Susceptibility of Goethite to Fe2+-Catalyzed Recrystallization over Time

Effect of Impurities on the Redox Properties of Goethite

Iron oxide minerals regulate the flux of electrons in the environment and are important hosts for trace and minor, yet critical, elements. Here, we present the first evidence of a direct link between the local coordination environments of Ni and Zn and the redox properties of their host phase goethite (α-FeOOH), the most abundant Fe(III) (oxyhydr)oxide at Earth's surface. We used aqueous redox measurements to show that the redox potential EH0, and hence the mineral's stability, follows the order: pure goethite ≥ Zn-goethite > Ni-goethite. Parallel X-ray absorption and scattering measurements demonstrate, using quantum-informed analysis, that the local coordination environment of the smaller impurity, Ni, causes more bulk strain energy than Zn, which nearly accounts for the difference in EH0 between Ni- and Zn-goethite. Our theory-informed, experimental study reveals how two common impurities affect the stability of goethite with implications for the biogeochemical reactivity of Fe(III) (oxyhydr)oxide in mediating elemental and electron fluxes in the environment.

Size-Dependent Reduction Kinetics of Iron Oxides in Single and Mixed Mineral Systems

Iron(III) (oxyhydr)oxide minerals with varying particle sizes commonly coexist in natural environments and are susceptible to both chemical and microbial reduction, affecting the fate and mobility of trace elements, nutrients, and pollutants. The size-dependent reduction behavior of iron (oxyhydr)oxides in single and mixed mineral systems remains poorly understood. In this study, we used microbial and mediated electrochemical reduction approaches to investigate the reduction kinetics and extents of goethite and hematite. We found that small particles were preferentially reduced relative to their large counterparts in single and mixed mineral systems regardless of microbial or electrochemical treatments, which is attributed to the combined effect of higher thermodynamic favorability and greater surface availability. In mixed mineral systems, small particles were reduced slightly faster, whereas large particles were reduced notably slower and less extensively than solely predicted from single mineral systems. Specifically, when reduced alone, small particles showed Fe(III) reduction rate constants that were 1.5- to 3.6-fold higher than large particles, while when reduced together, the reduction rate constants for small particles were 6- to 21-fold higher than the rate constants for large particles. These collective findings provide new insights into the pivotal role of nanoparticulate iron (oxyhydr)oxides in environmental redox reactions.

Effects of coexisting goethite or lepidocrocite on Fe(II)-induced ferrihydrite transformation pathways and Cd speciation

The efficacy of ferrihydrite in remediating Cd-contaminated soil is tightly regulated by Fe(II)-induced mineralogical transformations. Despite the common coexistence of iron minerals such as goethite and lepidocrocite, which can act as templates for secondary mineral formation, the impact of these minerals on Fe(II)-induced ferrihydrite transformation and the associated Cd fate have yet to be elucidated. Herein, we investigated the simultaneous evolution of secondary minerals and Cd speciation during Fe(II)-induced ferrihydrite transformation in the presence of goethite versus lepidocrocite. The presence of goethite resulted in a more pronounced ferrihydrite transformation than lepidocrocite because goethite facilitates electron transfer. Coexisting goethite promoted the production of secondary goethite with different morphology by triggering template-directed nucleation and growth of labile Fe(III) derived from ferrihydrite and intermediate lepidocrocite, respectively. However, coexisting lepidocrocite impeded goethite formation from ferrihydrite and acted as the template to facilitate secondary lepidocrocite production. Furthermore, variations in the crystallinity of coexisting lepidocrocite influenced the particle size and crystallinity of the secondary lepidocrocite, reflecting different dominant mechanisms in secondary lepidocrocite formation. Despite partial Cd mobilization into the solution due to Fe(II)-induced ferrihydrite transformation, secondary goethite and lepidocrocite re-sequestered Cd through lattice Fe(III) substitution, indicated by an increased structural Cd proportion, expanded lattice spacing, and reduced hyperfine field intensity. Additionally, secondary goethite was more effective than secondary lepidocrocite in sequestering Cd. Coexisting goethite increased the structural Cd proportion by 3.5-fold compared to coexisting lepidocrocite, demonstrating the superior ability of coexisting goethite in enhancing Cd stability during Fe(II)-induced ferrihydrite transformation in natural soils. These findings highlight the impact of template-driven mineralogical transformation on Cd fate in polluted soils and provide crucial implications for toxic metal remediation using mineral amendments.

