Recovery of extracellular biopolymers from conventional activated sludge: Potential, characteristics and limitation

Deteriorated abatement of micropollutants in biological activated carbon filters with aged media: Key role of permeability

Biological activated carbon (BAC) filtration is vital for the abatement of micropollutants in drinking water. However, limited information is available on contaminant removal in BAC filters with aged media (e.g., >6 year) which are commonly operated at water treatment plants, and mechanistic insights into linkages among media age, microbial community, and contaminant removal still lack. In this study, the effects of media age on the abatement of eight micropollutants with various functional groups were investigated. The abatement of micropollutants decreased with increasing media age. Pseudo-first-order rate constants for contaminant removal in 6- and 15-year BAC were (0.3-3.1) × 10-3 and (0.2-2.6) × 10-3 s-1, compared to (0.9-4.3) × 10-3 s-1 in 3.5-year BAC filter. Biosorption- and biodegradation-dominated contaminant removal depended on protein and adenosine triphosphate concentrations in biofilm, respectively. Micro-computed tomography revealed the formation of biofilm-dominated clogging with rare voids and channels in 15-year BAC, resulting in low permeability. The decreased permeability led to deficient dissolved O2 and nutrient supply and thus changed microbial community assembly process, reducing community diversity and function. Core members including families of Saprospiraceae, Chitinophagaceae, Rhodocyclaceae, Comamonadaceae, and Nitrospiraceae in 3.5-year BAC were affiliated with active aerobic metabolism and contaminant biodegradation capacity. Abundances of these functional microbes and genes decreased with increasing media age. Simultaneously, protein in biofilm decreased, thereby decreasing biosorption. The findings of this study reveal the pivotal role of permeability in shaping microbial community and function and the corresponding micropollutant removal in BAC filters with aged media.

An innovative high-rate biofilm-based process: Biopolymer production and recovery from wastewater organic pollutants

In this study, a novel high-rate moving bed biofilm reactor (MBBR) was constructed to enhance wastewater COD bio-conversion and biopolymer recovery with a hydraulic retention time (HRT) of 1.0 h and an organic loading rate (OLR) of 4.8 kg COD·m-3·d-1. A superior specific COD reduction rate of 4.1 kg COD·m-3·d-1 was obtained. The settleability analyses showed that within a settling time of 30 min, a low effluent suspended solids (SS) concentration (40.6 mg/L) with a high biomass recovery rate (83.3%) was achieved. From the recovered biomass, a remarkably higher alginate-like exopolymer (ALE) yield (274.2-385.1 mg/g VSS) was extracted as compared with seeding sludge (148.3 mg/g VSS). In addition, high protein/polysaccharide ratios of 8.5-12.4 were revealed owing to the short HRT condition. Moreover, key functional genes involving classic ALE synthesis were fully detected in such mixed-cultured bioprocess through metagenomic sequencing. Overall, this study offers a proof of concept that bio-refinery of organics into value-added biopolymers could provide a promising direction for the transformation of wastewater treatment plants from energy/resource-consuming factories to resource-recovery factories.

Novel Sodium Carbonate Activation for Manufacturing Sludge-Based Biochar and Assessment of Its Organic Adsorption Property in Treating Wool Scouring Wastewater

Under the concept of green and low-carbon development, efficient and environmentally friendly biochar preparation methods have attracted much attention. This study assessed a novel sodium carbonate activator combined with acid modification for sludge-based biochar (SB) production and its adsorption of organics in wool scouring wastewater. Under 600 °C, the optimal carbonization temperature, the residual weight percentage of biochar carbonized material increases from 27% to 73% after Na2CO3 activation compared to ZnCl2 activation. Compared to HCl-modified ZnCl2-activated biochar (Zn-Cl-SB), HCl-H2SO4-modified Na2CO3-activated biochar (Na-Cl/S-SB) had a specific surface area of 509.3 m2/g, and the average mesopore size was 7.896 nm, with micropore volume and specific surface area increasing by 83.3% and 79.8%, respectively. Meanwhile, the C-O oxygen-containing functional groups and pyrrole nitrogen-containing functional groups were significantly increased. Na-Cl/S-SB exhibited an excellent adsorption performance for organic matter in wool scouring wastewater, with a maximum adsorption capacity of 168.3 mg/g. Furthermore, the adsorption process followed the pseudo-second-order kinetic model. Three-dimensional fluorescence spectrum analysis showed that Na-Cl/S-SB had a strong adsorption capacity for aromatic protein analogs, proteins containing benzene rings, and dissolved microbial by-products in wool scouring wastewater. This study will serve as a guideline for the green synthesis of SB while improving its ability to adsorb pollutants.

Efficacy and application potential of purified hydrocolloid coatings sprayed onto maize seeds subjected to anti-aging

The use of purified hydrocolloids extracted from waste-activated sludge has significant potential for preventing seed deterioration caused by aging. In this study, we compared the advantages and disadvantages of 3 types of purified hydrocolloid seed coatings from different waste sludges and one commercial seed coating at different spraying times (2, 4, 6, and 8). Compared with coated maize seeds, uncoated maize seeds underwent significant functional changes during the aging process according to the infrared spectroscopy results. Subsequent pot experiments were conducted at 4 days after aging. The average germination rate of the coated maize seeds was greater than that of the uncoated seeds at all spraying times. In terms of antioxidant enzyme activities, seeds treated with different coatings presented an increasing trend with increasing spraying time, indicating a difference between different spraying times. Principal component analysis revealed that the optimum number of sprays to achieve the results of carboxymethyl cellulose seed coating was 8 for the Xiaohongmen Wastewater Treatment Plant, 6 for the Dongba Wastewater Treatment Plant, and 4 for the Nanyang Wastewater Treatment Plant. The number of sprays applied in practice is an important determining factor during seed storage.

