The role of the cleavage site 2'-hydroxyl in the Tetrahymena group I ribozyme reaction

Structural modifications as tools in mechanistic studies of the cleavage of RNA phosphodiester linkages

The cleavage of RNA phosphodiester bonds by RNase A and hammerhead ribozyme at neutral pH fundamentally differs from the spontaneous reactions of these bonds under the same conditions. While the predominant spontaneous reaction is isomerization of the 3',5'-phosphodiester linkages to their 2',5'-counterparts, this reaction has never been reported to compete with the enzymatic cleavage reaction, not even as a minor side reaction. Comparative kinetic measurements with structurally modified di-nucleoside monophosphates and oligomeric phosphodiesters have played an important role in clarification of mechanistic details of the buffer-independent and buffer-catalyzed reactions. More recently, heavy atom isotope effects and theoretical calculations have refined the picture. The primary aim of all these studies has been to form a solid basis for mechanistic analyses of the action of more complicated catalytic machineries. In other words, to contribute to conception of a plausible unified picture of RNA cleavage by biocatalysts, such as RNAse A, hammerhead ribozyme and DNAzymes. In addition, structurally modified trinucleoside monophosphates as transition state models for Group I and II introns have clarified some features of the action of large ribozymes.

Phosphodiester models for cleavage of nucleic acids

Nucleic acids that store and transfer biological information are polymeric diesters of phosphoric acid. Cleavage of the phosphodiester linkages by protein enzymes, nucleases, is one of the underlying biological processes. The remarkable catalytic efficiency of nucleases, together with the ability of ribonucleic acids to serve sometimes as nucleases, has made the cleavage of phosphodiesters a subject of intensive mechanistic studies. In addition to studies of nucleases by pH-rate dependency, X-ray crystallography, amino acid/nucleotide substitution and computational approaches, experimental and theoretical studies with small molecular model compounds still play a role. With small molecules, the importance of various elementary processes, such as proton transfer and metal ion binding, for stabilization of transition states may be elucidated and systematic variation of the basicity of the entering or departing nucleophile enables determination of the position of the transition state on the reaction coordinate. Such data is important on analyzing enzyme mechanisms based on synergistic participation of several catalytic entities. Many nucleases are metalloenzymes and small molecular models offer an excellent tool to construct models for their catalytic centers. The present review tends to be an up to date summary of what has been achieved by mechanistic studies with small molecular phosphodiesters.

Impact of steric constraints on the product distribution of phosphate-branched oligonucleotide models of the large ribozymes

To assess the extent to which steric constraints may influence the product distribution of the reactions of the large ribozymes, phosphate-branched oligonucleotides of varying length and sequence have been synthesized and their alkaline hydrolysis studied over a wide temperature range. At low temperatures, the branching trinucleoside-3',3',5'-monophosphate moiety is hydrolyzed almost exclusively by P-O3' fission. At higher temperatures, P-O5' fission competes, accounting at most for 22% of the overall reaction. The results suggest that steric constraints imposed by the secondary structure of the reaction site may significantly contribute to the observed regioselectivity of the transesterification reactions catalyzed by the large ribozymes.

Investigation of catalysis by bacterial RNase P via LNA and other modifications at the scissile phosphodiester

We analyzed cleavage of precursor tRNAs with an LNA, 2'-OCH(3), 2'-H or 2'-F modification at the canonical (c(0)) site by bacterial RNase P. We infer that the major function of the 2'-substituent at nt -1 during substrate ground state binding is to accept an H-bond. Cleavage of the LNA substrate at the c(0) site by Escherichia coli RNase P RNA demonstrated that the transition state for cleavage can in principle be achieved with a locked C3' -endo ribose and without the H-bond donor function of the 2'-substituent. LNA and 2'-OCH(3) suppressed processing at the major aberrant m(-)(1) site; instead, the m(+1) (nt +1/+2) site was utilized. For the LNA variant, parallel pathways leading to cleavage at the c(0) and m(+1) sites had different pH profiles, with a higher Mg(2+) requirement for c(0) versus m(+1) cleavage. The strong catalytic defect for LNA and 2'-OCH(3) supports a model where the extra methylene (LNA) or methyl group (2'-OCH(3)) causes a steric interference with a nearby bound catalytic Mg(2+) during its recoordination on the way to the transition state for cleavage. The presence of the protein cofactor suppressed the ground state binding defects, but not the catalytic defects.

The 2'-OH group at the group II intron terminus acts as a proton shuttle

Group II introns are self-splicing ribozymes that excise themselves from precursor RNAs and catalyze the joining of flanking exons. Excised introns can behave as parasitic RNA molecules, catalyzing their own insertion into DNA and RNA via a reverse-splicing reaction. Previous studies have identified mechanistic roles for various functional groups located in the catalytic core of the intron and within target molecules. Here we introduce a new method for synthesizing long RNA molecules with a modified nucleotide at the 3′-terminus. This modification allows us to examine the mechanistic role of functional groups adjacent to the reaction nucleophile. During reverse-splicing, the 3′-OH group of the intron terminus attacks the phosphodiester linkage of spliced exon sequences. Here we show that the adjacent 2′-OH group on the intron terminus plays an essential role in activating the nucleophile by stripping away a proton from the 3′-OH and then shuttling it from the active-site.

Phosphorane intermediate vs. leaving group stabilization by intramolecular hydrogen bonding in the cleavage of trinucleoside monophosphates: implications for understanding catalysis by the large ribozymes

Hydrolysis of 2',3'-O-methyleneadenosin-5'-yl 5'-O-methyluridin-2'-yl 5'-O-methyl-2'-trifluoroacetamido-2'-deoxyuridin-3'-yl phosphate (1b) has been followed by HPLC over a wide pH range to study the effects of potential hydrogen bonding interactions of the 2'-trifluoroacetamido function on the rate and product distribution of the reaction. At pH < 2, decomposition of 1b (and its 3',3',5'-isomer 1a) is first-order in hydronium-ion concentration and cleavage of the P-O3' bond of the 2'-trifluoroacetamido-modified nucleoside is slightly favored over cleavage of the P-O5' bond. Between pH 2 and 4, the overall hydrolysis is pH-independent and the P-O3' and P-O5' bonds are cleaved at comparable rates. At pH 5, the reaction becomes first-order in hydroxide-ion concentration, with P-O3' bond cleavage predominating. At 10 mmol L(-1) aqueous sodium hydroxide, no P-O5' bond cleavage is observed. Compared to the 2'-OH counterpart , a modest rate enhancement is observed over the entire pH range studied. The absence of P-O5' fission under alkaline conditions suggests hydrogen bond stabilization of the departing 3'-oxyanion by the neighboring 2'-trifluoroacetamido function.

Use of phosphorothioates to identify sites of metal-ion binding in RNA

Single atom substitutions provide an exceptional opportunity to investigate RNA structure and function. Replacing a phosphoryl oxygen with a sulfur represents one of the most common and powerful single atom substitutions and can be used to determine the sites of metal-ion binding. Using functional assays of ribozyme catalysis, based on pre-steady-state kinetics, it is possible to extend this analysis to the transition state, capturing ligands for catalytic metal ions in this fleeting state. In conjunction with data determined from X-ray crystallography, this technique can provide a picture of the environment surrounding catalytic metal ions in both the ground state and the transition state at atomic resolution. Here, we describe the principles of such analysis, explain limitations of the method, and provide a practical example based on our results with the Tetrahymena group I ribozyme.

