Biomolecular Condensates Regulate Enzymatic Activity under a Crowded Milieu: Synchronization of Liquid-Liquid Phase Separation and Enzymatic Transformation

Coacervates as enzymatic microreactors

Compartmentalization, a key aspect of biochemical regulation, naturally occurs in cellular organelles, including biomolecular condensates formed through liquid-liquid phase separation (LLPS). Inspired by biological compartments, synthetic coacervates have emerged as versatile microreactors, which can provide customed environments for enzymatic reactions. In this review, we explore recent advances in coacervate-based microreactors, while emphasizing the mechanisms by which coacervates accelerate enzymatic reactions, namely by enhancing substrate and enzyme concentrations, stabilizing intermediates, and providing molecular crowding. We discuss diverse coacervate systems, including those based on synthetic polymers, peptides, and nucleic acids, and describe the selection of enzymatic model systems, as well as strategies for enzyme recruitment and their impact on reaction kinetics. Furthermore, we discuss the challenges in monitoring reactions within coacervates and review the currently available techniques including fluorescence techniques, chromatography, and NMR spectroscopy. Altogether, this review offers a comprehensive perspective on recent progress and challenges in the design of coacervate microreactors, and addresses their potential in biocatalysis, synthetic biology, and nanotechnology.

Coalescence-Driven Local Crowding Promotes Liquid-to-Solid-Like Phase Transition in a Homogeneous and Heterogeneous Droplet Assembly: Regulatory Role of Ligands

Liquid-to-solid-like phase transition (LSPT) of disordered proteins via metastable liquid-like droplets is a well-documented phenomenon in biology and is linked to many pathological conditions including neurodegenerative diseases. However, very less is known about the early microscopic events and transient intermediates involved in the irreversible protein aggregation of functional globular proteins. Herein, using a range of microscopic and spectroscopic techniques, we show that the LSPT of a functional globular protein, human serum albumin (HSA), is exclusively driven by spontaneous coalescence of liquid-like droplets involving various transient intermediates in a temporal manner. We show that interdroplet communication via coalescence is essential for both initial aggregation and growth of amorphous aggregates within individual droplets, which subsequently transform to amyloid-like fibrils. Immobilized droplets neither show any nucleation nor any growth upon aging. Moreover, we found that the exchange of materials with the dilute dispersed phase has negligible influence on the LSPT of HSA. Our findings reveal that interfacial properties effectively modulate the feasibility and kinetics of LSPT of HSA via ligand binding, suggesting a possible regulatory mechanism that cells utilize to control the dynamics of LSPT. Furthermore, using a dynamic heterogeneous droplet assembly of two functional proteins, HSA and human serum transferrin (Tf), we show an intriguing phenomenon within the fused droplets where both liquid-like and solid-like phases coexist within the same droplet, which eventually transform to a mixed fibrillar assembly. These microscopic insights not only highlight the importance of interdroplet interactions behind the LSPT of biomolecules but also showcase its adverse effect on the structure and function of other functional proteins in a crowded and heterogeneous protein assembly.

Adaptive ATP-induced molecular condensation in membranized protocells

Liquid-liquid phase separation (LLPS) has been achieved in various cytomimetic (protocell) models, but controlling molecular condensation using noninert crowders to systematically alter protocell function remains challenging. Intracellular ATP levels influence protein-protein interactions, and dysregulation of ATP can alter cellular crowding dynamics, thereby disrupting the normal formation or dissolution of condensates. Here, we develop a membranized protocell model capable of endogenous LLPS and liquid-gel-like phase separation through precise manipulation of intermolecular interactions within semipermeable polysaccharide-based microcapsules (polysaccharidosomes, P-somes), prepared using microtemplate-guided assembly. We demonstrate that intraprotocellular diffusion-mediated LLPS can be extended into the liquid-gel-like domain by the uptake of the biologically active crowder ATP, resulting in a range of modalities dependent on the fine-tuning of molecular condensation. Endogenous enzyme activity in these crowded polysaccharidosomes is enhanced compared to free enzymes in solution, though this enhancement diminishes at higher levels of intraprotocellular condensation. Additionally, increased molecular crowding inhibits intraprotocell DNA strand displacement reactions. Our findings introduce an expedient and optimized approach to the batch construction of membranized protocell models with controllable molecular crowding and functional diversity. Our mix-incubate-wash protocol for inducing endogenous LLPS in membranized protocells offers potential applications in microreactor technology, environmental sensing, and the delivery and sustained release of therapeutics.

