Rethinking water treatment targets: Bacteria regrowth under unprovable conditions

The Complex Interplay Between Antibiotic Resistance and Pharmaceutical and Personal Care Products in the Environment

Antibiotic-resistant bacteria (ARB) and antibiotic resistance genes (ARGs) are important environmental contaminants. Nonetheless, what drives the evolution, spread, and transmission of antibiotic resistance dissemination is still poorly understood. The abundance of ARB and ARGs is often elevated in human-impacted areas, especially in environments receiving fecal wastes, or in the presence of complex mixtures of chemical contaminants, such as pharmaceuticals and personal care products. Self-replication, mutation, horizontal gene transfer, and adaptation to different environmental conditions contribute to the persistence and proliferation of ARB in habitats under strong anthropogenic influence. Our review discusses the interplay between chemical contaminants and ARB and their respective genes, specifically in reference to co-occurrence, potential biostimulation, and selective pressure effects, and gives an overview of mitigation by existing man-made and natural barriers. Evidence and strategies to improve the assessment of human health risks due to environmental antibiotic resistance are also discussed. Environ Toxicol Chem 2024;43:637-652. © 2022 SETAC.

Insights into antibiotic resistance-related changes in microbial communities, resistome and mobilome in paddy irrigated with reclaimed wastewater

Reclaimed wastewater (reclaimed wastewater, RWW) from municipal wastewater treatment plants for paddy irrigation is a well-established practice to alleviate water scarcity. However, the reuse may result in the persistent exposure of the paddy to residual antibiotics in RWW. Continuous presence of even low-level antibiotics can exert selective pressure on microbiota, resulting in the proliferation and dissemination of antibiotic resistance genes (ARGs) in paddy. In this study, metagenomic analysis was applied to firstly deciphered the effects of residual antibiotics on microbiome and resistome in constructed mesocosm-scale paddy soils. The diversity and abundance of ARG have remarkably risen with the increasing antibiotic concentration in RWW. Network analysis revealed that 28 genera belonging to six phyla were considered as the potential ARG hosts, and their abundances were enhanced with increasing antibiotic concentrations. A partial least-squares path model indicated that the microbial community was the principal direct driver of the ARG abundance and the resistome alteration in paddy soil under long-term RWW irrigation. Microbes may acquire ARGs via horizontal gene transfer. IntI1 could play an essential role in the propagation and spread of ARGs. Functional analysis suggested that enhanced SOS response and T4SSs (Type IV secretion systems) modules could stimulate horizontal transfer potential and promote the ARG abundance. The obtained results provide a scientific decision for assessing the ecological risk of RWW application.

Novel photoelectrochemical 3D-system for water disinfection by deposition of modified carbon nitride on vitreous carbon foam

Graphitic carbon nitride (GCN) is an optical semiconductor with excellent photoactivity under visible light irradiation. It has been widely applied for organic micropollutant removal from contaminated water, and less investigated for microorganisms' inactivation. The photocatalytic degradation mechanism using GCN is attributed to a series of reactions with reactive oxygen species and photogenerated holes that can be boosted by modifying its physical-chemical structure. This work reports a successful improvement of the overall photocatalytic and electrocatalytic activities of the pristine material by thermal and chemical modification by a copolymerisation synthesis method. The copolymerisation of dicyandiamide as a precursor with barbituric acid strongly reduced photoluminescence due to the enhanced charge separation thus improving the catalyst efficiency under visible light irradiation. The material with 1.6 wt% of barbituric acid showed the best photocatalytic performance and electrochemical properties. This photocatalyst was selected for immobilisation on a conductive carbon foam, which promotes a higher electrochemical active surface area and enhanced mass transfer. This three-dimensional metal-free electrode was employed for the photoelectrochemical inactivation of two different microorganisms, Escherichia coli, and Enterococcus faecalis, obtaining removals below the detection limit after 30 min in simulated faecal-contaminated waters. This photoelectrochemical reactor was also applied to treat polluted river and urban waste waters, and the faecal contamination indicators were vastly reduced to values below the detection limit in 60 min in both cases, showing the wide applicability of this innovative photoelectrode for different types of polluted aqueous matrices.

