Bromodomain-containing subunits BRD1, BRD2, and BRD13 are required for proper functioning of SWI/SNF complexes in Arabidopsis

Epigenetics in the modern era of crop improvements

Epigenetic mechanisms are integral to plant growth, development, and adaptation to environmental stimuli. Over the past two decades, our comprehension of these complex regulatory processes has expanded remarkably, producing a substantial body of knowledge on both locus-specific mechanisms and genome-wide regulatory patterns. Studies initially grounded in the model plant Arabidopsis have been broadened to encompass a diverse array of crop species, revealing the multifaceted roles of epigenetics in physiological and agronomic traits. With recent technological advancements, epigenetic regulations at the single-cell level and at the large-scale population level are emerging as new focuses. This review offers an in-depth synthesis of the diverse epigenetic regulations, detailing the catalytic machinery and regulatory functions. It delves into the intricate interplay among various epigenetic elements and their collective influence on the modulation of crop traits. Furthermore, it examines recent breakthroughs in technologies for epigenetic modifications and their integration into strategies for crop improvement. The review underscores the transformative potential of epigenetic strategies in bolstering crop performance, advocating for the development of efficient tools to fully exploit the agricultural benefits of epigenetic insights.

The SAS chromatin-remodeling complex mediates inflorescence-specific chromatin accessibility for transcription factor binding

While the role of transcription factors in flower development is well understood, the impact of chromatin remodeling on this process remains largely unclear. We conducted a comprehensive analysis to investigate the coordination of the SAS, BAS, and MAS-type SWI/SNF chromatin-remodeling complexes with transcription factors to regulate chromatin accessibility and gene transcription during flower development in Arabidopsis thaliana. Our findings indicate that the SAS complex binds to numerous genes related to flower development and is responsible for establishing chromatin accessibility of these genes in inflorescences. In contrast, the BAS and MAS complexes exhibit minimal involvement in regulating the accessibility of these genes. The SAS-bound genomic regions and the SAS-dependent accessible regions in infloresences are enriched with sites occupied by multiple MADS family transcription factors involved in flower development. Furthermore, we found that the SAS-dependent accessibility facilitates the binding of the MADS transcription factor AP1 to a subset of its target loci. This study highlights the dynamic role of the SAS complex in modulating the chromatin accessibility and genomic binding of transcription factors during plant development.

Isolation and Identification of Nuclear Protein Complexes Using GFP-Tagged Arabidopsis Lines and IP-MS Approach

Immunoprecipitation coupled with mass spectrometry (IP-MS) is a powerful method that enables the identification of protein-protein interactions and isolation of protein complexes. When optimized to work with plant material, it proved to be suitable for the isolation of different types of nuclear complexes from Arabidopsis. Here, we describe a detailed protocol for the isolation of chromatin remodeling and polycomb repressive complexes using Arabidopsis lines that express GFP-tagged proteins as baits, directly from whole-cell extracts or after nuclei enrichment. We describe different experimental variations of the key steps in the protocol and discuss the analysis and interpretation of the IP-MS data.

The BRAHMA-associated SWI/SNF chromatin remodeling complex controls Arabidopsis seed quality and physiology

The SWI/SNF (SWItch/Sucrose Non-Fermentable) chromatin remodeling complex is involved in various aspects of plant development and stress responses. Here, we investigated the role of BRM (BRAHMA), a core catalytic subunit of the SWI/SNF complex, in Arabidopsis thaliana seed biology. brm-3 seeds exhibited enlarged size, reduced yield, increased longevity, and enhanced secondary dormancy, but did not show changes in primary dormancy or salt tolerance. Some of these phenotypes depended on the expression of DOG1, a key regulator of seed dormancy, as they were restored in the brm-3 dog1-4 double mutant. Transcriptomic and metabolomic analyses revealed that BRM and DOG1 synergistically modulate the expression of numerous genes. Some of the changes observed in the brm-3 mutant, including increased glutathione levels, depended on a functional DOG1. We demonstrated that the BRM-containing chromatin remodeling complex directly controls secondary dormancy through DOG1 by binding and remodeling its 3' region, where the promoter of the long noncoding RNA asDOG1 is located. Our results suggest that BRM and DOG1 cooperate to control seed physiological properties and that BRM regulates DOG1 expression through asDOG1. This study reveals chromatin remodeling at the DOG1 locus as a molecular mechanism controlling the interplay between seed viability and dormancy.