2'-amino-modified ribonucleotides as probes for local interactions within RNA

The 2'-hydroxyl group plays an integral role in RNA structure and catalysis. This ubiquitous component of the RNA backbone can participate in multiple interactions essential for RNA function, such as hydrogen bonding and metal ion coordination, but the multifunctional nature of the 2'-hydroxyl renders identification of these interactions a significant challenge. By virtue of their versatile physicochemical properties, such as distinct metal coordination preferences, hydrogen bonding properties, and ability to be protonated, 2'-amino-2'-deoxyribonucleotides can serve as tools for probing local interactions involving 2'-hydroxyl groups within RNA. The 2'-amino group can also serve as a chemoselective site for covalent modification, permitting the introduction of probes for investigation of RNA structure and dynamics. In this chapter, we describe the use of 2'-aminonucleotides for investigation of local interactions within RNA, focusing on interactions involving 2'-hydroxyl groups required for RNA structure, function, and catalysis.

The 2'-hydroxyl group of the guanosine nucleophile donates a functionally important hydrogen bond in the tetrahymena ribozyme reaction

In the first step of self-splicing, group I introns utilize an exogenous guanosine nucleophile to attack the 5'-splice site. Removal of the 2'-hydroxyl of this guanosine results in a 10 (6)-fold loss in activity, indicating that this functional group plays a critical role in catalysis. Biochemical and structural data have shown that this hydroxyl group provides a ligand for one of the catalytic metal ions at the active site. However, whether this hydroxyl group also engages in hydrogen-bonding interactions remains unclear, as attempts to elaborate its function further usually disrupt the interactions with the catalytic metal ion. To address the possibility that this 2'-hydroxyl contributes to catalysis by donating a hydrogen bond, we have used an atomic mutation cycle to probe the functional importance of the guanosine 2'-hydroxyl hydrogen atom. This analysis indicates that, beyond its role as a ligand for a catalytic metal ion, the guanosine 2'-hydroxyl group donates a hydrogen bond in both the ground state and the transition state, thereby contributing to cofactor recognition and catalysis by the intron. Our findings continue an emerging theme in group I intron catalysis: the oxygen atoms at the reaction center form multidentate interactions that function as a cooperative network. The ability to delineate such networks represents a key step in dissecting the complex relationship between RNA structure and catalysis.

Synthesis and biochemical application of 2'-O-methyl-3'-thioguanosine as a probe to explore group I intron catalysis

Oligonucleotides containing 3'-S-phosphorothiolate linkages provide valuable analogues for exploring the catalytic mechanisms of enzymes and ribozymes, both to identify catalytic metal ions and to probe hydrogen-bonding interactions. Here, we have synthesized 2'-O-methyl-3'-thioguanosine to test a possible hydrogen-bonding interaction in the Tetrahymena ribozyme reaction. We developed an efficient method for the synthesis of 2'-O-methyl-3'-thioguanosine phosphoramidite in eight steps starting from 2'-O-methyl-N(2)-(isobutyryl) guanosine with 10.4% overall yield. Following incorporation into oligonucleotides using solid-phase synthesis, we used this new analogue to investigate whether the 3'-oxygen of the guanosine cofactor in the Tetrahymena ribozyme reaction serves as an acceptor for the hydrogen bond donated by the adjacent 2'-hydroxyl group. We show that regardless of whether the guanosine cofactor bears a 3'-oxygen or 3'-sulfur leaving group, replacing the adjacent 2'-hydroxyl group with a 2'-methoxy group incurs the same energetic penalty, providing evidence against an interaction. These results indicate that the hydrogen bond donated by the guanosine 2'-hydroxyl group contributes to catalytic function in a manner distinct from the U(-1) 2'-hydroxyl group.

Modulation of individual steps in group I intron catalysis by a peripheral metal ion

Enzymes are complex macromolecules that catalyze chemical reactions at their active sites. Important information about catalytic interactions is commonly gathered by perturbation or mutation of active site residues that directly contact substrates. However, active sites are engaged in intricate networks of interactions within the overall structure of the macromolecule, and there is a growing body of evidence about the importance of peripheral interactions in the precise structural organization of the active site. Here, we use functional studies, in conjunction with published structural information, to determine the effect of perturbation of a peripheral metal ion binding site on catalysis in a well-characterized catalytic RNA, the Tetrahymena thermophila group I ribozyme. We perturbed the metal ion binding site by site-specifically introducing a phosphorothioate substitution in the ribozyme's backbone, replacing the native ligands (the pro-R (P) oxygen atoms at positions 307 and 308) with sulfur atoms. Our data reveal that these perturbations affect several reaction steps, including the chemical step, despite the absence of direct contacts of this metal ion with the atoms involved in the chemical transformation. As structural probing with hydroxyl radicals did not reveal significant change in the three-dimensional structure upon phosphorothioate substitution, the effects are likely transmitted through local, rather subtle conformational rearrangements. Addition of Cd(2+), a thiophilic metal ion, rescues some reaction steps but has deleterious effects on other steps. These results suggest that native interactions in the active site may have been aligned by the naturally occurring peripheral residues and interactions to optimize the overall catalytic cycle.

Thio effects on the departure of the 3'-linked ribonucleoside from diribonucleoside 3',3'-phosphorodithioate diesters and triribonucleoside 3',3',5'-phosphoromonothioate triesters: implications for ribozyme catalysis

To provide a solid chemical basis for the mechanistic interpretations of the thio effects observed for large ribozymes, the cleavage of triribonucleoside 3',3',5'-phosphoromonothioate triesters and diribonucleoside 3',3'-phosphorodithioate diesters has been studied. To elucidate the role of the neighboring hydroxy group of the departing 3'-linked nucleoside, hydrolysis of 2',3'-O-methyleneadenosin-5'-yl bis[5'-O-methyluridin-3'-yl] phosphoromonothioate (1 a) has been compared to the hydrolysis of 2',3'-O-methyleneadenosin-5'-yl 5'-O-methyluridin-3'-yl 2',5'-di-O-methyluridin-3'-yl phosphoromonothioate (1 b) and the hydrolysis of bis[uridin-3'-yl] phosphorodithioate (2 a) to the hydrolysis of uridin-3'-yl 2',5'-di-O-methyluridin-3'-yl phosphorodithioate (2 b). The reactions have been followed by RP HPLC over a wide pH range. The phosphoromonothioate triesters 1 a,b undergo two competing reactions: the starting material is cleaved to a mixture of 3',3'- and 3',5'-diesters, and isomerized to 2',3',5'- and 2',2',5'-triesters. With phosphorodithioate diesters 2 a,b, hydroxide-ion-catalyzed cleavage of the P--O3' bond is the only reaction detected at pH >6, but under more acidic conditions desulfurization starts to compete with the cleavage. The 3',3'-diesters do not undergo isomerization. The hydroxide-ion-catalyzed cleavage reaction with both 1 a and 2 a is 27 times as fast as that compared with their 2'-O-methylated counterparts 1 b and 2 b. The hydroxide-ion-catalyzed isomerization of the 3',3',5'-triester to 2',3',5'- and 2',2',5'-triesters with 1 a is 11 times as fast as that compared with 1 b. These accelerations have been accounted for by stabilization of the anionic phosphorane intermediate by hydrogen bonding with the 2'-hydroxy function. Thio substitution of the nonbridging oxygens has an almost negligible influence on the cleavage of 3',3'-diesters 2 a,b, but the hydrolysis of phosphoromonothioate triesters 1 a,b exhibits a sizable thio effect, k(PO)/k(PS)=19. The effects of metal ions on the rate of the cleavage of diesters and triesters have been studied and discussed in terms of the suggested hydrogen-bond stabilization of the thiophosphorane intermediates derived from 1 a and 2 a.

