Insight into the Effect of the d-Orbital Energy of Copper Ions in Metal–Organic Frameworks on the Selectivity of Electroreduction of CO2 to CH4

Highly Elliptic Circular Dichroism of Copper Aspartate One-Dimensional Nanostructures across the Ultraviolet to Terahertz Ranges

Since the discovery of chirality, circular dichroism (CD) of mirror-asymmetric molecules has been studied across the ultraviolet, visible, and near-infrared ranges. Recently, chiroptical activity studies have expanded to the terahertz (THz) range, where resonance peaks originate from collective vibrations of tens and hundreds of atoms. In this study, we synthesized Cu2+ coordination complexes with L- and D-aspartic acid as nanowires and nanorods and characterized their chiroptical activity across multiple frequency ranges. Both chiral nanostructures exhibit strong electronic CD (ECD), primarily from Cu2+ d-d transitions, while vibrational CD (VCD) spectra show sharp C=O, C-H, and O-H vibronic peaks, indicating higher atomic defect densities in nanorods than nanowires. Although THz CD (TCD) spectra are broad, they exhibit ∼1000× greater ellipticity than ECD and VCD, perhaps warranting previous references to circular dichroism of nanostructures as giant. Comparative TCD analysis highlights strong chiral phonon sensitivity, underscoring its potential for probing defect densities and structural changes for various chiral nanostructures and (bio)crystals.

The Cu─O─Co Asymmetric Bimetallic Sites Constructed by Ion-Exchange for Efficient Oxygen Evolution Reaction

Recently, constructing oxygen-bridged asymmetric bimetallic sites has proven to be an effective strategy for enhancing electrocatalytic activity. The strong electronic interaction between the metals regulates the d-band center, optimizing the adsorption and desorption of oxygen intermediates and lowering the oxygen evolution reaction (OER) energy barrier. However, examples of constructing such asymmetric sites in π-d conductive metal-organic frameworks (cMOFs) are still scarce. Here, the Co/Cu-DBC (DBC = Dibenzo-[g,p]chrysene-2,3,6,7,10,11,14,15-octaol) with high crystallinity and asymmetric Cu─O─Co bimetallic sites are prepared using an ion-exchange method. By varying the reaction temperature and time, the metal content can be precisely controlled. The Co/Cu-DBC shows excellent OER activity, with a small overpotential of 251 mV at 10 mA cm-2. Both experimental and density functional theory (DFT) calculations indicate that the construction of asymmetric Cu─O─Co sites leads to strong electronic interactions between Cu and Co through the axial oxygen atom, which regulates the d-band center energy (Ed) level and electronic structure to optimize the adsorption of intermediates and facilitate the formation of *O intermediates on the active Co sites toward fast OER kinetics. This work provides new insights for the synthesis and the design of efficient OER catalysts.

Engineering Atom-Scale Cascade Catalysis via Multi-Active Site Collaboration for Ampere-Level CO2 Electroreduction to C2+ Products

Electrochemical reduction of CO2 to value-added multicarbon (C2+) productions offers an attractive route for renewable energy storage and CO2 utilization, but it remains challenging to achieve high C2+ selectivity at industrial-level current density. Herein, a Mo1Cu single-atom alloy (SAA) catalyst is reported that displays a remarkable C2+ Faradaic efficiency of 86.4% under 0.80 A cm-2. Furthermore, the C2+ partial current density over Mo1Cu reaches 1.33 A cm-2 with a Faradaic efficiency surpasses 74.3%. The combination of operando spectroscopy and density functional theory (DFT) indicates the as-prepared Mo1Cu SAA catalyst enables atom-scale cascade catalysis via multi-active site collaboration. The introduced Mo sites promote the H2O dissociation to fabricate active *H, meanwhile, the Cu sites (Cu0) far from Mo atom are active sites for the CO2 activation toward CO. Further, CO and *H are captured by the adjacent Cu sites (Cu&+) near Mo atom, accelerating CO conversion and C─C coupling process. Our findings benefit the design of tandem electrocatalysts at atomic scale for transforming CO2 to multicarbon products under a high conversion rate.

Increasing electrochemical carbon dioxide reduction to methane via a novel copper-based conductive metal organic framework

The development of a new system for the electrochemical carbon dioxide reduction reaction (ECO2RR) to methane (CH4) is challenging, and novel conductive metal organic frameworks (c-MOFs) for efficient ECO2RR to CH4 are critical to this system. Here, we report a novel c-MOF, copper-pyromellitic dianhydride-2-methylbenzimidazole (Cu-PD-2-MBI), in which the introduction of electron-withdrawing 2-methylbenzimidazole (2-MBI) into the copper-pyromellitic dianhydride (Cu-PD) interlayer elevated the valence of copper (Cu) ions, which improved the ECO2RR performance of Cu-PD-2-MBI. Cu-PD-2-MBI was tested in a flow cell, and the Faradaic efficiency of CH4 reached 73.7 %, with a corresponding partial current density of -428.3 mA·cm-2 at -1.3 V, which was higher than those of most reported Cu-based catalysts. Further exploration via theoretical calculations indicated that the intercalated 2-MBI in Cu-PD-2-MBI induced a shift in the d-band center in the Cu sites from -2.63 to -1.86 eV and reduced the formation energy of the *COOH and *CHO intermediates in the process of generating CH4 compared with those of the reference Cu-PD catalyst.

