Understanding the mechanism of proton movement linked to oxygen reduction in cytochrome c oxidase: lessons from other proteins

Cardiolipin deficiency in Rhodobacter sphaeroides alters the lipid profile of membranes and of crystallized cytochrome oxidase, but structure and function are maintained

Many recent studies highlight the importance of lipids in membrane proteins, including in the formation of well-ordered crystals. To examine the effect of changes in one lipid, cardiolipin, on the lipid profile and the production, function, and crystallization of an intrinsic membrane protein, cytochrome c oxidase, we mutated the cardiolipin synthase (cls) gene of Rhodobacter sphaeroides, causing a >90% reduction in cardiolipin content in vivo and selective changes in the abundances of other lipids. Under these conditions, a fully native cytochrome c oxidase (CcO) was produced, as indicated by its activity, spectral properties, and crystal characteristics. Analysis by MALDI tandem mass spectrometry (MS/MS) revealed that the cardiolipin level in CcO crystals, as in the membranes, was greatly decreased. Lipid species present in the crystals were directly analyzed for the first time using MS/MS, documenting their identities and fatty acid chain composition. The fatty acid content of cardiolipin in R. sphaeroides CcO (predominantly 18:1) differs from that in mammalian CcO (18:2). In contrast to the cardiolipin dependence of mammalian CcO activity, major depletion of cardiolipin in R. sphaeroides did not impact any aspect of CcO structure or behavior, suggesting a greater tolerance of interchange of cardiolipin with other lipids in this bacterial system.

Exploring the terminal region of the proton pathway in the bacterial nitric oxide reductase

The c-type nitric oxide reductase (cNOR) from Paracoccus (P.) denitrificans is an integral membrane protein that catalyzes NO reduction; 2NO+2e(-)+2H(+)-->N(2)O+H(2)O. It is also capable of catalyzing the reduction of oxygen to water, albeit more slowly than NO reduction. cNORs are divergent members of the heme-copper oxidase superfamily (HCuOs) which reduce NO, do not pump protons, and the reaction they catalyse is non-electrogenic. All known cNORs have been shown to have five conserved glutamates (E) in the catalytic subunit, by P. denitrificans numbering, the E122, E125, E198, E202 and E267. The E122 and E125 are presumed to face the periplasm and the E198, E202 and E267 are located in the interior of the membrane, close to the catalytic site. We recently showed that the E122 and E125 define the entry point of the proton pathway leading from the periplasm into the active site [U. Flock, F.H. Thorndycroft, A.D. Matorin, D.J. Richardson, N.J. Watmough, P. Adelroth, J. Biol. Chem. 283 (2008) 3839-3845]. Here we present results from the reaction between fully reduced NOR and oxygen on the alanine variants of the E198, E202 and E267. The initial binding of O(2) to the active site was unaffected by these mutations. In contrast, proton uptake to the bound O(2) was significantly inhibited in both the E198A and E267A variants, whilst the E202A NOR behaved essentially as wildtype. We propose that the E198 and E267 are involved in terminating the proton pathway in the region close to the active site in NOR.

EPR evidence of cyanide binding to the Mn(Mg) center of cytochrome c oxidase: support for Cu(A)-Mg involvement in proton pumping

We examined the anion binding behavior of the Mg(Mn) site in cytochrome c oxidase to test a possible role of this center in proton pumping. Rhodobacter sphaeroides grown in a Mn(II)-rich medium replaces the intrinsic Mg(II) ion with an EPR-detectable Mn(II) ion without change in activity. Due to its close proximity and a shared ligand, oxidized Cu(A) is spin-coupled to the Mn(II) ion, affecting the EPR spectrum. An examination of both bovine and R.s. oxidase crystal structures reveals a hydrogen-bonding pattern in the vicinity of the Mg(II) site that is consistent with three water ligands of the Mg(Mn) center when Cu(A) is oxidized. In the reduced structure, one water molecule in the vicinity of the Cu(A) ligand, E198, moves closer, appearing to be converted into an ionically bonded hydronium ion, while a second water molecule bonded to Mg(Mn) shows evidence of conversion to a hydroxide. The implied proton movement is proposed to be part of a redox-linked export of a pumped proton from the binuclear center into the exit pathway. To test the model, cyanide and azide were added to the oxidized and reduced forms of the enzyme, and Mn(II) CW-EPR and ESEEM spectra were recorded. Addition of azide broadened the CW-EPR spectra for both oxidized and reduced enzyme. Cyanide addition affected the Mn(II) CW-EPR spectrum of reduced cytochrome c oxidase by increasing Mn(II) zero field splitting and broadening the spectral line shapes but had no effect on oxidized enzyme. ESEEM measurements support a differential ability of Mn(II) to bind cyanide in the reduced state of cytochrome c oxidase. This new observation of anion binding at the Mg/Mn site is of interest in terms of accessibility of the buried site and its potential role in redox-dependent proton pumping.

