Octyl Glucoside-Mediated Solubilization and Reconstitution of Liposomes: Structural and Kinetic Aspects

Solubilization of biomimetic lipid mixtures by some commonly used non-ionic detergents

Detergents are amphiphilic molecules often used to solubilize biological membranes and separate their components. Here we investigate the solubilization of lipid vesicles by the commonly used non-ionic detergents polyoxyethylene (20) oleyl ether (Brij 98), n-octyl-β-D-glucoside (OG), and n-dodecyl β-D maltoside (DDM) and compare the results with the standard detergent Triton X-100 (TX-100). The vesicles were composed of palmitoyl oleoyl phosphatidylcholine (POPC) or of a biomimetic ternary mixture of POPC, egg sphingomyelin (SM) and cholesterol (2:1:2 molar ratio). To follow the solubilization profile of large unilamellar vesicles (LUVs), 90° light scattering measurements were done along the titration of LUVs with the detergents. Then, giant unilamellar vesicles (GUVs) were observed with optical microscopy during exposure to the detergents, to allow direct visualization of the solubilization process. Isothermal titration calorimetry (ITC) was used to assess the binding constant of the detergents in POPC bilayers. The results show that the incorporation of TX-100, Brij 98 and, to a lesser extent, OG in the pure POPC liposomes leads to an increase in the vesicle area, which indicates their ability to redistribute between the two leaflets of the membrane in a short scale of time. On the other hand, DDM incorporates mainly in the external leaflet causing an increase in vesicle curvature/tension leading ultimately to vesicle burst. Only TX-100 and OG were able to completely solubilize the POPC vesicles, whereas the biomimetic ternary mixture was partially insoluble in all detergents tested. TX-100 and OG were able to incorporate in the bilayer of the ternary mixture and induce macroscopic phase separation of liquid-ordered (Lo) and liquid-disordered (Ld) domains, with selective solubilization of the latter. Combination of ITC data with turbidity results showed that TX-100 and OG can be incorporated up to almost 0.3 detergent/lipid, significantly more than Brij 98 and DDM. This fact seems to be directly related to their higher capacity to solubilize POPC membranes and their ability to induce macroscopic phase separation in the biomimetic lipid mixture.

Pathways of Membrane Solubilization: A Structural Study of Model Lipid Vesicles Exposed to Classical Detergents

Understanding the pathways of solubilization of lipid membranes is of high importance for their use in biotechnology and industrial applications. Although lipid vesicle solubilization by classical detergents has been widely investigated, there are few systematic structural and kinetic studies where different detergents are compared under varying conditions. This study used small-angle X-ray scattering to determine the structures of lipid/detergent aggregates at different ratios and temperatures and studied the solubilization in time using the stopped-flow technique. Membranes composed of either of two zwitterionic lipids, DMPC or DPPC, and their interactions with three different detergents, sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS), n-dodecyl-beta-maltoside (DDM), and Triton X-100 (TX-100), were tested. The detergent TX-100 can cause the formation of collapsed vesicles with a rippled bilayer structure that is highly resistant to TX-100 insertion at low temperatures, while at higher temperatures, it partitions and leads to the restructuring of vesicles. DDM also causes this restructuring into multilamellar structures at subsolubilizing concentrations. In contrast, partitioning of SDS does not alter the vesicle structure below the saturation limit. Solubilization is more efficient in the gel phase for TX-100 but only if the cohesive energy of the bilayer does not prevent sufficient partitioning of the detergent. DDM and SDS show less temperature dependence compared to TX-100. Kinetic measurements reveal that solubilization of DPPC largely occurs through a slow extraction of lipids, whereas DMPC solubilization is dominated by fast and burst-like solubilization of the vesicles. The final structures obtained seem to preferentially be discoidal micelles where the detergent can distribute in excess along the rim of the disc, although we do observe the formation of worm- and rodlike micelles in the case of solubilization of DDM. Our results are in line with the suggested theory that bilayer rigidity is the main factor influencing which aggregate is formed.

