Valproate metabolism during valproate-associated hepatotoxicity in a surviving adult patient

Association of Valproic Acid and Its Main Metabolites' Plasma Concentrations with Clinical Outcomes among Epilepsy Patients: A 10-Year Retrospective Study Based on Therapeutic Drug Monitoring

Valproic acid (VPA) is a first-line antiepileptic drug with broad efficacy. Due to significant individual differences in its metabolism, therapeutic drug monitoring is commonly used. However, the recommended therapeutic range (50-100 μg/mL) is inadequate for predicting clinical outcomes. Additionally, the relationship between VPA metabolites and clinical outcomes remains unclear. In this retrospective study, 485 Chinese Southern Han epilepsy patients receiving VPA monotherapy were analyzed after reaching steady-state levels. Plasma concentrations of VPA and its five main metabolites were determined by liquid chromatography-mass spectrometry (LC-MS). We assessed the relevance of the recommended therapeutic VPA range for clinical outcomes and explored the association between VPA/metabolites levels and treatment efficacy/adverse effects. Vitro experiments were conducted to assess 4-ene-VPA hepatotoxicity. The therapeutic range of VPA exhibited no significant correlation with clinical outcomes, and plasma concentrations of VPA failed to serve as predictive indicators for treatment response/adverse effects. Treatment responders had higher 2-PGA concentrations (median, 26.39 ng/mL versus 13.68 ng/mL), with a threshold of 36.5 ng/mL for optimal epilepsy treatment. Patients with abnormal liver function had a higher 4-ene-VPA median concentration (6.41 μg/mL versus 4.83 μg/mL), and the ratio of 4-ene-VPA to VPA better predicted VPA-induced hepatotoxicity (area under the curve, 0.718) than 4-ene-VPA concentration. Vitro experiments revealed that 4-ene-VPA was more hepatotoxic than VPA in HepaRG and L02 cell lines. Total plasma VPA concentration does not serve as a predictor of clinical outcomes. 2-PGA concentrations may be associated with efficacy, whereas the ratio of 4-ene-VPA to VPA may be considered a better biomarker (threshold 10.03%) for VPA-induced hepatotoxicity. SIGNIFICANCE STATEMENT: This was the first and largest observational cohort in China to explore the relationship between patients' parent and metabolites concentrations of VPA and clinical outcomes during the maintenance of VPA monotherapy in epileptic patients. This study provided feasible references of VPA for epilepsy clinical treatment with a larger sample of patients compared with previous studies for a more definitive conclusion based on real-world situations. We found two potential biomarkers in predicting efficacy and liver injury, respectively. This breakthrough has the potential to assist in the rational use of VPA.

Valproic acid autoinduction: a case-based review

Although valproic acid (VPA) induces the metabolism of multiple other drugs, the clinical reports of VPA autoinduction are rare. A comprehensive literature search yielded only one published case series, which provided the rationale to conduct a review of the published cases along with a new case of VPA autoinduction. Although there may be myriad of reasons for lack of published cases of VPA autoinduction, potential underreporting may be one of the core reasons. Lack of understanding into the highly complex metabolism of VPA may also make it difficult to recognize and report VPA autoinduction. However, it is important to mention that in addition to autoinduction increased elimination of VPA may be mediated by several pharmacokinetic (PK) factors, such as drug interactions, genetic polymorphisms of metabolic enzymes, and protein displacement reactions. As VPA is metabolized by multiple metabolic pathways, the risk for drug interactions is relatively high. There is also a growing evidence for high genetic inducibility of some enzymes involved in VPA metabolism. Protein displacement reactions with VPA increase the biologically active and readily metabolizable free fraction and pose a diagnostic challenge as they are usually not requested by most clinicians. Thus, monitoring of free fraction with total VPA levels may prevent clinically serious outcomes and optimize VPA treatment in clinically challenging patients. This case-based review compares the clinical data from three published cases and a new case of VPA autoinduction to enhance clinicians' awareness of this relatively rare but clinically relevant phenomenon along with a discussion of potential underlying mechanisms.

Xanthotoxin enhances the anticonvulsant potency of levetiracetam and valproate in the 6-Hz corneal stimulation model in mice