Molecular architecture of the proton diode of cytochrome c oxidase

CytcO (cytochrome c oxidase) is a membrane-bound multisubunit protein which catalyses the reduction of O2 to H2O. The reaction is arranged topographically so that the electrons and protons are taken from opposite sides of the membrane and, in addition, it is also linked to proton pumping across the membrane. Thus the CytcO moves an equivalent of two positive charges across the membrane per electron transferred to O2. Proton transfer through CytcO must be controlled by the protein to prevent leaks, which would dissipate the proton electrochemical gradient that is maintained across the membrane. The molecular mechanism by which the protein controls the unidirectionality of proton-transfer (cf. proton diode) reactions and energetically links electron transfer to proton translocation is not known. This short review summarizes selected results from studies aimed at understanding this mechanism, and we discuss a possible mechanistic principle utilized by the oxidase to pump protons.

A chemically explicit model for the mechanism of proton pumping in heme-copper oxidases

A mechanism for proton pumping is described that is based on chemiosmotic principles and the detailed molecular structures now available for cytochrome oxidases. The importance of conserved water positions and a step-wise gated process of proton translocation is emphasized, where discrete electron transfer events are coupled to proton uptake and expulsion. The trajectory of each pumped proton is the same for all four substrate electrons. An essential role for the His-Tyr cross-linked species is discussed, in gating of the D- and K-channels and as an acceptor/donor of electrons and protons at the binuclear center.

Structural elements involved in proton translocation by cytochrome c oxidase as revealed by backbone amide hydrogen-deuterium exchange of the E286H mutant

Cytochrome c oxidase is the terminal electron acceptor in the respiratory chains of aerobic organisms and energetically couples the reduction of oxygen to water to proton pumping across the membrane. The mechanisms of proton uptake, gating, and pumping have yet to be completely elucidated at the molecular level for these enzymes. For Rhodobacter sphaeroides CytcO (cytochrome aa3), it appears as though the E286 side chain of subunit I is a branching point from which protons are shuttled either to the catalytic site for O2 reduction or to the acceptor site for pumped protons. Amide hydrogen-deuterium exchange mass spectrometry was used to investigate how mutation of this key branching residue to histidine (E286H) affects the structures and dynamics of four redox intermediate states. A functional characterization of this mutant reveals that E286H CytcO retains approximately 1% steady-state activity that is uncoupled from proton pumping and that proton transfer from H286 is significantly slowed. Backbone amide H-D exchange kinetics indicates that specific regions of CytcO, perturbed by the E286H mutation, are likely to be involved in proton gating and in the exit pathway for pumped protons. The results indicate that redox-dependent conformational changes around E286 are essential for internal proton transfer. E286H CytcO, however, is incapable of these specific conformational changes and therefore is insensitive to the redox state of the enzyme. These data support a model where the side chain conformation of E286 controls proton translocation in CytcO through its interactions with the proton gate, which directs the flow of protons either to the active site or to the exit pathway. In the E286H mutant, the proton gate does not function properly and the exit channel is unresponsive. These results provide new insight into the structure and mechanism of proton translocation by CytcO.

Deuterium isotope effect of proton pumping in cytochrome c oxidase

In mitochondria and many aerobic bacteria cytochrome c oxidase is the terminal enzyme of the respiratory chain where it catalyses the reduction of oxygen to water. The free energy released in this process is used to translocate (pump) protons across the membrane such that each electron transfer to the catalytic site is accompanied by proton pumping. To investigate the mechanism of electron-proton coupling in cytochrome c oxidase we have studied the pH-dependence of the kinetic deuterium isotope effect of specific reaction steps associated with proton transfer in wild-type and structural variants of cytochrome c oxidases in which amino-acid residues in proton-transfer pathways have been modified. In addition, we have solved the structure of one of these mutant enzymes, where a key component of the proton-transfer machinery, Glu286, was modified to an Asp. The results indicate that the P3-->F3 transition rate is determined by a direct proton-transfer event to the catalytic site. In contrast, the rate of the F3-->O4 transition, which involves simultaneous electron transfer to the catalytic site and is characteristic of any transition during CytcO turnover, is determined by two events with similar rates and different kinetic isotope effects. These reaction steps involve transfer of protons, that are pumped, via a segment of the protein including Glu286 and Arg481.