Optimization of detergents in solubilization and reconstitution of Aquaporin Z: A structural approach

BACKGROUND

The exceptional capacities of aquaporins in terms of water permeation and selectivity have made them an interesting system for membrane applications. Despite the multiple attempts for immobilizing the aquaporins over a porous substrate, there is a lack of studies related to the purification and reconstitution steps, principally associated with the use of detergents in solubilization and destabilization steps. This study analyzed the effect of detergents in Aquaporin Z solubilization, considering the purity and structural homogeneity of the protein.

METHODS

The extraction process was optimized by the addition of detergent at the sonication step, which enabled the omission of the ultracentrifugation and resuspension steps. Two detergents, Triton X-100, and octyl-glucoside were also evaluated. Destabilization mediated by detergents was used as reconstitution method. Saturation and solubilization points were defined by detergent concentration and both, liposomes and proteoliposomes, were analyzed by size distribution and permeability assays. Detergent removal with Bio-beads was also analyzed.

RESULTS

Octyl glucoside ensures structural stability and homogeneity of Aquaporin Z. However, high concentrations of detergents induce the presence of defects in proteoliposomes. While saturated liposomes create homogeneous and functional structures, solubilized liposomes get affected by a reassembly process, creating vesicle defects with anomalous permeability profiles.

CONCLUSIONS

Detergent concentration affects the structural conformation of proteoliposomes in the reconstitution process.

GENERAL SIGNIFICANCE

Since the destabilization process is dependent on vesicle, detergent, and buffer composition, optimization of this process should be mandatory for further studies. All these considerations will allow achieving the potential of Aquaporins and any other integral membrane protein in their applications for industrial purposes.

Tuning the photoexcitation response of cyanobacterial Photosystem I via reconstitution into Proteoliposomes

The role of natural thylakoid membrane housing of Photosystem I (PSI), the transmembrane photosynthetic protein, in its robust photoactivated charge separation with near unity quantum efficiency is not fundamentally understood. To this end, incorporation of suitable protein scaffolds for PSI incorporation is of great scientific and device manufacturing interest. Areas of interest include solid state bioelectronics, and photoelectrochemical devices that require bio-abio interfaces that do not compromise the photoactivity and photostability of PSI. Therefore, the surfactant-induced membrane solubilization of a negatively charged phospholipid (DPhPG) with the motivation of creating biomimetic reconstructs of PSI reconstitution in DPhPG liposomes is studied. Specifically, a simple yet elegant method for incorporation of PSI trimeric complexes into DPhPG bilayer membranes that mimic the natural thylakoid membrane housing of PSI is introduced. The efficacy of this method is demonstrated via absorption and fluorescence spectroscopy measurements as well as direct visualization using atomic force microscopy. This study provides direct evidence that PSI confinements in synthetic lipid scaffolds can be used for tuning the photoexcitation characteristics of PSI. Hence, it paves the way for development of fundamental understanding of microenvironment alterations on photochemical response of light activated membrane proteins.

Detergent optimized membrane protein reconstitution in liposomes for solid state NMR

For small helical membrane proteins, their structures are highly sensitive to their environment, and solid state NMR is a structural technique that can characterize these membrane proteins in native-like lipid bilayers and proteoliposomes. To date, a systematic method by which to evaluate the effect of the solubilizing detergent on proteoliposome preparations for solid state NMR of membrane proteins has not been presented in the literature. A set of experiments are presented aimed at determining the conditions most amenable to dialysis mediated reconstitution sample preparation. A membrane protein from M. tuberculosis is used to illustrate the method. The results show that a detergent that stabilizes the most protein is not always ideal and sometimes cannot be removed by dialysis. By focusing on the lipid and protein binding properties of the detergent, proteoliposome preparations can be readily produced, which provide double the signal-to-noise ratios for both the oriented sample and magic angle spinning solid state NMR. The method will allow more membrane protein drug targets to be structurally characterized in lipid bilayer environments.