The GTE4-EML chromatin reader complex concurrently recognizes histone acetylation and H3K4 trimethylation in Arabidopsis

Histone acetylation and H3K4 trimethylation (H3K4me3) are associated with active transcription. However, how they cooperate to regulate transcription in plants remains largely unclear. Our study revealed that GLOBAL TRANSCRIPTION FACTOR GROUP E 4 (GTE4) binds to acetylated histones and forms a complex with the functionally redundant H3K4me3-binding EMSY-like proteins EML1 or EML2 (EML1/2) in Arabidopsis thaliana. The eml1 eml2 (eml1/2) double mutant exhibits a similar morphological phenotype to gte4, and most of the differentially expressed genes in gte4 were coregulated in eml1/2. Through chromatin immunoprecipitation followed by deep sequencing, we found that GTE4 and EML2 co-occupy protein-coding genes enriched with both histone acetylation and H3K4me3, exerting a synergistic effect on the association of the GTE4-EML complex with chromatin. The association of GTE4 with chromatin requires both its bromodomain and EML-interacting domain. This study identified a complex and uncovered how it concurrently recognizes histone acetylation and H3K4me3 to facilitate gene transcription at the whole-genome level in Arabidopsis.

Genome-wide analysis of Triticum aestivum bromodomain gene family and expression analysis under salt stress

MAIN CONCLUSION

This study identified 82 wheat BRD genes, revealing both conserved evolutionary and functional characteristics across plant species and novel features specific to wheat. GTE8-12 cluster TaBRDs were found as positive response to salt stress. Bromodomain-containing proteins (BRDs) are crucial in histone acetylation "reading" and chromatin remodeling in eukaryotes. Despite some of their members showing importance in various biological processes in plants, our understanding of the BRD family in wheat (Triticum aestivum) remains limited. This study comprehensively analyzes the T. aestivum BRD (TaBRD) family. We identified 82 TaBRD genes in wheat genome encoding hydrophobic proteins with a conserved pocket structure. Phylogenetic analysis classified these genes into 16 distinct clusters, with conserved protein motifs and gene structures within clusters but diverse patterns across clusters. Gene duplication analysis revealed that whole-genome or segmental duplication events were the primary expansion mechanism for the TaBRD family, with purifying selection acting on these genes. Subcellular localization and Gene Ontology (GO) analyses indicated that TaBRD proteins are predominantly nuclear-localized and involved in transcription regulation and RNA metabolism. Promoter analysis and interaction network prediction suggested diverse regulatory mechanisms for TaBRDs. Notably, TaBRDs from the GTE8-12 cluster were enriched with cis-elements responsive to abscisic acid (ABA), methyl jasmonate (MeJA), and light, implying their involvement in physiological functions and abiotic stress responses. Expression analysis confirmed tissue-specific patterns and responsiveness to salinity stress. This comprehensive study enhances our understanding of the BRD family in higher plants and provides a foundation for developing salt-tolerant wheat varieties.

Composition and function of plant chromatin remodeling complexes

ATP-dependent chromatin remodelers play a crucial role in modifying chromatin configuration by utilizing the energy of ATP hydrolysis. They are involved in various processes, including transcription, DNA replication, and maintaining genome stability. These remodeling remodelers usually form multi-subunit chromatin remodeling complexes in eukaryotes. In plants, chromatin remodeling complexes have diverse functions in regulating plant development and stress response. Recent studies have conducted extensive research on plant chromatin remodeling complexes. This review focuses on recent advances in the classification and composition of plant chromatin remodeling complexes, the protein-protein interactions within the complexes, their impact on chromatin configuration, and their interactions with chromatin modifications and transcription factors.

