A Single Aspartate Coordinates Two Catalytic Steps in Hedgehog Autoprocessing

Conserved C143 forms a branched intermediate in Hedgehog autoprocessing: A cancer drug discovery target against Hedgehog signaling

Hedgehog (Hh) signaling plays fundamental roles in embryonic development while its abnormal activation in adults is associated with cancer. Hh targeting drugs have gained FDA approval but resistance emerged quickly, underlining the need for novel types of Hh inhibitors. Hh signaling is initiated by the Hh ligand, generated from the autoprocessing of Hh precursor. However, the catalytic role of a highly conserved Hedgehog residue C143 is still poorly understood. Here, we confirmed that C143 is required for Hh autoprocessing in mammalian cells. NMR titration showed that C143 has an extremely low pKa of 4.5, befitting a highly reactive catalytic residue. We further established that Hh autoprocessing involves a branched intermediate (BI) with two N-termini, formed as a thioester on the C143 sidechain. BI migrates slower than the linear Hh precursor on SDS-PAGE and disappears with DTT treatment. With trypsin digestion and LC-MS/MS, we detected the N-terminal fragment from BI, which is absent from the linear Hh precursor. Therefore, C143 mediates the formation of a BI thioester in Hh autoprocessing, with a catalytic role equivalent to C + 1 in intein splicing. These findings bring us closer to a full mechanistic understanding of Hh autoprocessing while unifying the first two catalytic steps of Hh autoprocessing with intein splicing, its likely evolutionary predecessor. C143 can also serve as a target for covalent drugs for inhibiting Hh signaling in cancer.

Paracatalytic induction: Subverting specificity in hedgehog protein autoprocessing with small molecules

Paracatalytic inducers are antagonists that shift the specificity of biological catalysts, resulting in non-native transformations. In this Chapter we describe methods to discover paracatalytic inducers of Hedgehog (Hh) protein autoprocessing. Native autoprocessing uses cholesterol as a substrate nucleophile to assist in cleaving an internal peptide bond within a precursor form of Hh. This unusual reaction is brought about by HhC, an enzymatic domain that resides within the C-terminal region of Hh precursor proteins. Recently, we reported paracatalytic inducers as a novel class of Hh autoprocessing antagonists. These small molecules bind HhC and tilt the substrate specificity away from cholesterol in favor of solvent water. The resulting cholesterol-independent autoproteolysis of the Hh precursor generates a non-native Hh side product with substantially reduced biological signaling activity. Protocols are provided for in vitro FRET-based and in-cell bioluminescence assays to discover and characterize paracatalytic inducers of Drosophila and human hedgehog protein autoprocessing, respectively.

A cell-based bioluminescence reporter assay of human Sonic Hedgehog protein autoprocessing to identify inhibitors and activators

The Sonic Hedgehog (SHh) precursor protein undergoes biosynthetic autoprocessing to cleave off and covalently attach cholesterol to the SHh signaling ligand, a vital morphogen and oncogenic effector protein. Autoprocessing is self-catalyzed by SHhC, the SHh precursor's C-terminal enzymatic domain. A method to screen for small molecule regulators of this process may be of therapeutic value. Here, we describe the development and validation of the first cellular reporter to monitor human SHhC autoprocessing noninvasively in high-throughput compatible plates. The assay couples intracellular SHhC autoprocessing using endogenous cholesterol to the extracellular secretion of the bioluminescent nanoluciferase enzyme. We developed a WT SHhC reporter line for evaluating potential autoprocessing inhibitors by concentration response-dependent suppression of extracellular bioluminescence. Additionally, a conditional mutant SHhC (D46A) reporter line was developed for identifying potential autoprocessing activators by a concentration response-dependent gain of extracellular bioluminescence. The D46A mutation removes a conserved general base that is critical for the activation of the cholesterol substrate. Inducibility of the D46A reporter was established using a synthetic sterol, 2-α carboxy cholestanol, designed to bypass the defect through intramolecular general base catalysis. To facilitate direct nanoluciferase detection in the cell culture media of 1536-well plates, we designed a novel anionic phosphonylated coelenterazine, CLZ-2P, as the nanoluciferase substrate. This new reporter system offers a long-awaited resource for small molecule discovery for cancer and for developmental disorders where SHh ligand biosynthesis is dysregulated.