Positive and negative effects of recirculating aquaculture water advanced oxidation: O3 and O3/UV treatments improved water quality but increased antibiotic resistance genes

Recirculating aquaculture systems (RASs) can be efficiently used for aquaculture, and oxidation treatment is commonly used to improve water quality. However, the effects of oxidation treatments on aquaculture water safety and fish yield in RASs are poorly understood. In this study, we tested the effects of O₃ and O₃/UV treatments on aquaculture water quality and safety during culture of crucian carp. O₃ and O₃/UV treatments reduced the dissolved organic carbon (DOC) concentration by ∼40% and destroyed the refractory organic lignin-like features. There was enrichment of ammonia oxidizing (Nitrospira, Nitrosomonas, and Nitrosospira) and denitrifying (Pelomonas, Methyloversatilis, and Sphingomonas) bacteria, and N-cycling functional genes were enriched by 23% and 48%, respectively, after O₃ and O₃/UV treatments. Treatment with O₃ and O₃/UV reduced NH₄⁺-N and NO₂^--N in RASs. O₃/UV treatment increased fish length and weight as well as probiotics in fish intestine. However, high saturated intermediates and tannin-like features induced antibiotic resistance genes (ARGs) in O₃ and O₃/UV treatments, by 52% and ∼28%, respectively, and also enhanced horizontal transfer of ARGs. Overall, the application of O₃/UV achieved better effects. However, understanding the potential biological risks posed by ARGs in RASs and determining the most efficient water treatment strategies to mitigate these risks should be goals of future work.

Source preventing mechanism of florfenicol resistance risk in water by VUV/UV/sulfite advanced reduction pretreatment

To avoid the inhibition of microbial activity and the emergence of bacterial resistance, effective abiotic pretreatment methods to eliminate the antibacterial activity of target antibiotics before the biotreatment system for antibiotic-containing wastewater are necessary. In this study, the VUV/UV/sulfite system was developed as a pretreatment technique for the source elimination of florfenicol (FLO) resistance risk. Compared with the VUV/UV/persulfate and sole VUV photolysis, the VUV/UV/sulfite system had the highest decomposition rate (0.33 min^‒1) and the highest defluorination (83.0%), resulting in the efficient elimination of FLO antibacterial activity with less than 2.0% mineralization, which would effectively retain the carbon sources for the sludge microorganisms in the subsequent biotreatment process. Furthermore, H• was confirmed to play a more important role in the elimination of FLO antibacterial activity by controlling the environmental conditions for the formation and transformation of reactive species and adding their scavengers. Based on the theoretical calculation and proposed photolytic intermediates, the elimination of FLO antibacterial activity was achieved by dechlorination, defluorination and removal of sulfomethyl groups. When the pretreated FLO-containing wastewater entered the biological treatment unit, the abundance of associated antibiotic resistance genes (ARGs) and the relative abundance of integrons were efficiently prevented by approximately 55.4% and 22.9%, respectively. These results demonstrated that the VUV/UV/sulfite system could be adopted as a promising pretreatment option for the source elimination of FLO resistance risk by target decomposition of its responsible structures before the subsequent biotreatment process.

Mechanisms of survival mediated by the stringent response in Pseudomonas aeruginosa under environmental stress in drinking water systems: Nitrogen deficiency and bacterial competition

Pseudomonas aeruginosa causes public health problems in drinking water systems. This study investigated the potential role of the stringent response in regulating the adaptive physiological metabolic behaviors of P. aeruginosa to low nitrogen stress and bacterial competition in drinking water systems. The results indicated that guanosine tetraphosphate (ppGpp) concentrations in P. aeruginosa increased to 135.5 pmol/g SS under short-term nitrogen deficiency. Meanwhile, the expression levels of the ppGpp synthesis genes (ppx, relA) and degradation gene (spoT) were upregulated by 37.0% and downregulated by 26.8%, respectively, indicating that the stringent response was triggered. The triggered stringent response inhibited the growth of P. aeruginosa and enhanced the metabolic activity of P. aeruginosa to adapt to nutrient deprivation. The interspecific competition significantly affected the regulation of the stringent response in P. aeruginosa. During short-term nitrogen deficiency, the extracellular polymeric substances concentration of P. aeruginosa decreased significantly, leading to desorption and diffusion of attached bacteria and increased ecological risks. The regulatory effect of stringent response on P. aeruginosa gradually weakened under long-term nitrogen deficiency. However, the expression of pathogenic genes (nalD/PA3310) and flagellar assembly genes (fliC) in P. aeruginosa was upregulated by the stringent response, which increased the risk of disease.