Location-Specific Microenvironment Modulation Around Single-Atom Metal Sites in Metal-Organic Frameworks for Boosting Catalysis

Despite coordination environment of catalytic metal sites has been recognized to be of great importance in single-atom catalysts (SACs), a significant challenge remains in the understanding how the location-specific microenvironment in the higher coordination sphere influences their catalysis. Herein, a series of Cu-based SACs, namely Cu1/UiO-66-X (X=-NO2, -H, and -NH2), are successfully constructed by anchoring single Cu atoms onto the Zr-oxo clusters of metal-organic frameworks (MOFs), i.e., UiO-66-X. The -X functional groups dangling on the MOF linkers could be regarded as location-specific remote microenvironment to regulate electronic properties of the single Cu atoms. Remarkably, they exhibit significant differences in the catalysis toward the hydroboration of alkynes. The activity follows the order of Cu1/UiO-66-NO2 > Cu1/UiO-66 > Cu1/UiO-66-NH2 under identical reaction conditions, where Cu1/UiO-66-NO2 showcases the phenylacetylene conversion of 92 %, ~3.5 times higher efficiency than that of Cu1/UiO-66-NH2. Experimental and calculation results jointly support that the Cu electronic structure is modulated by the location-specific microenvironment, thereby regulating the product desorption and promoting the catalysis.

Promoting CO2 Electroreduction to Hydrocarbon Products via Sulfur-Enhanced Proton Feeding in Atomically Precise Thiolate-Protected Cu Clusters

Thiolate-protected Cu clusters with well-defined structures and stable low-coordinated Cu+ species exhibit remarkable potential for the CO2RR and are ideal model catalysts for establishing structure-electrocatalytic property relationships at the atomic level. However, extant Cu clusters employed in the CO2RR predominantly yield 2e- products. Herein, two model Cu4(MMI)4 and Cu8(MMI)4(tBuS)4 clusters (MMI=2-mercapto-1-methylimidazole) are prepared to investigate the synergistic effect of Cu+ and adjacent S sites on the CO2RR. Cu4(MMI)4 can reduce CO2 to deep-reduced products with a 91.0 % Faradaic efficiency (including 53.7 % for CH4) while maintaining remarkable stability. Conversely, Cu8(MMI)4(tBuS)4 shows a remarkable preference for C2+ products, achieving a maximum FE of 58.5 % with a C2+ current density of 152.1 mA⋅cm-2. In situ XAS and ex situ XPS spectra reveal the preservation of Cu+ species in Cu clusters during CO2RR, extensively enhancing the adsorption capacity of *CO intermediate. Moreover, kinetic analysis and theoretical calculations confirm that S sites facilitate H2O dissociation into *H species, which directly participate in the protonation process on adjacent Cu sites for the protonation of *CO to *CHO. This study highlights the important role of Cu-S dual sites in Cu clusters and provides mechanistic insights into the CO2RR pathway at the atomic level.

Unveiling the Structural Effects in Hybrid Copper Phosphonate Frameworks for Selective Electrocatalytic CO2 Reduction Reaction

Electrochemical CO2 reduction holds tremendous promise for transforming carbon dioxide into several value-added energy feedstocks and utilizing renewable energy sources. Herein, we have developed two novel copper-based organophosphonates for selective electrocatalytic conversion of CO2 to CH3OH conversion. The two-dimensional layer structure of Cu3[(Hhedp)2(C4H4N2)].2H2O (I) and the three-dimensional Cu3[(H3hedp)2(C4H4N2)4(SO4)].2H2O (II) have been isolated as single crystals via a hydrothermal strategy. Compound I consists of Cu2+ oxidation states exclusively, while compound II has Cu1+ oxidation states in a network wherein a Cu2+-phosphonate template is embedded inside the framework. Depending on mixed valent oxidation states, compound II exhibits high selectivity compared to compound I for the electrocatalytic reduction of CO2 to CH3OH (C1) as the primary product and CH3COOH (C2) as the secondary product. Notably, product selectivity is enhanced as the Faradaic efficiency (FE) of the competing hydrogen evolution reaction (HER) is significantly reduced in compound II relative to that of I, particularly at higher applied reduction potentials. The optimal ratio of Cu1+ active sites in compound II plays a pivotal role in enhancing methanol selectivity, stabilizing critical intermediates, and maintaining ideal reduction potentials as a noble-metal free electrocatalyst. Moreover, the optical band gap and the Mott-Schottky measurements further suggest the title Cu-phosphonate materials could be promising and effective photocatalysts.

Construction of coherent interface between Cu2O and CeO2via electrochemical reconstruction for efficient carbon dioxide reduction to methane

Developing an efficient electrocatalyst that enables the efficient electrochemical conversion from CO2 to CH4 across a wide potential range remains a formidable challenge. Herein, we introduce a precatalyst strategy that realizes the in situ electrochemical reconstruction of ultrafine Cu2O nanodomains, intricately coupled on the CeO2 surface (Cu2O/CeO2), originating from the heterointerface comprised of ultrafine CuO nanodomains on the CeO2 surface (CuO/CeO2). When served as the electrocatalyst for the electrochemical CO2 reduction reaction, Cu2O/CeO2 delivers a selectivity higher than 49 % towards CH4 over a broad potential range from -1.2 V to -1.7 V vs. RHE, maintaining negligible activity decay for 20 h. Notably, the highest selectivity for CH4 reaches an impressive 70 % at -1.5 V vs. RHE. Through the combination of comprehensive analysis including synchrotron X-ray absorption spectroscopy, spherical aberration-corrected high-angle annular dark field scanning transmission electron microscope as well as the density functional theoretical calculation, the efficient production of CH4 is attributed to the coherent interface between Cu2O and CeO2, which could converted from the original CuO and CeO2 interface, ensuring abundant active sites and enhanced intrinsic activity and selectivity towards CH4.