Tracking Initial Fe(II)-Driven Ferrihydrite Transformations: A Mössbauer Spectroscopy and Isotope Investigation

Transformation of nanocrystalline ferrihydrite to more stable microcrystalline Fe(III) oxides is rapidly accelerated under reducing conditions with aqueous Fe(II) present. While the major steps of Fe(II)-catalyzed ferrihydrite transformation are known, processes in the initial phase that lead to nucleation and the growth of product minerals remain unclear. To track ferrihydrite-Fe(II) interactions during this initial phase, we used Fe isotopes, Mössbauer spectroscopy, and extractions to monitor the structural, magnetic, and isotope composition changes of ferrihydrite within ∼30 min of Fe(II) exposure. We observed rapid isotope mixing between aqueous Fe(II) and ferrihydrite during this initial lag phase. Our findings from Mössbauer spectroscopy indicate that a more magnetically ordered Fe(III) phase initially forms that is distinct from ferrihydrite and bulk crystalline transformation products. The signature of this phase is consistent with the early stage emergence of lepidocrocite-like lamellae observed in previous transmission electron microscopy studies. Its signature is furthermore removed by xylenol extraction of Fe(III), the same approach used to identify a chemically labile form of Fe(III) resulting from Fe(II) contact that is correlated to the ultimate emergence of crystalline product phases detectable by X-ray diffraction. Our work indicates that the mineralogical changes in the initial lag phase of Fh transformation initiated by Fe(II)-Fh electron transfer are critical to understanding ferrihydrite behavior in soils and sediments, particularly with regard to metal uptake and release.

Redox Potentials of Magnetite Suspensions under Reducing Conditions

Predicting the redox behavior of magnetite in reducing soils and sediments is challenging because there is neither agreement among measured potentials nor consensus on which Fe(III) | Fe(II) equilibria are most relevant. Here, we measured open-circuit potentials of stoichiometric magnetite equilibrated over a range of solution conditions. Notably, electron transfer mediators were not necessary to reach equilibrium. For conditions where ferrous hydroxide precipitation was limited, Nernstian behavior was observed with an E_H vs pH slope of -179 ± 4 mV and an E_H vs Fe(II)_aq slope of -54 ± 4 mV. Our estimated E_H^o of 857 ± 8 mV closely matches a maghemite|aqueous Fe(II) E_H^o of 855 mV, suggesting that it plays a dominant role in poising the solution potential and that it's theoretical Nernst equation of E_H[mV] = 855 - 177 pH - 59 log [Fe²⁺] may be useful in predicting magnetite redox behavior under these conditions. At higher pH values and without added Fe(II), a distinct shift in potentials was observed, indicating that the dominant Fe(III)|Fe(II) couple(s) poising the potential changed. Our findings, coupled with previous Mössbauer spectroscopy and kinetic data, provide compelling evidence that the maghemite/Fe(II)_aq couple accurately predicts the redox behavior of stoichiometric magnetite suspensions in the presence of aqueous Fe(II) between pH values of 6.5 and 8.5.

Coexisting Goethite Promotes Fe(II)-Catalyzed Transformation of Ferrihydrite to Goethite

In redox-affected soil environments, electron transfer between aqueous Fe(II) and solid-phase Fe(III) catalyzes mineral transformation and recrystallization processes. While these processes have been studied extensively as independent systems, the coexistence of iron minerals is common in nature. Yet it remains unclear how coexisting goethite influences ferrihydrite transformation. Here, we reacted ferrihydrite and goethite mixtures with Fe(II) for 24 h. Our results demonstrate that with more goethite initially present in the mixture more ferrihydrite turned into goethite. We further used stable Fe isotopes to label different Fe pools and probed ferrihydrite transformation in the presence of goethite using 57Fe Mössbauer spectroscopy and changes in the isotopic composition of solid and aqueous phases. When ferrihydrite alone underwent Fe(II)-catalyzed transformation, Fe atoms initially in the aqueous phase mostly formed lepidocrocite, while those from ferrihydrite mostly formed goethite. When goethite was initially present, more goethite was formed from atoms initially in the aqueous phase, and nanogoethite formed from atoms initially in ferrihydrite. Our results suggest that coexisting goethite promotes formation of more goethite via Fe(II)-goethite electron transfer and template-directed nucleation and growth. We further hypothesize that electron transfer onto goethite followed by electron hopping onto ferrihydrite is another possible pathway to goethite formation. Our findings demonstrate that mineral transformation is strongly influenced by the composition of soil solid phases.

