Characterization of intra- and intermolecular DNA ligation mediated by eukaryotic topoisomerase I. Role of bipartite DNA interaction in the ligation process

Gel-Free Tools for Quick and Simple Screening of Anti-Topoisomerase 1 Compounds

With the increasing need for effective compounds against cancer or pathogen-borne diseases, the development of new tools to investigate the enzymatic activity of biomarkers is necessary. Among these biomarkers are DNA topoisomerases, which are key enzymes that modify DNA and regulate DNA topology during cellular processes. Over the years, libraries of natural and synthetic small-molecule compounds have been extensively investigated as potential anti-cancer, anti-bacterial, or anti-parasitic drugs targeting topoisomerases. However, the current tools for measuring the potential inhibition of topoisomerase activity are time consuming and not easily adaptable outside specialized laboratories. Here, we present rolling circle amplification-based methods that provide fast and easy readouts for screening of compounds against type 1 topoisomerases. Specific assays for the investigation of the potential inhibition of eukaryotic, viral, or bacterial type 1 topoisomerase activity were developed, using human topoisomerase 1, Leishmania donovani topoisomerase 1, monkeypox virus topoisomerase 1, and Mycobacterium smegmatis topoisomerase 1 as model enzymes. The presented tools proved to be sensitive and directly quantitative, paving the way for new diagnostic and drug screening protocols in research and clinical settings.

Simple and Fast DNA Based Sensor System for Screening of Small-Molecule Compounds Targeting Eukaryotic Topoisomerase 1

Background: Eukaryotic topoisomerase 1 is a potential target of anti-parasitic and anti-cancer drugs. Parasites require topoisomerase 1 activity for survival and, consequently, compounds that inhibit topoisomerase 1 activity may be of interest. All effective topoisomerase 1 drugs with anti-cancer activity act by inhibiting the ligation reaction of the enzyme. Screening for topoisomerase 1 targeting drugs, therefore, should involve the possibility of dissecting which step of topoisomerase 1 activity is affected. Methods: Here we present a novel DNA-based assay that allows for screening of the effect of small-molecule compounds targeting the binding/cleavage or the ligation steps of topoisomerase 1 catalysis. This novel assay is based on the detection of a rolling circle amplification product generated from a DNA circle resulting from topoisomerase 1 activity. Results: We show that the binding/cleavage and ligation reactions of topoisomerase 1 can be investigated separately in the presented assay termed REEAD (C|L) and demonstrate that the assay can be used to investigate, which of the individual steps of topoisomerase 1 catalysis are affected by small-molecule compounds. The assay is gel-free and the results can be detected by a simple colorimetric readout method using silver-on-gold precipitation rendering large equipment unnecessary. Conclusion: REEAD (C|L) allows for easy and quantitative investigations of topoisomerase 1 targeting compounds and can be performed in non-specialized laboratories.

How Enzymes, Proteins, and Antibodies Recognize Extended DNAs; General Regularities

X-ray analysis cannot provide quantitative estimates of the relative contribution of non-specific, specific, strong, and weak contacts of extended DNA molecules to their total affinity for enzymes and proteins. The interaction of different enzymes and proteins with long DNA and RNA at the quantitative molecular level can be successfully analyzed using the method of the stepwise increase in ligand complexity (SILC). The present review summarizes the data on stepwise increase in ligand complexity (SILC) analysis of nucleic acid recognition by various enzymes-replication, restriction, integration, topoisomerization, six different repair enzymes (uracil DNA glycosylase, Fpg protein from Escherichia coli, human 8-oxoguanine-DNA glycosylase, human apurinic/apyrimidinic endonuclease, RecA protein, and DNA-ligase), and five DNA-recognizing proteins (RNA helicase, human lactoferrin, alfa-lactalbumin, human blood albumin, and IgGs against DNA). The relative contributions of structural elements of DNA fragments "covered" by globules of enzymes and proteins to the total affinity of DNA have been evaluated. Thermodynamic and catalytic factors providing discrimination of unspecific and specific DNAs by these enzymes on the stages of primary complex formation following changes in enzymes and DNAs or RNAs conformations and direct processing of the catalysis of the reactions were found. General regularities of recognition of nucleic acid by DNA-dependent enzymes, proteins, and antibodies were established.

Bulge oligonucleotide as an inhibitory agent of bacterial topoisomerase I

Bacterial topoisomerase I (Btopo I) was defined as potential target for discovery of new antibacterial compounds. Various oligonucleotides containing bulge structure were designed and synthesised as inhibitors to Btopo I in this investigation. The results of this study demonstrated that the designed oligonucleotides display high inhibitory efficiency on the activity of Btopo I and the inhibitory effect could be modulated by the amount of bulge DNA bases. The most efficient one among them showed an IC₅₀ value of 63.1 nM in its inhibition on the activity of Btopo I. In addition, our studies confirmed that the designed oligonucleotide would induce irreversible damages to Btopo I and without any effects occur to eukaryotic topoisomerase I. It is our hope that the results provided in these studies could provide a novel way to inhibit Btopo I.