Uncovering novel disinfection mechanisms of solar light/periodate system: The dominance of singlet oxygen and metabolomic insights

Disinfection plays an essential role in waterborne pathogen control and disease prevention, especially during the COVID-19 pandemic. Catalyst-free solar light/periodate (PI) system has recently presented great potential in water disinfection, whereas the in-depth chemical and microbiological mechanisms for efficient bacterial inactivation remain unclear. Our work delineated firstly the critical role of singlet oxygen, instead of reported hydroxyl radicals and superoxide radicals, in dominating bacterial inactivation by the PI/simulated sunlight (SSL) system. Multi-evidence demonstrated the prominent disinfection performance of this system for Staphylococcus aureus in terms of culturability (> 6 logs CFU), cellular integrity, and metabolic activity. Particularly, the excellent intracellular DNA removal (> 95%) indicated that PI/SSL system may function as a selective disinfection strategy to diminish bacterial culturability without damaging the cell membrane. The PI/SSL system could also effectively inhibit bacterial regrowth for > 5 days and horizontal gene transfer between E. coli genera. Nontargeted metabolomic analysis suggested that PI/SSL system inactivated bacteria by triggering the accumulation of intracellular reactive oxygen species and the depletion of reduced glutathione. Additionally, the PI/SSL system could accomplish simultaneous micropollutant removal and bacterial inactivation, suggesting its versatility in water decontamination. Overall, this study deciphers more comprehensive antibacterial mechanisms of this environmentally friendly disinfection system, facilitating the technical development and application of the selective disinfection strategy in environmental pathogen control.

Disinfection of treated urban effluents for reuse by combination of coagulation/flocculation and Fenton processes

In this study, a combination of coagulation/flocculation and Fenton processes was studied as tertiary treatment in order to generate treated water susceptible to reuse. The combination of both processes has never been applied in disinfection of real urban wastewater. The best removals of turbidity and enterobacteria were achieved when applying a coagulant (FeCl₃) dosage of 120 mg/L and the natural pH of the effluent (7.14). The following Fenton reaction presented the maximal enterobacteria inactivation after 120 min at 25 °C, when using hydrogen peroxide and added iron concentrations of 100 mg/L and 7 mg/L, respectively. The abundance of antibiotic resistant (amoxicillin and sulfamethoxazole) enterobacteria and total enterobacteria, enterococci, and heterotrophs, and antibiotic resistance genes - ARG - (sul1, bla_TEM and qnrS) was evaluated before and after each step of the treatment. Values below 10 CFU/100 mL were achieved for total and resistant cultivable enterobacteria immediately after treatment and after storage for 72 h, therefore meeting the strictest limit imposed for E. coli. Physico-chemical parameters also met the established limits for water reuse. Despite harbouring a rich and diverse bacterial community, the final stored disinfected wastewater contained high relative abundance of potentially hazardous bacteria. Such results point out the need of a deep microbiological characterization of treated wastewater to evaluate the risk of its reuse in irrigation.

Treatment of high-concentration phosphorus wastewater based on foamed concrete

Phosphorus is a nonrenewable resource, and the recovery of phosphorus from wastewater containing high concentrations of phosphorus is of great importance. In this work, a novel method for highly efficient treatment of high-concentration phosphorus-containing wastewater (50 mg/L, 100 mg/L and 150 mg/L) with low energy consumption was developed by using the block waste foam concrete (FC) as a potential phosphorus recovery material. The results showed that acid leaching significantly improved the accumulation efficiency of phosphorus in calcium hydroxyphosphate (HAP) via accelerating the release of calcium in wastewater. The recovery rate of phosphorus could reach 99.0% under the pH value of 9.0 at 25 °C, using 2.0 g FC. It was also found that the microporous structure of the surface of FC provided the adsorption sites for phosphorus, resulting in the adsorption rate in different concentrations of phosphorus-containing wastewater up to 14.5%. It indicated that FC achieved the recovery of phosphorus from high-concentration phosphorus-containing wastewater by coupling HAP crystallization and physical adsorption to polyphosphorus.