Xanthotoxin (8-methoxypsoralen; XANT) is a furanocoumarin that has many biological properties, including antiepileptic activity. This study evaluated the effect of XANT on the ability of classical and novel antiepileptic drugs to prevent seizures evoked by the 6-Hz corneal stimulation-induced seizure model, which is thought to be an experimental model of psychomotor (limbic) seizures in humans. XANT (50 mg/kg, administered i.p.) significantly potentiated the anticonvulsant activity of levetiracetam and valproate, decreasing their median effective dose (ED₅₀ ) values from 19.37 to 2.83 mg/kg (P < 0.01) for levetiracetam and from 92.89 to 44.44 mg/kg (P < 0.05) for valproate. Neither XANT (50 mg/kg) alone nor its combination with the anticonvulsant drugs (at their ED₅₀ values from the 6-Hz test) affected motor coordination; skeletal muscular strength and long-term memory, as determined in the chimney; and grip strength and passive avoidance tests, respectively. Measurement of total brain antiepileptic drug concentrations revealed that XANT (50 mg/kg) had no impact on levetiracetam total brain concentrations, indicating the pharmacodynamic nature of interaction between these antiepileptic drugs in the mouse 6-Hz model. However, XANT (50 mg/kg, i.p.) significantly increased total brain concentrations of valproate (P < 0.01), indicating the pharmacokinetic nature of interactions between drugs. XANT in combination with levetiracetam exerts beneficial anticonvulsant pharmacodynamic interactions in the 6-Hz mouse psychomotor seizure model.

Dispensability of Annual Laboratory Follow-Up After More than 2 Years of Valproic Acid Use: A Systematic Review

BACKGROUND

The necessity of annual laboratory follow-up in patients treated with valproic acid (VPA) is controversial.

OBJECTIVE

We investigated the need for annual laboratory follow-up of liver enzymes, electrolytes, and full blood count (FBC) in patients treated with VPA.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

A systematic search in Evidence-Based Medicine Reviews (EBMR), MEDLINE, and EMBASE was undertaken in December 2016 to identify all published articles investigating or citing valproic acid, liver function disorders, electrolyte disorders, and FBC deviations.

RESULTS

This review included 108 articles. As the number of participants and duration of the study was not adequate in most studies to detect rare adverse events, studies did not demonstrate a clear prevalence of hepatotoxicity. While a transient increase of transaminases is common and seldom harmful, severe hepatotoxicity is a rare phenomenon and is not prevented by routine laboratory monitoring. VPA had no relevant effect on serum calcium, sodium, potassium, and albumin. The prevalence of FBC varied from 0.6 to 27.8%, occurred mostly in the first 2 years of therapy, and was usually asymptomatic.

CONCLUSIONS

Long-term monitoring in VPA treatment is only necessary when there have been dose adjustments, co-medication switches, or co-morbidity. In uncomplicated cases, annual laboratory follow-up may be discontinued after 2 years of VPA treatment. Encouraging patients to be vigilant is more effective in the detection of hepatotoxicity than laboratory testing. Follow-up of FBC at 3-6 months, 1 year, and 2 years after start or after a dose increase of VPA or interacting medication is sufficient.

Neurointensive care management of raised intracranial pressure caused by severe valproic acid intoxication

INTRODUCTION

We describe the neurointensive care (NIC) management of a patient with severe cerebral swelling and raised intracranial pressure (ICP) after severe sodium valproic acid (VPA) intoxication. A previously healthy 25-year old male with mild tonic-clonic epilepsy was found unconscious with serum VPA levels >10,000 micromol/l. The patient deteriorated to Glasgow Motor Scale score (GMS) 2 and a CT scan showed signs of raised ICP. Early ICP was elevated, >50 mm Hg, and continuous EEG monitoring showed isoelectric readings.

METHODS

The patient was treated with an ICP-guided protocol including mild hyperventilation, normovolemia, head elevation and intermittent doses of mannitol. Due to refractory elevations of ICP, high-dose pentobarbital infusion was initiated, and ICP gradually normalised.

RESULTS

There were several systemic complications including coagulopathy, hypocalcemia and pancreatitis. The patient remained in a depressed level of consciousness for 2 months but gradually recovered, showing a good recovery with minor subjective cognitive deficits by 6 months.

CONCLUSION

We conclude that NIC may be an important treatment option in cases of severe intoxication causing cerebral swelling.

Drug metabolite profiling and elucidation of drug-induced hepatotoxicity

Drug metabolism studies, together with pathologic and histologic evaluation, provide critical data sets to help understand mechanisms underlying drug-related hepatotoxicity. A common practice is to trace morphologic changes resulting from liver injury back to perturbation of biochemical processes and to identify drug metabolites that affect those processes as possible culprits. This strategy can be illustrated in efforts of elucidating the cause of acetaminophen-, troglitazone- and valproic acid-induced hepatic necrosis, microvesicular steatosis and cholestasis with the aid of information from qualitative and quantitative analysis of metabolites. From a pharmaceutical research perspective, metabolite profiling represents an important function because a structure-activity relationship is essential to rational drug design. In addition, drugs are known to induce idiosyncratic hepatotoxicity, which usually escapes the detection by preclinical safety assessment and clinical trials. This issue is addressed, at present, by eliminating those molecules that are prone to metabolic bioactivation, based on the concept that formation of electrophilic metabolites triggers covalent protein modification and subsequent organ toxicity. Although pragmatic, such an approach has its limitations as a linear correlation does not exist between toxicity and the extent of bioactivation. It may be possible in the future that the advance of proteomics, metabonomics and genomics would pave the way leading to personalized medication in which beneficial effect of a drug is maximized, whereas toxicity risk is minimized.