The Top1 paradox: Friend and foe of the eukaryotic genome

Topoisomerases manage the torsional stress associated with the separation of DNA strands during transcription and DNA replication. Eukaryotic Topoisomerase I (Top1) is a Type IB enzyme that nicks and rejoins only one strand of duplex DNA, and it is especially important during transcription. By resolving transcription-associated torsional stress, Top1 reduces the accumulation of genome-destabilizing R-loops and non-B DNA structures. The DNA nicking activity of Top1, however, can also initiate genome instability in the form of illegitimate recombination, homologous recombination and mutagenesis. In this review, we focus on the diverse, and often opposing, roles of Top1 in regulating eukaryotic genome stability.

Portion mismatch in duplex oligonucleotides as inhibitors of bacterial topoisomerase I

The activities of bacterial topoisomerase I can be modulated by non-perfect match duplex oligonucleotides.

Real-Time Label-Free Direct Electronic Monitoring of Topoisomerase Enzyme Binding Kinetics on Graphene

Monolayer graphene field-effect sensors operating in liquid have been widely deployed for detecting a range of analyte species often under equilibrium conditions. Here we report on the real-time detection of the binding kinetics of the essential human enzyme, topoisomerase I interacting with substrate molecules (DNA probes) that are immobilized electrochemically on to monolayer graphene strips. By monitoring the field-effect characteristics of the graphene biosensor in real-time during the enzyme-substrate interactions, we are able to decipher the surface binding constant for the cleavage reaction step of topoisomerase I activity in a label-free manner. Moreover, an appropriate design of the capture probes allows us to distinctly follow the cleavage step of topoisomerase I functioning in real-time down to picomolar concentrations. The presented results are promising for future rapid screening of drugs that are being evaluated for regulating enzyme activity.

Real-time investigation of human topoisomerase I reaction kinetics using an optical sensor: a fast method for drug screening and determination of active enzyme concentrations

Human DNA topoisomerase I (hTopI) is a nuclear enzyme that catalyzes relaxation of super helical tension that arises in the genome during essential DNA metabolic processes. This is accomplished through a common reaction mechanism shared among the type IB topoisomerase enzymes, including eukaryotic and poxvirus topoisomerase I. The mechanism of hTopI is specifically targeted in cancer treatment using camptothecin derivatives. These drugs convert the hTopI activity into a cellular poison, and hence the cytotoxic effects of camptothecin derivatives correlate with the hTopI activity. Therefore, fast and reliable techniques for high throughput measurements of hTopI activity are of high clinical interest. Here we demonstrate potential applications of a fluorophore-quencher based DNA sensor designed for measurement of hTopI cleavage-ligation activities, which are the catalytic steps affected by camptothecin. The kinetic analysis of the hTopI reaction with the DNA sensor exhibits a characteristic burst profile. This is the result of a two-step ping-pong reaction mechanism, where a fast first reaction, the one creating the signal, is followed by a slower second reaction necessary for completion of the catalytic cycle. Hence, the burst profile holds information about two reactions in the enzymatic mechanism. Moreover, it allows the amount of active enzyme in the reaction to be determined. The presented results pave the way for future high throughput drug screening and the potential of measuring active hTopI concentrations in clinical samples for individualized treatment.

DNA-based sensor for real-time measurement of the enzymatic activity of human topoisomerase I

Sensors capable of quantitative real-time measurements may present the easiest and most accurate way to study enzyme activities. Here we present a novel DNA-based sensor for specific and quantitative real-time measurement of the enzymatic activity of the essential human enzyme, topoisomerase I. The basic design of the sensor relies on two DNA strands that hybridize to form a hairpin structure with a fluorophore-quencher pair. The quencher moiety is released from the sensor upon reaction with human topoisomerase I thus enabling real-time optical measurement of enzymatic activity. The sensor is specific for topoisomerase I even in raw cell extracts and presents a simple mean of following enzyme kinetics using standard laboratory equipment such as a qPCR machine or fluorimeter. Human topoisomerase I is a well-known target for the clinically used anti-cancer drugs of the camptothecin family. The cytotoxic effect of camptothecins correlates directly with the intracellular topoisomerase I activity. We therefore envision that the presented sensor may find use for the prediction of cellular drug response. Moreover, inhibition of topoisomerase I by camptothecin is readily detectable using the presented DNA sensor, suggesting a potential application of the sensor for first line screening for potential topoisomerase I targeting anti-cancer drugs.

[The structure and mechanism of the action of type-IB DNA topoisomerases]

DNA topoisomerases responsible for the superspiralization of genomic DNA participate in almost all vitally important cell processes, including replication, transcription, and recombination, and are essential for normal cell functioning. The present review summarizes published data for type-IB topoisomerases. The results concerning the thermodynamic, structural, and kinetic aspects of the functioning of topoisomerases and the peculiarities of the mechanisms of their action have been analyzed for the first time.

Dumbbell-shaped circular oligonucleotides as inhibitors of human topoisomerase I

A dumbbell-shaped circular oligonucleotide containing topoisomerase I-binding sites and two mismatched base pairs in its sequence has been designed and synthesized. Our further studies demonstrate that this particularly designed oligonucleotide displays an IC(50) value of 9 nM in its inhibition on the activity of human topoisomerase I, a magnitude smaller than that of camptothecin, an anticancer drug currently in clinical use.