Effective management of pre-existing biofilms using UV-LED through inactivation, disintegration and peeling

Managing undesirable biofilms is a persistent challenge in water treatment and distribution systems. Although ultraviolet-light emitting diode (UV-LED) irradiation, an emerging disinfection method with the chemical-free and emission-adjustable merits, has been widely reported effective to inactivate planktonic bacteria, few studies have examined its effects on biofilms. This study aims to fill this gap by exploring the performance and mechanism of UV-LEDs on the prefabricated Escherichia coli (E. coli) biofilms under varying irradiation conditions. The results showed that the wavelength of 275 nm exhibited the best inactivation effect on the biofilm-bound E.coli compared to 268, 312 and 370 nm, achieving 3.2 log inactivation at a fluence of 346.5 mJ/cm2 and an irradiance of 660 μW/cm2. Furthermore, irradiance and irradiation time are proposed for the first time to be a pair of conjugate variables correlated to log inactivation, as a modification of the Bunsen-Roscoe reciprocity law. Additionally, the effect of UV irradiation on extracellular polymeric substances (EPS) in terms of the structure and chemical properties was investigated. The findings support that the oxidative degradation of the polysaccharides and proteins in EPS matrix should be the primary reason for destroying the biofilm framework. Finally, additional hydraulic shear was applied on the irradiated biofilms, suggesting an effective approach for enhancing biofilm removal.

Effects of Extraction Methods on the Thermal Stability of Extracellular Polymeric Substances-Based Biomaterials from Wastewater Sludge

Various methods for recovering extracellular polymeric substances (EPS)-based biomaterials from wastewater sludge exist. However, the relationships between extraction methods and properties of biomaterials have not been fully explored. In this study, the thermal properties, including activation energy (AE) and thermal decomposition mechanism, of EPS-based biomaterials extracted by different methods have been determined by thermogravimetric analysis integrated with the deconvolution method. Simultaneously, the chemical properties of these biomaterials, such as the extraction yield, chemical composition, and functional groups, have been monitored to clarify the influences of extraction methods. Notably, proteins and humic-like substances have been found as the major components to determine thermal stability and AE. Moreover, the physicochemical method shows significant effects on enhancing extraction yield and AE, with the NaOH and heat methods proving to be outstanding by delivering the highest AE of 300 kJ/mol and a substantial char formation of 24%. The results have demonstrated the significant impact of extraction methods on the thermal stability of EPS-based biomaterials. Moreover, this finding provides insights into the linkages between the properties of EPS-based biomaterials and extraction methods to guide the selection of appropriate extraction methods tailored to specific applications, including flame-resistant materials.

Extracellular polymeric substances (EPS) in sewage sludge management: A call for methodological standardization

Extracellular polymeric substances (EPS) are crucial in sewage sludge management, influencing key processes such as sedimentation, dewatering, and drying. Despite their importance, the lack of standardized methods for EPS extraction and analysis has led to inconsistent research findings, hindering a thorough understanding of EPS's role in sludge treatment. This review paper addresses this issue by critically comparing various EPS extraction and analysis methods, emphasizing the urgent need for standardization in the field. Standardized methodologies will enable researchers to compare studies more accurately and derive meaningful insights into EPS's role across different stages of sludge treatment, ultimately advancing EPS knowledge and application in sludge management. Additionally, this paper summarizes findings from numerous studies on EPS impact in sedimentation, dewatering, and drying, offering a holistic view of their significance in sludge management. Moreover, it explores the potential EPS applications, highlighting both the future directions and the challenges associated with their production.

Bio-Refinery of Organics into Value-Added Biopolymers: Exploring the Effects of Hydraulic Retention Time and Organic Loading Rate on Biopolymer Harvesting from a Biofilm-Based Process

This study aimed to examine the impacts of hydraulic retention time (HRT) and organic loading rate (OLR) on the alginate-like exopolymers' (ALEs) recovery potential from a biofilm-based process. A lab-scale moving bed biofilm reactor (MBBR) was operated under different HRT (12.0, 6.0, and 2.0 h) and OLR (1.0, 2.0, and 6.0 kg COD/m3/d) conditions. The results demonstrated that the reduction in HRT and increase in OLR had remarkable effects on enhancing ALE production and improving its properties, which resulted in the ALE yield increasing from 177.8 to 221.5 mg/g VSS, with the protein content rising from 399.3 to 494.3 mg/g ALE and the enhanced alginate purity by 39.8%, corresponding to the TOC concentration increasing from 108.3 to 157.0 mg/g ALE. Meanwhile, to illustrate different ALE recovery potentials, microbial community compositions of the MBBR at various operational conditions were also assessed. The results showed that a higher relative abundance of EPS producers (29.86%) was observed in the MBBR with an HRT of 2.0 h than that of 12.0 h and 6.0 h, revealing its higher ALE recovery potential. This study yields crucial results in terms of resource recovery for wastewater reclamation by providing an effective approach to directionally cultivating ALEs.

Synergistic effect of electrooxidation and anaerobic digestion of waste-activated sludge for microbial inactivation

Electrochemical pretreatment and anaerobic digestion (AD), as well as a combination of both processes, were studied for the treatment of waste-activated sludge (WAS) to evaluate microbial inactivation, for faecal coliforms, Salmonella spp., bacteriophages, and helminth eggs. Electrooxidation (EO) of WAS was performed in a commercial cell with boron-doped diamond electrodes. 1 L of WAS (3% total solids) was fed to the electrochemical cell in recirculation mode. The conditions tested were 19.3 mA/cm2, 30 min, and 3.8 L/min. For AD tests, raw and pretreated WAS were digested in an OxiTop® OC 110 apparatus for 15 days. Inactivation of faecal coliforms, Salmonella spp., and bacteriophages reached more than 5 logs when EO was combined with AD. In contrast, EO alone did not inactivate these parameters, while AD achieved eliminations around 3 logs. Moreover, the combined process inactivated 91% of the initial viable helminth eggs, considerably higher than AD (29%) and EO (0%). The results suggest that EO separates extracellular polymeric substances and segregates particles, including microorganisms, that are exposed to environmental factors (e.g., volatile fatty acids or ammonia) during AD, showing a synergistic effect.

Deep dewatering of oily sludge: Mechanism, characterization, and pretreatment technology

Oily sludge, characterized by its high organic pollution, poses significant challenges for treatment and disposal due to its high proportion of bound water and elevated viscosity from petroleum hydrocarbons. This study focuses on the deep dewatering of oily sludge, examining the role of internal bound water and the pretreatment mechanisms involved. The deep dewatering process is categorized into two main areas: liberation of bound water and modification of physicochemical properties. (1) Bound water is primarily found in two major categories: water bound within proteins, EPS, and cells through hydrophilic interactions, and water within an oil-water emulsion structure facilitated by inorganic particles. (2) Physicochemical properties: The formation of flocs in oily sludge is crucial for effective dewatering, while creating dewatering channels in later stages enhances efficiency. Advanced oxidation and emerging demulsification technologies are also discussed, summarizing the latest research. The significant potential of electric fields in the deep dewatering of oily sludge is emphasized, offering valuable insights for future advancements.

