Rapid folding of calcium-free subtilisin by a stabilized pro-domain mutant

Engineering subtilisin proteases that specifically degrade active RAS

We describe the design, kinetic properties, and structures of engineered subtilisin proteases that degrade the active form of RAS by cleaving a conserved sequence in switch 2. RAS is a signaling protein that, when mutated, drives a third of human cancers. To generate high specificity for the RAS target sequence, the active site was modified to be dependent on a cofactor (imidazole or nitrite) and protease sub-sites were engineered to create a linkage between substrate and cofactor binding. Selective proteolysis of active RAS arises from a 2-step process wherein sub-site interactions promote productive binding of the cofactor, enabling cleavage. Proteases engineered in this way specifically cleave active RAS in vitro, deplete the level of RAS in a bacterial reporter system, and also degrade RAS in human cell culture. Although these proteases target active RAS, the underlying design principles are fundamental and will be adaptable to many target proteins.

Structural metamorphism and polymorphism in proteins on the brink of thermodynamic stability

The classical view of the structure-function paradigm advanced by Anfinsen in the 1960s is that a protein's function is inextricably linked to its three-dimensional structure and is encrypted in its amino acid sequence. However, it is now known that a significant fraction of the proteome consists of intrinsically disordered proteins (IDPs). These proteins populate a polymorphic ensemble of conformations rather than a unique structure but are still capable of performing biological functions. At the boundary, between well-ordered and inherently disordered states are proteins that are on the brink of stability, either weakly stable ordered systems or disordered but on the verge of being stable. In such marginal states, even relatively minor changes can significantly alter the energy landscape, leading to large-scale conformational remodeling. Some proteins on the edge of stability are metamorphic, with the capacity to switch from one fold topology to another in response to an environmental trigger (e.g., pH, temperature/salt, redox). Many IDPs, on the other hand, are marginally unstable such that small perturbations (e.g., phosphorylation, ligands) tip the balance over to a range of ordered, partially ordered, or even more disordered states. In general, the structural transitions described by metamorphic fold switches and polymorphic IDPs possess a number of common features including low or diminished stability, large-scale conformational changes, critical disordered regions, latent or attenuated binding sites, and expansion of function. We suggest that these transitions are, therefore, conceptually and mechanistically analogous, representing adjacent regions in the continuum of order/disorder transitions.

Identification of Structure-Stabilizing Interactions in Enzymes: A Novel Mechanism to Impact Enzyme Activity

Cruzain, a cysteine protease in the cathepsin family, is pivotal to the life-cycle of Trypanosoma cruzi, the etiological agent in Chagas disease. Current inhibitors of cruzain suffer from drawbacks involving gastrointestinal and neurological side effects and as a result have spurred the search for alternative anti-trypanocidals. Through sequence alignment studies and intra-residue interaction analysis of the pro-protein of cruzain (pro-cruzain), we have identified a host of non-active site residues that are conserved among the cathepsins. We hypothesize that these conserved amino acids play a critical role in structure-stabilizing interactions among the cathepsins and are therefore crucial for eventually gaining protease activity. As predicted, mutation of selected conserved non-active site amino-acid candidates in cruzain resulted in a compromised structural stability and a corresponding loss in enzymatic activity relative to wild-type enzyme. By advancing the discovery of novel, non-active-site-based targets to arrest enzymatic activity our results potentially open the field of alternative inhibitor design. The advantages of defining such a non-active-site inhibitor design space is discussed.

Insights from bacterial subtilases into the mechanisms of intramolecular chaperone-mediated activation of furin

Prokaryotic subtilisins and eukaryotic proprotein convertases (PCs) are two homologous protease subfamilies that belong to the larger ubiquitous super-family called subtilases. Members of the subtilase super-family are produced as zymogens wherein their propeptide domains function as dedicated intramolecular chaperones (IMCs) that facilitate correct folding and regulate precise activation of their cognate catalytic domains. The molecular and cellular determinants that modulate IMC-dependent folding and activation of PCs are poorly understood. In this chapter we review what we have learned from the folding and activation of prokaryotic subtilisin, discuss how this has molded our understanding of furin maturation, and foray into the concept of pH sensors, which may represent a paradigm that PCs (and possibly other IMC-dependent eukaryotic proteins) follow for regulating their biological functions using the pH gradient in the secretory pathway.

