Improved survival in management of empyema thoracis

A Global Bibliometric Analysis of the Top 100 Most Cited Articles on Early Thoracotomy and Decortication in Pleural Empyema

Most pleural empyema cases are linked to pneumonia, a substantial fraction of patients present with empyema without any association to pneumonia. The occurrence of empyema caused by tuberculosis (TB) is increasing in regions where TB is prevalent. In May 2024, a bibliometric analysis was conducted involving the screening of 7,620 articles sourced from Google Scholar. Google Scholar was selected for its comprehensive nature, encompassing articles indexed in prominent databases like Web of Science, Scopus, and PubMed. This allowed access to significant studies that might be overlooked if they were not indexed by these databases. Articles were selected based on their citation count and specific inclusion criteria, focusing on early thoracotomy and decortication in pleural empyema. Two authors (VB and MK) independently conducted a thorough screening and data collection. The hundred top articles published from 1945 to 2015, garnered a total of 16,928 citations. These articles were written by 93 distinct first authors from 22 countries and 83 institutions, and were featured in 35 journals. The primary categories of literature included those describing the disease characteristics, features, causes, and types of pleural empyema, as well as various treatment modalities and management strategies, each constituting 37% of the literature. Additionally, pediatric empyema was a focus in 11% of the articles. The present analysis highlights publication trends, identifies gaps in the literature, and suggests areas for future research, serving as a valuable resource for guiding upcoming studies on early thoracotomy and decortication in pleural empyema.

Recent developments in the management of pleural infection: A comprehensive review

OBJECTIVES

Pleural infection is a condition commonly encountered by the respiratory physician. This review aims to provide the reader with an update on the most recent data regarding the epidemiology, microbiology, and the management of pleural infection.

DATA SOURCE

Medline was searched for articles related to pleural infection using the terms "pleural infection," "empyema," and "parapneumonic." The search was limited to the years 1997-2017. Only human studies and reports in English were included.

RESULTS

A rise in the incidence of pleural infection is seen worldwide. Despite the improvement in healthcare practices, the mortality from pleural infection remains high. The role of oral microflora in the etiology of pleural infection is firmly established. A concise review of the recent insights on the pathogenesis of pleural infections is presented. A particular focus is made on the role of tPA, DNAse and similar substances and their interaction with inflammatory cells and how this affects the pathogenesis and treatment of pleural infection.

CONCLUSION

Pleural infection is a common disease with significant morbidity and mortality, as well as a considerable economic burden. The role of medical management is expanding thanks to the widespread use of newer treatments.

How important are anaerobic bacteria in aspiration pneumonia: when should they be treated and what is optimal therapy

Anaerobic bacteria are infrequent pulmonary pathogens, and, even then they are, they are almost never recovered due to the need for specimens uncontaminated by the upper airway flora and failure to do adequate anaerobic bacteriology. These bacteria are relatively common in selected types of lung infections including aspiration pneumonia, lung abscess, necrotizing pneumonia and emphyema. Preferred antibiotics for these infections based on clinical experience are clindamycin and any betalactam-betalactamase inhibitor.

Clinical background of cases showing a positive culture of pleural effusion at Shin-Kokura Hospital over a period of 5 years

We investigated the clinical background of patients at Shin-Kokura Hospital who showed a positive culture of pleural effusion during the period from January 1998 through December 2002. Microorganism cultures of the pleural effusions of 127 patients were performed in this 5-year period. Seventeen patients showed a positive microorganism culture from a pleural effusion, and 12 of these patients (70.6%) were 60 years old or more. Ten patients were diagnosed with thoracic empyema. Thirteen patients had an underlying disease such as malignancy (5 cases), diabetes mellitus (4 cases), etc. A purulent effusion and a high concentration of lactic dehydrogenase (LDH) in the pleural fluid were more frequently recognized in the positive-culture group. A total of 21 strains of microorganism were isolated from the 17 patients, including 10 strains of Gram-positive cocci, 6 strains of Gram-negative bacilli, 3 strains of anaerobes, 1 strain of mycobacterium (Mycobacterium tuberculosis), and 1 strain of fungus. Susceptibility to antimicrobial agents was generally good for most of the microorganisms isolated. Of the 17 patients, chest-tube drainage was performed in 13, and 6 needed a surgical operation. Twelve patients improved, but 5 died. In this study, thoracic empyema accounted for 58.8% of the 17 cases with a positive culture of pleural effusion. Of the 10 thoracic empyema patients, 5 patients needed surgical treatment in spite of adequate antimicrobial treatment and chest-tube drainage. Our data indicate that thoracic empyema is still difficult to treat, and thus adequate and rapid treatment is needed for any pleural infection.