Comparative transcriptomics of seed nourishing tissues: uncovering conserved and divergent pathways in seed plants

The evolutionary and ecological success of spermatophytes is intrinsically linked to the seed habit, which provides a protective environment for the initial development of the new generation. This environment includes an ephemeral nourishing tissue that supports embryo growth. In gymnosperms this tissue originates from the asexual proliferation of the maternal megagametophyte, while in angiosperms it is a product of fertilization, and is called the endosperm. The emergence of these nourishing tissues is of profound evolutionary value, and they are also food staples for most of the world's population. Here, using Orthofinder to infer orthologue genes among newly generated and previously published datasets, we provide a comparative transcriptomic analysis of seed nourishing tissues from species of several angiosperm clades, including those of early diverging lineages, as well as of one gymnosperm. Our results show that, although the structure and composition of seed nourishing tissues has seen significant divergence along evolution, there are signatures that are conserved throughout the phylogeny. Conversely, we identified processes that are specific to species within the clades studied, and thus illustrate their functional divergence. With this, we aimed to provide a foundation for future studies on the evolutionary history of seed nourishing structures, as well as a resource for gene discovery in future functional studies.

Characterization of the SWI/SNF complex and nucleosome organization in sorghum

The switch defective/sucrose non-fermentable (SWI/SNF) multisubunit complex plays an important role in the regulation of gene expression by remodeling chromatin structure. Three SWI/SNF complexes have been identified in Arabidopsis including BAS, SAS, and MAS. Many subunits of these complexes are involved in controlling plant development and stress response. However, the function of these complexes has hardly been studied in other plant species. In this study, we identified the subunits of the SWI/SNF complex in sorghum and analyzed their evolutionary relationships in six grass species. The grass species conserved all the subunits as in Arabidopsis, but gene duplication occurred diversely in different species. Expression pattern analysis in sorghum (Sorghum bicolor) showed that most of the subunit-encoding genes were expressed constitutively, although the expression level was different. Transactivation assays revealed that SbAN3, SbGIF3, and SbSWI3B possessed transactivation activity, which suggests that they may interact with the pre-initiation complex (PIC) to activate transcription. We chose 12 subunits in sorghum to investigate their interaction relationship by yeast two-hybrid assay. We found that these subunits displayed distinct interaction patterns compared to their homologs in Arabidopsis and rice. This suggests that different SWI/SNF complexes may be formed in sorghum to perform chromatin remodeling functions. Through the integrated analysis of MNase-seq and RNA-seq data, we uncovered a positive relationship between gene expression levels and nucleosome phasing. Furthermore, we found differential global nucleosome enrichments between leaves and roots, as well as in response to PEG treatment, suggesting that dynamics of nucleosome occupancy, which is probably mediated by the SWI/SNF complex, may play important roles in sorghum development and stress response.

Leaf growth - complex regulation of a seemingly simple process

Understanding the underlying mechanisms of plant development is crucial to successfully steer or manipulate plant growth in a targeted manner. Leaves, the primary sites of photosynthesis, are vital organs for many plant species, and leaf growth is controlled by a tight temporal and spatial regulatory network. In this review, we focus on the genetic networks governing leaf cell proliferation, one major contributor to final leaf size. First, we provide an overview of six regulator families of leaf growth in Arabidopsis: DA1, PEAPODs, KLU, GRFs, the SWI/SNF complexes, and DELLAs, together with their surrounding genetic networks. Next, we discuss their evolutionary conservation to highlight similarities and differences among species, because knowledge transfer between species remains a big challenge. Finally, we focus on the increase in knowledge of the interconnectedness between these genetic pathways, the function of the cell cycle machinery as their central convergence point, and other internal and environmental cues.

The regulation of chromatin configuration at AGAMOUS locus by LFR-SYD-containing complex is critical for reproductive organ development in Arabidopsis

Switch defective/sucrose non-fermentable (SWI/SNF) chromatin remodeling complexes are evolutionarily conserved, multi-subunit machinery that play vital roles in the regulation of gene expression by controlling nucleosome positioning and occupancy. However, little is known about the subunit composition of SPLAYED (SYD)-containing SWI/SNF complexes in plants. Here, we show that the Arabidopsis thaliana Leaf and Flower Related (LFR) is a subunit of SYD-containing SWI/SNF complexes. LFR interacts directly with multiple SWI/SNF subunits, including the catalytic ATPase subunit SYD, in vitro and in vivo. Phenotypic analyses of lfr-2 mutant flowers revealed that LFR is important for proper filament and pistil development, resembling the function of SYD. Transcriptome profiling revealed that LFR and SYD shared a subset of co-regulated genes. We further demonstrate that the LFR and SYD interdependently activate the transcription of AGAMOUS (AG), a C-class floral organ identity gene, by regulating the occupation of nucleosome, chromatin loop, histone modification, and Pol II enrichment on the AG locus. Furthermore, the chromosome conformation capture (3C) assay revealed that the gene loop at AG locus is negatively correlated with the AG expression level, and LFR-SYD was functional to demolish the AG chromatin loop to promote its transcription. Collectively, these results provide insight into the molecular mechanism of the Arabidopsis SYD-SWI/SNF complex in the control of higher chromatin conformation of the floral identity gene essential to plant reproductive organ development.