From waste to wealth: Exploring the effect of particle size on biopolymer harvesting from aerobic granular sludge

This study aimed to examine the impact of aerobic granular sludge (AGS) sizes on its properties and alginate-like exopolymers (ALE) recovery potential. The AGS was cultivated in a lab-scale bioreactor and categorized into six size classes with 200 μm intervals. There appeared a critical size (400-800 μm) for developing stable AGS structure and excellent ALE recovery. A higher hydrophobicity (74.36 %) and density (1,037 g/L) was observed in AGS400-600μm than other sizes. Moreover, the highest ALE yield was obtained in ALE600-800μm (388 mg/g VSS) for its higher abundance of EPS-producers (35.1 %), while the PN content of ALE400-600μm was higher than other samples. Meanwhile, the concentrations of metal elements within the ALE and AGS identified that there was no bio-accumulation of metal elements in the ALE. This study offers an in-depth understanding of biopolymer recovery from AGS, paving the way for a novel resource recovery strategy through the regulation of AGS sizes.

Microbial extracellular polymeric substances in the environment, technology and medicine

Microbial biofilms exhibit a self-produced matrix of extracellular polymeric substances (EPS), including polysaccharides, proteins, extracellular DNA and lipids. EPS promote interactions of the biofilm with other cells and sorption of organics, metals and chemical pollutants, and they facilitate cell adhesion at interfaces and ensure matrix cohesion. EPS have roles in various natural environments, such as soils, sediments and marine habitats. In addition, EPS are relevant in technical environments, such as wastewater and drinking water treatment facilities, and water distribution systems, and they contribute to biofouling and microbially influenced corrosion. In medicine, EPS protect pathogens within the biofilm against the host immune system and antimicrobials, and emerging evidence suggests that EPS can represent potential virulence factors. By contrast, EPS yield a wide range of valuable products that include their role in self-repairing concrete. In this Review, we aim to explore EPS as a functional unit of biofilms in the environment, in technology and in medicine.

Investigating enhancement of protease and lysozyme combination pretreatment on hydrolysis of sludge organics under humic acid inhibition

This study investigated the impact of humic acid (HA) on enzymatic pretreatment efficiency, focusing on sludge properties and HA molecular structure. The results showed that enzymatic pretreatment alleviates HA inhibition, improving hydrolysis efficiency. In the presence of HA, soluble proteins and polysaccharides in the enzyme-cocktail group reached 27.7 mg/L and 23.9 mg/L, 1.4 and 1.3 times higher than the blank group, respectively. The enzyme-cocktail group also had the highest soluble DNA concentration (19.4 mg/L) and the lowest viable cell proportion (69.3 %), indicating effective cell lysis. Enzyme-cocktail pretreatment reduced electrostatic repulsion, enhancing the mobility of extracellular organics. Enzyme interactions with HA released internal hydrolases and decreased amide groups on the HA surface, increasing the availability of biodegradable substrates. Overall, enzymatic pretreatment proves effective in mitigating HA-induced inhibition, thereby improving sludge biodegradation and enhancing carbon recovery in anaerobic fermentation.

Preparation of a novel organic-inorganic composite sludge bioflocculant (SBF) from dewatered sludge as raw material: Characteristics, flocculation mechanism and application for domestic sewage

In this work, a green sludge bioflocculant (SBF) was prepared via chemical hydrolysis of dewatered sludge and applied to flocculation of domestic wastewater. The process parameters for the preparation of the SBF were 1.80 % hydrochloric acid concentration, 60 min extraction time, and 4000 r/min centrifugation speed. SBF is polymeric flocculant composed of organic and inorganic compounds. Flocculation efficiency reached 97.31 ± 0.26 % under optimal flocculation conditions. Charge neutralization promotes the surface adsorption, bridging and net trapping and sweeping of Fe (OH)3, Al (OH)3 and active functional groups O-H/N-H and C = O in SBF, which together achieve efficient flocculation reactions. SBF had high efficiency and stable flocculation performance for phosphorus in urban domestic wastewater, and the concentration of TP in effluent was lower than 0.30 mg/L. Therefore, SBF prepared from dewatered sludge has efficient flocculation properties and is suitable for removing pollutant phosphorus, which has good application prospects in the field of wastewater treatment.

A holistic valorization of treasured waste activated sludge for directional high-valued products recovery: Routes, key technologies and challenges

Global energy shortages and environmental crises underscore the imperative for a circular economy to tackle resource scarcity and waste management. The circular economy model encourages the recovery and reuse of valuable materials, reducing reliance on finite natural resources and lessening the environmental impact of waste disposal. Among urban organic solid wastes, waste activated sludge (WAS) emerges as a potent reservoir of untapped resources (including various inorganic and organic ones) offering significant potential for recovery. This review delves into a comprehensive analysis of directional valorization of WAS to recover high-valued products, including the inorganic matters (i.e. phosphorus, ammonia nitrogen, and heavy metals), organic resources (i.e. extracellular polymers like alginate and protein, volatile fatty acid, methane, hydrogen, and plant growth hormones) and reutilization of WAS residues for the preparation of adsorbent materials - the biochar. Moreover, the main recovery methodologies associated influencing parameters, product application, and attendant challenges for those diverse recovered resources are unveiled. Future research are encouraged to prioritize the development of integrated multi-resource recovery approaches, the establishment of regulatory frameworks to support resource recovery and product utilization, and the systematic evaluation of disposal strategies to foster a more sustainable and resource-efficient future. This work illuminates avenues for sustainable WAS management with high-valued resource recovery towards circular economy.