Incidência de empiema pleural nos ferimentos tóraco-abdominais

OBJETIVO: Os ferimentos penetrantes com comprometimento simultâneo das cavidades torácica e abdominal (FTA), além da dificuldade diagnóstica, merecem especial atenção em relação à conduta adotada para o tratamento do espaço pleural. O objetivo do presente estudo foi identificar os principais fatores relacionados à incidência de empiema pleural em pacientes com ferimentos penetrantes localizados na transição toracoabdominal. MÉTODO: Utilizando-se o modelo estatístico de regressão logística múltipla, os autores analisaram 110 pacientes com ferida toracoabdominal penetrante, submetidos à drenagem pleural fechada e laparotomia. A complicação empiema pleural foi estudada quanto à incidência e fatores envolvidos. Considerou-se o nível alfa igual a 0,05. RESULTADOS: Do total, 91 (82,7%) pacientes eram do sexo masculino e 19 (17,3%) do feminino. A faixa etária situou-se entre 13 e 63 anos. Os FTA foram causados por projétil de arma de fogo em 60 casos (54,5%) e por arma branca em 50 casos (45,5%). O empiema pleural incidiu em quatro (3,6%) dos pacientes estudados. Na análise estatística a incidência de empiema pleural esteve relacionada com: lesão de víscera oca (OR=3,1386, p=0.4005); lesão do lado esquerdo do diafragma (OR= 12,98, p=0,1178) e choque hemorrágico à admissão (OR=23,9639, p=0,0250). CONCLUSÕES: A chance da ocorrência de empiema pleural foi cerca de três vezes maior em pacientes com lesão de víscera oca e, de 13 vezes se a esta lesão estava associada à lesão do lado esquerdo do diafragma; aumentando para 24 vezes se estes pacientes apresentavam, concomitantemente, estado de choque hemorrágico à admissão.

Is open thoracotomy still a good treatment option for the management of empyema in children?

BACKGROUND

The incidence of pediatric postpneumonic empyema increases, and there is little consensus on its management. Open thoracotomy has been linked with high morbidity and prolonged hospitalization. Our aim was to review the outcome after open thoracotomy and to provide a set of data for comparison with other treatment modalities.

METHODS

Forty-four children (median age, 8 years, 2 months to 16 years) undergoing surgery for postpneumonic empyema between 1993 and 2002 in our unit were studied.

RESULTS

The median time from onset of symptoms to admission in a pediatric unit was 8 days (range, 2 to 63 days), the median time from pediatric admission to surgical referral was 3 days (range, 0 to 19 days), and the median time from surgical admission to thoracotomy was 1 day (range, 0 to 2 days). Eight children had a chest drain before surgical admission. Six patients, who were referred late (19 to 69 days), had lung abscesses. A limited muscle sparing thoracotomy (44 patients), formal decortication (36 patients), lung debridement (5 patients), and lobectomy (1 patient) were performed. After thoracotomy, median time to apyrexia was 1 day (range, 0 to 27 days) and drain removal was 3 days (range, 1 to 16 days). A pathogen was isolated in 21 patients. There were no deaths. Four children with abscesses remained septic and had lobectomies (2 patients) and debridements (2 patients). The median postoperative hospital stay was 5 to 53 days. One child had postpneumonic empyema develop and had decortication 3 months postoperatively. At follow-up, all children were doing well and had satisfactory radiographs. The Kaplan-Meier 5-year and 10-year survival rate, freedom from any reoperation, and freedom from hospital readmission were 100%, 87%, and 98%, respectively.