Syntheses of (2')3'-15N-amino-(2')3'-deoxyguanosine and determination of their pKa values by 15N NMR spectroscopy

2'-Amino-2'-deoxyguanosine and 3'-amino-3'-deoxyguanosine are valuable probes for investigating the metal ion interactions at the active site of the group I ribozyme. However, these experiments require a thorough understanding of the protonation state of the amino group at a specific pH. Here, we describe the first syntheses of 2'-15N-amino-2'-deoxyadenosine, 2'-15N-amino-2'-deoxyguanosine, and 3'-15N-amino-3'-deoxyguanosine. The 15N-enriched nucleus allows convenient and accurate determination of the amine pKa by 15N NMR.

Reactions of phosphate and phosphorothiolate diesters with nucleophiles: comparison of transition state structures

A series of methyl aryl phosphorothiolate esters (SP) were synthesized and their reactions with pyridine derivatives were compared to those for methyl aryl phosphate esters (OP). Results show that SP esters react with pyridine nucleophiles via a concerted S(N)2(P) mechanism. Brønsted analysis suggests that reactions of both SP and OP esters proceed via transition states with dissociative character. The overall similarity of the transition state structures supports the use of phosphorothiolates as substrate analogues to probe mechanisms of enzyme-catalyzed phosphoryl transfer reactions.

RNA splicing: group I intron crystal structures reveal the basis of splice site selection and metal ion catalysis

The group I intron has served as a model for RNA catalysis since its discovery 25 years ago. Four recently determined high-resolution crystal structures complement extensive biochemical studies on this system. Structures of the Azoarcus, Tetrahymena and bacteriophage Twort group I introns mimic different states of the splicing or ribozyme reaction pathway and provide information on splice site selection and metal ion catalysis. The 5'-splice site is selected by formation of a conserved G.U wobble pair between the 5'-exon terminus and the intron. The 3'-splice site is identified through stacking of three base triples, in which the middle triple contains the conserved terminal nucleotide of the intron, OmegaG. The structures support a two-metal-ion mechanism for group I intron splicing that might have corollaries to group II intron and pre-mRNA splicing by the spliceosome.

Improved synthesis of 2'-amino-2'-deoxyguanosine and its phosphoramidite

2'-Amino-2'-deoxynucleosides and oligonucleotides containing them have proven highly effective for an array of biochemical applications. The guanosine analogue and its phosphoramidite derivatives have been accessed previously from 2'-amino-2'-deoxyuridine by transglycosylation, but with limited overall efficiency and convenience. Using simple modifications of known reaction types, we have developed useful protocols to obtain 2'-amino-2'-deoxyguanosine and two of its phosphoramidite derivatives with greater convenience, fewer steps, and higher yields than reported previously. These phosphoramidites provide effective synthons for the incorporation of 2'-amino-2'-deoxyguanosine into oligonucleotides.

Functional identification of catalytic metal ion binding sites within RNA

The viability of living systems depends inextricably on enzymes that catalyze phosphoryl transfer reactions. For many enzymes in this class, including several ribozymes, divalent metal ions serve as obligate cofactors. Understanding how metal ions mediate catalysis requires elucidation of metal ion interactions with both the enzyme and the substrate(s). In the Tetrahymena group I intron, previous work using atomic mutagenesis and quantitative analysis of metal ion rescue behavior identified three metal ions (M_A, M_B, and M_C) that make five interactions with the ribozyme substrates in the reaction's transition state. Here, we combine substrate atomic mutagenesis with site-specific phosphorothioate substitutions in the ribozyme backbone to develop a powerful, general strategy for defining the ligands of catalytic metal ions within RNA. In applying this strategy to the Tetrahymena group I intron, we have identified the pro-S_P phosphoryl oxygen at nucleotide C262 as a ribozyme ligand for M_C. Our findings establish a direct connection between the ribozyme core and the functionally defined model of the chemical transition state, thereby extending the known set of transition-state interactions and providing information critical for the application of the recent group I intron crystallographic structures to the understanding of catalysis.

A combination of substrate atomic mutagenesis with site-specific substitutions in the ribozyme backbone allow the ligands of catalytic metal ions to be identified.

Catalytic Phosphoryl Interactions of Topoisomerase IB

The reversible nucleophilic substitution reaction catalyzed by the vaccinia virus type IB topoisomerase has been investigated by measuring the equilibrium and rate effects of stereospecific sulfur substitution at the two nonbridging oxygen atoms of the attacked phosphodiester group. An energetic analysis of the combined effects of sulfur substitution and site-directed mutagenesis of active site residues of the enzyme has identified enzyme interactions with each oxygen in the ground state and transition state. We use these findings in combination with previous structural and 5'-bridging sulfur substitution results to deduce the web of enzymatic interactions with the nonbridging oxygens as well as the 5'-hydroxyl leaving group. A key finding is the central role of Arg130, which forms electrostatic interactions with both nonbridging oxygens and the 5'-leaving group.

Hydrolysis of 2',3'-O-methyleneadenosin-5'-yl bis-5'-O-methyluridin-3'-yl phosphate: the 2'-hydroxy group stabilizes the phosphorane intermediate, not the departing 3'-oxyanion, by hydrogen bonding

Hydrolytic reactions of 2',3'-O-methyleneadenosin-5'-yl bis-5'-O-methyluridin-3'-yl phosphate (1a) have been followed by RP HPLC over a wide pH range to elucidate the role of the 2'-OH group as an intermolecular hydrogen bond donor facilitating the cleavage of 1a. At pH < 2, where the decomposition of 1 is first-order in hydronium-ion concentration, the P-O5' and P-O3' bonds are cleaved equally rapidly. Over a relatively wide range from pH 2 to 4, the hydrolysis is pH-independent and the P-O5' bond is cleaved 1.6 times as rapidly as the P-O3' bond. At pH 6, the reaction becomes first-order in hydroxide-ion concentration and cleavage of the P-O3' bond starts to predominate, accounting for 89% of the overall hydrolysis in 10 mmol L(-)(1) aqueous sodium hydroxide. Under alkaline conditions, the 2'-OH group facilitates the cleavage of 1 by a factor of 27 compared to the 2'-OMe counterpart, the influence on the P-O3' and P-O5' bond cleavage being equal. Accordingly, the 2'-hydroxy group stabilizes the phosphorane intermediate, not the departing 3'-oxyanion, by hydrogen bonding.

General acid catalysis by the hepatitis delta virus ribozyme

Recent crystallographic and functional analyses of RNA enzymes have raised the possibility that the purine and pyrimidine nucleobases may function as general acid-base catalysts. However, this mode of nucleobase-mediated catalysis has been difficult to establish unambiguously. Here, we used a hyperactivated RNA substrate bearing a 5'-phosphorothiolate to investigate the role of a critical cytosine residue in the hepatitis delta virus ribozyme. The hyperactivated substrate specifically suppressed the deleterious effects of cytosine mutations and pH changes, thereby linking the protonation of the nucleobase to leaving-group stabilization. We conclude that the active-site cytosine provides general acid catalysis, mediating proton transfer to the leaving group through a protonated N3-imino nitrogen. These results establish a specific role for a nucleobase in a ribozyme reaction and support the proposal that RNA nucleobases may function in a manner analogous to that of catalytic histidine residues in protein enzymes.