Exploring pathways and barriers for coupled ET/PT in cytochrome c oxidase: a general framework for examining energetics and mechanistic alternatives

Gaining a detailed understanding of the energetics of the proton pumping process in cytochrome c oxidase (CcO) is one of the challenges of modern biophysics. Although there are several current mechanistic proposals, most of these ideas have not been subjected to consistent structure-function considerations. In particular most works have not related the activation barriers for different mechanistic proposals to the protein structure. The present work describes a general approach for exploring the energetics of different feasible models of the action of CcO, using the observed protein structure, established simulation methods and a modified Marcus' formulation. We start by reviewing our methods for evaluation of the energy diagrams for different proton translocation paths and then present a systematic analysis of various constraints that should be imposed on any energy diagram for the pumping process. After the general analysis we turn to the actual computational study, where we construct energy diagrams for forward and backward paths, using the estimated calculated reduction potentials and pK(a) values of all the relevant sites (including internal water molecules). We then explore the relationship between the calculated energy diagrams and key experimental constraints. This comparison allows us to identify some barriers that are not fully consistent with the overall requirement for an efficient pumping. In particular we identify back leakage channels, which are hard to block without stopping the forward channels. This helps to identify open problems that will require further experimental and theoretical studies. We also consider reasonable adjustments of the calculated barriers that may lead to a working pump. Although the present analysis does not establish a unique and workable model for the mechanism of CcO, it presents what is probably the most consistent current analysis of the barriers for different feasible pathways. Perhaps more importantly, the framework developed here should provide a general way for examining any proposal for the action of CcO as well as for the analysis of further experimental findings about the action of this fascinating system.

Identification of conserved lipid/detergent-binding sites in a high-resolution structure of the membrane protein cytochrome c oxidase

Well ordered reproducible crystals of cytochrome c oxidase (CcO) from Rhodobacter sphaeroides yield a previously unreported structure at 2.0 A resolution that contains the two catalytic subunits and a number of alkyl chains of lipids and detergents. Comparison with crystal structures of other bacterial and mammalian CcOs reveals that the positions occupied by native membrane lipids and detergent substitutes are highly conserved, along with amino acid residues in their vicinity, suggesting a more prevalent and specific role of lipid in membrane protein structure than often envisioned. Well defined detergent head groups (maltose) are found associated with aromatic residues in a manner similar to phospholipid head groups, likely contributing to the success of alkyl glycoside detergents in supporting membrane protein activity and crystallizability. Other significant features of this structure include the following: finding of a previously unreported crystal contact mediated by cadmium and an engineered histidine tag; documentation of the unique His-Tyr covalent linkage close to the active site; remarkable conservation of a chain of waters in one proton pathway (D-path); and discovery of an inhibitory cadmium-binding site at the entrance to another proton path (K-path). These observations provide important insight into CcO structure and mechanism, as well as the significance of bound lipid in membrane proteins.

Design principles of proton-pumping haem-copper oxidases

Transmembrane electrochemical proton gradients are used to store free energy in biological systems, and to drive the synthesis of biomolecules and transmembrane transport. These gradients are maintained by membrane-bound proton transporters that employ free energy provided by, for example, electron transfer or light. In recent years, the structures of several membrane proteins involved in proton translocation have been determined, and indicate that both protein-bound water molecules and protonatable amino acid residues play central roles in transmembrane proton conduction. From these structures, in combination with functional studies, have emerged general principles of proton transfer across membranes and control mechanisms for such reactions, in particular with regard to the electron-transfer-driven proton pump cytochrome c oxidase.

Inhibition of proton pumping by zinc ions during specific reaction steps in cytochrome c oxidase

Cytochrome c oxidase (CytcO) is a redox-driven proton pump in the respiratory chain of mitochondria and many aerobic bacteria. The results from several studies have shown that zinc ions interfere with both the uptake and release of protons, presumably by binding near the orifice of the proton entrance and exit pathways. To elucidate the effect of Zn2+ binding on individual electron and proton-transfer reactions, in this study, we have investigated the reaction of the fully reduced R. sphaeroides CytcO with O2, both with enzyme in detergent solution and reconstituted in phospholipid vesicles, and, with and without, Zn2+. The results show that addition of Zn2+ at concentrations of < or = 250 microM to the outside of the vesicles did not alter the transition rates between intermediates PR (P3)-->F3-->O4. However, proton pumping was impaired specifically during the P3-->F3, but not during the F3-->O4 transition at Zn2+ concentrations of < or = 25 microM. Furthermore, proton pumping during the P3-->F3 transition was typically impaired with the "as isolated" CytcO, which was found to contain Zn2+ ions at microM concentration. As has already been shown, Zn2+ was also found to obstruct proton uptake during the P3-->F3 transition, presumably by binding to a site near the orifice of the D-pathway. In this work we found a KI of approximately 1 microM for this binding site. In conclusion, the results show that Zn2+ ions bind on both sides of CytcO and that binding of Zn2+ at the proton output side selectively impairs proton release during the P3-->F3 transition.