CONCLUSIONS

Open thoracotomy remains an excellent option for management of stage II-III empyema in children. When open thoracotomy is performed in a timely manner there is low morbidity and it provides rapid resolution of symptoms with a short hospital stay. However, delayed referrals may result in advanced pulmonary sepsis and a protracted clinical course. The late results are encouraging. Use of thoracoscopy or fibrinolysis should be considered on the basis of their own merit, not on the assumption of probable adverse outcomes after thoracotomy.

Incidência de empiema pleural no trauma isolado do tórax com e sem uso da antibioticoterapia

OBJETIVO: O objetivo do presente estudo foi avaliar a incidência de empiema pós-drenagem pleural fechada, nos pacientes com lesão isolada do tórax, com e sem uso da antibioticoterapia associada. MÉTODO: Utilizando o modelo estatístico de acompanhamento de coortes, os autores analisaram 167 pacientes acometidos por lesão traumática do tórax. Dois grupos foram selecionados para o estudo. O grupo controle incluiu 104 (62,3%) pacientes sem uso da antibioticoterapia e, no grupo experimental, 63 (37,7%) pacientes receberam a cefalotina sódica no pós-operatório (500mg IV - 6/6h). RESULTADOS: Entre os pacientes estudados, 12 (7,2%) apresentavam trauma fechado; 98 (58,7%), ferimento por arma branca; 41 (24,6%) ferida por projétil de arma de fogo e 16 (9,5%) lesões por outros agentes vulnerantes. Entre os pacientes do grupo controle o tempo médio de permanência hospitalar foi de 5,7±3,2 dias e, no grupo com antibiótico, 5,7±2,9 dias. Os resultados mostraram que oito (4,7%) pacientes evoluíram com quadro de empiema pleural, sendo sete (6,7%) casos no grupo controle e apenas um (1,5%) no grupo experimental (p=0,26). O hemotórax coagulado foi a complicação não infecciosa mais freqüente, incidindo em 21 (12,5%) pacientes. CONCLUSÃO: No presente estudo, os resultados mostram que o uso da antibioticoterapia não se mostrou eficaz em diminuir a incidência de empiema pleural nos pacientes submetidos à drenagem pleural pós-traumática.

Empyema and Restrictive Pleural Processes after Blunt Trauma: An Under-Recognized Cause of Respiratory Failure

Respiratory failure is a common complication among patients sustaining major blunt trauma. This is usually due to the underlying pulmonary injury, pneumonia, or adult respiratory distress syndrome. However, we have frequently found these patients to actually have a pleural process as the cause of their respiratory failure. Our objective was to assess the frequency of empyema and restrictive pleural processes after blunt trauma and their contribution to respiratory failure. We retrospectively reviewed all blunt trauma patients over a 5-year period who required a thoracotomy and decortication for empyema. Twenty-eight patients with blunt trauma required a thoracotomy and decortication for empyema. The most common finding was infected, loculated hemothorax/effusion in 23 patients, whereas 5 had an associated pneumonia. Chest radiographs were nondiscriminating, whereas CT scans in 25 patients showed previously unrecognized fluid collections, air-fluid levels, or gas bubbles. Neither thoracentesis nor placement of additional chest tubes was helpful. Positive cultures were uncommon. Ventilator dependence was present preoperatively in 13 patients who were on the ventilator an average of 13 days preoperatively and only 5.8 days postoperatively. Several patients believed to have adult respiratory distress syndrome were weaned within 72 hours of operation. All patients were ultimately cured. Empyema is an under-recognized complication of blunt trauma and may contribute to respiratory failure and ventilator dependence. Although difficult to diagnose, empyema should be considered in blunt trauma patients with respiratory failure and an abnormal chest radiograph. CT aids in the diagnosis, and the results of surgical treatment are excellent.