A novel strategy for waste activated sludge treatment: Recovery of structural extracellular polymeric substances and fermentative production of volatile fatty acids

Structural extracellular polymeric substances (SEPS) as valuable biopolymers, can be extracted from waste activated sludge (WAS). However, the extraction yield is typically low, and detailed information on SEPS characterizations, as well as proper treatment of the sludge after SEPS extraction, remains limited. This study aimed to optimize the conditions of heating-Na2CO3 extraction process to increase the yield of SEPS extracted from WAS. Subsequently, SEPS were characterized, and, for the first time, insights into their protein composition were uncovered by using proteomics. A maximum SEPS yield of 209 mg g-1 volatile solid (VS) was obtained under optimal conditions: temperature of 90 °C, heating time of 60 min, Na+ dosage of 8.0 mmol/g VS, and pH required to precipitation of 4.0, which was comparable to that from the aerobic granular sludge reported in literature. Proteomics analysis unveiled that the proteins in SEPS primarily originated from microorganisms involved in nitrogen fixation and organic matter degradation, including their intracellular and membrane-associated regions. These proteins exhibited various catalytic activities and played crucial roles in aggregation processes. Besides, the process of SEPS extraction significantly enhanced volatile fatty acid (VFA) production during the anaerobic fermentation of residual WAS after SEPS extraction. A maximum VFA yield of 420 ± 14 mg COD/g VSadded was observed in anaerobic fermentation of 10 d, which was 77.2 ± 0.1 % higher than that from raw sludge. Mechanism analysis revealed that SEPS extraction not only improved WAS disintegration and solubilization but also reduced the relative activity of methanogens during anaerobic fermentation. Moreover, SEPS extraction shifted the microbial population during anaerobic fermentation in the direction towards hydrolysis and acidification such as Fermentimonas sp. and Soehngenia sp. This study proposed a novel strategy based on SEPS extraction and VFA production for sludge treatment, offering potential benefits for resource recovery and improved process efficiency.

Little alginates synthesized in EPS: Evidences from high-throughput community and metagenes

As a significant structure in activated sludge, extracellular polymeric substances (EPS) hold considerable value regarding resource recovery and applications. The present study aimed to elucidate the relationship between the microbial community and the composition and properties of EPS. A biological nutrient removal (BNR) reactor was set up in the laboratory and controlled under different solid retention times (SRT), altering microbial species within the system. Then EPS was extracted from activated and analyzed by chemical and spectroscopic methods. High-throughput sequencing and metagenomic approaches were employed to investigate bacterial community and metabolic pathways. The results showed that lower SRT with a higher abundance of the family-level Proteobacteria (27.7%-53.5%) favored EPS synthesis, while another dominant group Bacteroidetes (20.0%-32.6%) may not significantly affect EPS synthesis. Furthermore, the abundance of alginates-producing bacteria including Pseudomonas spp. and Azotobacter vinelandii was only 2.53%-6.76% and 1.98%-6.34%, respectively. The alginate synthesis pathway genes Alg8 and Alg44 were also present at very low levels (0.05‱-0.11‱, 0.01‱-0.02‱, respectively). Another important gene related to alginates operons, AlgK, was absent across all the SRT-operated reactors. These findings suggest an impossible and incomplete alginate synthesis pathway within sludge. In light of these results, it can be concluded that EPS does not necessarily contain alginate components.

Understanding the ionic hydrogel-forming property of extracellular polymeric substances: Differences in lipopolysaccharides between flocculent and granular sludge

An interesting and potential property of extracellular polymeric substances (EPS) is the hydrogel formation with calcium ions. Aiming at understanding the significant difference in the hydrogel formed between EPS from flocculent and granular sludge, a targeted investigation of the lipopolysaccharides (LPS), one of the important EPS components, was performed. LPS was isolated from the EPS of flocculent and granular sludge, and both the glycan and the lipid A parts of LPS were characterized and compared. The morphology of LPS-calcium (LPS-Ca) aggregates were visualized by the polymyxin B-based fluorescent probe. The LPS constituted about 25 % and 15 % of the EPS from flocculent and granular sludge, respectively. The flocculent sludge LPS showed a lower amount of glycans, shorter glycan chain length, lower molecular weight, and higher possibility of containing unsaturated lipids than the granular sludge EPS. The flocculent sludge LPS-Ca aggregates demonstrated invert structures with the water phase in between, contributing to the fluid-like property of the respect EPS-Ca. In contrast, with the remarkably different chemical structure, LPS-Ca aggregates from granular sludge displayed bilaminar multilayered morphology, contributing to the solid, self-standing hydrogel of EPS-Ca.

Distribution characteristics of sulfonamide antibiotics between water and extracellular polymeric substances in municipal sludge

The interaction between extracellular polymeric substances (EPS) in municipal sludge and antibiotics in wastewater is critical in wastewater treatment, resource recovery, and sludge management. Therefore, it is increasingly urgent to investigate the distribution coefficient (Log K) of sulfonamide antibiotics (SAs) in EPS, particularly in sludge-derived dissolved organic carbon (DOC) and aqueous phase systems. Herein, through balance experiments, the concentrations of SAs were determined using alkaline extraction EPS (AEPS) and alginate-like extracellular polymer (ALE) systems, and the Log KDOC values were determined. The results showed that the Log KDOC of AEPS was higher than that of ALE, which exhibited a negative KDOC value, indicating an inhibitory effect on dissolution. For the three SAs studied, the Log KDOC values were in the following order: sulfamethoxazole > sulfapyridine > sulfadiazine. This order can be attributed to the differing physicochemical properties, such as polarity, of the SAs. Three-dimensional excitation-emission matrix fluorescence spectra and fitting results indicated a lack of aromatic proteins dominated by tryptophan and humus-like substances in ALE. Meanwhile, the hydrophobic interaction of aromatic proteins dominated by tryptophan was the main driving force in the binding process between AEPS and SAs.

Occurrence and mechanism of sulfamethoxazole in alginate-like extracellular polymers from excess sludge

The recovery of biopolymers, particularly alginate-like extracellular polymers, from municipal sludge represents a promising step toward sustainable sludge treatment practices. Originating from wastewater plants in complexly polluted environments, alginate-like extracellular polymers carry potential environmental risks concerning their reuse. This study employs ultrahigh-performance liquid chromatography-tandem mass spectrometry to investigate the distribution coefficients and occurrence of alginate-like extracellular polymers and sulfamethoxazole. Results demonstrate a negative distribution coefficient, suggesting an inhibitory effect on sulfamethoxazole dissolution. The ethanol-extracted alginate-like extracellular polymers exhibits higher sulfamethoxazole levels (approximately 52%) than those obtained via dialysis extraction. Three-dimensional excitation-emission matrix analysis and adsorption studies indicate the absence of tyrosine-like substances in the alginate-like extracellular polymers, unlike in other extracellular polymeric substances. This absence diminishes hydrophobic interactions, highlighting that electrostatic interactions play a more important role. These insights are crucial for understanding the adsorption behavior of alginate-like extracellular polymers and optimizing their large-scale extraction processes.

