Coordination Engineering in Cobalt-Nitrogen-Functionalized Materials for CO2 Reduction

Coordination Environment Engineering of Metal Centers in Coordination Polymers for Selective Carbon Dioxide Electroreduction toward Multicarbon Products

Electrocatalytic carbon dioxide reduction reaction (CO2RR) toward value-added chemicals/fuels has offered a sustainable strategy to achieve a carbon-neutral energy cycle. However, it remains a great challenge to controllably and precisely regulate the coordination environment of active sites in catalysts for efficient generation of targeted products, especially the multicarbon (C2+) products. Herein we report the coordination environment engineering of metal centers in coordination polymers for efficient electroreduction of CO2 to C2+ products under neutral conditions. Significantly, the Cu coordination polymer with Cu-N2S2 coordination configuration (Cu-N-S) demonstrates superior Faradaic efficiencies of 61.2% and 82.2% for ethylene and C2+ products, respectively, compared to the selective formic acid generation on an analogous polymer with the Cu-I2S2 coordination mode (Cu-I-S). In situ studies reveal the balanced formation of atop and bridge *CO intermediates on Cu-N-S, promoting C-C coupling for C2+ production. Theoretical calculations suggest that coordination environment engineering can induce electronic modulations in Cu active sites, where the d-band center of Cu is upshifted in Cu-N-S with stronger selectivity to the C2+ products. Consequently, Cu-N-S displays a stronger reaction trend toward the generation of C2+ products, while Cu-I-S favors the formation of formic acid due to the suppression of C-C couplings for C2+ pathways with large energy barriers.

Single-Atom Catalysts and Dual-Atom Catalysts for CO2 Electroreduction: Competition or Cooperation?

Developing highly active and selective electrocatalysts for electrochemical reduction of CO2 can reduce environmental pollution and mitigation of greenhouse gas emission. Owing to maximal atomic utilization, the atomically dispersed catalysts are broadly adopted in CO2 reduction reaction (CO2 RR). Dual-atom catalysts (DACs), with more flexible active sites, distinct electronic structures, and synergetic interatomic interactions compared to single-atom catalysts (SACs), may have great potential to enhance catalytic performance. Nevertheless, most of the existing electrocatalysts have low activity and selectivity due to their high energy barrier. Herein, 15 electrocatalysts are explored with noble metallic (Cu, Ag, and Au) active sites embedded in metal-organic hybrids (MOHs) for high-performance CO2 RR and studied the relationship between SACs and DACs by first-principles calculation. The results indicated that the DACs have excellent electrocatalytic performance, and the moderate interaction between the single- and dual-atomic center can improve catalytic activity in CO2 RR. Four among the 15 catalysts, including (CuAu), (CuCu), Cu(CuCu), and Cu(CuAu) MOHs inherited a capability of suppressing the competitive hydrogen evolution reaction with favorable CO overpotential. This work not only reveals outstanding candidates for MOHs-based dual-atom CO2 RR electrocatalysts but also provides new theoretical insights into rationally designing 2D metallic electrocatalysts.

Concerted Proton-Coupled Electron Transfer to a Graphite Adsorbed Metalloporphyrin Occurs by Band to Bond Electron Redistribution

Surface immobilized catalysts are highly promising candidates for a range of energy conversion reactions, and atomistic mechanistic understanding is essential for their rational design. Cobalt tetraphenylporphyrin (CoTPP) nonspecifically adsorbed on a graphitic surface has been shown to undergo concerted proton-coupled electron transfer (PCET) in aqueous solution. Herein, density functional theory calculations on both cluster and periodic models representing π-stacked interactions or axial ligation to a surface oxygenate are performed. As the electrode surface is charged due to applied potential, the adsorbed molecule experiences the electrical polarization of the interface and nearly the same electrostatic potential as the electrode, regardless of the adsorption mode. PCET occurs by electron abstraction from the surface to the CoTPP concerted with protonation to form a cobalt hydride, thereby circumventing Co(II/I) redox. Specifically, the Co(II) d-state localized orbital interacts with a proton from solution and an electron from the delocalized graphitic band states to produce a Co(III)-H bonding orbital below the Fermi level, corresponding to redistribution of electrons from the band states to the bonding states. These insights have broad implications for electrocatalysis by chemically modified electrodes and surface immobilized catalysts.