Insight into the thermo-responsive phase behavior of the P1 domain of α-synuclein using atomistic simulations

Biomolecular condensate formation driven by intrinsically disordered proteins (IDPs) is regulated by interactions between various domains of the proteins. Such condensates are implicated in various neurodegenerative diseases. The presynaptic intrinsically disordered protein, α-Syn is involved in the pathogenesis of Parkinson's disease. The central non-amyloid β-component (NAC) domain in the protein is considered to be a major driver of pathogenic aggregation, although recent studies have suggested that the P1 domain from the flanking N-terminal region can act as a 'master controller' for α-Syn function and aggregation. To gain molecular insight into the phase behavior of the P1 domain itself, we investigate how assemblies of P1 (residues 36-42) chains phase separate with varying temperatures using all-atom molecular dynamics simulations. The simulations reveal that P1 is able to phase separate above a lower critical solution temperature. Formation of a condensed phase is driven by exclusion of water molecules by the hydrophobic chains. P1 chain density in the condensate is determined by weak multi-chain interactions between the residues. Moreover, tyrosine (Y39) is involved in the formation of strongest contacts between residue pairs in the dense phase. These results provide a detailed picture of condensate formation by a key segment of the α-Syn molecule.

Structured protein domains enter the spotlight: modulators of biomolecular condensate form and function

Biomolecular condensates are membraneless organelles that concentrate proteins and nucleic acids. One of the primary components of condensates is multidomain proteins, whose domains can be broadly classified as structured and disordered. While structured protein domains are ubiquitous within biomolecular condensates, the physical ramifications of their unique properties have been relatively underexplored. Therefore, this review synthesizes current literature pertaining to structured protein domains within the context of condensates. We examine how the propensity of structured domains for high interaction specificity and low conformational heterogeneity contributes to the formation, material properties, and functions of biomolecular condensates. Finally, we propose unanswered questions on the behavior of structured protein domains within condensates, the answers of which will contribute to a more complete understanding of condensate biophysics.

Continuity of Short-Time Dynamics Crossing the Liquid-Liquid Phase Separation in Charge-Tuned Protein Solutions

Liquid-liquid phase separation (LLPS) constitutes a crucial phenomenon in biological self-organization, not only intervening in the formation of membraneless organelles but also triggering pathological protein aggregation, which is a hallmark in neurodegenerative diseases. Employing incoherent quasi-elastic neutron spectroscopy (QENS), we examine the short-time self-diffusion of a model protein undergoing LLPS as a function of phase splitting and temperature to access information on the nanosecond hydrodynamic response to the cluster formation both within and outside the LLPS regime. We investigate the samples as they dissociate into microdroplets of a dense protein phase dispersed in a dilute phase as well as the separated dense and dilute phases obtained from centrifugation. By interpreting the QENS results in terms of the local concentrations in the two phases determined by UV-vis spectroscopy, we hypothesize that the short-time transient protein cluster size distribution is conserved at the transition point while the local volume fractions separate.