Monte Carlo simulations of proton pumps: on the working principles of the biological valve that controls proton pumping in cytochrome c oxidase

Gaining a detailed understanding of the proton-pumping process in cytochrome c oxidase (COX) is one of the challenges of modern biophysics. Recent mutation experiments have highlighted this challenge by showing that a single mutation (the N139D mutation) blocks the overall pumping while continuing to channel protons to the binuclear center without inhibiting the oxidase activity. Rationalizing this result has been a major problem because the mutation is quite far from E286, which is believed to serve as the branching point for the proton transport in the pumping process. In the absence of a reasonable explanation for this important observation, we have developed a Monte Carlo simulation method that can convert mutation and structural information to pathways for proton translocation and simulate the pumping process in COX on a millisecond and even subsecond time scale. This tool allows us to reproduce and propose a possible explanation to the effect of the N139D mutation and to offer a consistent model for the origin of the "valve effect" in COX, which is crucial for maintaining uphill proton pumping. Furthermore, obtaining the first structure-based simulation of proton pumping in COX, or in any other protein, indicates that our approach should provide a powerful tool for verification of mechanistic hypotheses about the action of proton transport proteins.

An elementary reaction step of the proton pump is revealed by mutation of tryptophan-164 to phenylalanine in cytochrome c oxidase from Paracoccus denitrificans

Cytochrome c oxidase couples reduction of dioxygen to water to translocation of protons over the inner mitochondrial or bacterial membrane. A likely proton acceptor for pumped protons is the Delta-propionate of heme a(3), which may receive the proton via water molecules from a conserved glutamic acid (E278 in subunit I of the Paracoccus denitrificans enzyme) and which receives a hydrogen bond from a conserved tryptophan, W164. Here, W164 was mutated to phenylalanine (W164F) to further explore the role of the heme a(3) Delta-propionate in proton translocation. FTIR spectroscopy showed changes in vibrations possibly attributable to heme propionates, and the midpoint redox potential of heme a(3) decreased by approximately 50 mV. The reaction of the oxidized W164F enzyme with hydrogen peroxide yielded substantial amounts of the intermediate F' even at high pH, which suggests that the mutation rearranges the local electric field in the binuclear center that controls the peroxide reaction. The steady-state proton translocation stoichiometry of the W164F enzyme dropped to approximately 0.5 H(+)/e(-) in cells and reconstituted proteoliposomes. Time-resolved electrometric measurements showed that when the fully reduced W164F enzyme reacted with O(2), the membrane potential generated in the fast phase of this reaction was far too small to account either for full proton pumping or uptake of a substrate proton from the inside of the proteoliposomes. Time-resolved optical spectroscopy showed that this fast electrometric phase occurred with kinetics corresponding to the transition from state A to P(R), whereas the subsequent transition to the F state was strongly delayed. This is due to a delay of reprotonation of E278 via the D-pathway, which was confirmed by observation of a slowed rate of Cu(A) oxidation and which explains the small amplitude of the fast charge transfer phase. Surprisingly, the W164F mutation thus mimics a weak block of the D-pathway, which is interpreted as an effect on the side chain isomerization of E278. The fast charge translocation may be due to transfer of a proton from E278 to a "pump site" above the heme groups and is likely to occur also in wild-type enzyme, though not distinguished earlier due to the high-amplitude membrane potential formation during the P(R)--> F transition.

Controlled uncoupling and recoupling of proton pumping in cytochrome c oxidase

Cytochrome c oxidase (CcO) is the terminal enzyme of the respiratory chain and couples energetically the reduction of oxygen to water to proton pumping across the membrane. The results from previous studies showed that proton pumping can be uncoupled from the O2-reduction reaction by replacement of one single residue, Asn-139 by Asp (N139D), located approximately 30 A from the catalytic site, in the D-proton pathway. The uncoupling was correlated with an increase in the pK(a) of an internal proton donor, Glu-286, from approximately 9.4 to >11. Here, we show that replacement of the acidic residue, Asp-132 by Asn in the N139D CcO (D132N/N139D double-mutant CcO) results in restoration of the Glu-286 pK(a) to the original value and recoupling of the proton pump during steady-state turnover. Furthermore, a kinetic investigation of the specific reaction steps in the D132N/N139D double-mutant CcO showed that proton pumping is sustained even if proton uptake from solution, through the D-pathway, is slowed. However, during single-turnover oxidation of the fully reduced CcO the P --> F transition, which does not involve electron transfer to the catalytic site, was not coupled to proton pumping. The results provide insights into the mechanism of proton pumping by CcO and the structural elements involved in this process.

