Tuning Localized Surface Plasmon Resonance in Scanning Near-Field Optical Microscopy Probes

Quantitative comparison of local field enhancement from tip-apex and plasmonic nanofocusing excitation via plasmon-assisted field emission resonances

Plasmonic nanofocusing via off-site excitation offers a promising approach to minimize background light scattering and enhance excitation efficiency in tip-enhanced optical spectroscopy. However, a comprehensive understanding of its effectiveness compared to direct tip-apex excitation remains limited. Here we introduce plasmon-assisted field emission resonances as a practicable approach for quantitative evaluation of the local field enhancement in a scanning-tunneling-microscope junction via off-site excitation compared to direct tip-apex excitation. By using single-groove pyramidal tips suitable for multi-wavelength excitations, we find that the near-field intensity is approximately 3.8 and 1.7 times higher for off-site excitation than for direct apex excitation at excitation wavelengths of 780 nm and 633 nm, respectively. These results are further supported by numerical electromagnetic field simulations. Our findings demonstrate the effective implementation of plasmonic nanofocusing in low-temperature scanning tunneling microscopy, paving the way for more precise and background-free tip-enhanced optical spectroscopy at the atomic scale.

Nanoscale chemical characterization of materials and interfaces by tip-enhanced Raman spectroscopy

Materials and their interfaces are the core for the development of a large variety of fields, including catalysis, energy storage and conversion. In this case, tip-enhanced Raman spectroscopy (TERS), which combines scanning probe microscopy with plasmon-enhanced Raman spectroscopy, is a powerful technique that can simultaneously obtain the morphological information and chemical fingerprint of target samples at nanometer spatial resolution. It is an ideal tool for the nanoscale chemical characterization of materials and interfaces, correlating their structures with chemical performances. In this review, we begin with a brief introduction to the nanoscale characterization of materials and interfaces, followed by a detailed discussion on the recent theoretical understanding and technical improvements of TERS, including the origin of enhancement, TERS instruments, TERS tips and the application of algorithms in TERS. Subsequently, we list the key experimental issues that need to be addressed to conduct successful TERS measurements. Next, we focus on the recent progress of TERS in the study of various materials, especially the novel low-dimensional materials, and the progresses of TERS in studying different interfaces, including both solid-gas and solid-liquid interfaces. Finally, we provide an outlook on the future developments of TERS in the study of materials and interfaces.

Double Tips for In-Plane Polarized Near-Field Microscopy and Spectroscopy

Near-field optical microscopy and spectroscopy provide high-resolution imaging below the diffraction limit, crucial in physics, chemistry, and biology for studying molecules, nanoparticles, and viruses. These techniques use a sharp metallic tip of an atomic force microscope (AFM) to enhance incoming and scattered light by excited near-fields at the tip apex, leading to high sensitivity and a spatial resolution of a few nanometers. However, this restricts the near-field orientation to out-of-plane polarization, limiting optical polarization choices. We introduce double tips that offer in-plane polarization for enhanced imaging and spectroscopy. These double tips provide superior enhancement over single tips, although with a slightly lower spatial resolution (∼30 nm). They enable advanced studies of nanotubes, graphene defects, and transition metal dichalcogenides, benefiting from polarization control. The double tips allow varied polarization in tip-enhanced Raman scattering and selective excitation of transverse-electric and -magnetic polaritons, expanding the range of nanoscale samples that can be studied.

Polarization-Resolved Electron Energy Gain Nanospectroscopy With Phase-Structured Electron Beams

Free-electron-based measurements in scanning transmission electron microscopes (STEMs) reveal valuable information on the broadband spectral responses of nanoscale systems with deeply subdiffraction limited spatial resolution. Leveraging recent advances in manipulating the spatial phase profile of the transverse electron wavefront, we theoretically describe interactions between the electron probe and optically stimulated nanophotonic targets in which the probe gains energy while simultaneously transitioning between transverse states with distinct phase profiles. Exploiting the selection rules governing such transitions, we propose phase-shaped electron energy gain nanospectroscopy for probing the 3D polarization-resolved response field of an optically excited target with nanoscale spatial resolution. Considering ongoing instrumental developments, polarized generalizations of STEM electron energy loss and gain measurements hold the potential to become powerful tools for fundamental studies of quantum materials and their interaction with nearby nanostructures supporting localized surface plasmon or phonon polaritons as well as for noninvasive imaging and nanoscale 3D field tomography.