Predictors of outcome and long-term survival in patients with pleural infection

In pleural infection, medical treatment failure (chest-tube drainage and antibiotics) requires surgery and increases mortality. It would be helpful to predict which patients will fail this approach. We examined clinical predictors in 85 consecutive patients with pleural infection receiving chest drainage and intrapleural fibrinolytics, and recorded age, length of history, antibiotic delay and choice, time to drainage, blood/pleural fluid (PF) bacteriology, PF pH, lactate dehydrogenase (LDH), glucose and appearance, effusion size, pleural thickness on computed tomographic (CT) scan, and survival from time of drainage. Failures (surgery/death) were compared with successes. There were 13 (15%) medical failures. PF purulence was more frequent in medical failures (10 of 13 versus 29 of 72 successes, p < 0.02 chi-square). Absence of purulence was a useful predictor of success (positive predictive value [PPV] 93%). Purulence was not useful in predicting medical failure (PPV 26%). There was a trend for positive blood culture to predict failure (5 of 13 failures versus 11 of 72 successes, p = 0.05 chi-square), but no significant differences in other endpoints. Twelve (14%) patients died in follow-up, all with comorbidity within 400 d after drainage. Probability of survival at 4 yr was 86%. Of endpoints considered in this study, PF purulence was the only useful predictor of outcome with medical therapy in pleural infection. There is good long-term survival from pleural infection.

Surgical treatment of pleural empyema--changing priorities

The surgical management of pleural empyema and post-traumatic clotted haemothorax is described. The study included 15 cases of post-thoracotomy empyema, 23 of empyema of other aetiology and five of post-traumatic haemothorax. Chest-tube drainage was the first measure in most cases. Post-pneumonectomy empyema was treated with partial thoracoplasty plus omentoplasty (8 cases) or plus myoplasty (1 case). Empyema after lobectomy or bilobectomy (4 cases) or after failed decortication (1 case) was managed with thoracoplasty or, in cases of concomitant wound infection, with open-window thoracostomy followed by thoracoplasty. Empyema after subclavian artery reconstruction (1 case) was cleared by removal of a previously unrecognized foreign body. For early empyema of other aetiology or haemothorax (10 cases in total), treatment comprised debridement by video-assisted thoracoscopic surgery (VATS). VATS was also used to establish suitable pleural drainage prior to elective thoracotomy (2 cases). Decortication and partial parietal pleurectomy were performed for organizing-stage empyema (16 cases). Three of the 15 patients with post-thoracotomy empyema died perioperatively, one died two months postoperatively and one had recurrence of bronchopleural fistula during follow-up. One patient with VATS debridement subsequently required thoracotomy and lobectomy for lung abscess. All the others with VATS or decortication recovered without complications. During follow-up there was no mortality or recurrence of empyema.

Predicting factors for outcome of tube thoracostomy in complicated parapneumonic effusion for empyema

STUDY OBJECTIVES

To determine the predicting factors for outcome of tube thoracostomy in patients with complicated parapneumonic effusion (CPE) or empyema.

DESIGN AND SETTINGS

Retrospective chart review over a 55-month period at a tertiary referred medical center.

PATIENTS AND MEASUREMENTS

The medical charts of patients with empyema or CPE were reviewed. Data including age, gender, clinical symptoms, important underlying diseases, leukocyte count, duration of preadmission symptoms, interval from first procedure to second procedure, the time from first procedure to discharge (recovery time), the amount of effusion drained, administration of intrapleural streptokinase, chest tube size and position, loculation of pleural effusion, and characteristics and culture results of pleural effusion were recorded and compared between groups of patients with successful and failed outcome of tube thoracostomy drainage.

RESULTS

One hundred twenty-one patients were selected for study. One hundred of these patients had received tube thoracostomy drainage with 53 successful outcomes and 47 failed outcomes of chest tube drainage. Nineteen patients received decortication directly, and the other two received antibiotics alone. Univariate analysis showed that pleural effusion leukocyte count, effusion amount, and loculation of pleural effusion were significantly related to the outcome of chest tube drainage. Multiple logistic regression analysis demonstrated that loculation and pleural effusion leukocyte count < or = 6,400/uL were the only independent predicting factors related to failure of tube thoracostomy drainage.