Energy transduction: proton transfer through the respiratory complexes

A series of metalloprotein complexes embedded in a mitochondrial or bacterial membrane utilize electron transfer reactions to pump protons across the membrane and create an electrochemical potential (DeltamuH+). Current understanding of the principles of electron-driven proton transfer is discussed, mainly with respect to the wealth of knowledge available from studies of cytochrome c oxidase. Structural, experimental, and theoretical evidence supports the model of long-distance proton transfer via hydrogen-bonded water chains in proteins as well as the basic concept that proton uptake and release in a redox-driven pump are driven by charge changes at the membrane-embedded centers. Key elements in the pumping mechanism may include bound water, carboxylates, and the heme propionates, arginines, and associated water above the hemes. There is evidence for an important role of subunit III and proton backflow, but the number and nature of gating mechanisms remain elusive, as does the mechanism of physiological control of efficiency.

Water chain formation and possible proton pumping routes in Rhodobacter sphaeroides cytochrome c oxidase: a molecular dynamics comparison of the wild type and R481K mutant

Cytochrome c oxidase (CcO) converts the energy from redox and oxygen chemistry to support proton translocation and create a transmembrane DeltamuH(+) used for ATP production. Molecular dynamics (MD) simulations were carried out to probe for the formation water chains capable of participating in proton translocation. Attention was focused on the region between and above the a and a(3) hemes where well-defined water chains have not been identified in crystallographic studies. An arginine (R481) (Rhodobacter sphaeroides numbering), positioned between the D-propionates of the hemes, had been mutated in vivo to lysine and showed to have altered activity consistent with an altered proton conductance [Qian, J., Mills, D. A., Geren, L., Wang, K. F., Hoganson, C. W., Schmidt, B., Hiser, C., Babcock, G. T., Durham, B., Millett, F., and Ferguson-Miller, S. (2004) Role of the conserved arginine pair in proton and electron transfer in cytochrome c oxidase, Biochemistry 43, 5748-5756; also see the accompanying paper by Mills et al.]. This mutant was created in silico, and the MD results for the mutant and wild type were compared to explore the effects on the formation of hydrogen-bonded water chains by this mutation. The simulations reveal the presence of hydrogen-bonded water chains that lead from E286 through the region above the hemes to the Mg(2+), and from E286 to the heme a(3) D-propionate and the binuclear center. The R481K mutant does not form as many, or as extensive, water chains as wild-type CcO, due to a new conformation of residues in a large loop between helices III and IV in subunit I, indicating a reduction in the level of water chain formation in the mutant. This loop appears to play a role in controlling the formation of hydrogen-bonded water chains above the hemes. The results suggest a possible gating mechanism for proton movement that includes key residues W172 and Y175 on the loop and F282 on helix VI.

An arginine to lysine mutation in the vicinity of the heme propionates affects the redox potentials of the hemes and associated electron and proton transfer in cytochrome c oxidase

Cytochrome c oxidase pumps protons across a membrane using energy from electron transfer and reduction of oxygen to water. It is postulated that an element of the energy transduction mechanism is the movement of protons to the vicinity of the hemes upon reduction, to favor charge neutrality. Possible sites on which protons could reside, in addition to the conserved carboxylate E286, are the propionate groups of heme a and/or heme a(3). A highly conserved pair of arginines (R481 and R482) interact with these propionates through ionic and hydrogen bonds. This study shows that the conservative mutant, R481K, although as fully active as the wild type under many conditions, exhibits a significant decrease in the midpoint redox potential of heme a relative to Cu(A) (DeltaE(m)) of approximately equal 40 mV, has lowered activity under conditions of high pH or in the presence of a membrane potential, and has a slowed heme a(3) reduction with dithionite. Another mutant, D132A, which strongly inhibits proton uptake from the internal side of the membrane, has <4% of the activity of the wild type and appears to be dependent on proton uptake from the outside. A double mutation, D132A/R481K, is even more strongly inhibited ( approximately 1% of that of the wild type). The more-than-additive effect supports the concept that R481K not only lowers the midpoint potential of heme a but also limits a supply route for protons from the outside of the membrane used by the D132 mutant. The results are consistent with an important role of R481 and heme a/a(3) propionates in proton movement in a reversible exit path.