Atomic Design of Copper Active Sites in Pristine Metal-Organic Coordination Compounds for Electrocatalytic Carbon Dioxide Reduction

Electrocatalytic carbon dioxide reduction reaction (CO2RR) has emerged as a promising and sustainable approach to cut carbon emissions by converting greenhouse gas CO2 to value-added chemicals and fuels. Metal-organic coordination compounds, especially the copper (Cu)-based coordination compounds, which feature well-defined crystalline structures and designable metal active sites, have attracted much research attention in electrocatalytic CO2RR. Herein, the recent advances of electrochemical CO2RR on pristine Cu-based coordination compounds with different types of Cu active sites are reviewed. First, the general reaction pathways of electrocatalytic CO2RR on Cu-based coordination compounds are briefly introduced. Then the highly efficient conversion of CO2 on various kinds of Cu active sites (e.g., single-Cu site, dimeric-Cu site, multi-Cu site, and heterometallic site) is systematically discussed, along with the corresponding catalytic reaction mechanisms. Finally, some existing challenges and potential opportunities for this research direction are provided to guide the rational design of metal-organic coordination compounds for their practical application in electrochemical CO2RR.

Asymmetric Cu-N1O3 Sites Coupling Atop-type and Bridge-type Adsorbed *C1 for Electrocatalytic CO2-to-C2 Conversion

2D functional porous frameworks offer a platform for studying the structure-activity relationships during electrocatalytic CO2 reduction reaction (CO2RR). Yet challenges still exist to breakthrough key limitations on site configuration (typical M-O4 or M-N4 units) and product selectivity (common CO2-to-CO conversion). Herein, a novel 2D metal-organic framework (MOF) with planar asymmetric N/O mixed coordinated Cu-N1O3 unit is constructed, labeled as BIT-119. When applied to CO2RR, BIT-119 could reach a CO2-to-C2 conversion with C2 partial current density ranging from 36.9 to 165.0 mA cm-2 in flow cell. Compared to the typical symmetric Cu-O4 units, asymmetric Cu-N1O3 units lead to the re-distribution of local electron structure, regulating the adsorption strength of several key adsorbates and the following catalytic selectivity. From experimental and theoretical analyses, Cu-N1O3 sites could simultaneously couple the atop-type (on Cu site) and bridge-type (on Cu-N site) adsorption of *C1 species to reach the CO2-to-C2 conversion. This work broadens the feasible C-C coupling mechanism on 2D functional porous frameworks.

Phosphorus Coordination in Second Shell of Single-Atom Cu Catalyst toward Acetate Production in CO Electroreduction

It is challenging to achieve highly efficient CO-CO coupling toward C2 products in electrochemical CO and CO2 reductions on single-atom catalysts (SACs). Herein, we report a modulation strategy of phosphorus coordination in the second shell of Cu SACs with a Cu-N4 structure (Cu-N4-P4/C4) and demonstrate experimentally and theoretically the CO-CO coupling through an Eley-Rideal mechanism in electrochemical CO reduction (COR). Remarkably, the Cu SACs exhibit a selectivity of 63.9% toward acetate production in alkaline media on a gas diffusion electrode. Operando synchrotron-based X-ray absorption spectroscopy confirms the robust Cu-N4-P4/C4 structure of the Cu SACs against the harsh electrochemical reduction conditions throughout the electrochemical COR, instead of forming Cu clusters for Cu-N4 configuration, enabling an excellent COR performance toward acetate. This work not only unravels a new mechanism for CO-CO coupling toward C2 products in COR but also offers a novel strategy for SAC regulation toward multicarbon production with high activity, selectivity, and durability.

Modulating Electronic States of Cu in Metal-Organic Frameworks for Emerging Controllable CH4/C2H4 Selectivity in CO2 Electroreduction

The intensive study of electrochemical CO2 reduction reaction (CO2RR) has resulted in numerous highly selective catalysts, however, most of these still exhibit uncontrollable selectivity. Here, it is reported for the first time the controllable CH4/C2H4 selectivity by modulating the electronic states of Cu incorporated in metal-organic frameworks with different functional ligands, achieving a Faradaic efficiency of 58% for CH4 on Cu-incorporated UiO-66-H (Ce) composite catalysts, Cu/UiO-66-H (Ce) and that of 44% for C2H4 on Cu/UiO-66-F (Ce). In situ measurements of Raman and X-ray absorption spectra revealed that the electron-withdrawing ability of the ligand side group controls the product selectivity on MOFs through the modulation of the electronic states of Cu. This work opens new prospects for the development of MOFs as a platform for the tailored tuning of selectivity in CO2RR.

Molecular enhancement of Cu-based catalysts for CO2 electroreduction

The electrochemical carbon dioxide reduction reaction (eCO2RR) represents an effective means of achieving renewable energy storage and a supply of carbon-based raw materials. However, there are still great challenges in selectively producing specific hydrocarbon compounds. The unique ability of the copper (Cu) catalyst to promote proton-coupled electron transfer processes offers clear advantages in generating value-added products. This review presents molecular enhancement strategies for Cu-based catalysts for CO2 electroreduction. We also elucidate the principles of each strategy for enhancing eCO2RR performance, discuss the structure-activity relationships, and propose some promising molecular enhancement strategies. This review will provide guidance for the development of organic-inorganic hybrid Cu-based catalysts as high-performance CO2 electroreduction catalysts.

