Biophysical Characterization of a Nanodisc with and without BAX: An Integrative Study Using Molecular Dynamics Simulations and Cryo-EM

Examining the Thermotropic properties of Large, Circularized Nanodiscs

Nanodiscs, soluble membrane mimetics composed of an amphipathic membrane scaffold protein encircling a lipid bilayer, are widely used in biophysical and structural studies of membrane proteins. Because many membrane proteins are responsive to their membrane environment, through specific protein-lipid interactions and bulk membrane shape and structure, it is important to understand the properties of lipid bilayers contained within nanodiscs in order to interpret studies using this technology. Nanodiscs are known to alter lipid properties, such as membrane thickness and melting temperature, and interactions with the nanodisc rim have been hypothesized to produce local perturbations in lipid structure and dynamics. Larger nanodiscs should compensate for this effect with a larger unperturbed area. To test this hypothesis, we examined the lipid bilayer properties of several lipids (DMPC, DPPC, POPC, DSPC) and soy polar extract in circularized nanodiscs of 11 nm to 50 nm diameter using the environmentally-sensitive fluorophore, Laurdan. In nanodiscs containing a single lipid type, as nanodisc size increased, lipid packing, melting temperature, and cooperativity better approximated the properties of that lipid in large unilamellar vesicles (LUVs). In spNW50 (50 nm nanodisc), the lipid packing and melting temperature were identical to LUVs. However, nanodiscs containing soy polar lipids did not follow this trend suggesting that complex lipid mixtures may produce preferential incorporation of lipids into the nanodisc or nonhomogeneous distribution of lipids within the nanodisc.

Unraveling membrane protein localization and interactions in nanodiscs

Nanodiscs, consisting of a lipid bilayer surrounded by membrane scaffold proteins (MSPs), are extensively used to study membrane proteins (MPs) because they provide a stable lipid environment. However, the precise mechanism governing MP behavior within the nanodisc remains elusive. Here, we examined the cryo-EM structures of various MPs reconstituted in nanodiscs from EMPIAR. By analyzing the heterogeneity and interactions in the nanodiscs, we discovered that MPs display a distinct spatial preference toward the edges of the nanodisc shells. Furthermore, MPs can establish direct, amphipathic interactions with the MSPs, causing a reduction in local protein dynamics. These interactions may rearrange MSP-MSP interactions into MP-MSP interactions. Collectively, we provide structural insights into how nanodiscs contribute to MP structural behavior and dynamics. Impact statement Nanodiscs are used to study membrane proteins (MPs), but the mechanisms governing the behavior of MPs within nanodiscs remain elusive. Here, we provide structural insights into how nanodiscs contribute to the behavior of MPs, which will aid the interpretation of cryo-EM studies performed using nanodiscs.

Poration of mitochondrial membranes by amyloidogenic peptides and other biological toxins

Mitochondria are essential organelles known to serve broad functions, including in cellular metabolism, calcium buffering, signaling pathways and the regulation of apoptotic cell death. Maintaining the integrity of the outer (OMM) and inner mitochondrial membranes (IMM) is vital for mitochondrial health. Cardiolipin (CL), a unique dimeric glycerophospholipid, is the signature lipid of energy-converting membranes. It plays a significant role in maintaining mitochondrial architecture and function, stabilizing protein complexes and facilitating efficient oxidative phosphorylation (OXPHOS) whilst regulating cytochrome c release from mitochondria. CL is especially enriched in the IMM and at sites of contact between the OMM and IMM. Disorders of protein misfolding, such as Alzheimer's and Parkinson's diseases, involve amyloidogenic peptides like amyloid-β, tau and α-synuclein, which form metastable toxic oligomeric species that interact with biological membranes. Electrophysiological studies have shown that these oligomers form ion-conducting nanopores in membranes mimicking the IMM's phospholipid composition. Poration of mitochondrial membranes disrupts the ionic balance, causing osmotic swelling, loss of the voltage potential across the IMM, release of pro-apoptogenic factors, and leads to cell death. The interaction between CL and amyloid oligomers appears to favour their membrane insertion and pore formation, directly implicating CL in amyloid toxicity. Additionally, pore formation in mitochondrial membranes is not limited to amyloid proteins and peptides; other biological peptides, as diverse as the pro-apoptotic Bcl-2 family members, gasdermin proteins, cobra venom cardiotoxins and bacterial pathogenic toxins, have all been described to punch holes in mitochondria, contributing to cell death processes. Collectively, these findings underscore the vulnerability of mitochondria and the involvement of CL in various pathogenic mechanisms, emphasizing the need for further research on targeting CL-amyloid interactions to mitigate mitochondrial dysfunction.