CONCLUSIONS

Loculation and pleural effusion leukocyte count < or = 6,400/microL were independent predicting factors of poor outcome of tube thoracostomy drainage. These results suggest that if the initial attempt at chest tube drainage fails, early surgical intervention should be considered in good surgical candidates with loculated empyema or pleural effusion with leukocyte count < or = 6,400/microL.

Real-time CT fluoroscopy: usefulness in thoracic drainage

OBJECTIVE

The purpose of our study was to review the application of real-time CT fluoroscopy in the drainage of localized pleural and mediastinal collections.

SUBJECTS AND METHODS

Between July 1996 and August 1997, 20 patients with 10 loculated pleural effusions, two mediastinal fluid collections, and 12 focal pneumothoraces were treated using CT fluoroscopy. The patient population was 25-77 years old and included 14 men and six women. Methods of drainage included using a modified Seldinger technique with a guidewire and serial dilators in 10 patients and a single-stick trocar technique in the remaining 14. Total room time, procedure time, and CT fluoroscopy time were recorded.

RESULTS

All 24 collections were successfully evacuated using either real-time or interrupted real-time CT fluoroscopy. The real-time capability of CT fluoroscopy proved particularly useful for rapid placement of drainage tubes in patients who were unable to cooperate with breathing instructions and in patients who had a narrow window of access. Average total room time was 65 min. Average procedure time was 32 min, and average CT fluoroscopy time was 143 sec.

CONCLUSION

CT fluoroscopy permits rapid drainage of intrathoracic collections. CT fluoroscopy is a particularly useful treatment for patients who are unable to perform breath-holding or in whom access to the drainage site is difficult.

Thoracoscopy in the management of pediatric empyema

The surgical management of empyema consists of (1) aggressive therapy with thoracotomy and decortication or (2) conservative treatment with chest tube drainage and intravenous antibiotics. Recently, Kern and Rodgers introduced thoracoscopic debridement as an adjunct to the management of children with empyema, with promising results. Hence, the authors report their experience with thoracoscopy in the management of pediatric patients with empyema. In the last years, 10 children have undergone thoracoscopic debridement (TD) for empyema. The average age was 6.9 years (range, 2 to 16). Children underwent TD an average of 14 days (range, 8 to 16) after initial presentation and 4 days (range, 2 to 6) after admission to the authors' hospital. Indications for TD were persistent requirement of supplemental oxygen and failure of conservative medical management that consisted of antibiotics and tube thoracostomy. Three children had positive pleural fluid cultures for Streptococcus pneumoniae. In all cases, preoperative ultrasound or chest computed tomography examination showed dense pleural fluid with septation. During surgery, TD allowed for lung expansion and precise chest tube placement in all patients except one who required conversion to minithoracotomy and decortication for persistent encasement with a thick pleural peel. There were no postoperative complications related to the procedure. After TD, all children had prompt clinical improvement. The patients were weaned from supplemental oxygen by postoperative day 2, and following early chest tube removal, nine children were discharged home by postoperative day 7 (range, 3 to 10). One child required further hospitalization for underlying renal failure. In the authors' hands, TD was effective in producing prompt clinical improvement in children with empyema.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Guided percutaneous drainage for posttraumatic empyema thoracis

BACKGROUND

Guided percutaneous drainage (GPD) is used in the management of posttraumatic empyema thoracis; however, its equivalence to decortication has not been evaluated.

METHODS

We retrospectively reviewed the records of 12 patients who underwent GPD and nine who were treated with decortication.

RESULTS

No primarily GPD-managed empyemas necessitated a subsequent thoracotomy. The size and number of fibrinopurulent loculations treated by each technique were equivalent. Sterile purulent collections were found in 55.6% of decortication-treated patients and in 33% of patients who underwent GPD. Intrapleural analgesia was administered to 71.4% of decortication-treated patients and 28.6% of GPD-treated patients. Five patients undergoing decortication required intensive care unit monitoring after operation (average, 2.8 days), compared with no GPD-treated patients. The catheter was left in place at discharge in 41.6% of GPD-treated patients and was removed on an outpatient basis.