Membrane fusion intermediates via directional and full assembly of the SNARE complex

Cellular membrane fusion is thought to proceed through intermediates including docking of apposed lipid bilayers, merging of proximal leaflets to form a hemifusion diaphragm, and fusion pore opening. A membrane-bridging four-helix complex of soluble N-ethylmaleimide-sensitive factor attachment protein receptors (SNAREs) mediates fusion. However, how assembly of the SNARE complex generates docking and other fusion intermediates is unknown. Using a cell-free reaction, we identified intermediates visually and then arrested the SNARE fusion machinery when fusion was about to begin. Partial and directional assembly of SNAREs tightly docked bilayers, but efficient fusion and an extended form of hemifusion required assembly beyond the core complex to the membrane-connecting linkers. We propose that straining of lipids at the edges of an extended docking zone initiates fusion.

Structural Versatility of Bicellar Systems and Their Possibilities as Colloidal Carriers

Bicellar systems are lipid nanostructures formed by long- and short-chained phospholipids dispersed in aqueous solution. The morphological transitions of bicellar aggregates due to temperature, composition and time variations have been revised in this work. To this end, two bicellar systems have been considered; one formed by dimyristoyl-phosphatidylcholine (DMPC) and dihexanoyl- phosphatidylcholine (DHPC) and another formed by dipalmitoyl-phosphatidylcholine (DPPC) and DHPC. The relationship between the magnetic alignment, the morphology of the aggregates and the phase transition temperature (T_m) of lipids is discussed. In general terms, the non-alignable samples present rounded objects at temperature below the T_m. Above this temperature, an increase of viscosity is followed by the formation of large elongated aggregates. Alignable samples presented discoidal objects below the T_m. The best alignment was achieved above this temperature with large areas of lamellar stacked bilayers and some multilamellar vesicles. The effect of the inclusion of ceramides with different chain lengths in the structure of bicelles is also revised in the present article. A number of physical techniques show that the bicellar structures are affected by both the concentration and the type of ceramide. Systems are able to incorporate 10% mol of ceramides that probably are organized forming domains. The addition of 20% mol of ceramides promotes destabilization of bicelles, promoting the formation of mixed systems that include large structures. Bicellar systems have demonstrated to be morphologically stable with time, able to encapsulate different actives and to induce specific effects on the skin. These facts make bicellar systems good candidates as colloidal carriers for dermal delivery. However, water dilution induces structural changes and formation of vesicular structures in the systems; stabilization strategies have been been explored in recent works and are also updated here.

Bicosomes: bicelles in dilute systems

Bicelles are discoidal phospholipid nanostructures at high lipid concentrations. Under dilute conditions, bicelles become larger and adopt a variety of morphologies. This work proposes a strategy to preserve the discoidal morphology of bicelles in environments with high water content. Bicelles were formed in concentrated conditions and subsequently encapsulated in liposomes. Later dilution of these new structures, called bicosomes, demonstrated that lipid vesicles were able to isolate and protect bicelles entrapped inside them from the medium. Characterization of systems before and after dilution by dynamic light-scattering spectroscopy and cryo-transmission electron microscopy showed that free bicelles changed in size and morphology, whereas encapsulated bicelles remained unaltered by the effect of dilution. Free and entrapped bicelles (containing the paramagnetic contrast agent gadodiamide) were injected into rat brain lateral ventricles. Coronal and sagittal visualization was performed by magnetic resonance imaging. Whereas rats injected with free bicelles did not survive the surgery, those injected with bicosomes did, and a hyperintensity effect due to gadodiamide was observed in the cerebrospinal fluid. These results indicate that bicosomes are a good means of preserving the morphology of bicelles under dilution conditions.

