Evaluation of immunogenicity and protection mediated by Lawsonia intracellularis subunit vaccines

Combined immunoinformatic approaches with computational biochemistry for development of subunit-based vaccine against Lawsonia intracellularis

Lawsonia intracellularis (LI) are obligate intracellular bacteria and the causative agent of proliferative hemorrhagic enteropathy that significantly impacts the health of piglets and the profitability of the swine industry. In this study, we used immunoinformatic and computational methodologies such as homology modelling, molecular docking, molecular dynamic (MD) simulation, and free energy calculations in a novel three stage approach to identify strong T and B cell epitopes in the LI proteome. From ∼ 1342 LI proteins, we narrowed our focus to 256 proteins that were either not well-identified (unknown role) or were expressed at a higher frequency in pathogenic strains relative to non-pathogenic strains. At stage 1, these proteins were analyzed for predicted virulence, antigenicity, solubility, and probability of residing within a membrane. At stage 2, we used NetMHCPan4-1 to identify over ten thousand cytotoxic T lymphocyte epitopes (CTLEs) and 286 CTLEs were ranked as having high predicted binding affinity for the SLA-1 and SLA-2 complexes. At stage 3, we used homology modeling to predict the structures of the top ranked CTLEs and we subjected each of them to molecular docking analysis with SLA-1*0401 and SLA-2*0402. The top ranked 25 SLA-CTLE complexes were selected to be an input for subsequent MD simulations to fully investigate the atomic-level dynamics of proteins under the natural thermal fluctuation of water and thus potentially provide deep insight into the CTLE-SLA interaction. We also performed free energy evaluation by Molecular Mechanics/Poisson-Boltzmann Surface Area to predict epitope interactions and binding affinities to the SLA-1 and SLA-2. We identified the top five CTLEs having the strongest binding energy to the indicated SLAs (-305.6 kJ/mol, -219.5 kJ/mol, -214.8 kJ/mol, -139.5 kJ/mol and -92.6 kJ/mol, respectively.) W also performed B-cell epitope prediction and the top-ranked 5 CTLEs and 3 B-cell epitopes were organized into a multi-epitope subunit antigen vaccine construct joined using EAAAK, AAY, KK, and GGGGG linkers with 40 residues of the LI DnaK protein attached to the N-terminus to further enhance the antigenicity of the vaccine construct. Blind docking studies showed strong interactions between our vaccine construct with swine Toll-like receptor 5. Collectively, these molecular modeling and immunoinformatic analyses present a useful in silico protocol for the discovery of candidate antigen in many viral and bacterial pathogens.

Vaccination with a Lawsonia intracellularis subunit water in oil emulsion vaccine mitigated some disease parameters but failed to affect shedding

Lawsonia intracellularis is the causative agent of ileitis in swine that manifests as slower weight gain, mild or hemorrhagic diarrhea and/or death in severe cases. As an economically important swine pathogen, development of effective vaccines is important to the swine industry. In developing a subunit vaccine with three recombinant antigens - FliC, GroEL and YopN - we wanted to identify a formulation that would produce robust immune responses that reduce disease parameters associated with Lawsonia intracellularis infection. We formulated these three antigens with four adjuvants: Montanide ISA 660 VG, Montanide Gel 02 PR, Montanide IMS 1313 VG NST, and Montanide ISA 61 VG in an immunogenicity study. Groups vaccinated with formulations including Montanide ISA 660 VG or Montanide ISA 61 VG had significantly more robust immune responses than groups vaccinated with formulations including Montanide Gel 02 PR or Montanide IMS 1313 VG NST. In the challenge study, animals vaccinated with these antigens and Montanide ISA 61 VG had reduced lesion scores, reduced lesion lengths, and increased average daily gain, but no reduction in shedding relative to the control animals. This work shows that this vaccine formulation should be considered for future study in a field and performance trial.