Regions within the N-terminal domain of human topoisomerase I exert important functions during strand rotation and DNA binding

The human topoisomerase I N-terminal domain is the only part of the enzyme still not crystallized and the function of this domain remains enigmatical. In the present study, we have addressed the specific functions of individual N-terminal regions of topoisomerase I by characterizing mutants lacking amino acid residues 1-202 or 191-206 or having tryptophane-205 substituted by glycine in a broad variety of in vitro activity assays. As a result of these investigations we find that mutants altered in the region 191-206 distinguished themselves from the wild-type enzyme by a faster strand rotation step, insensitivity towards the anti-cancer drug camptothecin in relaxation and the inability to ligate blunt end DNA fragments. The mutant lacking amino acid residues 1-202 was impaired in blunt end DNA ligation and showed wild-type sensitivity towards camptothecin in relaxation. Taken together, the presented data support a model according to which tryptophane-205 and possibly other residues located between position 191-206 coordinates the restriction of free strand rotation during the topoisomerization step of catalysis. Moreover, tryptophane-205 appears important for the function of the bulk part of the N-terminal domain in direct DNA interaction.

Recombinogenic flap ligation mediated by human topoisomerase I

Aberration of eukaryotic topoisomerase I catalysis leads to potentially recombinogenic pathways by allowing the joining of heterologous DNA strands. Recently, a new ligation pathway (flap ligation) was presented for vaccinia virus topoisomerase I, in which blunt end cleavage complexes ligate the recessed end of duplex acceptors having a single-stranded 3'-tail. This reaction was suggested to play an important role in the repair of topoisomerase I-induced DNA double-strand breaks. Here, we characterize flap ligation mediated by human topoisomerase I. We demonstrate that cleavage complexes containing the enzyme at a blunt end allow invasion of a 3'-acceptor tail matching the scissile strand of the donor, which facilitates ligation of the recessed 5'-hydroxyl end. However, the reaction was strictly dependent on the length of double-stranded DNA of the donor complexes, and longer stretches of base-pairing inhibited strand invasion. The stabilization of the DNA helix was most probably provided by the covalently bound enzyme itself, since deleting the N-terminal domain of human topoisomerase I stimulated flap ligation. We suggest that stabilization of the DNA duplex upon enzyme binding may play an important role during normal topoisomerase I catalysis by preventing undesired strand transfer reactions. For flap ligation to function in a repair pathway, factors other than topoisomerase I, such as helicases, would be necessary to unwind the DNA duplex and allow strand invasion.

Residues within the N-terminal domain of human topoisomerase I play a direct role in relaxation

All eukaryotic forms of DNA topoisomerase I contain an extensive and highly charged N-terminal domain. This domain contains several nuclear localization sequences and is essential for in vivo function of the enzyme. However, so far no direct function of the N-terminal domain in the in vitro topoisomerase I reaction has been reported. In this study we have compared the in vitro activities of a truncated form of human topoisomerase I lacking amino acids 1-206 (p67) with the full-length enzyme (p91). Using these enzyme forms, we have identified for the first time a direct role of residues within the N-terminal domain in modulating topoisomerase I catalysis, as revealed by significant differences between p67 and p91 in DNA binding, cleavage, strand rotation, and ligation. A comparison with previously published studies showing no effect of deleting the first 174 or 190 amino acids of topoisomerase I (Stewart, L., Ireton, G. C., and Champoux, J. J. (1999) J. Biol. Chem. 274, 32950-32960; Bronstein, I. B., Wynne-Jones, A., Sukhanova, A., Fleury, F., Ianoul, A., Holden, J. A., Alix, A. J., Dodson, G. G., Jardillier, J. C., Nabiev, I., and Wilkinson, A. J. (1999) Anticancer Res. 19, 317-327) suggests a pivotal role of amino acids 191-206 in catalysis. Taken together the presented data indicate that at least part(s) of the N-terminal domain regulate(s) enzyme/DNA dynamics during relaxation most probably by controlling non-covalent DNA binding downstream of the cleavage site either directly or by coordinating DNA contacts by other parts of the enzyme.

Topoisomerase I-mediated DNA damage

Topoisomerase I is a ubiquitous and essential enzyme in multicellular organisms. It is involved in multiple DNA transactions including DNA replication, transcription, chromosome condensation and decondensation, and probably DNA recombination. Besides its activity of DNA relaxation necessary to eliminate torsional stresses associated with these processes, topoisomerase I may have other functions related to its interaction with other cellular proteins. Topoisomerase I is the target of the novel anticancer drugs, the camptothecins. Recently a broad range of physiological and environmentally-induced DNA modifications have also been shown to poison topoisomerases. This review summarizes the various factors that enhance or suppress top1 cleavage complexes and discusses the significance of such effects. We also review the different mechanisms that have been proposed for the repair of topoisomerase I-mediated DNA lesions.

Human ARF protein interacts with topoisomerase I and stimulates its activity

The ARF gene (p19(ARF) in mouse and p14(ARF) in man) has become a central actor of the cell cycle regulation process as it participates to the ARF-MDM2-p53 pathway and the Rb-E2F-1 pathway. By use of immunoprecipitation and Western blotting (IP/WB), we now show that ARF physically associates with topoisomerase I (Topo I). ARF-Topo I immune complexes were detected in SF9 insect cells infected with recombinant baculoviruses encoding the two genes as well as in 293 cells that express endogenously these proteins. Preparations of a GST-ARF recombinant protein stimulated the DNA relaxation activity of Topo I but, in contrast, had no effect on the decatenation activity of Topo II. The Topo I stimulation was also detected in cell extracts of SF9 cells expressing both proteins. A confocal microscopy study indicated that part of ARF and Topo I colocalized in the granular component structure of the nucleolus. As a whole, our data indicate that Topo I is a new partner of ARF and suggest that ARF is involved in cell reactions that require Topo I.