Potential for curdlan recovery from aerobic granular sludge wastewater treatment systems - A review

The aerobic granular sludge (AGS) biotechnology has been explored for wastewater treatment for over two decades. AGS is gaining increased interest due to its enhanced treatment performance ability and the potential for resource recovery from AGS-based wastewater treatment systems. Resource recovery from AGS is a promising approach to sustainable wastewater treatment and attaining a circular economy in the wastewater management industry. Currently, research is at an advanced stage on recovering value-added resources such as phosphorus, polyhydroxyalkanoates, alginate-like exopolysaccharides, and tryptophan from waste aerobic granules. Recently, other value-added resources, including curdlan, have been identified in the aerobic granule matrix, and this may increase the sustainability of biotechnology in the wastewater industry. This paper provides an overview of AGS resource recovery potential. In particular, the potential for enhanced curdlan biosynthesis in the granule matrix and its recovery from AGS wastewater treatment systems is outlined.

Deciphering the Dual Roles of an Alginate-Based Biodegradable Flocculant in Anaerobic Fermentation of Waste Activated Sludge: Dewaterability and Degradability

Biodegradable flocculants are rarely used in waste activated sludge (WAS) fermentation. This study introduces an alginate-based biodegradable flocculant (ABF) to enhance both the dewatering and degradation of WAS during its fermentation. Alginate was identified in structural extracellular polymeric substances (St-EPS) of WAS, with alginate-producing bacteria comprising ∼4.2% of the total bacterial population in WAS. Owing to its larger floc size, higher contact angle, and lower free energy resulting from the Lewis acid-base interaction, the addition of the prepared ABF with a network structure significantly improved the dewaterability of WAS and reduced capillary suction time (CST) by 72%. The utilization of ABF by an enriched alginate-degrading consortium (ADC) resulted in a 35.5% increase in the WAS methane yield owing to its higher hydrolytic activity on both ABF and St-EPS. Additionally, after a 30 day fermentation, CST decreased by 62% owing to the enhanced degradation of St-EPS (74.4%) and lower viscosity in the WAS + ABF + ADC group. The genus Bacteroides, comprising 12% of ADC, used alginate lyase (EC 4.2.2.3) and pectate lyase (EC 4.2.2.2 and EC 4.2.2.9) to degrade alginate and polygalacturonate in St-EPS, respectively. Therefore, this study introduces a new flocculant and elucidates its dual roles in enhancing both the dewaterability and degradability of WAS. These advancements improve WAS fermentation, resulting in higher methane production and lower CSTs.

Resource recovery of high value-added products from wastewater: Current status and prospects

Wastewater resource recovery not only allows the extraction of value-added products and offsets the operational costs of wastewater treatment, but it is also conducive to alleviating adverse environmental issues due to energy and chemical inputs and associated emissions. A number of attractive compounds such as alginate-like polymers, struvite, polyhydroxyalkanoates, and sulfated polysaccharides, were found and successfully obtained from wastewater and have a wide range of application prospects. The aim of this work is to provide a comprehensive review of recent advances in recovery of these popular products from wastewater, and their physicochemical properties, main sources, and current recovery status are summarized. Various factors influencing the recovery performance of these materials are thoroughly discussed. Moreover, the research needs and future directions towards wastewater resource recovery are highlighted. This study can provide valuable insights for future research endeavors aiming to improve wastewater resource recovery through the retrieval of high value-added products.

Spatial gradients and molecular transformations of DOM, DON and DOS in human-impacted estuarine sediments

Dissolved organic matter (DOM) constitutes the most active fraction in global carbon pools, with estuarine sediments serving as significant repositories, where DOM is susceptible to dynamic transformations. Anthropogenic nitrogen (N) and sulfur (S) inputs further complicate DOM by creating N-bearing DOM (DON) and S-bearing DOM (DOS). This study delves into the spatial gradients and transformation mechanisms of DOM, DON, and DOS in Pearl River Estuary (PRE) sediments, China, using combined techniques of UV-visible spectroscopy, Excitation-emission matrix (EEM) fluorescence spectroscopy, Fourier transform ion cyclotron resonance mass spectrometry (FT-ICR MS), and microbial high-throughput sequencing. Results uncovered a distinct spatial gradient in DOM concentration, aromaticity (SUVA254), hydrophobicity (SUVA260), the content of substituent groups including carboxyl, carbonyl, hydroxyl and ester groups (A253/A203) of chromophoric DOM (CDOM), and the abundances of tyrosine/tryptophan-like protein and humic-like substances in fluorophoric DOM (FDOM). These all decreased from upper to lower PRE, accompanied by a decrease in O3S and O5S components, indicating seaward reduction in the contribution of terrestrial OM, especially anthropogenic inputs. Additionally, sediments exhibited a reduction in molecular diversity (number of formulas) of DOM, DON, and DOS from upper to lower PRE, with molecules tending towards a lower nominal oxidation state of carbon (NOSC) and higher bio-reactivity (MLBL), molecular weight (m/z) and saturation (H/C). While molecular composition of DOM remained similar in PRE sediments, the relative abundance of lignin-like substances decreased, with a concurrent increase in protein-like and lipid-like substances in DON and DOS from upper to lower PRE. Mechanistic analysis identified the joint influence of terrestrial OM, anthropogenic N/S inputs, and microbial processes in shaping the spatial gradients of DOM, DON, and DOS in PRE estuarine sediments. This study contributes valuable insights into the intricate spatial gradients and transformations of DOM, DON, and DOS within human-impacted estuarine sediments.

Trace analysis of 47 psychotropic medications in environmental samples by ultra-performance liquid chromatography tandem mass spectrometry (UPLC-MS/MS)