Unraveling the hydration dynamics of ACC1-13K24 with ATP: From liquid to droplet to amyloid fibril

In order to achieve a comprehensive understanding of protein aggregation processes, an exploration of solvation dynamics, a key yet intricate component of biological phenomena, is mandatory. In the present study, we used Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy and terahertz spectroscopy complemented by atomic force microscopy and kinetic experiments utilizing thioflavin T fluorescence to elucidate the changes in solvation dynamics during liquid-liquid phase separation and subsequent amyloid fibril formation, the latter representing a transition from liquid to solid phase separation. These processes are pivotal in the pathology of neurodegenerative disorders such as Alzheimer's and Parkinson's diseases. We focus on the ACC1-13K24-ATP protein complex, which undergoes fibril formation followed by droplet generation. Our investigation reveals the importance of hydration as a driving force in these processes, offering new insights into the molecular mechanisms at play.

Affinity-Controlled Partitioning of Biomolecules at Aqueous Interfaces and Their Bioanalytic Applications

All-aqueous phase separation systems play essential roles in bioanalytical and biochemical applications. Compared to conventional oil and organic solvent-based systems, these systems are characterized by their rich bulk and interfacial properties, offering superior biocompatibility. In particular, phase separation in all-aqueous systems facilitates the creation of compartments with specific physicochemical properties, and therefore largely enhances the accessibility of the systems. In addition, the all-aqueous compartments have diverse affinities, with an important property known as partitioning, which can concentrate (bio)molecules toward distinct immiscible phases. This partitioning affinity imparts all-aqueous interfaces with selective permeability, enabling the controlled enrichment of target (bio)molecules. This review introduces the basic principles and applications of partitioning-induced interfacial phenomena in a typical all-aqueous system, namely aqueous two-phase systems (ATPSs); these applications include interfacial chemical reactions, bioprinting, and assembly, as well as bio-sensing and detection. The primary challenges associated with designing all-aqueous phase separation systems and several future directions are also discussed, such as the stabilization of aqueous interfaces, the handling of low-volume samples, and exploration of suitable ATPSs compositions with the efficient protocol.

Optical Control over Liquid–Liquid Phase Separation

Liquid-liquid phase separation (LLPS) is responsible for the emergence of intracellular membrane-less organelles and the development of coacervate protocells. Benefitting from the advantages of simplicity, precision, programmability, and noninvasiveness, light has become an effective tool to regulate the assembly dynamics of LLPS, and mediate various biochemical processes associated with LLPS. In this review, recent advances in optically controlling membrane-less organelles within living organisms are summarized, thereby modulating a series of biological processes including irreversible protein aggregation pathologies, transcription activation, metabolic flux, genomic rearrangements, and enzymatic reactions. Among these, the intracellular systems (i.e., optoDroplet, Corelet, PixELL, CasDrop, and other optogenetic systems) that enable the photo-mediated control over biomolecular condensation are highlighted. The design of photoactive complex coacervate protocells in laboratory settings by utilizing photochromic molecules such as azobenzene and diarylethene is further discussed. This review is expected to provide in-depth insights into phase separation-associated biochemical processes, bio-metabolism, and diseases.

Harnessing Water Competition to Drive Enzyme Crosstalk

In nature, enzymatic pathways often involve compartmentalization effects that can modify the intrinsic activity and specificity of the different enzymes involved. Consequently, extensive research has focused on replicating and studying the compartmentalization effects on individual enzymes and on multistep enzyme "cascade" reactions. This study explores the influence of compartmentalization achieved using molecular crowding on the glucose oxidase/horseradish peroxidase (GOx/HRP) cascade reaction. The crowder tested is methoxy poly(ethylene glycol) (mPEG) that can, depending on conditions, promote GOx and HRP coassociation at the nanoscale and extend their contact time. Low-molecular-weight mPEG (0.35 kDa), but not mPEG of higher molecular weights (5 or 20 kDa), significantly enhanced the cascade reaction where up to a 20-fold increase in the rate of the cascade reaction was observed under some conditions. The combined analyses emphasize the particularity of low-molecular-weight mPEG and point toward mPEG-induced coassociation of HRP and GOx, producing nearest crowded neighbor effects of HRP on GOx, and vice versa. These altered the nanoscale environments of these enzymes, which influenced substrate affinity. Using mPEG to promote protein coassociation is simple and does not chemically modify the proteins studied. This approach could be of interest for more broadly characterizing nearest crowded neighbor effects (i.e., protein-protein interactions) for multiprotein systems (i.e., more than just two), thus making it an interesting tool for studying very complex systems, such as those found in nature.