Optimizing Transmembrane Protein Assemblies in Nanodiscs for Structural Studies: A Comprehensive Manual

Membrane protein structures offer a more accurate basis for understanding their functional correlates when derived from full-length proteins in their native lipid environment. Producing such samples has been a primary challenge in the field. Here, we present robust, step-by-step biochemical and biophysical protocols for generating monodisperse assemblies of full-length transmembrane proteins within lipidic environments. These protocols are particularly tailored for cases where the size and molecular weight of the proteins align closely with those of the lipid islands (nanodiscs). While designed for single-span bitopic membrane proteins, these protocols can be easily extended to proteins with multiple transmembrane domains. The insights presented have broad implications across diverse fields, including biophysics, structural biology, and cryogenic electron microscopy (cryo-EM) studies. Key features • Overview of the sample preparation steps from protein expression and purification and reconstitution of membrane proteins in nanodiscs, as well as biobeads and lipids preparation. • Focus on single-span bitopic transmembrane proteins. • Includes protocols for validation procedures via characterization using biochemical, biophysical, and computational techniques. • Guide for cryogenic electron microscopy data acquisition from vitrification to image processing.

The membrane insertion of the pro-apoptotic protein Bax is a Tom22-dependent multi-step process: a study in nanodiscs

Membrane insertion of the pro-apoptotic protein Bax was investigated by setting up cell-free synthesis of full-length Bax in the presence of pre-formed nanodiscs. While Bax was spontaneously poorly inserted in nanodiscs, co-synthesis with the mitochondrial receptor Tom22 stimulated Bax membrane insertion. The initial interaction of Bax with the lipid bilayer exposed the hydrophobic GALLL motif in Hα1 leading to Bax precipitation through hydrophobic interactions. The same motif was recognized by Tom22, triggering conformational changes leading to the extrusion and the ensuing membrane insertion of the C-terminal hydrophobic Hα9. Tom22 was also required for Bax-membrane insertion after Bax was activated either by BH3-activators or by its release from Bcl-xL by WEHI-539. The effect of Tom22 was impaired by D154Y substitution in Bax-Hα7 and T174P substitution in Bax-Hα9, which are found in several tumors. Conversely, a R9E substitution promoted a spontaneous insertion of Bax in nanodiscs, in the absence of Tom22. Both Tom22-activated Bax and BaxR9E alone permeabilized liposomes to dextran-10kDa and formed ~5-nm-diameter pores in nanodiscs. The concerted regulation of Bax membrane insertion by Tom22 and BH3-activators is discussed.

The structure, self-assembly and dynamics of lipid nanodiscs revealed by computational approaches

Nanodisc technology is increasingly being used in structural, biochemical and biophysical studies of membrane proteins. The computational approaches have revealed many important features of nanodisc assembly, structures and dynamics. Therefore, we reviewed the application of computational approaches, especially molecular modeling and molecular dyncamics (MD) simulations, to characterize nanodiscs, including the structural models, assembly and disassembly, protocols for modeling, structural properties and dynamics, and protein-lipid interactions in nanodiscs. More amazing computational studies about nanodiscs are looked forward to in the future.