Psychotropic medications are one of the most prescribed pharmaceuticals in the world. Given their frequent detection and ecotoxicity to the no-target organism, the emission of these medications into environments has gradually draw attention. The study developed a sensitive and reliable analytic method to simultaneously investigate 47 psychotropic medications in four matrices: wastewater, surface water, activated sludge, and sediment by ultra-performance liquid chromatography-electrospray ionization-tandem mass spectrometry (UPLC-ESI-MS/MS). These 47 target analytes include 24 antidepressants, 17 antianxiety drugs, 5 anticonvulsants, and 1 relevant hormone. Solid phase extraction (SPE) was employed to extract analytes from water-phase samples. Ultrasonic Solvent Extraction method with Enhanced Matrix Removal clean-up (USE-EMR) was utilized to extract target compounds from solid-phase samples, which requires more straightforward and convenient procedures than previous methods. The extraction recoveries of all analytes ranged from 80 % to 120 % in these four sample matrices. In this study, The limit of quantitation for 47 psychotropic medications were 0.15 ng/L (estazolam) to 2.27 ng/L (lorazepam), 0.08 ng/L (desvenlafaxine) to 2 ng/L (mianserin), 0.22 ng/g (dry weight, dw) (nordiazepam) to 3.65 ng/g (dw) (lorazepam), and 0.07 ng/g (dw) (carbamazepine) to 2.85 ng/g (lorazepam), in wastewater, surface water, sludge, and sediment, respectively. In addition, the developed method was employed to analyse actual samples in two wastewater treatment plants and their receiving rivers. Carbamazepine, escitalopram, clozapine, desvenlafaxine, diazepam, lamotrigine, sertraline, temazepam, and venlafaxine were nearly ubiquitous in all matrices. Moreover, this study indicated that the inadequate removal efficiencies of psychotropic medications in wastewater treatment plants (WWTPs) had resulted in a persistent discharge of these contaminants from human sources into environments.

Valorization of sewage sludge for facile and green wood bio-adhesives production

A method is presented herein for the design of wood bio-adhesives using sewage sludge extracts (SSE). SSE was extracted from SS using deep eutectic solvents and processed with glycerol triglycidyl ether (GTE) to disrupt the secondary structure of proteins. An additive was also used to improve mechanical performance. The resulting bio-adhesive (SSE/GTE@TA) had a wet shear strength of 0.93 MPa, meeting the Chinese national standard GB/T 9846-2015 (≥0.7 MPa). However, the high polysaccharide content in SSE would weaken the mechanical properties of wood bio-adhesives. The key to improve bio-adhesive quality was the formation of a strong chemical bond via Maillard reaction as well as higher temperatures (140 °C) to reduce polysaccharide content via dehydration. This approach has lower environmental impact and higher economic efficiency compared to incineration and anaerobic digestion of sewage sludge. This work provides a new perspective on the high-value utilization of SS and offers a novel approach to developing bio-adhesives for the wood industry.

Recovering and potentially applying of alginate like extracellular polymers from anaerobic digested sludge

Extracellular polymeric substances (EPS) are biopolymers contained in both aerobic and anaerobic sludge. In EPS, alginate like extracellular polymers (ALE) is thought as a highly valued material, which have been widely studied with aerobic sludge. Nevertheless, a curiosity on ALE remains in anaerobic digested sludge (ADS). With 5 different sludge sources, anaerobic digestion of excess sludge was conducted in a batch mode, and then ADS was used to extract ALE and to analyze its physicochemical properties for potential applications. The yield of ALE extracted from ADS (ALE-ADS) ranged from 119.4 to 179.4 mg/g VSS. The compositional characteristics of ALE-ADS observed by FT-IR, 3D-EEM and UV-Vis spectroscopy revealed that there were minor differences in the composition and property of ALE-ADS but a similarity of 62 %-70 % to a commercial alginate remained in terms of chemical functional groups. Moreover, ALE-ADS composed of 1,4-linked β-d-mannuronic acid (M) and 1,4 α-l-guluronic acid (G) residues that form blocks of GG (20.8 %-33.8 %), MG (12.8 %-30.1 %) and MM (6.6 %-15.1 %), respectively. Based on the gel-forming capacity, film-forming property, adsorbility, and amphiphilicity, ALE-ADS seems potential as a water-proof coating with even a better performance than the commercial alginate, as a seed coating with an increased germination rate, and as a bio-adsorbent with a similar performance to the commercial alginate and ALE from aerobic sludge.

Enhanced alginate-like exopolymers recovery from algal-bacterial aerobic granular sludge: Optimal cultivation condition and contribution of bacteria and microalgae during the transport/storage period

Extracting alginate-like exopolymers (ALE) is a promising approach for valuable resources recovery from excess algal-bacterial aerobic granular sludge (AGS) to achieve circular bioeconomy and environmental sustainability in wastewater treatment plants (WWTPs). In this study, six batch cultivation tests were conducted to investigate the optimal cultivation duration or transport/storage period, light intensity, and temperature for algal-bacterial AGS after sampling and before further processing or ALE extraction. At a light intensity of 5 klux, the highest ALE content (36.33 mg/g-VSS) was detected at a low temperature of 10°C, which increased by 300% from its original level after 6-h cultivation. Results from levofloxacin (LVX) exposure and dark condition imply that microalgae contributed more to ALE synthesis in the algal-bacterial granules. This work not only provides a better understanding of the mechanisms involved in ALE biosynthesis but also offers useful guidance for maintaining or improving ALE recovery after algal-bacterial biomass sampling.

Extracting compositional blocks of alginate-like extracellular polymers (ALE) from conventional activated sludge (CAS)

As a highly added value material, alginate-like extracellular polymers (ALE) can be extracted from extracellular polymeric substances (EPS) from aerobic granular sludge (AGS). In fact, conventional activated sludge (CAS) also contains a certain amount of ALE. As CAS is widely used everywhere, waste activated sludge (WAS) from CAS is huge in its absolute amount. Although the ALE property of CAS was identified not so good as that from AGS, the mechanisms remains unclear. For this reason, it is necessary to unravel the chemically compositional blocks of ALE. Referring to natural alginate, ALE can be separated into three compositional blocks: GGL, GML and MML (like units containing guluronate or mannuronate), associated with other compositions including protein (PN), polysaccharide (PS), phosphorus (P), humic acid (HA). With real WAS from CAS, ALE was extracted and three blocks were separated: GGL = 54 %, GML = 42 % and MML = 4 % in weight, which is similar to the previous study. Moreover, the GGL blocks in CAS were obviously lower than AGS, down to by 1/3-1/2. And the GML and MML blocks in CAS were much higher than AGS, by more than 1/2. Different compositional blocks of ALE in AGS and CAS should be the reason forming different properties in applications. For this reason, a further study will be initiated to dispense/reorganize three blocks of ALE from CAS for expanding its potential applications, based on the compositional blocks of ALE from AGS.