Force Decomposition Analysis: A Method to Decompose Intermolecular Forces into Physically Relevant Component Contributions

Computational quantum chemistry can be more than just numerical experiments when methods are specifically adapted to investigate chemical concepts. One important example is the development of energy decomposition analysis (EDA) to reveal the physical driving forces behind intermolecular interactions. In EDA, typically the interaction energy from a good-quality density functional theory (DFT) calculation is decomposed into multiple additive components that unveil permanent and induced electrostatics, Pauli repulsion, dispersion, and charge-transfer contributions to noncovalent interactions. Herein, we formulate, implement, and investigate decomposing the forces associated with intermolecular interactions into the same components. The resulting force decomposition analysis (FDA) is potentially useful as a complement to the EDA to understand chemistry, while also providing far more information than an EDA for data analysis purposes such as training physics-based force fields. We apply the FDA based on absolutely localized molecular orbitals (ALMOs) to analyze interactions of water with sodium and chloride ions as well as in the water dimer. We also analyze the forces responsible for geometric changes in carbon dioxide upon adsorption onto (and activation by) gold and silver anions. We also investigate how the force components of an EDA-based force field for water clusters, namely MB-UCB, compare to those from force decomposition analysis.

Positive Valent Metal Sites in Electrochemical CO2 Reduction Reaction

The discovery of high-performance catalysts for the electrochemical CO₂ reduction reaction (CO₂ RR) has faced an enormous challenge for years. The lack of cognition about the surface active structures or centers of catalysts in complex conditions limits the development of advanced catalysts for CO₂ RR. Recently, the positive valent metal sites (PVMS) are demonstrated as a kind of potential active sites, which can facilitate carbon dioxide (CO₂ ) activation and conversation but are always unstable under reduction potentials. Many advanced technologies in theory and experiment have been utilized to understand and develop excellent catalysts with PVMS for CO₂ RR. Here, we present an introduction of some typical catalysts with PVMS in CO₂ RR and give some understanding of the activity and stability for these related catalysts.

Catalytic Potential of Post-Transition Metal Doped Graphene-Based Single-Atom Catalysts for the CO2 Electroreduction Reaction

Catalysts are required to ensure electrochemical reduction of CO2 to fuels proceeds at industrially acceptable rates and yields. As such, highly active and selective catalysts must be developed. Herein, a density functional theory study of p-block element and noble metal doped graphene-based single-atom catalysts in two defect sites for the electrochemical reduction of CO2 to CO and HCOOH is systematically undertaken. It is found that on all of the systems considered, the thermodynamic product is HCOOH. Pb/C3 , Pb/N4 and Sn/C3 are identified as having the lowest overpotential for HCOOH production while Al/C3 , Al/N4 , Au/C3 and Ga/C3 are identified as having the potential to form higher order products due to the strength of binding of adsorbed HCOOH.

Rational Design of Main Group Metal-Embedded Nitrogen-Doped Carbon Materials as Frustrated Lewis Pair Catalysts for CO2 Hydrogenation to Formic Acid