Spotlight on Plant Bromodomain Proteins

Bromodomain-containing proteins (BRD-proteins) are the "readers" of histone lysine acetylation, translating chromatin state into gene expression. They act alone or as components of larger complexes and exhibit diverse functions to regulate gene expression; they participate in chromatin remodeling complexes, mediate histone modifications, serve as scaffolds to recruit transcriptional regulators or act themselves as transcriptional co-activators or repressors. Human BRD-proteins have been extensively studied and have gained interest as potential drug targets for various diseases, whereas in plants, this group of proteins is still not well investigated. In this review, we aimed to concentrate scientific knowledge on these chromatin "readers" with a focus on Arabidopsis. We organized plant BRD-proteins into groups based on their functions and domain architecture and summarized the published work regarding their interactions, activity and diverse functions. Overall, it seems that plant BRD-proteins are indispensable components and fine-tuners of the complex network plants have built to regulate development, flowering, hormone signaling and response to various biotic or abiotic stresses. This work will facilitate the understanding of their roles in plants and highlight BRD-proteins with yet undiscovered functions.

Arabidopsis LFR, a SWI/SNF complex component, interacts with ICE1 and activates ICE1 and CBF3 expression in cold acclimation

Low temperatures restrict the growth and geographic distribution of plants, as well as crop yields. Appropriate transcriptional regulation is critical for cold acclimation in plants. In this study, we found that the mutation of Leaf and flower related (LFR), a component of SWI/SNF chromatin remodeling complex (CRC) important for transcriptional regulation in Arabidopsis (Arabidopsis thaliana), resulted in hypersensitivity to freezing stress in plants with or without cold acclimation, and this defect was successfully complemented by LFR. The expression levels of CBFs and COR genes in cold-treated lfr-1 mutant plants were lower than those in wild-type plants. Furthermore, LFR was found to interact directly with ICE1 in yeast and plants. Consistent with this, LFR was able to directly bind to the promoter region of CBF3, a direct target of ICE1. LFR was also able to bind to ICE1 chromatin and was required for ICE1 transcription. Together, these results demonstrate that LFR interacts directly with ICE1 and activates ICE1 and CBF3 gene expression in response to cold stress. Our work enhances our understanding of the epigenetic regulation of cold responses in plants.

Genome-wide analysis of bromodomain gene family in Arabidopsis and rice

The bromodomain-containing proteins (BRD-proteins) belongs to family of 'epigenetic mark readers', integral to epigenetic regulation. The BRD-members contain a conserved 'bromodomain' (BRD/BRD-fold: interacts with acetylated-lysine in histones), and several additional domains, making them structurally/functionally diverse. Like animals, plants also contain multiple Brd-homologs, however the extent of their diversity and impact of molecular events (genomic duplications, alternative splicing, AS) therein, is relatively less explored. The present genome-wide analysis of Brd-gene families of Arabidopsis thaliana and Oryza sativa showed extensive diversity in structure of genes/proteins, regulatory elements, expression pattern, domains/motifs, and the bromodomain (w.r.t. length, sequence, location) among the Brd-members. Orthology analysis identified thirteen ortholog groups (OGs), three paralog groups (PGs) and four singleton members (STs). While more than 40% Brd-genes were affected by genomic duplication events in both plants, AS-events affected 60% A. thaliana and 41% O. sativa genes. These molecular events affected various regions (promoters, untranslated regions, exons) of different Brd-members with potential impact on expression and/or structure-function characteristics. RNA-Seq data analysis indicated differences in tissue-specificity and stress response of Brd-members. Analysis by RT-qPCR revealed differential abundance and salt stress response of duplicate A. thaliana and O. sativa Brd-genes. Further analysis of AtBrd gene, AtBrdPG1b showed salinity-induced modulation of splicing pattern. Bromodomain (BRD)-region based phylogenetic analysis placed the A. thaliana and O. sativa homologs into clusters/sub-clusters, mostly consistent with ortholog/paralog groups. The bromodomain-region displayed several conserved signatures in key BRD-fold elements (α-helices, loops), along with variations (1-20 sites) and indels among the BRD-duplicates. Homology modeling and superposition identified structural variations in BRD-folds of divergent and duplicate BRD-members, which might affect their interaction with the chromatin histones, and associated functions. The study also showed contribution of various duplication events in Brd-gene family expansion among diverse plants, including several monocot and dicot plant species.