Recombinogenic flap ligation pathway for intrinsic repair of topoisomerase IB-induced double-strand breaks

Topoisomerase IB catalyzes recombinogenic DNA strand transfer reactions in vitro and in vivo. Here we characterize a new pathway of topoisomerase-mediated DNA ligation in vitro (flap ligation) in which vaccinia virus topoisomerase bound to a blunt-end DNA joins the covalently held strand to a 5' resected end of a duplex DNA containing a 3' tail. The joining reaction occurs with high efficiency when the sequence of the 3' tail is complementary to that of the scissile strand immediately 5' of the cleavage site. A 6-nucleotide segment of complementarity suffices for efficient flap ligation. Invasion of the flap into the duplex apparently occurs while topoisomerase remains bound to DNA, thereby implying a conformational flexibility of the topoisomerase clamp around the DNA target site. The 3' flap acceptor DNA mimics a processed end in the double-strand-break-repair recombination pathway. Our findings suggest that topoisomerase-induced breaks may be rectified by flap ligation, with ensuing genomic deletions or translocations.

Position-specific trapping of topoisomerase I-DNA cleavage complexes by intercalated benzo[a]- pyrene diol epoxide adducts at the 6-amino group of adenine

DNA topoisomerase I (top1) is the target of potent anticancer agents, including camptothecins and DNA intercalators, which reversibly stabilize (trap) top1 catalytic intermediates (cleavage complexes). The aim of the present study was to define the structural relationship between the site(s) of covalently bound intercalating agents, whose solution conformations in DNA are known, and the site(s) of top1 cleavage. Two diastereomeric pairs of oligonucleotide 22-mers, derived from a sequence used to determine the crystal structure of top1-DNA complexes, were synthesized. One pair contained either a trans-opened 10R- or 10S-benzo[a]pyrene 7, 8-diol 9,10-epoxide adduct at the N(6)-amino group of a central 2'-deoxyadenosine residue in the scissile strand, and the other pair contained the same two adducts in the nonscissile strand. These adducts were derived from the (+)-(7R,8S,9S,10R)- and (-)-(7S,8R,9R, 10S)-7,8-diol 9,10-epoxides in which the benzylic 7-hydroxyl group and the epoxide oxygen are trans. On the basis of analogy with known solution conformations of duplex oligonucleotides containing these adducts, we conclude that top1 cleavage complexes are trapped when the hydrocarbon adduct is intercalated between the base pairs flanking a preexisting top1 cleavage site, or between the base pairs immediately downstream (3' relative to the scissile strand) from this site. We propose a model with the +1 base rotated out of the duplex, and in which the intercalated adduct prevents religation of the corresponding nucleotide at the 5' end of the cleaved DNA. These results suggest mechanisms whereby intercalating agents interfere with the normal function of human top1.

Degradation of DNA topoisomerase I by a novel trypsin-like serine protease in proliferating human T lymphocytes

DNA topoisomerase I (Topo I) contributes to various important biological functions, and its activity is therefore likely regulated in response to different physiological conditions. Increases in both the synthesis and degradation of Topo I were previously shown to accompany phytohemagglutinin stimulation of proliferation in human peripheral T lymphocytes. The mechanism of this degradation of Topo I has now been investigated with both in vivo and in vitro assays. The activity of a nuclear protease that specifically degrades Topo I was induced in proliferating T lymphocytes. The full-length Topo I protein (100 kDa) was sequentially degraded to 97- and 82-kDa fragments both in vivo and in vitro. The initial site of proteolytic cleavage was mapped to the NH(2)-terminal region of the enzyme. The degradation of Topo I in vitro was inhibited by aprotinin or soybean trypsin inhibitor, suggesting that the enzyme responsible is a trypsin-like serine protease. Furthermore, Topo I degradation by this protease was Mg(2+)-dependent. The Topo I-specific protease activity induced during T lymphocytes proliferation was not detected in Jurkat (human T cell leukemia) cells and various other tested human cancer cell lines, possibly explaining why the abundance of Topo I is increased in tumor cells.

Benzo[a]pyrene diol epoxide adducts in DNA are potent suppressors of a normal topoisomerase I cleavage site and powerful inducers of other topoisomerase I cleavages

The catalytic intermediates of DNA topoisomerase I (top1) are cleavage complexes that can relax DNA supercoiling (intramolecular reaction) or mediate recombinations (intermolecular religation). We report here that DNA adducts formed from benzo[a]pyrene bay-region diol epoxides can markedly affect top1 activity. Four oligonucleotide 22-mers of the same sequence were synthesized, each of which contained a stereoisomerically unique benzo[a]pyrene 7, 8-diol 9,10-epoxide adduct at the 2-amino group of a central 2'-deoxyguanosine residue. These four adducts correspond to either cis or trans opening at C-10 of the (+)-(7R, 8S, 9S, 10R)- or (-)-(7S, 8R, 9R, 10S)-7,8-diol 9,10-epoxides. Their solution conformations in duplex DNA (intercalated and minor-groove bound for the cis and trans opened adducts respectively) can be deduced from previous NMR studies. All four adducts completely suppress top1 cleavage activity at the alkylation site and induce the formation of new top1cleavage complexes on both strands of the DNA 3-6 bases away from the alkylation site. The trans opened adduct from the highly carcinogenic (+)-diol epoxide is the most active in inducing top1 cleavage independently of camptothecin, demonstrating that minor groove alkylation can efficiently poison top1. We also found that this isomer of the diol epoxide induces the formation of top1-DNA complexes in mammalian cells, which suggests a possible relationship between induction of top1 cleavage complexes and carcinogenic activity of benzo[a]pyrene diol epoxides.