Developing efficient and inexpensive main group catalysts for CO₂ conversion and utilization has attracted increasing attention, as the conversion process would be both economical and environmentally benign. Here, based on the main group element Al, we designed several heterogeneous frustrated Lewis acid/base pair (FLP) catalysts and performed extensive first-principles calculations for the hydrogenation of CO₂. These catalysts, including Al@N-Gr-1, Al@N-Gr-2, and Al@C₂N, are composed of a single Al atom and two-dimensional (2D) N-doped carbon-based materials to form frustrated Al/C or Al/N Lewis acid/base pairs, which are all predicted to have high reactivity to absorb and activate hydrogen (H₂). Compared with Al@N-Gr-1, both Al@N-Gr-2 and Al@C₂N, especially Al@N-Gr-2, containing Al/N Lewis pairs exhibit better catalytic activity for CO₂ hydrogenation with lower activation energies. CO₂ hydrogenation on the three catalysts prefers to go through a three-step mechanism, i.e., the heterolytic dissociation of H₂, followed by the transfer of the hydride near Al to CO₂, and finally the activation of a second H₂ molecule. Other IIIA group element (B and Ga)-embedded N-Gr-2 materials (B@N-Gr-2 and Ga@N-Gr-2) were also explored and compared. Both Al@N-Gr-2 and Ga@N-Gr-2 show higher catalytic activity for CO₂ hydrogenation to HCOOH than B@N-Gr-2. However, the CO₂ hydrogenation path on Ga@N-Gr-2 tends to follow a two-step mechanism, including H₂ dissociation and subsequent hydrogen transfer. The present study provides a potential solution for CO₂ hydrogenation by designing novel and effective FLP catalysts based on main group elements.

Clustering of metal dopants in defect sites of graphene-based materials

Single-atom catalysts are promising candidates for many industrial reactions. However, making true single-atom catalysts is an experimental dilemma, due to the difficulty of keeping dopant single atoms stable at temperature and under pressure. This difficulty can lead to clustering of the metal dopant atoms in defect sites. However, the electronic and geometric structure of sub-nanoscale clusters in single-atom defects has not yet been explored. Furthermore, recent studies have proven sub-nanoscale clusters of dopants in single-atom defect sites can be equally good or better catalysts than their single-atom counterparts. Here, a comprehensive DFT study is undertaken to determine the geometric and electronic structure effects that influence clustering of noble and p-block dopants in C₃- and N₄-defect sites in graphene-based systems. We find that the defect site is the primary driver in determining clustering dynamics in these systems.

Coordination environment engineering on nickel single-atom catalysts for CO2 electroreduction

Coordination engineering has recently emerged as a promising strategy to boost the activity of single atom catalysts (SACs) in electrocatalytic CO₂ reduction reactions (CO₂RR). Understanding the correlation between activity/selectivity and the coordination environment would enable the rational design of more advanced SACs for CO₂ reduction. Herein, via density functional theory (DFT) computations, we systematically studied the effects of coordination environment regulation on the CO₂RR activity of Ni SACs on C, N, or B co-doped graphene. The results reveal that the coordination environments can strongly affect the adsorption and reaction characteristics. In the C and/or N coordinated Ni-B_XC_YN_Z (B-free, X = 0), only Ni acts as the active site. While in the B, C and/or N coordinated Ni-B_XC_YN_Z (X ≠ 0), the B has transition-metal-like properties, where B and Ni function as dual-site active centers and concertedly tune the adsorption of CO₂RR intermediates. The tunability in the adsorption modes and strengths also results in a weakened linear scaling relationship between *COOH and *CO and causes a significant activity difference. The CO₂RR activity and the adsorption energy of *COOH/*CO are correlated to construct a volcano-type activity plot. Most of the B, C, and/or N-coordinated Ni-B_XC_YN_Z (X ≠ 0) are located in the left region where *CO desorption is the most difficult step, while the C and/or N coordinated Ni-B_XC_YN_Z (X = 0) are located in the right region where *COOH formation is the potential-determining step. Among all the possible Ni-B_XC_YN_Z candidates, Ni-B₀C₃N₁ and Ni-B₁C₁N_2-N-oppo are predicted to be the most active and selective catalysts for the CO₂RR. Our findings provide insightful guidance for developing highly effective CO₂RR catalysts based on a codoped coordination environment.