New Formulation of a Subunit Vaccine Candidate against Lawsonia intracellularis Increases Humoral and Cellular Immune Responses

Previously, we designed a subunit vaccine candidate based on three L. intracellularis antigens with promising results in pigs. In this study, antigens were produced individually to achieve an even antigen ratio in the formulation. The emulsion characterization included the drop size and the mechanical and thermal stability. Immune response was evaluated by indirect and sandwich ELISAs, qPCR, and flow cytometry. The vaccine candidate's safety was assessed by histopathology and monitoring the clinical behavior of animals. The average production yielded for the chimeric antigen as inclusion bodies was around 75 mg/L. The formulation showed mechanical and thermal stability, with a ratio Hu/Ho > 0.85 and a drop size under 0.15 nm. Antigens formulated at a ratio of 1:1:1 induced a significant immune response in inoculated pigs that persisted until the end of the experiment (week 14). The dose of 200 μg significantly activated cellular response measured by transcriptional and translational levels of cytokines. The cell proliferation assay revealed an increment of lymphocytes T CD4+ at the same dose. Animals gained weight constantly and showed proper clinical behavior during immunization assays. This research demonstrated the immunological robustness of the new subunit vaccine candidate against Porcine Proliferative Enteropathy evenly formulated with three chimeric antigens of L. intracellularis.

Co-Formulation of Recombinant Porcine IL-18 Enhances the Onset of Immune Response in a New Lawsonia intracellularis Vaccine

Pig is one of the most consumed meats worldwide. One of the main conditions for pig production is Porcine Enteropathy caused by Lawsonia intracellularis. Among the effects of this disease is chronic mild diarrhea, which affects the weight gain of pigs, generating economic losses. Vaccines available to prevent this condition do not have the desired effect, but this limitation can be overcome using adjuvants. Pro-inflammatory cytokines, such as interleukin 18 (IL-18), can improve an immune response, reducing the immune window of protection. In this study, recombinant porcine IL-18 was produced and expressed in Escherichia coli and Pichia pastoris. The protein's biological activity was assessed in vitro and in vivo, and we determined that the P. pastoris protein had better immunostimulatory activity. A vaccine candidate against L. intracellularis, formulated with and without IL-18, was used to determine the pigs' cellular and humoral immune responses. Animals injected with the candidate vaccine co-formulated with IL-18 showed a significant increase of Th1 immune response markers and an earlier increase of antibodies than those vaccinated without the cytokine. This suggests that IL-18 acts as an immunostimulant and vaccine adjuvant to boost the immune response against the antigens, reducing the therapeutic window of recombinant protein-based vaccines.

Using a novel structure/function approach to select diverse swine major histocompatibility complex 1 alleles to predict epitopes for vaccine development

MOTIVATION

Swine leukocyte antigens (SLAs) (i.e. swine major histocompatibility complex proteins) conduct a fundamental role in swine immunity. To generate a protective vaccine across an outbred species, such as pigs, it is critical that epitopes that bind to diverse SLA alleles are used in the vaccine development process. We introduced a new strategy for epitope prediction.

RESULTS

We employed molecular dynamics simulation to identify key amino acids for interactions with epitopes. We developed an algorithm wherein each SLA-1 is compared to a crystalized reference allele with unique weighting for non-conserved amino acids based on R group and position. We then performed homology modeling and electrostatic contact mapping to visualize how relatively small changes in sequences impacted the charge distribution in the binding site. We selected eight diverse SLA-1 alleles and performed homology modeling followed, by protein-peptide docking and binding affinity analyses, to identify porcine reproductive and respiratory syndrome virus matrix protein epitopes that bind with high affinity to these alleles. We also performed docking analysis on the epitopes identified as strong binders using NetMHCpan 4.1. Epitopes predicted to bind to our eight SLA-1 alleles had equivalent or higher energetic interactions than those predicted to bind to the NetMHCpan 4.1 allele repertoire. This approach of selecting diverse SLA-1 alleles, followed by homology modeling, and docking simulations, can be used as a novel strategy for epitope prediction that complements other available tools and is especially useful when available tools do not offer a prediction for SLAs/major histocompatibility complex.