Facet-dependent Fe(II) redox chemistry on iron oxide for organic pollutant transformation and mechanisms

Fe(II) redox chemistry is a pivotal process of biogeochemical Fe cycle and the transformation of organic pollutants in subsurface aquifers, while its interfacial reactivity on iron oxides with varying surface chemistries remains largely unexplored. In this study, the redox processes of Fe(II) on two hematite with highly exposed {001} and {110} facets and their impacts on the transformation of nitrobenzene were investigated. Results suggest that Fe(II) adsorption is the rate-limiting step of the redox chain reactions, controlling the reduction potential (E_H). Nitrobenzene activates the facet electron transfer on hematite, leading to nitrobenzene reduction and Fe(II) oxidation. Moreover, {001} facet exhibits a higher reactivity and electron transport efficiency than {110} facet, which is attributed to a lower site density (0.809 #Fe/nm²) and a lower E_H of hematite {001} facet than that of {110} facet. It is worth noting that the facet-dependent reduction activity is more intense at low pH or high Fe(II) activity. A slight dissolution of {110} facet was observed, indicating hematite {001} facet exhibits higher thermodynamic stability than {110} facet. This study confirms the facet-dependent reducing activity of surface bound Fe(II) on hematite, providing a new perspective for in-depth understanding of the interfacial reactions on hematite. The findings of this work broaden the biogeochemical process of Fe cycle in subsurface environments and its impact on the fate of organic pollutants in groundwater.

Redox-Driven Recrystallization of PbO2

Lead(IV) oxide (PbO₂) is one of the lead corrosion products that forms on the inner surface of lead pipes used for drinking water supply. It can maintain low dissolved Pb(II) concentrations when free chlorine is present. When free chlorine is depleted, PbO₂ and soluble Pb(II) will co-occur in these systems. This study used a stable lead isotope (²⁰⁷Pb) as a tracer to examine the interaction between aqueous Pb(II) and solid PbO₂ at conditions with no net change in dissolved Pb concentration. While the dissolved Pb(II) concentration remained unchanged, significant isotope exchange occurred that indicated that substantial amounts (24.3-35.0% based on the homogeneous recrystallization model) of the Pb atoms in the PbO₂ solids had been exchanged with those in solution over 264 h. Neither α-PbO₂ nor β-PbO₂ displayed a change in mineralogy, particle size, or oxidation state after reaction with aqueous Pb(II). The combined isotope exchange and solid characterization results indicate that redox-driven recrystallization of PbO₂ had occurred. Such redox-driven recrystallization is likely to occur in water that stagnates in lead pipes that contain PbO₂, and this recrystallization may alter the reactivity of PbO₂ with respect to its stability and susceptibility to reductive dissolution.

Natural organic matter inhibits Ni stabilization during Fe(II)-catalyzed ferrihydrite transformation

Trace metals, such as nickel (Ni), are often found associated with ferrihydrite (Fh) in soil and sediment and have been shown to redistribute during Fe(II)-catalyzed transformation of Fh. Fe(II)-catalyzed transformation of Fh, however, is often inhibited when natural organic matter (NOM) is associated with Fh. To explore whether NOM affects the behavior of Ni during Fe(II)-catalyzed transformation of Fh, we tracked Ni distribution, Fe atom exchange, and mineral transformation of Fh and Fh coprecipitated with Suwannee River natural organic matter (SRNOM-Fh). As expected, in the absence of Fe(II), Fh and SRNOM-Fh did not transform to secondary Fe minerals after two weeks. We further observed little difference in Ni adsorption on SRNOM-Fh compared to Fh. In the presence of Fe(II), however, we found that Ni associated with SRNOM-Fh was more susceptible to acid extraction than Fh. Specifically, we found almost double the amount of Ni remaining in the Fh after mild extraction compared to SRNOM-Fh. XRD showed that Fh transformed to goethite and magnetite whereas SRNOM-Fh did not transform despite ⁵⁷Fe isotope tracer experiments confirmed that SRNOM-Fh underwent extensive atom exchange with aqueous Fe(II). Our findings suggest that Fe atom exchange may not be sufficient for obvious Ni stabilization and that transformation to secondary minerals may be necessary for Ni stabilization to occur.