BRM Complex in Arabidopsis Adopts ncBAF-like Composition and Requires BRD Subunits for Assembly and Stability

ATP-dependent SWI/SNF chromatin remodelling complexes are conserved multi-subunit assemblies that control genome activity. Functions of SWI/SNF complexes in plant development and growth have been well established, but the architecture of particular assemblies is unclear. In this study, we elucidate the organization of Arabidopsis SWI/SNF complexes formed around a BRM catalytic subunit, and define the requirement of bromodomain-containing proteins BRD1/2/13 for the formation and stability of the entire complex. Using affinity purification followed by mass spectrometry, we identify a set of BRM-associated subunits and demonstrate that the BRM complexes strongly resemble mammalian non-canonical BAF complexes. Furthermore, we identify BDH1 and 2 proteins as components of the BRM complex and, using mutant analyses, show that BDH1/2 are important for vegetative and generative development, as well as hormonal responses. We further show that BRD1/2/13 represent unique subunits of the BRM complexes, and their depletion severely affects the integrity of the complex, resulting in the formation of residual assemblies. Finally, analyses of BRM complexes after proteasome inhibition revealed the existence of a module consisting of the ATPase, ARP, and BDH proteins, assembled with other subunits in a BRD-dependent manner. Together, our results suggest modular organization of plant SWI/SNF complexes and provide a biochemical explanation for mutant phenotypes.

Comprehensive characterization of three classes of Arabidopsis SWI/SNF chromatin remodelling complexes

Although SWI/SNF chromatin remodelling complexes are known to regulate diverse biological functions in plants, the classification, compositions and functional mechanisms of the complexes remain to be determined. Here we comprehensively characterized SWI/SNF complexes by affinity purification and mass spectrometry in Arabidopsis thaliana, and found three classes of SWI/SNF complexes, which we termed BAS, SAS and MAS (BRM-, SYD- and MINU1/2-associated SWI/SNF complexes). By investigating multiple developmental phenotypes of SWI/SNF mutants, we found that three classes of SWI/SNF complexes have both overlapping and specific functions in regulating development. To investigate how the three classes of SWI/SNF complexes differentially regulate development, we mapped different SWI/SNF components on chromatin at the whole-genome level and determined their effects on chromatin accessibility. While all three classes of SWI/SNF complexes regulate chromatin accessibility at proximal promoter regions, SAS is a major SWI/SNF complex that is responsible for mediating chromatin accessibility at distal promoter regions and intergenic regions. Histone modifications are related to both the association of SWI/SNF complexes with chromatin and the SWI/SNF-dependent chromatin accessibility. Three classes of SWI/SNF-dependent accessibility may enable different sets of transcription factors to access chromatin. These findings lay a foundation for further investigation of the function of three classes of SWI/SNF complexes in plants.

Bromodomain-containing factor GTE4 regulates Arabidopsis immune response

Background

Plants are continuously challenged with biotic stress from environmental pathogens, and precise regulation of defense responses is critical for plant survival. Defense systems require considerable amounts of energy and resources, impairing plant growth, and plant hormones controlling transcriptional regulation play essential roles in establishing the appropriate balance between defense response to pathogens and growth. Chromatin regulators modulating gene transcription are broadly involved in regulating stress-responsive genes. However, which chromatin factors are involved in coordinating hormone signaling and immune responses in plants, and their functional mechanisms, remains unclear. Here, we identified a role of bromodomain-containing protein GTE4 in negatively regulating defense responses in Arabidopsis thaliana.