Penetration and growth of DPPC/DHPC bicelles inside the stratum corneum of the skin

The effect of dipalmitoyl phosphatidylcholine (DPPC)/dihexanoyl phosphatidylcholine (DHPC) bicelles on the microstructure of pig stratum corneum (SC) in vitro was evaluated. The physicochemical characterization of these nanoaggregates revealed small disks with diameters around 15 nm and a thickness of 5.4 nm. Upon dilution, the bicelles grow and transform into vesicles. Cryogenic scanning electron microscopy (cryo-SEM) images of the SC pieces treated with this system showed vesicles of about 200 nm and lamellar-like structures in the intercellular lipid areas. These vesicles probably resulted from the growth and molecular rearrangement of the DPPC/DHPC bicelles after penetrating the SC. The presence of lamellar-like structures is ascribed to the interaction of the lipids from bicelles with the SC lipids. The bicellar system used is suitable to penetrate the skin SC and to reinforce the intercellular lipid areas, constituting a promising tool for skin applications.

Micellization of dissymmetric cationic gemini surfactants and their interaction with dimyristoylphosphatidylcholine vesicles

The micellization process of a series of dissymmetric cationic gemini surfactants [CmH2m+1(CH3)2N(CH2)6N(CH3)2C6H13]Br2 (designated as m-6-6 with m = 12, 14, and 16) and their interaction with dimyristoylphosphatidylcholine (DMPC) vesicles have been investigated. In the micellization process of these gemini surfactants themselves, critical micelle concentration (cmc), micelle ionization degree, and enthalpies of micellization (DeltaHmic) were determined, from which Gibbs free energies of micellization (DeltaGmic) and entropy of micellization (DeltaSmic) were derived. These properties were found to be influenced significantly by the dissymmetry in the surfactant structures. The phase diagrams for the solubilization of DMPC vesicles by the gemini surfactants were constructed from calorimetric results combining with the results of turbidity and dynamic light scattering. The effective surfactant to lipid ratios in the mixed aggregates at saturation (Resat) and solubilization (Resol) were derived. For the solubilization of DMPC vesicles, symmetric 12-6-12 is more effective than corresponding single-chain surfactant DTAB, whereas the dissymmetric m-6-6 series are more effective than symmetric 12-6-12, and 16-6-6 is the most effective. The chain length mismatch between DMPC and the gemini surfactants may be responsible for the different Re values. The transfer enthalpy per mole of surfactant within the coexistence range may be associated with the total hydrophobicity of the alkyl chains of gemini surfactants. The transfer enthalpies of surfactant from micelles to bilayers are always endothermic due to the dehydration of headgroups and the disordering of lipid acyl chain packing during the vesicle solubilization.

Aggregation behavior in mixed system of double-chained anionic surfactant with single-chained nonionic surfactant in aqueous solution

The aggregation behavior of mixed systems of sodium bis(2-ethylhexyl) sulfosuccinate (AOT) or sodium bis(4-phenylbutyl) sulfosuccinate (SBPBS) with nonionic surfactant pentaethylene glycol mono-n-dodecyl ether (C12E5) have been studied by means of steady-state fluorescence, electrical conductivity, dynamic light scattering, transmission electron microscopy, electrophoretic light scattering and pyrene solubilization measurements. The critical concentrations for aggregation, micropolarity, mobility, solubilization capacity and morphology of aggregates are characterized. Two critical concentrations for aggregation are observed in the mixed surfactants, which may correspond to the formation of different kinds of aggregates. Moreover, it is more favorable for AOT-C12E5 to form mixed vesicles compared to SBPBS-C12E5 at higher mole fraction of C12E5. In addition, it is revealed that SBPBS-C12E5 mixture has larger solubilization capacity for pyrene than AOT-C12E5 system.