The intramolecular chaperone-mediated protein folding

Some proteins have evolved to contain a specific sequence as an intramolecular chaperone, which is essential for protein folding but not required for protein function, as it is removed after the protein is folded by autoprocessing or by an exogenous protease. To date, a large number of sequences encoded as N-terminal or C-terminal extensions have been identified to function as intramolecular chaperones. An increasing amount of evidence has revealed that these intramolecular chaperones play an important role in protein folding both in vivo and in vitro. Here, we summarize recent studies on intramolecular chaperone-assisted protein folding and discuss the mechanisms as to how intramolecular chaperones play roles in protein folding.

Main chain NMR assignments of subtilisin Sbt70 in its prodomain-bound state

Main chain assignments are described for a 266-residue subtilisin mutant, Sbt70, in its 35 kDa complex with an N-terminal prodomain. The assignments provide the basis for understanding how the prodomain assists folding of subtilisin at a residue-specific level.

A platform for high-throughput expression of recombinant human enzymes secreted by insect cells

Functional genomics and proteomics have been fields of intense investigation, since the disclosure of the sequence of the human genome. To contribute to the assignment of a physiological role to the vast number of coding genes with unknown function, we have undertaken a program to clone, express, purify and determine the catalytic activity of those enzymes predicted to enter the secretory pathway, focusing our efforts on human peptidases. Our strategy to promote high-throughput expression and purification of recombinant proteins secreted by insect cells relies on the expression of the target enzymes with their native leader sequences and on the carboxyl-terminal fusion with a poly-histidine tag. Growth of host cells were optimized in 24-well format to achieve highly paralleled culture conditions with production yields comparable to shake flask. The purification was performed by a robotic system in 96-well format using either magnetic beads or minicolumns. In a pilot study using reference peptidases and lipases, the high-throughput approach demonstrated to support the secretion in the insect cell medium of 85% of the sample enzymes. Of them, 66% have been proven to be catalytically active using fluorescent homogeneous assays in 384-well format compatible with the high-throughput screening criteria. The implications of these results are discussed in light of the application of this procedure to genomic-predicted peptidases.

Inhibitor-assisted refolding of protease: A protease inhibitor as an intramolecular chaperone

Pleurotus ostrearus proteinase A inhibitor 1 (POIA1), which was discovered as a protease inhibitor, is unique in that it shows sequence homology to the propeptide of subtilisin, which functions as an intramolecular of a cognate protease. In this study, we demonstrate that POIA1 can function as an intramolecular chaperone of subtilisin by in vitro and in vivo experiments. The specific cleavage between POIA1 and the mature region of subtilisin BPN' occurred in a refolding process of a chimera protein, and Bacillus cells transformed with a chimera gene formed a halo on a skim milk plate. The mutational analyses of POIA1 in the chimera protein suggested that the tertiary structure of POIA1 is required for such a function, and that an increase in its ability to bind to subtilisin BPN' makes POIA1 a more effective intramolecular chaperone.

In vitro refolding of carboxypeptidase T precursor from Thermoactinomyces vulgaris obtained in Escherichia coli as cytoplasmic inclusion bodies

Carboxypeptidase T precursor from Thermoactinomyces vulgaris, which fails to contain its own leader peptide, has been expressed in Escherichia coli as insoluble cytoplasmic inclusion bodies. The yield of a washed recombinant protein from 1 L of culture liquid was about 60 mg. The obtained inclusion bodies were denatured in 6 M guanidine-HCl and then renatured by a rapid dilution. The important role of calcium for the complete stabilization of the refolded carboxypeptidase T precursor was established. After removal of minor admixture proteins by gel-filtration through Superdex 75, an electrophoretically homogeneous preparation of the native precursor of carboxypeptidase T was obtained. Processing of the resulting protein by subtilisin led to the formation of the mature carboxypeptidase T in which N-terminal sequence, molecular size, thermal stability, and catalytic properties were comparable to those of the natural enzyme.

Folding Pathway Mediated by an Intramolecular Chaperone: Intrinsically Unstructured Propeptide Modulates Stochastic Activation of Subtilisin

Several secreted proteases are synthesized with N-terminal propeptides that function as intramolecular chaperones (IMCs) and direct the folding of proteases to their native functional states. Using subtilisin E as our model system, we had earlier established that (i) release and degradation of the IMC from its complex with the protease upon completion of folding is the rate-determining step to protease maturation and, (ii) IMC of SbtE is an extremely charged, intrinsically unstructured polypeptide that adopts an alpha-beta structure only in the presence of the protease. Here, we explore the mechanism of IMC release and the intricate relationship between IMC structure and protease activation. We establish that the release of the first IMC from its protease domain is a non-deterministic event that subsequently triggers an activation cascade through trans-proteolysis. By in silico simulation of the protease maturation pathway through application of stochastic algorithms, we further analyze the sub-stages of the release step. Our work shows that modulating the structure of the IMC domain through external solvent conditions can vary both the time and randomness of protease activation. This behavior of the protease can be correlated to varying the release-rebinding equilibrium of IMC, through simulation. Thus, a delicate balance underlies IMC structure, release, and protease activation. Proteases are ubiquitous enzymes crucial for fundamental cellular processes and require deterministic activation mechanisms. Our work on SbtE establishes that through selection of an intrinsically unstructured IMC domain, nature appears to have selected for a viable deterministic handle that controls a fundamentally random event. While this outlines an important mechanism for regulation of protease activation, it also provides a unique approach to maintain industrially viable subtilisins in extremely stable states that can be activated at will.