Mapping of eukaryotic DNA topoisomerase I catalyzed cleavage without concomitant religation in the vicinity of DNA structural anomalies

Sensitive sites for covalent trapping of eukaryotic topoisomerase I at DNA structural anomalies were mapped by a new method using purified enzyme and defined DNA substrates. To insure that the obtained topoisomerase I trapping patterns were not influenced by DNA sequence variations, a single DNA imperfection was placed centrally within a homonucleotide track. Mapping of topoisomerase I-mediated irreversible cleavage sites on homopolymeric DNA substrates containing mismatches showed trapping of the enzyme in several positions in close vicinity of the DNA imperfection, with a strong preference for the 5' junction between the duplex DNA and the base-pairing anomaly. On homopolymeric DNA substrates containing a nick, sites of topoisomerase I-mediated cleavage on the intact strand were located just opposite to the nick and from one to ten nucleotides 5' to the nick. Sites of enzyme-mediated cleavage next to a nick and an immobile single-stranded branch were located 5' to the strand interruption in distances of two to six nucleotides and two to ten nucleotides, respectively. Taken together these findings suggest that covalent trapping of topoisomerase I proceeds at positions adjacent to mismatches, nicks and single-stranded branches, where the cleavage reaction is allowed and the ensuing ligation reaction prevented. In principle, the developed interference method might be of general utility to define topoisomerase-DNA interactions relative to different types of structural anomalies.

The interaction between p53 and DNA topoisomerase I is regulated differently in cells with wild-type and mutant p53

DNA topoisomerase I is a nuclear enzyme involved in transcription, recombination, and DNA damage recognition. Previous studies have shown that topoisomerase I interacts directly with the tumor-suppressor protein p53. p53 is a transcription factor that activates certain genes through binding to specific DNA sequences. We now report that topoisomerase I can be stimulated by both latent and activated wild-type p53 as well as by several mutant and truncated p53 proteins in vitro, indicating that sequence-specific DNA-binding and stimulation of topoisomerase I are distinct properties of p53. These assays also suggest that the binding site for topoisomerase I on p53 is between amino acids 302 and 321. In living cells, the interaction between p53 and topoisomerase I is strongly dependent on p53 status. In MCF-7 cells, which have wild-type p53, the association between the two proteins is tightly regulated in a spatial and temporal manner and takes place only during brief periods of genotoxic stress. In marked contrast, the two proteins are constitutively associated in HT-29 cells, which have mutant p53. These findings have important implications for both cellular stress response and genomic stability, given the ability of topoisomerase I to recognize DNA lesions as well as to cause illegitimate recombination.

Human DNA topoisomerase I-mediated cleavage and recombination of duck hepatitis B virus DNA in vitro

In this study, we report that eukaryotic topoisomerase I (top1) can linearize the open circular DNA of duck hepatitis B virus (DHBV). Using synthetic oligonucleotides mimicking the three-strand flap DR1 region of the DHBV genome, we found that top1 cleaves the DNA plus strand in a suicidal manner, which mimics the linearization of the virion DNA. We also report that top1 can cleave the DNA minus strand at specific sites and can linearize the minus strand via a non-homologous recombination reaction. These results are consistent with the possibility that top1 can act as a DNA endo-nuclease and strand transferase and play a role in the circularization, linearization and possibly integration of viral replication intermediates.

Induction of reversible complexes between eukaryotic DNA topoisomerase I and DNA-containing oxidative base damages. 7, 8-dihydro-8-oxoguanine and 5-hydroxycytosine

We recently showed that abasic sites, uracil mismatches, nicks, and gaps can trap DNA topoisomerase I (top1) when these lesions are introduced in the vicinity of a top1 cleavage site (Pourquier, P., Ueng, L.-M., Kohlhagen, G., Mazumder, A., Gupta, M., Kohn, K. W., and Pommier, Y. (1997) J. Biol. Chem. 272, 7792-7796; Pourquier, P., Pilon, A. A., Kohlhagen, G., Mazumder, A., Sharma, A., and Pommier, Y. (1997) J. Biol. Chem. 26441-26447). In this study, we investigated the effects on top1 of an abundant base damage generated by various oxidative stresses: 7,8-dihydro-8-oxoguanine (8-oxoG). Using purified eukaryotic top1 and oligonucleotides containing the 8-oxoG modification, we found a 3-7-fold increase in top1-mediated DNA cleavage when 8-oxoG was present at the +1 or +2 position relative to the cleavage site. Another oxidative lesion, 5-hydroxycytosine, also enhanced top1 cleavage by 2-fold when incorporated at the +1 position of the scissile strand. 8-oxoG at the +1 position enhanced noncovalent top1 DNA binding and had no detectable effect on DNA religation or on the incision step. top1 trapping by 8-oxoG was markedly enhanced when asparagine adjacent to the catalytic tyrosine was mutated to histidine, suggesting a direct interaction between this residue and the DNA major groove immediately downstream from the top1 cleavage site. Altogether, these results demonstrate that oxidative base lesions can increase top1 binding to DNA and induce top1 cleavage complexes.

