Water crystallization and its importance to freezing of foods: A review

Formulation strategies, texture improvement, and sensory perception of healthy ice cream: A review

The growing awareness of health issues and the increasing demand for specialized diets have driven consumer demand for healthier ice cream products. The high fat and sugar contents of traditional ice cream have raised health concerns, prompting researchers to seek alternative formulations that address the demand for low-fat, low-sugar, dairy-free, and functional creams. This review examines the latest innovations in healthier ice cream formulations, with a focus on the use of fat replacers, sweeteners, dairy-free ingredients, and functional components. This review also discusses how optimizing fat partial coalescence and controlling ice crystal recrystallization can help overcome texture deficiencies in the healthification process of ice cream. Furthermore, this review highlights the application of oral tribology techniques, such as the creaminess of ice cream, in analyzing sensory attributes. Future research will continue to focus on balancing health benefits and sensory quality to meet evolving consumer expectations.

Influence of pulsed electric field and glycerol pretreatments on freeze-thaw process and quality of white radish

This study focused on the effects of pulsed electric field (PEF) and glycerol (G) pretreatments on the quality of freeze-thawed white radishes. The optimal PEF strength, frequency, and treatment time were 800 V/cm, 5 Hz, and 0.1 s, respectively. The liquid-solid ratio of G impregnation pretreatment was 1:20 (w/w). The PEF, G, and PEF + G pretreatments accelerated the phase transition during the freeze-thaw process. Combination of PEF and G pretreatments decreased juice loss by 90.37 % and ascorbic acid loss by 59.3 % in thawed samples. Pretreatments also optimized the texture and color properties of the thawed samples. The low-field nuclear magnetic resonance results demonstrated that PEF pretreatment increased the water-holding capacity of the samples after thawing. The microstructure of the PEF + G-pretreated sample was the most homogeneous. These results revealed a potential method for preventing quality deterioration of freeze-thawed vegetables and fruits using PEF and G pretreatment.

Investigation of protein structure and quality of Acipenser sinensis frozen by liquid nitrogen

BACKGROUND

The quality of Acipenser sinensis deteriorates significantly during frozen storage due to its high water, protein, and unsaturated fatty acid content. Conventional freezing methods are insufficient to preserve it effectively. This study investigated the effects of liquid nitrogen freezing (LNF) on the quality and myofibrillar protein (MP) characteristics of A. sinensis during frozen storage.

RESULTS

Freezing A. sinensis with LNF resulted in faster freezing, lower free water content, smaller ice crystals, and less structural damage to MPs than refrigerator freezing (RF). It also resulted in higher shear force, Ca2+-ATPase activity, and total sulfhydryl content, as well as lower total volatile basic nitrogen (TVBN) values, thawing loss rate, and disulfide bond content, demonstrating that LNF can inhibit protein denaturation and delay the deterioration in the quality of A. sinensis during frozen storage. There were no significant differences between LNF-80 and LNF-110 in quality and myofibrillar protein characteristics of A. sinensis.

CONCLUSIONS

Liquid nitrogen freezing can maintain the quality of A. sinensis and reduce the degree of MP denaturation and oxidation during frozen storage. Freezing with LNF at -80 °C might be more appropriate for A. sinensis. The study has important implications for the application of cryogenic storage technology to aquatic products. © 2025 Society of Chemical Industry.

Mitigation of mechanical damage and protein deterioration in giant river prawn (Macrobrachium rosenbergii) by multi-frequency ultrasound-assisted immersion freezing

In order to investigate the effects of multi-frequency ultrasound-assisted immersion freezing (MUIF) on the meat quality of Macrobrachium rosenbergii, tail meat was subjected to different MUIF treatments respectively, namely 20 + 40 kHz (MUIF-20 + 40), 20 + 60 kHz (MUIF-20 + 60), 40 + 60 kHz (MUIF-40 + 60) and 20 + 40 + 60 kHz (MUIF-20 + 40 + 60), and the immersion freezing (IF) as control. Results showed that average diameter of ice crystals was 28 μm in IF, and that was only 8 μm in MUIF-20 + 40 + 60. When compared to IF, MUIF alleviated oxidative deterioration of lipids and proteins, but only at higher ultrasound frequency (MUIF-40 + 60; MUIF-20 + 40 + 60). Carbonyl content of MUIF-20 + 40 + 60 was only 40% of that in IF. Similarly, protein denaturation was inhibited in MUIF (except for MUIF-20 + 40). Transmission electron microscopy showed greater distortion of the ultrastructural components in IF, MUIF-40 + 60, and MUIF-20 + 40 + 60, suggested by bended Z-line. In conclusion, MUIF can be an effective strategy to mitigate mechanical damage and protein deterioration in the meat of Macrobrachium rosenbergii.

State analysis of a biobased hydrogel subjected to freeze and thaw processes by X ray absorption spectroscopy using synchrotron radiation

Freezing hydrogels can compromise their network structures and modify their properties as a result of ice crystal formation. Therefore, understanding the internal structure, including ice crystals and the state of chemical components within hydrogels, is essential. In this study, we evaluated the elemental distribution in bio-based hydrogels subjected to freezing-thaw process using X-ray absorption spectroscopy with synchrotron radiation. A bio-based hydrogel, prepared from Alaska pollock, underwent both slow and rapid freezing processes. Tomographic images and linear X-ray absorption coefficient distributions of the rapidly frozen hydrogel displayed a uniform image with a mean absorption coefficient of 2.81 cm-1. Conversely, the slowly frozen sample exhibited distinct contrasts with peaks at 2.516 cm-1 (dark) and 3.691 cm-1 (bright), occupying 28% and 72% of the image, respectively. The mean absorption coefficient of the slowly frozen sample was comparable to that of the rapidly frozen sample, indicating no elemental loss. The elements within the hydrogel were categorized into organic elements, macrominerals, and trace elements. The bright areas in the images were attributed to the concentration of macrominerals. Notably, Cl and Na were the primary contributors to the absorption coefficients among the elements present, signifying salt migration during freezing. These findings suggest that the contrast observed in X-ray computed tomography images after freezing reflects the elemental distribution within the hydrogel and successfully demonstrates element localization due to cryoconcentration.