CONCLUSIONS

The efficacy of GPD in handling loculated pleural space infections equals that of decortication. An intensive care unit stay is avoided. The ability to discharge patients with external drainage catheters and the decreased requirement of pain control should reduce the number of inpatient hospital days. GPD is an effective first-line approach for posttraumatic empyema thoracis.

Interventional chest radiology

Radiologically guided percutaneous drainage procedures are commonly performed to manage a variety of intrathoracic collections. As a natural extension of similar procedures performed for abdominal and pelvic collections, these procedures use both the conventional and cross-sectional imaging modalities to detect intrathoracic collections and to guide safe percutaneous diagnostic aspiration and drainage. The high-resolution images obtainable on current computed tomographic and ultrasound units allow detection of lung abscesses, empyemas, malignant effusions, and infected mediastinal fluid collections that are amenable to percutaneous drainage. Advances in catheter design and introduction techniques have allowed drainage of collections previously managed by open procedures. The ease of fluoroscopically guided catheter placement for treatment of spontaneous or biopsy-induced pneumothorax has provided a safe, effective, and comfortable alternative to blind large-bore surgical tube placement. Transthoracic needle biopsy of lung, mediastinal, and pleural or chest-wall masses has resulted from the availability of image intensifiers and cross-sectional imaging modalities useful in guiding needle placement and tissue sampling. Equally important has been the development of cytopathology as a subspecialty that can provide diagnoses of malignant and benign thoracic conditions from needle aspirates. This technique has had a major impact on the preoperative evaluation of the patient with a solitary pulmonary nodule and has eliminated unnecessary surgery in a significant percentage of such patients. Transcatheter arterial embolization has made a significant contribution to the management of the patient with massive hemoptysis and is the procedure of choice for treatment of pulmonary arteriovenous malformations. A thorough knowledge of the vascular anatomy of the thorax and expertise in catheterization and embolization techniques are prerequisites for the safe performance of these procedures.

Empyema thoracis: a review of a 4 1/2 year experience of cases requiring surgical treatment

During the period January 1985 to June 1989, 53 cases of empyema thoracis were treated surgically at Papworth hospital regional cardio-thoracic centre. Of these, 47 patients underwent thoracotomy and decortication as their primary surgical treatment. The remaining six patients were treated by rib resection. Prior to surgical referral 20 of these had undergone previous tube drainage for a mean period of 18 days (range 7-42 days). The principle cause of empyema was broncho-pulmonary infection. In 57% of cases no organisms were isolated from pleural debris or fluid. In the remainder, a variety of organisms were encountered. Early surgical drainage and freeing of the underlying lung met with good results and no deaths in the uncomplicated group. The median duration of postoperative chest drainage for the whole group was 7 days (mean 12 days) and median postoperative in-hospital stay was 13 days (mean 20 days). This is in stark contrast to the duration of hospitalization of patients prior to surgical referral (mean 103.6 days). There were five deaths. All occurred in patients with severe debilitating associated illnesses. In these patients initial drainage of the empyema space with a tube or by rib resection may have allowed recovery prior to more major surgery.

Management of refractory empyema with early decortication

One hundred consecutive patients underwent surgical procedures for empyema. Sixty-six patient acquired empyema from pneumonia, 16 from trauma, 11 from abdominal sepsis, and 7 from other causes. If tube thoracostomy failed, computerized tomography and ultrasonography were used to demonstrate a loculated empyema. After a median observation period of 11 days, 91 patients underwent thoracotomy and decortication and 9 patients underwent either rib resection, an Eloesser flap procedure, or both. The mortality rate was 6 percent 30 days postoperatively, the in-hospital mortality rate was 9 percent, and the overall morbidity rate was 17 percent. An excellent result was achieved in 85 percent of the patients with a recurrence rate of 4 percent. Gram-positive aerobes were the most common organisms cultured, but several opportunistic infections were encountered. We have concluded that early thoracotomy and decortication of empyema results in eradication of difficult pleural infections with hospital stays of an acceptable length and reasonably low morbidity and mortality rates.