AVAILABILITY AND IMPLEMENTATION

The data underlying this article are available in the online Supplementary Material.

Evaluation of host and bacterial gene modulation during Lawsonia intracellularis infection in immunocompetent C57BL/6 mouse model

BACKGROUND

Proliferative enteritis caused by Lawsonia intracellularis undermines the economic stability of the swine industry worldwide. The development of cost-effective animal models to study the pathophysiology of the disease will help develop strategies to counter this bacterium.

OBJECTIVES

This study focused on establishing a model of gastrointestinal (GI) infection of L. intracellularis in C57BL/6 mice to evaluate the disease progression and lesions of proliferative enteropathy (PE) in murine GI tissue.

METHODS

We assessed the murine mucosal and cell-mediated immune responses generated in response to inoculation with L. intracellularis.

RESULTS

The mice developed characteristic lesions of the disease and shed L. intracellularis in the feces following oral inoculation with 5 × l07 bacteria. An increase in L. intracellularis 16s rRNA and groEL copies in the intestine of infected mice indicated intestinal dissemination of the bacteria. The C57BL/6 mice appeared capable of modulating humoral and cell-mediated immune responses to L. intracellularis infection. Notably, the expression of genes for the vitamin B12 receptor and for secreted and membrane-bound mucins were downregulated in L. intracellularis -infected mice. Furthermore, L. intracellularis colonization of the mouse intestine was confirmed by the immunohistochemistry and western blot analyses.

CONCLUSIONS

This is the first study demonstrating the contributions of bacterial chaperonin and host nutrient genes to PE using an immunocompetent mouse model. This mouse infection model may serve as a platform from which to study L. intracellularis infection and develop potential vaccination and therapeutic strategies to treat PE.

Intrauterine immunizations trigger antigen-specific mucosal and systemic immunity in pigs and passive protection in suckling piglets

We assessed whether vaccines administered to the uterus at breeding can lead to sufficient colostral antibodies to protect suckling piglets against Porcine Endemic Diarrhea Virus (PEDV). An antigen from Lawsonia intracellularis, a disease that impacts weanling intestinal health, was also included because we have extensive knowledge on the pig immune response to this antigen. Gilts were mock-bred at 2nd estrus with killed sperm including an intrauterine (i.u.) vaccine comprised of recombinant (r) PEDV Spike protein (rPEDVS1) and L. intracellularis flagellin (rFliC) formulated with poly I:C, host defense peptide, and polyphosphazene (TriAdj). Gilts returned to estrus within 3 weeks and they were inseminated with killed sperm (3rd estrus) or live sperm (4th estrus) with rPEDVS1-TriAdj vaccine. They also received an i.m. injection of rFliC-TriAdj at 3rd and 4th estrus to establish whether i.u. vaccination primes systemic immunity without inducing mucosal tolerance. Control gilts were administered semen alone at 2nd estrus which allowed us to compare litter weights and sizes to industry standards. Colostrum from gilts challenged with low dose PEDV plus alum was used as positive reference samples for neutralizing antibodies and passive protection. Thirteen weeks later, the i.u.-vaccinated gilts showed significant PEDVS1-specific serum, colostral, and uterine antibody titers and colostral PEDVS1-neutralizing antibodies but poor cell-mediated immunity. Piglets born to i.u. vaccinated gilts received partial passive protection from PEDV infection 3 days after birth but eventually succumbed to the disease. Immunization by the i.u./i.m. route triggered significant anti-FliC cell-mediated immunity and colostral FliC antibodies that remained high in weaned piglet serum. This trial and a repeat trial wherein gilts were immunized at 1st estrus without semen and at 2nd estrus with live semen showed that intrauterine immunization did not impact fertility, number of live births or piglet growth kinetics. Further optimization is needed to promote robust passive protection in suckling offspring.