The geologic history of seawater oxygen isotopes from marine iron oxides

The oxygen isotope composition (δ¹⁸O) of marine sedimentary rocks has increased by 10 to 15 per mil since Archean time. Interpretation of this trend is hindered by the dual control of temperature and fluid δ¹⁸O on the rocks' isotopic composition. A new δ¹⁸O record in marine iron oxides covering the past ~2000 million years shows a similar secular rise. Iron oxide precipitation experiments reveal a weakly temperature-dependent iron oxide-water oxygen isotope fractionation, suggesting that increasing seawater δ¹⁸O over time was the primary cause of the long-term rise in δ¹⁸O values of marine precipitates. The ¹⁸O enrichment may have been driven by an increase in terrestrial sediment cover, a change in the proportion of high- and low-temperature crustal alteration, or a combination of these and other factors.

Linking Isotope Exchange with Fe(II)-Catalyzed Dissolution of Iron(hydr)oxides in the Presence of the Bacterial Siderophore Desferrioxamine-B

Dissolution of Fe(III) phases is a key process in making iron available to biota and in the mobilization of associated trace elements. Recently, we have demonstrated that submicromolar concentrations of Fe(II) significantly accelerate rates of ligand-controlled dissolution of Fe(III) (hydr)oxides at circumneutral pH. Here, we extend this work by studying isotope exchange and dissolution with lepidocrocite (Lp) and goethite (Gt) in the presence of 20 or 50 μM desferrioxamine-B (DFOB). Experiments with Lp at pH 7.0 were conducted in carbonate-buffered suspensions to mimic environmental conditions. We applied a simple empirical model to determine dissolution rates and a more complex kinetic model that accounts for the observed isotope exchange and catalytic effect of Fe(II). The fate of added tracer ⁵⁷Fe(II) was strongly dependent on the order of addition of ⁵⁷Fe(II) and ligand. When DFOB was added first, tracer ⁵⁷Fe remained in solution. When ⁵⁷Fe(II) was added first, isotope exchange between surface and solution could be observed at pH 6.0 but not at pH 7.0 and 8.5 where ⁵⁷Fe(II) was almost completely adsorbed. During dissolution of Lp with DFOB, ratios of released ⁵⁶Fe and ⁵⁷Fe were largely independent of DFOB concentrations. In the absence of DFOB, addition of phenanthroline 30 min after tracer ⁵⁷Fe desorbed predominantly ⁵⁶Fe(II), indicating that electron transfer from adsorbed ⁵⁷Fe to ⁵⁶Fe of the Lp surface occurs on a time scale of minutes to hours. In contrast, comparable experiments with Gt desorbed predominantly ⁵⁷Fe(II), suggesting a longer time scale for electron transfer on the Gt surface. Our results show that addition of 1-5 μM Fe(II) leads to dynamic charge transfer between dissolved and adsorbed species and to isotope exchange at the surface, with the dissolution of Lp by ligands accelerated by up to 60-fold.