Cell death induced by topoisomerase-targeted drugs: more questions than answers

Chemotherapeutic agents that target topoisomerase I and II set into motion a series of biochemical changes that culminate in cell death, but only under some conditions. The realization that stabilization of covalent topoisomerase-DNA complexes is not sufficient to insure cell death has prompted investigators to examine various aspects of the drug-induced death process itself. Several discrete steps along this pathway have been identified, including (a) the processing of stabilized cleavage complexes into frank DNA strand breaks; (b) sensing of the DNA damage, leading to activation of stress-associated signaling pathways and cell cycle arrest; and (c) activation of a preexisting group of enzymes and enzyme precursors, typified by the cysteine-dependent aspartate-directed proteases (caspases), that catalyze the relatively orderly biochemical cascade of terminal events known as apoptosis. The present review discusses the evidence that these steps occur after treatment with etoposide or camptothecin, the two prototypic topoisomerase poisons that are commonly studied. As in any emerging area, a large number of questions remain to be answered about the process of cell death induced by topoisomerase-directed drugs.

Mechanism of action of eukaryotic DNA topoisomerase I and drugs targeted to the enzyme

DNA topoisomerase I is essential for cellular metabolism and survival. It is also the target of a novel class of anticancer drugs active against previously refractory solid tumors, the camptothecins. The present review describes the topoisomerase I catalytic mechanisms with particular emphasis on the cleavage complex that represents the enzyme's catalytic intermediate and the site of action for camptothecins. Roles of topoisomerase I in DNA replication, transcription and recombination are also reviewed. Because of the importance of topoisomerase I as a chemotherapeutic target, we review the mechanisms of action of camptothecins and the other topoisomerase I inhibitors identified to date.

A unified DNA- and dNTP-binding mode for DNA polymerases

Crystal structures of various DNA polymerases show a common structural topology that resembles a right hand and has distinct finger, palm and thumb subdomains. Early models of the klenow fragment (KF) of Escherichia coli polymerase I showed DNA entering a large cleft that faces the palm subdomain where the catalytic site is situated1,2. However, subsequent resolution of the structures of HIV-1 reverse transcriptase, KF and polymerase beta (pol beta) bound to DNA3-5 yielded conflicting data that suggested a different orientation for DNA bound to pol beta compared with DNA bound to other polymerases. The debate, on the correct orientation of the template-primer DNA, that followed failed to reach a consensus. Using an alternative superposition scheme, we now provide convincing evidence for a common DNA-binding mode that is applicable to all polymerases, including pol beta.

Cloning of the TIS gene suppressed by topoisomerase inhibitors

We recently cloned the cDNA TIS (topoisomerase inhibitor-suppressed) in RVC lymphoma cells exposed to the topoisomerase inhibitors. To elucidate the suppression mechanism of the TIS mRNA by camptothecin, we characterized the structures of the TIS gene. The gene spanned about 21 kb including 11 exons and was present as a single copy. The putative transcription site was present 192 bp upstream from the ATG codon. The typical TATA sequence and CCAAT promoter element were located at positions -21 and -81, respectively. The unidirectional deletion analysis of the 5'-flanking region revealed that [-132/+160] is the promoter region, which participates in the responsiveness to camptothecin. A Northern blot analysis showed that the TIS was expressed in most mouse tissues; at the highest level in the liver and to less extent in the heart and skeletal muscle. The present study showed that the expression of the TIS is suppressed at the transcriptional level by camptothecin. Considering that topoisomerase I is an essential enzyme in mammalian cells, the TIS protein may have an important role in camptothecin toxicity.

DNA duplexes containing 3'-deoxynucleotides as substrates for DNA topoisomerase I cleavage and ligation

The DNA cleavage-ligation reaction of DNA topoisomerase I was investigated employing synthetic DNA substrates containing 3'-deoxyadenosine or 3'-deoxythymidine at specific sites and acceptor oligonucleotides of different lengths. The modified nucleotides were substituted systematically within the putative enzyme-binding domain and also next to the high efficiency cleavage site to determine the effect of single base changes on enzyme function. Depending on the site of substitution, the facility of the cleavage and ligation reactions were altered. The bases at positions -1 and -2 on the noncleaved strand were found to be important for determining the site of cleavage. Inclusion of 3'-deoxythymidine in the scissile strand at position -1 permitted the demonstration that topoisomerase I can cleave and form a 2' --> 5'-phosphodiester linkage. Partial duplexes doubly modified at positions -4 or -6 in the noncleaved strand and at positions +1 or -1 within scissile strand were not good substrates for topoisomerase I, showing that cleavage can depend importantly on binding interactions based on structural alterations at spatially separated sites. Substitution of a 3'-deoxynucleotide on the scissile strand at position -6 enhanced formation of the ligation product resulting from cleavage at site 1 and suppressed cleavage at site 2.