A review on recovery of extracellular biopolymers from flocculent and granular activated sludges: Cognition, key influencing factors, applications, and challenges

A reasonable recovery of excess sludge may shift the waste into wealth. Recently an increasing attention has been paid to the recycling of extracellular biopolymers from conventional and advanced biological wastewater treatment systems such as flocculent activated sludge (AS), bacterial aerobic granular sludge (AGS), and algal-bacterial AGS processes. This review provides the first overview of current research developments and future directions in the recovery and utilization of high value-added biopolymers from the three types of sludge. It details the discussion on the recent evolvement of cognition or updated knowledge on functional extracellular biopolymers, as well as a comprehensive summary of the operating conditions and wastewater parameters influencing the yield, quality, and functionality of alginate-like exopolymer (ALE). In addition, recent attempts for potential practical applications of extracellular biopolymers are discussed, suggesting research priorities for overcoming identification challenges and future prospects.

The mixed/mixotrophic nitrogen removal for the effective and sustainable treatment of wastewater: From treatment process to microbial mechanism

Biological nitrogen removal (BNR) is one of the most important environmental concerns in the field of wastewater treatment. The conventional BNR process based on heterotrophic nitrogen removal (HeNR) is suffering from several limitations, including external carbon source dependence, excessive sludge production, and greenhouse gas emissions. Through the mediation of autotrophic nitrogen removal (AuNR), mixed/mixotrophic nitrogen removal (MixNR) offers a viable solution to the optimization of the BNR process. Here, the recent advance and characteristics of MixNR process guided by sulfur-driven autotrophic denitrification (SDAD) and anammox are summarized in this review. Additionally, we discuss the functional microorganisms in different MixNR systems, shedding light on metabolic mechanisms and microbial interactions. The significance of MixNR for carbon reduction in the BNR process has also been noted. The knowledge gaps and the future research directions that may facilitate the practical application of the MixNR process are highlighted. Overall, the prospect of the MixNR process is attractive, and this review will provide guidance for the future implementation of MixNR process as well as deciphering the microbially metabolic mechanisms.

Fate, toxicity and effect of triclocarban on the microbial community in wastewater treatment systems

Triclocarban (TCC), one of the typical antimicrobial agents, is a contaminant of emerging concern commonly found in high concentration in water environments. However, the fate and toxicity of TCC in wastewater treatment systems remain poorly understood. Here, we investigated how TCC impacts chemical oxygen demand and inorganic nitrogen transformation in a hydrolytic anaerobic-anoxic/oxic process. In the anaerobic section, the transformation of TCC was dominated by reductive dechlorination and supplemented by two amid bonds hydrolysis. In the anoxic and oxic sections, the hydrolysis of amid bonds dominated. The toxicity was reduced after the treatment (IC₅₀ from 0.09 to 0.54). TCC inhibited NH₄⁺-N removal in the anaerobic section and led to the NO₃^--N accumulation (2.84-4.13 mg/L) after treatment, with the abundance of N-removal bacteria decreased by 6%. Furthermore, the original ecological niche was gradually replaced by TCC-resistant/degradative bacteria, formating new microbial modules to resist the TCC stress. Importantly, fourteen genera including Methanosaeta, Longilinea, Dokdonella and Mycobacterium as potential bioindicators warning TCC and its intermediates were proposed. Overall, this study provides new insights into the fate of TCC in biological wastewater treatment systems and suggests a great importance for TCC control to ensure the health and resilience of ecosystems.

Accelerated stabilization of high solid sludge by thermal hydrolysis pretreatment in autothermal thermophilic aerobic digestion (ATAD) process

Autothermal thermophilic aerobic digestion (ATAD) is a rapid biological treatment technology for sludge stabilization. To improve digestion efficiency and shorten stabilization time, thermal hydrolysis pretreatment was employed before ATAD of high solid sludge. The results showed that accelerated stabilization of high solid sludge (total solid = 10.1%) was achieved by thermal hydrolysis pretreatment with volatile solid removal efficiency of 40.3% after 8 days of ATAD, 11 days earlier than unpretreated sludge. The enhanced release and hydrolysis of intracellular organics resulted in a solubilization degree of 45.3%. The reduced sludge viscosity and improved fluidity after thermal hydrolysis facilitated mixing, aeration and organics degradation during ATAD. Excitation emission matrix analysis indicated that the fluorescence intensity of soluble microbial byproduct and tyrosine-like protein increased markedly after thermal hydrolysis and decreased after ATAD. The proportion of high molecular weight (MW > 10 kDa) substances in the supernatant increased significantly after thermal hydrolysis, while the low MW (MW < 1 kDa) substances decreased after ATAD. The significant difference in microbial composition between the pretreatment and control groups elucidated the accelerated sludge stabilization under thermal hydrolysis. This work provides an efficient and practical strategy to achieve rapid stabilization of high solid sludge.

Enhancing extraction of alginate like extracellular polymers (ALE) from flocculent sludge by surfactants

Alginate like extracellular polymers (ALE) recovered from flocculent sludge has been identified as a kind of highly valuable biomaterials. However, the extraction protocols limit the production of biopolymers as ALE extracted from flocculent sludge is at a lower level, around 90-190 mg/g VSS. Under this circumstance, the eco-friendly and effective optimizations for the ALE extraction protocols are expected, and thus surfactants have gained an attention to enhancing the ALE extraction. With this study, different surfactants with different structures and chemical characteristics, such as sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS), cetyltrimethylammonium bromide (CTAB) and octyl phenyl polyoxyethylene ether (Triton X-100), were experimented to improve the ALE extraction, and in turn the optimal conditions and the associated mechanisms were evaluated and figured out. The experimental results indicated that surfactants could enhance the ALE extraction but also improve the alginate purification of ALE. With the optimal dosage of surfactants, the ALE extraction increased from 124.1 mg/g VSS to about 222.8-281.9 mg/g VSS, and the alginate purify was at around 54%-70%, in which the efficiency of the ALE extraction was improved by 79.5%-127.2%. Among others, Triton X-100 had the best performance on improving the ALE extraction, followed by CTAB and SDS. The mechanisms of surfactants on enhancing the ALE extraction and improving the alginate purify can be attributed to: i) surfactants micelles, which can solubilize flocs and extracellular biopolymers; ii) similar structures of surfactants and ALE, which follows the rule of "like dissolves like"; iii) functional groups adsorption, which facilitates the ALE release from matrixes. In a word, the optimized extraction protocol by using surfactants can be effectively applied to extract ALE from flocculent sludge.