Overgrowth control of potentially hazardous bacteria during storage of ozone treated wastewater through natural competition

Improving the chemical and biological quality of treated wastewater is particularly important in world regions under water stress. In these regions, reutilization of wastewater is seen as an alternative to reduce water demand, particularly for agriculture irrigation. In a reuse scenario, the treated wastewater must have enough quality to avoid chemical and biological contamination of the receiving environment. Ozonation is among the technologies available to efficiently remove organic micropollutants and disinfect secondary effluents, being implemented in full-scale urban wastewater treatment plants worldwide. However, previous studies demonstrated that storage of ozone treated wastewater promoted the overgrowth of potentially harmful bacteria, putting at risk its reutilization, given for instance the possibility of contaminating the food-chain. Therefore, this study was designed to assess the potential beneficial role of inoculation of ozone treated wastewater with a diverse bacterial community during storage, for the control of the overgrowth of potentially hazardous bacteria, through bacterial competition. To achieve this goal, ozone treated wastewater (TWW) was diluted with river water (RW) in the same proportion, and the resulting bacterial community (RW+TWW) was compared to that of undiluted TWW over 7 days storage. As hypothesized, in contrast to TWW, where dominance of Beta- and Gammaproteobacteria, namely Pseudomonas spp. and Acinetobacter spp., was observed upon storage for 7 days, the bacterial communities of the diluted samples (RW+TWW) were diverse, resembling those of RW. Moreover, given the high abundance of antibiotic resistance genes in RW, the concentration of these genes in RW+TWW did not differ from that of the non-ozonated controls (WW, RW and RW+WW) over the storage period. These results highlight the necessity of finding a suitable pristine diverse bacterial community to be used in the future to compete with bacteria surviving ozonation, to prevent reactivation of undesirable bacteria during storage of treated wastewater.

Metagenomic analysis of MWWTP effluent treated via solar photo-Fenton at neutral pH: Effects upon microbial community, priority pathogens, and antibiotic resistance genes

The effectiveness of advanced technologies on eliminating antibiotic resistant bacteria (ARB) and resistance genes (ARGs) from wastewaters have been recently investigated. Solar photo-Fenton has been proven effective in combating ARB and ARGs from Municipal Wastewater Treatment Plant effluent (MWWTPE). However, most of these studies have relied solely on cultivable methods to assess ARB removal. This is the first study to investigate the effect of solar photo-Fenton upon ARB and ARGs in MWWTPE by high throughput metagenomic analysis (16S rDNA sequencing and Whole Genome Sequencing). Treatment efficiency upon priority pathogens and resistome profile were also investigated. Solar photo-Fenton (30 mg L^-1 of Fe²⁺ intermittent additions and 50 mg L^-1 of H₂O₂) reached 76-86% removal of main phyla present in MWWTPE. An increase in Proteobacteria abundance was observed after solar photo-Fenton and controls in which H₂O₂ was present as an oxidant (Fenton, H₂O₂ only, solar/H₂O₂). Hence, tolerance mechanisms presented by this group should be further assessed. Solar photo-Fenton achieved complete removal of high priority Staphylococcus and Enterococcus, as well as Klebsiella pneumoniae and Pseudomonas aeruginosa. Substantial reduction of intrinsically multi-drug resistant bacteria was detected. Solar photo-Fenton removed nearly 60% of ARGs associated with sulfonamides, macrolides, and tetracyclines, and complete removal of ARGs related to β-lactams and fluoroquinolones. These results indicate the potential of using solar-enhanced photo-Fenton to limit the spread of antimicrobial resistance, especially in developing tropical countries.