Hedgehog Autoprocessing: From Structural Mechanisms to Drug Discovery

Hedgehog (Hh) signaling plays pivotal roles in embryonic development. In adults, Hh signaling is mostly turned off but its abnormal activation is involved in many types of cancer. Hh signaling is initiated by the Hh ligand, generated from the Hh precursor by a specialized autocatalytic process called Hh autoprocessing. The Hh precursor consists of an N-terminal signaling domain (HhN) and a C-terminal autoprocessing domain (HhC). During Hh autoprocessing, the precursor is cleaved between N- and C-terminal domain followed by the covalent ligation of cholesterol to the last residue of HhN, which subsequently leads to the generation of Hh ligand for Hh signaling. Hh autoprocessing is at the origin of canonical Hh signaling and precedes all downstream signaling events. Mutations in the catalytic residues in HhC can lead to congenital defects such as holoprosencephaly (HPE). The aim of this review is to provide an in-depth summary of the progresses and challenges towards an atomic level understanding of the structural mechanisms of Hh autoprocessing. We also discuss drug discovery efforts to inhibit Hh autoprocessing as a new direction in cancer therapy.

Intein Inhibitors as Novel Antimicrobials: Protein Splicing in Human Pathogens, Screening Methods, and Off-Target Considerations

Protein splicing is a post-translational process by which an intervening polypeptide, or intein, catalyzes its own removal from the flanking polypeptides, or exteins, concomitant with extein ligation. Although inteins are highly abundant in the microbial world, including within several human pathogens, they are absent in the genomes of metazoans. As protein splicing is required to permit function of essential proteins within pathogens, inteins represent attractive antimicrobial targets. Here we review key proteins interrupted by inteins in pathogenic mycobacteria and fungi, exciting discoveries that provide proof of concept that intein activity can be inhibited and that this inhibition has an effect on the host organism's fitness, and bioanalytical methods that have been used to screen for intein activity. We also consider potential off-target inhibition of hedgehog signaling, given the similarity in structure and function of inteins and hedgehog autoprocessing domains.

Hedgehog proteins create a dynamic cholesterol interface

During formation of the Hedgehog (Hh) signaling proteins, cooperative activities of the Hedgehog INTein (Hint) fold and Sterol Recognition Region (SRR) couple autoproteolysis to cholesterol ligation. The cholesteroylated Hh morphogens play essential roles in embryogenesis, tissue regeneration, and tumorigenesis. Despite the centrality of cholesterol in Hh function, the full structure of the Hint-SRR ("Hog") domain that attaches cholesterol to the last residue of the active Hh morphogen remains enigmatic. In this work, we combine molecular dynamics simulations, photoaffinity crosslinking, and mutagenesis assays to model cholesterolysis intermediates in the human Sonic Hedgehog (hSHH) protein. Our results provide evidence for a hydrophobic Hint-SRR interface that forms a dynamic, non-covalent cholesterol-Hog complex. Using these models, we suggest a unified mechanism by which Hh proteins can recruit, sequester, and orient cholesterol, and offer a molecular basis for the effects of disease-causing hSHH mutations.

The Mechanism of Cholesterol Modification of Hedgehog Ligand

Hedgehog (Hh) proteins are important components of signal transduction pathways involved in animal development, and their defects are implicated in carcinogenesis. Their N-terminal domain (HhN) acts as a signaling ligand, and their C-terminal domain (HhC) performs an autocatalytic function of cleaving itself away, while adding a cholesterol moiety to HhN. HhC has two sub-domains: a hedgehog/intein (hint) domain that primarily performs the autocatalytic activity, and a sterol-recognition region (SRR) that binds to cholesterol and properly positions it with respect to HhN. The three-dimensional details of this autocatalytic mechanism remain unknown, as does the structure of the precursor Hh protein. In this study, a complete cholesterol-bound precursor form of the drosophila Hh precursor is modeled using known crystal structures of HhN and the hint domain, and a hypothesized similarity of SRR to an unrelated but similar-sized cholesterol binding protein. The restrained geometries and topology switching (RGATS) strategy is then used to predict atomic-detail pathways for the full autocatalytic reaction starting from the precursor and ending in a cholesterol-linked HhN domain and a cleaved HhC domain. The RGATS explicit solvent simulations indicate the roles of individual HhC residues in facilitating the reaction, which can be confirmed through mutational experiments. These simulations also provide plausible structural models for the N/S acyl transfer intermediate and the product states of this reaction. This study thus provides a good framework for future computational and experimental studies to develop a full structural and dynamic understanding of Hh autoprocessing. © 2019 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.

Subverting Hedgehog Protein Autoprocessing by Chemical Induction of Paracatalysis

Hedgehog proteins, a family of vital cell signaling factors, are expressed in precursor form, which requires specialized autoprocessing, called cholesterolysis, for full biological activity. Cholesterolysis occurs in cis through the action of the precursor's C-terminal enzymatic domain, HhC. In this work, we describe HhC activator compounds (HACs), a novel class of noncovalent modulators that induce autoprocessing infidelity, diminishing native cholesterolysis in favor of precursor autoproteolysis, an otherwise minor and apparently nonphysiological side reaction. HAC-induced autoproteolysis generates hedgehog protein that is cholesterol free and hence signaling deficient. The most effective HAC has an AC50 of 9 μM, accelerates HhC autoproteolytic activity by 225-fold, and functions in the presence and absence of cholesterol, the native substrate. HACs join a rare class of "antagonists" that suppress native enzymatic activity by subverting mechanistic fidelity.