Phosphodiester cleavage of guanylyl-(3',3')-(2'-amino-2'-deoxyuridine): rate acceleration by the 2'-amino function

Hydrolytic reactions of the structural analogue of guanylyl-(3',3')-uridine, guanylyl-(3',3')-(2'-amino-2'-deoxyuridine), having one of the 2'-hydroxyl groups replaced with an amino function, have been followed by RP HPLC in the pH range 0-13 at 90 degrees C. The results are compared to those obtained earlier with guanylyl-(3',3')-uridine, guanylyl-(3',3')-(2',5'-di-O-methyluridine), and uridylyl-(3',5')-uridine. Under basic conditions (pH > 8), the hydroxide ion-catalyzed cleavage of the P-O3' bond (first-order in [OH(-)]) yields a mixture of 2'-amino-2'-deoxyuridine and guanosine 2',3'-cyclic phosphate which is hydrolyzed to guanosine 2'- and 3'-phosphates. Under these conditions, guanylyl-(3',3')-(2'-amino-2'-deoxyuridine) is 10 times less reactive than guanylyl-(3',3')-uridine. Under acidic and neutral conditions (pH 3-8), where the pH-rate profile for the cleavage consists of two pH-independent regions (from pH 3 to pH 4 and from 6 to 8), guanylyl-(3',3')-(2'-amino-2'-deoxyuridine) is considerably reactive. For example, in the latter pH range, guanylyl-(3',3')-(2'-amino-2'-deoxyuridine) is more than 2 orders of magnitude more labile than guanylyl-(3',3')-(2',5'-di-O-methyluridine), while in the former pH range the reactivity difference is 1 order of magnitude. Under very acidic conditions (pH < 3), the isomerization giving guanylyl-(2',3')-(2'-amino-2'-deoxyuridine) and depurination yielding guanine (both first-order in [H(+)]) compete with the cleavage. The Zn(2+)-promoted cleavage ([Zn(2+)] = 5 mmol L(-)(1)) is 15 times faster than the uncatalyzed reaction at pH 5.6. The mechanisms of the reactions of guanylyl-(3',3')-(2'-amino-2'-deoxyuridine) are discussed, particularly focusing on the possible stabilization of phosphorane intermediate and/or transition state via an intramolecular hydrogen bonding by the 2'-amino group.

New strategies for exploring RNA's 2'-OH expose the importance of solvent during group II intron catalysis

The 2'-hydroxyl group contributes inextricably to the functional behavior of many RNA molecules, fulfilling numerous essential chemical roles. To assess how hydroxyl groups impart functional behavior to RNA, we developed a series of experimental strategies using an array of nucleoside analogs. These strategies provide the means to investigate whether a hydroxyl group influences function directly (via hydrogen bonding or metal ion coordination), indirectly (via space-filling capacity, inductive effects, and sugar conformation), or through interactions with solvent. The nucleoside analogs span a broad range of chemical diversity, such that quantitative structure activity relationships (QSAR) now become possible in the exploration of RNA biology. We employed these strategies to investigate the spliced exons reopening (SER) reaction of the group II intron. Our results suggest that the cleavage site 2'-hydroxyl may mediate an interaction with a water molecule.

Principles of RNA Compaction: Insights from the Equilibrium Folding Pathway of the P4-P6 RNA Domain in Monovalent Cations

Counterions are required for RNA folding, and divalent metal ions such as Mg(2+) are often critical. To dissect the role of counterions, we have compared global and local folding of wild-type and mutant variants of P4-P6 RNA derived from the Tetrahymena group I ribozyme in monovalent and in divalent metal ions. A remarkably simple picture of the folding thermodynamics emerges. The equilibrium folding pathway in monovalent ions displays two phases. In the first phase, RNA molecules that are initially in an extended conformation enforced by charge-charge repulsion are relaxed by electrostatic screening to a state with increased flexibility but without formation of long-range tertiary contacts. At higher concentrations of monovalent ions, a state that is nearly identical to the native folded state in the presence of Mg(2+) is formed, with tertiary contacts that involve base and backbone interactions but without the subset of interactions that involve specific divalent metal ion-binding sites. The folding model derived from these and previous results provides a robust framework for understanding the equilibrium and kinetic folding of RNA.

A systematic method for identifying small-molecule modulators of protein-protein interactions

Discovering small-molecule modulators of protein-protein interactions is a challenging task because of both the generally noncontiguous, large protein surfaces that form these interfaces and the shortage of high-throughput approaches capable of identifying such rare inhibitors. We describe here a robust and flexible methodology that couples disruption of protein-protein complexes to host cell survival. The feasibility of this approach was demonstrated through monitoring a small-molecule-mediated protein-protein association (FKBP12-rapamycin-FRAP) and two cases of dissociation (homodimeric HIV-1 protease and heterodimeric ribonucleotide reductase). For ribonucleotide reductase, we identified cyclic peptide inhibitors from genetically encoded libraries that dissociated the enzyme subunits. A solid-phase synthetic strategy and peptide ELISAs were developed to characterize these inhibitors, resulting in the discovery of cyclic peptides that operate in an unprecedented manner, thus highlighting the strengths of a functional approach. The ability of this method to process large libraries, coupled with the benefits of a genetic selection, allowed us to identify rare, uniquely active small-molecule modulators of protein-protein interactions at a frequency of less than one in 10 million.

Cross talk between the +73/294 interaction and the cleavage site in RNase P RNA mediated cleavage

To monitor functionally important metal ions and possible cross talk in RNase P RNA mediated cleavage we studied cleavage of substrates, where the 2'OH at the RNase P cleavage site (at -1) and/or at position +73 had been replaced with a 2' amino group (or 2'H). Our data showed that the presence of 2' modifications at these positions affected cleavage site recognition, ground state binding of substrate and/or rate of cleavage. Cleavage of 2' amino substituted substrates at different pH showed that substitution of Mg2+ by Mn2+ (or Ca2+), identity of residues at and near the cleavage site, and addition of C5 protein influenced the frequency of miscleavage at -1 (cleavage at the correct site is referred to as +1). From this we infer that these findings point at effects mediated by protonation/deprotonation of the 2' amino group, i.e. an altered charge distribution, at the site of cleavage. Moreover, our data suggested that the structural architecture of the interaction between the 3' end of the substrate and RNase P RNA influence the charge distribution at the cleavage site as well as the rate of cleavage under conditions where the chemistry is suggested to be rate limiting. Thus, these data provide evidence for cross talk between the +73/294 interaction and the cleavage site in RNase P RNA mediated cleavage. We discuss the role metal ions might play in this cross talk and the likelihood that at least one functionally important metal ion is positioned in the vicinity of, and use the 2'OH at the cleavage site as an inner or outer sphere ligand.

An Atomic Mutation Cycle for Exploring RNA's 2‘-Hydroxyl Group

The 2'-hydroxyl group fulfills numerous structural and functional roles in RNA, including those of hydrogen bond donor and acceptor. While loss of function upon 2'-deoxynucleotide substitution establishes the importance of specific 2'-hydroxyl groups within RNA, this approach provides no information about how these hydroxyl groups impart their functional contribution. We use an atomic mutation cycle to evaluate the functional importance of the 2'-hydroxyl group's hydrogen atom. Using the Tetrahymena ribozyme reaction, we challenge the cycle to expose the catalytic contribution of the cleavage site 2'-hydroxyl group and its associated hydrogen bond network. The results establish the viability of this cycle as an approach to reveal 2'-hydroxyl groups that donate functionally significant hydrogen bonds.