Creation of distinctive Bax-lipid complexes at mitochondrial membrane surfaces drives pore formation to initiate apoptosis

Apotosis is an essential process tightly regulated by the Bcl-2 protein family where proapoptotic Bax triggers cell death by perforating the mitochondrial outer membrane. Although intensively studied, the molecular mechanism by which these proteins create apoptotic pores remains elusive. Here, we show that Bax creates pores by extracting lipids from outer mitochondrial membrane mimics by formation of Bax/lipid clusters that are deposited on the membrane surface. Time-resolved neutron reflectometry and Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy revealed two kinetically distinct phases in the pore formation process, both of which were critically dependent on cardiolipin levels. The initially fast adsorption of Bax on the mitochondrial membrane surface is followed by a slower formation of pores and Bax-lipid clusters on the membrane surface. Our findings provide a robust molecular understanding of mitochondrial membrane perforation by cell-killing Bax protein and illuminate the initial phases of programmed cellular death.

Bcl-xL Is Spontaneously Inserted into Preassembled Nanodiscs and Stimulates Bax Insertion in a Cell-Free Protein Synthesis System

The antiapoptotic protein Bcl-xL is a major regulator of cell death and survival, but many aspects of its functions remain elusive. It is mostly localized in the mitochondrial outer membrane (MOM) owing to its C-terminal hydrophobic α-helix. In order to gain further information about its membrane organization, we set up a model system combining cell-free protein synthesis and nanodisc insertion. We found that, contrary to its proapoptotic partner Bax, neosynthesized Bcl-xL was spontaneously inserted into nanodiscs. The deletion of the C-terminal α-helix of Bcl-xL prevented nanodisc insertion. We also found that nanodisc insertion protected Bcl-xL against the proteolysis of the 13 C-terminal residues that occurs during expression of Bcl-xL as a soluble protein in E. coli. Interestingly, we observed that Bcl-xL increased the insertion of Bax into nanodiscs, in a similar way to that which occurs in mitochondria. Cell-free synthesis in the presence of nanodiscs is, thus, a suitable model system to study the molecular aspects of the interaction between Bcl-xL and Bax during their membrane insertion.

Apoptotic mitochondrial poration by a growing list of pore-forming BCL-2 family proteins

The pore-forming BCL-2 family proteins are effectors of mitochondrial poration in apoptosis initiation. Two atypical effectors-BOK and truncated BID (tBID)-join the canonical effectors BAK and BAX. Gene knockout revealed developmental phenotypes in the absence the effectors, supporting their roles in vivo. During apoptosis effectors are activated and change shape from dormant monomers to dynamic oligomers that associate with and permeabilize mitochondria. BID is activated by proteolysis, BOK accumulates on inhibition of its degradation by the E3 ligase gp78, while BAK and BAX undergo direct activation by BH3-only initiators, autoactivation, and crossactivation. Except tBID, effector oligomers on the mitochondria appear as arcs and rings in super-resolution microscopy images. The BH3-in-groove dimers of BAK and BAX, the tBID monomers, and uncharacterized BOK species are the putative building blocks of apoptotic pores. Effectors interact with lipids and bilayers but the mechanism of membrane poration remains elusive. I discuss effector-mediated mitochondrial poration.

DNA-nanostructure-templated assembly of planar and curved lipid-bilayer membranes

Lipid-bilayer nanodiscs and liposomes have been developed to stabilize membrane proteins in order to study their structures and functions. Nanodiscs are detergent-free, water-soluble, and size-controlled planar phospholipid-bilayer platforms. On the other hand, liposomes are curved phospholipid-bilayer spheres with an aqueous core used as drug delivery systems and model membrane platforms for studying cellular activities. A long-standing challenge is the generation of a homogenous and monodispersed lipid-bilayer system with a very wide range of dimensions and curvatures (elongation, bending, and twisting). A DNA-origami template provides a way to control the shapes, sizes, and arrangements of lipid bilayers via enforcing the assembly of lipid bilayers within the cavities created by DNA nanostructures. Here, we provide a concise overview and discuss how to design planar and curved lipid-bilayer membranes by using DNA-origami nanostructures as templates. Finally, we will discuss the potential applications of DNA-origami nanostructures in the structural and functional studies of large membrane proteins and their complexes.

