any FDA regulatory submission, although the NDDI-E was designed as a screening tool and is therefore unlikely to be suitable as an instrument for capturing change in a clinical trial and the SHE lacks the conceptual focus on signs and symptoms favoured by the FDA.

Epilepsy is associated with unmet health care needs compared to the general population despite higher health resource utilization--a Canadian population-based study

PURPOSE

(1) To determine whether health resource utilization (HRU) and unmet health care needs differ for individuals with epilepsy compared to the general population or to those with another chronic condition (asthma, diabetes, migraine); and (2) to assess the association among epilepsy status, sociodemographic variables and HRU.

METHODS

Data on HRU were assessed using the 2001-2005 Canadian Community Health Surveys, a nationally representative population-based survey. Weighted estimates of association were produced as adjusted odds ratio with 95% confidence intervals, and logistic regression was used to explore the association between sociodemographic variables and HRU in those with epilepsy. All data on disease status, HRU, and unmet health care needs were self-reported.

KEY FINDINGS

Individuals with epilepsy had the highest rate of hospitalizations and the highest mean number of consultations with physicians. Despite higher rates of consultation with psychologists and social workers compared to the general population, those with epilepsy were significantly more likely to say they had unmet mental health care needs. People with epilepsy were also less likely to use dental services compared to the general population. Epilepsy was a significant predictor of HRU in logistic regression models.

SIGNIFICANCE

Given the prevalence of psychiatric comorbidities in those with epilepsy, it is concerning that this group perceives unmet mental health care needs. It is also troublesome that there was decreased utilization of dental health care resources in those with epilepsy considering that these patients are more likely to have poor oral health. Although individuals with epilepsy use more health care services than the general population, this increase appears to be insufficient to address their health care needs.

Living with epilepsy accompanied by cognitive difficulties: young adults' experiences

OBJECTIVE

Epilepsy can sometimes be followed by memory impairment. This can result from the underlying cause of epilepsy or from recurrent seizures, or can be a side effect of antiepileptic drugs or a symptom of another disease such as depression. The aim of the study described here was to explore the experience of living with epilepsy and subjective cognitive decline.

METHOD

To better understand the deeper meaning of the phenomenon, a qualitative design was chosen. Fourteen adults aged 18-35 took part in focus group interviews. The participants were divided into four groups, two groups of women and two groups of men, and the interviews were conducted according to a semistructured protocol. Transcripts were analyzed in accordance with the content analysis guidelines.

RESULTS

Four themes emerged: "affecting the whole person," "influencing daily life," "affecting relationships," and "meeting ignorance in society."

CONCLUSIONS

Cognitive decline has a heavy impact on young adults with intractable epilepsy. In contrast to seizures, the cognitive decline is persistent. The themes reflected different hardships faced by the participants. The consequences of living with epilepsy and cognitive impairment concerned education, employment, social life, self-esteem, and hope for the future. The participants were already using strategies to cope with their cognitive decline, but may benefit from help in developing new strategies to better adjust to their memory problems. Development of more educational programs for both people with epilepsy and their relatives could improve their difficult situations. With help, people can learn to adjust their goals in life and live a fulfilling life despite the disease.

The impact of epilepsy on children and adult patients' lives: development of a conceptual model from qualitative literature

AIM

This study aimed to develop a conceptual model of the impact of partial onset or generalized epilepsy on children and adults in order to guide the identification of endpoints that capture patient perspectives in new treatment trials.

METHODS

A systematic literature search was conducted in Embase and Medline to identify qualitative research reporting the impact of epilepsy on child and adult patients' lives. The search identified 20 publications describing 18 qualitative studies. Qualitative results were extracted from these publications into structured summary tables separately for impact on children and adults.