Site-specific ribonuclease activity of eukaryotic DNA topoisomerase I

Type I topoisomerases alter DNA topology by cleaving and rejoining one strand of duplex DNA through a covalent protein-DNA intermediate. Here we show that vaccinia topoisomerase, a eukaryotic type IB enzyme, catalyzes site-specific endoribonucleolytic cleavage of an RNA-containing strand. The RNase reaction occurs via transesterification at the scissile ribonucleotide to form a covalent RNA-3'-phosphoryl-enzyme intermediate, which is then attacked by the vicinal 2' OH of the ribose sugar to yield a free 2', 3' cyclic phosphate product. Introduction of a single ribonucleoside at the scissile phosphate of an otherwise all-DNA substrate suffices to convert the topoisomerase into an endonuclease. Human topoisomerase I also has endoribonuclease activity. These findings suggest potential roles for topoisomerases in RNA processing.

Trapping of mammalian topoisomerase I and recombinations induced by damaged DNA containing nicks or gaps. Importance of DNA end phosphorylation and camptothecin effects

We used purified mammalian topoisomerases I (top1) and oligonucleotides containing a unique top1 cleavage site to study top1-mediated cleavage and recombination in the presence of nicks and short gaps mimicking DNA damage. In general, top1 cleavage was not induced opposite to the nicks, and nicks upstream from the top1 cleavage site suppressed top1 activity. Irreversible top1 cleavage complexes ("suicide products" or "aborted complexes") were produced in DNA containing nicks or short gaps just opposite to the normal top1 cleavage site. Camptothecin enhanced the formation of the aborted top1 complexes only for nicks downstream from the cleavage site. These aborted (suicide) complexes can mediate DNA recombination and promote illegitimate recombination by catalyzing the ligation of nonhomologous DNA fragments (acceptors). We report for the first time that top1-mediated recombination is greatly enhanced by the presence of a phosphate at the 5' terminus of the top1 aborted complex (donor DNA). By contrast, phosphorylation of the 3' terminus of the gap did not affect recombination. At concentrations that strongly enhanced inhibition of intramolecular religation, resulting in an increase of top1 cleavable complexes, camptothecin did not reduce recombination (intermolecular religation). Nicks or gaps with 5'-phosphate termini would be expected to be produced directly by ionizing radiations or by processing of abasic sites and DNA lesions induced by carcinogens or drugs used in cancer chemotherapy. Thus, these results further demonstrate that DNA damage can efficiently trap top1-cleavable complexes and enhance top1-mediated DNA recombination.

Reconstitution of human topoisomerase I by fragment complementation

Human topoisomerase I (topo I, 91 kDa) is composed of four major domains; the unconserved and highly charged "N-terminal" domain (24 kDa), the conserved "core" domain (54 kDa), a poorly conserved and positively charged "linker" region (5 kDa), and the highly conserved "C-terminal" domain (8 kDa) which contains the active site tyrosine at position 723. Here we demonstrate that human topo I activity can be reconstituted by mixing a 58 kDa recombinant core domain (residues Lys175 to Ala659) with any one of a series of recombinant C-terminal fragments that range in size from 12 kDa (linker and C-terminal domains, residues Leu658 to Phe765) to 6.3 kDa (C-terminal domain residues Gln713 to Phe765). The C-terminal fragments bind tightly to the core domain, forming a 1:1 complex that is stable irrespective of ionic strength (0.01 to 1 M). The reconstituted enzymes are active only over a relatively narrow range of salt concentrations (25 to 200 mM KCl) as compared to the intact topo70 enzyme (missing the N-terminal domain). Under physiological conditions (150 mM KCl and 10 mM Mg2+) they are much more distributive in their mode of action than topo70. The reconstituted enzyme binds DNA with an affinity that is approximately 20-fold lower than that of the intact topo70. In addition, the cleavage/religation equilibrium of the reconstituted enzyme appears to be biased towards religation relative to that of the intact enzyme. Despite differences in the cleavage/religation equilibrium and affinity for DNA, the reconstituted and intact enzymes have identical sequence specificities for the cleavage of duplex DNA or suicide cleavage of oligonucleotide substrates.

The effect of camptothecin on topoisomerase I catalysis

The existence of a covalent intermediate in topoisomerase I catalysis allows uncoupling of the cleavage and ligation half-reactions on partially single-stranded DNA substrates containing a highly preferred interaction site. Using this model DNA substrate system we have demonstrated that the cleavage reaction requires bipartite interaction with two distinct DNA duplex regions; One located around the cleavage site (region A) and another located on the side holding the 5'-OH end generated by cleavage (region B). The postcleavage complexes containing the enzyme covalently attached at an internal position are capable of ligating DNA strands matching the noncleaved strand. Previously, we have characterized the effect of the antitumor agent camptothecin on the two half-reactions of topoisomerase I catalysis on DNA substrates allowing bipartite DNA interaction. The obtained results demonstrated that the drug only inhibited the ligation reaction leaving the cleavage reaction unaffected at the studied site. Here, we report that camptothecin also impairs ligation of the cleaved strand to a dinucleotide within region A in the absence of additional DNA contacts. When these results are taken together with the observation that camptothecin-trapped topoisomerase I-DNA complexes preferentially are generated at sites containing guanine immediately 3' to the cleavage position, it suggests that camptothecin inhibits the ligation reaction by forming a reversible ternary complex with the enzyme and DNA at the cleavage site within region A.