Single-Molecule Surface-Enhanced Raman Spectroscopy

Single-molecule surface-enhanced Raman spectroscopy (SM-SERS) has the potential to detect single molecules in a non-invasive, label-free manner with high-throughput. SM-SERS can detect chemical information of single molecules without statistical averaging and has wide application in chemical analysis, nanoelectronics, biochemical sensing, etc. Recently, a series of unprecedented advances have been realized in science and application by SM-SERS, which has attracted the interest of various fields. In this review, we first elucidate the key concepts of SM-SERS, including enhancement factor (EF), spectral fluctuation, and experimental evidence of single-molecule events. Next, we systematically discuss advanced implementations of SM-SERS, including substrates with ultra-high EF and reproducibility, strategies to improve the probability of molecules being localized in hotspots, and nonmetallic and hybrid substrates. Then, several examples for the application of SM-SERS are proposed, including catalysis, nanoelectronics, and sensing. Finally, we summarize the challenges and future of SM-SERS. We hope this literature review will inspire the interest of researchers in more fields.

Circular nanocavity substrate-assisted plasmonic tip for its enhancement in nanofocusing and optical trapping

Plasmonic tip nanofocusing has widely been applied in tip-enhanced Raman spectroscopy, optical trapping, nonlinear optics, and super-resolution imaging due to its capability of high local field enhancement. In this work, a substrate with a circular nanocavity is proposed to enhance the nanofocusing and optical trapping characteristics of the plasmonic tip. Under axial illumination of a tightly focused radial polarized beam, the circular nanohole etched on a metallic substrate can form a nanocavity to induce an interference effect and further enhance the electric field intensity. When a plasmonic tip is placed closely above such a substrate, the electric field intensity of the gap-plasmon mode can further be improved, which is 10 folds stronger than that of the conventional gap-plasmon mode. Further analysis reveals that the enhanced gap-plasmon mode can significantly strengthen the optical force exerted on a nanoparticle and stably trap a 4-nm-diameter dielectric nanoparticle. Our proposed method can improve the performance of tip-enhanced spectroscopy, plasmonic tweezers and extend their applications. We anticipate that our methods allow simultaneously manipulating and characterizing single nanoparticles in-situ.

Recent advances in plasmon-enhanced Raman spectroscopy for catalytic reactions on bifunctional metallic nanostructures

Metallic nanostructures exhibit superior catalytic performance for diverse chemical reactions and the in-depth understanding of reaction mechanisms requires versatile characterization methods. Plasmon-enhanced Raman spectroscopy (PERS), including surface-enhanced Raman spectroscopy (SERS), shell-isolated nanoparticle-enhanced Raman spectroscopy (SHINERS), and tip-enhanced Raman spectroscopy (TERS), appears as a powerful technique to characterize the Raman fingerprint information of surface species with high chemical sensitivity and spatial resolution. To expand the range of catalytic reactions studied by PERS, catalytically active metals are integrated with plasmonic metals to produce bifunctional metallic nanostructures. In this minireview, we discuss the recent advances in PERS techniques to probe the chemical reactions catalysed by bifunctional metallic nanostructures. First, we introduce different architectures of these dual-functionality nanostructures. We then highlight the recent works using PERS to investigate important catalytic reactions as well as the electronic and catalytic properties of these nanostructures. Finally, we provide some perspectives for future PERS studies in this field.