Hydrolytic Reactions of Guanosyl-(3‘,3‘)-uridine and Guanosyl-(3‘,3‘)-(2‘,5‘-di-O-methyluridine)

Hydrolytic reactions of guanosyl-(3',3')-uridine and guanosyl-(3',3')-(2',5'-di-O-methyluridine) have been followed by RP HPLC over a wide pH range at 363.2 K in order to elucidate the role of the 2'-hydroxyl group as a hydrogen-bond donor upon departure of the 3'-uridine moiety. Under neutral and basic conditions, guanosyl-(3',3')-uridine undergoes hydroxide ion-catalyzed cleavage (first order in [OH(-)]) of the P-O3' bonds, giving uridine and guanosine 2',3'-cyclic monophosphates, which are subsequently hydrolyzed to a mixture of 2'- and 3'-monophosphates. This bond rupture is 23 times as fast as the corresponding cleavage of the P-O3' bond of guanosyl-(3',3')-(2',5'-di-O-methyluridine) to yield 2',5'-O-dimethyluridine and guanosine 2',3'-cyclic phosphate. Under acidic conditions, where the reactivity differences are smaller, depurination and isomerization compete with the cleavage. The effect of Zn(2+) on the cleavage of the P-O3' bonds of guanosyl-(3',3')-uridine is modest: about 6-fold acceleration was observed at [Zn(2+)] = 5 mmol L(-)(1) and pH 5.6. With guanosyl-(3',3')-(2',5'-di-O-methyluridine) the rate-acceleration effect is greater: a 37-fold acceleration was observed. The mechanisms of the partial reactions, in particular the effects of the 2'-hydroxyl group on the departure of the 3'-linked nucleoside, are discussed.

Efficient Synthesis of 2‘,3‘-Dideoxy-2‘-amino-3‘-thiouridine

[reaction: see text] Metal ion rescue experiments provide a powerful approach to establish the presence and role of divalent metal ions in the biological function of RNA. The utility of this approach depends on the availability of suitable nucleoside analogues. To expand the range of this experimental strategy, we describe the first synthesis of 2',3'-dideoxy-2'-amino-3'-thiouridine (12) in 19.5% overall yield starting from 2,2'-anhydrouridine (1).

Selective inhibition of calcineurin-NFAT signaling by blocking protein-protein interaction with small organic molecules

Transient or reversible protein-protein interactions are commonly used to ensure efficient targeting of signaling enzymes to their cellular substrates. These interactions include direct binding to substrate, interaction with an accessory or scaffold protein, and positioning at subcellular locations in proximity to substrates. The existence of specialized targeting mechanisms raises the possibility of designing inhibitors that do not block enzyme activity per se, but rather interfere with targeting of the enzyme to one or more of its substrates within the cell. Here, we identify small organic molecules that specifically block targeting of the protein phosphatase calcineurin to its substrate nuclear factor of activated T cells (NFAT, also termed NFATc) and show that they are effective inhibitors of calcineurin-NFAT signaling.

RISC is a 5' phosphomonoester-producing RNA endonuclease

Gene silencing in the process of RNA interference is mediated by a ribonucleoprotein complex referred to as RNA-induced silencing complex (RISC). Here we describe the molecular mechanism of target RNA cleavage using affinity-purified minimal RISC from human cells. Cleavage proceeds via hydrolysis and the release of a 3'-hydroxyl and a 5'-phosphate terminus. Substitution of the 2'-hydroxyl group at the cleavage site by 2'-deoxy had no significant effect, suggesting that product release and/or a conformational transition rather than a chemical step is rate-limiting. Substitution by 2'-O-methyl at the cleavage site substantially reduced cleavage, which is presumably due to steric interference. Mutational analysis of the target RNA revealed that mismatches across from the 5' or the 3' end of the siRNA had little effect and that substrate RNAs as short as 15 nucleotides were cleaved by RISC.

Comparison of the cleavage profiles of oligonucleotide duplexes with or without phosphorothioate linkages by using a chemical nuclease probe

A manganese porphyrin complex, Mn-TMPyP, associated with KHSO(5) is a chemical nuclease able to selectively recognize the minor groove of three consecutive AT base pairs of DNA and to mediate very precise cleavage chemistry at that particular site. This specific recognition and cleavage were used to probe the accessibility of the minor groove of DNA duplexes composed of one phosphodiester strand and one phosphorothioate strand. The cleavage of 5'-GCAAAAGC/5'-GCTTTTGC duplexes by Mn-TMPyP/KHSO(5) was monitored by HPLC coupled to electrospray mass analysis. Each single strand was synthesized with all-phosphate, all- Rp-phosphorothioate and all- Sp-phosphorothioate internucleotide bonds. We found that the manganese porphyrin was able to recognize its favorite (AT)(3)-box binding site within the heteroduplexes, as in the case of natural DNA. Molecular modeling studies on the interactions of the reactive porphyrin manganese-oxo species with both types of duplexes confirmed the experimental data.

A homogeneous 384-well high-throughput binding assay for a TNF receptor using alphascreen technology

To take advantage of the growing knowledge of cellular signaling pathways, modern-day drug discovery faces an increasing challenge to develop assays to screen for compounds that modulate protein-protein interactions. One bottleneck in achieving this goal is a lack of suitable and robust assay technologies amenable to a high-throughput format. In this report, we describe how we utilized Alphascreen trade mark technology to develop a high-throughput assay to monitor ligand binding to a member of the tumor necrosis factor receptor superfamily. We expressed a fusion protein consisting of the extracellular domain of the OX40 receptor with the constant domains of human IgG. In the presence of OX40 ligand, we determined a binding affinity constant consistent with reported values and optimized the protocol to develop a simple, homogeneous, and sensitive binding assay in a 384-well format. Finally, we assessed if this system could identify small peptides capable of inhibiting the OX40 receptor and ligand interaction. The results showed that the assay was able to detect such peptides and could be used to launch a high-throughput screening campaign for small molecules able to prevent OX40 receptor activation.

Synthesis of phosphorothioamidites derived from 3'-thio-3'-deoxythymidine and 3'-thio-2',3'-dideoxycytidine and the automated synthesis of oligodeoxynucleotides containing a 3'-S-phosphorothiolate linkage

The synthesis of N4-benzoyl-5'-O-dimethoxytrityl-2',3'-dideoxy-3'-thiocytidine and its phosphorothioamidite is described for the first time, together with a shortened procedure for the preparation of 5'-O-dimethoxytrityl-3'-deoxy-3'-thiothymidine and its corresponding phosphorothioamidite. The first fully automated coupling procedure for the incorporation of a phosphorothioamidite into a synthetic oligodeoxynucleotide has been developed, which conveniently uses routine activators and reagents. Coupling yields using this protocol were in the range of 85-90% and good yields of singularly modified oligonucleotides were obtained. Coupling yields were also equally good when performed on either a 0.2 or 1 micro mol reaction column, thus facilitating large scale syntheses required for mechanistic studies.