Electric Field-Enhanced Ion Rejection Rate in Freeze Desalination

Freeze desalination is an appealing method for seawater desalination through freezing seawater. The percentage of ions in the liquid phase, which is termed ion rejection rate, is a critical factor affecting the performance of freeze desalination. Improving the ion rejection rate is an important topic for freeze desalination. In this work, we investigate the effects of electric fields on the ion rejection rate during the freezing of seawater through molecular dynamics simulations. It is found that the ion rejection rate increases with increasing electric field strength. The enhanced ion rejection rate is due to the reduction of the energy barrier at the ice-water interface caused by the electric field, which affects the orientation of water molecules and ion-water interactions. However, the electric field hinders the ice growth rate, which affects the productivity of freeze desalination. Nevertheless, the finding in this work offers a new idea to improve the ion rejection rate. Practically, a trade-off needs to be found to optimize the overall performance of freeze desalination.

In situ investigation of ice fractions and water states during partial freezing of pork loins and shrimps

Ice fractions and water states in partially frozen muscle foods greatly affect their quality. In the study, a variable temperature nuclear magnetic resonance (VT-NMR) with a liquid nitrogen temperature control system was employed to in situ investigate the relationship between ice fractions and temperatures and changes in water states during partial freezing and thawing of pork and shrimp. Results indicated that changes in ice fractions ranging from -2 ∼ -20 °C could be divided into 3 stages including slow increase, random leap and remarkable leap. More serious damages to the structures related to immobile water occurred in shrimp than in pork, and partial freezing also caused deterioration in muscle fibres related to free water. Additionally, -2 ∼ -3 °C and - 3.5 °C were the appropriate partial freezing temperatures for pork and shrimp, respectively. Therefore, the VT-NMR method possessed great potential for fundamental studies and applications of partial freezing of muscle foods.

Impact of freeze-thaw cycles on the physicochemical properties and structure-function relationship of potato starch with varying granule sizes in frozen dough

Starch, as a critical component of dough, significantly influences quality preservation during the freezing process. In particular, the fine structure of potato (B-type) starch in frozen processing is a subject of considerable interest. This study aims to investigate the intrinsic differences of B-type starch and the impact of freeze-thaw (F/T) treatment on its molecular structure and physicochemical properties. Chain length distribution and X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy were utilized to examine the structural characteristics of natural potato starch with different granule sizes. Furthermore, the fine structure, thermal properties, and rheological properties of the isolated starches after F/T treatment were analyzed. The results indicate that potato starch with smaller particle sizes exhibits higher surface CC and PO content along with a higher proportion of very short chains (DP < 6, 8.17 %) and long B chains (DP > 25, 20.68 %). The study found that after F/T treatment, the surface of small-sized starch granules was initially damaged, exhibiting threads on the surface centered on the umbilical point. Following F/T treatment, both the crystallinity (very large (VL): 24.52-18.36 %; small (S): 17.03-16.69 %) and short-range order (VL: 2.97-2.61; S: 2.71-2.35) of starch particle size decreased. Both the amylose content (20.88-14.57 %) and ΔH (10.15-8.62 J/g) of isolated starch after freeze-thaw-treated dough exhibited a decrease to varying degrees. With the exception of the fifth cycle, small-size starch particles exhibited relatively higher G' and G" values and showed significant changes as a result of F/T treatment, demonstrating high hardness and complex viscosity. Clarifying the physicochemical properties of potato starches with different granule sizes is expected to expand their applications in frozen dough.

Electric fields as effective strategies for enhancing quality attributes of meat in cold chain logistics: A review

Meat quality (MQ) is unstable during cold chain logistics (CCL). Different technologies have been developed to enhance MQ during the CCL process, while most of them cannot cover all the links of the cold chain because of complex environment (especially transportation and distribution), compatibility issues, and their single effect. Electric fields (EFs) have been explored as a novel treatment for different food processing. The effects and potential advantages of EFs for biological cryopreservation have been reported in many publications and some commercial applications in CCL have been realized. However, there is still a lack of a systematic review on the effects of EFs on their quality attributes in meat and its applications in CCL. In this review, the potential mechanisms of EFs on meat physicochemical properties (heat and mass transfer and ice formation and melting) and MQ attributes during different CCL links (freezing, thawing, and refrigeration processes) were summarized. The current applications and limitations of EFs for cryopreserving meat were also discussed. Although high intensity EFs have some detrimental effects on the quality attributes in meat due to electroporation and electro-breakdown effect, EFs present good applicability opportunities in most CCL scenes that have been realized in some commercial applications. Future studies should focus on the biochemical reactions of meat to the different EFs parameters, and break the limitations on equipment, so as to make EFs techniques closer to usability in the production environment and realize cost-effective large-scale application of EFs on CCL.

Enhancing cell cryopreservation with acidic polyamino acids integrated liquid marbles

Cryopreservation is highly desired for long-term maintenance of the viability of living biosamples, while effective cell cryopreservation still relies heavily on the addition of dimethyl sulfoxide (DMSO) and fetal bovine serum (FBS). However, the intrinsic toxicity of DMSO is still a bottleneck, which could not only cause the clinical side effect but also induce cell genetic variants. In the meantime, the addition of FBS may bring potentially the risk of pathogenic microorganism contamination. The liquid marbles (LMs), a novel biotechnology tool for cell cryopreservation, which not only have a small volume system that facilitated recovery, but the hydrophobic shell also resisted the harm to cells caused by adverse environments. Previous LM-based cell cryopreservation relied heavily on the addition of FBS. In this work, we introduced acidic polyaspartic acid and polyglutamic acid as cryoprotectants to construct LM systems. LMs could burst in an instant to facilitate and achieve ultrarapid recovery process, and the hydrophilic carboxyl groups of the cryoprotectants could form hydrogen bonds with water molecules and further inhibit ice growth/formation to protect cells from cryoinjuries. The L929 cells could be well cryopreserved by acidic polyamino acid-based LMs. This new biotechnology platform is expected to be widely used for cell cryopreservation, which has the potential to propel LMs for the preservation of various functional cells in the future.

Structure and mechanical properties of anisotropic agar gels obtained via unidirectional freezing

The controllable formation of anisotropic gel structures is presently sought for the development of foods with novel textures. Here, we used unidirectional freezing to generate agar gels consisting of a honeycomb-like porous network of elongated and aligned pores. A custom-built Peltier system allowed for control of the freezing front velocity throughout the agar gels. A higher freezing velocity (10 µm/s) led to smaller pore sizes compared to the slower freezing velocity tested (2 µm/s). Texture analysis highlighted the significantly higher Young's modulus in the gels when compressed in the axial vs. radial direction - a direct consequence of the unidirectional freezing. The proton spin-spin relaxation time revealed greater water mobility in the unidirectionally frozen gel with larger pores. This study serves as the basis for the development of anisotropic hydrocolloid gels with a tunable microstructure and texture.