The timing of proton migration in membrane-reconstituted cytochrome c oxidase

In mitochondria and aerobic bacteria energy conservation involves electron transfer through a number of membrane-bound protein complexes to O2. The reduction of O2, accompanied by the uptake of substrate protons to form H2O, is catalyzed by cytochrome c oxidase (CcO). This reaction is coupled to proton translocation (pumping) across the membrane such that each electron transfer to the catalytic site is linked to the uptake of two protons from one side and the release of one proton to the other side of the membrane. To address the mechanism of vectorial proton translocation, in this study we have investigated the solvent deuterium isotope effect of proton-transfer rates in CcO oriented in small unilamellar vesicles. Although in H2O the uptake and release reactions occur with the same rates, in D2O the substrate and pumped protons are taken up first (tau(D) congruent with 200 micros, "peroxy" to "ferryl" transition) followed by a significantly slower proton release to the other side of the membrane (tau(D) congruent with 1 ms). Thus, the results define the order and timing of the proton transfers during a pumping cycle. Furthermore, the results indicate that during CcO turnover internal electron transfer to the catalytic site is controlled by the release of the pumped proton, which suggests a mechanism by which CcO orchestrates a tight coupling between electron transfer and proton translocation.

A mechanistic principle for proton pumping by cytochrome c oxidase

In aerobic organisms, cellular respiration involves electron transfer to oxygen through a series of membrane-bound protein complexes. The process maintains a transmembrane electrochemical proton gradient that is used, for example, in the synthesis of ATP. In mitochondria and many bacteria, the last enzyme complex in the electron transfer chain is cytochrome c oxidase (CytcO), which catalyses the four-electron reduction of O2 to H2O using electrons delivered by a water-soluble donor, cytochrome c. The electron transfer through CytcO, accompanied by proton uptake to form H2O drives the physical movement (pumping) of four protons across the membrane per reduced O2. So far, the molecular mechanism of such proton pumping driven by electron transfer has not been determined in any biological system. Here we show that proton pumping in CytcO is mechanistically coupled to proton transfer to O2 at the catalytic site, rather than to internal electron transfer. This scenario suggests a principle by which redox-driven proton pumps might operate and puts considerable constraints on possible molecular mechanisms by which CytcO translocates protons.

Slow proton transfer through the pathways for pumped protons in cytochrome c oxidase induces suicide inactivation of the enzyme

In the absence of subunit III the aa(3)-type cytochrome c oxidase exhibits a shortened catalytic life span (total number of turnovers) due to an increased probability of undergoing irreversible inactivation during steady-state turnover. Inactivation results from structural alteration of the heme a(3)-Cu(B) active site in subunit I [Hosler (2004) Biochim. Biophys. Acta 1655, 332-339]. The absence of subunit III also dramatically slows proton uptake to the active site via the D proton pathway, as well as inhibiting the proton backflow/exit pathway that connects the active site/proton pump with the outer surface of the oxidase complex. Here we demonstrate that these phenomena are linked: slow proton delivery to the active site through these pathways induces suicide inactivation, thus shortening the catalytic life span of the enzyme. Mutations that inhibit the D pathway, but not the K pathway, increase the probability of suicide inactivation. Strong inhibition of the D pathway allows suicide inactivation to occur even in the presence of subunit III. Arachidonic acid, which stimulates proton uptake by the D pathway, retards suicide inactivation. Steady-state turnover in the presence of DeltaPsi and DeltapH, which inhibits proton uptake from the inner surface of the protein, enhances suicide inactivation. Simultaneous inhibition of proton uptake from both sides of the protein by a double mutation affecting the D pathway and the proton backflow/exit pathway greatly shortens the catalytic life span of the oxidase even in the presence of subunit III. Thus, maintenance of rapid proton transfer through the D pathway and the backflow/exit pathway is one mechanism by which subunit III normally functions to prevent suicide inactivation of cytochrome c oxidase. The experiments suggest that increased lifetimes of the heme a(3) oxoferryl intermediates as well as the anionic form of Glu286 of the D pathway cause suicide inactivation in the active site.

Simulating redox coupled proton transfer in cytochromecoxidase: Looking for the proton bottleneck

Gaining a detailed understanding of the molecular nature of the redox coupled proton transfer in cytochrome c oxidase (COX) is one of the challenges of modern biophysics. The present work addresses this by integrating approaches for simulations of proton transport (PTR) and electron transfer (ET). The resulting method converts the electrostatic energies of different charge configurations and reorganization energies to free-energy profiles for different PTR and ET pathways. This approach provides for the first time a tool to study the actual activation barriers and kinetics of different feasible PTR processes in the cycle of COX. Using this tool, we explore the PTR through the bottleneck water molecules. It is found that a stepwise PTR along this commonly assumed path leads to far too high barriers and is, thus, inconsistent with the observed kinetics. Furthermore, the simulated free-energy profile does not provide a simple gating mechanism. Fortunately, we obtain reasonable kinetics when we consider a PTR that involves a concerted transfer of protons to and from E286. Finally, semi-qualitative considerations of the forward and backward barriers point toward open questions about the actual gating process and offer a feasible pumping mechanism. Although further studies are clearly needed, we believe that our approach offers a general and effective tool for correlating the structure of COX with its function.