Folding pathway mediated by an intramolecular chaperone. A functional peptide chaperone designed using sequence databases

Catalytic domains of several prokaryotic and eukaryotic protease families require dedicated N-terminal propeptide domains or "intramolecular chaperones" to facilitate correct folding. Amino acid sequence analysis of these families establishes three important characteristics: (i) propeptides are almost always less conserved than their cognate catalytic domains, (ii) they contain a large number of charged amino acids, and (iii) propeptides within different protease families display insignificant sequence similarity. The implications of these findings are, however, unclear. In this study, we have used subtilisin as our model to redesign a peptide chaperone using information databases. Our goal was to establish the minimum sequence requirements for a functional subtilisin propeptide, because such information could facilitate subsequent design of tailor-made chaperones. A decision-based computer algorithm that maintained conserved residues but varied all non-conserved residues from a multiple protein sequence alignment was developed and utilized to design a novel peptide sequence (ProD). Interestingly, despite a difference of 5 pH units between their isoelectric points and despite displaying only 16% sequence identity with the wild-type propeptide (ProWT), ProD chaperones folding and functions as a potent subtilisin inhibitor. The computed secondary structures and hydrophobic patterns within these two propeptides are similar. However, unlike ProWT, ProD adopts a well defined alpha-beta conformation as an isolated peptide and forms a stoichiometric complex with mature subtilisin. The CD spectra of this complex is similar to ProWT.subtilisin. Our results establish that despite low sequence identity and dramatically different charge distribution, both propeptides adopt similar structural scaffolds. Hence, conserved scaffolds and hydrophobic patterns, but not absolute charge, dictate propeptide function.

Inhibitory potency and specificity of subtilase-like pro-protein convertase (SPC) prodomains

The SPCs (subtilisin-like pro-protein convertases) are a family of enzymes responsible for the proteolytic processing of numerous precursor proteins of the constitutive and regulated secretory pathways. SPCs are themselves synthesized as inactive zymogens. Activation of SPCs occurs via the intramolecular autocatalytic removal of the prodomain. SPC prodomains have been proposed as templates in the development of potent and specific SPC inhibitors. In this study, we investigated the specificity and potency of complete prodomains and short C-terminal prodomain peptides of each SPC on highly purified, soluble enzyme preparations of human SPC1, SPC6, and SPC7. Progress curve kinetic analysis of prodomain peptides and complete prodomains showed competitive inhibitory profiles in the low nanomolar range. Complete prodomains were 5-100 times more potent than C-terminal prodomain peptides, suggesting that N-terminal determinants are involved in the recognition process. However, complete prodomains and prodomain peptides exhibit only a partial specificity toward their cognate enzyme. Ala-scan structure activity studies indicated the importance of basic residues in the P(4), P(5), and P(6) positions for inhibition of SPC1. In contrast, hydrophobic residues in P(6) and P(7), as well as basic residues in P(4) and P(5), were critical for inhibition of SPC7. Our data demonstrated that the use of prodomains as specific inhibitors acting in trans would be of limited usefulness, unless modified into more specific compounds.

Structured disorder and conformational selection

Traditionally, molecular disorder has been viewed as local or global instability. Molecules or regions displaying disorder have been considered inherently unstructured. The term has been routinely applied to cases for which no atomic coordinates can be derived from crystallized molecules. Yet, even when it appears that the molecules are disordered, prevailing conformations exist, with population times higher than those of all alternate conformations. Disordered molecules are the outcome of rugged energy landscapes away from the native state around the bottom of the funnel. Ruggedness has a biological function, creating a distribution of structured conformers that bind via conformational selection, driving association and multimolecular complex formation, whether chain-linked in folding or unlinked in binding. We classify disordered molecules into two types. The first type possesses a hydrophobic core. Here, even if the native conformation is unstable, it still has a large enough population time, enabling its experimental detection. In the second type, no such hydrophobic core exists. Hence, the native conformations of molecules belonging to this category have shorter population times, hindering their experimental detection. Although there is a continuum of distribution of hydrophobic cores in proteins, an empirical, statistically based hydrophobicity function may be used as a guideline for distinguishing the two disordered molecule types. Furthermore, the two types relate to steps in the protein folding reaction. With respect to protein design, this leads us to propose that engineering-optimized specific electrostatic interactions to avoid electrostatic repulsion would reduce the type I disordered state, driving the molten globule (MG) --> native (N) state. In contrast, for overcoming the type II disordered state, in addition to specific interactions, a stronger hydrophobic core is also indicated, leading to the denatured --> MG --> N state.