Rational design of organic ligands for metal-organic frameworks as electrocatalysts for CO2 reduction

Electrocatalytic carbon dioxide (CO2) reduction to valuable chemical compounds is a sustainable technology with enormous potential to facilitate carbon neutrality by transforming intermittent energy sources into stable fuels. Among various electrocatalysts, metal-organic frameworks (MOFs) have garnered increasing attention for the electrochemical CO2 reduction reaction (CO2RR) owing to their structural diversity, large surface area, high porosity and tunable chemical properties. Ligands play a vital role in MOFs, which can regulate the electronic structure and chemical environment of metal centers of MOFs, thereby influencing the activity and selectivity of products. This feature article discusses the strategies for the rational design of ligands and their impact on the CO2RR performance of MOFs to establish a structure-performance relationship. Finally, critical challenges and potential opportunities for MOFs with different ligand types in the CO2RR are mentioned with the aim to inspire the targeted design of advanced MOF catalysts in the future to achieve efficient electrocatalytic CO2 conversion.

In situ Raman reveals the critical role of Pd in electrocatalytic CO2 reduction to CH4 on Cu-based catalysts

Electrocatalytic CO2 reduction reaction (CO2RR) for CH4 production presents a promising strategy to address carbon neutrality, and the incorporation of a second metal has been proven effective in enhancing catalyst performance. Nevertheless, there remains limited comprehension regarding the fundamental factors responsible for the improved performance. Herein, the critical role of Pd in electrocatalytic CO2 reduction to CH4 on Cu-based catalysts has been revealed at a molecular level using in situ surface-enhanced Raman spectroscopy (SERS). A "borrowing" SERS strategy has been developed by depositing Cu-Pd overlayers on plasmonic Au nanoparticles to achieve the in situ monitoring of the dynamic change of the intermediate during CO2RR. Electrochemical tests demonstrate that Pd incorporation significantly enhances selectivity toward CH4 production, and the Faradaic efficiency (FE) of CH4 is more than two times higher than that for the catalysts without Pd. The key intermediates, including *CO2-, *CO, and *OH, have been directly identified under CO2RR conditions, and their evolution with the electrochemical environments has been determined. It is found that Pd incorporation promotes the activation of both CO2 and H2O molecules and accelerates the formation of abundant active *CO and hydrogen species, thus enhancing the CH4 selectivity. This work offers fundamental insights into the understanding of the molecular mechanism of CO2RR and opens up possibilities for designing more efficient electrocatalysts.

Ab Initio Studies of Electrocatalytic CO2 Reduction for Small Cu Cluster Supported on Polar Substrates

Small Cu clusters are excellent candidates for the electrocatalytic reduction of carbon dioxide (CO2RR), and their catalytic performance is expected to be significantly influenced by the interaction between the substrate and cluster. In this study, we systematically investigate the CO2RR for a Cu3 cluster anchored on Janus MoSX (X = Se, Te) substrates using density functional theory calculations. These substrates feature a broken vertical mirror symmetry, which generates spontaneous out-of-plane polarization and offers two distinct polar surfaces to support the Cu3 cluster. Our findings reveal that the CO2RR performance on the Cu3 cluster is strongly influenced by the polarization direction and strength of the MoSX (X = Se, Te) substrates. Notably, the Cu3 cluster supported on the S-terminated MoSTe surface (Cu3(S)@MoSTe) demonstrates the highest CO2RR activity, producing methane. These results underscore the pivotal role of substrate polarization in modulating the binding strength of reactants and reaction intermediates, thereby enhancing the CO2RR efficiency.

Hydrogen-Bonded Organic Framework Supporting Atomic Bi-N2O2 Sites for High-Efficiency Electrocatalytic CO2 Reduction

Single atomic catalysts (SACs) offer a superior platform for studying the structure-activity relationships during electrocatalytic CO2 reduction reaction (CO2RR). Yet challenges still exist to obtain well-defined and novel site configuration owing to the uncertainty of functional framework-derived SACs through calcination. Herein, a novel Bi-N2O2 site supported on the (1 1 0) plane of hydrogen-bonded organic framework (HOF) is reported directly for CO2RR. In flow cell, the target catalyst Bi1-HOF maintains a faradaic efficiency (FE) HCOOH of over 90 % at a wide potential window of 1.4 V. The corresponding partial current density ranges from 113.3 to 747.0 mA cm-2. And, Bi1-HOF exhibits a long-term stability of over 30 h under a successive potential-step test with a current density of 100-400 mA cm-2. Density function theory (DFT) calculations illustrate that the novel Bi-N2O2 site supported on the (1 1 0) plane of HOF effectively induces the oriented electron transfer from Bi center to CO2 molecule, reaching an enhanced CO2 activation and reduction. Besides, this study offers a versatile method to reach series of M-N2O2 sites with regulable metal centers via the same intercalation mechanism, broadening the platform for studying the structure-activity relationships during CO2RR.

Cu-phen Coordination Enabled Selective Electrocatalytic Reduction of CO2 to Methane

Manipulation of selectivity in the catalytic electrochemical carbon dioxide reduction reaction (eCO2RR) poses significant challenges due to inevitable structure reconstruction. One approach is to develop effective strategies for controlling reaction pathways to gain a deeper understanding of mechanisms in robust CO2RR systems. In this work, by precise introduction of 1,10-phenanthroline as a bidentate ligand modulator, the electronic property of the copper site was effectively regulated, thereby directing selectivity switch. By modification of [Cu3(btec)(OH)2]n, the use of [Cu2(btec)(phen)2]n·(H2O)n achieved the selectivity switch from ethylene (faradaic efficiency (FE) = 41%, FEC2+ = 67%) to methane (FECH4 = 69%). Various in situ spectroscopic characterizations revealed that [Cu2(btec)(phen)2]n·(H2O)n promoted the hydrogenation of *CO intermediates, leading to methane generation instead of dimerization to form C2+ products. Acting as a delocalized π-conjugation scaffold, 1,10-phenanthroline in [Cu2(btec)(phen)2]n·(H2O)n helps stabilize Cuδ+. This work presents a novel approach to regulate the coordination environment of active sites with the aim of selectively modulating the CO2RR.