Electrochemical Tip-Enhanced Raman Spectroscopy: An In Situ Nanospectroscopy for Electrochemistry

Revealing the intrinsic relationships between the structure, properties, and performance of the electrochemical interface is a long-term goal in the electrochemistry and surface science communities because it could facilitate the rational design of electrochemical devices. Achieving this goal requires in situ characterization techniques that provide rich chemical information and high spatial resolution. Electrochemical tip-enhanced Raman spectroscopy (EC-TERS), which provides molecular fingerprint information with nanometer-scale spatial resolution, is a promising technique for achieving this goal. Since the first demonstration of this technique in 2015, EC-TERS has been developed for characterizing various electrochemical processes at the nanoscale and molecular level. Here, we review the development of EC-TERS over the past 5 years. We discuss progress in addressing the technical challenges, including optimizing the EC-TERS setup and solving tip-related issues, and provide experimental guidelines. We also survey the important applications of EC-TERS for probing molecular protonation, molecular adsorption, electrochemical reactions, and photoelectrochemical reactions. Finally, we discuss the opportunities and challenges in the future development of this young technique.

Tip-enhanced Raman spectroscopy for nanoscale probing of dynamic chemical systems

Dynamics are fundamental to all aspects of chemistry and play a central role in the mechanism and product distribution of a chemical reaction. All dynamic processes are influenced by the local environment, so it is of fundamental and practical value to understand the structure of the environment and the dynamics with nanoscale resolution. Most techniques for measuring dynamic processes have microscopic spatial resolution and can only measure the average behavior of a large ensemble of sites within their sampling volumes. Tip-enhanced Raman spectroscopy (TERS) is a powerful tool for overcoming this limitation due to its combination of high chemical specificity and spatial resolution that is on the nanometer scale. Adapting it for the study of dynamic systems remains a work in progress, but the increasing sophistication of TERS is making such studies more routine, and there are now growing efforts to use TERS to examine more complex processes. This Perspective aims to promote development in this area of research by highlighting recent progress in using TERS to understand reacting and dynamic systems, ranging from simple model reactions to complex processes with practical applications. We discuss the unique challenges and opportunities that TERS presents for future studies.

Beam Modulation for Aberration Control and Signal Enhancement in Tip-Enhanced Raman Spectroscopy

Tip-enhanced Raman spectroscopy (TERS) provides the sensitivity required to obtain the vibrational fingerprint of few molecules. While single molecule detection has been demonstrated in UHV experiments, the sensitivity of the technique in ambient, liquid and electrochemical conditions is still limited. In this work, we present a new strategy to increase the signal-to-noise in TERS by spatial light modulation. We iteratively optimize the phase of the excitation beam employing two different feedback mechanisms. In one optimization protocol, we monitor the spectral changes upon aberration correction and tight far-field focusing. In a second protocol, we use a phase-optimization strategy where TER spectra are directly used for feedback. Far-field tight focusing results in average signal enhancements of a factor of 3.5 in air and has no impact on TER signals obtained from solid/liquid interfaces. Using the TER spectrum as direct feedback, we obtain average signal enhancements between a factor of 2.6 in liquid and 4.3 in air. In individual cases, some bands increase by more than one order of magnitude in intensity upon spatial light modulation. Importantly, phase modulation in addition allowed the retrieval of bands that were initially not discernible from the noise. The proposed beam-modulation strategy can be easily implemented in existing TERS instruments and can help to push the detection limit of the technique in applications where the signal-to-noise level is low.

Inverse design of plasmonic metasurfaces by convolutional neural network

Artificial neural networks have shown effectiveness in the inverse design of nanophotonic structures; however, the numerical accuracy and algorithm efficiency are not analyzed adequately in previous reports. In this Letter, we demonstrate the convolutional neural network as an inverse design tool to achieve high numerical accuracy in plasmonic metasurfaces. A comparison of the convolutional neural networks and the fully connected neural networks show that convolutional neural networks have higher generalization capabilities. We share practical guidelines for optimizing the neural network and analyzed the hierarchy of accuracy in the multi-parameter inverse design of plasmonic metasurfaces. A high inverse design accuracy of $\pm 8\;{\rm nm}$±8nm for the critical geometrical parameters is demonstrated.