Successful treatment of empyema thoracis with polymethylmethacrylate antibiotic-impregnated beads in the guinea pig

Two hundred nine Duncan-Harley guinea pigs had intrathoracic inoculation with 10(8) Staphylococcus aureus, accompanied by blood and umbilical tape. One hundred fifty-two animals were excluded because of clinical recovery, early death, or complications related to intrathoracic polymethylmethacrylate (PMMA) bead placement. The remaining 57 animals had clinical signs of empyema thoracis and were the subjects of this study. Group I animals (N = 24) served as the controls and had no therapy. Group II animals (N = 14) were treated by intrathoracic placement of placebo PMMA beads. Group III animals (N = 19) were treated by intrathoracic placement of tobramycin sulfate-impregnated PMMA beads. There were no differences between the groups in pleural reaction or pneumonia scores. These findings demonstrate a similar host response to the established infection. Group III, however, had a higher sterilization rate than Groups I and II (p less than 0.05), a finding underlining the therapeutic effect of tobramycin-treated PMMA beads. We conclude that intrathoracic local antimicrobial therapy with slow-release tobramycin-impregnated PMMA beads may enhance empyema treatment by increasing the rate of local sterilization. More experiments are necessary to assess the efficacy of this potentially important therapeutic arm for the treatment of thoracic empyema.

Experimental aerobic-anaerobic thoracic empyema in the guinea pig

The clinical and pathological features of experimental aerobic-anaerobic thoracic empyema in the Duncan-Harley guinea pig are described. Thoracic empyema development and early death (less than 14 days after bacterial inoculation) were noted after various concentrations and species were inoculated into the pleural space with a piece of umbilical tape, which was used as a cofactor. The effect of concomitant hemothorax was also tested. Gram-negative infection was found to have a more virulent course than Gram-positive infection in the thoracic cavity. Moreover, these findings support the thesis that intrathoracic inoculation of anaerobic bacteria, even in combination with other anaerobic species, fails to produce clinical empyemas. However, anaerobic bacteria appear to enhance synergistically the virulence of sublethal and subempyema-forming concentrations of aerobic bacteria such as Staphylococcus aureus and Escherichia coli.

Reappraisal of empyema thoracis. Surgical intervention when the duration of illness is unknown

The timing of surgical treatment of empyema remains controversial. Traditionally, thoracotomy is performed either within three weeks of diagnosis or delayed until presumed pleurodesis occurs. Often, these patients are moribund and the duration of illness impossible to determine. We report our surgical results in seven patients with a deteriorating clinical course and multiple loculations which persisted after tube thoracostomy and would not have responded to multiple thoracostomies. Five patients required decortication. One required lobectomy for an abscess which developed on the contralateral side six weeks after discharge. There were no deaths or recurrences of empyema. Average times from surgery to tube removal and to discharge were six to 12 days, respectively. We conclude that one can safely and cost-effectively treat these patients surgically even when the duration of illness and presence of pleurodesis are unknown, and that the postoperative course will be uncomplicated.

Streptococcal sepsis and death caused by empyema

A case is presented of a young man who complained of pain in the pectoral area secondary to empyema, which was not recognized. The patient subsequently died of Streptococcal sepsis. Empyema of the thorax is a well known suppurative disease of the chest. The incidence of empyema has declined dramatically since the advent of antibiotics. It is rarely encountered in the modern emergency department.