Covalent DNA binding by vaccinia topoisomerase results in unpairing of the thymine base 5' of the scissile bond

We have used potassium permanganate to probe contacts between vaccinia DNA topoisomerase and thymine residues in its 5'-CCCTT downward arrow DNA target site. Two major conclusions emerge from the experiments presented: (i) permanganate oxidation of the +2T base of the scissile strand interferes with topoisomerase binding to DNA, and (ii) the +1T base of the scissile strand becomes unpaired upon formation of the covalent topoisomerase-DNA intermediate. Disruption of T:A base pairing is confined to the +1-position. Covalently bound DNAs that have experienced this structural distortion (such DNAs being marked by oxidation at +1T) are fully capable of being religated. We suggest that a protein-induced DNA conformational change is a component of the strand passage step of the topoisomerase reaction.

The domain organization of human topoisomerase I

Using limited proteolysis, we show that the domain boundaries of human topoisomerase I closely parallel those predicted from sequence comparisons with other cellular Topo I enzymes. The enzyme is comprised of (i) an NH2-terminal domain (approximately 24 kDa), which is known to be dispensable for activity, (ii) the core domain (approximately 54 kDa), (iii) a linker region (approximately 3 kDa), and (iv) the COOH-terminal domain (approximately 10 kDa), which contains the active site tyrosine. The highly conserved core and COOH-terminal domains are resistant to proteolysis, while the unconserved NH2-terminal and linker domains are sensitive. Noncovalent binding of Topo I to plasmid DNA or to short duplex oligonucleotides decreases the sensitivity of the linker to proteolysis by approximately a factor of 10 but has no effect on proteolysis of the NH2-terminal domain. When the enzyme is covalently complexed to an 18 base pair single-stranded oligonucleotide, the linker region is sensitive to proteolysis whether or not duplex DNA is present. The net positive charge of the linker domain suggests that at a certain point in catalysis the linker may bind directly to DNA. Further, we show that limited subtilisin cleavage can generate a mixture of 60-kDa core and approximately 10-kDa COOH-terminal fragments, which retain a level of topoisomerase activity that is nearly equal to undigested control samples, presumably because the two fragments remain associated after proteolytic cleavage. Thus, despite its potential role in DNA binding, the linker domain (in addition to the NH2-terminal domain) appears to be dispensable for topoisomerase activity. Finally, the limited proteolysis pattern of the human enzyme differs substantially from the limited proteolysis pattern of the vaccinia viral Topo I, indicating that the two enzymes belong to separate eukaryotic topoisomerase I subfamilies.

Purification and characterization of human topoisomerase I mutants

A system for rapid purification and characterization of eukaryotic topoisomerase-I mutants has been developed. The system utilizes six-histidine tagging of human topoisomerase I expressed in Saccharomyces cerevisiae to enable purification by nickel-affinity chromatography. Virtually homogenous mutant proteins are then tested for their ability to relax supercoiled DNA plasmids and their capacity for binding, cleaving and religating short defined DNA substrates. Relaxation-deficient mutants were obtained by site-directed mutagenesis of selected highly conserved amino acids. The mutants Tyr723Phe (active site mutation), Arg488Gln and Lys532Glu were inert in relaxation of DNA, whereas Lys720Glu showed a 50-fold reduction in specific relaxation activity. Accordingly, only Lys720Glu showed low, but detectable cleavage activity on suicide DNA substrates, uncoupling the cleavage and religation events of topoisomerase I. The relative religation efficiency of Lys720Glu comparable to that of wild-type topoisomerase I, indicating that Lys720 is involved in interactions important for normal DNA cleavage, but not for the religation reaction. All mutants could be cross linked by ultraviolet light to bromo-dUTP-substituted DNA oligonucleotides carrying a topoisomerase-I-binding site, indicating that the deficiency of Tyr723Phe, Arg488Gln and Lys532Glu in DNA relaxation and cleavage is not due to an inability of these mutants to bind DNA non-covalently.

DNA recombinase activity of eukaryotic DNA topoisomerase I; effects of camptothecin and other inhibitors

DNA oligonucleotides containing a strong topoisomerase I cleavage site were used to study the DNA cleavage and strand transferase activities of calf thymus topoisomerase I (top1) in the absence and presence of camptothecin. A partially single-stranded oligonucleotide with only two nucleotides on the 3' side of the cleavage site (positions +1 and +2) was cleaved at the same position as the corresponding duplex oligonucleotide. However, cleavage in the absence of camptothecin was more pronounced than in the duplex oligonucleotide and was only partially reversible in the presence of 0.5 M NaCl, consistent with release of the dinucleotide 3' to the top1 break. Another reaction took place generating a larger DNA fragment which resulted from religation (strand transfer) of the 5'-hydroxyl terminus of the non-scissile DNA strand to the 3' end of the top1-linked oligonucleotide after loss of the +1 and +2 nucleotides. Top1 religation activity appeared efficient since only the last 5' base of the single-stranded DNA acceptor was complementary to the 3' tail of the donor DNA. Religation was not detectable with a double-stranded DNA acceptor, which is consistent with the persistence of top1-induced DNA double-strand breaks in camptothecin-treated cells. Camptothecin and other top1 inhibitors enhanced cleavage in both the partially single-stranded and the duplex oligonucleotides, indicating that they did not inhibit the induction of top1-mediated DNA cleavage but primarily blocked the religation step of the enzyme catalytic cycle. The top1 DNA strand transferase activity was reversibly inhibited by camptothecin and several derivatives, as well as saintopin. These results are discussed in terms of camptothecin-induced DNA recombinations.