Electrochemical Reduction of CO2: A Review of Cobalt Based Catalysts for Carbon Dioxide Conversion to Fuels

Electrochemical CO2 reduction reaction (CO2RR) provides a promising approach to curbing harmful emissions contributing to global warming. However, several challenges hinder the commercialization of this technology, including high overpotentials, electrode instability, and low Faradic efficiencies of desirable products. Several materials have been developed to overcome these challenges. This mini-review discusses the recent performance of various cobalt (Co) electrocatalysts, including Co-single atom, Co-multi metals, Co-complexes, Co-based metal-organic frameworks (MOFs), Co-based covalent organic frameworks (COFs), Co-nitrides, and Co-oxides. These materials are reviewed with respect to their stability of facilitating CO2 conversion to valuable products, and a summary of the current literature is highlighted, along with future perspectives for the development of efficient CO2RR.

Atomically Structural Regulations of Carbon-Based Single-Atom Catalysts for Electrochemical CO2 Reduction

The electrochemical carbon dioxide reduction reaction (CO₂ RR) converting CO₂ into value-added chemicals and fuels to realize carbon recycling is a solution to the problem of renewable energy shortage and environmental pollution. Among all the catalysts, the carbon-based single-atom catalysts (SACs) with isolated metal atoms immobilized on conductive carbon substrates have shown significant potential toward CO₂ RR, which intrigues researchers to explore high-performance SACs for fuel and chemical production by CO₂ RR. Especially, regulating the coordination structures of the metal centers and the microenvironments of the substrates in carbon-based SACs has emerged as an effective strategy for the tailoring of their CO₂ RR catalytic performance. In this review, the current in situ/operando study techniques and the fundamental parameters for CO₂ RR performance are first briefly presented. Furthermore, the recent advances in synthetic strategies which regulate the atomic structures of the carbon-based SACs, including heteroatom coordination, coordination numbers, diatomic metal centers, and the microenvironments of substrates are summarized. In particular, the structure-performance relationship of the SACs toward CO₂ RR is highlighted. Finally, the inevitable challenges for SACs are outlined and further research directions toward CO₂ RR are presented from the perspectives.

Rational Design and Effective Control of Gold-Based Bimetallic Electrocatalyst for Boosting CO2 Reduction Reaction: A First-Principles Study

Electrochemical CO₂ reduction reaction (CO₂ RR) is an effective strategy converting CO₂ to value-added products. Au is regarded as an efficient catalyst for electrochemical reduction of CO₂ to CO, and the introduction of Pd can tune CO₂ RR properties due to its strong affinity to CO. Herein, Au-Pd bimetallic electrocatalysts with different metal ratio were firstly investigated on CO₂ RR mechanism by using density functional theory. The Au monolayer over Pd substrate and single Pd atom on Au(111) were found to show better CO₂ RR selectivity against hydrogen evolution reaction (HER). Based on this, various single-atom catalysts on Au(111) and core-shell models with top Au monolayer were designed to study their CO₂ RR performance. The results indicated that Pt, Cu, and Rh substrates below Au monolayer could enhance the activity and selectivity for CO production compared to pure Au, in which the limiting potential reduced from -0.74 to -0.63, -0.69, and -0.71 V, respectively. The single Pd embedded on Au(111) could adjust the adsorption strength, which provided an effective site to receive and further reduce CO to CH₃ OH and CH₄ at a low limiting potential of -0.61 V, and also avoided catalyst poisoning due to the over-strengthened CO adsorption caused by high Pd proportion on the surface. In addition, the adsorption energy of COOH was observed as a better CO₂ RR reactivity descriptor than the common CO adsorption when establishing scaling relationship, which could avoid the fitting error caused by intermediate physisorption of CO.