The modern use of thoracoplasty

Thoracoplasty is a time-honored but, at present, rarely indicated procedure for reducing thoracic cavity volume. This study reviews a series of 30 patients treated with thoracoplasty over a 14-year period (1970 through 1983). Indications were to close a persistent pleural space in 28 patients and to tailor the thoracic cavity to accept diminished lung volume concomitant with a pulmonary resection in 2 patients. Persistent pleural space, often associated with a bronchopleural fistula (24 patients), occurred after operation in 19 patients: following pulmonary resection in 17 patients, resection of mesothelioma in 1 patient, and following decortication without resection in 1. In the remaining 9 patients with a persistent pleural space, problems developed from primary lung destruction due to tuberculosis (4 patients), postpneumonic empyema (1 patient), or as late infection of a residual pleural space many years after therapeutic pneumothorax and collapse therapy for tuberculosis (4 patients). The overall success rate of thoracoplasty in eliminating intrathoracic space problems was 73%. There were 3 deaths (10%) and 5 failures to heal, representing a 33% failure in the first half of the series (to 1976) and a 17% failure rate thereafter (1 death and 1 nonhealing patient). The primary underlying disease was tuberculosis in 23 patients, 8 of whom had concomitant aspergilloma and 1, atypical tuberculosis. The failures were analyzed and reviewed to clarify the principles for the successful use of thoracoplasty. It is concluded that thoracoplasty is a rarely required salvage-type procedure applicable to moderately debilitated patients in whom it is considered desirable to eliminate open drainage.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Analysis of thirty-seven cases of pleural empyema

A retrospective analysis of 37 pediatric patients with pleural empyema revealed that Streptoccoccus pneumoniae was the most frequently isolated pathogen (41%), followed by Staphylococcus aureus (14%). Twenty-three patients were treated with thoracic drainage and systemic antibiotics, and the other 14 patients with antibiotics only. The case fatality ratio (11%), the complication rate (38%), the length of hospital stay, and the number of febrile days did not differ significantly between the two treatment groups. The immediate insertion of drainage tubes is probably not indicated in all children with pleural empyema but should be reserved for specific indications.

The management of empyema thoracis by thoracoscopy and irrigation

A technique of irrigation for the management of empyema is described. Initial thoracoscopy under general anesthesia enabled full debridement and division of loculi within the empyema cavity under direct vision. Irrigation with two tubes was instituted until three consecutive cultures of irrigation fluid became sterile; then the chest drains were removed. The results in 12 patients are presented. Using this method, irrigation was required for an average of 14 days and chest drains were removed after an average of 20 days. Patients remained in the hospital for an average of 4.8 weeks. Tuberculous empyema was not found to be a contraindication to the irrigation technique.

Mortality in thoracic empyema

With a view of elucidating factors influencing mortality in patients with thoracic empyema, which varies widely (10-50%) in reported case series, a retrospective analysis was made. The series comprised 259 patients treated for thoracic empyema at Bispebjerg Hospital in the period 1965-1980. The mortality was 33% in the total case series, 61% when the underlying pathology was malignant and 25% when it was benign. As malignancy was apparently cured in only 17% of the cases, the investigation was focused on the 200 patients with benign conditions underlying the empyema. The mortality then ranged from nil in spontaneous pneumothorax and thoracic trauma to 50% in lung abscess. Most of the patients with empyema were elderly, but there was no clear difference in mortality between younger and older groups. Concomitant, other disease was present in 80% of the patients who died, but in only 40% of the survivors. Mortality showed no significant difference in relation to primary treatment. Staphylococcus aureus was statistically predominant among the fatal cases. It is concluded that empyema occurring, as in the present study, mainly in elderly and enfeebled patients, is a serious complication with high mortality.

Acute empyema in children treated by open thoracotomy and decortication

Acute nontuberculous empyema treated conventionally by thoracentesis, thoracostomy drainage, and antibiotics has an unacceptably high rate of morbidity and mortality. Early open thoracotomy to eliminate the empyema with decortication of the fibrinous peel and reexpansion of the lung has proven safe and effective for 25 years. The goals of treatment of acute nontuberculous empyema are: (1) to save life, (2) to eliminate the empyema, (3) to reexpand the trapped lung, (4) to restore mobility of the chest wall and diaphragm, (5) to return respiratory function to normal, (6) to eliminate complications or chronicity, and (7) to reduce the duration of hospital stay. Our studies confirm the normal values to be expected in patients who have had complete recovery from the acute empyema, and we lay to rest any concern that decortication might, in time, limit pulmonary function. We present the cases of 21 children who had acute and mature empyemas that were treated by open thoracotomy and decortication, with an average follow-up of 18 years, among whom there were no deaths or complications.