Biomolecular Condensation of Trypsin Prevents Autolysis and Promotes Ca2+-Mediated Activation of Esterase Activity

The presence of Ca2+ ions is known to facilitate the activity of trypsin-like serine proteases via structural stabilization against thermal denaturation and autolysis. Herein, we report a new and hidden regulatory role of Ca2+ in the catalytic pathways of trypsin and α-chymotrypsin under physiological conditions. We discovered that macromolecular crowding promotes spontaneous homotypic condensation of trypsin via liquid-liquid phase separation to yield membraneless condensates over a broad range of concentrations, pH, and temperature, which are stabilized by multivalent hydrophobic interactions. Interestingly, we found that Ca2+ binding in the calcium binding loop reversibly regulates the condensation of trypsin and α-chymotrypsin. Spontaneous condensation effectively prevents autolysis of trypsin and preserves its native-like esterase activity for a prolonged period of time. It has also been found that phase-separated trypsin responds to Ca2+-dependent activation of its esterase activity even after 14 days of storage while free trypsin failed to do so. The present study highlights an important physiological aspect by which cells can spatiotemporally regulate the biocatalytic efficacy of trypsin-like serine proteases via Ca2+-signaling.

Substrate-induced phase transition within liquid condensates reverses the catalytic activity of nanoparticles

Liquid-liquid phase separation is reported to enhance the catalytic reaction rates severalfold. Herein, we explored the interactions between a catalyst and a range of substrate concentrations to understand the impact on the droplet phase and catalytic reaction kinetics. We observed that the substrate above a critical concentration induces phase transitions within liquid condensates and restricts the free movement of both the substrate and products, resulting in an overall reduction of the reaction rate, an observation not reported earlier.

Interplay of condensation and chromatin binding underlies BRD4 targeting

Nuclear compartments form via biomolecular phase separation, mediated through multivalent properties of biomolecules concentrated within condensates. Certain compartments are associated with specific chromatin regions, including transcriptional initiation condensates, which are composed of transcription factors and transcriptional machinery, and form at acetylated regions including enhancer and promoter loci. While protein self-interactions, especially within low-complexity and intrinsically disordered regions, are known to mediate condensation, the role of substrate-binding interactions in regulating the formation and function of biomolecular condensates is underexplored. Here, utilizing live-cell experiments in parallel with coarse-grained simulations, we investigate how chromatin interaction of the transcriptional activator BRD4 modulates its condensate formation. We find that both kinetic and thermodynamic properties of BRD4 condensation are affected by chromatin binding: nucleation rate is sensitive to BRD4-chromatin interactions, providing an explanation for the selective formation of BRD4 condensates at acetylated chromatin regions, and thermodynamically, multivalent acetylated chromatin sites provide a platform for BRD4 clustering below the concentration required for off-chromatin condensation. This provides a molecular and physical explanation of the relationship between nuclear condensates and epigenetically modified chromatin that results in their mutual spatiotemporal regulation, suggesting that epigenetic modulation is an important mechanism by which the cell targets transcriptional condensates to specific chromatin loci.