Phenazine-1-Carboxylic Acid-Producing Bacteria Enhance the Reactivity of Iron Minerals in Dryland and Irrigated Wheat Rhizospheres

Phenazine-1-carboxylic acid (PCA) is a broad-spectrum antibiotic produced by rhizobacteria in the dryland wheat fields of the Columbia Plateau. PCA and other phenazines reductively dissolve Fe and Mn oxyhydroxides in bacterial culture systems, but the impact of PCA upon Fe and Mn cycling in the rhizosphere is unknown. Here, concentrations of dithionite-extractable and poorly crystalline Fe were approximately 10% and 30-40% higher, respectively, in dryland and irrigated rhizospheres inoculated with the PCA-producing (PCA⁺) strain Pseudomonas synxantha 2-79 than in rhizospheres inoculated with a PCA-deficient mutant. However, rhizosphere concentrations of Fe(II) and Mn did not differ significantly, indicating that PCA-mediated redox transformations of Fe and Mn were transient or were masked by competing processes. Total Fe and Mn uptake into wheat biomass also did not differ significantly, but the PCA⁺ strain significantly altered Fe translocation into shoots. X-ray absorption near edge spectroscopy revealed an abundance of Fe-bearing oxyhydroxides and phyllosilicates in all rhizospheres. These results indicate that the PCA⁺ strain enhanced the reactivity and mobility of Fe derived from soil minerals without producing parallel changes in plant Fe uptake. This is the first report that directly links significant alterations of Fe-bearing minerals in the rhizosphere to a single bacterial trait.

Direct Observation of Nanoparticulate Goethite Recrystallization by Atom Probe Analysis of Isotopic Tracers

Goethite (α-FeOOH) is dispersed throughout the earth's surface, and its propensity to recrystallize in aqueous solutions determines whether this mineral is a source or sink for critical trace elements in the environment. Under reducing conditions, goethite commonly coexists with aqueous Fe(II) (Fe(II)_aq), which accelerates recrystallization by coupled electron transfer and atom exchange. Quantifying the amount of the mineral phase that exchanges its structural Fe(III) atoms with Fe(II)_aq is complicated by recrystallization models with untested assumptions of whether, and to what extent, the recrystallized portion of the mineral continues to interact with the solution. Here, we reacted nanoparticulate goethite with ⁵⁷Fe-enriched Fe(II)_aq and used atom probe tomography (APT) to resolve the three-dimensional distribution of Fe isotopes in goethite at the sub nm scale. We found that the ⁵⁷Fe tracer isotope is enriched in the bulk structure (tens of nanometers deep), with some samples having ⁵⁷Fe penetration throughout at a level that is similar to the isotopic composition of Fe(II)_aq. This suggests that some particles undergo near-complete recrystallization. In other cases, however, the distribution of ⁵⁷Fe is more heterogeneous and generally concentrates near the particle periphery. Nanoparticle encapsulation and subsequent APT can hence capture hidden recrystallization mechanisms which are critical to predicting mineral reactivity in aqueous solutions.

Visualizing the iron atom exchange front in the Fe(II)-catalyzed recrystallization of goethite by atom probe tomography

The autocatalytic redox interaction between aqueous Fe(II) and Fe(III)-(oxyhydr)oxide minerals such as goethite and hematite leads to rapid recrystallization marked, in principle, by an atom exchange (AE) front, according to bulk iron isotopic tracer studies. However, direct evidence for this AE front has been elusive given the analytical challenges of mass-resolved imaging at the nanoscale on individual crystallites. We report successful isolation and characterization of the AE front in goethite microrods by 3D atom probe tomography (APT). The microrods were reacted with Fe(II) enriched in tracer ⁵⁷Fe at conditions consistent with prior bulk studies. APT analyses and 3D reconstructions on cross-sections of the microrods reveal an AE front that is spatially heterogeneous, at times penetrating several nanometers into the lattice, in a manner consistent with defect-accelerated exchange. Evidence for exchange along microstructural domain boundaries was also found, suggesting another important link between exchange extent and initial defect content. The findings provide an unprecedented view into the spatial and temporal characteristics of Fe(II)-catalyzed recrystallization at the atomic scale, and substantiate speculation regarding the role of defects controlling the dynamics of electron transfer and AE interaction at this important redox interface.