RESULTS

Results tables were reviewed by two qualitative researchers who identified 23 concepts/areas of impact. Concepts were largely universal between child and adult studies, although concept content did vary between age-groups, for example child relationship concerns were focused on developing friendships and problematic family relationships. For adults the concerns were problematic relationships with spouse or partner and fulfilling the family roles. Concepts influenced directly by epilepsy were cognitive, physical and seizure effects, other concepts such as future hopes, burden and self-esteem were influenced more indirectly by impact on other concepts. The 23 concepts were linked to form a conceptual model of the impact of epilepsy for patients guided by qualitative results reported by studies.

CONCLUSION

The conceptual model suggests potential areas of patients' lives that may be enhanced by effective treatment and allows for concepts of concern to both children and adults to be identified and explored as potential endpoints in trials of new epilepsy treatments.

The impact of stigma in healthcare on people living with chronic illnesses

Approximately half of adults are living with a chronic illness, many of whom may feel stigmatized by their chronic illness in different contexts. We explored the impact of internalized, experienced, and anticipated stigma within healthcare settings on the quality of life of 184 participants living with chronic illnesses (e.g. diabetes, inflammatory bowel disease, asthma). Results of a path analysis demonstrate that participants who internalized stigma and experienced stigma from healthcare workers anticipated greater stigma from healthcare workers. Participants who anticipated greater stigma from healthcare workers, in turn, accessed healthcare less and experienced a decreased quality of life.

Associates of stigma in an incident epilepsy population from northern Manhattan, New York City

OBJECTIVE

Stigma is associated with prevalent epilepsy, but its association with incident epilepsy is unknown.

METHODS

We identified 209 children and adults with incident seizures from the diverse impoverished community of northern Manhattan. We interviewed 94 participants, aged 16 and older, about lifetime history of depression, health status, medical history, and stigma.

RESULTS

At baseline, 18 (22.5%) participants reported experiencing stigma. Stigma was reported by 9 (50.0%) with depression and 9 (14.5%) without depression (P=0.002). At 1 year, 7 (8.1%) participants reported experiencing stigma. Stigma was reported by 5 (31.3%) with depression versus 1 (1.6%) without depression (P<0.0001). At both time points, odds of stigma increased when lifetime history of depression and fair/poor health was present.

CONCLUSIONS

Previous work revealed negative effects of prevalent epilepsy on stigma. In the low-income, predominantly Hispanic community of northern Manhattan, we found incident epilepsy was associated with stigma when lifetime history of depression or fair/poor health was present.

Epilepsy-associated stigma in Zambia: what factors predict greater felt stigma in a highly stigmatized population?

Epilepsy-associated stigma in Africa has been described largely in terms of enacted stigma or discrimination. We conducted a study of 169 adults with epilepsy attending epilepsy clinics in Zambia's Lusaka or Southern province using a three-item instrument (maximum score = 3). Potential determinants of felt stigma including age, gender, education, wealth, disclosure status (meaning whether or how their community members knew of their condition), seizure type (generalized vs partial), seizure frequency, the presence of visible epilepsy-associated stigmata, personal contagion beliefs, and community contagion beliefs. The median stigma score was 2.5, suggesting some ceiling effect in the instrument. People with epilepsy who believed their condition to be contagious, who thought their community believed epilepsy to be contagious, and whose condition had been revealed to their community against their wishes reported more felt stigma. Community and clinic-based educational campaigns to dispel contagion beliefs are needed.

European survey of the level of satisfaction of patients and physicians in the management of epilepsy in general practice

Many people with epilepsy report treatment-emergent adverse effects (AEs) while on drug therapy despite optimized treatment. We explored the level of treatment satisfaction with current management among people with epilepsy and treating physicians from seven different European countries. There was discordance between patients and physicians: patients would like greater involvement in discussions regarding treatment options and, although generally satisfied with their current medication, saw the need for a more effective balance between seizure control and AEs. Conversely, physicians were less satisfied with current treatments, but were less concerned with AEs. People with epilepsy also wanted to be better educated about epilepsy and its management. Key challenges for the future include improvement in the self-management of epilepsy by patients and more proactive patient-physician interactions. An additional aim is to improve the public's perception of epilepsy so as to remove any associated stigma.