Protonmotive cooperativity in cytochrome c oxidase

Cooperative linkage of solute binding at separate binding sites in allosteric proteins is an important functional attribute of soluble and membrane bound hemoproteins. Analysis of proton/electron coupling at the four redox centers, i.e. Cu(A), heme a, heme a(3) and Cu(B), in the purified bovine cytochrome c oxidase in the unliganded, CO-liganded and CN-liganded states is presented. These studies are based on direct measurement of scalar proton translocation associated with oxido-reduction of the metal centers and pH dependence of the midpoint potential of the redox centers. Heme a (and Cu(A)) exhibits a cooperative proton/electron linkage (Bohr effect). Bohr effect seems also to be associated with the oxygen-reduction chemistry at the heme a(3)-Cu(B) binuclear center. Data on electron transfer in cytochrome c oxidase are also presented, which, together with structural data, provide evidence showing the occurrence of direct electron transfer from Cu(A) to the binuclear center in addition to electron transfer via heme a. A survey of structural and functional data showing the essential role of cooperative proton/electron linkage at heme a in the proton pump of cytochrome c oxidase is presented. On the basis of this and related functional and structural information, variants for cooperative mechanisms in the proton pump of the oxidase are examined.

Dynamic water networks in cytochrome C oxidase from Paracoccus denitrificans investigated by molecular dynamics simulations

We present a molecular dynamics study of cytochrome c oxidase from Paracoccus denitrificans in the fully oxidized state, embedded in a fully hydrated dimyristoylphosphatidylcholine lipid bilayer membrane. Parallel simulations with different levels of protein hydration, 1.125 ns each in length, were carried out under conditions of constant temperature and pressure using three-dimensional periodic boundary conditions and full electrostatics to investigate the distribution and dynamics of water molecules and their corresponding hydrogen-bonded networks inside cytochrome c oxidase. The majority of the water molecules had residence times shorter than 100 ps, but a few water molecules are fixed inside the protein for up to 1.125 ns. The hydrogen-bonded network in cytochrome c oxidase is not uniformly distributed, and the degree of water arrangement is variable. The average number of solvent sites in the proton-conducting K- and D-pathways was determined. In contrast to single water files in narrow geometries we observe significant diffusion of individual water molecules along these pathways. The highly fluctuating hydrogen-bonded networks, combined with the significant diffusion of individual water molecules, provide a basis for the transfer of protons in cytochrome c oxidase, therefore leading to a better understanding of the mechanism of proton pumping.

A single-amino-acid lid renders a gas-tight compartment within a membrane-bound transporter

Proteins undergo structural fluctuations between nearly isoenergetic substates. Such fluctuations are often intimately linked with the functional properties of proteins. However, in some cases, such as in transmembrane ion transporters, the control of the ion transport requires that the protein is designed to restrict the motions in specific regions. In this study, we have investigated the dynamics of a membrane-bound respiratory oxidase, which acts both as an enzyme catalyzing reduction of O(2) to H(2)O and as a transmembrane proton pump. The segment of the protein where proton translocation is controlled ("gating" region) overlaps with a channel through which O(2) is delivered to the catalytic site. We show that the replacement of an amino acid residue with a small side chain (Gly) by one with a larger side chain (Val), in a narrow part of this channel, completely blocks the O(2) access to the catalytic site and results in formation of a compartment around the site that is impermeable to small gas molecules. Thus, the protein motions cannot counter the blockage introduced by the mutation. These results indicate that the protein motions are restricted in the proton-gating region and that rapid O(2) delivery to the catalytic site requires a gas channel, which is confined within a rigid protein body.