Hydrolysis of 2‘,3‘-O-methyleneadenos-5‘-yl Bis(2‘,5‘-di-O-methylurid-3‘-yl) Phosphate, a Sugar O-Alkylated Trinucleoside 3‘,3‘,5‘-Monophosphate: Implications for the Mechanism of Large Ribozymes

Hydrolytic reactions of 2',3'-O-methyleneadenos-5'-yl bis(2',5'-di-O-methylurid-3'-yl) phosphate (1), a sugar O-alkylated trinucleoside 3',3',5'-monophosphate, have been followed by RP HPLC over a wide pH range. Under neutral and mildly acidic conditions, the only reaction observed was a pH-independent cleavage of the O-C5' bond of the 5'-linked nucleoside. Under more alkaline conditions nucleophilic attack by hydroxide ion starts to compete. The reaction is first order in [OH(-)] and becomes predominant at pH 10. Each of the 3'-linked nucleosides is displaced 2.9 times as readily as the 5'-linked one. To determine the beta(lg) value for the hydroxide ion catalyzed hydrolysis of 1, two diesters (2a,b) having 2',3'-O-methyleneadenosine (7) and 2',5'-di-O-methyluridine (4) as leaving groups were hydrolyzed under alkaline conditions. Since the beta(lg) value for this reaction is known, DeltapK(a) between 4 and 7 could be calculated. The beta(lg) for the hydrolysis of 1 was estimated to be -0.5 with use of this information. The mechanisms of the partial reactions and the role of leaving group properties in ribozyme reactions of large ribozymes are discussed.

Catalysis by RNase P RNA: unique features and unprecedented active site plasticity

Metal ions are essential cofactors for precursor tRNA (ptRNA) processing by bacterial RNase P. The ribose 2'-OH at nucleotide (nt) -1 of ptRNAs is known to contribute to positioning of catalytic Me2+. To investigate the catalytic process, we used ptRNAs with single 2'-deoxy (2'-H), 2'-amino (2'-N), or 2'-fluoro (2'-F) modifications at the cleavage site (nt -1). 2' modifications had small (2.4-7.7-fold) effects on ptRNA binding to E. coli RNase P RNA in the ground state, decreasing substrate affinity in the order 2'-OH > 2'-F > 2'-N > 2'-H. Effects on the rate of the chemical step (about 10-fold for 2'-F, almost 150-fold for 2'-H and 2'-N) were much stronger, and, except for the 2'-N modification, resembled strikingly those observed in the Tetrahymena ribozyme-catalyzed reaction at corresponding position. Mn2+ rescued cleavage of the 2'-N but also the 2'-H-modified ptRNA, arguing against a direct metal ion coordination at this location. Miscleavage between nt -1 and -2 was observed for the 2'-N-ptRNA at low pH (further influenced by the base identities at nt -1 and +73), suggesting repulsion of a catalytic metal ion due to protonation of the amino group. Effects caused by the 2'-N modification at nt -1 of the substrate allowed us to substantiate a mechanistic difference in phosphodiester hydrolysis catalyzed by Escherichia coli RNase P RNA and the Tetrahymena ribozyme: a metal ion binds next to the 2' substituent at nt -1 in the reaction catalyzed by RNase P RNA, but not at the corresponding location in the Tetrahymena ribozyme reaction.

Cross-modulation of the pKa of nucleobases in a single-stranded hexameric-RNA due to tandem electrostatic nearest-neighbor interactions

The pH titration studies (pH 6.7-12.1) in a series of dimeric, trimeric, tetrameric, pentameric, and hexameric oligo-RNA molecules [GpA (2a), GpC (3a), GpApC (5), GpA(1)pA(2)pC (6), GpA(1)pA(2)pA(3)pC (7), GpA(1)pA(2)pA(3)pA(4)pC (8)] have shown that the pK(a) of N(1)-H of 9-guaninyl could be measured not only from its own deltaH8G, but also from the aromatic marker protons of other constituent nucleobases. The relative chemical shift differences [Deltadelta((N)(-)(D))] between the protons in various nucleotide residues in the oligo-RNAs at the neutral (N) and deprotonated (D) states of the guanine moiety show that the generation of the 5'-(9-guanylate ion) in oligo-RNAs 2-8 reduces the stability of the stacked helical RNA conformation owing to the destabilizing anion(G(-))-pi/dipole(Im(delta)(-)) interaction. This destabilizing effect in the deprotonated RNA is, however, opposed by the electrostatically attractive atom-pisigma (major) as well as the anion(G(-))-pi/dipole(Py(delta)(+)) (minor) interactions. Our studies have demonstrated that the electrostatically repulsive anion(G(-))-pi/dipole(Im(delta)(-)) interaction propagates from the first to the third nucleobase quite strongly in the oligo-RNAs 6-8, causing destacking of the helix, and then its effect is gradually reduced, although it is clearly NMR detectable along the RNA chain. Thus, such specific generation of a charge at a single nucleobase moiety allows us to explore the relative strength of stacking within a single-stranded helix. The pK(a) of 5'-Gp residue from its own deltaH8G in the hexameric RNA 8 is found to be 9.76 +/- 0.01; it, however, varies from 9.65 +/- 0.01 to 10.5 +/- 0.07 along the RNA chain as measured from the other marker protons (H2, H8, H5, and H6) of 9-adeninyl and 1-cytosinyl residues. This nucleobase-dependent modulation of pK(a)s (DeltapK(a) +/- 0.9) of 9-guaninyl obtained from other nucleobases in the hexameric RNA 8 represents a difference of ca. 5.1 kJ mol(-)(1), which has been attributed to the variable strength of electrostatic interactions between the electron densities of the involved atoms in the offset stacked nucleobases as well as with that of the phosphates. The chemical implication of this variable pK(a) for guanin-9-yl deprotonation as obtained from all other marker protons of each nucleotide residue within a ssRNA molecule is that it enables us to experimentally understand the variation of the electronic microenvironment around each constituent nucleobase along the RNA chain in a stepwise manner with very high accuracy without having to make any assumption. This means that the pseudoaromaticity of neighboring 9-adeninyl and next-neighbor nucleobases within a polyanionic sugar-phosphate backbone of a ssRNA can vary from one case to another due to cross-modulation of an electronically coupled pi system by a neighboring nucleobase. This modulation may depend on the sequence context, spatial proximity of the negatively charged phosphates, as well as whether the offset stacking is ON or OFF. The net outcome of this electrostatic interaction between the neighbors is creation of new sequence-dependent hybrid nucleobases in an oligo- or polynucleotide whose properties are unlike the monomeric counterpart, which may have considerable biological implications.

Protein grafting of an HIV-1-inhibiting epitope

Protein grafting, the transfer of a binding epitope of one ligand onto the surface of another protein, is a potentially powerful technique for presenting peptides in preformed and active three-dimensional conformations. Its utility, however, has been limited by low biological activity of the designed ligands and low tolerance of the protein scaffolds to surface substitutions. Here, we graft the complete binding epitope (19 nonconsecutive amino acids with a solvent-accessible surface area of >2,000 A2) of an HIV-1 C-peptide, which is derived from the C-terminal region of HIV-1 gp41 and potently inhibits HIV-1 entry into cells, onto the surface of a GCN4 leucine zipper. The designed peptide, named C34coil, displays a potent antiviral activity approaching that of the native ligand. Moreover, whereas the linear C-peptide is unstructured and sensitive to degradation by proteases, C34coil is well structured, conformationally stable, and exhibits increased resistance to proteolytic degradation compared with the linear peptide. In addition to being a structured antiviral inhibitor, C34coil may also serve as the basis for the development of an alternative class of immunogens. This study demonstrates that "one-shot" protein grafting, without subsequent rounds of optimization, can be used to create ligands with structural conformations and improved biomedical properties.

