Experimental autoimmune uveoretinitis in mice (Biozzi ABH and NOD) expressing the autoimmune-associated H-2A(g7) molecule: identification of a uveitogenic epitope

Autoimmune encephalomyelitis in NOD mice is not initially a progressive multiple sclerosis model

Objective

Despite progress in treating relapsing multiple sclerosis (MS), effective inhibition of nonrelapsing progressive MS is an urgent, unmet, clinical need. Animal models of MS, such as experimental autoimmune encephalomyelitis (EAE), provide valuable tools to examine the mechanisms contributing to disease and may be important for developing rational therapeutic approaches for treatment of progressive MS. It has been suggested that myelin oligodendrocyte glycoprotein (MOG) peptide residues 35‐55 (MOG^35‐55)‐induced EAE in nonobese diabetic (NOD) mice resembles secondary progressive MS. The objective was to determine whether the published data merits such claims.

Methods

Induction and monitoring of EAE in NOD mice and literature review.

Results

It is evident that the NOD mouse model lacks validity as a progressive MS model as the individual course seems to be an asynchronous, relapsing‐remitting neurodegenerative disease, characterized by increasingly poor recovery from relapse. The seemingly progressive course seen in group means of clinical score is an artifact of data handling and interpretation.

Interpretation

Although MOG^35‐55‐induced EAE in NOD mice may provide some clues about approaches to block neurodegeneration associated with the inflammatory penumbra as lesions form, it should not be used to justify trials in people with nonactive, progressive MS. This adds further support to the view that drug studies in animals should universally adopt transparent raw data deposition as part of the publication process, such that claims can adequately be interrogated. This transparency is important if animal‐based science is to remain a credible part of translational research in MS.

Identification of novel dendritic cell populations in normal mouse retina

PURPOSE

Whether tissue resident or infiltrating antigen-presenting cells (APCs) are involved in modulating immune responses in the retina and initiating inflammation is controversial. In this histologic study, the authors examine the retinas of mice strains with different susceptibility to experimental autoimmune uveoretinitis (EAU) for tissue resident APC.

METHODS

Retinal wholemounts from normal and inflamed eyes of B10R III, C57BL/6, BALB/c, and ABH Biozii mice were immunostained for APC markers (33D1, CD11c, CD11b, major histocompatibility complex [MHC] class II, F4/80, CD80, CD86, CD205, mPDCA, B220, and GR1) and analyzed by confocal fluorescence microscopy using emission fingerprinting and three-dimensional reconstruction techniques. Hematoxylin and eosin-stained histologic sections were used to evaluate EAU disease scores and to assess outer blood retina barrier (retinal pigment epithelium [RPE]) structures.

RESULTS

A population of 33D1(+) cells was identified exclusively in the peripheral margins and juxtapapillary areas of the retina in normal, nonimmunized C57BL/6 adult mice. These cells were also MHC class II(high), and their location corresponded to sites of earliest inflammation in EAU. Numbers in the papillary area were very low (less than 10), but this region marked the predominant anatomic site for initiation of inflammation in this moderately susceptible strain. The distribution and phenotype of these cells within the retinas differed between mouse strains exhibiting different disease susceptibility. In EAU-resistant BALB/c mice, many more 33D1(+) dendritic cells were present in the normal retina but were MHC class II(low/-). Conversely, no 33D1(+) or MHC class II (+) dendriform cells could be found in the normal retinas of highly EAU-susceptible B10.RIII mice.

CONCLUSIONS

A novel population of 33D1(+) DCs was identified in normal mouse retina. The function of these cells remains to be defined, but increased numbers correlate positively with structural abnormalities in the RPE and increased resistance of the strain to EAU.

The anti-IRBP IgG1 and IgG2a response does not correlate with susceptibility to experimental autoimmune uveitis

Susceptibility to experimental autoimmune uveitis (EAU) in inbred mice has been associated with a dominant Th1 response. Elevated anti-inter-photoreceptor retinoid-binding protein (anti-IRBP) IgG2a/IgG1 antibody ratios have been implicated as candidate markers to predict disease severity. In the present study, both the anti-IRBP antibody isotype and severity of EAU phenotypes were examined in 4 non-isogenic genetically selected mouse lines to determine if they can be used as general markers of disease. Mice between 8 and 12 weeks old selected for high (H(III)) or low (L(III)) antibody response and for maximum (AIR(MAX)) or minimum (AIR(MIN)) acute inflammatory reaction (AIR) were immunized with IRBP. Each experiment was performed with at least 5 mice per group. EAU was evaluated by histopathology 21 days after immunization and the minimal criterion was inflammatory cell infiltration of the ciliary body, choroid and retina. Serum IgG1- and IgG2a-specific antibodies were determined by ELISA. EAU was graded by histological examination of the enucleated eyes. The incidence of EAU was lower in AIR(MIN) mice whereas in the other strains approximately 40% of the animals developed the disease. Low responder animals did not produce anti-IRBP IgG2a antibodies or interferon-gamma. No correlation was observed between susceptibility to EAU and anti-IRBP isotype profiles. Susceptibility to EAU is related to the intrinsic capacity to mount higher inflammatory reactions and increased production of anti-IRBP IgG2a isotype is not necessarily a marker of this immunologic profile.