The impact of magnetic field-assisted freeze-thaw treatment on the quality of foxtail millet sourdough and steamed bread

Foxtail millet and sourdough are used to make foxtail millet sourdough steamed bread to improve the flavor and taste. Compared with the conventional freeze-thaw treatment (CFT), the effect of magnetic field-assisted freeze-thaw treatment (MFT) on the storage quality of foxtail millet sourdough and steamed bread is explored. The results showed that compared with CFT, MFT shortened the phase transition time of dough; decreased the water loss rate, the water mobility, and the freezable water content; increased the fermentation volume; stabilized the rheological properties; and minimized the damage of freezing and thawing to the secondary structure and microstructure of the gluten. In addition, an analysis of the specific volume, texture, surface color, and texture structure showed that MFT was beneficial to slowing the deterioration of the steamed bread texture. Finally, MFT effectively inhibited the growth and recrystallization of ice crystals during freezing and thawing, improving the quality of millet dough and steamed bread.

Basic Theory of Ice Crystallization Based on Water Molecular Structure and Ice Structure

Freezing storage is the most common method of food preservation and the formation of ice crystals during freezing has an important impact on food quality. The water molecular structure, mechanism of ice crystal formation, and ice crystal structure are elaborated in the present review. Meanwhile the methods of ice crystal characterization are outlined. It is concluded that the distribution of the water molecule cluster structure during the crystallization process directly affects the formed ice crystals' structure, but the intrinsic relationship needs to be further investigated. The morphology and distribution of ice crystals can be observed by experimental methods while simulation methods provide the possibility to study the molecular structure changes in water and ice crystals. It is hoped that this review will provide more information about ice crystallization and promote the control of ice crystals in frozen foods.

Effect of Oscillating Magnetic Fields (OMFs) and Pulsed Electric Fields (PEFs) on Supercooling Preservation of Atlantic Salmon (Salmo salar L.) Fillets

Salmon, rich in protein and omega-3 fatty acids, has a short shelf life of 1 to 3 days when stored at 2 to 8 °C. Freezing, used for long-term preservation, often results in ice crystal formation. Ice crystals can cause structural damage, leading to cell wall rupture, which can affect the texture and cause nutrient loss. Ultimately, this process reduces the overall quality of the salmon. Supercooling, which cools food below its freezing temperature without forming ice crystals, offers an alternative. This study investigated the effects of oscillating magnetic fields (OMFs) and pulsed electric fields (PEFs) on ice crystal formation during salmon supercooling. The results showed that using OMFs and PEFs in supercooling reduced the storage temperature of salmon, maintaining a similar thiobarbituric acid reactive substances (TBARS) value to that of frozen and refrigerated samples. There was no significant difference in meat color between the fresh and frozen samples, and drip loss weight was comparable between the fresh and supercooled samples. The microbiological counts were the lowest in the supercooled samples compared to the frozen and refrigerated ones. These findings suggest that supercooling storage with OMFs and PEFs can mitigate quality degradation in salmon typically associated with freezing.

Plant Cryopreservation: Principles, Applications, and Challenges of Banking Plant Diversity at Ultralow Temperatures

Progressive loss of plant diversity requires the protection of wild and agri-/horticultural species. For species whose seeds are extremely short-lived, or rarely or never produce seeds, or whose genetic makeup must be preserved, cryopreservation offers the only possibility for long-term conservation. At temperatures below freezing, most vegetative plant tissues suffer severe damage from ice crystal formation and require protection. In this review, we describe how increasing the concentration of cellular solutes by air drying or adding cryoprotectants, together with rapid cooling, results in a vitrified, highly viscous state in which cells can remain viable and be stored. On this basis, a range of dormant bud-freezing, slow-cooling, and (droplet-)vitrification protocols have been developed, but few are used to cryobank important agricultural/horticultural/timber and threatened species. To improve cryopreservation efficiency, the effects of cryoprotectants and molecular processes need to be understood and the costs for cryobanking reduced. However, overall, the long-term costs of cryopreservation are low, while the benefits are huge.

Effect of Static Magnetic Field on the Quality of Pork during Super-Chilling Storage

Fresh pork tenderloin was stored at -3 °C under different static magnetic fields (SMF) of 0, 4, and 10 mT (control, MF-4, and MF-10) to investigate their physicochemical properties changes during storage of 8 days. The initial equilibrium temperature of the samples stored with 4 mT MF was found to be -2.3 °C, which was slightly lower (0.3 °C) than that the control value. The super-chilling phenomenon on the pork was then observed, as the samples stored under the magnetic field did not freeze throughout storage period, but the control experienced a sudden change in temperature after 138 h and then froze. The preservation effect of MF-4 on meat quality was the best in all treatment groups. MF-4 achieved a higher water-retention rate, with drip and cook losses of 6.5% and 29.0% lower than the control, respectively. Meanwhile, the MF-4 effectively delayed the color change in the meat during the storage and the texture hardening after cooking, and effectively controlled the growth of the total volatile saline nitrogen content on the samples. In addition, MF-4 delayed the reduction in myofibrillar protein solubility, sulfhydryl content, and emulsification capacity, indicating that this field inhibited the denaturation of myofibrillar protein. This study can be considered as an application reference of magnetic fields during meat storage at a super-chilled temperature.

Synergistic mechanism of steam blanching and freezing conditions on the texture of frozen yellow peaches based on macroscopic and microscopic properties

Freezing and blanching are essential processing steps in the production of frozen yellow peaches, inevitably leading to texture softening of the fruit. In this study, the synergistic mechanism of stem blanching, freezing conditions (-20°C, -40°C, -80°C, and liquid nitrogen [-173°C]), and sample sizes (cubes, slices, and half peaches) on macroscopic properties of texture, cellular structure, and ice crystal size distribution of frozen yellow peaches were measured. Blanching enhanced the heat and mass transfer rates in the subsequent freezing process. For nonblanched samples, cell membrane integrity was lost at any freezing rate, causing a significant reduction in textural quality. Slow freezing further exacerbated the texture softening, while the ultra-rapid freezing caused structural rupture. For blanched samples, the half peaches softened the most. The water holding capacity and fracture stress were not significantly affected by changes in freezing rate, although the ice crystal size distribution was more susceptible to the freezing rate. Peach cubes that had undergone blanching and rapid freezing (-80°C) experienced 4% less drip loss than nonblanched samples. However, blanching softened yellow peaches more than any freezing conditions. The implementation of uniform and shorter duration blanching, along with rapid freezing, has been proven to be more effective in preserving the texture of frozen yellow peaches. Optimization of the blanching process may be more important than increasing the freezing rate to improve the textural quality of frozen yellow peaches.