Catalysis of amide synthesis by RNA phosphodiester and hydroxyl groups

The functional groups found among the RNA bases and in the phosphoribose backbone represent a limited repertoire from which to construct a ribozyme active site. This work investigates the possibility that simple RNA phosphodiester and hydroxyl functional groups could catalyze amide bond synthesis. Reaction of amine groups with activated esters would be catalyzed by a group that stabilizes the partial positive charge on the amine nucleophile in the transition state. 2'-Amine substitutions adjacent to 3'-phosphodiester or 3'-hydroxyl groups react efficiently with activated esters to form 2'-amide and peptide products. In contrast, analogs in which the 3'-phosphodiester is replaced by an uncharged phosphotriester or is constrained in a distal conformation react at least 100-fold more slowly. Similarly, a nucleoside in which the 3'-hydroxyl group is constrained trans to the 2'-amine is also unreactive. Catalysis of synthetic reactions by RNA phosphodiester and ribose hydroxyl groups is likely to be even greater in the context of a preorganized and solvent-excluding catalytic center. One such group is the 2'-hydroxyl of the ribosome-bound P-site adenosine substrate, which is close to the amine nucleophile in the peptidyl synthesis reaction. Given ubiquitous 2'-OH groups in RNA, there exists a decisive advantage for RNA over DNA in catalyzing reactions of biological significance.

Probing the Tetrahymena group I ribozyme reaction in both directions

The Tetrahymena L-21 ScaI ribozyme derived from the self-splicing group I intron catalyzes a reversible reaction analogous to the first step of self-splicing: CCCUCUA (S) + [UC]G right harpoon over left harpoon CCCUCU (P) + [UC]GA. To relate our understanding of the ribozyme to the self-splicing reaction and to further the mechanistic dissection of the ribozyme reaction, we have established a quantitative kinetic and thermodynamic framework for the forward and reverse reaction of the L-21 ScaI ribozyme under identical conditions. Examination of the framework shows that binding of products is cooperative with binding enhanced 5-fold, as was observed previously for binding of the substrates. Further, binding of UCGA is 12-fold weaker than binding of the unphosphorylated UCG, analogous to the 20-fold weaker binding of phosphorylated S relative to P; the molecular interactions underlying the stronger binding of UCG were traced to the 3'-hydroxyl group of UCG. The symmetrical effects on binding of substrates and products result in the equilibrium between ribozyme-bound species, K(int), that is essentially unperturbed from the solution equilibrium, K(ext) (K(int) = [E.P.UCGA]/[E.S.UCG] = 4.6 and K(ext) = [P][UCGA]/[S][UCG] = 1.9). Last, we show that the pK(a) values of the nucleophiles in the forward and reverse reactions are >/=10. This observation suggests that metal ion activation of the nucleophile and stabilization of the leaving group can only account for a portion of the rate enhancement of this ribozyme. These and prior results suggest that the Tetrahymena group I ribozyme, analogous to protein enzymes, uses multiple catalytic strategies to achieve its large rate enhancement.

Identification of an active site ligand for a group I ribozyme catalytic metal ion

The transition state of the group I intron self-splicing reaction is stabilized by three metal ions. The functional groups within the intron substrates (guanosine and an oligoribonucleotide mimic of the 5'-exon) that coordinate these metal ions have been systematically defined through a series of metal ion specificity switch experiments. In contrast, the catalytic metal ligands within the ribozyme active site are unknown. In an effort to identify them, stereospecific (R(P) or S(P)) single-site phosphorothioate substitutions were introduced at five phosphates predicted to be in the vicinity of the catalytic center (A207, C208, A304, U305, and A306) within the Tetrahymena intron. Of the 10 ribozymes that were studied, four phosphorothioate substitutions (A207 S(P), C208 S(P), A306 R(P), and A306 S(P)) exhibited a significant reduction in the cleavage rate. Only the effect of the C208 S(P) phosphorothioate substitution could be significantly rescued by the addition of a thiophilic metal ion, either Mn(2+) or Zn(2+), when tested with an all-oxy substrate. The effect was not rescued with Cd(2+). To determine if one of the catalytic metal ions is coordinated to the C208 pro-S(P) oxygen, the phosphorothioate-substituted ribozymes were also assayed using oligonucleotide substrates with a 3'-phosphorothiolate or an S(P) phosphorothioate substitution at the scissile phosphate. This resulted in a second metal specificity switch, in that Mn(2+) or Zn(2+) no longer rescued the C208 S(P) ribozyme, but Cd(2+) provided efficient rescue in the context of either sulfur-containing substrate. The 3'-oxygen and the pro-S(P) oxygen of the scissile phosphate are both known to coordinate the same metal ion, M(A), which stabilizes the negative charge on the leaving group 3'-oxygen in the transition state. Taken together, these data suggest that metal M(A) is coordinated to the C208 pro-S(P) phosphate oxygen, which constitutes the first functional link between a specific catalytic metal ion and a particular functional group within the group I ribozyme active site.

Comparison of metal-ion-dependent cleavages of RNA by a DNA enzyme and a hammerhead ribozyme

Joyce's DNA enzyme catalyzes cleavage of RNAs with almost the same efficiency as the hammerhead ribozyme. The cleavage activity of the DNA enzyme was pH dependent, and the logarithm of the cleavage rate increased linearly with pH from pH 6 to pH 9 with a slope of approximately unity. The existence of an apparent solvent isotope effect, with cleavage of RNA by the DNA enzyme in H(2)O being 4.3 times faster than cleavage in D(2)O, was in accord with the interpretation that, at a given pH, the concentration of the active species (deprotonated species) is 4.3 times higher in H(2)O than the concentration in D(2)O. This leads to the intrinsic isotope effect of unity, demonstrating that no proton transfer occurs in the transition state in reactions catalyzed by the DNA enzyme. Addition of La(3+) ions to the Mg(2+)-background reaction mixture inhibited the DNA enzyme-catalyzed reactions, suggesting the replacement of catalytically and/or structurally important Mg(2+) ions by La(3+) ions. Similar kinetic features of DNA enzyme mediated cleavage of RNA and of hammerhead ribozyme-mediated cleavage suggest that a very similar catalytic mechanism is used by the two types of enzyme, despite their different compositions.

Leaving group stabilization by metal ion coordination and hydrogen bond donation is an evolutionarily conserved feature of group I introns

To understand the behavior of group I introns on a biologically fundamental level, we must distinguish those traits that arise as the products of natural selection (selected traits) from those that arise as the products of neutral drift (non-selected traits). In practice, this distinction relies on comparing the similarities and differences among widely divergent introns to identify conserved traits. Here we address whether the strategies used by the eukaryotic group I intron from the Tetrahymena ciliate to stabilize the leaving group during splicing are maintained in the group I intron from the widely divergent Azoarcus bacterium. A substrate analogue containing a 3'-phosphorothiolate linkage, in which a sulfur atom replaces the bridging 3'-oxygen atom of the scissile phosphate, reacts 20-fold slower in the Azoarcus reaction than the corresponding unmodified substrate in the presence of Mg(II) as the only divalent cation. However, Mn(II) relieves this negative effect such that the 3'-S-P bond cleaves 21-fold faster than does the 3'O-P bond. Other thiophilic divalent metal ions such as Co(II), Cd(II), and Zn(II) similarly support cleavage of the S-P bond. These results indicate that a metal ion directly coordinates to the leaving group in the transition state of the Azoarcus ribozyme reaction. Additionally, the 3'-sulfur substitution eliminates the approximately 10(3)-fold contribution of the adjacent 2'-OH to transition state stabilization. Considering that sulfur accepts hydrogen bonds weakly compared to oxygen, this result suggests that the 2'-OH contributes to catalysis by donating a hydrogen bond to the 3'-oxygen leaving group in the transition state, presumably acting in conjunction with the metal ion to stabilize the developing negative charge. These same catalytic strategies of metal ion coordination and hydrogen bond donation operate in the Tetrahymena ribozyme reaction, suggesting that these features of catalysis have been conserved during evolution and thus extend to all group I introns. The two ribozymes also exhibit quantitative differences in their response to 3'-sulfur substitution. The Azoarcus ribozyme binds and cleaves the phosphorothiolate substrate more efficiently relative to the natural substrate than the Tetrahymena ribozyme under the same conditions, suggesting that the Azoarcus ribozyme better accommodates the phosphorothiolate at the active site both in the ground state and in the transition state. These differences may reflect either a less tightly knit Azoarcus structure and/or spatial deviations between backbone atoms in the two ribozymes that arise during divergent evolution, analogous to the well-documented relationship between protein sequence and structure.