Travel light: Essential packing for membrane proteins with an active lifestyle

We review the considerable progress during the recent decade in the endeavours of designing, optimising, and utilising carrier particle systems for structural and functional studies of membrane proteins in near-native environments. New and improved systems are constantly emerging, novel studies push the perceived limits of a given carrier system, and specific carrier systems consolidate and entrench themselves as the system of choice for particular classes of target membrane protein systems. This review covers the most frequently used carrier systems for such studies and emphasises similarities and differences between these systems as well as current trends and future directions for the field. Particular interest is devoted to the biophysical properties and membrane mimicking ability of each system and the manner in which this may impact an embedded membrane protein and an eventual structural or functional study.

Release of nanodiscs from charged nano-droplets in the electrospray ionization revealed by molecular dynamics simulations

Electrospray ionization (ESI) is essential for application of mass spectrometry in biological systems, as it prevents the analyte being split into fragments. However, due to lack of a clear understanding of the mechanism of ESI, the interpretation of mass spectra is often ambiguous. This is a particular challenge for complex biological systems. Here, we focus on systems that include nanodiscs as membrane environment, which are essential for membrane proteins. We performed microsecond atomistic molecular dynamics simulations to study the release of nanodiscs from highly charged nano-droplets into the gas phase, the late stage of ESI. We observed two distinct major scenarios, highlighting the diversity of morphologies of gaseous product ions. Our simulations are in reasonable agreement with experimental results. Our work provides a detailed atomistic view of the ESI process of a heterogeneous system (lipid nanodisc), which may give insights into the interpretation of mass spectra of all lipid-protein systems.

Cell-free synthesis and reconstitution of Bax in nanodiscs: Comparison between wild-type Bax and a constitutively active mutant

Bax is a major player in the mitochondrial pathway of apoptosis, by making the Outer Mitochondrial Membrane (OMM) permeable to various apoptogenic factors, including cytochrome c. In order to get further insight into the structure and function of Bax when it is inserted in the OMM, we attempted to reconstitute Bax in nanodiscs. Cell-free protein synthesis in the presence of nanodiscs did not yield Bax-containing nanodiscs, but it provided a simple way to purify full-length Bax without any tag. Purified wild-type Bax (BaxWT) and a constitutively active mutant (BaxP168A) displayed biochemical properties that were in line with previous characterizations following their expression in yeast and human cells followed by their reconstitution into liposomes. Both Bax variants were then reconstituted in nanodiscs. Size exclusion chromatography, dynamic light scattering and transmission electron microscopy showed that nanodiscs formed with BaxP168A were larger than nanodiscs formed with BaxWT. This was consistent with the hypothesis that BaxP168A was reconstituted in nanodiscs as an active oligomer.

Biohybrid Membrane Formation by Directed Insertion of Aquaporin into a Solid-State Nanopore

Biohybrid nanopores combine the durability of solid-state nanopores with the precise structure and function of biological nanopores. Particular care must be taken to control how biological nanopores adapt to their surroundings once they come into contact with the solid-state nanopores. Two major challenges are to precisely control this adaptability under dynamic conditions and provide predesigned functionalities that can be manipulated for engineering applications. In this work, we report on the computational design of a distinctive class of biohybrid active membrane layers, built from the directed-insertion of an aquaporin-incorporated lipid nanodisc into a model alkyl-functionalized silica pore. We show that in an aqueous environment when a pressure difference exists between the two sides of the solid-state nanopore, the preferential interactions between the hydrocarbon tail of the lipid molecules that surround the aquaporin protein and the alkyl group functionalizing the interior surface of the silica nanopore enable the insertion of the aquaporin-incorporated lipid shell into the nanopore by forcing out the water molecules. The same preferential interactions are responsible for the structural stability of the inserted aquaporin-incorporated lipid shell as well as the water sealing properties of the lipid-alkyl interface. We further show that the aquaporin protein stabilized in the alkyl-functionalized silica nanopore preserves its biological structure and function in both pure and saline water, and, remarkably, its water permeability is equal to the one measured in the biological environment. The designed biohybrid membrane could pave the way for the development of durable transformative devices for water filtration.