Inulin Can Improve Red Blood Cell Cryopreservation by Promoting Vitrification, Stabilizing Cell Membranes, and Inhibiting Ice Recrystallization

In transfusion medicine, the cryopreservation of red blood cells (RBCs) is of major importance. The organic solvent glycerol (Gly) is considered the current gold-standard cryoprotectant (CPA) for RBC cryopreservation, but the deglycerolization procedure is complex and time-consuming, resulting in severe hemolysis. Therefore, it remains a research hotspot to find biocompatible and effective novel CPAs. Herein, the natural and biocompatible inulin, a polysaccharide, was first employed as a CPA for RBC cryopreservation. The presence of inulin could improve the thawed RBC recovery from 11.83 ± 1.40 to 81.86 ± 0.37%. It was found that inulin could promote vitrification because of its relatively high viscosity and glass transition temperature (Tg'), thus reducing the damage during cryopreservation. Inulin possessed membrane stability, which also had beneficial effects on RBC recovery. Moreover, inulin could inhibit the mechanical damage induced by ice recrystallization during thawing. After cryopreservation, the RBC properties were maintained normally. Mathematical modeling analysis was adopted to compare the performance of inulin, Gly, and hydroxyethyl starch (HES) in cryopreservation, and inulin presented the best efficiency. This work provides a promising CPA for RBC cryopreservation and may be beneficial for transfusion therapy in the clinic.

The limit of macroscopic homogeneous ice nucleation at the nanoscale

Nucleation in small volumes of water has garnered renewed interest due to the relevance of pore condensation and freezing under conditions of low partial pressures of water, such as in the upper troposphere. Molecular simulations can in principle provide insight on this process at the molecular scale that is challenging to achieve experimentally. However, there are discrepancies in the literature as to whether the rate in confined systems is enhanced or suppressed relative to bulk water at the same temperature and pressure. In this study, we investigate the extent to which the size of the critical nucleus and the rate at which it grows in thin films of water are affected by the thickness of the film. Our results suggest that nucleation remains bulk-like in films that are barely large enough accommodate a critical nucleus. This conclusion seems robust to the presence of physical confining boundaries. We also discuss the difficulties in unambiguously determining homogeneous nucleation rates in nanoscale systems, owing to the challenges in defining the volume. Our results suggest any impact on a film's thickness on the rate is largely inconsequential for present day experiments.

An open-hardware community ice nucleation cold stage for research and teaching

Aerosol particles with rare specific properties act as nuclei for ice formation. The presence of ice nucleating particles in the atmosphere leads to heterogeneous freezing at warm temperatures and thus these particles play an important role in modulating microphysical properties of clouds. This work presents an ice nucleation cold stage instrument for measuring the concentration of ice nucleating particles in liquids. The cost is ∼ $10 k including an external chiller. Using a lower cost heat sink reduces the cost to ∼ $6 k. The instrument is suitable for studying ambient ice nucleating particle concentrations and laboratory-based process-level studies of ice nucleation. The design plans allow individuals to self-manufacture the cold-stage using 3D printing, off-the-shelf parts, and a handful of standard tools. Software to operate the instrument and analyze the data is also provided. The design is intended to be simple enough that a graduate student can build it as part of a course or thesis project. Costs are kept to a minimum to facilitate use in classroom demonstrations and laboratory classes.

Observation on the ice crystal formation process of large yellow croaker (Pseudosciaena crocea) and the effect of multiple cryoprotectants pre-soaking treatments on frozen quality

By observing the formation behavior of ice crystals, the quality of food products under different freezing conditions can be intuitively judged. In this paper, large yellow croaker was taken as the research object, and a novel cryomicroscopic system was developed to directly observe the structure of ice crystals during the freezing process. The cryoprotective effects of 4% sucrose +4% sorbitol (SU + SO), 4% xylo-oligosaccharide (XO), 4% xylo-oligosaccharide + 0.3% tetrasodium pyrophosphate (XO + TSPP) and 0.2% antifreeze protein (AFP) at different freezing temperatures were investigated. And the evaluation indicators, such as cell deformation degree, equivalent diameters, roundness, elongation and fractal dimension were introduced to quantify the damage of ice crystals to muscle tissues and fibers. The results indicate that reducing the freezing temperature and adding cryoprotectants can improve the quality of large yellow croaker. AFP has the best cryoprotective effect, with a reduction in cell deformation degree of 54.78% and 67.83% compared to the Control group at -5 °C and -20 °C, respectively. SU + SO and XO have the equivalent antifreeze effect, which is slightly inferior to XO + TSPP. In addition, physical parameters of large yellow croaker samples were measured to verify the influence of ice crystal structure on product quality. Therefore, direct observation of the ice crystal formation process and evaluation of ice crystal structure can accurately reflect the quality of frozen products, which is of great significance for the development of refrigeration and preservation technology.

Challenges and processing strategies to produce high quality frozen meat

Freezing is an effective means to extend the shelf-life of meat products. However, freezing and thawing processes lead to physical (e.g., ice crystals formation and freezer burn) and biochemical changes (e.g., protein denaturation and lipid oxidation) in meat resulting in loss of quality. Over the last two decades, several attempts have been made to produce thawed meat with qualities similar to that of fresh meat to no avail. This is due to the fact that no single technique exists to date that can mitigate all the quality challenges caused by freezing and thawing. This is further confounded by the consumer perception of frozen meat as lower quality compared to equivalent fresh-never-frozen meat cuts. Therefore, it remains challenging for the meat industry to produce high quality frozen meat and increase consumer acceptability of frozen products. This review aimed to provide an overview of the applications of novel freezing and thawing technologies that could improve the quality of thawed meat including deep freezing, high pressure, radiofrequency, electro-magnetic resonance, electrostatic field, immersion solution, microwave, ohmic heating, and ultrasound. This review will also discuss the development in processing strategies such as optimising the ageing of meat pre- or post-freezing, and the integration of freezing and thawing in one process/regime to collapse the difference in quality between thawed meat and fresh-never-frozen equivalents.