Regulation of the d-band center of metal-organic frameworks for energy-saving hydrogen generation coupled with selective glycerol oxidation

The hybrid electrolyzer coupled glycerol oxidation (GOR) with hydrogen evolution reaction (HER) is fascinating to simultaneously generate H2 and high value-added chemicals with low energy input, yet facing a challenge. Herein, Cu-based metal-organic frameworks (Cu-MOFs) are reported as model catalysts for both HER and GOR through doping of atomically dispersed precious and nonprecious metals. Remarkably, the HER activity of Ru-doped Cu-MOF outperformed a Pt/C catalyst, with its Faradaic efficiency for formate formation at 90% at a low potential of 1.40 V. Furthermore, the hybrid electrolyzer only needed 1.36 V to achieve 10 mA cm-2, 340 mV lower than that for splitting pure water. Theoretical calculations demonstrated that electronic interactions between the host and guest (doped) metals shifted downward the d-band centers (εd) of MOFs. This consequently lowered water adsorption and dissociation energy barriers and optimized hydrogen adsorption energy, leading to significantly enhanced HER activities. Meanwhile, the downshift of εd centers reduced energy barriers for rate-limiting step and the formation energy of OH*, synergistically enhancing the activity of MOFs for GOR. These findings offered an effective means for simultaneous productions of hydrogen fuel and high value-added chemicals using one hybrid electrolyzer with low energy input.

Electronic Structure Design of Transition Metal-Based Catalysts for Electrochemical Carbon Dioxide Reduction

With the increasingly serious greenhouse effect, the electrochemical carbon dioxide reduction reaction (CO2RR) has garnered widespread attention as it is capable of leveraging renewable energy to convert CO2 into value-added chemicals and fuels. However, the performance of CO2RR can hardly meet expectations because of the diverse intermediates and complicated reaction processes, necessitating the exploitation of highly efficient catalysts. In recent years, with advanced characterization technologies and theoretical simulations, the exploration of catalytic mechanisms has gradually deepened into the electronic structure of catalysts and their interactions with intermediates, which serve as a bridge to facilitate the deeper comprehension of structure-performance relationships. Transition metal-based catalysts (TMCs), extensively applied in electrochemical CO2RR, demonstrate substantial potential for further electronic structure modulation, given their abundance of d electrons. Herein, we discuss the representative feasible strategies to modulate the electronic structure of catalysts, including doping, vacancy, alloying, heterostructure, strain, and phase engineering. These approaches profoundly alter the inherent properties of TMCs and their interaction with intermediates, thereby greatly affecting the reaction rate and pathway of CO2RR. It is believed that the rational electronic structure design and modulation can fundamentally provide viable directions and strategies for the development of advanced catalysts toward efficient electrochemical conversion of CO2 and many other small molecules.

Electron Localization-Triggered Proton Pumping Toward Cu Single Atoms for Electrochemical CO2 Methanation of Unprecedented Selectivity

Slow multi-proton coupled electron transfer kinetics and unexpected desorption of intermediates severely hinder the selectivity of CO2 methanation. In this work, a one-stone-two-bird strategy of pumping protons and improving adsorption configuration/capability enabled by electron localization is developed to be highly efficient for CH4 electrosynthesis over Cu single atoms anchored on bismuth vacancies of BiVO4 (Bi1-xVO4─Cu), with superior kinetic isotope effect and high CH4 Faraday efficiency (92%), far outperforming state-of-the-art electrocatalysts for CO2 methanation. Control experiments and theoretical calculations reveal that the bismuth vacancies (VBi) not only act as active sites for H2O dissociation but also induce electron transfer toward Cu single-atom sites. The VBi-induced electron localization pumps *H from VBi sites to Cu single atoms, significantly promoting the generation and stabilization of the pivotal intermediate (*CHO) for highly selective CH4 electrosynthesis. The metal vacancies as new initiators show enormous potential in the proton transfer-involved hydrogenative conversion processes.

Steering the Selectivity of Carbon Dioxide Electroreduction from Single-Carbon to Multicarbon Products on Metal-Organic Frameworks via Facet Engineering

Although metal-organic frameworks (MOFs) have attracted more attention for the electrocatalytic CO2 reduction reaction (CO2RR), obtaining multicarbon products with a high Faradaic efficiency (FE) remains challenging, especially under neutral conditions. Here, we report the controlled synthesis of stable Cu(I) 5-mercapto-1-methyltetrazole framework (Cu-MMT) nanostructures with different facets by rationally modulating the reaction solvents. Significantly, Cu-MMT nanostructures with (001) facets are acquired using isopropanol as a solvent, which favor multicarbon production with an FE of 73.75% and a multicarbon:single-carbon ratio of 3.93 for CO2RR in a neutral electrolyte. In sharp contrast, Cu-MMT nanostructures with (100) facets are obtained utilizing water, promoting single-carbon generation with an FE of 63.98% and a multicarbon: single-carbon ratio of only 0.18. Furthermore, this method can be extended to other Cu-MMT nanostructures with different facets in tuning the CO2 reduction selectivity. This work opens up new opportunities for the highly selective and efficient CO2 electroreduction to multicarbon products on MOFs via facet engineering.