Encephalitogenic and tolerogenic potential of altered peptide ligands of MOG and PLP in Biozzi ABH mice

Altered peptide ligands (APL) are highly effective in inhibiting experimental autoimmune encephalomyelitis (EAE) in rodents although clinical trials in multiple sclerosis reveal severe limitations probably due to the diverse and differential effects of APL in vivo compared to in vitro. Myelin oligodendrocyte glycoprotein (MOG 8-21) induces relapsing EAE in ABH (A(g7)) mice associated with broadening of the autoimmune repertoire thus providing a dynamic system to examine the efficacy of peptide analogues. Subtle changes in MOG 8-21 dramatically influenced disease susceptibility and T cell responses in vitro. Non-encephalitogenic APL that induce production of the 'regulatory' cytokines IL-10 and/or TGFbeta and concomitant low levels of the 'proinflammatory' cytokines IFNgamma and TNFalpha modulated relapsing EAE but were far less effective than the 'proinflammatory' wild-type MOG 8-21 peptide. These data reveal that APL differ greatly in their ability to activate encephalitogenic T cells. The extensive heterogeneity of responses of APL in vitro suggests that selection of APL on this criteria is highly unpredictable and probably less effective for therapy than selecting the dominant wild-type epitope and delivering it using a tolerogenic route.

Biozzi mice: Of mice and human neurological diseases

In 1972 Guido Biozzi selectively bred mice to study the immunopathological mechanisms underlying polygenic diseases. One line, the Biozzi antibody high (AB/H) mouse (now designated the ABH strain) was later found to be highly susceptible to many experimentally induced diseases such as autoimmune encephalomyelitis, autoimmune neuritis, autoimmune uveitis, as well as virus-induced demyelination and has thus been a key mouse strain to study human inflammatory neurological diseases. In this paper we discuss the background of the Biozzi ABH mouse and review how studies with these mice have shed light on the pathogenic mechanisms operating in chronic neurological disease.

Epitope spread is not critical for the relapse and progression of MOG 8-21 induced EAE in Biozzi ABH mice

Emerging autoimmunity (epitope-spreading) generated as a consequence of myelin damage is suggested to underlie the relapses in multiple sclerosis (MS). Myelin oligodendrocyte glycoprotein (MOG 8-21) induces relapsing EAE in ABH mice characterized by broadening of the autoimmune reportoire. Despite epitope spreading tolerance to the priming antigen, but not emerging epitope reactivities, resulted in long-term inhibition of clinical relapse. In contrast, spinal cord homogenate induced EAE was dominated by a proteolipid protein (PLP 56-70) autoreactivity despite the plethora of CNS antigens in the immunogen. This data suggests that during relapsing-remitting demyelinating disease the pathogenic process is dominated by the initiating antigen, with only a minor role played by emerging T-cell populations. These findings may have important implications for the efficacy of antigen-based immune therapies in autoimmune disorders.

Encephalitogenic and immunogenic potential of myelin-associated glycoprotein (MAG), oligodendrocyte-specific glycoprotein (OSP) and 2',3'-cyclic nucleotide 3'-phosphodiesterase (CNPase) in ABH and SJL mice

Synthetic peptides of myelin-associated glycoprotein (MAG), oligodendrocyte-specific glycoprotein (OSP) and 2',3'-cyclic nucleotide 3'-phosphodiesterase (CNPase) were screened for their ability to induce experimental allergic encephalomyelitis (EAE) in ABH (H-2A(g7)) and SJL (H-2(s)) mice. The use of overlapping 16mer MAG peptides identified residues 97-112 as a T-cell and encephalitogenic epitope in ABH mice which induced clinical and histological signs of acute EAE. Immunization of SJL mice with MAG peptides failed to induce disease whereas immunization of SJL mice with synthetic peptides of OSP induced major T-cell responses to OSP 73-88 and 81-96. Another epitope, OSP 57-72, that induced EAE, failed to induce T-cell responses in mice immunised with peptides based on the whole sequence supporting a role for cryptic epitopes. In comparison, whilst immunization of ABH mice with OSP revealed two immunodominant T-cell epitopes (49-64 and 137-152), an encephalitogenic epitope was not identified. Similarly, immunization of both SJL and ABH mice with CNPase peptides induced T-cell responses to several epitopes. However, these were not encephalitogenic. This study is the first to identify an encephalitogenic epitope of MAG and immunodominant epitopes of MAG, OSP and CNPase in SJL and ABH mice. The ability of both cryptic and noncryptic peptide epitopes of these myelin antigens to initiate EAE suggests that mice at least are not tolerant to some regions of MAG and OSP and that such specific autoimmune responses may play an important role in the pathogenesis of immune-mediated neurological diseases such as multiple sclerosis.