Fe(II)-Catalyzed Ligand-Controlled Dissolution of Iron(hydr)oxides

Dissolution of iron(III)phases is a key process in soils, surface waters, and the ocean. Previous studies found that traces of Fe(II) can greatly increase ligand controlled dissolution rates at acidic pH, but the extent that this also occurs at circumneutral pH and what mechanisms are involved are not known. We addressed these questions with infrared spectroscopy and ⁵⁷Fe isotope exchange experiments with lepidocrocite (Lp) and 50 μM ethylenediaminetetraacetate (EDTA) at pH 6 and 7. Addition of 0.2-10 μM Fe(II) led to an acceleration of the dissolution rates by factors of 7-31. Similar effects were observed after irradiation with 365 nm UV light. The catalytic effect persisted under anoxic conditions, but decreased as soon as air or phenanthroline was introduced. Isotope exchange experiments showed that added ⁵⁷Fe remained in solution, or quickly reappeared in solution when EDTA was added after ⁵⁷Fe(II), suggesting that catalyzed dissolution occurred at or near the site of ⁵⁷Fe incorporation at the mineral surface. Infrared spectra indicated no change in the bulk, but changes in the spectra of adsorbed EDTA after addition of Fe(II) were observed. A kinetic model shows that the catalytic effect can be explained by electron transfer to surface Fe(III) sites and rapid detachment of Fe(III)EDTA due to the weaker bonds to reduced sites. We conclude that the catalytic effect of Fe(II) on dissolution of Fe(III)(hydr)oxides is likely important under circumneutral anoxic conditions and in sunlit environments.

Fe(II)-Catalyzed Transformation of Organic Matter-Ferrihydrite Coprecipitates: A Closer Look Using Fe Isotopes

Ferrihydrite is a common Fe mineral in soils and sediments that rapidly transforms to secondary minerals in the presence of Fe(II). Both the rate and products of Fe(II)-catalyzed ferrihydrite transformation have been shown to be significantly influenced by natural organic matter (NOM). Here, we used enriched Fe isotope experiments and ⁵⁷Fe Mössbauer spectroscopy to track the formation of secondary minerals, as well as electron transfer and Fe mixing between aqueous Fe(II) and ferrihydrite coprecipitated with several types of NOM. Ferrihydrite coprecipitated with humic acids transformed primarily to goethite after reaction with Fe(II). In contrast, ferrihydrite coprecipitated with fulvic acids and Suwannee River NOM (SRNOM) resulted in no measurable formation of secondary minerals. Despite no secondary mineral transformation, Mössbauer spectra indicated electron transfer still occurred between Fe(II) and ferrihydrite coprecipitated with fulvic acid and SRNOM. In addition, isotope tracer experiments revealed that a significant fraction of structural Fe in the ferrihydrite mixed with the aqueous phase Fe(II) (∼85%). After reaction with Fe(II), Mössbauer spectroscopy indicated some subtle changes in the crystallinity, particle size, or particle interactions in the coprecipitate. Our observations suggest that ferrihydrite coprecipitated with fulvic acid and SRNOM remains a highly dynamic phase even without ferrihydrite transformation.

The Role of Defects in Fe(II)-Goethite Electron Transfer

Despite substantial experimental evidence for Fe(II)-Fe(III) oxide electron transfer, computational chemistry calculations suggest that oxidation of sorbed Fe(II) by goethite is kinetically inhibited on structurally perfect surfaces. We used a combination of ⁵⁷Fe Mössbauer spectroscopy, synchrotron X-ray absorption and magnetic circular dichroism (XAS/XMCD) spectroscopies to investigate whether Fe(II)-goethite electron transfer is influenced by defects. Specifically, Fe L-edge and O K-edge XAS indicates that the outermost few Angstroms of goethite synthesized by low temperature Fe(III) hydrolysis is iron deficient relative to oxygen, suggesting the presence of defects from Fe vacancies. This nonstoichiometric goethite undergoes facile Fe(II)-Fe(III) oxide electron transfer, depositing additional goethite consistent with experimental precedent. Hydrothermal treatment of this goethite, however, appears to remove defects, decrease the amount of Fe(II) oxidation, and change the composition of the oxidation product. When hydrothermally treated goethite was ground, surface defect characteristics as well as the extent of electron transfer were largely restored. Our findings suggest that surface defects play a commanding role in Fe(II)-goethite redox interaction, as predicted by computational chemistry. Moreover, it suggests that, in the environment, the extent of this interaction will vary depending on diagenetic history, local redox conditions, as well as being subject to regeneration via seasonal fluctuations.