Active-site stabilized Bi metal-organic framework-based catalyst for highly active and selective electroreduction of CO2 to formate over a wide potential window

Bismuth-based materials have been validated to be a kind of effective electrocatalyst for electrocatalytic CO2 reduction (ECR) to formate (HCOO-). However, the established studies still encounter the problems of low current density, low selectivity, narrow potential window, and poor catalyst stability. Herein, a bismuth-terephthalate framework (Bi-BDC MOF) material was successfully synthesized. The optimized Bi-BDC-120 °C exhibited excellent activity, selectivity, and durability for formate production. At an operating potential of -1.1 V vs. RHE in 0.1 mol L-1 KHCO3 electrolyte, the ECR catalyzed by Bi-BDC-120 °C achieved a Faraday efficiency (FE) of 97.2% towards formate generation, and the total current density reached about 30 mA cm-2. The operating potential window with FEformate values > 95% ranged in -0.9 to -1.5 V vs. RHE. The density-functional theory (DFT) calculation demonstrated that the (001) crystalline planes of Bi-BDC are preferable for the adsorption of CO2 and the conversion of *OCHO intermediates, thus ultimately promoting the electrocatalytic production of formate. Although the MOF structure of Bi-BDC-120 °C was insufficiently stabilized, the FEformate could be maintained at around 90% after 36 h of ECR operation. The long-term durability for formate production was attributed to the fact that the in situ reconstructed Bi2O2CO3 could retain the Bi-O active sites in the structure. These results offer an opportunity to design CO2 reduction electrocatalysts with high activity and selectivity for potential applications.

Near-Infrared Light-Enhanced Generation of Hydroxyl Radical for Cancer Immunotherapy

Hydroxyl radical (• OH) as a highly oxidizing reactive oxygen species can induce immunogenic cell death (ICD) in cancer treatment. However, high-efficiency cancer immunotherapy is still a huge challenge due to the low • OH generation efficiency in the tumor microenvironment, resulting in insufficient immunogenicity and the poor immune response. Here, a near-infrared (NIR) light-enhanced • OH generation strategy is developed for cancer immunotherapy by using a copper-based metal-organic framework (Cu-DBC) nanoplatform. With this strategy, the generation efficiency of • OH under NIR irradiation is increased 7.34 times than that without NIR irradiation, which induces robust ICD and immune response, thus leading to primary tumor elimination and the inhibition of distant tumor growth and tumor lung metastasis. Experimental results show that Cu-DBC can induce • OH boosting through photothermal (PT)-enhanced Cu-catalytic Fenton-like reaction and photocatalytic electron transfer under NIR light irradiation to amplify tumor ICD for immunotherapy.

Efficient electroreduction of CO to acetate using a metal-azolate framework with dicopper active sites

Electrochemical reduction of CO to value-added products, especially C2 products, provides a potential approach to achieve carbon neutrality and overcome the energy crisis. Herein, we report a metal-azolate framework (CuBpz) with dicopper active sites as an electrocatalyst for the electrochemical CO reduction reaction (eCORR). As a result, CuBpz achieved an impressive faradaic efficiency (FE) of 47.8% for yielding acetate with a current density of -200 mA cm-2, while no obvious degradation was observed over 60 hours of continuous operation at a current density of -200 mA cm-2. Mechanism studies revealed that the dicopper site can promote C-C coupling between two C1 intermediates, thereby being conducive to the generation of the key *CH2COOH intermediate.

Atomic Cu Sites Engineering Enables Efficient CO2 Electroreduction to Methane with High CH4/C2H4 Ratio

Electrochemical reduction of CO2 into high-value hydrocarbons and alcohols by using Cu-based catalysts is a promising and attractive technology for CO2 capture and utilization, resulting from their high catalytic activity and selectivity. The mobility and accessibility of active sites in Cu-based catalysts significantly hinder the development of efficient Cu-based catalysts for CO2 electrochemical reduction reaction (CO2RR). Herein, a facile and effective strategy is developed to engineer accessible and structural stable Cu sites by incorporating single atomic Cu into the nitrogen cavities of the host graphitic carbon nitride (g-C3N4) as the active sites for CO2-to-CH4 conversion in CO2RR. By regulating the coordination and density of Cu sites in g-C3N4, an optimal catalyst corresponding to a one Cu atom in one nitrogen cavity reaches the highest CH4 Faraday efficiency of 49.04% and produces the products with a high CH4/C2H4 ratio over 9. This work provides the first experimental study on g-C3N4-supported single Cu atom catalyst for efficient CH4 production from CO2RR and suggests a principle in designing highly stable and selective high-efficiency Cu-based catalysts for CO2RR by engineering Cu active sites in 2D materials with porous crystal structures.

Dicopper(I) Sites Confined in a Single Metal-Organic Layer Boosting the Electroreduction of CO2 to CH4 in a Neutral Electrolyte

It is challenging and important to achieve high performance for an electrochemical CO2 reduction reaction (eCO2RR) to yield CH4 under neutral conditions. So far, most of the reported active sites for eCO2RR to yield CH4 are single metal sites; the performances are far below the commercial requirements. Herein, we reported a nanosheet metal-organic layer in single-layer, namely, [Cu2(obpy)2] (Cuobpy-SL, Hobpy = 1H-[2,2']bipyridinyl-6-one), possessing dicopper(I) sites for eCO2RR to yield CH4 in a neutral aqueous solution. Detailed examination of Cuobpy-SL revealed high performance for CH4 production with a faradic efficiency of 82(1)% and a current density of ∼90 mA cm-2 at -1.4 V vs. reversible hydrogen electrode (RHE). No obvious degradation was observed over 100 h of continuous operation, representing a remarkable performance to date. Mechanism studies showed that compared with the conventional single-copper sites and completely exposed dicopper(I) sites, the dicopper(I) sites in the confined space formed by the molecular stacking have a strong affinity to key C1 intermediates such as *CO, *CHO, and *CH2O to facilitate the CH4 production, yet inhibiting C-C coupling.