Self-organization of the ternary didecyldimethylammonium bromide/octyl-beta-D-glucopyranoside/water system

The spontaneous and thermodynamically stable mixed vesicles constituted by a double-chain cationic surfactant with 10 carbon atoms hydrophobic tail, didecyldimethylammonium bromide (di-C(10)DMAB), and a nonionic single-chain surfactant, octyl-beta-d-glucopyranoside (OBG), have been characterized in aqueous media by means of a series of experimental techniques, as well as a theoretical approach. Conductivity data allow for the determination of the concentrations at which the monomer-to-vesicle (CVC) and/or vesicle-to-micelle (CMC) transitions occur. Electrophoretic mobilities, obtained from laser-doppler-electrophoresis experiments, permit the determination of zeta-potentials and, from them, the surface charge density of the vesicle aggregates. Cryogenic transmission electron microscopy (cryo-TEM) provides pictures of the vesicles, their size and shape being, thus, determined. Finally, the sensitivity of the emission spectra of some fluorescent probes, such as the cationic TNS and the nonionic PRODAN, to the polarity of the environment, allow for a complete study of different pre- and post-vesicle microdomains, of variable rigidity and micropolarity. This, in turn, yield interesting information about the vesicle surface and bilayer, as well as, about the existence of clusters and/or nanoaggregates prior to the formation of vesicles, as was proposed by us in a previous paper.

Aggregation phenomena on the ternary ionic-nonionic surfactant system: didodecyldimethylammonium bromide/octyl-beta-D-glucopyranoside/water. Mixed microaggregates, vesicles, and micelles

The formation of a variety of mixed colloidal aggregates has been investigated on a ternary ionic-nonionic system constituted by (i) a double-chain cationic surfactant with a 12-carbon atom hydrophobic tail, didodecyldimethylammonium bromide (di-C(12)DMAB), (ii) a nonionic single-chain surfactant, octyl-beta-D-glucopyranoside (OBG), and (iii) water. The study has been carried out by means of conductivity, zeta-potential, transmission electron microscopy (TEM), and cryogenic transmission electron microscopy (cryo-TEM) experiments on the highly diluted, very diluted, and moderately diluted regions. The formation of mixed microaggregates, prior to the appearance of mixed vesicles, has been undoubtly confirmed by conductivity, TEM, and zeta-potential results. The concentrations at which these mixed colloidal aggregates form, i.e., the mixed critical microaggregate concentration (CAC), the mixed critical vesicle concentration (CVC), and the mixed critical micelle concentration (CMC), have been determined from conductivity data, while the zeta-potential experiments allow for the characterization of the aggregate/solution interface. The shape and size of the microaggregates and vesicles have been evaluated from TEM and cryo-TEM micrographs, respectively. All of the experimental evidence has been also analyzed in terms of the theoretical packing parameter, P.

Membrane solubilization by detergent: resistance conferred by thickness

The commonly held model for membrane dissolution by detergents/surfactants requires lipid transport from the inner to the outer bilayer leaflet ('flip-flop'). Although applicable to many systems, it fails in cases where cross-bilayer transport of membrane components is suppressed. In this paper we investigate the mechanism for surfactant-induced solubilization of polymeric bilayers. To that end, we examine the dissolution of a series of increasingly thick, polymer-based vesicles (polymersomes) by a nonionic surfactant, Triton X-100, using dynamic light scattering. We find that increasing the bilayer thickness imparts better resistance to dissolution, so that the concentration required for solubilization, after a fixed amount of time, increases nearly linearly with membrane thickness. Combining our experimental data with a theoretical model, we show that the dominant mechanism for the surfactant-induced dissolution of polymeric vesicles, where polymer flip-flop across the membrane is suppressed, is the surfactant transport through the bilayer. This mechanism is different both qualitatively and quantitatively from the mechanisms by which surfactants dissolve pure lipid vesicles.