Quantitative comparison of plasmon resonances and field enhancements of near-field optical antennae using FDTD simulations

Plasmon resonances and electric field enhancements of several near-field optical antennae with plasmonic nanostructures engineered at their apices were quantitatively compared using finite difference time domain simulations. Although many probe designs have been tested experimentally, a systematic comparison of field enhancements has not been possible, due to differences in instrument configuration, reporter mechanism, excitation energy, and plasmonic materials used. For plasmonic nanostructures attached to a non-plasmonic support (e.g., a nanoparticle functionalized AFM tip), we find that the complex refractive index of the support material is critical in controlling the overall plasmonic behavior of the antenna. Supports with strong absorption at optical energies (Pt, W) dampen plasmon resonances and lead to lower enhancements, while those with low absorption (SiO₂, Si₃N₄, Si) boost enhancement by increasing the extinction cross-section of the apex nanostructure. Using a set of physically realistic constraints, probes were optimized for peak plasmonic enhancement at common near-field optical wavelengths (633-647 nm) and those with focused ion-beam milled grooves near the apex were found to give the largest local field enhancements (~30x). Compared to unstructured metal cones, grooved probes gave a 300% improvement in field strength, which can boost tip-enhanced Raman spectroscopy (TERS) signals by 1-2 orders of magnitude. Moreover, grooved probe resonances can be easily tuned over visible and near-infrared energies by varying the plasmonic metal (Ag or Au) and groove location. Overall, this work shows that probes with strong localized surface plasmon resonances at their apices can be engineered to provide large field enhancements and boost signals in near-field optical experiments.

Tip-Enhanced Raman Scattering from Nanopatterned Graphene and Graphene Oxide

Tip-enhanced Raman spectroscopy (TERS) is particularly sensitive to analytes residing at plasmonic tip-sample nanojunctions, where the incident and scattered optical fields may be localized and optimally enhanced. However, the enhanced local electric fields in this so-called gap-mode TERS configuration are nominally orthogonal to the sample plane. As such, any given Raman active vibrational eigenstate needs to have projections (of its polarizability derivative tensor elements) along the sample normal to be detectable via TERS. The faint TERS signals observed from two prototypical systems, namely, pristine graphene and graphene oxide are a classical example of the aforementioned rather restrictive TERS selection rules in this context. In this study, we demonstrate that nanoindentation, herein achieved using pulsed-force lithography with a sharp single-crystal diamond atomic force microscope probe, may be used to locally enhance TERS signals from graphene and graphene oxide flakes on gold. Nanoindentation locally perturbs the otherwise flat graphene structure and introduces out-of-plane protrusions that generate enhanced TERS. Although our approach is nominally invasive, we illustrate that the introduced nanodefects are highly localized, as evidenced by TERS nanoscale chemical mapping. As such, the described protocol may be used to extend and generalize the applicability of TERS for the rapid identification of two-dimensional material systems on the nanoscale.

Nanoscale Optical Microscopy and Spectroscopy Using Near-Field Probes

Light-matter interactions can provide a wealth of detailed information about the structural, electronic, optical, and chemical properties of materials through various excitation and scattering processes that occur over different length, energy, and timescales. Unfortunately, the wavelike nature of light limits the achievable spatial resolution for interrogation and imaging of materials to roughly λ/2 because of diffraction. Scanning near-field optical microscopy (SNOM) breaks this diffraction limit by coupling light to nanostructures that are specifically designed to manipulate, enhance, and/or extract optical signals from very small regions of space. Progress in the SNOM field over the past 30 years has led to the development of many methods to optically characterize materials at lateral spatial resolutions well below 100 nm. We review these exciting developments and demonstrate how SNOM is truly extending optical imaging and spectroscopy to the nanoscale.

