HLA typing in multiple sclerosis

HLA-DRB1*15 influences the development of brain tissue damage in early PPMS

OBJECTIVES

To investigate whether (1) there were differences between HLA-DRB1*15-positive and -negative patients at baseline, and (2) HLA-DRB1*15-positive patients showed a greater development of brain and spinal cord damage, as assessed by MRI, and greater progression of disability, during a 5-year follow-up, compared with HLA-DRB1*15-negative patients.

METHODS

HLA-DRB1*15 typing was performed in 41 patients with primary progressive multiple sclerosis (PPMS) who were recruited within 5 years of symptom onset. All patients and 18 healthy controls were studied clinically and with MRI at baseline, and every 6 months for 3 years, and then at 5 years. Magnetization transfer ratio parameters and volumes for brain gray matter and normal-appearing white matter, brain T2 lesion load, and spinal cord cross-sectional area were obtained. Patient disability was assessed at each visit using the Expanded Disability Status Scale and Multiple Sclerosis Functional Composite subscores.

RESULTS

There were no significant differences between HLA-DRB1*15-positive and -negative patients at baseline. HLA-DRB1*15-positive patients showed a greater decline in brain magnetization transfer ratio for gray matter and normal-appearing white matter (both p = 0.005) than HLA-DRB1*15-negative patients over 5 years, while the same parameters did not change over time in healthy controls. HLA-DRB1*15-positive patients also showed a trend toward a faster increase in brain T2 lesion load than HLA-DRB1*15-negative patients (0.29 [95% confidence interval 0.20-0.38] vs 0.21 [0.13-0.30] mL/mo, p = 0.085) and higher T2 lesion volumes at all time points (average difference [95% confidence interval]: 10.58 mL [7.09-14.07], p < 0.001) during the follow-up, after adjusting for disease duration.

CONCLUSIONS

These findings suggest that HLA-DRB1*15 influences the progression of brain pathology in PPMS.

Multiple sclerosis and the HLA-D region: linkage and association studies

Inheritance patterns of multiple sclerosis (MS) in multiplex families suggest a complex aetiology involving environmental and genetically determined components. The association between the HLA class II DR15, DQ6, Dw2 haplotype and MS has been well documented in patients with ancestral origins in Northern Europe. Conversely, linkage analysis of this region in multiplex families, derived from a population base, has generated negative results. Thus, given the Dw2 specificity association, evidence implicating this locus in disease susceptibility appears contradictory. We have collected and determined the HLA-DR and -DQ haplotypes of 115 sibling pairs with multiple sclerosis, and confirm a significant association with the Dw2-associated haplotype, both in index cases and their affected siblings compared with controls. However, using a sibling pair linkage analysis that restricts haplotype sharing probabilities to defined genetic models, we have not observed linkage of this region to susceptibility in MS. We discuss the basis for association and linkage and conclude that the DR15, DQ6, Dw2 haplotype does represent a susceptibility locus but its contribution to the pathogenesis is small; although it may interact epistatically with other susceptibility genes, this haplotype is not necessary for disease expression.

The mystery of the origin of multiple sclerosis

Our present understanding of the aetiology and pathogenesis of multiple sclerosis is discussed in relation to the views of Sir William Gowers. He perceived that both environmental and genetic factors might be implicated in the aetiology of the disease. Evidence for the former was first reported in 1903, but has become convincing only in the past 20 years; the nature of the environmental factor remains obscure. Evidence for a genetic influence on susceptibility has accumulated since the 1930s, the most compelling coming from the recent Canadian twin study. The number and mode of operation of the genetic factors is still uncertain, but there is evidence for the implication of genetically controlled cellular immune mechanisms in the pathogenesis of the disease. The precise relationship between transient changes in immunological status and the development of new lesions has yet to be defined; magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) promises to play a significant role in this analysis because of its sensitivity in detecting abnormalities in multiple sclerosis. MRI is not in itself specific; it is probable that the similar appearances in multiple sclerosis and cerebral vascular disease both derive at least in part from the influence of astrocytic gliosis on proton content and distribution. The significance of the gliosis is uncertain. Gowers believed that the primary defect in multiple sclerosis lay in the astrocyte. Recent observations on the immunological functions of this cell in vitro suggest that it could be involved early in the pathogenesis of the lesion.

HLA and multiple sclerosis: population and families study

Association between HLA and multiple sclerosis (MS) was investigated at the population level on 100 MS patients genotyped for HLA-A, B, C, DR and Bf, Glo, and on 155 patients phenotyped for the same HLA antigens. Association between MS and DR2 was clearly confirmed, although its strength is rather weak. No other genetic marker could be related to the disease, no haplotype nor any allelic combination could be recognized as MS specific, and antigen genotype frequencies among the diseased could not ascertain the mode of inheritance, although dominance is very likely. Computer analysis between HLA, Bf, Glo and age of the patient, sex, age of onset and evolution of MS, impairment indexes, titres of anti-DNA and anti-measles antibodies in CSF did not show any interaction. Twenty sib pairs and two trios of MS were also studied; they showed no significant distortion with the random distribution of haplotypes. DR2 gene frequency, however, was significantly higher in sib pairs showing one or two haplotypes than in HLA different affected siblings. Three crossing-overs were identified which suggest where the HLA-linked MS susceptibility (MSS) gene could be located within the HLA segment, while other epistatic MSS genes or environmental factors are likely to be important.

A review of the etiology of multiple sclerosis

The geographic distribution of multiple sclerosis and the influence of migration on the risk of contracting it point to an environmental factor as cause of the disease. This environmental factor might be a virus which might produce the demyelination process through an autoimmune reaction against components of the central nervous system. The other possible cause of multiple sclerosis is a genetic susceptibility, inferred from the higher risk for the disease found among relatives of patients with multiple sclerosis and on the association between the disease and some histocompatibility antigens of the HLA system. Both theories seem to be correct, with the environmental factors(s) causing multiple sclerosis only in the presence of a genetic susceptibility.

Multiple sclerosis: the present position

The advances of the past decade particularly in the application of evoked potential techniques and electrophoresis of CSF proteins have improved the accuracy of early diagnosis of multiple sclerosis. The geographical distribution of the disease, the effect of migration on prevalence, and the existence of clusters suggest that an environmental factor is involved in the aetiology; it is probably infective. Family and twin studies provide evidence for a genetic contribution which is probably multifactorial and related to immune regulation. The pathogenesis is at least in part immunologically mediated. A rational approach to therapy is difficult. In the present state of knowledge we are unlikely to be able to modify the course of multiple sclerosis by tackling a putative environmental agent. We are more likely to be able to do so by manipulating the pathogenesis, although an effective means of doing so has yet to be defined.