Methods to Study the Structure and Catalytic Activity of cis-Splicing Inteins

The autocatalytic process of protein splicing is facilitated by an intein, which interrupts flanking polypeptides called exteins. The mechanism of protein splicing has been studied by overexpression in E. coli of intein fusion proteins with nonnative exteins. Inteins can be used to generate reactive α-thioesters, as well as proteins with N-terminal Cys residues, to facilitate expressed protein ligation. As such, a more detailed understanding of the function of inteins can have significant impact for biotechnology applications. Here, we provide biochemical methods to study splicing activity and NMR methods to study intein structure and the catalytic mechanism.

General Base Swap Preserves Activity and Expands Substrate Tolerance in Hedgehog Autoprocessing

Hedgehog (Hh) autoprocessing converts Hh precursor protein to cholesterylated Hh ligand for downstream signaling. A conserved active-site aspartate residue, D46, plays a key catalytic role in Hh autoprocessing by serving as a general base to activate substrate cholesterol. Here we report that a charge-altering Asp-to-His mutant (D46H) expands native cholesterylation activity and retains active-site conformation. Native activity toward cholesterol was established for D46H in vitro using a continuous FRET-based autoprocessing assay and in cellulo with stable expression in human 293T cells. The catalytic efficiency of cholesterylation with D46H is similar to that with wild type (WT), with kmax/KM = 2.1 × 103 and 3.7 × 103 M-1 s-1, respectively, and an identical pKa = 5.8 is obtained for both residues by NMR. To our knowledge this is the first example where a general base substitution of an Asp for His preserves both the structure and activity as a general base. Surprisingly, D46H exhibits increased catalytic efficiency toward non-native substrates, especially coprostanol (>200-fold) and epicoprostanol (>300-fold). Expanded substrate tolerance is likely due to stabilization by H46 of the negatively charged tetrahedral intermediate using electrostatic interactions, which are less constrained by geometry than H-bond stabilization by D46. In addition to providing fundamental insights into Hh autoprocessing, our findings have important implications for protein engineering and enzyme design.

Sterol A-ring plasticity in hedgehog protein cholesterolysis supports a primitive substrate selectivity mechanism

Cholesterolysis of Hedgehog family proteins couples endoproteolysis to protein C-terminal sterylation. The transformation is self-catalyzed by HhC, a partially characterized enzymatic domain found in precursor forms of Hedgehog. Here we explore spatial ambiguity in sterol recognition by HhC, using a trio of derivatives where the sterol A-ring is contracted, fused, or distorted. Sterylation assays indicate that these geometric variants react as substrates with relative activity: cholesterol, 1.000 > A-ring contracted, 0.100 > A-ring fused, 0.020 > A-ring distorted, 0.005. Experimental results and computational sterol docking into the first HhC homology model suggest a partially unstructured binding site with substrate recognition governed in large part by hydrophobic interactions.

Genetically Encoded Cholesterol-Modified Polypeptides

Biological systems use post-translational modifications (PTMs) to control the structure, location, and function of proteins after expression. Despite the ubiquity of PTMs in biology, their use to create genetically encoded recombinant biomaterials is limited. We have utilized a natural lipidation PTM (hedgehog-mediated cholesterol modification of proteins) to create a class of hybrid biomaterials called cholesterol-modified polypeptides (CHaMPs) that exhibit programmable self-assembly at the nanoscale. To demonstrate the biomedical utility of CHaMPs, we used this approach to append cholesterol to biologically active peptide exendin-4 that is an approved drug for the treatment of type II diabetes. The exendin-cholesterol conjugate self-assembled into micelles, and these micelles activate the glucagon-like peptide-1 receptor with a potency comparable to that of current gold standard treatments.

Chemical Bypass of General Base Catalysis in Hedgehog Protein Cholesterolysis Using a Hyper-Nucleophilic Substrate

Proteins in the hedgehog family undergo self-catalyzed endoproteolysis involving nucleophilic attack by a molecule of cholesterol. Recently, a conserved aspartate residue (D303, or D46) of hedgehog was identified as the general base that activates cholesterol during this unusual autoprocessing event; mutation of the catalyzing functional group (D303A) reduces activity by >104-fold. Here we report near total rescue of this ostensibly dead general base mutant by a synthetic substrate, 3β-hydroperoxycholestane (3HPC) in which the sterol -OH group is replaced by the hyper nucleophilic -OOH group. Other hedgehog point mutants at D303, also unreactive with cholesterol, accepted 3HPC as a substrate with the rank order: WT > D303A ≈ D303N ≫ D303R, D303E. We attribute the revived activity with 3-HPC to the α-effect, where tandem electronegative atoms exhibit exceptionally high nucleophilicity despite relatively low basicity.