A classical description of subnanometer resolution by atomic features in metallic structures

Recent experiments have evidenced sub-nanometer resolution in plasmonic-enhanced probe spectroscopy. Such a high resolution cannot be simply explained using the commonly considered radii of metallic nanoparticles on plasmonic probes. In this contribution the effects of defects as small as a single atom found on spherical plasmonic particles acting as probing tips are investigated in connection with the spatial resolution provided. The presence of abundant edge and corner sites with atomic scale dimensions in crystalline metallic nanoparticles is evident from transmission electron microscopy (TEM) images. Electrodynamic calculations based on the Finite Element Method (FEM) are implemented to reveal the impact of the presence of such atomic features in probing tips on the lateral spatial resolution and field localization. Our analysis is developed for three different configurations, and under resonant and non-resonant illumination conditions, respectively. Based on this analysis, the limits of field enhancement, lateral resolution and field confinement in plasmon-enhanced spectroscopy and microscopy are inferred, reaching values below 1 nanometer for reasonable atomic sizes.

Mastering high resolution tip-enhanced Raman spectroscopy: towards a shift of perception

Recent years have seen tremendous improvement of our understanding of high resolution reachable in TERS experiments, forcing us to re-evaluate our understanding of the intrinsic limits of this field, but also exposing several inconsistencies.

Stimuli-Responsive Extraction and Ambidextrous Redispersion of Zwitterionic Amphiphile-Capped Silver Nanoparticles

Citrate-stabilized silver nanoparticles (AgNPs) were functionalized with a pH-responsive amphiphile, 3-[(2-carboxy-ethyl)-hexadecyl-amino]-propionic acid (C16CA). At pH ∼ 4, the zwitterionic C16CA assembled into lamellar structures due to the protonation of the amine groups of the amphiphile that neutralized the anionic charge of the carboxylate groups. The lamellar supramolecules incorporated the AgNPs into their 3D network and extracted them from water. C16CA supramolecules dissolved into water (at pH > 6) and organic solvents; consequently, the recovered C16CA-AgNPs were redispersed not only to water but also to chloroform and tetrahydrofuran without any additional functionalization. C16CA acted as a pH-responsive stabilizer of AgNPs and formed a solvent-switchable molecular layer such as a bilayered structure in water and densely packed monolayer in chloroform and tetrahydrofuran. Redispersion of the AgNPs was achieved in different solvents by changing the solvent affinity of the adsorbed C16CA molecular layer based on the protonation of the amine groups of the pH-responsive amphiphile. The morphology of redispersed AgNPs did not change during the recovery and redispersion procedure, due to the high steric effect of the network structure of C16CA supramolecules. These observations can lead to a novel solvent-exchange method for nanocrystals without aggregation and loss of nanocrystals, and they enable effective preparations of stimuli-responsive plasmonic nanomaterials.

Slow Relaxation of Surface Plasmon Excitations in Au55: The Key to Efficient Plasmonic Heating in Au/TiO2

Gold nanoparticles distinguish themselves from other nanoparticles due to their unique surface plasmon resonance properties that can be exploited for a multiplicity of applications. The promise of plasmonic heating in systems of Au nanoparticles on transition metal oxide supports, for example, Au/TiO2, rests with the ability of the surface plasmon in Au nanoparticles to effectively transfer energy into the transition metal oxide. Here, we report a critical observation regarding Au nanoparticle (Au55) surface plasmon excitations, that is, the relaxation of the surface plasmon excitation is very slow, on the order of several picoseconds. Starting from five plasmon states in Au55 nanoparticles using nonadiabatic molecular dynamics simulations, we find that the relaxation time constant resulting from these simulations is ∼6.8 ps, mainly resulting from a long-lived intermediate state found at around -0.8 eV. This long-lived intermediate state aligns with the conduction band edge of TiO2, thereby facilitating energy transfer injection from the Au55 nanoparticle into the TiO2. The current results rule out the previously reported molecular-like relaxation dynamics for Au55.