Customization from Single to Dual Atomic Sites for Efficient Electrocatalytic CO2 Reduction to Value-added Chemicals

In recent years, single-atom catalysts (SACs) have received increasing attention in the field of electrochemical CO2 RR with their efficient atom utilization efficiency and excellent catalytic performance. However, their low metal loading and the presence of linear relationships for single active sites with simple structures possibly restrict their activity and practical applications. Active site tailoring at the atomic level is a visionary approach to break the existing limitations of SACs. This paper first briefly introduces the synthesis strategies of SACs and DACs. Then, combining previous experimental and theoretical studies, this paper introduces four optimization strategies, namely spin-state tuning engineering, axial functionalization engineering, ligand engineering, and substrate tuning engineering, for improving the catalytic performance of SACs in the electrochemical CO2 RR process by combining previous experimental and theoretical studies. Then it is introduced that DACs exhibit significant advantages over SACs in increasing metal atom loading, promoting the adsorption and activation of CO2 molecules, modulating intermediate adsorption, and promoting C-C coupling. At the end of this paper, we briefly and succinctly summarize the main challenges and application prospects of SACs and DACs in the field of electrochemical CO2 RR at present.

Regulation of Electrocatalytic Behavior by Axial Oxygen Enhances the Catalytic Activity of CoN4 Sites for CO2 Reduction

Recent studies have found that the existence of oxygen around the active sites may be essential for efficient electrochemical CO2 -to-CO conversion. Hence, this work proposes the modulation of oxygen coordination and investigates the as-induced catalytic behavior in CO2 RR. It designs and synthesizes conjugated phthalocyanine frameworks catalysts (CPF-Co) with abundant CoN4 centers as an active source, and subsequently modifies the electronic structure of CPF-Co by introducing graphene oxide (GO) with oxygen-rich functional groups. A systematic study reveals that the axial coordination between oxygen and the catalytic sites could form an optimized O-CoN4 structure to break the electron distribution symmetry of Co, thus reducing the energy barrier to the activation of CO2 to COOH*. Meanwhile, by adjusting the content of oxygen, the proper supports can also facilitate the charge transfer efficiency between the matrix layer and the catalytic sites. The optimized CPF-Co@LGO exhibits a high TOF value (2.81 s-1 ), CO selectivity (97.6%) as well as stability (24 h) at 21 mA cm-2 current density. This work reveals the modulation of oxygen during CO2 RR and provides a novel strategy for the design of efficient electrocatalysts, which may inspire new exploration and principles for CO2 RR.

A rational design of functional porous frameworks for electrocatalytic CO2 reduction reaction

The electrocatalytic CO₂ reduction reaction (ECO₂RR) is considered one of the approaches with the most potential to achieve lower carbon emissions in the future, but a huge gap still exists between the current ECO₂RR technology and industrial applications. Therefore, the design and preparation of catalysts with satisfactory activity, selectivity and stability for the ECO₂RR have attracted extensive attention. As a classic type of functional porous framework, crystalline porous materials (e.g., metal organic frameworks (MOFs) and covalent organic frameworks (COFs)) and derived porous materials (e.g., MOF/COF composites and pyrolysates) have been regarded as superior catalysts for the ECO₂RR due to their advantages such as designable porosity, modifiable skeleton, flexible active site structure, regulable charge transfer pathway and controllable morphology. Meanwhile, with the rapid development of nano-characterization and theoretical calculation technologies, the structure-activity relationships of functional porous frameworks have been comprehensively considered, i.e., metallic element type, local coordination environment, and microstructure, corresponding to selectivity, activity and mass transfer efficiency for the ECO₂RR, respectively. In this review, the rational design strategy for functional porous frameworks is briefly but precisely generalized based on three key factors including metallic element type, local coordination environment, and microstructure. Then, details about the structure-activity relationships for functional porous frameworks are illustrated in the order of MOFs, COFs, composites and pyrolysates to analyze the effect of the above-mentioned three factors on their ECO₂RR performance. Finally, the challenges and perspectives of functional porous frameworks for the further development of the ECO₂RR are reasonably proposed, aiming to offer insights for future studies in this intriguing and significant research field.

Metal-Organic Frameworks as Electrocatalysts

Transition metal complexes are well-known homogeneous electrocatalysts. In this regard, metal-organic frameworks (MOFs) can be considered as an ensemble of transition metal complexes ordered in a periodic arrangement. In addition, MOFs have several additional positive structural features that make them suitable for electrocatalysis, including large surface area, high porosity, and high content of accessible transition metal with exchangeable coordination positions. The present review describes the current state in the use of MOFs as electrocatalysts, both as host of electroactive guests and their direct electrocatalytic activity, particularly in the case of bimetallic MOFs. The field of MOF-derived materials is purposely not covered, focusing on the direct use of MOFs or its composites as electrocatalysts. Special attention has been paid to present strategies to overcome their poor electrical conductivity and limited stability.