The Bak core dimer focuses triacylglycerides in the membrane

Apoptosis, the intrinsic programmed cell death process, is mediated by the Bcl-2 family members Bak and Bax. Activation via formation of symmetric core dimers and oligomerization on the mitochondrial outer membrane (MOM) leads to permeabilization and cell death. Although this process is linked to the MOM, the role of the membrane in facilitating such pores is poorly understood. We recently described Bak core domain dimers, revealing lipid binding sites and an initial role of lipids in oligomerization. Here we describe simulations that identified localized clustering and interaction of triacylglycerides (TAGs) with a minimized Bak dimer construct. Coalescence of TAGs occurred beneath this Bak dimer, mitigating dimer-induced local membrane thinning and curvature in representative coarse-grain MOM and model membrane systems. Furthermore, the effects observed as a result of coarse-grain TAG cluster formation was concentration dependent, scaling from low physiological MOM concentrations to those found in other organelles. We find that increasing the TAG concentration in liposomes mimicking the MOM decreased the ability of activated Bak to permeabilize these liposomes. These results suggest that the presence of TAGs within a Bak-lipid membrane preserves membrane integrity and is associated with reduced membrane stress, suggesting a possible role of TAGs in Bak-mediated apoptosis.

High-resolution analysis of the conformational transition of pro-apoptotic Bak at the lipid membrane

Permeabilization of the outer mitochondrial membrane by pore-forming Bcl2 proteins is a crucial step for the induction of apoptosis. Despite a large set of data suggesting global conformational changes within pro-apoptotic Bak during pore formation, high-resolution structural details in a membrane environment remain sparse. Here, we used NMR and HDX-MS (Hydrogen deuterium exchange mass spectrometry) in lipid nanodiscs to gain important high-resolution structural insights into the conformational changes of Bak at the membrane that are dependent on a direct activation by BH3-only proteins. Furthermore, we determined the first high-resolution structure of the Bak transmembrane helix. Upon activation, α-helix 1 in the soluble domain of Bak dissociates from the protein and adopts an unfolded and dynamic potentially membrane-bound state. In line with this finding, comparative protein folding experiments with Bak and anti-apoptotic BclxL suggest that α-helix 1 in Bak is a metastable structural element contributing to its pro-apoptotic features. Consequently, mutagenesis experiments aimed at stabilizing α-helix 1 yielded Bak variants with delayed pore-forming activity. These insights will contribute to a better mechanistic understanding of Bak-mediated membrane permeabilization.

Structural and Biophysical Properties of Supercharged and Circularized Nanodiscs

Nanodiscs based on membrane scaffold proteins (MSPs) and phospholipids are used as membrane mimics to stabilize membrane proteins in solution for structural and functional studies. Combining small-angle X-ray scattering (SAXS), differential scanning calorimetry (DSC), and time-resolved small-angle neutron scattering (TR-SANS), we characterized the structure and lipid bilayer properties of five different nanodiscs made with dimyristoylphosphatidylcholine and different MSPs varying in size, charge, and circularization. Our SAXS modeling showed that the structural parameters of the embedded lipids are all similar, irrespective of the MSP properties. DSC showed that the lipid packing is not homogeneous in the nanodiscs and that a 20 Å wide boundary layer of lipids with perturbed packing is located close to the MSP, while the packing of central lipids is tighter than in large unilamellar vesicles. Finally, TR-SANS showed that lipid exchange rates in nanodiscs decrease with increasing nanodisc size and are lower for the nanodiscs made with supercharged MSPs compared to conventional nanodiscs. Altogether, the results provide a thorough biophysical understanding of the nanodisc as a model membrane system, which is important in order to carry out and interpret experiments on membrane proteins embedded in such systems.

General Protocol for Constructing Molecular Models of Nanodiscs

Nanodisc technology is increasingly being applied for structural and biophysical studies of membrane proteins. In this work, we present a general protocol for constructing molecular models of nanodiscs for molecular dynamics simulations. The protocol is written in python and based on geometric equations, making it fast and easy to modify, enabling automation and customization of nanodiscs in silico. The novelty being the ability to construct any membrane scaffold protein (MSP) variant fast and easy given only an input sequence. We validated and tested the protocol by simulating seven different nanodiscs of various sizes and with different membrane scaffold proteins, both circularized and noncircularized. The structural and biophysical properties were analyzed and shown to be in good agreement with previously reported experimental data and simulation studies.