Distinct responses of aerobic granular sludge sequencing batch reactors to nitrogen and phosphorus deficient conditions

The nutrients availability determines efficiency of biological treatment systems, along with the structure and metabolism of microbiota. Herein nutrients deficiencies on aerobic granular sludge were comparatively evaluated, treating wastewater with mass ratios of chemical oxygen demand : nitrogen : phosphorus being 200:20:4, 200:2:4, and 200:20:0.4 (deemed as nutrient-balanced, nitrogen-deficient, and phosphorus-deficient), respectively. Results revealed that both nitrogen and phosphorus deficiencies significantly raised the effluent qualities especially nitrogen removal. However, nitrogen deficiency aroused considerable growth of filamentous bacteria, while granules kept compact structure under phosphorus deficient condition. Extracellular polymeric substances (EPS) also varied in contents and structures in response to different wastewaters. Microbial community structure analysis demonstrated that nitrogen deficiency led to lower richness and higher diversity, while the reverse was observed under phosphorus deficient condition. Nitrogen deficiency mainly induced decrease of nitrifying bacteria, while similarly phosphorus deficiency led to loss of phosphorus accumulating organisms. Dramatic enrichment Candidatus_Competibacter and filamentous Thiothrix were found under nutrients deficiencies, in which the latter explained and indicated filamentous bulking potential especially under nitrogen limited condition. Bacterial metabolism patterns verified the functions of microbial community responding to nutrients via PICRUSt2 prediction mainly by up-regulating cell motility, and cellular processes and signaling. This study could aid understanding of long-term stability of aerobic granular sludge for low-strength wastewater treatment.

Cyanophycin Granule Polypeptide: a Neglected High Value-Added Biopolymer, Synthesized in Activated Sludge on a Large Scale

Recovery of microbial synthetic polymers with high economic value and market demand in activated sludge has attracted extensive attention. This work analyzed the synthesis of cyanophycin granule peptide (CGP) in activated sludge and its adsorption capacity for heavy metals and dyes. The distribution and expression of synthetic genes for eight biopolymers in two wastewater treatment plants (WWTPs) were analyzed by metagenomics and metatranscriptomics. The results indicate that the abundance and expression level of CGP synthase (cphA) are similar to those of polyhydroxyalkanoate polymerase, implying high synthesis of CGP in activated sludges. CGP in activated sludge is mainly polymerized from aspartic acid and arginine, and its secondary structure is mainly β-sheet. The crude yields of CGP are as high as 104 ± 26 and 76 ± 13 mg/g dry sludge in winter and in summer, respectively, comparable to those of polyhydroxyalkanoate and alginate. CGP has a stronger adsorption capacity for anionic pollutants (Cr (VI) and methyl orange) than for cationic pollutants because it is rich in guanidine groups. This study highlights prospects for recovery and application of CGP from WWTPs. IMPORTANCE The conversion of organic pollutants into bioresources by activated sludge can reduce the carbon dioxide emission of wastewater treatment plants. Identification of new high value-added biopolymers produced by activated sludge is beneficial to recover bioresources. Cyanophycin granule polypeptide (CGP), first discovered in cyanobacteria, has unique chemical and material properties suitable for industrial food, medicine, cosmetics, water treatment, and agriculture applications. Here, we revealed for the first time that activated sludge has a remarkable ability to produce CGP. These findings could further facilitate the conversion of wastewater treatment plants into resource recycling plants.

Encapsulation of bacteria in different stratified extracellular polymeric substances and its implications for performance enhancement and resource recovery

Simultaneous recovery of biopolymers and enhanced bio-reactor performance are promising options for sustainable wastewater treatment, and the bioactivity of sludge after biopolymer extraction is thus critical for the performance of the system. To this end, stratified extracellular polymeric substances (EPS), including slime, loosely bound EPS (LB-EPS), and tightly bound EPS (TB-EPS), were extracted, and the bioactivities of the consequent extraction residues were assessed using aerobic respirogram, kinetic, and flow cytometry (FCM). After the initial weak extraction of slime, the particle size distribution of the sludge significantly decreased, and subsequent extractions of LB-EPS and TB-EPS produced an equivalent size distribution. In contrast, the fractal dimension decreased after each extraction, suggesting that LB-EPS and TB-EPS affected the compactness of flocs rather than the size. The aerobic bacteria distribution estimated using respirogram shows that slime mainly encapsulated heterotrophs while LB-EPS mainly encapsulated nitrifiers. In addition, the ammonia-nitrogen affinity coefficient decreased from 1.79 to 0.28 mg/L when slime was removed, thereby encouraging the activities of autotrophic nitrifiers. Further removal of LB-EPS induced high energy dispersion as the maintenance coefficient m and the metabolic dispersion index μ/m increased from 0.11 to 0.22 and 0.44 to 0.63, respectively. Meanwhile, the yield rate decreased from 0.77 to 0.66. Although pellets that resulted from TB-EPS extraction were not aerobically active as described by respirogram and growth curves, they were still metabolically active as measured by live/dead cell counting and redox sensor green signal. These pellets used more energy for maintenance as indicated by the high maintenance coefficient than those residual after either slime or LB-EPS extraction. In addition, the variation in bacteria community distribution across flocs was related to the variation in temperatures, suggesting that the inner part of a floc might be hotter than the outer side. Therefore, compared to bacteria in the raw sludge, the viable bacteria bounded in LB-EPS and TB-EPS convert more energy to heat rather than growth. These results indicate that energy was dispersed as metabolic heat for the LB-EPS extracted sludge, and removal of LB-EPS favored thermogenesis and sludge reduction. Based on the above findings, a simultaneously EPS-recovery and performance enhancement configuration is thus proposed, which holds great promise for the integration of next-generation wastewater treatment plants.

Uncover the secret of the stability and interfacial Gibbs free energy of aerobic granular sludge

Interfacial Gibbs free energy (IGFE) as a thermodynamic indicator characterize the stability of the natural system. For aerobic granular sludge (AGS), how IGFE determines the stability of sludge remains to be determined. The Gibbs free energy change at the AGS-water interface (ΔG_sw^a) and AGS interfaces (ΔG_s^c) were selected as the main interfacial thermodynamic factors. Results indicated that the stable AGS was guaranteed with ΔG_s^c at the range of -31 to - 46 J m^-2. Pearson correlation coefficients between ΔG_sw^a/ ΔG_s^c and relative hydrophobicity, water content, SVI₃₀, integrity coefficient were -0.9, 0.8, 0.85, and 0.84, which illustrated that the IGFE could be a more comprehensive thermodynamic indicator. Microbial community and EPS analysis verified the importance of denitrifiers, Amide III, protein-like substances for AGS stability. This work offers a new insight into the development of AGS stability based on IGFE.