The effect of octyl glucoside on the lamellar phase of diluted C12E4 and alcohol systems

A systematic study on phase behavior of the mixture of nonionic surfactants with alcohols at 30.0+/-0.1 degrees C was carried out. The total surfactant concentration was kept to 0.1 M varying the mole ratio of n-octyl beta-d-glucopyranoside (OG) and tetraethylene glycol monododecyl ether. Two uniphasic regions were found, the lamellar phase at low OG mole fraction and micelles at high OG mole fraction. The presence of OG favors the lamellae-micelle transition. Alkanols and benzyl alcohol were used as cosurfactants. The more hydrophobic alcohols (octanol and decanol) increase the OG content in the mixed bilayers. On the contrary, benzyl alcohol is not as favorable to the OG incorporation in the lamellar phase as in the mixed micelles. The L(3) phase has only been found as a uniphasic region with hexanol.

Effect of the electrostatic charge on the mechanism inducing liposome solubilization: a kinetic study by synchrotron radiation SAXS

The anionic surfactant sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS) was used to induce the initial steps of the solubilization of liposomes. The structural transformations as well as the kinetics associated with this initial period were studied by means of time-resolved small-angle X-ray scattering (SAXS) using a synchrotron radiation source. Neutral and electrically charged (anionic and cationic) liposomes were used to investigate the effect of the electrostatic charges on the kinetics of these initial steps. The mechanism that induces the solubilization process consisted of adsorption of surfactant on the bilayers and desorption of mixed micelles from the liposomes surface to the aqueous medium. In all cases the time needed for desorption of the first mixed micelles was shorter than that for complete adsorption of the surfactant on the liposomes surface. The present work demonstrates that adsorption of the SDS molecules on negatively charged liposomes was slower and release of mixed micelles from the surface of these liposomes was faster than for neutral liposomes. In contrast, in the case of positively charged liposomes, the adsorption and release processes were, respectively, faster and slower than those for neutral vesicles.

Exploring the interaction of the surfactant N-terminal domain of gamma-Zein with soybean phosphatidylcholine liposomes

Zeins are maize storage proteins that accumulate inside large vesicles called protein bodies. gamma-Zein lines the inner surface of the protein body membrane, and its N-terminal, proline-rich, repetitive domain with the sequence (VHLPPP)(8) appears to be necessary for the accumulation of the protein within the organelle. Synthetic (VHLPPP)(8) adopts an amphipathic polyproline II conformation and forms cylindrical micelles in aqueous solution. Here we explore the interaction of (VHLPPP)(8) with soybean phosphatidylcholine unilamellar lipid vesicles and examine its effect on the stability and permeability of the liposome membrane. The amphipathic N-terminal domain of gamma-zein interacts with the membrane and assembles to form extended domains over the phospholipid membrane. The interaction between the peptide and the membrane increases the stability and permeability of the liposome membrane. The spontaneous amphipathic aggregation of (VHLPPP)(8) on the membrane suggests a mechanism of gamma-zein deposition inside maize protein bodies.

Kinetics of the micelle-to-vesicle transition: aqueous lecithin-bile salt mixtures

Important routes to lipid vesicles (liposomes) are detergent removal techniques, such as dialysis or dilution. Although they are widely applied, there has been only limited understanding about the structural evolution during the formation of vesicles and the parameters that determine their properties. We use time-resolved static and dynamic light scattering to study vesicle formation in aqueous lecithin-bile salt mixtures. The kinetic rates and vesicle sizes are found to strongly depend on total amphiphile concentration and, even more pronounced, on ionic strength. The observed trends contradict equilibrium calculations, but are in agreement with a kinetic model that we present. This model identifies the key kinetic steps during vesicle formation: rapid formation of disk-like intermediate micelles, growth of these metastable micelles, and their closure to form vesicles once line tension dominates bending energy. A comparison of the rates of growth and closure provides a kinetic criterion for the critical size at which disks close and thus for the vesicle size. The model suggests that liposomes are nonequilibrium, kinetically trapped structures of very long lifetime. Their properties are hence controlled by kinetics rather than thermodynamics.