Observation and Measurement of Ice Morphology in Foods: A Review

Freezing is an effective technology with which to maintain food quality. However, the formation of ice crystals during this process can cause damage to the cellular structure, leading to food deterioration. A good understanding of the relationship between food microstructure and ice morphology, as well as the ability to effectively measure and control ice crystals, is very useful to achieve high-quality frozen foods. Hence, a brief discussion is presented on the fundamentals/principles of optical microscopic techniques (light microscopy), electronic microscopic techniques (transmission electron microscopy (TEM) and scanning electron microscopy (SEM)), as well as other non-invasive techniques (X-rays, spectroscopy, and magnetic resonance) and their application to measuring ice formation rates and characterizing ice crystals, providing insight into the freezing mechanisms as well as direct monitoring of the entire process. And, in addition, this review compares (the negative and positive aspects of) the use of simple and cheap but destructive technologies (optical microscopy) with detailed microscopic technologies at the micro/nanometer scale but with pretreatments that alter the original sample (SEM and TEM), and non-destructive technologies that do not require sample preparation but which have high acquisition and operational costs. Also included are images and examples which demonstrate how useful an analysis using these techniques can be.

Natural deep eutectic solvent: A promising eco-friendly food bio-inspired antifreezing

Bio-antifreezing is a green and highly effective strategy to inhibit ice nucleation. Bio-inspired antifreezing faces the severe challenges of significant toxicity and complex manufacturing procedures. Bio-inspired antifreezing natural deep eutectic solvent (Ba-NADES) could be an efficient and low or no-toxicity approach for the frozen food industry. Ba-NADES form a strong hydrogen bond network system under cold conditions, capably reducing the melting point of the system below the freezing point and effectively inhibiting ice growth. It has efficaciously alleviated freeze injury by Ba-NADES. The review highlights the current strategies of bio-inspired antifreezing, cold resistance behavior in organisms, and the existing applications of Ba-NADES. It updated information concerning their mechanisms for antifreezing. It emphasizes that the role of water on the antifreezing quality of NADES is worthy of further investigation for more extensive food applications. This work will provide a comprehensive overview of NADES antifreezing.

Qualitative Comparison of Cryostat- versus Snap-Frozen Neurosurgical Intraoperative Consultations

Background. Frozen sections (FS) are common in neurosurgery to address varied clinical concerns. Artifacts in central nervous system (CNS) FS can be severe and affect or hinder interpretation. We performed a case-control study using a semiquantitative scale: the Histologic Preservation Score (HPS), and a quantitative scale: the Ice Crystal Vacuolization Score (ICVS), to compare the histologic quality yielded by snap- versus cryostat freezing techniques. Material and Methods. All specimens were sectioned in 2 halves, one half was used for FS and the other for permanent evaluation. HPS assigns a distortion score to the FS sample using the non-frozen half as the comparator: 1  =  minimal, 2  =  slight, 3  =  moderate, 4 & 5  =  severe. The ICVS is the average size in µm of the 5 largest vacuoles/0.05 mm2, evaluated on digitized slides. Results. 86 CNS-FS were collected: 22 snap- and 64 cryostat-FS. Significant differences in HPS: 2.28 versus 2.84 (p <0.05) and ICVS 7.47 versus 14.56 (p < 0.001) were obtained for snap- versus cryostat-FS, respectively. HPS and ICVS showed a strong correlation: R2 = 0.63, p < 0.0001. Histologic distortion was worse for neuroglial than mesenchymal tissue by both methods; however, a significant difference was only observed in cryostat-FS: HPS: 3.23 versus 2.33, p < 0.001; ICVS: 16.86 μm versus 10.26 μm, p < 0.001. Conclusion. Snap-FS yields better histologic quality than cryostat-FS for CNS-FS, and the difference is more pronounced in neuroglial samples. HPS and ICVS correlate strongly, indicating that the histologic quality is inversely proportional to water-crystallization. These results may apply to other areas of surgical pathology.

Dielectric relaxation of ice in a partially crystallized poly(N-isopropylacrylamide)microgel suspension compared to other partially crystalized polymer-water mixtures

A broadband dielectric spectroscopy study was conducted on a partially crystallized 10 wt% poly(N-isopropylacrylamide) [PNIPAM] microgel aqueous suspension to investigate the dielectric relaxation of ice in microgel suspensions. The measurements covered a frequency range of 10 mHz to 10 MHz and at temperatures ranging from 123 K to 273 K. Two distinct relaxation processes were observed at specific frequencies below the melting temperature. One is associated with the combination of the local chain motion of PNIPAM and interfacial polarization in the uncrystallized phase, while another is associated with ice. To understand the temperature-dependent behaviour of the ice relaxation process, the relaxation time of ice was compared with those observed in other frozen polymer water mixtures, including gelatin, poly-vinylpyrrolidone (PVP), and bovine serum albumin (BSA). For concentrations ≥ 10 wt%, the temperature dependence of the relaxation time of ice was found to be independent. Therefore, the study primarily focused on the 10 wt% data for easier comprehension of the ice relaxation process. It was found that the microgel and globular protein BSA had no significant effect on ice crystallization, while gelatin slowed down the crystallization process, and PVP accelerated it. To discuss the mechanism of the dielectric relaxation of ice, the trap-controlled proton transport model developed by Khamzin et al. [Chem. Phys., 2021, 541, 111040.] was employed. The model was used to discuss the dynamic heterogeneity of ice observed in this investigation, distinguishing it from the spatial heterogeneity of ice commonly discussed.

Effects of sodium carboxymethyl cellulose on storage stability and qualities of different frozen dough

Hydrocolloids as Additives have been used for improving the quality of frozen dough for a long time. In this work, the effects of sodium carboxymethyl cellulose (CMC) on quality changes of frozen dough in storage were studied. The water loss rate of the dough and water holding capacity were measured. Rheological and texture properties of the frozen dough were measured by a rheometer and a texture analyzer, respectively. Scanning electron microscopy (SEM) was used to characterize surface network structure and protein structure changes of the frozen dough. Our results reveal that the addition of CMC can inhibit the formation of ice crystals and recrystallization, thus effectively stabilizing the molecular structure of starch, and resulting in more uniform moisture distribution in the frozen dough. When 3% addition of CMC, the water holding capacity of the two kinds of dough reached the best, and the water loss rate of corn dough reached the lowest. The cohesion of the two kinds of dough reaches the maximum with 3 wt% addition of CMC, while the hardness and chewiness of wheat and corn multigrain dough reaches the maximum with 3 wt% and 4 wt% addition of CMC, respectively. The results show proper CMC addition (3 wt% and 4 wt%) finally improves the stability and qualities of the frozen dough. The research concerning the effects of CMC on quality of frozen dough provides better understanding for the frozen food industry.