A High-Throughput Screen for Porphyrin Metal Chelatases: Application to the Directed Evolution of Ferrochelatases for Metalloporphyrin Biosynthesis

Porphyrins are of particular interest in a variety of applications ranging from biocatalysis and chemical synthesis to biosensor and electronic technologies as well as cancer treatment. Recently, we have developed a versatile system for the high-level production of porphyrins in engineered E. coli cells with the aim of diversifying substitution patterns and accessing porphyrin systems not readily available through chemical synthesis. However, this approach failed to produce significant amounts of the metalloporphyrin in vivo from overproduced protoporphyrin due to insufficient metal insertion. Therefore, we systematically assessed the activity of the B. subtilis ferrochelatase in vivo and in vitro. A true high-throughput-screening approach based on catalytic in vivo ferrochelatase activity was developed by using fluorescence-activated cell sorting (FACS). This assay was used to screen a library of 2.4 x 10(6) ferrochelatase mutants expressed in protoporphyrin-overproducing recombinant E. coli cells. Several selected protein variants were purified, and their improved catalytic activity was confirmed in vitro. In addition to ferrochelatase activity, metal transport into E. coli was identified as another limitation for in vivo heme overproduction. Overexpression of the metal transporter zupT as part of the assembled pathway increased the overall metalloporphyrin production twofold. This report represents the most exhaustive in vitro evolution study of a ferrochelatase and demonstrates the effectiveness of our novel high-throughput-screening system for directed evolution of ferrochelatases based on their catalytic activity.

Thermodynamic and choreographic constraints for energy transduction by cytochrome c oxidase

Cooperative effects are fundamental for electroprotonic energy transduction processes, crucial to sustain much of life chemistry. However, the primary cooperative mechanism by which transmembrane proteins couple the downhill transfer of electrons to the uphill activation (acidification) of protic groups is still a matter of great controversy. To understand cooperative processes fully, it is necessary to obtain the microscopic thermodynamic parameters of the functional centres and relate them to the relevant structural features, a task difficult to achieve for large proteins. The approach discussed here explores how this may be done by extrapolation from mechanisms used by simpler proteins operative in similar processes. The detailed study of small, soluble cytochromes performing electroprotonic activation has shown how they use anti-electrostatic effects to control the synchronous movement of charges. These include negative e(-)/H(+) (redox-Bohr effect) cooperativities. This capacity is the basis to discuss an unorthodox mechanism consistent with the available experimental data on the process of electroprotonic energy transduction performed by cytochrome c oxidase (CcO).

Cytochrome c oxidase: 25 years of the elusive proton pump

Since its discovery [Nature 266 (1977) 271], the function of cytochrome c oxidase (and other haem-copper oxidases) as a redox-driven proton pump has been subject of both intense research and controversy, and is one of the key unsolved issues of bioenergetics and of biochemistry more generally. Despite the fact that the mechanism of proton translocation is not yet fully understood on the molecular level, many important details and principles have been learned. In the hope of accelerating progress, some of these will be reviewed here, together with a brief presentation of a novel proton pump mechanism, and of the emergence of a molecular basis for control of its efficiency.

Arsenite oxidation by the heterotroph Hydrogenophaga sp. str. NT-14: the arsenite oxidase and its physiological electron acceptor

Heterotrophic arsenite oxidation by Hydrogenophaga sp. str. NT-14 is coupled to the reduction of oxygen and appears to yield energy for growth. Purification and partial characterization of the arsenite oxidase revealed that it (1). contains two heterologous subunits, AroA (86 kDa) and AroB (16 kDa), (2). has a native molecular mass of 306 kDa suggesting an alpha(3)beta(3) configuration, and (3). contains molybdenum and iron as cofactors. Although the Hydrogenophaga sp. str. NT-14 arsenite oxidase shares similarities to the arsenite oxidases purified from NT-26 and Alcaligenes faecalis, it differs with respect to activity and overall conformation. A c-551-type cytochrome was purified from Hydrogenophaga sp. str. NT-14 and appears to be the physiological electron acceptor for the arsenite oxidase. The cytochrome can also accept electrons from the purified NT-26 arsenite oxidase. A hypothetical electron transport chain for heterotrophic arsenite oxidation is proposed.

X-Ray Structure Determination of Three Mutants of the Bacterial Photosynthetic Reaction Centers from Rb. sphaeroides

In the photosynthetic reaction center (RC) from Rhodobacter sphaeroides, the reduction of a bound quinone molecule Q(B) is coupled with proton uptake. When Asp-L213 is replaced by Asn, proton transfer is inhibited. Proton transfer was restored by two second-site revertant mutations, Arg-M233-->Cys and Arg-H177-->His. Kinetic effects of Cd(2+) on proton transfer showed that the entry point in revertant RCs to be the same as in the native RC. The structures of the parental and two revertant RCs were determined at resolutions of 2.10, 1.80, and 2.75 A. From the structures, we were able to delineate alternate proton transfer pathways in the revertants. The main changes occur near Glu-H173, which allow it to substitute for the missing Asp-L213. The electrostatic changes near Glu-H173 cause it to be a good proton donor and acceptor, and the structural changes create a cavity which accommodates water molecules that connect Glu-H173 to other proton transfer components.