Recent progress of theoretical studies on electro- and photo-chemical conversion of CO2 with single-atom catalysts

The CO2 reduction reaction (CO2RR) into chemical products is a promising and efficient way to combat the global warming issue and greenhouse effect. The viability of the CO2RR critically rests with finding highly active and selective catalysts that can accomplish the desired chemical transformation. Single-atom catalysts (SACs) are ideal in fulfilling this goal due to the well-defined active sites and support-tunable electronic structure, and exhibit enhanced activity and high selectivity for the CO2RR. In this review, we present the recent progress of quantum-theoretical studies on electro- and photo-chemical conversion of CO2 with SACs and frameworks. Various calculated products of CO2RR with SACs have been discussed, including CO, acids, alcohols, hydrocarbons and other organics. Meanwhile, the critical challenges and the pathway towards improving the efficiency of the CO2RR have also been discussed.

Highly Selective Monomethylation of Amines with CO2 /H2 via Ag/Al2 O3 as a Catalyst

The selective synthesis of monomethylated amines with CO₂ is particularly challenging because the formation of tertiary amines is thermodynamically more favorable. Herein, a new strategy for the controllable synthesis of N-monomethylated amines from primary amines and CO₂ /H₂ is explored. First-principle calculations reveal that the dissociation of H₂ via an heterolytic route reduces the reactivity of methylated amines and thus inhibit successive methylation. In situ DRIFTS proves the process of formation and decomposition of ammonium salt by secondary amine reversible binding with H⁺ on the Ag/Al₂ O₃ catalyst, thereby reducing its reactivity. Meanwhile, the energy barrier for the rate-determining step of monomethylation was much lower than that of overmethylation (0.34 eV vs. 0.58 eV) means amines monomethylation in preference to successive methylation. Under optimal reaction conditions, a variety of amines were converted to the corresponding monomethylated amines in good to excellent yields, and more than 90 % yield of product was obtained.

Rational Design of Metal-Organic Frameworks for Electroreduction of CO2 to Hydrocarbons and Carbon Oxygenates

Since CO2 can be reutilized by using renewable electricity in form of product diversity, electrochemical CO2 reduction (ECR) is expected to be a burgeoning strategy to tackle environmental problems and the energy crisis. Nevertheless, owing to the limited selectivity and reaction efficiency for a single component product, ECR is still far from a large-scale application. Therefore, designing high performance electrocatalysts is the key objective in CO2 conversion and utilization. Unlike most other types of electrocatalysts, metal-organic frameworks (MOFs) have clear, designable, and tunable catalytic active sites and chemical microenvironments, which are highly conducive to establish a clear structure-performance relationship and guide the further design of high-performance electrocatalysts. This Outlook concisely and critically discusses the rational design strategies of MOF catalysts for ECR in terms of reaction selectivity, current density, and catalyst stability, and outlines the prospects for the development of MOF electrocatalysts and industrial applications. In the future, more efforts should be devoted to designing MOF structures with high stability and electronic conductivity besides high activity and selectivity, as well as to develop efficient electrolytic devices suitable for MOF catalysts.

Thermo-, Electro-, and Photocatalytic CO2 Conversion to Value-Added Products over Porous Metal/Covalent Organic Frameworks

ConspectusThe continuing increase of the concentration of atmospheric CO₂ has caused many environmental issues including climate change. Catalytic conversion of CO₂ using thermochemical, electrochemical, and photochemical methods is a potential technique to decrease the CO₂ concentration and simultaneously obtain value-added chemicals. Due to the high energy barrier of CO₂ however, this method is still far from large-scale applications which requires high activity, selectivity, and stability. Therefore, development of efficient catalysts to convert CO₂ to different products is urgent. With their well-engineered pores and chemical compositions, high surface area, elevated CO₂ adsorption capability, and adjustable active sites, porous crystalline frameworks including metal-organic frameworks (MOFs) and covalent organic frameworks (COFs) are potential materials for catalytic CO₂ conversion. Here, we summarize our recent work on MOFs and COFs for thermocatalytic, electrocatalytic, and photocatalytic CO₂ conversion and describe the structure-activity relationships that could guide the design of effective catalysts.The first section of this paper describes imidazolium-functionalized porous MOFs, including porous liquid and cationic MOFs with nucleophilic halogen ions, which can promote thermocatalytically CO₂ cycloaddition reaction with epoxides toward cyclic carbonates at one bar pressure. A porous liquid MOF takes on the role of a CO₂ reservoir to tackle the low local CO₂ concentrations in gas-liquid-solid heterogeneous reactions. Imidazolium-functionalized MOFs with halogen ions for CO₂ cycloaddition could avoid the use of cocatalysts, and this leads to milder and more facile experimental conditions and separation processes.In a section dealing with the electrocatalytic CO₂ reduction reaction (CO₂RR), we developed a series of conductive porous framework materials with fast electron transmission capabilities, which afford high current densities and outperform the traditional MOF and COF catalysts that have been reported. The intrinsically conductive two-dimensional 2D MOFs and COFs nanosheets based on the fully π-conjugated phthalocyanine motif with excellent electron transport capability were prepared, and strong electron transporters were also integrated into metalloporphyrin-based COFs for CO₂RR. Cu₂O quantum dots and Cu nanoparticles (NPs) can be uniformly dispersed on porous conductive MOFs/COFs to afford synergistic and/or tandem electrocatalysts, which can achieve highly selective production of CH₄ or C₂H₄ in CO₂RR.A third section describes our efforts to facilitate electron-hole separation in CO₂ photocatalysis. Our focus is on regulation of coordination spheres in MOFs, fabrication of the architecture of MOF heterojunctions, and engineering MOF films to facilitate photocatalytic CO₂ reduction.Finally, we discuss several problems associated with the studies of MOFs and COFs for CO₂ conversion and consider some prospects of the fabrication of effective porous frameworks for CO₂ adsorption and conversion.