Storage Quality Changes in Craft and Industrial Blueberry, Strawberry, Raspberry and Passion Fruit-Mango Sorbets

Sorbets are a popular dessert, especially during hot summer days. They can also have health-promoting qualities, mainly due to the nutritional value of the fruit from which they are made. The production technology can also have an impact on the final nutritional quality of the sorbets. This paper presents a comparative assessment of the quality of industrial fruit sorbets and their craft analogs. Sorbets with the following flavors were selected for the research: blueberry, strawberry, raspberry, and passion fruit with mango. An organoleptic evaluation was performed, and the overrun, melting resistance, active acidity (pH), color in the CIE Lab system, antiradical activity (DDPH method), and content of vitamin C and total polyphenols were determined. The research revealed the differences between sorbets produced from different fruits as well as the differences depending on the production method between products made of the same type of fruit. Craft sorbets were found to be better than industrial sorbets, and storage time had a significant effect on the sorbets' quality. In terms of organoleptic characteristics, craft mango-passion fruit sorbet turned out to be the best; in terms of antioxidant properties, craft raspberry and strawberry sorbets were the best, and these two sorbets also showed good, stable overrun and melting resistance values during storage.

The mechanisms and applications of cryoprotectants in aquatic products: An overview

Frozen storage technology has been widely used for the preservation of Aquatic products. However, ice crystals formation, lipid oxidation and protein denaturation still easily causes aquatic products deterioration. Cryoprotectants are a series of food additives that could efficiently prolong the shelf life and guarantee the acceptability of frozen aquatic products. This review comprehensively illustrated the mechanism of protein denaturation caused by the ice crystal formation and lipid oxidation. The cryoprotective mechanism of various kinds of antifreeze agents (saccharides, phosphates, antifreeze proteins and peptides) and these cryoprotective structure-activity relationship, application efficiency on the quality of aquatic products were also discussed. Moreover, the advantages and disadvantages of each cryoprotectant are also prospected. Compared with others, antifreeze peptides show higher commercial and application values. While, lots of scientific research works are still required to develop novel antifreeze agent as a versatile ingredient with commercial value, applicable in the aquatic products preservation industry.

Spatiotemporal Control of Ice Crystallization in Supercooled Water via an Ultrashort Laser Impulse

Focused irradiation with ultrashort laser pulses realized the fine spatiotemporal control of ice crystallization in supercooled water. An effective multiphoton excitation at the laser focus generated shockwaves and bubbles, which acted as an impulse for inducing ice crystal nucleation. The impulse that was localized close to the laser focus and accompanied by a small temperature elevation allowed the precise position control of ice crystallization and its observation with spatiotemporal resolution of micrometers and microseconds using a microscope. To verify the versatility of this laser method, we also applied it using various aqueous systems (e.g., plant extracts). The systematic study of crystallization probability revealed that laser-induced cavitation bubbles play a crucial role in inducing ice crystal nucleation. This method can be used as a tool for studying ice crystallization dynamics in various natural and biological phenomena.

Non-destructive and in-situ detection of shrimp freshness using mid-infrared fiber-optic evanescent wave spectroscopy

There is strong interest in non-destructive and rapid determination of food freshness in food research. In this study, mid-infrared (MIR) fiber-optic evanescent wave (FOEW) spectroscopy was applied to monitor shrimp freshness through the evaluation of protein, chitin, and calcite contents in conjunction with a Partial Least Squares Discriminant Analysis (PLS-DA) model. Shrimp shells were wiped with a micro fiber-optic probe to obtain a FOEW spectrum which quickly and nondestructively allowed evaluation of the shrimp freshness. Peaks for proteins, chitin, and calcite, which are closely related to shrimp freshness, were detected and quantified. Compared with the standard indicator for evaluating shrimp freshness (total volatile basic nitrogen), the PLS-DA model gave recognition rates for shrimp freshness using calibration and validation sets of the FOEW data of 87.27%, 90.28%, respectively. Our results show that FOEW spectroscopy is a feasible method for non-destructive and in-site detection of shrimp freshness.

Carboxymethylcellulose reinforced, double-network hydrogel-based strain sensor with superior sensing stability for long-term monitoring

Hydrogel-based strain sensors have garnered significant attention for their potential for human health monitoring. However, its practical application has been hindered by water loss, freezing, and structural impairment during long-term motion monitoring. Here, a strain sensor based on double-network (DN) hydrogel of polyacrylamide (PAAm)/carboxymethylcellulose (CMC) was developed in a ternary solvent system of lithium chloride (LiCl)/ethylene glycol (EG)/H₂O through a facile one-pot radical polymerization strategy. The incorporation of EG effectively mitigated the hydration of lithium salts by generating stable ion clusters with Li⁺ and stronger hydrogen bonds within the polymer matrix. The sensor demonstrated excellent mechanical properties, including a stretchability of 1858 %, toughness of 1.80 MJ/m³, and recoverability of 102 %. Furthermore, the LiCl/EG/H₂O ternary system resulted in high conductivity, excellent anti-freezing performance, and superior sensing stability. In addition, the sensor exhibited remarkable sensitivity, enabling the monitoring of human movements ranging from subtle to significant deformations, including throat motion and bending of the elbow, wrist, finger, and lower limb. This study presents a viable approach for constructing hydrogel-based strain sensors with exceptional sensing stability for long-term tracking of human motions.

Effects of electric and magnetic field on freezing characteristics of gel model food

The novel freezing technologies including electrostatic field assisted freezing (EF), static magnetic field assisted freezing (MF), electrostatic field combined with static magnetic field assisted freezing (EMF) were conducted on model food to facilitate comparing their application effect. The results show that the effect of EMF treatment was best, which significantly changed the freezing parameters of the sample. Compared with the control, the phase transition time and total freezing time were shortened by 17.2% and 10.5%, respectively; the proportion of the sample free water content detected by low-field nuclear magnetic resonance was significantly decreased; the gel strength and hardness were significantly improved; the protein secondary and tertiary structures were better maintained; the ice crystal area was reduced by 49.28%. Inverted fluorescence and scanning electron microscopic results indicated that the gel structure of EMF treatment samples was better than MF and EF. MF was less effective in maintaining the quality of frozen gel model.