Carbon and Oxygen Coordinating Atoms Adjust Transition Metal Single-Atom Catalysts Based On Boron Nitride Monolayers for Highly Efficient CO2 Electroreduction

Although single-atom catalysts (SACs) with transition metal-nitrogen complexes have been studied widely, investigations that use light-element atoms to adjust the coordination environment of the central metal atoms in metal-nitrogen complexes are still rare but show enormous potential for various electrocatalytic reactions. Herein, we design novel SACs based on monolayer BN adjusted by B, C, or O coordinating atoms as catalysts for the CO₂ reduction reaction (CRR). These SACs are denoted as M@BN_D (BN = monolayer boron nitride; D = B, C, or O atom; M = Co, Cr, Fe, Mn, Mo, Pd, Pt, Ru, V, W, Ni, Zn, Zr, Ag, Au, Cu, or Ti atom) and are investigated as CRR catalysts using density functional theory calculations. Among these structures, we identified some promising candidate catalysts for CRR with impressive low limiting potential (U_L): Pt@BN_C with a U_L of -0.18 for the product CH₄ and Co@BN_C and Au@BN_O with U_L of -0.41 and -0.37 V, respectively, for the product CH₃OH. In particular, Pt@BN_C shows a remarkable reduction in U_L for the product CH₄ compared to any existing catalysts, synthesized or predicted. In addition, the ultralow U_L for CRR on Pt@BN_C was derived from the unique bonding feature between the single metal atom and adsorbates and the modulation of ionic interactions induced by the coordination effect of the C atom.

Nanostructured Cobalt-Based Electrocatalysts for CO2 Reduction: Recent Progress, Challenges, and Perspectives

CO₂ reduction reaction (CO₂ RR) provides a promising strategy for sustainable carbon fixation by converting CO₂ into value-added fuels and chemicals. In recent years, considerable efforts are focused on the development of transition-metal (TM)-based catalysts for the selectively electrochemical CO₂ reduction reaction (ECO₂ RR). Co-based catalysts emerge as one of the most promising electrocatalysts with high Faradaic efficiency, current density, and low overpotential, exhibiting excellent catalytic performance toward ECO₂ RR for CO and HCOOH productions that are economically viable. The intrinsic contribution of Co and the synergistic effects in Co-hybrid catalysts play essential roles for future commercial productions by ECO₂ RR. This review summarizes the rational design of Co-based catalysts for ECO₂ RR, including molecular, single-metal-site, and oxide-derived catalysts, along with the nanostructure engineering techniques to highlight the distribution of the ECO₂ RR products by Co-based catalysts. The density functional theory (DFT) simulations and advanced in situ characterizations contribute to interpreting the synergies between Co and other materials for the enhanced product selectivity and catalytic activity. Challenges and outlook concerning the catalyst design and reaction mechanism, including the upgrading of reaction systems of Co-based catalysts for ECO₂ RR, are also discussed.

Atomically dispersed Cu and Fe on N-doped carbon materials for CO2 electroreduction: insight into the curvature effect on activity and selectivity

CO₂ electroreduction reaction (CO₂ER) by single metal sites embedded in N-doped graphene (M@N-Gr, M = Cu and Fe) and carbon nanotubes (M@N-CNT, M = Cu and Fe) has been explored by extensive first-principles calculations in combination with the computational hydrogen electrode model. Both atomically dispersed Cu and Fe nanostructures, as the single atom catalysts (SACs), have higher selectivity towards CO₂ER, compared to hydrogen evolution reduction (HER), and they can catalyze CO₂ER to CO, HCOOH, and CH₃OH. In comparison with Cu@N-Gr, the limiting potentials for generating CO, HCOOH, and CH₃OH are reduced obviously on the high-curvature Cu@N-CNT. However, the curvature effect is less notable for the single-Fe-atom catalysts. Such discrepancies can be attributed to the d-band center changes of the single Cu and Fe sites and their different dependences on the curvature of carbon-based support materials.

Atomically dispersed Cu/Fe catalysts have high selectivity toward CO₂ER and the curvature of the catalyst support influences their activity.