Protein engineering of subtilisin

The serine protease subtilisin is an important industrial enzyme as well as a model for understanding the enormous rate enhancements affected by enzymes. For these reasons along with the timely cloning of the gene, ease of expression and purification and availability of atomic resolution structures, subtilisin became a model system for protein engineering studies in the 1980s. Fifteen years later, mutations in well over 50% of the 275 amino acids of subtilisin have been reported in the scientific literature. Most subtilisin engineering has involved catalytic amino acids, substrate binding regions and stabilizing mutations. Stability has been the property of subtilisin which has been most amenable to enhancement, yet perhaps least understood. This review will give a brief overview of the subtilisin engineering field, critically review what has been learned about subtilisin stability from protein engineering experiments and conclude with some speculation about the prospects for future subtilisin engineering.

Binding and folding: in search of intramolecular chaperone-like building block fragments

We propose an intramolecular chaperone which catalyzes folding and neither dissociates nor is cleaved. This uncleaved foldase is an intramolecular chain-linked chaperone, which constitutes a critical building block of the structure. Macroscopically, all molecular chaperones facilitate folding reactions and manifest similar energy landscapes. However, microscopically they differ. While intermolecular chaperones catalyze folding by unfolding misfolded conformations or prevent misfolding, the chain-linked cleaved (proregion) and uncleaved intramolecular chaperone-like building blocks suggested here, catalyze folding by binding to, stabilizing and increasing the populations of native conformations of adjacent building block fragments. In both, the more stable the intramolecular chaperone fragment region, the faster is the folding rate. Hence, mechanistically, intramolecular chaperones and chaperone-like segments are similar. Both play a dual role, in folding and in protein function. However, while the functional role of the proregions is inhibitory, necessitating their cleavage, the function of the uncleaved intramolecular chaperone-like building blocks does not require their subsequent removal. On the contrary, it requires that they remain in the structure. This may lead to the difference in the type of control they are under: proteins folding with the assistance of the proregion have been shown to be under kinetic control. It has been suggested that kinetically controlled folding reactions, with the proregion catalyst removed, lend longevity under harsh conditions. On the other hand, proteins with uncleaved intramolecular chaperone-like building blocks, with their 'foldases' still attached, are largely under thermodynamic control, consistent with the control observed in most protein folding reactions. We propose that an uncleaved intramolecular chaperone-like fragment occurs frequently in proteins. We further propose that such proteins would be prone to changing conditions and in particular, to mutations in this critical building block region. We describe the features qualifying it for its proposed chaperone-like role, compare it with inter- and intramolecular chaperones and review current literature in this light. We further propose a mechanism showing how it lowers the barrier heights, leading to faster folding reaction rates. Since these fragments constitute an intergal part of the protein structure, we call these critical building blocks intramolecular, chaperone-like fragments, to clarify, distinguish and adhere to the definition of the transiently associating chaperones. The new mechanism presented here differs from the concept of 'folding nuclei'. While the concept of folding nuclei focuses on a non-sequential distribution of the folding information along the entire protein chain, the chaperone-like building block fragments proposition focuses on a segmental distribution of the folding information. This segmental distribution controls the distributions of the populations throughout the hierarchical folding processes.

Intramolecular chaperones: polypeptide extensions that modulate protein folding

Several prokaryotic and eukaryotic proteins are synthesized as precursors in the form of pre-pro-proteins. While the pre-regions function as signal peptides that are involved in transport, the propeptides can often catalyze correct folding of their associated proteins. Such propeptides have been termed intramolecular chaperones. In cases where propeptides may not directly catalyze the folding reaction, it appears that they can facilitate processes such as structural organization and oligomerization, localization, sorting and modulation of enzymatic activity and stability of proteins. Based on the available literature it appears that propeptides may actually function as 'post-translational modulators' of protein structure and function. Propeptides can be classified into two broad categories: Class I propeptides that function as intramolecular chaperones and directly catalyze the folding reaction; and Class II propeptides that are not directly involved in folding.