The tetrahymena ribozyme cleaves a 5'-methylene phosphonate monoester approximately 10(2)-fold faster than a normal phosphate diester: implications for enzyme catalysis of phosphoryl transfer reactions

Single-atom substrate modifications have revealed an intricate network of transition state interactions in the Tetrahymena ribozyme reaction. So far, these studies have targeted virtually every oxygen atom near the reaction center, except one, the 5'-bridging oxygen atom of the scissile phosphate. To address whether interactions with this atom play any role in catalysis, we used a new type of DNA substrate in which the 5'-oxygen is replaced with a methylene (-CH2-) unit. Under (kcat/Km)S conditions, the methylene phosphonate monoester substrate dCCCUCUT(mp)TA4 (where mp indicates the position of the phosphonate linkage) unexpectedly reacts approximately 10(3)-fold faster than the analogous control substrates lacking the -CH2- modification. Experiments with DNA-RNA chimeric substrates reveal that the -CH2- modification enhances docking of the substrates into the catalytic core of the ribozyme by approximately 10-fold and stimulates the chemical cleavage by approximately 10(2)-fold. The docking effect apparently arises from the ability of the -CH2- unit to suppress inherently deleterious effects caused by the thymidine residue that immediately follows the cleavage site. To analyze the -O- to -CH2- modification in the absence of this thymidine residue, we prepared oligonucleotide substrates containing methyl phosphate or ethyl phosphonate at the reaction center, thereby eliminating the 3'-terminal TA4 nucleotidyl group. In this context, the -O- to -CH2-modification has no effect on docking but retains the approximately 10(2)-fold effect on the chemical step. To investigate further the stimulatory influence on the chemical step, we measured the "intrinsic" effect of the -O- to -CH2- modification in nonenzymatic reactions with nucleophiles. We found that in solution, the -CH2- modification stimulates chemical reactivity of the phosphorus center by <5-fold, substantially lower in magnitude than the stimulatory effect in the catalytic core of the ribozyme. The greater stimulatory effect of the -CH2- modification in the active site compared to in solution may arise from fortuitous changes in molecular geometry that allow the ribozyme to accommodate the phosphonate transition state better than the natural phosphodiester transition state. As the -CH2- unit lacks lone pair electrons, its effectiveness in the ribozyme reaction suggests that the 5'-oxygen of the scissile phosphate plays no role in catalysis via hydrogen bonding or metal ion coordination. Finally, we show by analysis of physical organic data that such interactions in general provide little catalytic advantage to RNA and protein phosphoryl transferases because the 5'-oxygen undergoes only a small buildup of negative charge during the reaction. In addition to its mechanistic significance for the Tetrahymena ribozyme reaction and phosphoryl transfer reactions in general, this work suggests that phosphonate monoesters may provide a novel molecular tool for determining whether the chemical step limits the rate of an enzymatic reaction. As methylene phosphonate monoesters react modestly faster than phosphate diesters in model reactions, a similarly modest stimulatory effect on an enzymatic reaction upon -CH2- substitution would suggest rate-limiting chemistry.

Defining the catalytic metal ion interactions in the Tetrahymena ribozyme reaction

Divalent metal ions play a crucial role in catalysis by many RNA and protein enzymes that carry out phosphoryl transfer reactions, and defining their interactions with substrates is critical for understanding the mechanism of biological phosphoryl transfer. Although a vast amount of structural work has identified metal ions bound at the active site of many phosphoryl transfer enzymes, the number of functional metal ions and the full complement of their catalytic interactions remain to be defined for any RNA or protein enzyme. Previously, thiophilic metal ion rescue and quantitative functional analyses identified the interactions of three active site metal ions with the 3'- and 2'-substrate atoms of the Tetrahymena group I ribozyme. We have now extended these approaches to probe the metal ion interactions with the nonbridging pro-S(P) oxygen of the reactive phosphoryl group. The results of this study combined with previous mechanistic work provide evidence for a novel assembly of catalytic interactions involving three active site metal ions. One metal ion coordinates the 3'-departing oxygen of the oligonucleotide substrate and the pro-S(P) oxygen of the reactive phosphoryl group; another metal ion coordinates the attacking 3'-oxygen of the guanosine nucleophile; a third metal ion bridges the 2'-hydroxyl of guanosine and the pro-S(P) oxygen of the reactive phosphoryl group. These results for the first time define a complete set of catalytic metal ion/substrate interactions for an RNA or protein enzyme catalyzing phosphoryl transfer.

Self-splicing of the Tetrahymena group I ribozyme without conserved base-triples

BACKGROUND

Group I introns share a conserved core region consisting of two domains, P8-P3-P7 and P4-P6, joined by four base-triples. We showed previously that the T4 td intron can perform phosphoester transfer reactions at two splice sites in the absence of both P4-P6 and the conserved base-triples, whereas it is barely able to perform the intact splicing reaction due to the difficulty of conducting the sequential reactions.

RESULTS

Based on previous findings, we constructed a bimolecular ribozyme lacking a large portion of P4-P6 and the base-triples from the Tetrahymena intron, on the assumption that the long-range interactions of the peripheral regions in the two RNAs can compensate for the deteriorated core. The bimolecular ribozyme performed the intact splicing reaction.

CONCLUSION

The present analysis indicates that the base-triples are nonessential, but that L4 and the distal part of P4 in P4-P6 are important for conducting the splicing reaction. The reconstituted self-splicing ribozyme provides an amenable system for analysing the role(s) of elements in the core region in the self-splicing reaction mechanism.

Recent advances in the elucidation of the mechanisms of action of ribozymes

The cleavage of RNA can be accelerated by a number of factors. These factors include an acidic group (Lewis acid) or a basic group that aids in the deprotonation of the attacking nucleophile, in effect enhancing the nucleophilicity of the nucleophile; an acidic group that can neutralize and stabilize the leaving group; and any environment that can stabilize the pentavalent species that is either a transition state or a short-lived intermediate. The catalytic properties of ribozymes are due to factors that are derived from the complicated and specific structure of the ribozyme-substrate complex. It was postulated initially that nature had adopted a rather narrowly defined mechanism for the cleavage of RNA. However, recent findings have clearly demonstrated the diversity of the mechanisms of ribozyme-catalyzed reactions. Such mechanisms include the metal-independent cleavage that occurs in reactions catalyzed by hairpin ribozymes and the general double-metal-ion mechanism of catalysis in reactions catalyzed by the Tetrahymena group I ribozyme. Furthermore, the architecture of the complex between the substrate and the hepatitis delta virus ribozyme allows perturbation of the pK(a) of ring nitrogens of cytosine and adenine. The resultant perturbed ring nitrogens appear to be directly involved in acid/base catalysis. Moreover, while high concentrations of monovalent metal ions or polyamines can facilitate cleavage by hammerhead ribozymes, divalent metal ions are the most effective acid/base catalysts under physiological conditions.