Visible light laser direct-writing of high-resolution, biocompatible, super-multifunctional and tough hydrogels without photoinitiators in 30 s

Currently, the lack of bioinks and long printing time limits the further development of biofabrication. Here we report a novel biocompatible, multi-functional and tough 3D printable hydrogel via visible light photocrosslinking of polyvinyl alcohol bearing styrylpyridinium group (PVA-SbQ). The high-resolution PVA-SbQ hydrogels with different designed shapes can be generated via laser direct-writing in 30 s without extra toxic crosslinkers or photoinitiators, and demonstrates excellent biocompatibility. The rapid laser direct-writing technology also results in a super-strong, tough hydrogel with excellent adhesive, swelling, self-healing, and photo-tunable properties due to the photodimerization of styrylpyridinium (SbQ) groups and the left-over massive amount of free hydroxyl groups in the hydrogel. For example, the maximum tensile strength, elongation, compressive strength adhesive strength of printed PVA-SbQ hydrogels can reach 1.0 MPa, 810 %, 33 MPa, 31 kPa, and 25,000 % respectively. And these properties can be adjusted by controlling the parameters for laser direct-writing. In addition, the introduced nitrogen cations by SbQ groups further endow hydrogels with the potential to develop novel functionality, which is demonstrated by integrating negatively charged nanocelluloses in the PVA-SbQ system to develop underwater adhesives, anti-freezing (-24.9 °C), and anti-bacterial hydrogels. This discovery opens multiple doors for developing PVA-SbQ based multi-functional hydrogel for various applications including biofabrication and tissue engineering.

Development of Antifreezing, Printable, Adhesive, Tough, Biocompatible, High-Water Content Hydrogel for Versatile Applications

Hydrogels with different functionalities such as printability, antifreezing properties, adhesion, biocompatibility, and toughness are being continually developed. However, it has been extremely challenging to design adhesive, antifreezing, tough, and biocompatible multifunctional hydrogels with complex shapes simultaneously and prepare them in a short period. In this paper, novel composite hydrogels, which consist of poly(vinyl alcohol) grafted with styrylpyridinium group (PVA-SbQ) and TEMPO-oxidized cellulose nanofibrils (CNF), were successfully synthesized via UV photo-cross-linking. In addition to UV photo-cross-linking, the PVA-SbQ/CNF hydrogels with different shapes could be rapidly printed by facile visible light-based stereolithography printing and laser direct-writing without any photoinitiators in 3 min and 30 s, respectively. The results show that PVA-SbQ/CNF hydrogels are biocompatible because there are no photoinitiators and cross-linkers required during the printing process under visible light. Moreover, the adhesive, antifreezing, mechanical properties, and water-binding capacity of PVA-SbQ/CNF with high-water contents improved significantly as the CNF contents increased. Such hydrogels, which combine multiple advantages, present great potential for application in wound dressings and portable devices with specific requirements for shapes, adhesion, toughness, and tolerance in extreme environments such as dry environments and low temperatures.

A biocompatible cell cryoprotectant based on sulfoxide-containing amino acids: mechanism and application

The preservation of cells at cryogenic temperatures requires the presence of cryoprotectants (CPAs). Dimethyl sulfoxide (DMSO), as a state-of-the-art CPA, is widely used for the storage of many types of cells. However, its intrinsic toxicity is still an obstacle for its applications in clinical practice. Herein, we report a DMSO analogue, L-methionine sulfoxide (Met(O)-OH), as a CPA for cell cryopreservation. The molecular-level cryopreservation roles of Met(O)-OH were investigated by experiments and molecular dynamics simulations. The results also found that Met(O)-OH showed high ice recrystallization inhibition (IRI) activity and the ice crystals in Met(O)-OH solution tend to be relatively round and smooth; moreover, the ice size was significantly reduced to 30.26 μm compared with pure water (135.87 μm) or DMSO solution (45.08 μm). At the molecular level, Met(O)-OH could stably bind the surface of the ice crystals and form more stable hydrogen bonds with ice compared with L-methionine. Moreover, Met(O)-OH could significantly reduce the damage to cells caused by osmotic shock and did not change the cell viability even at high concentration (4%). Based on these results, nucleated L929 cells and anuclear sheep red blood cells (SRBCs) were used as cell models to investigate the cryopreservation activity of Met(O)-OH. The results suggested that, under the optimum protocol, Met(O)-OH showed an effective post-thaw survival efficiency with ultrarapid freezing, and the post-thaw survival efficiency of L929 cells reached 84.0%. This work opens up the possibility for an alternative to traditional toxic CPA DMSO, and provides insights for the development of DMSO analogues with non-toxic/low toxicity for cell cryoprotection applications.

Effect of freezing raw meat on the physicochemical characteristics of beef jerky

The effect of freezing raw meat on the quality characteristics of beef jerky was evaluated in the present study. Jerky was made using different types of raw beef (fresh, frozen, and frozen-thawed) with different curing times (6 h and 12 h). Frozen-thawed beef had a lower moisture content than fresh or frozen beef due to higher exudate loss (P < 0.05). Jerky made using frozen and frozen-thawed beef showed lower drying yield and higher shear force than jerky prepared using fresh beef (P < 0.05). Freezing raw beef decreased the fat content and increased the redness, yellowness, chroma, and hue values of jerky (P < 0.05). The microstructure of beef jerky was showed to increase the deformation and contraction of muscle fibers due to freezing. Longer curing times increased the moisture content of jerky made using frozen meat (P < 0.05). Jerky made using frozen or frozen-thawed meat was tough due to excessive fat and moisture loss.

Research progress on quality deterioration mechanism and control technology of frozen muscle foods

Freezing can prolong the shelf life of muscle foods and is widely used in their preservation. However, inevitable quality deterioration can occur during freezing, frozen storage, and thawing. This review explores the eating quality deterioration characteristics (color, water holding capacity, tenderness, and flavor) and mechanisms (irregular ice crystals, oxidation, and hydrolysis of lipids and proteins) of frozen muscle foods. It also summarizes and classifies the novel physical-field-assisted-freezing technologies (high-pressure, ultrasound, and electromagnetic) and bioactive antifreeze (ice nucleation proteins, antifreeze proteins, natural deep eutectic solvents, carbohydrate, polyphenol, phosphate, and protein hydrolysates), regulating the dynamic process from water to ice. Moreover, some novel thermal and nonthermal thawing technologies to resolve the loss of water and nutrients caused by traditional thawing methods were also reviewed. We concluded that the physical damage caused by ice crystals was the primary reason for the deterioration in eating quality, and these novel techniques promoted the eating quality of frozen muscle foods under proper conditions, including appropriate parameters (power, time, and intermittent mode mentioned in ultrasound-assisted techniques; pressure involved in high-pressure-assisted techniques; and field strength involved in electromagnetic-assisted techniques) and the amounts of bioactive antifreeze. To obtain better quality frozen muscle foods, more efficient technologies and substances must be developed. The synergy of novel freezing/thawing technology may be more effective than individual applications. This knowledge may help improve the eating quality of frozen muscle foods.