Disposition of valproic acid in self-poisoned adults

Acute intoxication with valproic acid is increasingly being observed in clinical practice. In Poland, such intoxication frequently occurs as a result of mixing different drugs or alcohol. We studied the pharmacokinetics of valproic acid in five intoxicated patients. Apart from valproic acid, barbiturates, chlorprotixene, tricyclic antidepressants, tetrahydrocannabinols and alcohol were detected and measured. The absorption of the drug was rapid and the maximum concentration was observed after the period of 3.5-5.6 hr. The lowering of the valproic acid level in plasma was biphasic, with terminal half-life ranging between 8.8-30.9 hr. The calculated apparent volume of distribution was 0.17-0.72 l/kg and could be affected by varied levels of doses as well as time of drug intake (data from interviews of patients) used for calculation and reduction in plasma protein binding at higher concentration of valproic acid. Frequent multiple drug poisonings oblige toxicological laboratories not only to monitor valproic acid concentration in serum, but also to perform the toxicological screenings.

Valproate therapy and nonalcoholic fatty liver disease

Nonalcoholic fatty liver disease was defined recently as another symptom of insulin resistance. Continuous therapy with valproate can result in increased body weight and insulin resistance, but no data are yet available on a possible relationship between valproate and nonalcoholic fatty liver disease. We here demonstrate in abdominal ultrasound investigations that characteristics of fatty liver disease were present in 61% of valproate-treated patients as compared with 23% receiving carbamazepine therapy.

Fulminant liver disease

Fulminant liver disease, acute liver failure (ALF), is one of the most intriguing and challenging conditions in the entire field of internal medicine. ALF is defined as the onset of hepatic encephalopathy and coagulopathy in patients with no known underlying liver disease within 8 to 26 weeks of onset of illness. Many cases develop within a few days, dramatically transforming an otherwise healthy individual to a patient with a high risk for developing multi-organ failure and death.

Abnormal alterations in the metabolic patterns of patients on valproate therapy

Four cases of abnormal metabolic patterns which were obtained from three infantile patients and one adult on valproate (valproic acid; 2-n-propyl-pentanoic acid) therapy are reported. Serum levels of valproate and 15 metabolites were measured by gas chromatography/mass spectrometry. A mentally retarded, 11-month-old boy developed an extremely altered metabolic profile after having been treated with valproate polytherapy for 3 months. The altered pattern included strongly elevated serum levels of the 4-ene as well as of the omega-/omega1-metabolites, with the beta-metabolites (2-ene; 2,3'-diene) being diminished. Two samples obtained previously had shown a common pattern. The infant died 3 weeks after the last sample had been taken. Two boys of the same age showed similar but less intense deviations in their metabolic profiles at the onset of valproate therapy. Within a few weeks they approached, in a step-wise fashion, the average pattern common for children under 3 years of age. The striking alterations were paralleled by the metabolic profiles of an adult patient who suffered from intrahepatic metastasis and renal insufficiency. From the close resemblance of the abnormal metabolic patterns it was concluded that liver dysfunction results in alteration of the whole metabolic system. Regular inspection of the entire profile of an individual might help to recognize conspicuous alterations in time to avoid severe side effects.

Establishing individual metabolite patterns for patients on valproate therapy

The aim of this study was to establish individual metabolic profiles of patients receiving valproate (VPA) mono- or polytherapy in order to estimate inter- and intraindividual variability under normal conditions. Serum levels of VPA and 15 metabolites were measured by gas chromotography/mass spectrometry (GC/MS) with selected ion monitoring (SIM). Because of a huge inter-subject variability, calculating means for large epileptic populations resulted in broad and vague ranges for serum levels of VPA and its metabolites. It therefore remained difficult to recognize any significant alteration in the individual metabolic profile. Over long term periods, within-patient changes appeared to be much less intense than inherent interindividual differences. In epileptics consecutively receiving various forms of polytherapy, alterations in the metabolic profiles occurred. Therefore, integrating different kinds of co-medication into a single polytherapy group seemed to be inadequate. An adult patient on VPA monotherapy, suffering form intrahepatic metastasis and renal insufficiency, showed an extremely altered metabolic pattern, with the 4-ene and the omega-/omega1-metabolites being strongly elevated and the major beta-metabolites (E)-2-ene and (E,E)-2,3'-diene being significantly diminished. We suggest determining the individual metabolic profile, consisting of accessible major and minor metabolites, for every patient when VPA therapy has been started or been modified. The moment any clinical complications arise, the previously obtained specific pattern of the individual can be taken as reference in order to assess the possible presance of significant alterations which might indicate or even cause any severe side effects. There seems to be no need of monitoring metabolite levels of the average patient continuously except for the high risk group (e.g. infants under 3 years age receiving polytherapy) which exhibited the highest between-subject as well as within-patient variability.