Enabling High Activation of Glucose-6-Phosphate Dehydrogenase Activity Through Liquid Condensate Formation and Compression

Droplet formation via liquid-liquid phase separation is thought to be involved in the regulation of various biological processes, including enzymatic reactions. We investigated a glycolytic enzymatic reaction, the conversion of glucose-6-phosphate to 6-phospho-D-glucono-1,5-lactone with concomitant reduction of NADP+ to NADPH both in the absence and presence of dynamically controlled liquid droplet formation. Here, the nucleotide serves as substrate as well as the scaffold required for the formation of liquid droplets. To further expand the process parameter space, temperature and pressure dependent measurements were performed. Incorporation of the reactants in the liquid droplet phase led to a boost in enzymatic activity, which was most pronounced at medium-high pressures. The crowded environment of the droplet phase induced a marked increase of the affinity of the enzyme and substrate. An increase in turnover number in the droplet phase at high pressure contributed to a further strong increase in catalytic efficiency. Enzyme systems that are dynamically coupled to liquid condensate formation may be the key to deciphering many biochemical reactions. Expanding the process parameter space by adjusting temperature and pressure conditions can be a means to further increase the efficiency of industrial enzyme utilization and help uncover regulatory mechanisms adopted by extremophiles.

Kinetic Study of the Esterase-like Activity of Albumin following Condensation by Macromolecular Crowding

The ability of bovine serum albumin (BSA) to form condensates in crowded environments has been discovered only recently. Effects of this condensed state on the secondary structure of the protein have already been unraveled as some aging aspects, but the pseudo-enzymatic behavior of condensed BSA has never been reported yet. This article investigates the kinetic profile of para-nitrophenol acetate hydrolysis by BSA in its condensed state with poly(ethylene) glycol (PEG) as the crowding agent. Furthermore, the initial BSA concentration was varied between 0.25 and 1 mM which allowed us to modify the size distribution, the volume fraction, and the partition coefficient (varying from 136 to 180). Hence, the amount of BSA originally added was a simple way to modulate the size and density of the condensates. Compared with dilute BSA, the initial velocity (vi) with condensates was dramatically reduced. From the Michaelis-Menten fits, the extracted Michaelis constant Km and the maximum velocity Vmax decreased in control samples without condensates when the BSA concentration increased, which was attributed to BSA self-oligomerization. In samples containing condensates, the observed vi was interpreted as an effect of diluted BSA remaining in the supernatants and from the condensates. In supernatants, the crowding effect of PEG increased the kcat and catalytic efficiency. Last, Vmax was proportional to the volume fraction of the condensates, which could be controlled by varying its initial concentration. Hence, the major significance of this article is the control of the size and volume fraction of albumin condensates, along with their kinetic profile using liquid-liquid phase separation.

From a Droplet to a Fibril and from a Fibril to a Droplet: Intertwined Transition Pathways in Highly Dynamic Enzyme-Modulated Peptide-Adenosine Triphosphate Systems

Many cellular coassemblies of proteins and polynucleotides facilitate liquid-liquid phase separation (LLPS) and the subsequent self-assembly of disease-associated amyloid fibrils within the liquid droplets. Here, we explore the dynamics of coupled phase and conformational transitions of model adenosine triphosphate (ATP)-binding peptides, ACC1-13Kn, consisting of the potent amyloidogenic fragment of insulin's A-chain (ACC1-13) merged with oligolysine segments of various lengths (Kn, n = 16, 24, 40). The self-assembly of ATP-stabilized amyloid fibrils is preceded by LLPS for peptides with sufficiently long oligolysine segments. The two-component droplets and fibrils are in dynamic equilibria with free ATP and monomeric peptides, which makes them susceptible to ATP-hydrolyzing apyrase and ACC1-13Kn-digesting proteinase K. Both enzymes are capable of rapid disassembly of amyloid fibrils, producing either monomers of the peptide (apyrase) or free ATP released together with cleaved-off oligolysine segments (proteinase K). In the latter case, the enzyme-sequestered Kn segments form subsequent droplets with the co-released ATP, resulting in an unusual fibril-to-droplet transition. In support of the highly dynamic nature of the aggregate-monomer equilibria, addition of superstoichiometric amounts of free peptide to the ACC1-13Kn-ATP coaggregate causes its disassembly. Our results show that the droplet state is not merely an intermediate phase on the pathway to the amyloid aggregate but may also constitute the final phase of a complex amyloidogenic protein misfolding scenario rich in highly degraded protein fragments incompetent to transition again into fibrils.