Impact of different microwave treatments on food texture

Electromagnetic waves are frequently used for food processing with commercial or domestic type microwave ovens at present. Microwaves cause molecular movement by the migration of ionic particles or rotation of dipolar particles. Considering the potential applications of microwave technique in food industry, it is seen that microwaves have many advantages such as saving time, better final product quality (more taste, color, and nutritional value), and rapid heat generation. Although microwave treatment used for food processing with developing technologies have a positive effect in terms of time, energy, or nutrient value, it is also very important to what extent they affect the textural properties of the food that they apply to. For this purpose, in this study, it has been investigated that the effects of commonly used microwave treatments such as drying, heating, baking, cooking, thawing, toasting, blanching, frying, and sterilization on the textural properties of food. In addition, this study has also covered the challenges of microwave treatments and future work. In conclusion, microwave treatments cause energy saving due to a short processing time. Therefore, it can be said that it affects the textural properties positively. However, it is important that the microwave processing conditions used are chosen appropriately for each food material.

Freezing-induced denaturation of myofibrillar proteins in frozen meat

Freezing is commonly used to extend the shelf life of meat and meat products but may impact the overall quality of those products by inducing structural changes in myofibrillar proteins (MPs) through denaturation, chemical modification, and encouraging protein aggregation. This review covers the effect of freezing on the denaturation of MPs in terms of the effects of ice crystallization on solute concentrations, cold denaturation, and protein oxidation. Freezing-induced denaturation of MPs begins with ice crystallization in extracellular spaces and changes in solute concentrations in the unfrozen water fraction. At typical temperatures for freezing meat (lower than -18 °C), cold denaturation of proteins occurs, accompanied by an alteration in their secondary and tertiary structure. Moreover, the disruption of muscle cells triggers the release of cellular enzymes, accelerating protein degradation and oxidation. To minimize severe deterioration during the freezing and frozen storage of meat, there is a vital need to use an appropriate freezing temperature below the glass transition temperature and to avoid temperature fluctuations during storage to prevent recrystallization. Such an understanding of MP denaturation can be applied to determine the optimum freezing conditions for meat products with highly retained sensory, nutritional, and functional qualities.

Desmin as molecular chaperone for myofibrillar degradation during freeze-thaw cycles

This study investigated the relationship of secondary protein structures with textural attributes of chicken breast subjected to 6 freeze (-20 °C) thaw (4 °C for 12 h) cycles. 2DE identified 78 distinct protein spots. Moreover, WB indicated a remarkable increase in the degree of desmin degradation during multiple freeze-thaw (MFT). In addition, the TEM micrographs revealed that MFT remarkably increased the spacing between the muscle fibers, especially from cycles 3 to 5, slightly decreased H-zone, but a remarkable shrinkage of Z-lines, as well as degradation of myofibril structures (Z-line, I-bands, and M-lines). DSC showed shifts in first and second endothermic transition peaks during the 3rd and 5th cycles. Viscoelastic graphs revealed a cycle-dependent decrease in gel-forming ability (G') during MFT. Finally, the MFT chicken breast samples exhibited significantly decreased shear force in a cycle-dependent manner. This study highlighted the critical role of desmin in regulating myofibrillar degradation through various routes and mechanisms.

The drip loss inhibitory mechanism of nanowarming in jumbo squid (Dosidicus gigas) mantles: protein structure and molecular dynamics simulation

BACKGROUND

The magnetic nanoparticles plus microwave thawing (MNPMT), a new rewarming technology entitled 'nanowarming', can serve as an effective method to achieve rapid and uniform thawing, thus reducing drip loss. The purpose of this study was to decipher the drip loss inhibitory mechanism of MNPMT in jumbo squid (Dosidicus gigas) from the perspectives of protein structure and ice crystal recrystallization. A number of different techniques such as dynamic rheology, Raman spectra, intrinsic fluorescence measurement, and ultraviolet (UV) absorption spectra were conducted to analyze myofibrillar protein conformation and stability of jumbo squid. Scanning electron microscopy (SEM) and myofibrillar fragmentation index (MFI) were used to observe the growth of ice crystals. The interaction between magnetic nanoparticles (MNPs) and ice crystals was studied by using molecular dynamic (MD) simulation.

RESULTS

MNPMT exhibited the highest storage modulus (G') value at 90 °C, suggesting the protein conformation was more stable. The increase in α-helices, fluorescence intensity and characteristic absorption peak of MNPMT illustrated that MNPMT can effectively maintain the secondary and tertiary structure of the protein. Compared with cold storage thawing (CST) and microwave thawing (MT), the MFI value of MNPMT was significantly decreased (P < 0.01). The result of MD simulation showed that MNPs displayed a tendency to gradually approach the surface of ice crystals, and induced a certain degree of damage to the ice crystal surface, thereby markedly inhibiting ice crystal recrystallization.

CONCLUSION

MNPMT can reduce the drip loss by keeping the protein conformation stable and inhibiting the recrystallization of ice crystals during the thawing process. © 2022 Society of Chemical Industry.

Homogeneous ice nucleation rates for mW and TIP4P/ICE models through Lattice Mold calculations

Water freezing is the most common liquid-to-crystal phase transition on Earth, however, despite its critical implications on climate change and cryopreservation among other disciplines, its characterization through experimental and computational techniques remains elusive. In this work, we make use of computer simulations to measure the nucleation rate (J) of water at normal pressure under different supercooling conditions, ranging from 215 to 240K. We employ two different water models, mW, a coarse-grained potential for water, and TIP4P/ICE, an atomistic non-polarizable water model that provides one of the most accurate representations of the different ice phases. To evaluate J, we apply the Lattice Mold technique, a computational method based on the use of molds to induce the nucleus formation from the metastable liquid under conditions at which observing spontaneous nucleation would be unfeasible. With this method, we obtain estimates of the nucleation rate for ice Ih, Ic and a stacking mixture of ice Ih/Ic; reaching consensus with most of the previously reported rates, although differing with some others. Furthermore, we confirm that the predicted nucleation rates by the TIP4P/ICE model are in better agreement with experimental data than those obtained through the mW potential. Taken together, our study provides a reliable methodology to measure nucleation rates in a simple and computationally efficient manner which contributes to benchmarking the freezing behaviour of two popular water models.