Theoretical Understandings of Graphene-based Metal Single-Atom Catalysts: Stability and Catalytic Performance

Research on heterogeneous single-atom catalysts (SACs) has become an emerging frontier in catalysis science because of their advantages in high utilization of noble metals, precisely identified active sites, high selectivity, and tunable activity. Graphene, as a one-atom-thick two-dimensional carbon material with unique structural and electronic properties, has been reported to be a superb support for SACs. Herein, we provide an overview of recent progress in investigations of graphene-based SACs. Among the large number of publications, we will selectively focus on the stability of metal single-atoms (SAs) anchored on different sites of graphene support and the catalytic performances of graphene-based SACs for different chemical reactions, including thermocatalysis and electrocatalysis. We will summarize the fundamental understandings on the electronic structures and their intrinsic connection with catalytic properties of graphene-based SACs, and also provide a brief perspective on the future design of efficient SACs with graphene and graphene-like materials.

Microenvironment modulation of single-atom catalysts and their roles in electrochemical energy conversion

Single-atom catalysts (SACs) have become the most attractive frontier research field in heterogeneous catalysis. Since the atomically dispersed metal atoms are commonly stabilized by ionic/covalent interactions with neighboring atoms, the geometric and electronic structures of SACs depend greatly on their microenvironment, which, in turn, determine the performances in catalytic processes. In this review, we will focus on the recently developed strategies of SAC synthesis, with attention on the microenvironment modulation of single-atom active sites of SACs. Furthermore, experimental and computational advances in understanding such microenvironment in association to the catalytic activity and mechanisms are summarized and exemplified in the electrochemical applications, including the water electrolysis and O2/CO2/N2 reduction reactions. Last, by highlighting the prospects and challenges for microenvironment engineering of SACs, we wish to shed some light on the further development of SACs for electrochemical energy conversion.

Descriptor-Based Design Principle for Two-Dimensional Single-Atom Catalysts: Carbon Dioxide Electroreduction

Single-atom catalysis has recently emerged as a promising approach for catalyzing the carbon dioxide reduction reaction (CO₂RR). In this study, we present a principle for designing active single-atom catalysts (SACs) for CO₂RR. We systematically examine totally 24 transition metals supported by a graphitic carbon nitride (g-CN) monolayer and find that their catalytic activities are highly correlated with the adsorption free energies of two intermediate species (OH and OCH). We then identify two important intrinsic descriptors, namely, the number of electrons in the outmost d-shell and the enthalpy of vaporization of the transition metal. Test calculations on transition metals supported by a C₂N monolayer indicate that both descriptors are quite universal for SACs of CO₂RR. Based on these results, we show that Ni@g-CN, Cu@g-CN, and Co@C₂N are promising SACs for CO₂RR. This study offers an effective principle for designing highly active SACs for CO₂RR on the basis of intrinsic properties of transition metals.

Optimizing Electron Densities of Ni-N-C Complexes by Hybrid Coordination for Efficient Electrocatalytic CO2 Reduction

Metal-N-C is a type of attractive electrocatalyst for efficient CO₂ reduction to CO. Because of the ambiguity in their atomic structures, the active sites and catalytic mechanisms of the catalysts have remained under debate. Here, the effects of N and C hybrid coordination on the activity of Ni-N-C catalysts were investigated, combining theoretical and experimental methods. The theoretical calculations revealed that N and C hybrid coordination greatly enhanced the capability of single-atom Ni active sites to provide electrons to reactant molecules and strengthens the bonding of Ni to N and C in the Ni-N-C complexes. During the reaction process, the C and N coordination synergistically optimized the reaction energies in the conversion of CO₂ to CO. A good agreement between theoretical calculations and electrochemical experiments was achieved based on the newly developed Ni-N-C electrocatalysts. The activity of hybrid-coordination NiN₂ C₂ was more than double that of single-coordination NiN₄ .