Techniques for studying membrane pores

Pore-forming proteins (PFPs) are of special interest because of the association of their activity with the disruption of the membrane impermeability barrier and cell death. They generally convert from a monomeric, soluble form into transmembrane oligomers that induce the opening of membrane pores. The study of pore formation in membranes with molecular detail remains a challenging endeavor because of its highly dynamic and complex nature, usually involving diverse oligomeric structures with different functionalities. Here we discuss current methods applied for the structural and functional characterization of PFPs at the individual vesicle and cell level. We highlight how the development of high-resolution and single-molecule imaging techniques allows the analysis of the structural organization of protein oligomers and pore entities in lipid membranes.

Distortion of the bilayer and dynamics of the BAM complex in lipid nanodiscs

The β-barrel assembly machinery (BAM) catalyses the folding and insertion of β-barrel outer membrane proteins (OMPs) into the outer membranes of Gram-negative bacteria by mechanisms that remain unclear. Here, we present an ensemble of cryoEM structures of the E. coli BamABCDE (BAM) complex in lipid nanodiscs, determined using multi-body refinement techniques. These structures, supported by single-molecule FRET measurements, describe a range of motions in the BAM complex, mostly localised within the periplasmic region of the major subunit BamA. The β-barrel domain of BamA is in a 'lateral open' conformation in all of the determined structures, suggesting that this is the most energetically favourable species in this bilayer. Strikingly, the BAM-containing lipid nanodisc is deformed, especially around BAM's lateral gate. This distortion is also captured in molecular dynamics simulations, and provides direct structural evidence for the lipid 'disruptase' activity of BAM, suggested to be an important part of its functional mechanism.

Confinement in Nanodiscs Anisotropically Modifies Lipid Bilayer Elastic Properties

Lipid nanodiscs are small synthetic lipid bilayer structures that are stabilized in solution by special circumscribing (or scaffolding) proteins or polymers. Because they create native-like environments for transmembrane proteins, lipid nanodiscs have become a powerful tool for structural determination of this class of systems when combined with cryo-electron microscopy or nuclear magnetic resonance. The elastic properties of lipid bilayers determine how the lipid environment responds to membrane protein perturbations, and how the lipid in turn modifies the conformational state of the embedded protein. However, despite the abundant use of nanodiscs in determining membrane protein structure, the elastic material properties of even pure lipid nanodiscs (i.e., without embedded proteins) have not yet been quantitatively investigated. A major hurdle is due to the inherently nonlocal treatment of the elastic properties of lipid systems implemented by most existing methods, both experimental and computational. In addition, these methods are best suited for very large “infinite” size lipidic assemblies, or ones that contain periodicity, in the case of simulations. We have previously described a computational analysis of molecular dynamics simulations designed to overcome these limitations, so it allows quantification of the bending rigidity (K_C) and tilt modulus (κ_t) on a local scale even for finite, nonperiodic systems, such as lipid nanodiscs. Here we use this computational approach to extract values of K_C and κ_t for a set of lipid nanodisc systems that vary in size and lipid composition. We find that the material properties of lipid nanodiscs are different from those of infinite bilayers of corresponding lipid composition, highlighting the effect of nanodisc confinement. Nanodiscs tend to show higher stiffness than their corresponding macroscopic bilayers, and moreover, their material properties vary spatially within them. For small-size MSP1 nanodiscs, the stiffness decreases radially, from a value that is larger in their center than the moduli of the corresponding bilayers by a factor of ∼2–3. The larger nanodiscs (MSP1E3D1 and MSP2N2) show milder spatial changes of moduli that are composition dependent and can be maximal in the center or at some distance from it. These trends in moduli correlate with spatially varying structural properties, including the area per lipid and the nanodisc thickness. Finally, as has previously been reported, nanodiscs tend to show deformations from perfectly flat circular geometries to varying degrees, depending on size and lipid composition. The modulations of lipid elastic properties that we find should be carefully considered when making structural and functional inferences concerning embedded proteins.