Leveraging liquid-liquid phase separation and volume modulation to regulate the enzymatic activity of formate dehydrogenase

Engineering of reaction media is an exciting alternative for modulating kinetic properties of biocatalytic reactions. We addressed the combined effect of an aqueous two-phase system (ATPS) and high hydrostatic pressure on the kinetics of the Candida boidinii formate dehydrogenase-catalyzed oxidation of formate to CO2. Pressurization was found to lead to an increase of the binding affinity (decrease of KM, respectively) and a decrease of the turnover number, kcat. The experimental approach was supported using thermodynamic modeling with the electrolyte Perturbed-Chain Statistical Associating Fluid Theory (ePC-SAFT) equation of state to predict the liquid-liquid phase separation and the molecular crowding effect of the ATPS on the kinetic properties. The ePC-SAFT was able to quantitatively predict the KM-values of the substrate in both phases at 1 bar as well as up to a pressure of 1000 bar. The framework presented enables significant advances in bioprocess engineering, including the design of processes with significantly fewer experiments and trial-and-error approaches.

Macromolecular Crowding Promotes Re-entrant Liquid-Liquid Phase Separation of Human Serum Transferrin and Prevents Surface-Induced Fibrillation

Protein aggregation and inactivation upon surface immobilization are major limiting factors for analytical applications in biotechnology-related fields. Protein immobilization on solid surfaces often requires multi-step surface passivation, which is time-consuming and inefficient. Herein, we have discovered that biomolecular condensates of biologically active human serum transferrin (Tf) can effectively prevent surface-induced fibrillation and preserve the native-like conformation of phase-separated Tf over a period of 30 days. It has been observed that macromolecular crowding promotes homotypic liquid-liquid phase separation (LLPS) of Tf through enthalpically driven multivalent hydrophobic interactions possibly via the involvement of its low-complexity domain (residues 3-20) containing hydrophobic amino acids. The present LLPS of Tf is a rare example of salt-mediated re-entrant phase separation in a broad range of salt concentrations (0-3 M) solely via the involvement of hydrophobic interactions. Notably, no liquid-to-solid-like phase transition has been observed over a period of 30 days, suggesting the intact conformational integrity of phase-separated Tf, as revealed from single droplet Raman, circular dichroism, and Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy measurements. More importantly, we discovered that the phase-separated condensates of Tf completely inhibit the surface-induced fibrillation of Tf, illustrating the protective role of these liquid-like condensates against denaturation and aggregation of biomolecules. The cell mimicking compact aqueous compartments of biomolecular condensates with a substantial amount of interfacial water preserve the structure and functionality of Tf. Our present study highlights an important functional aspect of biologically active protein condensates and may have wide-ranging implications in cell physiology and biotechnological applications.

Biomolecular Liquid-Liquid Phase Separation for Biotechnology

The liquid-liquid phase separation (LLPS) of biomolecules induces condensed assemblies called liquid droplets or membrane-less organelles. In contrast to organelles with lipid membrane barriers, the liquid droplets induced by LLPS do not have distinct barriers (lipid bilayer). Biomolecular LLPS in cells has attracted considerable attention in broad research fields from cellular biology to soft matter physics. The physical and chemical properties of LLPS exert a variety of functions in living cells: activating and deactivating biomolecules involving enzymes; controlling the localization, condensation, and concentration of biomolecules; the filtration and purification of biomolecules; and sensing environmental factors for fast, adaptive, and reversible responses. The versatility of LLPS plays an essential role in various biological processes, such as controlling the central dogma and the onset mechanism of pathological diseases. Moreover, biomolecular LLPS could be critical for developing new biotechnologies such as the condensation, purification, and activation of a series of biomolecules. In this review article, we introduce some fundamental aspects and recent progress of biomolecular LLPS in living cells and test tubes. Then, we discuss applications of biomolecular LLPS toward biotechnologies.