Results

GTE4 mainly functions as activator of gene expression upon infection with Pseudomonas syringe. Genome-wide profiling of GTE4 occupancy shows that GTE4 tends to bind to active genes, including ribosome biogenesis related genes and maintains their high expression levels during pathogen infection. However, GTE4 is also able to repress gene expression. GTE4 binds to and represses jasmonate biosynthesis gene OPR3. Disruption of GTE4 results in overaccumulation of jasmonic acid (JA) and enhanced JA-responsive gene expression. Unexpectedly, over-accumulated JA content in gte4 mutant is coupled with downregulation of JA-mediated immune defense genes and upregulation of salicylic acid (SA)-mediated immune defense genes, and enhanced resistance to Pseudomonas, likely through a noncanonical pathway.

Conclusions

Overall, we identified a new role of the chromatin factor GTE4 as negative regulator of plant immune response through inhibition of JA biosynthesis, which in turn noncanonically activates the defense system against Pseudomonas. These findings provide new knowledge of chromatic regulation of plant hormone signaling during defense responses.

The TRIPLE PHD FINGERS proteins are required for SWI/SNF complex-mediated +1 nucleosome positioning and transcription start site determination in Arabidopsis

Eukaryotes have evolved multiple ATP-dependent chromatin remodelers to shape the nucleosome landscape. We recently uncovered an evolutionarily conserved SWItch/Sucrose Non-Fermentable (SWI/SNF) chromatin remodeler complex in plants reminiscent of the mammalian BAF subclass, which specifically incorporates the MINUSCULE (MINU) catalytic subunits and the TRIPLE PHD FINGERS (TPF) signature subunits. Here we report experimental evidence that establishes the functional relevance of TPF proteins for the complex activity. Our results show that depletion of TPF triggers similar pleiotropic phenotypes and molecular defects to those found in minu mutants. Moreover, we report the genomic location of MINU2 and TPF proteins as representative members of this SWI/SNF complex and their impact on nucleosome positioning and transcription. These analyses unravel the binding of the complex to thousands of genes where it modulates the position of the +1 nucleosome. These targets tend to produce 5′-shifted transcripts in the tpf and minu mutants pointing to the participation of the complex in alternative transcription start site usage. Interestingly, there is a remarkable correlation between +1 nucleosome shift and 5′ transcript length change suggesting their functional connection. In summary, this study unravels the function of a plant SWI/SNF complex involved in +1 nucleosome positioning and transcription start site determination.

Comprehensive identification of SWI/SNF complex subunits underpins deep eukaryotic ancestry and reveals new plant components

Over millions of years, eukaryotes evolved from unicellular to multicellular organisms with increasingly complex genomes and sophisticated gene expression networks. Consequently, chromatin regulators evolved to support this increased complexity. The ATP-dependent chromatin remodelers of the SWI/SNF family are multiprotein complexes that modulate nucleosome positioning and appear under different configurations, which perform distinct functions. While the composition, architecture, and activity of these subclasses are well understood in a limited number of fungal and animal model organisms, the lack of comprehensive information in other eukaryotic organisms precludes the identification of a reliable evolutionary model of SWI/SNF complexes. Here, we performed a systematic analysis using 36 species from animal, fungal, and plant lineages to assess the conservation of known SWI/SNF subunits across eukaryotes. We identified evolutionary relationships that allowed us to propose the composition of a hypothetical ancestral SWI/SNF complex in the last eukaryotic common ancestor. This last common ancestor appears to have undergone several rounds of lineage-specific subunit gains and losses, shaping the current conformation of the known subclasses in animals and fungi. In addition, our results unravel a plant SWI/SNF complex, reminiscent of the animal BAF subclass, which incorporates a set of plant-specific subunits of still unknown function.

Multiple functions of SWI/SNF chromatin remodeling complex in plant-pathogen interactions

The SWI/SNF chromatin remodeling complex utilizes the energy of ATP hydrolysis to facilitate chromatin access and plays essential roles in DNA-based events. Studies in animals, plants and fungi have uncovered sophisticated regulatory mechanisms of this complex that govern development and various stress responses. In this review, we summarize the composition of SWI/SNF complex in eukaryotes and discuss multiple functions of the SWI/SNF complex in regulating gene transcription, mRNA splicing, and DNA damage response. Our review further highlights the importance of SWI/SNF complex in regulating plant immunity responses and fungal pathogenesis. Finally, the potentials in exploiting chromatin remodeling for management of crop disease are presented.